An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business
- Order of Business 1 speech
The Leader sets the schedule for budget statements and a Private Members’ motion on Irish neutrality and the triple lock.
Garret Ahearn
- Newbridge Jigsaw service 1 speech
O’Loughlin welcomes recurring funding for a Jigsaw service in Newbridge to support young people’s mental health.
Fiona O'Loughlin
- Illegal hare coursing 2 speeches
Murphy raises the increase in illegal hare coursing in rural areas, distinguishing it from regulated coursing; Boyhan supports the scheduled budget and neutrality debates.
PJ Murphy, Victor Boyhan
- Bus service for MTU students 1 speech
Collins raises a public transport issue affecting students travelling from Abbeyfeale to Munster Technological University.
Joanne Collins
- Louth mental health crisis nurses 1 speech
Comyn welcomes recurring funding for crisis nurses at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, noting the need for mental health support beyond office hours.
Alison Comyn
- Rural Garda staffing 1 speech
Boyle says rural communities in Donegal are concerned about Garda shortages despite improving recruitment.
Manus Boyle
- RTÉ centenary and staff 1 speech
Conway marks RTÉ’s centenary and recognises the thousands of staff who have worked behind its well-known presenters.
Joe Conway
- Creeslough tragedy remembrance 1 speech
Boyle remembers the victims of the Creeslough tragedy and offers condolences to their families.
Manus Boyle
- N65 road safety 1 speech
Rabbitte calls for budget funding and safety improvements on the N65 between Portumna and Loughrea, particularly at Kilmeen Cross.
Anne Rabbitte
- Rural policing and Garda visibility 1 speech
Scahill supports reviewing Garda allocation across rural Ireland and asks for a debate on rural policing.
Gareth Scahill
- Tribute to a Roscommon public servant 4 speeches
Scahill pays tribute to the late Keenan, offering condolences to his family and describing him as a valued public servant and community member.
Maria Byrne, Gareth Scahill
- State funding for greyhound racing 4 speeches
Andrews criticises continued public funding for greyhound racing, citing greyhound deaths and questioning the report used to justify support. The Leader cautions against allegations about absent people.
Chris Andrews, Maria Byrne
- Breast cancer awareness 1 speech
Fitzpatrick marks breast cancer awareness month and highlights efforts to raise awareness of the disease.
Mary Fitzpatrick
- Abortion reflection period evidence 2 speeches
Keogan criticises the health committee for declining to hear from women who reconsidered abortion after the three-day reflection period; the Chair welcomes visiting students.
Sharon Keogan, Maria Byrne
- Road safety data in Rosslare 1 speech
Byrne raises the RSA’s refusal to provide requested speed and fatality statistics for a road in Rosslare.
Cathal Byrne
- Garvaghy Road residents 1 speech
Tully raises concerns affecting residents on Garvaghy Road in Portadown.
Pauline Tully
- Wind farm proposals and communities 1 speech
Duffy says uncertainty around proposed wind farms is troubling communities, including those in the Cooneel area of Mayo.
Mark Duffy
- Unanswered questions about Creeslough 1 speech
Clonan says families affected by the Creeslough tragedy still need answers and calls attention to unanswered questions about the review of the premises’ change of use.
Tom Clonan
- Breastfeeding support 1 speech
O’Reilly calls for timely lactation support for women who wish to breastfeed, noting Ireland’s low breastfeeding rates.
Sarah O'Reilly
- Bombing in Oleshky, Ukraine 1 speech
McCarthy describes a deadly bombing in Oleshky, including damage to the ambassador’s family home, and warns against becoming indifferent to the war.
Aubrey McCarthy
- Lahinch wastewater consultation 2 speeches
Conway presses Uisce Éireann for an answer on holding a public consultation about its proposed Lahinch and Calluragh wastewater treatment site; the Chair welcomes guests.
Martin Conway, Maria Byrne
- Leader’s replies to Senators 5 speeches
The Leader responds to several matters raised, including Jigsaw funding, road safety and rural Garda resources, and says Senators will have an opportunity to debate the abortion bill. Members interject during the replies.
Garret Ahearn, A Senator, Sharon Keogan
- Commemoration of 7 October 2 speeches
Keogan asks the House to remember those killed and taken hostage in the 7 October 2023 attacks; the Leader agrees and condemns the killings.
Sharon Keogan, Garret Ahearn
The Order of Business is No. 1, statements on budget 2027 from the Department of Finance, to be taken at 12.30 p.m. and to conclude at 2.30 p.m., if not previously concluded, with the time allocated to the opening remarks of the Minister not to exceed ten minutes, group spokespersons not to exceed eight minutes, all other Senators not to exceed five minutes and the Minister to be given no less than ten minutes to reply to the debate; and No. 65, motion 6, Private Members' business, motion regarding a referendum on Irish neutrality and protection of the triple lock, to be taken at 3 p.m., with the time allocated to this debate not to exceed two hours.
Comment on this
I thank the Leader for outlining the Order of Business, which I support and second here today.
I had the opportunity to speak on the budget yesterday evening but there is one item I want to highlight this morning. I had a Commencement matter recently on the provision of a Jigsaw service in Newbridge, so I am delighted to confirm that in the small print of the budget, Newbridge is going to get a Jigsaw service. That is going to be an investment of €1.1 million every year for the prevention of mental health crises in young people aged between 12 and 25 from Newbridge, but it will be operating in other parts of Kildare. Apart from the free counselling this will give to young people, Jigsaw also works with schools, clubs etc. I am delighted to focus on that this morning.
I also wish to speak about the lack of regulation of rickshaws on our streets, which was brought into very sharp and devastating focus by the recent tragic death of Danielle O'Keane following a rickshaw crash on North Wall Quay. It is entirely unacceptable that, years after legislation was first promised, commercial rickshaws continue to operate across Dublin without mandatory licensing, registration or insurance. That mirrors an issue I have raised repeatedly in this House about sulky racing. Whether we are dealing with horse-drawn sulkies creating chaotic conditions on our roads, which I often see around Newbridge and Kildare, or passenger-carrying rickshaws, the risk to life is catastrophic and we need to have a debate. I heard Councillor Michael Crowe on the radio yesterday morning talking about the introduction of by-laws in Galway in 2013. Since then, they do not have any rickshaws. It is important that, at a local level, action is taken but we need to take it at a national level too.
