We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Leader’s replies to Senators

Summary

The Leader responds to several matters raised, including Jigsaw funding, road safety and rural Garda resources, and says Senators will have an opportunity to debate the abortion bill. Members interject during the replies.

I thank the 19 Senators who have made contributions. Senator O'Loughlin spoke about the new Jigsaw service to be provided in Newbridge at a cost of €1.1 million investment annually. We have seen in Tipperary, Wicklow and other countries the service Jigsaw provides for young people aged between 18 and 25. More investment in facilities like this in each county is hugely important. I know Senator has been focused on that for a number of years. She also spoke of regulation of rickshaws. We had a tragedy a number of days ago and there is no licensing legislation at the moment. I will try to facilitate a debate in the Seanad on it.

Senator P.J. Murphy spoke of lurchers, rural crime in general and how rural pursuits can be an important part of people's livelihood. There are a certain group of people involved in illegal activity, which needs to be regulated. The Senator spoke to the local garda on it. Investment in gardaí, particularly in rural Ireland, is important. I suggest the Senator put down a Commencement matter on that issue with the Minister. He makes a valid point about how other countries, particularly Spain, deal with that through DNA tracking of all dogs. That might be useful.

Senator Boyhan spoke about the 270 new GPs who have graduated, which is hugely welcome. One of the challenges for every community is having a local GP. Having 270 graduating, which is supposedly the highest number in quite some time, is important. The Senator asked for a number of debates. On Food Vision, the Senator asked for a debate couple of weeks ago and I am working with the Minister's office to see when we can do it. On a debate on Our Rural Future with the Minister, Deputy Calleary, I will see if that is possible. We have not had the Minister in for a while. I will talk to his office. As to the local government task force, we will have a debate on that next week with the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins. Many Senators asked me in the weeks before we went on recess for a debate on the local government task force report that was to be published. I have agreement from the Minister of State's office that he will be available next week to do that.

Senator Collins spoke of the junior certificate results. I am sure she is nervous for her daughter today. I hope everything goes well; I have no doubt it will. She also raised the 271 bus from Abbeyfeale to Tralee, which a lot of students take. That service should be provided from closer to the city. I think that is what she said. It seems incredible there has been no response from Bus Éireann. I do not know whether it has been before the transport committee recently. A number of public transport groups have. When it is before the committee, it is always a good opportunity to bring up local issues. If not, I will talk to the Minister on the Senator's behalf.

Senator Comyn spoke about mental health funding for County Louth and said €660,000 annually is going to our Lady of Lourdes Hospital for four nurses to support people's mental health. The Minister of State, Deputy Butler, has done an awful lot in recent years to increase funding and investment and bring the first piece of legislation on mental health through these Houses. She is very passionate about it and we are starting to see the work she is doing in places like Louth, which is positive.

Senator Boyle mentioned the Creeslough tragedy, which many people have spoken about today. To follow on from the sentiments of most people, we are all thinking of those people today and of the community that still has a burden of pain from that tragedy. The Senator also mentioned the junior certificate results. His son Barry sat it. Barry, Senator Boyle, Arlene and the family are waiting patiently but I am sure he will get on fine. I have met him once or twice. He is an intelligent young fella, so I have no doubt he will do well. The Senator asked for a debate on gardaí in rural Ireland. A number of Senators have asked this. There is continuously extra funding in relation to numbers of gardaí. We are going to hit record numbers of members of An Garda Síochána coming through Templemore shortly. There will be an extra 1,000 next year through the budget, which is positive. I attend the passing-out ceremony there quite often and one of the most frustrating things is when 200 or 250 new gardaí are graduating, it is read out where they are all going and there is no mention of Tipperary or Donegal. It can be frustrating seeing over 200 of them in front of you and knowing they are all off to other parts of the country, predominantly cities. That said, cities need extra gardaí as well. Everywhere does but there is an opportunity to have a debate on rural crime and security.

Senator Joe Conway spoke about a number of anniversaries, particularly RTÉ's 100-year anniversary. Perhaps the Cathaoirleach will write on behalf of the Seanad to congratulate it on its anniversary, the work it does and the service it provides to people across the country. I am happy to do it. I am not sure which is more appropriate but one of us should certainly write to RTÉ.

Comment on this
A Senator

Both of you.

Comment on this

Both of us could do it. We will double down and talk about how much good work it does.

Senator Rabbitte spoke of road safety, particularly on the N65 between Portumna and Kilmeen Cross. There is investment in road safety measures and in transport. She said an assessment should be done. It would seem logical the council would do a safety assessment in conjunction with An Garda Síochána and make recommendations on the back of that. Sometimes it seems we have to wait for a very bad accident to happen before something gets done.

Senator Scahill also spoke on rural Ireland and the number of gardaí, and asked for a debate on rural policing. I am more than happy to do that. He mentioned the passing of former councillor Ernie Keenan in Roscommon. He was a wonderful councillor, a former cathaoirleach and a loved person in Boyle, particularly in Boyle GAA. I pass on condolences on behalf of Fine Gael to his wife Carmel and his extended family. We had the passing of another former councillor in Sligo, Ita Fox. She served about 27 years as a councillor. She took over from her husband when he died and her son, Tom Fox, was a councillor as well up to the last election. Our thoughts are with the Fox family in Sligo also.

Senator Andrews spoke about the good results. Soccer is going well. Hopefully, the girls will get another win next week. That is the biggest match we have coming up. Hopefully, they get over the line.

