We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Referendum on Irish Neutrality and Protection of the Triple Lock: Motion

Summary

Senator Clonan’s motion called for a referendum to constitutionally guarantee military neutrality and protect the Triple Lock, alongside stronger investment and support for the Defence Forces. Supporters argued that removing the UN mandate requirement risks deployments in offensive operations and weakens Ireland’s impartial peacekeeping role. Government supporters said reforming the statutory Triple Lock does not change neutrality, and would return deployment decisions to Ireland’s democratic institutions while preserving oversight and international-law obligations. The Minister began her response; no decision is recorded in this section.

Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I welcome the Minister to the House for the motion on a referendum on Irish neutrality and protection of the triple lock. The combined speeches for the proposer and seconder shall not exceed 15 minutes and all other Senators have six minutes. I call on Senator Clonan to move the motion.

Comment on this

I move:

That Seanad Éireann:

acknowledges that:

- the Irish Times/Ipsos B&A opinion poll from February 2026 shows that 71 per cent of the population believes that a guarantee of Ireland’s neutrality should be added to the Constitution; 45 per cent of the population believes that Ireland should keep the Triple Lock, 35 per cent thinks it should be removed while 21 per cent don’t know or have no opinion;

- a more recent poll published by The Irish Times in September showed that 68 per cent supported Ireland’s current model of neutrality, while 44 per cent of the population favoured retaining the Triple Lock;

- Ireland’s military neutrality – not being members of a formal international military alliance – has been and remains a central and invaluable component of our foreign policy since the foundation of the State;

- the Government has published the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026 that will abolish the Triple Lock;

- the Government Legislation Programme Autumn 2026, published by the Department of An Taoiseach, states the Bill is currently on ‘Order for Second Stage’ and it is currently at First Stage in the Dáil;

- the Bill explicitly states that it provides for ‘The despatch and deployment for service outside the State of members of the Defence Forces’;

- in the absence of the Triple Lock, any future Government may deploy any number of Irish soldiers to any conflict at any time and to any conflict without UN Security Council sanction and by simple Government majority;

- without UN Security Council Mandates, any such future mission will not be a UN mission, will not be a blue helmet mission and will be a ‘Chapter 7’ or ‘Peace Enforcement’ type mission including, but not limited to, so-called ‘coalitions of the willing’, ‘stabilisation forces’, ‘special military operations’, ‘major combat operations’ or ‘armed interventions’;

- in the absence of a UN Security Council Mandate, such missions will not involve the consent of all parties to a conflict and will therefore be de facto offensive military operations;

- in the absence of the Triple Lock and UN Security Council Mandate, the Irish people will rely on a community of decision makers in the Departments of An Taoiseach, Defence and Justice that have left Ireland virtually defenceless in the air, maritime, ground and cyber domains to make competent decisions as to what future conflict zones Ireland will deploy the men and women of Óglaigh na hÉireann;

- while the Dáil has the constitutional mandate to make such decisions, given the track record of domestic decision making on defence matters, there is a requirement for some oversight mechanism to ensure that we do not commit troops to international conflict zones contrary to the best interests of the Irish people;

- abolishing the Triple Lock, which has been a core component of Irish neutrality consists of abandoning the multilateral principle of a UN mandate and is taking place at time of high global instability, where illegal unilateral military actions are becoming more commonplace and where full spectrum powers are seeking to undermine the multilateral principles of the UN Charter, the UN Security Council and the laws and conventions of international law;

- at this inflection point, Ireland should ensure in this state of geopolitical instability and flux, Ireland should have its non-aligned militarily neutral status explicitly stated in Bunreacht na hÉireann by way of a referendum put to the Irish people;

notes that:

- Ireland’s military neutrality underpins our international status as an independent and impartial voice for peace and the de-escalation of armed conflict and the non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction throughout the world;

- Ireland’s military neutrality – in tandem with our highly esteemed global diaspora – contributes to Ireland’s unique voice for peace and reconciliation throughout the world;

- Ireland’s military neutrality and our leadership in peacekeeping gives great moral authority and legitimacy to our voice for the international rule of law, and the peaceful resolution of conflict and oppression;

- Ireland retains the political discretion to support any member of the international community in crisis, on a case-by-case basis, with the protection of the Triple Lock mechanism, without the necessity to join a military alliance;

- in a time of increased political and military instability in Europe – with the invasion of Ukraine – and in a time of global de-stabilisation and accelerating climate change, that our military neutrality is more important than ever;

- the Oireachtas Committee on Defence has been prevented from properly scrutinising decisions being made by the Government;

calls on the Government to:

- hold a referendum on inserting our non-aligned military neutrality into the Constitution in the context of the imminent abolition of the Triple Lock;

- properly fund Ireland’s Army, Air Corps, Naval Service and cyber capability in order that we can vindicate our sovereign, neutral status and properly secure our land, air, maritime and cyber domains;

- pay our soldiers, air-crew and sailors a living wage as a matter of urgency in order to address the current chronic recruitment and retention crisis in order that Ireland can meaningfully respond to man-made and natural disasters;

- expand the Reserve Defence Forces in order that Ireland can harness its unique human capital and skill-sets on a voluntary basis to support whole of society resilience in a time of accelerating climate change and rising hybrid threat assessments;

- appoint a Minister for Defence, with an exclusive portfolio, in all future administrations, to properly lead and advocate for Ireland’s defence and national security in order to vindicate our sovereign neutral status and to allow for ‘whole of society’ resilience; and

- guarantee Ireland’s status as a militarily neutral state and commits to preserving that neutral status by way of a constitutional guarantee as is the case in Austria and Switzerland.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I believe the Senators are sharing time. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister to the House. Before I begin, I acknowledge her very progressive statements at the UN General Assembly. She and the Taoiseach did the nation proud. They were very clear in their condemnation of the actions of Netanyahu and the IDF. It is great to have a Government that is so clear and explicit on those matters.

In relation to today's debate, the reason I introduced this motion is that I was in the Defence Forces for 11 years. I participated in aid-to-the-civil-power operations and I commanded troops at home and abroad in conflict conditions. I did my PhD in the military. For the past 25 years, I have been publishing peer-reviewed academic articles about defence and chapters in international military journals. In addition, I have been The Irish Times security analyst for 15 years and, latterly, for The Journal. I do a lot of analysis for international platforms and think-tanks. I will give the keynote speech next May to the Austrian defence academy in Vienna in the Flakturm about neutrality. What I am going to set out today is not just a subjective, deeply held personal opinion. It is based on lived and professional experience and a proven track record in peer-reviewed publication in this area.

I am very concerned about the misinformation and disinformation being circulated in our public discourse about the removal of the triple lock. I am very concerned that there is a concerted public affairs effort to manufacture consent for the erosion of what the Taoiseach said was at the core of our neutrality, namely, the triple lock. At the moment, if we want to deploy troops overseas, we need a UN Security Council mandate and approval by the Dáil and the Government. Those are three elements. If the triple lock is removed, then that is it. There is no safeguard, brake or oversight mechanism for the deployment of our troops overseas. I was heartened to hear the Minister say at some point in the past couple of months that she would be open to the idea of an expert group or somebody whom the Government could consult to fully explore the legal ramifications and otherwise of a deployment. I welcome that idea. That is what other countries do. For example, Austria has a set of mechanisms it employs as a filter or frame through which it makes the decision to deploy its troops internationally.

If the triple lock as set out in the legislation is removed - here is another myth - that is not reforming the triple lock or revising it. It is abolishing it, simply removing it and not replacing it with anything else. When that happens, it means any future government by simple government majority can send any number of Irish troops to any conflict internationally without any reference to any oversight mechanism, backstop or brake to such a decision. To do that, we would be relying on a community of decision-makers who have left this country completely defenceless in the maritime, air, ground and cyber domains. They have allowed us to be in a position where the Royal Air Force now patrols our airspace, contrary to our sovereign status and, as Senator Craughwell is trying to prove in the courts, unconstitutional. British and French naval assets are providing security. Portuguese and Spanish military assets - not police - were on the roof of this House with anti-drone weapons. That is farcical. How can we trust that community of decision-makers to make a coherent or rational decision about where we send out troops in the future?

I implore the Minister not to set her face against the will of the people. The triple lock was guaranteed by a solemn national declaration in 2002, responded to by the European Union in the Seville declaration of that year. The Government cannot just renegue on solemn declarations given to the Irish people by fiat. If the Government guillotines this and whips it through the Houses, there will be a great deal of disquiet, discomfort and alarm. It is the wrong thing to do.

Another myth constantly recirculated, which the Taoiseach said in the Irish Examiner last week and I have heard the Minister of State, Deputy Thomas Byrne, and the Minister herself say regularly, is that they are doing this to safeguard our proud tradition of peacekeeping. Let me be absolutely clear: without a UN Security Council mandate, it is not a blue helmet mission and it is certainly not peacekeeping. What kinds of missions would our troops be going on? They would be coalitions of the willing, stabilisation forces - who knows? - special military operations, or task forces like the one proposed for Donbas in the event of a settlement. President Zelenskyy, Keir Starmer, then Prime Minister of the UK, and Emmanuel Macron co-signed a letter of intent to create a European task force to help monitor the peace in Donbas. The Russians issued an official statement saying this is unacceptable and that they would be legitimate targets for the Russians and for resistance groups in the area. That is not going to be a peacekeeping mission; it will be a peace enforcement mission.

I have heard people in this House say we should stay on in Lebanon after the mandate expires. If we leave Irish troops in Lebanon after the mandate expires, they will be slaughtered either by Hezbollah or the Israelis or by both because they will have no legal basis for being there. If they are invited by the Lebanese Government to support the Lebanese armed forces, then they will become a de facto part of a Lebanese civil war. That is not peacekeeping; it is picking sides and fighting. They are de facto peace enforcement missions.

There will be no more peacekeeping missions in this century. The days of the classic Cold War peacekeeping mission like UNIFIL with the consent of all of the belligerent parties are over. They do not exist any more. The Minister needs to be honest with the people. The Government is removing the triple lock so it can send troops on Chapter VII peace enforcement fighting missions around the world.

