An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business
- Order of Business 1 speech
The Leader proposed taking the school meals programme committee report after the Order of Business, without debate; Fitzpatrick also congratulated the Spanish ambassador.
Mary Fitzpatrick
- Mid-west eating disorder clinic 2 speeches
Ryan welcomed dedicated funding for a specialist eating disorder clinic in Limerick. The Chair welcomed visitors to the Gallery.
Dee Ryan, Maria Byrne
- Killybegs port listing 1 speech
Boyle sought confirmation that the Department would apply for the port listing, saying it is important for jobs in Killybegs and coastal communities.
Manus Boyle
- Removing pornography from the internet 1 speech
Mullen said he hoped pornography could eventually be removed from the internet, while welcoming a visitor and mentioning the Oireachtas essay competition.
Rónán Mullen
- Unlicensed Dublin horse carriages 1 speech
Andrews raised the rise of unlicensed horse carriages in Dublin and the concerns they create.
Chris Andrews
- World Mental Health Day 1 speech
Murphy O’Mahony marked World Mental Health Day, urged people to check in on others and acknowledged the Minister of State’s work.
Margaret Murphy O'Mahony
- Leinster House staff strike 1 speech
Flynn urged politicians not to cross the picket if Leinster House staff strike next Wednesday, and expressed support for staff.
Eileen Flynn
- Garda vetting process 1 speech
Scahill called for a review of Garda vetting efficiency while stressing that protections for children and vulnerable adults must remain strong.
Gareth Scahill
- Greenways connecting towns 1 speech
McCarthy argued that greenways should connect homes, schools, workplaces and town centres, rather than being viewed only as tourism routes.
Aubrey McCarthy
- Cavan-Monaghan orthodontic waiting list 1 speech
Tully highlighted long HSE orthodontic waits and a vacant consultant post, and sought action for patients in the Cavan-Monaghan-Louth-Meath area.
Pauline Tully
- Horse Sport Ireland examinership 3 speeches
Flaherty questioned whether Horse Sport Ireland disclosed its financial and PRSI difficulties when bidding for the equine breeding services contract. The Chair cautioned against discussing an ongoing court case; Flaherty said the examinership proceedings could be discussed.
Joe Flaherty, Maria Byrne
- Lisa Smith conviction upheld 1 speech
Keogan welcomed the Court of Appeal’s decision upholding Lisa Smith’s conviction for membership of ISIS, calling it a victory for anti-terrorism frameworks.
Sharon Keogan
- Liscannor hare coursing concerns 1 speech
Conway asked the Justice Minister to bring reports of trespass, intimidation and hare coursing by lurcher dogs in Liscannor to Garda attention.
Martin Conway
- Sustainable third-level funding 4 speeches
The Leader welcomed the eating-disorder clinic funding and proposed a debate with Minister Lawless on progress, challenges and sustainable funding for third-level education. Mullen questioned whether the Funding the Future commitments would be honoured, and the Leader began responding to Andrews’ concerns about illegal carriage operators.
Mary Fitzpatrick, Rónán Mullen, Maria Byrne
I join the Leas-Chathaoirleach in congratulating the ambassador, all the team at the embassy and Spanish people everywhere. Happy national day and I hope you enjoy your celebrations. They are well deserved.
The Order of Business is No. 1, motion regarding the report of the Joint Committee on Education and Youth entitled Report on Evaluating the Impact of the School Meals Programme, to be taken on conclusion of the Order of Business without debate.
Comment on this
I extend my congratulations and welcome to the Spanish ambassador. I wish her all the best in celebrating her national day next week. I welcome all the visitors in the Gallery.
I welcome the announcement by the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, yesterday evening in the Dáil of dedicated funding for a specialist eating disorder clinic in the mid-west to be based in Limerick. The funding is there to put all the healthcare professionals in place and to provide wraparound care for adults suffering from eating disorders who require ongoing support. It completes the work of opening eating disorder clinics in each healthcare region across the country. There will be approximately €1 million in funding from the Minister of State for this important resource and the funding is being provided on an ongoing, sustainable basis. I thank the Minister of State for recognising the need for this in the mid-west. I commend all the advocates, parents and sufferers who have long advocated for such supports in Limerick and the mid-west. I wish the HSE well in its recruitment, which is expected to take 12 to 18 months to get this up and running.