I also wish to talk about the epidemic of nitrous oxide canisters. They are blighting the countryside everywhere. We have seen a lot of it around the Curragh. We have seen volunteers collecting them, and fair play. It is an issue with disposal. We need to get a correct policy on this. I commend my colleague, Senator Teresa Costello, who has been doing a lot of work on this in demanding stricter legislative policy, but we need a robust public education campaign on this. Popular social media trends are normalising fast gas but, in reality, a landmark Irish study led by Professor Seamus Looby at Beaumont Hospital proves that recreational use blocks B12 processing. That can lead to the diagnosis of severe spinal cord damage in young adults. It is shocking. We need to have a Minister in. I know that both the Minister of State, Deputy Murnane O'Connor, and the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, are working on trying to resolve the issue here but we need to have a debate on it.
Comment on this
I rise today to address one particular aspect of rural crime: the blight of illegal lurching, or the illegal chasing of hares with greyhounds and lurchers in the rural countryside. First, I emphasise the fact that I am a lover of rural pursuits. I am a shooter and an angler. I am a supporter of hunting and I like to attend regulated coursing meetings. What I am talking about here is very different from regulated coursing. We have seen a great increase in its prevalence in my area. It is groups of men being dropped off with dogs in both daylight hours and at night-time throughout my area of Craughwell, Ardrahan and Clarinbridge, and all across County Galway. These people have dogs, greyhounds and lurchers without muzzles and they are killing a large number of hares in the countryside. They are frightening and chasing livestock. There were a number of cases in my area where flocks of sheep have mixed from farm to farm where gates have been left open. Elderly citizens are very much afraid of these groups and gangs of men who are travelling around the countryside, very often at night-time recently.
I have written to the local Garda superintendent responsible for the Gort area asking for all necessary Garda resources in the area to be made available to tackle this, but the Garda does not currently have the tools available to it which are necessary to tackle this blight. I will reference a motion that was passed unanimously in the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown local authority just last year. It was brought forward by my own party colleague, Councillor Pierce Dargan, and it was that we follow the lead of Spain on this one. In Spain, whenever a dog is brought for its mandatory microchipping, a saliva sample is also taken from that dog, building up a bank of DNA samples of the dogs of the country, with the owner attached. If a sheep is found mauled, then saliva samples will be found and traced back to a dog and the owner. If the faeces of a dog are found in area where lurching occurred the night before, DNA samples can be taken from those faeces. They can be tracked back to the owner and the dog can be taken from its owner and destroyed if necessary, with the owner prosecuted.
We need to challenge this head-on. Gardaí need to be given the necessary tools and I urge the Ministers for housing and agriculture to work together on this and follow the lead of Spain in building up a database of the DNA of the dogs of the country and the owners assigned to them.
Comment on this
I thank the Leader for the Order of Business. I fully support it and the timing arrangements, etc. I am particularly pleased that the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance is expected in here and I thank him in advance. I will be here myself in relation to the Department of Finance and we will have an opportunity to discuss the budget then. I also thank the Leader for his arrangements for other budgetary matters on the schedule in recent days.
I also acknowledge what will be a very significant debate on Irish neutrality and the protection of the triple lock.
Much has been said inside and outside these Houses and I look forward to a respectful and constructive engagement. I note the Government's position on the counter-motion.
I acknowledge a significant graduation that happened last Saturday. Some 274 new GPs graduated from the Irish College of General Practitioners at Dublin's convention centre. I thank Mr. Fintan Foy, the CEO of the college, who said it was the largest graduation in the history of the college. What a great story. We talk a lot about community healthcare, the lack of community GPs and the difficulties, particularly in rural areas but also in the cities, for people accessing GPs. I congratulate each and every one of the 274 newly qualified GPs.
I also call for a debate on Food Vision 2030. It is not the first time I have called for it. There has been engagement between the Leader's office and the Department of agriculture on the topic of artisan foods. I never asked for a debate on artisan foods and I do not know who did. I was talking to the Minister's office last week to clarify a few points. To reiterate, I have spoken to representatives of the Department of agriculture in the past few days. They would be more than happy to come in and provide some debate, discussion or statements on Food Vision 2030. I spoke last week about the fact that nearly €2 billion worth of vegetables and fruits are imported into this country. We know our climate. We know our horticultural and agricultural capabilities. We need to put a dent in that if we are going to talk seriously about organic and sustainable agriculture and horticulture within Ireland and to work collaboratively with Teagasc on the matter.
I wish to put on the list of requests a debate on Our Rural Future and the next iteration of it. The Minister, Deputy Calleary, confirmed today during Commencement matters - it was not my Commencement matter but I was chairing the debate - that he was putting the final touches to the next iteration of Our Rural Future. It is an amazing document and positive blueprint for rural development in a managed and focused way, with particular deliverables. I ask for that debate.
I again ask for a debate on the local government task force. Importantly, we do not need to go back on history anymore. We need to see a timeline for its implementation. The Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, talks about a phased implementation over a number of years, and I understand that makes sense. There are many issues. There is partnership. There is agreement without sitting county councillors, city and county managers and chief executives. I ask that the debate would focus on phased implementation. The Minister of State might come to the House and take us through it as he sees it. Everyone has worked well. The feeling in the past few days, and certainly at the Association of Irish Local Government, AILG, conference last week, is that there is beginning to be a bit of a lull. We need to kick-start that. I would appreciate it if the Leader would convey that message to the Minister of State.
Comment on this
I offer the best of luck and congratulations to all the junior certificate students receiving their results today, and especially to my daughter, Abby, and all her classmates. I would say there will be plenty of celebrations tonight, seeing as I am not around to watch them.