That is fine and that is the prerogative of the Dáil but the people have said in poll after poll they do not want to send their children off to fight in foreign wars. Another myth being circulated, which I hear former Members of these Houses stating constantly, is that we can only send 12 troops abroad to help our citizens in distress, such as getting them out of Sudan or Kabul Airport. They say we can only send 12 troops because of the triple lock. That is a lie. That is disinformation. It was confirmed to the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Defence and National Security last May that there is no such prohibition and an Irish government can send any number of troops it wants to deal with man-made or natural disasters internationally because they are ad hoc operations and not formal military missions, so let us knock that one on the head. In addition, we are at a point when the United States has declared war on Iran - in fact, it has not even declared war but just taken unilateral action against Iran, contrary to the international laws of armed conflict. When that happened the Minister was asked if that was an illegal war and she was either unable, or to put it charitably unwilling, to say whether it was illegal or not, so again how can we rely on this decision-making community to make rational decisions about where we send our troops? We should not be abandoning the rules-based order but embracing, supporting and reforming the multilateral principles of the UN Security Council and there is an initiative to reform the Security Council.

I am going to respond to the amendments that were set down in my concluding remarks. I agree with about three of them but so many of them are factually incorrect, such as the statement that we do not belong to any military alliance. We are a member of the European Union battle groups. We are a member of the United Nations standby arrangements system. The Government should proofread its documents because I do not know where it is getting its information from. It has been repeated over and over again that we should not allow Russia or China to veto where we send our troops. Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin do not care where we send our troops. I am surprised they even know we have an army. The decision to be bound by the multilateral principles of the UN Security Council was a sovereign decision by the Irish people and reinforced by solemn declarations in Seville and in the national declaration in 2022. If the Government rows back on that without the consent of the people, then we must have a referendum to put neutrality into the Constitution, as is the case in Austria in Switzerland. As for the amendment that says that would tie the hands of future governments, of course it would. That is what it is designed to do. That is what it means to be neutral. It means not having the freedom or discretion to get involved in foreign wars, which is the expressed will of the people in poll after poll. Let us keep the triple lock, let us reform the UN or replace it with something meaningful and in the absence of that let us have a referendum to put neutrality into our Constitution.

Comment on this

I thank Senator Clonan for asking me to second his motion. His remarks are especially important and profound because of his experience in the Defence Forces and he is a voice we should listen to in this space. This is particularly so as active Defence Forces members cannot comment as they are effectively civil servants.

The question of neutrality and the triple lock is so close to my heart because prior to getting into politics, I worked in peacebuilding and saw the direct impact peacekeeping has within that space. This debate has been going on for a while and the Minister will say differently but we are chipping away very explicitly at Ireland’s neutrality by removing the triple lock. We are seeing increasing militarisation globally and the very tenets and fundamental belief in multilateralism, as Senator Clonan mentioned, and international law are under threat. Rather than pulling back, we should be leaning into that to protect those institutions. I have said here before that it is might makes right if we do not uphold those institutions both by implementing international law and through peacekeeping and multilateralism. We have historically had an outsized influence on global politics, especially in the space of peace, with Frank Aiken leading on the nuclear non-proliferation treaty. I fundamentally believe our status as a neutral country that has allowed us to do that. We are known as a neutral country and known as having that peacemaking capacity but we undermine that once we start engaging in active battle groups, and that is what will happen.

One of the lines in the amendment that rips up Senator Clonan's Private Members' motion states "the absence of a specific United Nations Security Council mandate does not, of itself, mean that an overseas mission constitutes a Chapter VII mission, an offensive military operation...". That is not true. Peacekeeping was conceptualised through the UN and the Security Council. Without that it is not peacekeeping. Without the blue beret it is actually not peacekeeping but an active mission. That is a real danger and Senator Clonan outlined the risk it has for the Defence Forces if they are not wearing the blue beret. On the point about soft power, there is so much soft power we get from being a nation that only engages in overseas deployment through peacekeeping missions. We hold power within that. The Nice and Lisbon treaties were already referenced. It was the triple lock that was upheld as a guarantee of Ireland's neutrality. The Taoiseach said it in 2013. Fianna Fáil's policy has since changed and I do not understand why.

The UN is not perfect but we are not meaningfully engaging in efforts to reform it. Instead we are distancing ourselves from it. I would like to know if the Minister has proposed, for example, using the UN General Assembly, which is a pathway for the implementation and approval of peacekeeping missions. Are we actively pursuing that as an option? Did we pursue it with UNIFIL? Are we going to consider that? It seems we are leaning out of the UN institutions instead of trying to actively reform them and using the pathways that exist in the constitutions and founding documents, including the UN General Assembly for approving peacekeeping missions. Are we going to be redeploying troops to the United Nations disengagement observer force? If we are talking about peacekeeping and how important it is why are we not doing that? Are we going to have more Defence Forces personnel out with EU search and rescue in the Mediterranean?

The Government maintains it is committed to Irish neutrality but it is so difficult to understand that position once the triple lock is gone when time and again we have seen our neutrality undermined via our relationship with the US, especially US military planes and commercial civil carriers bringing munitions of war through Ireland. That is an undermining of our neutrality. In some instances, we have seen munitions that have gone to Israel and been used by the IDF flying through Ireland, which is not ideal for a country that claims neutrality. In addition, Ireland has taken every opportunity to send the 12 troops we do not need triple lock approval to deploy. I believe we had troops in Iraq-----

Comment on this

Afghanistan.

Comment on this

Some 12 troops in Afghanistan, for example. Thus it is really hard for us to believe that without the triple lock we are not going to be jumping every time an ally of ours wishes. We talk about the Russian veto but with the most recent UNIFIL mission it was the US veto. It is hard for us to believe the Government will not jump at every opportunity to deploy troops when evidence shows it has when within the legal allowance. That is why we need a referendum on the triple lock, which is core to our neutrality no matter what the Minister says.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

To delete all words after "That Seanad Éireann:" and substitute the following:

“acknowledges that:

- Ireland has a proud and longstanding policy of military neutrality, characterised by non-membership of military alliances and non-participation in common or mutual defence arrangements;

- Ireland has an outstanding and internationally respected record of overseas peacekeeping, dating back to 1958, and remains firmly committed to the United Nations, multilateralism, international law and the peaceful resolution of disputes;

- the existing Triple Lock can allow any one of the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council to prevent Ireland from participating in an overseas peace support operation, irrespective of the position of the Government and Dáil Éireann;

- the Triple Lock is a statutory mechanism and is not enshrined in Bunreacht na hÉireann, and reform of that mechanism does not alter Ireland’s policy of military neutrality;

- the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026, which is due to proceed to Second Stage in Dáil Éireann very shortly, provides for the reform of the statutory arrangements governing the despatch and deployment of members of the Defence Forces for service outside the State;

- the Bill removes the requirement for a United Nations mandate but provides for participation in relevant international forces, including UN-led or organised missions and missions organised or led by bodies such as the EU and the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, which operate in a manner consistent with the Charter of the United Nations and international law;

- reform of the Triple Lock is not an abandonment of Irish military neutrality or a move towards membership of a military alliance, but is intended to ensure that decisions concerning Ireland’s participation in appropriate overseas missions ultimately rest with Ireland’s own democratic institutions;

notes that:

- the Government remains firmly committed to Ireland’s longstanding policy of military neutrality, to the United Nations and multilateralism, and to maintaining Ireland’s proud contribution to international peacekeeping;

- the absence of a specific United Nations Security Council mandate does not, of itself, mean that an overseas mission constitutes a Chapter VII mission, an offensive military operation, a major combat operation, an armed intervention or a so-called coalition of the willing;

- reform of the Triple Lock will not provide an unrestricted power to deploy the Defence Forces to any conflict at any time, and decisions on participation in overseas missions will continue to be taken in accordance with the statutory framework and Ireland’s obligations under international law;

- maintaining Ireland’s policy of military neutrality does not require the State to surrender sovereign decision-making over overseas deployments to any permanent member of the United Nations Security Council;

- Ireland will continue to decide on participation in overseas missions on a case-by-case basis, having regard to the nature and purpose of the mission, Ireland’s foreign and security policy, international law and the safety and security of Defence Forces personnel and Dáil Éireann will continue to play the central role in those decisions;

- the significantly changed international security environment requires Ireland to strengthen its defence and security capabilities and ensure that the Defence Forces have the personnel, equipment, infrastructure and capabilities required to fulfil the roles assigned to them;

- significant progress is being made in transforming the Defence Forces, including measures relating to pay, recruitment, retention, working conditions, medical care and career opportunities for personnel;

- the Reserve Defence Force has an important role in supporting Defence Forces capability and strengthening national and whole-of-society resilience;

calls on the Government to:

- continue to uphold Ireland’s longstanding policy of military neutrality and its commitment to the United Nations, multilateralism, international law, international peacekeeping and the peaceful resolution of disputes;

- ensure that decisions concerning Ireland’s participation in appropriate international peace operations ultimately rest with Ireland’s own democratic institutions and are not dependent on the agreement of each of the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council;

- progress the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026 through the Houses of the Oireachtas, ensuring that appropriate democratic oversight and accountability continue to apply to decisions concerning the despatch and deployment of Defence Forces personnel overseas;

- continue the significant programme of investment, transformation and capability development across the Defence Forces, including the Army, Air Corps, Naval Service and cyber capabilities, to strengthen Ireland’s ability to protect its sovereignty and national interests;

- continue the ongoing and substantial measures to improve recruitment and retention and enhance the pay, conditions, career opportunities and quality of life of Defence Forces personnel;

- continue the development and revitalisation of the Reserve Defence Force and enhance its contribution to Defence Forces capability and national resilience;

- maintain appropriate Oireachtas scrutiny of defence and national security policy;

- continue to pursue an independent foreign, security and defence policy grounded in Ireland’s sovereignty, military neutrality, multilateralism, respect for international law and commitment to international peace and security;

- reject the proposal to constitutionally guarantee the policy of military neutrality, which could unnecessarily restrict the ability of future Governments and the Oireachtas to respond to changing threats and international circumstances; and

- continue to provide strong political leadership of defence and national security, while recognising that the configuration of ministerial responsibilities is properly a matter for the Taoiseach and that Ireland’s security and resilience are best advanced through coordinated action across Government and society rather than by prescribing the structure of future Governments.”

I thank the Minister for being here and Senators Clonan and Stephenson for bringing this forward because it is important we discuss it and we should not shy from doing so. As Senator Clonan said, we need to be honest and open. Although we might have different perspectives on this topic, there is always the opportunity in this House to discuss it and that is important. We must start at the central point which is that Ireland's policy of military neutrality and the triple lock are not the same thing. Ireland's military neutrality is characterised as non-membership of the military alliances and non-participation in common or mutual defence arrangements. The triple lock is the statutory mechanism governing central overseas deployments of the Defence Forces and reforming it through the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026 does not alter that neutrality.

Comment on this

On a point of order, under Standing Order 55 the Chair has the discretion to deal with a matter that is either deliberately or inadvertently untruthful.