It may have got lost in all the budget discussions earlier in the week, but Gráinne Seoige aired a very important documentary on Virgin Media One on Monday evening, "Deepfake Ireland". I commend her bravery and professionalism in applying her skill set to highlighting the huge impact deepfakes have on their victims. People can often laugh or sneer almost jokingly about a nude that may appear in their WhatsApp group or something going around online that is AI generated. Gráinne Seoige highlighted the personal impact of such a crime. The creation and dissemination of such images is a crime punishable by up to seven years in person. She brought home the victim impact. She spoke to Cara Hunter, a politician in the North who suffered a similar episode; a 15-year-old girl who experienced this in her personal life; and a gentleman who was a victim of sextortion, who is a spoken word artist and who used the experience to speak out about the impact. These are not victimless crimes. They are very serious and there are serious real-world consequences when anyone choose to misuse technology in this way. They are crimes the Government and the EU take seriously.
Comment on this
I welcome students from St. Colmcille's school in Knocklyon, Dublin, who are guests of Deputy Ahern. I hope they enjoy their visit.
I welcome Brendan Walsh from Dundalk, who is celebrating his junior certificate results from yesterday. Congratulations to Brendan. He is a guest of Senator Andrews.
Comment on this
Will the Leader get an update on the port listing for Killybegs from the Department of marine? Has the port listing been applied for? This is a very important step for securing jobs in Killybegs, in County Donegal and around all the coastal communities.
Denmark applied for this port listing and it had it in six weeks. We have been talking about this in this Chamber for the last 12 months. The Department officials tell us they are working on it but could we get something to say yes, we are applying, that we are going to be there? January is coming very soon and for the coastal communities in Donegal that is when mainly all the pelagic fish is landed. We really need this in place to secure these jobs, or the few that are left. The fishing industry has taken a massive hit over the last five years. This is really a crucial piece of the puzzle moving forward. Will the Leader get some clarity on it for me?
Comment on this
First, I welcome Brendan from Dundalk and congratulate him on his junior certificate. I remind him that as a transition year student he is now eligible to enter the Oireachtas essay competition for transition year, fifth and sixth year students. If he goes to oireachtasessay.ie he might find himself in the way of winning €1,000 if he wins the best essay in this year's competition on the theme of "Parliamentary Politics Matters for Europe".
I commend everything Senator Dee Ryan has said. We need to dare to dream of the day when pornography is completely off-line. It is going to be very hard to deal with any of these serious problems. What the Senator just described is at the most serious end, along with child abuse, on the internet, but we need to be so much more courageous and direct about protecting people from online harms.
There is a lot of talk on RTÉ today about its disappointed expectations in terms of the €20 million it thought it was getting that it is not getting in this year's budget. However, we can compare that with the shortfall in the funding of third level education, which matters so much for our future. In the Funding the Future paper in 2022, it was identified and agreed to by the Government and the then Minister for further and higher education, Deputy Harris, that the third level sector was underfunded to the tune of €307 million. It was committed to that this shortfall would be dealt with. That has not happened. This year, there is only a €10 million increase in the funding being made available to third level students. We are just about half way towards meeting that annual €307 million shortfall. Simon Harris said when that was published, "Today, we settle the question on higher education funding". Well, they did not, because cumulatively since the Funding the Future paper I have calculated that the third level sector has been underfunded by €935 million. How corrosive it is to make promises and then blatantly and publicly disregard them. At a time when there is so much talk of fake news and disinformation, the Government itself, in this case the previous government but followed on by the current Government which is largely composed of the same people, is setting false narratives of its own. It is, in effect, gaslighting people by saying it has committed to solving this problem, is solving this problem and the question is settled, but it is not. The funding of third level education is critical to our future. There has been an emphasis in this budget with the €250 reduction in the student contribution and approaching third level as a cost-of-living expense for parents. That is important, but what about the vital investment in the country's future? This must be addressed.