Staying on the theme of students, I have an issue to raise. It is not necessarily about school transport but public transport. A Bus Éireann service starts in Abbeyfeale, County Limerick, and travels towards Tralee and onto Killarney in County Kerry. It hits the Munster Technological University, MTU, just before 9 a.m., which is ideal for students living in County Limerick to attend college in Tralee and get there in time for their lectures. The issue is that the bus route only starts in Abbeyfeale, which is the border town as people leave Limerick. There has been a request for the route to start 15 minutes earlier in Newcastle West, which is the main and biggest town in County Limerick, to accommodate students there. The only other bus will get them there at 9.30 a.m. or 10 a.m. and they are missing their first lectures. They want to avoid the need to commute by car and would prefer to use public transport. It would mean that if there were events on, they might be able to stay and go to the events without the need to drive straight home.
I have got onto Bus Éireann numerous times with no replies or acknowledgement. I ask the Leader to bring this issue to the Minister for Transport and ask is there a way of getting a reply from Bus Éireann or does everything have to go through the Minister to get a reply. I understand it is busy, with all the different departments it has, but I would appreciate even just an acknowledgement that it will look into the issue. It is a very small request for the students and people who might need to go down to the hospital in Tralee for appointments to have an extra service early in the morning. I would like something in writing from the Minister.
Comment on this
I also wish good luck to everybody with their junior certificate results today. I assure them that 40 years later, they will not even remember what they got.
I give a warm welcome to today's announcement of some mental health funding for County Louth. Some €660,000 in recurring funding has been allocated in particular for crisis nurses for Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, which will be an amazing addition. We all know that mental health crises do not necessarily happen between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. We need to focus on providing support when somebody needs it. When somebody puts up his or her hand and says, "I need help now", we need to be able to provide it. Those four mental health nurses will provide out-of-hour care when the consultants are not there or there is no availability elsewhere.
Another wonderful addition is funding for a Solace café in County Louth. We are not yet sure exactly where it will be based but generally such cafés are in close proximity to hospitals so we hope the one in County Louth will be close to Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital. These Solace cafés have been a tremendous success in the likes of Waterford and Dublin, etc. It will be amazing to have one in County Louth. They often provide that first point of reference and are the first port of call for people in crisis, perhaps late in the evenings on Thursday, Friday, Saturday or Sunday. Quite often, an early intervention with people who will listen and who know how to handle these kinds of crises can stop quite an upsetting trip to emergency departments. For this recurring funding, I thank the Minister of State with responsibility for mental health, Deputy Butler. I thank her for placing her trust in us. I am sure we will make the best use of the funding.
If you are in crisis, we hope these initiatives will help. You should also ensure that you contact your local Garda station or a tremendous service, SOSAD, in counties Louth, Meath and Cavan. Its 24-hour helpline is 1800 901 909. Do not be afraid to ask for help.
Comment on this
Like other Senators, I wish all the children the best with their junior certificate results today. My son, Barry, is waiting for results at the minute. As I said to him, it does not matter what is in the results, we are still proud of him. He is doing his work. It will be great for them this evening.
I raise an issue that I have raised a couple of times in the House. During my travels in Donegal, I listen to everything that is going on. One of the major concerns I am hearing about on a weekly basis is the lack of gardaí serving in rural communities. Recruitment is moving in the right direction. Many people are coming through the Garda College and there is a strong interest among people wanting to join the force. That is welcome. However, I hear on the ground in Donegal that some rural communities are not seeing enough of their gardaí locally. Our population is growing. Communities are growing. The demand on the Garda is growing. Yet, some villages feel that the Garda presence available to them locally is moving in the opposite direction.
We must consider how gardaí are allocated. They must be appointed to rural communities and become the pillars of the community that they always have been. Gardaí in a community know exactly what is going on in a local area. They know the people to talk to and have their fingers on the pulse.
I welcome the news yesterday that there are 1,000 new recruits to go through Templemore. That is welcome. Will the Minister prioritise rural counties, such as Donegal, for gardaí? They are essential parts of a community. Going forward, with the numbers now coming through Templemore, we should prioritise local communities.
Comment on this
I wish to advert to a few notable anniversaries. The first is one which has been mentioned many times in the Houses. It is the 100th anniversary of RTÉ. For my pleasure or my sins, I am not too sure yet, I am reading Shane Ross's book on RTÉ.
One thing I am struck by is that it highlights many of the popular faces of RTÉ. I was thinking that, behind those popular faces, there are thousands of men and women who, since 1926, have made RTÉ what it is today. Whether people like it or loathe it, it entertains, informs and enlightens us and all the people who work behind the scenes should be remembered in places like the Seanad, as we are remembering them today.
There are another two notable anniversaries. On 7 October 1946, the first edition of "Woman's Hour" was broadcast on the BBC. Nothing has done more to put the spotlight on women's issues than "Woman's Hour" with its various presenters over the years. If that were not enough, a 100th anniversary is being celebrated today by the BBC. On 7 October 1926, the first outside broadcast of "Choral Evensong" was broadcast. I do not know how many Senators tune into it on Wednesday afternoons but if they want a little relaxed enlightenment and spirituality, you cannot be beat it.
The House should record for the cultural attaché in the British embassy, the great work that is done across the Border in Northern Ireland and the transmitters that help to enrich our lives as a near neighbour of Britain. We should mark the 100th anniversary of the first outside broadcast of "Choral Evensong" and the 80th anniversary of the first broadcast of "Woman's Hour" in some way and signal to Terence O'Rourke of RTÉ the Seanad's appreciation of 100 years of public broadcasting by RTÉ.
Comment on this
I forgot to mention that today is the anniversary of the Creeslough tragedy, which devastated Donegal. Many lives were torn apart by what happened in Creeslough so I wanted to bring attention to it today. Our thoughts are with the families in Creeslough.