It has been stated here that we are not part of any military alliances. Since 2000, we have become more and more integrated into European military structures, for example, Partnership for Peace, which was introduced by Bertie Ahern, which is an adjunct to NATO. We are also members of the United Nations Standby Arrangements System, which I outlined earlier. We are also members of the European Union battle group system, that is, members of the Nordic battle group. We have participated in the German-led battle group. We have troops in Potsdam and the planning cells and elsewhere. We also have a general on the EU military staffs, and we have staff officers participating on EU military staffs. It is untruthful to declare here in the House-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I am sorry, Senator, but you are extending beyond the point of-----

Comment on this

It is untruthful to say in the House that we are not part of the military organisation.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator, you are extending way beyond the point of order.

Comment on this

I am asking the Acting Chairperson, under Standing Order 55, to make a ruling on whether that is truthful or untruthful.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I ask Senator Ahearn to continue while I-----

Comment on this

I thank the Acting Chair very much. The Senator cannot argue that we are neutral now and then take the opposite view when he stands up to speak. It is important that we have this conversation. I know the Minister will outline Government's position when she gets the opportunity to do so and make sure the factual position from Government is put forward.

I was listening to Senator Clonan and he was talking about how if the triple lock is not there, this random group of decision-makers will make the decisions. That random group of decision-makers is the elected Government. It is elected Members of this House. The Government itself cannot do it. I assume it has to be passed by the Dáil and by this House as well. It is not just these random decision-makers that come from nowhere. It is the Government, which is elected by the people of Ireland, who we represent. Painting a picture that it is almost some random person who is going to make these decisions from now on because the triple lock is not there is factually not true.

Comment on this

That is not what I said. I said very specifically-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator Ahearn, without interruption.

Comment on this

The Senator said, and I quote-----

Comment on this

That group of decision-makers is how he phrased it.

Comment on this

However-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

The Senator, without interruption.

Comment on this

They are called the Government.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator Ahearn, please, through the Chair.

Comment on this

If we talk about defence, we had good news yesterday in terms of increased expenditure in defence, increased numbers of people coming into the Defence Forces, hopefully, because of that expenditure, and increased funding in terms of salaries, which is part of the public service pay agreement. There has been an awful lot done to try to attract new people in terms of recruitment into the Defence Forces. There is a lot more we need to do but I have absolute confidence that the Minister, in her time as Minister for Defence, will tackle those issues and deliver to improve our Defence Forces. There is not a country in the European Union that does not need to increase its defence budget and increase its numbers because of the geopolitical changes that are happening right across the world and we are we are no different. I welcome the debate. I look forward to the Minister's response on this. This is obviously something that is not going to be solved today or tomorrow but there is definitely a clear approach the Minister and Government are taking going forward to modernise our Defence Forces and modernise our policy around defence. I look forward to hearing from the Minister on that.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator Clonan may wish to take the issue he has up with the Cathaoirleach and allow him to make the ruling.

Senator Wilson has six-----

Comment on this

On a point of order, under Standing Order 55, the Chair has to make a determination as to whether something is truthful or untruthful, so I am asking him to make a determination on whether or not it is truthful-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I ask the Senator-----

Comment on this

-----to say that we are not members of any military alliance or any military organisation.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I have asked the Senator to raise that with the Cathaoirleach, who can adjudicate on that. The record can be rectified at that point. I am not in a position to make that ruling today.

Senator Wilson has six minutes.

Comment on this

I thank the Acting Chairperson very much. I welcome the Minister to the House and this debate. I thank Senator Clonan and his colleagues for tabling this motion. There is quite a bit of that with which I would agree. However, I stand today to second our amendment to Senator Clonan's motion. One of the things I do agree with Senator Clonan and his colleagues on is that we need to have a united and focused approach, across all sides of this House, on insisting that the Government does more to deliver on the commitment of level of ambition 2, as recommended by the Commission on the Defence Forces.

I share the concerns expressed by the signatories of Senator Clonan's motion that we will not meet that target of achieving 11,500 permanent members of our Defence Forces by 2028. It is not going to be achieved. In fact, if we achieve 7,500 to 8,000 by 2028, we will be doing very well. In that regard, I want to mention the Reserve Defence Forces, which were also included in the Commission on the Defence Forces and which tend to be forgotten about when the numbers are mentioned of 11,500 by 2028. My understanding is that our ambition is to bring the reserve up to 4,000 by the early 2030s, so it is important to bear that in mind as well.

Where I must depart from Senator Clonan and his honourable colleagues is on whether the best way to protect Ireland’s traditional policy of neutrality, while having the capacity to respond to changing circumstances, is to place a rigid and potentially ambiguous definition of neutrality into the Constitution. The Government's view and, indeed, my view is that it is not. There is no proposal to abandon Ireland’s policy of military neutrality. There is no proposal by this Government and by my party, in particular, to abandon Ireland's policy of military neutrality. Ireland is not seeking membership of a military alliance nor are we proposing to enter a common or mutual defence arrangement. Our commitment to the United Nations Charter and our national interests is non-negotiable.

I strongly believe the Constitution, via Article 29, already affirms Ireland’s "devotion to ... peace and friendly co-operation amongst nations founded on international justice and morality". That constitutional framework is important but it should not be converted into a political instrument that limits the ability of democratically-elected governments to respond to new and unforeseen security circumstances. A constitutional amendment cannot anticipate every future threat. I know Senator Clonan is going to cover that in his response. It cannot protect the nature of the next crisis, the next form of hybrid interference, the next attack on undersea infrastructure or the next challenge to our airspace, maritime approaches, cyber networks or critical national systems.

We should also be honest about what a referendum would not achieve. It would not put a single extra patrol vessel to sea. It would not recruit a single extra engineer, radar operator, cyber specialist or aircraft technician. It would not protect a single subsea cable, monitor our airspace or improve the capacity of our Reserve Defence Forces. It would not solve the recruitment and retention problems facing the Defence Forces and it would not deliver the modern equipment and infrastructure Ireland urgently needs. Those are the challenges we must confront.

The Commission on the Defence Forces made clear that Ireland must move beyond the limited capacity associated with level of ambition 1. The Government has accepted that report and committed to achieve level of ambition 2 by 2028. We have to be honest with each other in this House; that is not going to be achieved. Delivery on that commitment must be stepped up and every one of us in this House has an obligation to ensure that it is.

I welcome yesterday's announcement in the budget, which has already been outlined by my colleague, Senator Ahearn, of the €1.6 billion investment in 2027, 850 new Defence Forces recruits, enhanced cyber and maritime security, new helicopters and radar and the modernisation of military facilities. I would also like to add to that while the Minister is here. I want to see the reopening of some of the barracks that were closed, which had a detrimental effect on recruitment and retention into our Defence Forces.

I want to mention especially Dún Uí Néill Army barracks in Cavan town, which was one of only two facilities purpose-built by the Defence Forces in the history of our State. It is there in Cavan and ready to be reopened and play its part in the defence of our nation.

My time is up and I did not finish what I had to say. I would like a clarification from the Minister and Senator Clonan could comment on the issue in his reply. Under the triple lock at the moment, my understanding is that we cannot send any more than 12 troops without the sanction of the United Nations. It is important to realise that under Article 28.3.1°,-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator-----

Comment on this

-----by a vote of Dáil Éireann, we can go to war, but we cannot send our troops to peace.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

That is an indictment on all of us.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for coming to the House for the debate. I also thank Senator Clonan for putting forward this Private Members' motion, and for being a voice of reason and clarity in this neutrality debate. Sinn Féin completely supports this motion. I welcome the important debate. It is an important time to have the debate. It is extremely concerning that the Government is dead set on dismantling the triple lock. It is similarly worrying that the Government has been so set on misrepresenting the triple lock and its role in our neutrality. The Taoiseach and his Ministers are evidently doing all they can to try to sell this change to the public. The vast majority of the public is opposed to attempts to undermine Irish neutrality. I have no doubt but that the Government is well aware of that. Senator Wilson mentioned a referendum. The reason I believe that the Government will not hold a referendum is because it does not trust the public. It believes that it knows better and will not allow the public to decide this important issue. That is shameful of the Government.

It has been claimed many times that abolishing the triple lock is about protecting our sovereignty and not weakening our neutrality. That is complete nonsense. The Taoiseach, in 2013, described the triple lock as "at the core of our neutrality". Now, he claims they are completely separate. Requiring a UN mandate on our military deployments prevents breaches of our neutrality and explicitly prevents the Government from sending our soldiers to take a side in a foreign war. A peacekeeping mission that is not endorsed by the world's military powers and that lacks a mandate under international law is simply not a peacekeeping mission. It is picking a side in a foreign war. However justified the government of the day finds participating in a war, the reality is that it would be a fundamental breach of neutrality.

I think everybody would agree that the United Nations is flawed, but if we are a country that stands up for multilateralism and international law, the last thing we should be doing is weakening the UN further. We should be working to strengthen the UN and that is not what this Government is doing.

The likes of Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump would like nothing more than to tear down international institutions such as the UN and bring back a world in which might equals right. We are facilitating them in that process. Abolishing the triple lock helps them to achieve just that and would be an unmistakable step towards the end of our neutrality. That neutrality has been a defining characteristic of our foreign policy since the foundation of the State. It has allowed Ireland to punch significantly above its weight on the world stage. Ireland will never be a military, political or economic superpower, but we have been able to exercise influence well beyond our size because of our reputation as peacekeepers, diplomats and humanitarians.

The world is getting more unstable and volatile every day and our neutrality is more important than ever to ensure that we do not get entangled in foreign wars and we are allowed to speak up for those who lack a voice of their own. Despite this, the Government has opted to attack the core of neutrality in a clear attempt to move us closer to NATO and to align us with EU militarisation. That is clearly the direction of travel that the Government is putting us on and even if it tries to spin it as something else, nobody is swallowing it. The Government is moving us away from our proud history as a voice for peace and diplomacy and towards the future as a tiny piece of a European military machine. Ireland should be proud of our history as a neutral country standing up for peace and international law. It would be absolutely shameful for us to abandon this legacy when we need it most.

Removing the triple lock would be a monumental change in Ireland's foreign policy and the Government should stop trying to brush away the ramifications of doing that. As I said, why will the Government not hold a referendum? It should allow the public to have its say. It is too important to just let the government of the day decide the issue. The public should be trusted. As Senator Wilson said, this Government clearly does not want to hold a referendum. I think it is shameful that we would not allow a referendum and trust the public to let them decide.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire. I welcome to the Gallery Ms Orla Robinson, who is on a student placement with Senator Harmon.