Comment on this
Anyone who visits or lives in Dublin city will know that the horse carriages are a common feature on our streets, particularly in the south inner city, parts of which have a long tradition of urban horse ownership. In previous years, this took the form of a tightly regulated industry of professional and licensed carriage drivers who would typically ferry tourists between St. Stephen's Green and the Guinness Storehouse and other tourist sites. Recently, however, there has been a massive surge in the number of unlicensed and unregistered carriages. There are a lot of rogue operators who are involved in criminality. Professional carriage operators who meet Dublin City Council's standards and requirements under the old by-laws are now working alongside unlicensed ones who do not have any certification. In many cases, these carriages are driven by people who have no experience or interest in properly taking care of their animals or abiding by the rules of the road. It is not uncommon to see these carriages driven by children at high speed around the city, and stories of intimidation, crime and antisocial behaviour by carriage drivers are becoming all too common now. Reputable, long-standing, licensed carriage owners are having their livelihoods taken away from them. These rogue operators are to the detriment of the licence-holders and the city in general. It is only a matter a time until someone is killed by one of these irresponsible carriages, and without proper regulation both animal welfare and upkeep of the city suffer. Residents are really frustrated by horse manure collecting outside their homes and along the streets in the south inner city, as well as by antisocial behaviour and the mistreatment of horses by carriage operators at their stables, which are often illegally set up in residential areas.
For years now, the Government has been aware that the rules and enforcement around Dublin's horse carriages are conflicting, outdated, inconsistent and inadequate. It is very unfortunate that nothing has been done to reform this legislation. The legislation governing this dates back to 1853, which is completely outdated for a modern city. It is long past time we address these failures to improve public safety and clean up our streets. Dublin's inner city urgently needs this legal gap to be closed and the current hands-off approach from Dublin City Council to end. Sinn Féin has introduced a Bill to this effect and I hope the Government will support this legislation in due course. I ask that the Minister for Transport come in to the House to provide an update on what is being done to clamp down on these unregulated horse carriages and the rogue operators who are involved in criminality.
Comment on this
I wish to speak about World Mental Health Day, which is happening on 10 October, this coming Saturday. This day is in existence since 1992. Thankfully, lot of work has been done since then but unfortunately there is still a huge stigma around mental health, which is very sad to see. It probably behoves us all to make sure all our colleagues, friends and family are doing okay. Even to ask the simple question, "Are you okay?" is very important. I acknowledge the fantastic work being done by the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, in this field. She is pioneering an awful lot of projects and doing very well. I encourage us all to ask not only on Saturday are people okay. It is very important to get the message out that it is okay not to be okay. It is okay to struggle. It is very important to ask for help. It could be any one of us.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, for all of her support around Traveller mental health and also in the budget. I put that on record.
Next Wednesday, the staff in Leinster House, from the ushers to the restaurant staff, will be on strike. It looks like that at the moment. That may change. I encourage every single politician not to cross the picket, not to be brought in the back of Leinster House and to have respect for the people in these Houses who are not TDs and Senators. They turn on the lights and look after all the Members, etc. I remind everybody next Wednesday that there might be a protest for the workers in Leinster House. Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, Labour, Sinn Féin and Independent Members should not show up if that is the case because as one of the ushers said to me earlier, it would be a kick in the teeth for the workers here who work with us every single day. I have a Bill next Wednesday and even if I have to just not show up for that Bill, I will not be coming in.
Comment on this
I call for a review of An Garda Síochána’s vetting process. I put it on the record that the vetting process is essential and very important. Protecting children and vulnerable adults is most important and I am in no way trying to weaken that protection. However, we need to look at the efficiencies of the Garda vetting process itself.
In 2025, more than 633,000 Garda vetting applications were received but what we do not know is how many of those were duplicate applications, with people applying for multiple organisations or in multiple areas. One particular concern I have is with regard to school transport drivers. Bus Éireann's published requirements state that drivers must be vetted and approved in each school transport office location the contractor operates from. A bus driver can get Garda the vetting in County Roscommon but if they have to drive to Williamstown, which is only a few kilometres down the road, they have to get Garda vetting clearance in County Galway and County Mayo. There has to be a simpler system. I would like to understand why a driver has to be vetted in multiple areas. Is there scope to streamline the whole process?
I ask the Minister to examine whether individuals could have a secure national vetting record that authorised organisations can verify, rather than repeatedly starting the process from scratch. We should also examine a standardised renewal cycle, potentially every three to five years, with automatic reminders sent out to individuals six months before the expiration of that. That way, we will prevent any unnecessary lapses in people's approval, and reduce disruptions for employers, volunteers and, as I said, school transport providers.
Importantly, the existing legislation already provides for joint vetting requirements between organisations under certain circumstances but I do not believe that process is looked at and utilised enough. In the past five years, vetting responsibilities have doubled. There are more requirements and a greater onus on volunteers and multiple organisations to get involved in this. It is something we really need to look at. I would welcome an opportunity to have a debate on it.