Comment on this
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach and the Leader for the opportunity to address ongoing issues in east Galway with road safety. It was great that the budget was announced yesterday with new allocations of funding. I call for some of that funding to be spent on the N65, from the bridge in Portumna to Kilmeen Cross into Loughrea. For many years before me, politicians have talked in both Houses about Kilmeen Cross. Coming into the winter, there is no doubt, that coming from Loughrea towards Portumna, Kilmeen Cross is hard to find as the fog comes down on a dark, dreary winter's night. For many years, people have called for more signage and an additional light or two approaching it. It is a national route and it needs to be categorised as such and respected in that vein. There has been loss of life on that road and the funding has not come behind it, notwithstanding that a lot of investment has been made in the N65. When it comes to safety measures when people are turning right or left, they need to know they can do so safely without putting themselves or others at risk. That is why I support the Kilmeen Cross and N65 Action Group.
When such work is being done, it would also be a good time to put in a speed counter to measure the speed and volume of cars travelling on the N65 and crossing the bridge every day. The N65 goes right through the town of Portumna and, unfortunately, there is only one pedestrian crossing in the whole town, in a town that is approximately 1 km and built on both sides of the N65. It is incumbent on the TII to show its ambition for the N65. I say again that I totally support the Kilmeen Cross and N65 Action Group.
Comment on this
I too wish all the junior certificate students who are receiving their results today well. I encourage them to have a safe evening celebrating, if that is what they plan to do tonight.
I also support Senator Boyle's call for the additional gardaí committed to in the budget to be looked at in the context of visibility and redistribution throughout rural Ireland. We need to look at the policing model and I would welcome the opportunity to have a debate in this House on rural policing and the allocation of those resources, if we have the opportunity.
This morning the funeral mass is taking place of former councillor, Ernie Keenan, in Boyle, County Roscommon. Members of Fine Gael and the Boyle GAA club will have held a guard of honour just before the funeral started in Boyle. Mr. Keenan was 90 when he died on Sunday. He was a devoted family man, a proud Boyle and Roscommon man and a lifelong GAA man. He served on Roscommon County Council for 11 years. He was co-opted when Deputy Feighan was first elected to the Dáil. Then he managed to win elections in 2004 and 2009. He served as leas-chathaoirleach of Roscommon County Council and, for an unusual four months, as cathaoirleach when Luke Ming Flanagan MEP was elected to the Dáil. It was poignant, on Monday, to be in the company of Councillor Domnick Connolly and the Minister of State, Deputy Feighan, in Boyle. Councillor Connolly had the cathaoirleach's chain and we noticed Mr. Keenan's name and year on it. It is nice to acknowledge him and to acknowledge where he came from. He was a proud public representative who got all his direction from where he was embedded in his community and from his love for his community, like many public representatives. He was involved in the farming community and often showed up at agricultural shows as a councillor. He was a proud member of the Irish Farmers Association, IFA, but his connection with Boyle GAA is what I really wanted to highlight. The Keenan Cup in Roscommon is in recognition of his son-----
Comment on this
-----and it just happens that the under-13s Boyle team currently holds it. I send my sympathy to his wife Carmel, his family John, Karl, Mary, Elizabeth and Fiona and the wider Keenan family.
Comment on this
Boyle and Roscommon have lost a great public servant, a good community man and a gentleman.
Comment on this
I congratulate the Irish under-21s team on beating England 3:1 in the European championships. It is a great achievement. Any day we beat the English is a good day.
Since 2001, consecutive Governments have given €407 million of taxpayers' money to the inhumane and unpopular greyhound industry. Greyhound racing will receive more than €20 million from the State in 2027 and that is up €500,000 from 2026. Given that 3,000 or more greyhounds were killed or died last year, that is unacceptable. For the past five years, the funding has been justified by a faulty, self-commissioned report which vastly over-estimates the significance of the greyhound industry to the Irish economy.
The funding is by far and away more than has been given to the League of Ireland, which has to fight for scraps while Greyhound Racing Ireland, GRI, is guaranteed a mountain of cash every year in perpetuity. A report from 2024 found the League of Ireland contributes €164.7 million annually to the Irish economy, significantly more than the greyhound industry has ever claimed to produce. More than 1.1 million people attended League of Ireland matches last year, while greyhound meets attracted only one third of that number and yet the Government barely has any interest in investing in Irish football.
It is clear to me that it is simply the case the greyhound industry and lobbyists have Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil by the neck. There is a revolving door of those who profit from the greyhound industry and those responsible for overseeing and allocating taxpayers' money to it. A case in point is that the director of Kilkenny Greyhound Racing Company, a senior Fine Gael member, was appointed chairperson of what is now GRI by former Minister, Deputy Simon Coveney, in 2011. In the final week of his term, the chairperson signed off on a €1 million grant of taxpayers' money to the Kilkenny Greyhound Company. A few months later, he resumed his position as director of the company, which was newly enriched by the money he signed off on. There is a worrying intertwining of the for-profit greyhound industry-----
Comment on this
-----and our political system. The Government would be wise to commission an independent review of greyhound racing and its record, which is duplicitous, and the unnecessary and wasteful use of taxpayer funding.
Comment on this
I remind Members about making allegations about people who are not here to defend themselves. I ask them to be careful as we go forward.
Comment on this
I would like to congratulate every young boy and girl receiving their junior cert results today. Well done to all of them. Well done to the students themselves, to their families and to their teachers. It is the first major State exam that they will have completed and they have achieved it. Good luck to them. Go n-éirí an bóthar leo.
We are into October, which is breast cancer awareness month. This month Breast Cancer Ireland and many others, including my colleague Senator Teresa Costello, are devoting time and effort to raising awareness about breast cancer. Breast cancer is a curable disease but, unfortunately, one in seven women in Ireland in their lifetime will develop breast cancer. More than 4,000 women and around 30 men are diagnosed with breast cancer every year in Ireland. It is a curable disease and the potential for recovery is greatly increased and enhanced if there is early detection. The only way we can achieve early detection is by knowing what is normal. What is normal to me is not necessarily normal to you or normal to anybody else in this House. The message is to know what is normal for yourself, to raise and promote awareness about this, and to promote education and research. This is a curable disease. This is one that we have many survivors of. It is important that we all support the raising of awareness of breast cancer in our country and do what we can to support survivors of this disease. Go raibh maith agat.