I commend Senator Clonan for being a voice of reason in this debate. I am very proud to be a signatory to this motion. The Senator has spoken so passionately about this issue for so long with informed knowledge. He has been a guide and adviser to many of us in the House. I thank him for that.

We hold an international reputation as a trusted impartial force. Since 1958, Irish peacekeepers have served with distinction in the world's most troubled regions, from Lebanon and the Congo to the Golan Heights and Chad. Wherever Óglaigh na hÉireann go, they make a positive difference and we can all be very proud of that.

We have never been an imperial power or occupying force. We have avoided direct engagement with military alliances such as NATO or an emerging EU army and I believe that we must continue to do so. Entanglement in military alliances poses severe risks that the majority of Irish people and Irish troops reject. It increases the risk of mass casualties among our Defence Forces. It elevates the threat of attacks against our civilian population and risks placing Irish soldiers under the command of, and serving alongside, forces responsible for war crimes. We have already seen troops under NATO command accused of such crimes in Afghanistan, Serbia and Libya. When troops become involved in wars of choice, aggression or greed, repression and war crimes inevitably follow and we know this very well from our own history as a colonised nation.

Today, our military neutrality and the triple lock are vital shields protecting our troops from being dragged into foreign conflicts that do not concern us. Neutrality has been essential to our national identity since the foundation of the State, rooted in figures such as James Connolly.

Europe is moving towards war, with defence spending soaring across the Continent. Ireland does need to increase its defence budget, but this funding must be focused on paying our Defence Forces properly. It is welcome that this has been included in the budget. We must provide decent housing, ensure modern kit and improve working conditions.

Being neutral does not mean passivism. We require active modern forces capable of defending our own seas, airspace and cyberspace. Outsourcing our security to NATO, the Royal Navy or the Royal Air Force places us in their debt and risks pulling us into their wars.

We must have a frank discussion about the military's role as we progress towards the reunification of our island. We must navigate the future of Twenty-six Counties in the EU but outside NATO, alongside Six Counties currently in NATO but outside the EU. We can look to modern countries such as Switzerland and Austria and can see that a credible, modern nation can defend its homeland without relying on a military alliance.

Comment on this

We fought very hard for our sovereignty. As has been said, the UN is not perfect but it is definitely the best international, pro-peace co-operative body that we have. Of course, it requires reform, but not weakening or replacing with something else. If all members of the Security Council do not agree that a peacekeeping operation should take place, there can be no peacekeeping.

Comment on this

I was here in 2017. I remember being here in the Seanad Chamber for the debate about Operation Sophia. Similarly, we heard lots of talk from the Government about the proud tradition of our navy, the work we had done rescuing people from the Mediterranean, the fact that we had this record and how credible it was, and how terrible it was that the Opposition was acting as if it was stepping away from it, when we were just simply tweaking and changing it.

There were speeches by people who were very proud of our navy and its rescues and who spoke about how, in one year, 8,000 lives were saved in the Mediterranean. We had all of this discussion. We were raising the flag about the fact there was a change because the then Minister of State, Paul Kehoe, gave it away. He said we were moving from a primarily humanitarian operation to a primarily security operation. Sure enough, once we did this we stopped rescuing people from the Mediterranean. We left them to drown, and Europe left them to drown. The rescue figure went down from 8,000 to 1,000 and then there was no search and rescue mandate at all. Right now, there is no search and rescue mandate for those drowning in the Mediterranean. I know many very proud members of the navy whose hearts were broken. One of the many issues with morale, alongside underfunding, has been the move away from a mandate we can be proud of.

To be very clear, what is proposed here is a shift from a UN principle-based form of peacekeeping to interest-based peacekeeping. It is not even peacekeeping but military action. This is there in the Government's text. It is not simply peacekeeping. This is not what is in the triple lock legislation. It is peacekeeping, conflict prevention and strengthening international security. What is this? Whose security? Is it the security of commercial interests in the Strait of Hormuz? Is this there? Is this part of it? There is a blurring of the line in terms of what strengthening international security might mean, and what it might mean when we come under pressure from countries like the United States, which we saw took a vengeful approach to Spain when Spain said it would not be part of its illegal war on Iran.

Do we trust our Government to always take the same level of principled stand that Spain took, given that we sent troops to Afghanistan and to Iraq, and that we are importing LNG from a country that left the Paris Agreement? The public knew the Realpolitik we all hear about all the time regarding the international pressures that get placed, and this is one of the reasons the public blocked the Lisbon treaty in the referendum. People were concerned that we would be dragged into inappropriate military action. The promise made was the triple lock, to state it would be based only on UN principles. The architect, by the way, of some of our legislation on this, the former Minister, Willie O'Dea, of Fianna Fáil, has been very clear that the architecture we already have does not restrict us to the Security Council and that the General Assembly does allow a mandate for action. In fact, we have two examples of peacekeeping missions that were sanctioned and took place based on the General Assembly. These are real examples versus the hypothetical blocks that we are hearing about.

It does matter what Ireland does because right now we are at a point when international law is under attack. We could be the champions for protecting the International Criminal Court and for fully applying what the International Court of Justice does. There are important things our troops can do, which are already allowed for, in terms of search and rescue and humanitarian missions. None of these are precluded or limited by what is there right now. What has been proposed includes that we should play a role in protecting international law facilities and the work, for example, of the International Criminal Court or the International Court of Justice.

There is a lot that Ireland could be doing if we are really serious about making a contribution in the world while maintaining our neutrality and while maintaining our credibility. It is an active neutrality whereby we are regarded as an honest broker who says international law applies to all, that we have no interests and that we do not send our people to fight for interests. It is not solely about friendships and allies; it is about consistency. This is what has given us our credibility. This is why we were able to negotiate the cluster munitions ban. This is why we could be the one who could lead a ban on autonomous weapons. This is where our credibility lies. It is being thrown away for some narrative about stepping up in the military realm by those who want to cash in the capital built by Frank Aiken and through the record of our nation and all our work on disarmament, and make us open for business in respect of military action. Bear in mind, we have Ministers talking about the money that Ireland should be trying to get in on with regard to armaments. We have already compromised, through the funding of cluster munitions in some of the EU vehicles that we have.

On the SAFE programme, I referenced the climate report and the finance committee's report. The Commission told us the money Ireland is contributing is going to cluster munitions, for example. Frankly, we cannot trust a Government not to slide. We need to retain our triple lock and we need to have pride in Ireland's record. The way we show this is by committing to these same principles in the future. I commend and support the movers of the motion.

Comment on this

I want to make it clear at the outset that the Fianna Fáil Party and I will be supporting the Government's countermotion. Senator Clonan's motion wrongly equates an amendment to the triple lock with a change to our long-standing policy on military neutrality. Speaking for my party, Fianna Fáil, we have absolutely no intention in government of altering our policy of neutrality. They are not the same thing. Our manifesto in 2024 pledged to reform the triple lock and also pledged to protect our neutrality. We are doing both.

The changes to the triple lock are merely about peacekeeping and nothing else. It is over 12 years since the UN Security Council approved a peacekeeping mission. Whatever may have been the situation in the past, the fact is that now the triple lock is an obstacle to Irish peacekeeping. When the UNIFIL mission ends, having lost its Security Council sanction, there will be fewer than 50 Defence Forces personnel on UN or UN-mandated missions. What we are proposing is to change this to give us the flexibility to decide on our own peacekeeping plans, should an option arise.

Comment on this

Under Standing Order 55-----

Comment on this

Coming from Kildare-----

Comment on this

-----and it is also a matter-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator Clonan cannot keep interrupting. Senator O'Loughlin has the floor and she gave the floor to Senator Clonan without interruption.

Comment on this

I can raise a point of order under Standing Order 55 and it is my right to do so. I know the Acting Chair does not like me standing up but that is nothing to do with it.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I have no problem with Senator Clonan standing up.

Comment on this

Under Standing Order 55, we have to be very careful that nothing untruthful is set before the House. This Bill explicitly provides for the deployment of Irish troops overseas. It states there is no peacekeeping-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Can I speak just for a second? Senator Clonan has gone beyond a point of order. If he has an issue with what is said on the floor here today, he can make that complaint to the Cathaoirleach and let him rule on it.

Comment on this

I have made that complaint to you. It is on the record. I do not need to write it down.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

It is not my role. Senator Clonan can put it in writing.

Comment on this

No, I have put it on the record of the House. I do not need to write it down again.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

You can put it on the record but I am not ruling on it.

Comment on this

You take the transcript and bring it to the Cathaoirleach if you are unable to discharge the function in which you are acting here.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I am not in a position to discharge that function today.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Because I am not. It is the Cathaoirleach, and it is not a point of order.

Comment on this

It is a point of order under Standing Order 55.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

It is not my role to rule on the truthfulness of statements. If Senator Clonan wishes, we will forward it to the Cathaoirleach-----

Comment on this

I can quote Standing Order 55 to you, if you wish.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

No. The Chair is the sole judge of order in proceedings and has the authority to suppress disorder and to enforce prompt obedience to his or her ruling. I ask Senator O'Loughlin to continue. She has the floor.

Comment on this

As I was saying before I was interrupted, I come from Kildare and I am very au fait with many of those proud men and women who serve in the Defence Forces.

I have had the opportunity to speak to them not just over the past weekend when this motion was tabled but over the past two years, when the issue started to be discussed both by Government and the Opposition. I know there have also been many debates in the committee. Having had that opportunity to speak to many of those serving, to a person and to a man and a woman, they were totally in support of this. Not one person serving or who has retired from the Defence Forces said at any point that this would be the wrong thing to do. I was never a member of the Defence Forces but I always agree with lived experience. I accept that Senator Clonan has lived experience in relation to the Defence Forces, as does Senator Craughwell and he takes the completely the opposite view from Senator Clonan. I tend to take my advice from the experience of those in the field.

What we propose is to change the flexibility to decide on our own peacekeeping plans. That means that neither Putin nor the three nuclear powers in NATO, for that matter, can stop us from peacekeeping. I have spoken to many veterans who, over the years, have spent quite an amount of time on peacekeeping missions. They talk very fondly about the work they have done and the experience they have gained but also about the relationships they have built up in regard to both the country in which they served and with other peacekeeping forces, where they were able to exchange experiences, information and knowledge.

The triple lock is not an expression of military neutrality. Ireland's policy of military neutrality is characterised by non-membership of military alliances or common or mutual defence arrangements. The Government and the Minister, Deputy McEntee, have been very clear that this will not be changed.