I did not fully listen to Senator Mullen's contribution - and I have pulled the Minister, Deputy Lawless, up more times than anyone in this House about some of the investment in further and higher education - but I highlight the fact that €5.3 billion has been allocated. That is a significant budget. Between the SUSI grants and maintenance fee, 150,000 students and families are going to benefit from the budget this year. As well as that, additional money has been put towards more apprenticeship delivery, which is going to help us deliver on the national development plan. We are getting closer to the 12,500 apprentices delivery target every year. Is that enough? No. We want to keep pushing but we do have to set targets and deliver on them. I would welcome a debate with the Minister but I think he is doing a very good job.
Comment on this
I raise the value of greenways throughout Ireland and question why we are actually underestimating them. When people think of a greenway, they think of Waterford or Mayo or a tourism route through the countryside. That is relevant but it has left us with too narrow a view of what a greenway is. A greenway can change how a town works. It can connect homes, schools, workplaces and take cars off streets and bring people safely into the town centre where they can spend their money.
A greenway that stops at the edge of a town, which is fairly usual, gets used at weekends. People go out in their jogging gear with a cappuccino and use the greenway. However, if there is one that reaches the school gate, it will get used every day. Local authorities are central to this. They propose, design, and deliver greenways with Transport Infrastructure Ireland approving and funding them.
How a council sees a greenway decides whether it gets built. Money is tight. Earlier in the year, TII told the Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food that greenways cost up to €2 million per kilometre. The budget has set aside €62 million, which means 31 kilometres of greenway are going to be built. Every kilometre is important.
In my hometown of Naas, much of the town's new housing is on the north side but many of the schools, such as in the Killashee area, are on the south side which has a huge population. Every morning and afternoon, the town of Naas clogged. I try to avoid it by going the back roads. There is a short greenway along the old Tullow rail line and it is a corridor that links communities to schools and the town centre through Sallins to the Grand Canal greenway and the national rail network. It is only a few kilometres. If that was to be taken seriously, it would result in no congestion, safer school runs and more use of a greenway, which is what it was meant for. That is the whole purpose.
The Government is looking at the national greenway strategy, so I ask the Leader for a debate on that review to see if we can get the local authorities to plan greenways as core infrastructure linked to housing, schools and town centres. We should not judge a greenway on its length but on its connection to a town centre.
Comment on this
I raise the HSE orthodontic waiting list in the Cavan-Monaghan-Louth-Meath area where people are seen in Navan hospital. Last year I made an inquiry on behalf of a young girl on the list since November 2022. I was told at that time that there was no consultant orthodontist working for the service and the post had been vacant since 2022. I was assured efforts were being made to recruit someone - and I do not doubt serious efforts were being made - but they were having no success. There were 300 patients on the list at that time, with the longest waiting 309 weeks, which is almost six years. The person I was inquiring about was number 43 on the list.
I then made an inquiry for somebody else in June, and was told there were now 183 on the list. It had come down from 300 to 183, with the longest waiting four and a half years. However, the person I first made an inquiry about, who was 43 on the list, had not been seen. The list is not coming down because of people being seen. Obviously, some people are seeking private dental care, or are utilising cross-Border arrangements although not everybody can utilise that because you have to pay upfront and not everybody is in a position to do that.
I have been told by the HSE that it has just recruited someone, which I really welcome, but they are looking at a waiting list of 183 people, with some of them on it four or five years. Many of these people are in pain and need serious treatment. People do not get on this list unless they have very serious issues. I am asking whether the HSE would look at outsourcing some of this work because we want to keep that orthodontist there. I do not know why the person left four years ago. It was possibly because of the stress of the job, with there being so many on the list. I do not know why the HSE could not recruit for this position in all of that time but we want to keep this person there and, if possible, recruit a second person to address the list and to get the people who are waiting the longest seen as quickly as possible. It is a very serious issue.