Comment on this
A Sinn Féin Bill to remove the three-day reflection period before an abortion is currently before the Oireachtas health committee. Shockingly, the committee refused a request to hear from women who had attended their first abortion appointment, experienced the three-day wait, and ultimately decided not to proceed with an abortion. Their voices were directly relevant and deserved to be heard. When the committee would not listen, the women held an event in a nearby hotel last week to tell their stories. It was an incredible event. One of the women, Meg, said she fully expected to proceed with the abortion but those three days gave her time to speak with her family and consider her future. Just 30 minutes before taking the pill she changed her mind. She said that those three days gave her something she desperately needed: time to think beyond the immediate situation and time to ask herself whether this was really what she wanted. Another woman, Lauren, said that without the waiting period she almost certainly would have taken the first abortion pill immediately and that those three days changed everything. Beside her was her two-year-old son, Jack, playing with his toys. These are just some of the stories we heard and they should not have been excluded from the process. It is just awful how one-sided the health committee has been in censoring evidence, testimonies and lived experience that do not fit preconceived narratives. The public deserves better and democracy deserves better. Women who say their children are alive because of the three-day wait deserve better. It is not too late for the health committee to rethink its approach and in doing so restore some confidence in its work and in politics generally.
I too want to remember today the people of the Creeslough community in relation to the atrocity that happened there. I am also thinking of the people in Israel and the awful tragedy that happened in Israel on 7 October at the hands of Hamas, the terrorist group.
Comment on this
Before I call an Seanadóir Byrne, I welcome the pupils from Gorey Educate Together Secondary School. They are accompanied by Peter Mernagh who is their teacher. You are all very welcome and I hope you enjoy your visit to Leinster House today, and especially to the Seanad.
Comment on this
I would also like to welcome the students from Gorey who are here today. I hope they have a very enjoyable and educational experience when they are here. They are getting to see democracy in action. While the people in this Chamber might not always agree, the views that individual people have up and down the country are very much put to the fore in this Chamber. I hope they enjoy their experience.
Today I want to bring up what I consider quite a serious issue. At a recent meeting of the Rosslare municipal district of Wexford County Council, a request was made to the Road Safety Authority, RSA, for crash statistics on the N25 road in County Wexford. The response that came back from the RSA was that it was not able to share those statistics to Wexford County Council, which is a statutory local authority, on the basis of GDPR. I cannot understand on what basis GDPR would have anything to do with how many road crashes, how many serious crashes or how many fatalities occurred on a stretch of road. The RSA said that it currently does not have the legal authority to be able to issue those statistics to Wexford County Council. I really do not accept that. As a statutory authority that is responsible for roads, the RSA should absolutely be sharing that data. I ask the Leader to raise this at the highest possible level so we can bring back some common sense. How is Wexford County Council meant to improve road safety for residents in the Rosslare district if they cannot get access to the data on the basis of GDPR? I cannot understand what the hell is going on here. This has to be brought up and raised.
Comment on this
I wish the best of luck to all the post-junior cert students who are getting their results today. My youngest son is getting his results. They are available in the school from 10 o'clock but they are not being given to them until last class so it is going to be a nervous day for a lot of them. I can totally understand why the school would do that because they want to contain all the celebrations. The celebrations this evening are being looked forward to. I hope all the students get the results they expect and are happy with them.
I want to speak about the residents on the Garvaghy Road in Portadown and speak out in support of them and in solidarity with them. For 28 years the people there have lived in peace and they just want to continue to live in peace. The relations between people have been good and especially young people. They were not aware of all of that happened 30 years ago, and suddenly it is all being raked up again and old wounds opened. That is totally irresponsible of the Orange Order. The peace there and those improved relations need to be protected and they need to be built on. The actions of the Orange Order and the ridiculous decision by the Parades Commission have undermined all that good work. The residents have another appeal in the court and we are awaiting the decision on that. I hope it will not be too long and I hope it is the right one. We need to do everything to ensure that the peace and the Good Friday Agreement are not undermined. That is what this is. It is an attempt by the Orange Order to do just that because there is an election coming up, of course, and the unionist parties just want to distract from their own issues within the party and try to build their support. The people of the Garvaghy Road have the support of the vast majority of the people on this island regardless of denomination or political persuasion, and indeed they have a lot of international support as well. The unionist parties have proposed a motion of no confidence in Michelle O'Neill and the other ministers for standing with the people of the Garvaghy Road. I have every confidence in Michelle and the Sinn Féin ministers because they are doing what they can to protect the peace, protect the Good Friday Agreement and do what is right for the people of the North.
In relation to Sinn Féin's Bill on the three-day wait that is going through the committee on health, I trust women to make the right decision for themselves. Women can take three days or longer, if they can afford to do so, to make that decision. Nobody is forcing them to have the abortion on the day they go to the doctor. Let us trust women to make the right decision for themselves. They know their own minds.
Comment on this
This morning I rise to raise an issue that is popping up in every community and part of the country, which is the development and proposed development of different wind farms. We see it every number of months in different parts of County Mayo or different parts of every county where communities are left fearful and unsure because of speculation and proposals around different developments. There is a clear lack of clarity for communities such as one most recently in Cooneal in my home county of Mayo.
It affects the Cooneal, Ardagh, Moygownagh, Crossmolina and Killala general area. A pre-application proposal has been put forward to An Coimisiún Pleanála. The point I am making is on the lack of clarity at a national level in terms of wind energy guidelines. Some draft guidelines were published but they need to be fully enacted to give clarity to communities such as Cooneal and many other communities in north Mayo, which are constantly bombarded with speculative planning applications that cause a lot of fear, anxiety and worry among the communities that are potentially affected.
I have been working with Councillor Jarlath Munnelly on this. It is something we have discussed and it really needs to be raised. I note and welcome the fact that Mayo County Council has zoned the area as unsuitable for wind farm developments. It is something I worked on when I was a member of the strategic policy committee with responsibility for energy and environment. There are schools there, and families and people are building homes there. The lack of clarity is causing real fear and anxiety. There will be a public meeting on this next week. I am standing with the community and the people affected there. The Minister needs to publish and enact clear guidelines to remove this uncertainty that communities across the country are facing.