The motion put forward by Senator Clonan and the Independent Senators fails to adequately address the challenging international security context or the complexity of the foreign security and defence policy choices facing the State. I know also that the Government rejects the proposition that the absence of a specific UN Security Council mandate necessarily means that a mission is a Chapter VII operation, an offensive military intervention, a major combat operation or a so-called "coalition of the willing". International peace support and crisis management operations may be undertaken under a variety of mandates.

Reform of the triple lock does not, therefore, represent an abandonment of either military neutrality or multilateralism. Ireland will remain firmly committed to the UN, international law and the peaceful resolution of disputes. I want to state my support for the Defence Forces. We had a good budget yesterday in the context of the extra funding being put in place in respect of our personnel and military equipment.

The Minister might forgive me if I say that I am still awaiting a meeting with her about the Curragh Plains, which is still under the management of the Defence Forces. It is something we need to deal with quickly.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

The Minister has indicated that she wishes to make her contribution now. She has 15 minutes.

Comment on this
Helen McEntee Minister for Defence Fine Gael

I thank the Acting Chair and colleagues. I welcome the opportunity to discuss this matter because it is really important for something of this significance. We all agree that we should have this debate and discussion. I have no doubt we will have many more in the weeks ahead.

I will begin my contribution by thanking our Defence Forces serving at home and overseas, and past as well as present members. That includes Senator Clonan. I thank him and all members for the extremely important work they do and have done. We are extremely proud of the sacrifices made by them and their families in the service of peace.

For decades, Irish peacekeepers have made life more bearable for some of the most vulnerable people on earth. They have brought hope, stability and safety to people in some of the most challenging environments in the world. We all agree that their work is a practical expression of our values. It is a tradition that everyone in Ireland is immensely proud of and one we have a responsibility to protect. This tradition is under threat, however, and I agree there is a lot of misinformation and disinformation but I do not believe it is coming from the Government side or anybody on these benches.

The triple lock - and we have heard this but I will outline it for those many people who are not aware of the mechanisms of it - is the legal mechanism governing the deployment of our Defence Forces on peacekeeping missions. To deploy our peacekeepers under the current arrangement, three things are required: a UN Security Council mandate, Government or Cabinet approval, and Dáil approval. In regard to the 12 figure, that does not apply if we are conducting search-and-rescue missions but it does apply where we are sending people to international force missions. That does constrain us in our overall capacity.

As we are aware, the UN Security Council is the main body within the UN that is responsible for maintaining international peace and security. Within that there are five permanent members of the Security Council: Russia, China, the US, the UK and France, all of whom can use their veto power to prevent the Security Council from taking decisions. This includes those related to new and ongoing peacekeeping operations. Unfortunately, what we have seen in practice is that even the threat of a veto by a permanent member, rather than its actual use or pushing something to a vote, is enough to prevent the Council from taking action. This is exactly what has been happening for the past number of years. No new peacekeeping mission has been agreed since 2014 and, now, we see the opposite happening. Ongoing operations, which we have been involved in for decades, are not being renewed.

Two recent examples are Operation Irini and one that is better known as UNIFIL in Lebanon, which I will explain in a moment. Importantly, what does this mean for Ireland? It means that the Security Council, in particular the five permanent members Russia, China, the US, the UK and France, hold an effective veto over whether we can deploy our Defence Forces on peacekeeping missions. We talk about world military powers; these are powers and countries that are, at the moment, inflicting brutal war - in particular Russia, on European soil. Why would we allow any country of this kind to dictate or veto where we send our troops? We have to ask that question. We are a sovereign country. We should never allow any other country to decide where we send our peacekeepers and our troops. Unfortunately, this is what is happening and it is why the triple lock needs to be reformed.

In May, the UN mandate underpinning Operation Irini, which is a naval operation in the Mediterranean tasked with enforcing the United Nations arms embargo on Libya, was not renewed. Our four Defence Forces personnel had to withdraw immediately but the EU mission continued. Some 23 countries remained; Ireland alone had to leave because of our legal requirements to have UN Security Council approval. I happened to be in Rome at that time and met with three of those members. What they talked about very directly to me was not just the loss for them personally and what they achieved and gained in their contribution but also the loss to Ireland because the knowledge, experience and what we take back from these missions are significant, and that is now lost. Some 23 countries continue but our members had to leave immediately. Our participation-----

Comment on this

I wish to make a point of information.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

A point of information now.

Comment on this

It is a point of correction because-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

The Senator can make a point of order but not a point of correction.

Comment on this

Apologies. It is a point of order. As the Acting Chair will know, I do not usually do these. What has been suggested is that there was a blocking by the UN Security Council in respect of this mission.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Hold on. This has gone way beyond-----

Comment on this

That is what the Minister has just said. The Minister has just stated-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator Higgins, this has gone way beyond a point of order.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I ask the Senator to resume her seat.

Comment on this

France did not seek renewal because the EU wished to change the mandate in respect of Operation Irini.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Will the Senator respect the Chair?

Comment on this

I will, Acting Chair, but there is a disingenuous inaccuracy-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

There was a point of order. The Senator is gone way beyond a point of order.

Comment on this

-----which suggests that the UN Security Council veto was the reason for the ending of Operation Irini-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I ask the Minister to continue.

Comment on this

-----but it was not.

Comment on this

There is nothing disingenuous about what I have said. I am very clear that we should not allow France or anybody else to dictate where we send our troops, particularly a mission we have been on for many years where all 23 countries remained but Ireland had to leave. That is a statement of fact.

Our participation had Government approval. Our personnel were contributing to the safety of people in the region. Yet, this outdated law required us to withdraw. While many people may not have heard of Operation Irini, everyone in this country knows the role we have played as peacekeepers in Lebanon.

In Lebanon, UNIFIL’s operations are due to end on 31 December this year, because the UN mandate was not renewed. After almost five decades of Irish service, we will no longer be able to contribute to peacekeeping in Lebanon in the way we have done for years if the triple lock is not reformed.

The EU is currently considering a new mission in Lebanon, a proposal that Ireland put forward with other countries. I want to push back on any suggestion that we will be sending people into wars and conflict zones in a combative way. Any mission we participate in would be consistent with the principles of the UN Charter, international law, and the advice of our Defence Forces. For any legislation we enact here we have courts and mechanisms to ensure they are upheld, if they are not implemented or enforced in the way set out by all of us here, as democratically elected representatives. Nothing has been agreed on this legislation. I will be before the House in the coming weeks. If it were to go ahead with the current triple lock in place, our participation in the mission I have outlined, as it has currently been set out, would be limited to providing office appointments and a small number of training teams. A training mission would require armed force protection, something which is not spoken of, but that we already provide in Lebanon. This is something our soldiers are trained for but would not be able to provide under the current limitations of the triple lock. I have spoken to many soldiers, in particular over the past year. They have told me that the opportunity to serve their country overseas was why they joined the Defence Forces. If we keep things as they are, we would not contribute beyond a handful of personnel training other soldiers, which in itself, would be an important contribution - I do not diminish that for a second - but we would then require other countries' soldiers to provide protection to our trainers. We already do this at the moment. I do not see how any of this would make sense.

Leaving the triple lock in place would mean having to walk away from our proud tradition in Lebanon and what we have provided for many years. It would mean walking away from the peacekeeping efforts which have strengthened our neutrality. I believe the work we have done has strengthened our neutrality. I do not believe that is what Irish people want. The Opposition knows that this is the consequence of what it is advocating for. We need to be clear that this is what it wants to happen, whether it is Lebanon or any other important mission. When we engage in military partnerships there is a question of whether we are engaged in military alliances. Everything we engage in and in particular, Partnership for Peace - the word "peace" is important - is voluntary. We decide how and when we contribute and what types of mission we contribute to. In that regard, if we were to join NATO or any other alliance - as others are suggesting we will - we would be committing to having troops at their disposal and direction. That is not what we are talking about here. That is not what removal of the triple lock is. We continue to have discretion and to require approval by these Houses as to where we send our troops, in line with the UN Charter, international law and the recommendations from the Defence Forces. In the Presidency at the moment, we are bringing forward different files within the defence sector. Military mobility is one example. We did not move on that until we were absolutely certain that Ireland's military neutrality and that of any other country in the EU would be taken into consideration, so that at no point would we be forced into any decisions that would be taken by other member states. We are clear in the work going on at the moment, the partnerships we choose to join and the decisions we will take in the future, that we will focus on peacekeeping and on the missions in which we have participated in the past.

This Government will preserve Ireland's military neutrality as every Government has done since the foundation of the State. It is important to our citizens, to all of us in this House, and to me as Minister. We share the public's commitment to neutrality, which is a commitment to not join military alliances, as I have outlined. This commitment is the basis of our neutrality, not the triple lock, because that is a statutory mechanism. It can be amended through legislation passed by the Oireachtas, and this is how our democracy works. We change our legislation. We respond to the changing environment of the world we live in. The world is a very different place. The UN Security Council is a very different place to what it was decades ago. That is why Government believes that a referendum is not necessary. We will commit to maintain our military neutrality. The triple lock is a legal mechanism introduced through these Houses which governs how we deploy our Defence Forces on peacekeeping missions. We were a neutral country before we introduced this mechanism, and we will remain a neutral country if it changes. As I have said, the world has changed since the triple lock was introduced at a time when the UN Security Council was operating effectively, and we all agree it is not now. The fact there has been no new peacekeeping mission since 2014 is a sign of that.

I agree with those who say we should reform the UN Security Council. We all agree that we need to try to make reforms but that has been the objective for many years now. When I attended the UN General Assembly as part of high-level week, I spoke about this with the UN General Secretary. There was an ambition from him but we have not seen that change. The United Nations will remain, however, central to our foreign policy. We will relentlessly defend its Charter, support its work, and press for reform of the Security Council.

In terms of the UN General Assembly and suggestions that we use it, without the reform, the UN General Assembly can only make recommendations. It cannot implement any of those decisions. It was relayed very clearly to me at the UN recently that we are known as one of the strongest defenders of the UN and its objectives, and that will not change. We have to be honest, protecting the UN and standing up for multilateralism has nothing to do with allowing other countries to dictate to our Defence Forces and where they can serve. No other country in the world has this mechanism that would allow Russia - a country waging a war on our European colleagues on European soil - to decide or to dictate where we can send our troops. Russia might not know it but it is impacting where we can keep our troops and where we can send them.

Comment on this

On a point of information-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator, you cannot bring a point of information.

Comment on this

No, it is a point of order.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Make the distinction clear. What is the point of order?