In relation to the horse and greyhound fund, the Senator has spoken about it a number of times in this House and has been very passionate. As to his questions about Kilkenny and someone being on a board, I do not have the details. I am sure if there is something wrong with that, an investigation will happen. It is not for us, or certainly for me, to make a judgment on that. The only thing I will say is that, as the Senator knows, given that he has been here long enough, we have a debate in this House on the horse and greyhound fund every year. It is always an opportunity for people to lay out their positions, and I have no doubt that will happen. The Senator heard people talking about rural pursuits already this morning and the importance of those in their communities, but that does not mean his concerns are not genuine either.

Senator Rabbitte spoke about breast cancer awareness month. There has been a vast improvement in outcomes. One in seven women get breast cancer, and some men get it as well, but we have seen a huge improvement in the past 20 or 30 years. I always relate it to when my mother passed away with breast cancer 26 years ago. Due to the improved investment and medical care in this country, if she had it today, she would survive. There are a lot of women alive today because of the improved care, particularly in breast cancer. However, having awareness and people being aware of their bodies is the number one priority. The more we can do on that to support people to make them aware so that they will go and get checked, the more the rates will reduce in terms of people passing from it.

Senator Keogan spoke about the three-day abortion Bill going the committee at the moment. She spoke about people who were not invited to it to give their perspective. I am not sure if the Senator is on the committee, but she knows from all committees that the members decide who comes in to speak. I do not know what the decisions were within the 14 members of the health committee. The Chair makes the final decision based on what the members decide. Whether it is on this legislation or any other, it seems to me that there are always people on both sides coming in who are experts in their lines of work and can give a perspective like the Senator gave today. It would be disappointing if that did not happen-----

Comment on this

It did not happen.

Comment on this

-----but that is for the Chair and members to decide. The members can put as much pressure on the Chair as they want. The Senator knows that this Bill will leave that committee at some point and then come to us, and there will be an opportunity to debate it in this House, but the real scrutiny happens at that committee, and it is important to acknowledge that.

Senator Cathal Byrne raised the strange case of a councillor looking for statistics in terms of speed and deaths on a particular road in Rosslare in County Wexford and the fact that the Road Safety Authority decided that it would not give those figures because of general data protection regulation, GDPR. That makes absolutely no sense. How are we meant to invest in road infrastructure in counties if councils, which play a key role in that, cannot get information on speed and road deaths? I will take that up directly with the Minister for Transport because it just does not seem right at all.

Senator Tully spoke about the Garvaghy Road, and a number of people spoke about it yesterday. We are all on the same wavelength in this House and the Lower House in terms of wanting a solution and people to come to their senses. No one wants to go back to where we were. The Minister for foreign affairs has been in constant contact with her counterpart in the UK. She was in Northern Ireland the day before yesterday and she has spoken to all parties on all sides, but we need to come some sort of resolution. I know that the Minister is in here this evening to discuss neutrality and the triple lock. She has been working extremely hard on this for the past week to make sure that we do not go back to where we were.

Senator Clonan raised the disability payment, and he raised it yesterday as well. I thank him for his appreciation as regards getting the Minister of State in. It is important that we have her in to speak about disability matters in general, but he believes that there could be an issue with some people missing out on that €500 payment. There will be an opportunity to speak to the Minister of State about it in two weeks' time. The Finance Bill will go through both Houses, and if there is anything that needs to be tweaked or done, I have no doubt that the Senator will make very good suggestions on that. There will be an opportunity to discuss it.

Senator Sarah O'Reilly spoke about breastfeeding week and the importance of educating people on the benefits of breastfeeding. She gave an example of where people were not encouraged as much as they should be to breastfeed. I can only speak from my own experience, but we got great encouragement in Cork University Hospital in terms of education and how to do it when our two boys were born. Obviously, kids react differently. There were always people there to help, encourage and educate new mothers in particular on the benefits of breastfeeding. I would hope that that happens in all hospitals.

Senator McCarthy about Ukraine. It is something that does not come up as much as it should because as he rightly said, things are changing at the moment and not for the better. The German Chancellor was over there during the week, and it was welcomed. He is giving a €1 billion investment from Germany to support Ukraine going forward. As I said a few minutes ago, we will have a debate on neutrality and the triple lock with the Minister for foreign affairs at 3 p.m., but I am sure she will be well able to sidestep into a comment on Ukraine.

Senator Martin Conway spoke about Lahinch. He has been on this from the very start and has pushed and pushed. He is starting to see that no matter how strongly people push with Uisce Éireann, they still get nothing back from it sometimes. Councillors are telling us this all of the time about their communications with Uisce Éireann and the lack of detail and knowing what will actually be done. The Senator asked Uisce Éireann for a simple thing like a consultation with the public to put forward what its plan is. It said that it would be back in a week but a month later, it still has not come back. I will contact it again on the Senator's behalf and we should both talk to the Minister directly about it because it is just not acceptable. Uisce Éireann is a publicly funded body but it certainly does not have the same accountability as other publicly funded bodies, which is one of the problems with it.

Finally, Senator Duffy raised wind energy. Wind and solar energy are things that we do not have clear guidelines on. We see it in rural areas across the country where it stokes up an awful lot of fear - fear of the unknown and of what is going to happen. I know that the Senator is someone who is very pro renewable energy, but for it to be done right. He gave a good example from his county of Mayo where things needed to be done, but done correctly. I know that he, along with Councillor Jarlath Munnelly, will support that community in trying to get as much information as possible.

I have finished on Senator Duffy for a reason. I am not sure that the House is aware but-----

Comment on this