Comment on this
I also want to commemorate the Creeslough tragedy. Recently, I travelled to Donegal and met many of the families who lost loved ones in that foreseeable and predictable tragedy. As a House, we need to be mindful that there are officeholders, such as county managers and fire officers, who ought to have participated more proactively in the review process of the change of use for that premises. There are serious unanswered questions about these deaths, and the families cannot move on and cannot grieve. We understand and support the families of Omagh in getting answers to what happened to their loved ones and we should show the same enthusiasm and support for the families of Creeslough in finding out what happened to their loved ones. I know what happened to them, and it was foreseeable, predictable and preventable. We need a proper inquiry into it.
Overnight, I have been contacted by many members of our community of carers and disabled citizens. Unfortunately, the cost of disability payment has been tied directly to the social welfare status of many of our citizens. For example, families with disabled children under the age of 16 will not qualify for this cost-of-disability payment. When children are young and small, the costs are significant. I thank the Ceannaire for organising the Minister of State, Deputy Higgins, to come to the House for a debate on all of these issues. I really appreciate it. I know the motivation behind the payment was well intentioned but it is grounded in a very deterministic view of the rights of disabled citizens, and we need to have a full conversation about this.
Comment on this
This is National Breastfeeding Week and we have to ensure that women who want to breastfeed are supported to do so. There are women who gave birth in hospitals and wanted to breastfeed but felt the bottle was presented very quickly before they had proper help or time to establish breastfeeding. If women want to breastfeed but are struggling or nervous, then a lactation consultant should be made available to them. Ireland has made some progress, and this is worth recognising, but our breastfeeding rates are some of the lowest internationally. We know that breastfeeding lowers the risk of many illnesses, so funding support is a positive investment for our health system and the baby's long-term health.
The issue comes back to resources. Budget 2026 promised funding for five new lactation consultant posts, which remain unfilled because of HSE budget pressures. In total, there are 11 unfilled posts, which represent about 16% of breastfeeding consultants who should be working in our hospitals. Breastfeeding support cannot be viewed as an optional extra. We know the first few weeks are crucial. These positions need to be filled and I have contacted the Minister in relation to this.
It was brilliant to see the Baddies Breastfeed mural launched this week, because it uses art to help normalise breastfeeding for our younger generation. We have to keep women and mothers at the centre of this conversation. They are the only ones who can biologically breastfeed their babies and this reality needs to be recognised and protected. If women want to breastfeed, they should know that help is available and a lactation consultant is there to support them.
Comment on this
I have come to the House today to speak about the Oleshky situation in Ukraine. Just as I was coming up the stairs, the ambassador to Ireland, Larysa Gerasko, sent me photographs and videos of her hometown, which was bombed overnight. I believe that 15 people have lost their lives. Her own family home - her auntie's home - was bombed, and it is rubble. Her aunt survived. Horrendous stuff is happening in Ukraine. It seems like we have got used to the barrage of information and bombings, we are not taking as much notice and there is a bit of apathy. I was in Ukraine three weeks ago and I saw the devastation on the ground.
I do think the war is turning, and it is not turning in favour of Ukraine. We need to be seen to be very supportive. The town of Oleshky is 9 km from the city of Kherson. This is 2026 and there are 6,000 people there who are starving. Food has been cut off. Delivery of gas and electricity has been cut off. People are making soup from grass. The head of the town's administration has evidence that some families have eaten their own dogs. The hospital has turned its basement into a place for holding bodies but it is not able to get the bodies out or bury them because it is not allowed. Of the 6,000 people who are in Oleshky at the moment, 200 are children.
The UN is monitoring the situation but it has said people cannot get out and it cannot get food in. Ukraine has offered safe routes and a ceasefire, and the Red Cross has said it is ready, but Russia is saying "No" to every proposal. Under the fourth Geneva Convention, an occupying power must feed the people it occupies, and we discussed this recently in the House in relation to other areas such as Gaza. What Russia is doing is the opposite of what the Geneva Convention states and it is using hunger as a weapon.
I ask the Leader to request the Minister for foreign affairs to come to the House to raise the issue of Oleshky, and to request her to raise it at the next meeting of EU foreign ministers and press for a humanitarian corridor supervised by the Red Cross. I ask that the Minister come before the House to tell us what Ireland is doing to support this. Winter is coming to Oleshky and it is a cruel time. When the family of our ambassador from Ukraine to Ireland is experiencing bombings, we can see how close this is coming.
Comment on this
Three weeks ago, I raised the Lahinch and Calluragh wastewater treatment proposal that Uisce Éireann had been engaging in and I requested that Uisce Éireann establish and enter into a non-statutory public consultation on the specific proposed site for this development. A meeting between Oireachtas Members, councillors and Uisce Éireann was held three weeks ago next Friday, at which I also made my request. Uisce Éireann said that it would be back within a week with an answer, one way or the other. That was almost three weeks ago and all Uisce Éireann has sent is a standard acknowledgement, thanking people for attending the meeting. Straight away, we have a breach of good faith on the part of Uisce Éireann. It is completely and totally unacceptable. I see this project in Lahinch in County Clare as an example of how Uisce Éireann does its business throughout the country. I would say to colleagues here and to communities throughout the country to watch this proposed treatment plant and how Uisce Éireann behaves in the process.
Let it be an example as to how it does its business because this proposal is not acceptable and is not in the right location. Lahinch lost its blue flag as a result of improper and inappropriate wastewater. We are now going to build a new facility, which will be substandard, based on what is being proposed, in the wrong area, and will continue this issue. The sun is shining brightly on the community in Lahinch and surrounding areas because they are standing up, being counted and calling out what is wrong but there is a dark cloud over Irish Water because of sharp practice, commitments broken and questionable behaviour.
I reiterate my call on Irish Water to establish a non-statutory public consultation. If it believes this to be the best solution, what has it to hide? Why is it not establishing such a consultation? Will the Leader send another letter to Irish Water and to the Minister requesting that this happen? Lahinch is a jewel in the crown of this country and we want to get this right. I and the local community want to work with Irish Water but this breach of faith on its part is simply not good enough.