Comment on this

The point of order is that the Minister has just acknowledged that the UN General Assembly is a mechanism and then said that it cannot compel us to act. However, the point is that the UN General Assembly allows Ireland to act-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

That is going beyond a point of order-----

Comment on this

-----and then the Minister said that Russia will dictate-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

You have an interpretation-----

Comment on this

That is not the case, because under a UN General Assembly motion-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Once again, you are going beyond a point of order.

Comment on this

-----we are not bound under the current triple lock by a Russian veto-----

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Senator Higgins-----

Comment on this

We can act under a UN General Assembly motion.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

-----you have no respect for the Chair.

Comment on this

I am just tired of an inaccuracy that is being restated.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I want to inform Senator Higgins that this is not a committee room. It is the Seanad and we are debating a very important issue.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Thank you, Senator.

Comment on this

The Minister has a time limit and is attempting to make her contribution, so that other Members get an opportunity to make their contributions before time runs out.

Comment on this
Pat Casey Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Minister, please continue without interruption.

Comment on this

The point I am making is the only way in which a decision can then be enforced - that is what we want to happen through the UN General Assembly - is through the UN Security Council, so it would have to be reformed. I fully agree with the Senator that the UN should be reformed. It is not working as it should and has not done so for many years. That would still require a change to the UN General Assembly and how it can currently operate. We will continue to work with the new Secretary General, whoever he or she may be, in the coming term. There is an ambition there but as much as we want to see it happen, it has not happened yet. That would require a change in the UN General Assembly as well. As I said, we are known as one of the strongest defenders of the UN and its objectives but protecting the UN and standing up for multilateralism has nothing to do with allowing other countries to dictate where our Defence Forces can serve. No other country in the world has this mechanism.

A genuine commitment to multilateralism and to helping some of the most vulnerable people on earth requires us to take concrete actions that take into account the real world we live in. It requires action that allows us to defend our values in practice, not just in words. We cannot claim to defend international law while retaining rules that force us to abandon vulnerable people in Lebanon. People who depend on peacekeepers need more than words and expressions of solidarity. They need countries that will act. We cannot praise the work of our peacekeepers while refusing to address the barriers that would prevent them from serving, not in the future, but now.

We cannot remain static when the world is changing around us. We can be neutral when it comes to protecting our own people, territory and critical national infrastructure. Ireland is a small, open, and highly interconnected country. We cannot rely on our geographic isolation for our security, nor can we isolate ourselves from events happening around us. Our maritime domain, telecommunications infrastructure, energy connections and digital networks link us directly to the wider world.

That is why the co-operation we have spoken about with our partners is important, and is why we are investing significantly in our Defence Forces.

To touch on some of the motion, following budget 2027, our defence Vote group funding will have increased by 53% since 2022. We may say we are starting from a low base, but for any Department to increase its Votes by 53% in four years is a significant increase. For 2026, €1.492 billion was allocated to the defence Vote group, which is again an increase of €142 million. Budget 2027 will allocate just over €1.6 billion, a further increase that builds on the significant increases secured in recent budgets.

We have provided record capital funding of €1.7 billion for defence for the period 2026 to 2030, and there will be a review of that. My ambition and intention in 2028 are to seek even further funding. In 2027 alone, capital investment will increase by €40 million to €340 million, an increase of 13%, which is above the overall increase we have seen right across all the different Departments. This investment will help strengthen our Defence Forces, our personnel, our maritime security, our air surveillance and monitoring, our radar capability, our subsea awareness and our ability to respond to hybrid and cyber threats. It is funding major projects, including the military radar programme, subsea awareness, software-defined radio, our new helicopters and significant improvements in force protection equipment, including the body armour that is being launched today and the helmets that we will procure for next year.

Neutrality does not absolve us from investing in our own security, which is exactly what we are doing. If Ireland chooses an independent approach to defence and security, we must possess the credible national capabilities required to underpin that choice. However, our greatest capability is our people. We have made major improvements in pay and conditions. Budget 2027 represents a further significant investment in our people. An overall pay allocation of €638 million has been provided, including funding to support a Permanent Defence Force, PDF, strength of up to 8,300 personnel by the end of 2027. This will provide for a net increase of 400 permanent Defence Forces personnel. Following pay measures implemented in recent years, a recruit now earns more than €42,000 following completion of training, rising above €45,000 within three years. A graduate cadet is paid €52,265 on commissioning as a lieutenant, while a school-leaver cadet commissioned as a second lieutenant starts at €46,823. We are seeing encouraging results as a result of these changes in investment. There were more than 16,500 applications in 2025 and more than 14,000 by August of this year. Cadetship applications have increased by 58% and we are on course for more than 800 inductions this year. We are at approximately 835 and we set a target of 850, with the plan being 900 for next year.

I accept that there is more work to do, and I will never pretend otherwise, but these are important signs that our investment in pay, conditions, recruitment and retention is making a real difference. This budget will allow us to do the same.

In tabling legislation to amend, we are clearly saying that we want to be in a position to be able to deploy our troops on peacekeeping missions in the same way we have done for many years. However, with the triple lock as it currently stands and with the UN Security Council not working or operating in the way it did when we introduced this requirement, we are preventing ourselves from making this decision and allowing other countries to make it for us. I do not believe that, as a sovereign country and Government, we should allow that to happen.

Comment on this

I want to say that there is a misunderstanding in the House today. The majority of members of the Independent Group have not supported this motion. This motion is supported by a minority of members of the Independent Group and others. I just want to make that clear.

First, Senator Wilson's contribution was a model of clarity and correctness. There is no such thing as an absolute or constitutional rule of neutrality. As Senator Wilson pointed out, Article 28 of the Constitution says, "the State shall not participate in any war save with the assent of Dáil Éireann". That was passed by the Irish people in the shadow of the Second World War. It is not the case that Ireland is constitutionally bound to remain neutral, nor would it be a wise idea for Ireland to insert into its Constitution some obligation of neutrality, like that of the Austrian model, which was imposed by Joseph Stalin in the 1950s. That is not what we are talking about.

Ireland is a sovereign, independent state and is free to make alliances with whomever it wishes to defend its sovereignty and independence. If it comes to protecting our underwater cables, our airspace or whatever else from threats, the Irish State and its institutions are free to make whatever arrangements they consider necessary to bring about the security and independence of this country. It is completely untrue to suggest that there is some constitutional rule of neutrality.

Another point people seem to forget is that if you were to insert into the Constitution an obligation of neutrality and if it was interpreted by the courts, it would mean that you could not assist any other state, no matter how friendly, by allowing transit through your territory during wartime or whatever. That would be a retrograde and foolish change to make to our Constitution. We are a free, independent, democratic state and we have enacted a Constitution that gives to Dáil Éireann the right to say "Yes" or "No" for participation in any war.

However, it is also important to bear in mind that we have dedicated ourselves to the ideal of peace and friendly co-operation among nations, to the rule of law and the Pacific Settlement of International Disputes. That is something we are committed to. It does not mean that we should be defenceless. It is a gross exaggeration for some people to say that Ireland is somehow committed never to assist any other state that is invaded, never to give any succour to any state or never to permit an aircraft moving assistance from one state to another to use our airspace or airports. That is what neutrality in the Constitution would actually mean. It is not for the Supreme Court to determine what does or does not amount to neutrality. It is for Dáil Éireann and the elected representatives of the Irish people to determine what should or should not happen.

Second, we need to defend our State. We are in a sad position where there are only 7,800 members of the Defence Forces when there should be 11,800. We are in the sadder position that our reserve forces, which numbered approximately 20,000 when I was in them, now number less than 2,000. This is what has happened. While warfare is going to change and we are going to have different forms of it in the future, we need to resource our own independence and defence. Being neutral or non-aligned means nothing if it means being helpless.

People can change their minds and are free to do so, and people can become passionate and are free to do so, but Senator Clonan will remember that he and I have contributed to The Irish Times and, in 2003, he advocated for the abolition of the triple lock. I have the article here. Let us be consistent. I favour the triple lock in normal circumstances, but we have now got to a situation where the main participants in the UN Security Council are determined to damage the operation of the UN to the greatest possible extent in respect of Ukraine, the International Criminal Court and right across the board. We live in a different world now from the one we lived in until recently. In those circumstances, to say that Ireland cannot do internationally what it used to be able to do because one of five nuclear powers says "No" does not make sense any more, so I agree with what Senator Wilson has said.

I do not agree with the Government's countermotion. The terms of the Defence (Amendment) Bill are too broad. We need to do something about that. As far as inserting into our Constitution an obligation of neutrality, when the people of Ireland in 1937 and 1938 did not do so and would not have rejected British or American help had we been invaded, the people of Ireland gave to Dáil Éireann, and to that House alone, the right to declare to become involved in a war in those circumstances. I am simply saying that the motion tabled in the name of a minority of Independents but not the majority of Independent Members in this House is not one that commands my support at all. I just want to make that very clear because the Minister talked about the Independent Group's position. The Independent Group's position is not reflected in this motion.

Comment on this

The Minister is very welcome to the House this afternoon. Following on from my colleague Senator Wilson, I too would very much support the Government counter motion. I very much welcome the debate. It is important that we shine a light on this subject in a very calm and rational manner. I very much welcome it. It is important that we come here and people are entitled to change their mind. That is what democracy is all about. As circumstances change sometimes people's opinions change. That is a good thing and that is where I will be coming from in this regard.

The motion mistakenly equates an amendment to the triple lock with a change to the long-standing policy of military neutrality. From a Fianna Fáil perspective, in government we have absolutely no intention of altering the policy of neutrality. The Fianna Fáil manifesto in 2024 pledged to reform the triple lock. It also pledged to protect our neutrality and we are doing both.

The changes to the triple lock are about peacekeeping and nothing else. It is over 12 years since the UN Security Council approved a peacekeeping mission. Whatever may have been the situation in the past, the fact is that the triple lock is now an obstacle to Irish peacekeeping. When the UNIFIL mission ends, having lost its Security Council sanction, there will be fewer than 50 Defence Forces personnel on UN-mandated missions. We are proposing to change that to give us the flexibility to decide our own peacekeeping plans should an option arise. It means that none of Mr. Putin, King Charles or Donald Trump, or indeed any other member for that matter can stop us from participating in a peacekeeping mission. The triple lock is a legal mechanism governing the overseas deployment of members of the Defence Forces. It currently requires three elements: Government approval, Dáil approval and a UN Security Council mandate. The triple lock is not in itself the definition of Irish neutrality. Ireland's military neutrality is based on our non-membership of military alliances and common or mutual defence arrangements. This policy is not being changed. This is about peacekeeping. The central issue here is peacekeeping.

The international environment has changed, however, as Senator McDowell outlined, so we have to ask ourselves a straightforward question. Do we want Ireland's ability to contribute to international peacekeeping to depend on some of the gentlemen I mentioned earlier, or if any other permanent member of the Security Council decides to allow it? That is not consistent with an independent Irish foreign policy. The proposed reform is designed to ensure that it is Ireland, through its own democratic institutions, that makes that decision. It will continue to require Government and Dáil approval. It will operate within international law. The legislation will expressly require international forces in which the Defence Forces participate, to operate for peacekeeping, peace enforcement or conflict prevention, consistent with the principles of the UN Charter. It is about protecting Ireland's sovereign capacity to participate in peacekeeping missions where we so wish. Neutrality remains. Ireland was neutral before the triple lock existed. As Senator McDowell outlined, there was no triple lock during the Second World War. Removing the requirement of a UN Security Council mandate does not mean joining NATO. It does not mean joining a military alliance. It does not mean joining a European army. It does not change the constitutional position that Ireland will not participate in common European defence.

The Government has been absolutely clear that Ireland will remain militarily neutral. Our neutrality should mean that Ireland makes its own decisions. The UN remains central. Let me also be clear that removing the Security Council requirements does not mean turning our back on the United Nations. Ireland remains firmly committed to the UN Charter, international law, multilateralism and the peaceful resolution of disputes. The State will continue to work with other neutral and non-aligned countries to strengthen the UN and to restore its supremacy as the international forum for resolving conflicts and upholding international law. We will not walk away from it but we have to recognise the reality of the world in which we operate today. If the UN Security Council is paralysed by disagreement between its permanent members Ireland should not be prevented from making a sovereign decision to contribute to legitimate international peace support or crisis management operations.

This debate also has to be viewed in the wider context of Ireland's defence capability. That is why there is a significant increase in funding in budget 2027 for our Defence Forces' land, air, maritime and cyber capabilities, as well as recruitment, retention, accommodation, training, pay and working conditions. These investments are absolutely necessary because neutrality does not mean having no defence capabilities.

I will sum up by taking this opportunity to pay tribute yet again to the men and women of our Defence Forces. We are extremely proud of their dedication and loyalty to the State. As Senator McDowell outlined, we must continue to ensure that the Defence Forces grow to a realistic level. I will be doing all in my power on this side of the House to ensure that resources are given to make that happen, and that people would want to join the Defence Forces and would want to stay there for the entire duration of their career.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister, Deputy McEntee, for being here, although she has had to leave, and the Minister of State, Deputy Collins, and the officials from the Department. I would also like to thank Senator Clonan for tabling this Private Members' motion because it has facilitated a fairly robust engagement and debate in this House, which is not a bad thing in politics. We should never shirk away from or be resistant to meaningful, strong and robust political engagement. This is what political chambers are, up and down the country and all over the world. I thank the Senator, genuinely, for putting this motion forward. I respect that people all have different points of view, which is important in this debate.

I acknowledge Deputy Catherine Callaghan who has spent most of this afternoon in the Distinguished Visitors Gallery. She is a former member of the Air Corps and a UN peacekeeper. The Deputy has vast experience in defence. It was very telling that she should stay for all of this debate. I salute her and acknowledge her significant contribution in peacekeeping and her engagement. That is important to acknowledge in the House.

There has been a lot of talk about the Irish Times today. An Irish Times-Ipsos-B and A opinion poll shows that 71% of the population believe that a guarantee of Ireland's neutrality should be added to the Constitution. I just want to peg that there. That is some barometer. Opinion polls are not everything. They read a given opinion on a given day, and I just wanted to point this out too.

There are a number of other aspects to the motion tabled by Senator Clonan. The Senator talks about properly funding Ireland's Army, Air Corps, Naval Service and cyber capability in order that we can secure our land, our air, and our maritime and cyber domains. The motion also deals with pay for our soldiers, aircrew and sailors. A living wage is a matter of urgency to address the current chronic recruitment and retention crisis.

The motion also seeks to expand on the Reserve Defence Force in order for Ireland to harness its unique human capital and skill sets to support a whole-of-security resilience. The motion also deals with guaranteeing Ireland's status as a militarily neutral state and commits to preserving that neutral status by way of constitutional guarantee, as is the case in Austria and Switzerland. We are all very familiar with that.

The Irish people take great pride in our Defence Forces. That has been echoed by Senators across the House today. The Defence Forces are made up of the Permanent Defence Force, the Reserve Defence and the Civil Defence. Their greatest asset is its people. The Minister of State and I both know that. I think we can agree on it. I will take this opportunity to thank and salute the men and women of the Defence Forces for their excellent service to our country both at home and abroad and also their families and partners who support them in their work every day. That cannot be easy. They are the ones we do not always hear about. It is important to recognise that here today. In this evening's debate, it is also important to acknowledge the realities on the ground and the challenges facing our Defence Forces. In 2025, the Defence Forces' total number of personnel stood at 7,715, 79% of the agreed establishment strength of 9,739. The target recommended by the Commission on the Defence Forces is 11,500 personnel by 2028.

I acknowledge that there were improvements in the budget, as the Minister said. We are moving in the right direction and it is important to be fair and to acknowledge that in our debate here this evening. The budget provided for 850 new Permanent Defence Force members and increases for Air Corps and Naval Service equipment. The budget also provides the national development plan funding of €340 million that will support the delivery of new helicopters and the military radar programme. The Minister of State has confirmed that. I have spoken with the Department to seek confirmation on it myself. Funding through the budget will also support investment in maritime surveillance and cybersecurity as well as the modernisation and upgrading of military installations throughout the country. That is all to be welcomed.

Neutrality is the foundation upon which Ireland champions engagement, diplomacy, the primacy of human rights, and the prevention and resolution of conflict through dialogue. That is an important point. Political trust is at stake here. Our citizens have genuine concerns. There are misgivings among the political ranks within each party in this House, in the Dáil and everywhere else. We have a lot further to go in this debate. We must remember to be in tune with the citizens we represent. Trust and confidence in the political establishment is central to this debate. I thank all of the contributors to the debate. It has been meaningful and robust. It is an important debate and one we should have.

Comment on this

I thank my colleague Senator Tom Clonan for bringing forward this important Private Member's motion. I support his position and I am a signatory to the motion. When the Second World War broke out, Éamon de Valera, who had seen war himself and experienced its consequences, said that we must keep out. He understood that the best course of action for the Irish people and for his Government was neutrality. Neutrality is not a position of cowardice. It is a position of independence. It has become an important political tradition and it has allowed Ireland to make its own decisions about where and when we involve ourselves in international conflicts. Irish troops are among the most respected peacekeepers in the world. They are welcomed in places where other armies would never be accepted. That reputation comes from Ireland being seen as an independent and neutral country.

It was a Fianna Fáil Taoiseach who declared neutrality and a Fianna Fáil Taoiseach who codified it in law. Now, it is a Fianna Fáil Taoiseach who wants to rip it up and throw it out. Ireland should retain the political discretion to support countries in crisis on a case-by-case basis, protected by the triple lock, without having to join a military alliance. If this Government genuinely believes that neutrality is worth preserving, it should be given a constitutional guarantee here as it is Austria and Switzerland. The Government amendment states that the removal of the triple lock is not "a move towards membership of a military alliance" but I do not believe that.

The whole point of neutrality is that Ireland decides for itself. Once that safeguard is removed that requires UN authorisation, Government approval and Dáil approval, it makes it easier for Ireland to be drawn into military operations based on the decisions of other countries or alliances. If you formally align yourself with one side of a conflict, you have made a choice. You are no longer simply deciding what is in Ireland's interests on a case-by-case basis. You are choosing to stand with one side rather than remaining independent of both. That is particularly concerning when EU leaders, including Ursula von der Leyen, are openly talking about a stronger European defence policy, closer co-operation with NATO and hundreds of billions of euro in increased military spending. De Valera had the political courage to decide what was right for Ireland. Our current Taoiseach seems far more willing to follow where Brussels leads.

The Irish people rejected the Nice treaty in 2001. Concerns about neutrality were central to that rejection. The assurances around the triple lock helped secure support when the treaty was put back to the people in 2002. Those assurances remained important during the Lisbon treaty process. Who exactly gave this Government permission to take it away? If this Government wants to dismantle the triple lock, it should hold a referendum and let the people have their say. Polls have consistently shown that the Irish people agree with the current position. However, the Government does not want to do that because it knows what the answer from the Irish people will be.

Comment on this

The Minister of State is very welcome to the Chamber. I highly commend my colleague Senator Tom Clonan on bringing this vital and timely motion before the House. I am proud to speak in full support of it. The motion is exceptional because it approaches our national security from a position of common sense and reality. It addresses the immediate structural starvation of our front line, explicitly calling for our soldiers, sailors and air crew to be paid a mandatory living wage to solve the chronic recruitment crisis. It also rightly demands the appointment of a dedicated and exclusive Minister for Defence, rather than giving a part-time portfolio to a Minister shared with other heavy Departments, to properly lead and safeguard our national security.

The true brilliance of Senator Clonan's motion is that it cuts to the root cause of the entire triple lock debate. For months, we have heard endless legalistic back and forth about the UN Security Council mandates, deploying numbers and specific statutory restrictions. All of that technocratic wrangling completely misses the central point, however. According to recent poll data cited in this very motion, the overwhelming majority of the Irish people, nearly 70%, want our military neutrality to be permanently guaranteed. They do not want our non-aligned status to hinge on the whim of a simple whipped majority of any future Dáil. They do not want a temporary executive coalition to be able to arbitrarily rewrite our defensive guardrails overnight and get our young men and women sucked into foreign alliances and their bloody wars. This is exactly what a constitutional amendment and referendum represent. Enshrining neutrality in Bunreacht na hÉireann removes the decision from the hands of the political class and places it permanently where it belongs: in the sovereign vote of the Irish people.

I must address the amendment the Government Members have tabled. Like much of the rhetoric we have heard from the State benches, this amendment flatly ignores the core argument of the motion. Instead of engaging in a concrete intellectual discussion about constitutional protections, the Government is, to be frank, fobbing us off with promises that it intends to maintain a policy of non-alignment. Without meaning to impugn anyone's sincerity, the concrete reality is that this political promise is mere paper.

This Administration cannot guarantee our future neutrality on a handshake and a nod. It simply does not know what geopolitical pressures will unfold in the next five years. The Minister of State cannot guarantee that he or the Minister, Deputy McEntee, will be in office. There is no knowing what radical ideological shift could occur under a future Government. I will put a direct question. If the Government truly agrees with the principle of military neutrality, why does it refuse to support a referendum on constitutional neutrality? What is it afraid of? Let us put it to the people. Once our non-aligned status is secure in the Constitution, then, and only then, can we constructively debate the triple lock or any military legislation. I urge all sides of the House to support this common-sense motion tabled by my colleague, Senator Clonan.