Comment on this
I welcome two guests of our colleague, Senator Comyn. They are Jack Jones and Jerome Lavelle. I hope they enjoy their visit to Leinster House.
Comment on this
I thank the 19 Senators who have made contributions. Senator O'Loughlin spoke about the new Jigsaw service to be provided in Newbridge at a cost of €1.1 million investment annually. We have seen in Tipperary, Wicklow and other countries the service Jigsaw provides for young people aged between 18 and 25. More investment in facilities like this in each county is hugely important. I know Senator has been focused on that for a number of years. She also spoke of regulation of rickshaws. We had a tragedy a number of days ago and there is no licensing legislation at the moment. I will try to facilitate a debate in the Seanad on it.
Senator P.J. Murphy spoke of lurchers, rural crime in general and how rural pursuits can be an important part of people's livelihood. There are a certain group of people involved in illegal activity, which needs to be regulated. The Senator spoke to the local garda on it. Investment in gardaí, particularly in rural Ireland, is important. I suggest the Senator put down a Commencement matter on that issue with the Minister. He makes a valid point about how other countries, particularly Spain, deal with that through DNA tracking of all dogs. That might be useful.
Senator Boyhan spoke about the 270 new GPs who have graduated, which is hugely welcome. One of the challenges for every community is having a local GP. Having 270 graduating, which is supposedly the highest number in quite some time, is important. The Senator asked for a number of debates. On Food Vision, the Senator asked for a debate couple of weeks ago and I am working with the Minister's office to see when we can do it. On a debate on Our Rural Future with the Minister, Deputy Calleary, I will see if that is possible. We have not had the Minister in for a while. I will talk to his office. As to the local government task force, we will have a debate on that next week with the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins. Many Senators asked me in the weeks before we went on recess for a debate on the local government task force report that was to be published. I have agreement from the Minister of State's office that he will be available next week to do that.
Senator Collins spoke of the junior certificate results. I am sure she is nervous for her daughter today. I hope everything goes well; I have no doubt it will. She also raised the 271 bus from Abbeyfeale to Tralee, which a lot of students take. That service should be provided from closer to the city. I think that is what she said. It seems incredible there has been no response from Bus Éireann. I do not know whether it has been before the transport committee recently. A number of public transport groups have. When it is before the committee, it is always a good opportunity to bring up local issues. If not, I will talk to the Minister on the Senator's behalf.
Senator Comyn spoke about mental health funding for County Louth and said €660,000 annually is going to our Lady of Lourdes Hospital for four nurses to support people's mental health. The Minister of State, Deputy Butler, has done an awful lot in recent years to increase funding and investment and bring the first piece of legislation on mental health through these Houses. She is very passionate about it and we are starting to see the work she is doing in places like Louth, which is positive.
Senator Boyle mentioned the Creeslough tragedy, which many people have spoken about today. To follow on from the sentiments of most people, we are all thinking of those people today and of the community that still has a burden of pain from that tragedy. The Senator also mentioned the junior certificate results. His son Barry sat it. Barry, Senator Boyle, Arlene and the family are waiting patiently but I am sure he will get on fine. I have met him once or twice. He is an intelligent young fella, so I have no doubt he will do well. The Senator asked for a debate on gardaí in rural Ireland. A number of Senators have asked this. There is continuously extra funding in relation to numbers of gardaí. We are going to hit record numbers of members of An Garda Síochána coming through Templemore shortly. There will be an extra 1,000 next year through the budget, which is positive. I attend the passing-out ceremony there quite often and one of the most frustrating things is when 200 or 250 new gardaí are graduating, it is read out where they are all going and there is no mention of Tipperary or Donegal. It can be frustrating seeing over 200 of them in front of you and knowing they are all off to other parts of the country, predominantly cities. That said, cities need extra gardaí as well. Everywhere does but there is an opportunity to have a debate on rural crime and security.
Senator Joe Conway spoke about a number of anniversaries, particularly RTÉ's 100-year anniversary. Perhaps the Cathaoirleach will write on behalf of the Seanad to congratulate it on its anniversary, the work it does and the service it provides to people across the country. I am happy to do it. I am not sure which is more appropriate but one of us should certainly write to RTÉ.
Comment on this
Both of us could do it. We will double down and talk about how much good work it does.
Senator Rabbitte spoke of road safety, particularly on the N65 between Portumna and Kilmeen Cross. There is investment in road safety measures and in transport. She said an assessment should be done. It would seem logical the council would do a safety assessment in conjunction with An Garda Síochána and make recommendations on the back of that. Sometimes it seems we have to wait for a very bad accident to happen before something gets done.
Senator Scahill also spoke on rural Ireland and the number of gardaí, and asked for a debate on rural policing. I am more than happy to do that. He mentioned the passing of former councillor Ernie Keenan in Roscommon. He was a wonderful councillor, a former cathaoirleach and a loved person in Boyle, particularly in Boyle GAA. I pass on condolences on behalf of Fine Gael to his wife Carmel and his extended family. We had the passing of another former councillor in Sligo, Ita Fox. She served about 27 years as a councillor. She took over from her husband when he died and her son, Tom Fox, was a councillor as well up to the last election. Our thoughts are with the Fox family in Sligo also.
Senator Andrews spoke about the good results. Soccer is going well. Hopefully, the girls will get another win next week. That is the biggest match we have coming up. Hopefully, they get over the line.
In relation to the horse and greyhound fund, the Senator has spoken about it a number of times in this House and has been very passionate. As to his questions about Kilkenny and someone being on a board, I do not have the details. I am sure if there is something wrong with that, an investigation will happen. It is not for us, or certainly for me, to make a judgment on that. The only thing I will say is that, as the Senator knows, given that he has been here long enough, we have a debate in this House on the horse and greyhound fund every year. It is always an opportunity for people to lay out their positions, and I have no doubt that will happen. The Senator heard people talking about rural pursuits already this morning and the importance of those in their communities, but that does not mean his concerns are not genuine either.