Comment on this

I again draw attention to the final half page of the Minister's statement which says the Seanad Independent Group's position is clear and goes on to say that it means Ireland will stop contributing to the world. As my colleague on my right said, the Independent position is far from being clear in that regard. Of the eight members of the Civil Engagement Group, three signed Senator Clonan's motion. That is the way things are and it is important the House take note of that.

Nevertheless, bhí an díospóireacht an-deas, an-bhreá agus an-soiléir againn, cé go raibh sí an-torannach in amanna. Listening to the to and fro of the debate helped to distil in my mind something I am sure is confusing for us all to one degree or another, and probably quite confusing for the suited gentleman on the Rathmines omnibus. If I were to ask him questions, the first would be whether he believes in holding Ireland's sovereignty. I am sure the answer would be a resounding "Yes". Second, if I were to ask if he believes Ireland has a national right to neutrality, I am sure he would say "Absolutely, yes", that it has always been that way and that is the way it should continue. Then if I were to ask the tricky third question, which of the concepts of sovereignty or neutrality should be supreme, I imagine I would get a long, questioning face.

Five score and five years ago, our forefathers, to paraphrase Abraham Lincoln, begot this nation, in 1921. It was a nation committed to sovereignty. That was copperfastened in 1949 by the Republic of Ireland Act. We hold that we are a sovereign republic and that means that we, as a sovereign people, have the right to decide our future. We can decide on neutrality or not. Do we have a sovereign right to neutrality? It does not work the other way because neutrality would then become sovereign and would be dictating to the sovereignty of the nation. Therefore, as democrats and believers in the sovereign State, we must yield to the fact that sovereignty is supreme and neutrality, however valued and wonderful and however timely it might have been in 1937 or 1939, is not something we are necessarily bound to under sovereignty.

It is a fast-changing world. Why are so many of the Baltic states and Finland and Sweden, which have strongly adhered to neutrality in the last while, rushing into NATO? What is the subtext? Why are we getting nations that suffered unbelievable genocide a few generations ago now effecting genocide in another part of the world? How are they so amnesic as to do that? How are post-colonial states such as Britain and France taking recourse to the rule of law to substantiate their holding of influence in Africa and other parts of the world, including Las Malvinas, to give away the game?

I was given six minutes to speak today, which is exactly the same length of time it would take one of Mr. Putin's ballistic missiles to launch from western Russia and hit Dublin. It is an unbelievably changed world and our defences and the people we engage to look after the defence of our assets have to be given the wherewithal to measure up to the ever-changing world. I do not necessarily see that, in this day and age, neutrality is necessarily the best way to guarantee that.

Comment on this

I will make a few points. As a proud member of the Seanad Independent Group, I do not think I signed this motion. Whether I did or not, it is in a sense immaterial to me whether a majority or minority of our group did because, as I have always said, we are a group of Independents and we rub along well together. We are an exemplary group in that regard and we have our differences and so on. I am always keen to stress - I do not think any of my colleagues in the group would disagree - that we are not a whipped group. We all make proposals. Sometimes, members are in a minority of one and sometimes we will be unanimous and that is fine. We then move on to the next proposal.

My position on this motion is that there is a lot in it I agree with. Two thoughts loom large in my mind. The UN, for all its faults, and it has many, is an organisation, at a time when there is a retreat from multilateralism in the world, offers some kind of opportunity to try to get to a consensus about intervention being justified, that is intervention that involves putting armed forces into another state. Our proudest moments in the activity of the Defence Forces over the years have come in the context of our UN commitments.

Second, what worries me about abandoning the triple lock is partly that we have a weak enough parliamentary system, as we all know. What the Government wants, the Government generally gets and it is on rare occasions that politicians feel enabled to go against what the Government wants, because we all know that decision can have consequences for political advancement. In recent times, we have started, around abortion and so on, to talk about conscience voting more respectfully. However, in the absence of the triple guarantee, in the end, we will be exposing ourselves to decision making in this sensitive area that will be about what the Government wants, and what the Government wants, it will get through pressure on its parliamentary majority. That is of concern to me, because it will be a conscience vote issue for many people.

I had a conversation recently in a group setting. I threw out a subject for conversation: military service in Ireland, "Yes" or "No". I was taken by the diversity. There were some solid definite nods and some people said that we need to develop our readiness as citizens, that we need to have a greater sense of our need to protect ourselves and that it undoubtedly involves multilateral relationships and so on. I welcome the budget commitment to add 850 members to the Defence Forces. We need to think imaginatively about how we encourage participation in military life in Ireland and what kinds of roles can be given to people in the Defence Forces in times of national crisis or challenge, whether they are weather related or have to do directly with defensive matters.

We certainly should look to a future in which some kind of commitment, as far as possible, is expected of each citizen. We need to start thinking in those terms.

As for removing the triple lock, I prefer a model under which Ireland, as a small country, draws on its very valued tradition of our political neutrality enabling us to be a broker for peace in the world. I have listened very carefully to colleagues' arguments and am open to changing to my mind but, right now, I think we are better served by keeping the important link with the United Nations that is the requirement for a mandate from the Security Council before we make any commitment. It strikes me that, in the end, all of this rests on a legislative decision. I am not ready to say I am in favour of a constitutional referendum to enshrine our neutrality in a particular way. In the meantime, these decisions will come down to the Government and the Oireachtas. We should not legislate upfront at this point to exclude the requirement for a UN mandate. It is always open to the Government and the Oireachtas to respond in an ad hoc way to a particular situation and it might be in that context that a particular decision would have to be considered by the Executive and the Legislature of the State. For now, I am inclined to say I support most of what is in the motion. I will vote for it while retaining the right to consider and ponder aspects of its proposals.

Comment on this

Senator Conway mentioned the besuited gentleman from Rathmines. I want to answer the besuited gentleman from Ranelagh, namely, my great colleague Senator McDowell. He is correct that I wrote about the triple lock in 2003 - in October 2003, to be precise. This issue has been raised with me previously and it speaks to the very point I am making. In that newspaper article, I said that the triple lock needs to be reformed. In my opening remarks in this debate, I said that the Government is talking about reforming the triple lock but what it is actually doing is seeking to abolish it. I referenced in the article the International Peace Missions Deployment Bill 2003 put forward by Fine Gael, in which other mechanisms were proposed by which we might apply checks and balances to decisions to deploy our troops. There is nothing inconsistent in what I am saying now with what I wrote as a young man, or at least a younger man, 23 years ago.

Comment on this

Senator Clonan wrote that when he was young and irresponsible.

Comment on this

I will address some of the issues that were raised in the debate. Senator Wilson knows the very high esteem and regard in which I hold him and my affection for him. I have similar regard for Senator O'Loughlin, who said she spoke for Fianna Fáil in stating that there is no intention to alter our position on neutrality. However, the reality is that if we send troops on a peace enforcement mission that does not have a UN mandate, that is not a blue helmet mission. It would mean, de facto, that we were participating in a conflict on one side or the other. The Minister of State suggested in his speech that we ought to be part of an EU mission in Lebanon after the UNIFIL mandate expires. That would basically be to support the Lebanese armed forces to disarm Hezbollah. We would, de facto, be participating in a Lebanese civil war. We can ask the United States what that is like. That country had 500 of its troops murdered in a Hezbollah truck bomb in Beirut in the eighties.

I know the intention is not to erode our neutral status but if we are participating in chapter VII missions, we are, de facto, no longer neutral. Overnight, we would lose the international respect we have built up if we participated in the wrong mission. All I am saying is that we should not abolish the triple lock. I will be introducing amendments consistent with what Senator Mullen said. Perhaps there should be a non-whipped vote on the legislation in the Dáil or, as Senator Wilson has suggested at the Joint Committee on Defence and National Security, the Upper House might be involved in some way in reviewing such decisions. We have to be careful.

The Minister constantly references peacekeeping and correctly commends our peacekeeping record, in which I participated. Thirty years ago, Ireland did one thing for one international agency. We did peacekeeping for the UN. Now, we do peacekeeping and peace enforcement for the UN, NATO and the European Union. For example, Irish troops participated and distinguished themselves in UN-mandated NATO fighting missions in Afghanistan and in peace enforcement missions with NATO in Kosovo, with one of our generals commanding NATO's multinational division south in Kosovo. That is something we should be proud of but to underplay or dismiss it is wrong. We did peace enforcement, which involved fighting, in Somalia as part of UNISOM II in Mogadishu, in the same year that the incident we have all seen depicted in the film "Black Hawk Down" occurred. Our troops have excelled themselves but always with a UN mandate. Similarly, we sent our troops, mostly Army Ranger troops, to a peace enforcement mission in East Timor in the nineties. Ireland led the first EU expeditionary mission outside of the territory of the EU to Chad and the Central African Republic. Downplaying our peace enforcement role or suggesting it will not be a part of what we do next is to diminish the work of the Defence Forces.

My principal point in this is about neutrality and our constitutional sovereignty. At the moment, our airspace is being patrolled by the Royal Air Force. That is a diminution of both our neutral status and our sovereignty. It is a perfect storm. I set out in my motion that we must invest in our defence. I suggested we follow the Finnish model but not in a compulsory way. We need to massively expand our reserves in order to allow our citizens, with their unique skill sets and human capital, to prepare us for the climate-related challenges that lie ahead and the ongoing global insecurity. This is the wrong time to walk away from the multilateral rules-based order. I ask my colleagues across the Chambers, please, not to set their faces against the will of the Irish people. Let us amend the legislation. If we are going to get rid of the triple lock, we need to replace it with something in which the Irish people will have faith and confidence.

I want to make a final point. Senator Ahearn mentioned there being some random group of decision-makers. That is wrong. I was very clear that I am talking about the same community of decision-makers who have left this country defenceless in the maritime, ground, air and cyber domains. They are the people who will be deciding where we send our troops. They are the people who opted not to close our airspace when we spotted military-grade drones operating in it recently. Every other EU state closes its airspace when that happens. These people do not have the required operational and situational awareness. I do not have faith in their capacity to make sensible decisions about where we send troops, particularly in the absence of the safeguard mechanism that is the triple lock. What I am asking for is simple. I am asking the Government to do what it claims to be doing, which is to modify the triple lock, not simply to abolish it.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 29
·
Níl 16
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

When is it proposed to sit again?

Comment on this

Tomorrow at 9.30 a.m.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this