Senator Rabbitte spoke about breast cancer awareness month. There has been a vast improvement in outcomes. One in seven women get breast cancer, and some men get it as well, but we have seen a huge improvement in the past 20 or 30 years. I always relate it to when my mother passed away with breast cancer 26 years ago. Due to the improved investment and medical care in this country, if she had it today, she would survive. There are a lot of women alive today because of the improved care, particularly in breast cancer. However, having awareness and people being aware of their bodies is the number one priority. The more we can do on that to support people to make them aware so that they will go and get checked, the more the rates will reduce in terms of people passing from it.
Senator Keogan spoke about the three-day abortion Bill going the committee at the moment. She spoke about people who were not invited to it to give their perspective. I am not sure if the Senator is on the committee, but she knows from all committees that the members decide who comes in to speak. I do not know what the decisions were within the 14 members of the health committee. The Chair makes the final decision based on what the members decide. Whether it is on this legislation or any other, it seems to me that there are always people on both sides coming in who are experts in their lines of work and can give a perspective like the Senator gave today. It would be disappointing if that did not happen-----
Comment on this
-----but that is for the Chair and members to decide. The members can put as much pressure on the Chair as they want. The Senator knows that this Bill will leave that committee at some point and then come to us, and there will be an opportunity to debate it in this House, but the real scrutiny happens at that committee, and it is important to acknowledge that.
Senator Cathal Byrne raised the strange case of a councillor looking for statistics in terms of speed and deaths on a particular road in Rosslare in County Wexford and the fact that the Road Safety Authority decided that it would not give those figures because of general data protection regulation, GDPR. That makes absolutely no sense. How are we meant to invest in road infrastructure in counties if councils, which play a key role in that, cannot get information on speed and road deaths? I will take that up directly with the Minister for Transport because it just does not seem right at all.
Senator Tully spoke about the Garvaghy Road, and a number of people spoke about it yesterday. We are all on the same wavelength in this House and the Lower House in terms of wanting a solution and people to come to their senses. No one wants to go back to where we were. The Minister for foreign affairs has been in constant contact with her counterpart in the UK. She was in Northern Ireland the day before yesterday and she has spoken to all parties on all sides, but we need to come some sort of resolution. I know that the Minister is in here this evening to discuss neutrality and the triple lock. She has been working extremely hard on this for the past week to make sure that we do not go back to where we were.
Senator Clonan raised the disability payment, and he raised it yesterday as well. I thank him for his appreciation as regards getting the Minister of State in. It is important that we have her in to speak about disability matters in general, but he believes that there could be an issue with some people missing out on that €500 payment. There will be an opportunity to speak to the Minister of State about it in two weeks' time. The Finance Bill will go through both Houses, and if there is anything that needs to be tweaked or done, I have no doubt that the Senator will make very good suggestions on that. There will be an opportunity to discuss it.
Senator Sarah O'Reilly spoke about breastfeeding week and the importance of educating people on the benefits of breastfeeding. She gave an example of where people were not encouraged as much as they should be to breastfeed. I can only speak from my own experience, but we got great encouragement in Cork University Hospital in terms of education and how to do it when our two boys were born. Obviously, kids react differently. There were always people there to help, encourage and educate new mothers in particular on the benefits of breastfeeding. I would hope that that happens in all hospitals.
Senator McCarthy about Ukraine. It is something that does not come up as much as it should because as he rightly said, things are changing at the moment and not for the better. The German Chancellor was over there during the week, and it was welcomed. He is giving a €1 billion investment from Germany to support Ukraine going forward. As I said a few minutes ago, we will have a debate on neutrality and the triple lock with the Minister for foreign affairs at 3 p.m., but I am sure she will be well able to sidestep into a comment on Ukraine.
Senator Martin Conway spoke about Lahinch. He has been on this from the very start and has pushed and pushed. He is starting to see that no matter how strongly people push with Uisce Éireann, they still get nothing back from it sometimes. Councillors are telling us this all of the time about their communications with Uisce Éireann and the lack of detail and knowing what will actually be done. The Senator asked Uisce Éireann for a simple thing like a consultation with the public to put forward what its plan is. It said that it would be back in a week but a month later, it still has not come back. I will contact it again on the Senator's behalf and we should both talk to the Minister directly about it because it is just not acceptable. Uisce Éireann is a publicly funded body but it certainly does not have the same accountability as other publicly funded bodies, which is one of the problems with it.
Finally, Senator Duffy raised wind energy. Wind and solar energy are things that we do not have clear guidelines on. We see it in rural areas across the country where it stokes up an awful lot of fear - fear of the unknown and of what is going to happen. I know that the Senator is someone who is very pro renewable energy, but for it to be done right. He gave a good example from his county of Mayo where things needed to be done, but done correctly. I know that he, along with Councillor Jarlath Munnelly, will support that community in trying to get as much information as possible.
I have finished on Senator Duffy for a reason. I am not sure that the House is aware but-----
Comment on this
Regarding the commemoration of what happened in Israel on 7 October 2023, will the Leader mention that as well? It was the largest killing of Jews since the Holocaust. Some 1,200 people died and hundreds of hostages were taken, so we should mention that today.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I concur with Senator Keogan. The date of 7 October is a significant day for the people of Israel and Jewish people in general. We have a lot of people who live in Ireland who will be thinking of loved ones and family members who died in that tragedy. We are a Parliament and a people who do not want to see any killings from any side. It does not matter what or who it is, and we certainly do not want a terrorist organisation like Hamas killing thousands of people. It is important to acknowledge it, and I thank the Senator for raising it. We do not want to see any more killings today, tomorrow or in the future.
I want to finish on Senator Duffy for a reason. I know that the Leas-Chathaoirleach is aware, but I am not sure that the House knows that Senator Duffy got married yesterday. While we were at budget and working, Senator Duffy went off to marry his wonderful now wife, Sarah. I know he is taking some time off in the next couple of weeks. His honeymoon was at the transport committee in committee room 4 this morning.
As a House, I know we all wish Senator Duffy and his wife Sarah and daughter Bridget well. I know it was a big day for the whole family.