Comment on this
We heard mention of the Horse Sport Ireland, HSI, examinership case in the High Court again this week. A barrister for the organisation explained that any survival plan during examinership for the body will be predicated on the agency retaining the €6.5 million-----
Comment on this
It is okay. It is an examinership case, so it is fine. The €6.5 million national equine breeding services tender was awarded earlier this year. If the agency's survival is dependent on this contract, we need to address a series of important questions. Earlier this year, HSI lost its appeal against the Department of Social Protection’s determination for €67,000 relating to PRSI. It failed to pay this by 31 May and missed a further deadline of 31 July. I need to know whether it made the Department of agriculture aware of this situation when it submitted the tender. The national equine breeding services tender process clearly stipulates that where the applicant is aware of such a breach, or the outstanding liability has not been paid or made subject to a binding agreement, exclusion from the tender process is mandatory. HSI has been under the protection of the examiner process since 24 August, and the tender process clearly provides for the exclusion of any applicant subject to insolvency or an arrangement with creditors.
Did HSI advise the Department at any stage that it was at risk of examinership, or did it wait until it had secured the €6.5 million contract before going into examinership? The tender process required turnover figures for 2023 through to 2025, as well as audited accounts for the last three years. HSI had no audited accounts for 2025. However, its own management accounts showed net liability in excess of €1 million at 31 December 2025, and negative net assets on 30 June 2026 of €364,000. HSI's own accounts have shown serious concerns - we now know that they are alarming concerns - from 2022 onwards. The management accounts dated 4 March 2026 showed that the cash had fallen from €1.8 million to €400,000. The tender process deadline of 15 May required HSI to confirm that it has met all its tax and social security liabilities. If it did not advise the Department of the outstanding €67,000 liability to social welfare, we have to ask why not. I have the height of respect for the staff working for HSI, but senior management has serious questions to answer in this case. I am under time restrictions, but I have many more questions relating to this organisation. I will be returning to them in due course.
Comment on this
It is lovely to see the Acting Leader in the Chair today. If her late father was looking down, I am sure he would be so proud to see her there.
I welcome the recent decision by the Court of Appeal to uphold the conviction of former soldier Lisa Smith for membership of the terrorist organisation ISIS. As many of those in this House know, she travelled to Syria and lived there as part of the Islamic State from 2015 to 2019. This judgment is a significant victory for our anti-terror frameworks. It proves that when it comes to prosecuting overt actions committed abroad, our courts have done their job. When it comes to monitoring extremist ideology within our own borders, however, there is a hell of a lot more to do. While we convict individuals returning from Syria, I have to ask what did we do and what will we do to stop them going there in the first place. This State remains blind to the deep institutional root structures of Islamic extremism going completely unchecked under our noses. I have stood in this Chamber before and warned this Government about our absolute naivety regarding the Muslim Brotherhood and its various front organisations flourishing across this Republic. We cannot afford to be naive anymore. The geopolitical reality across Europe is a loud wake-up call. We have witnessed an horrific surge in Islamic extremism and violence across our neighbouring countries, from the brutal knife attacks in Solingen and Mannheim to the continuous elevated terror alerts shutting down public spaces across France and Belgium. International experts have repeatedly warned us that Ireland is being utilised as a haven and a logistical base for European extremist operations. It is no longer enough for a tragedy to happen before we intervene. Our national security cannot be managed with an attitude of administrative complacency. I am calling on the Acting Leader to schedule an urgent debate on national security. I demand that the Minister for justice launches an immediate investigation into the influence, funding and domestic structures of the Muslim Brotherhood and its affiliates in Ireland.
Comment on this
I support Senator Flaherty in his call for accountability at Horse Racing Ireland. It is a potential developing scandal, to be quite frank about it.
In Liscannor, County Clare, which is a lovely area of the country where people love their animals, there is a developing problem with people coming from outside with lurcher dogs to chase hares, enter lands illegally, behave in a threatening manner towards people and essentially intimidate people. Will the Acting Leader write to the Minister for justice and ask him to bring this to the attention of An Garda Síochána? What is going on there is intimidating old people, people who are working on their farms and people who are visiting the area. Liscannor has a proud tradition of looking after animals and caring for them. They have their own coursing festival there every year. This developing problem of people coming from outside with vans and lurcher dogs, chasing hares and entering land and so on is becoming a serious problem. There was a meeting the other night because people are so worried and concerned about it. It needs to be nipped in the bud and dealt with quickly. The best way is for the Minister for justice to bring it to the attention of the Garda Commissioner and the Garda chief superintendent in Clare. Resources need to be deployed to the Liscannor area to deal with this problem once and for all.
Comment on this
I thank all of the Senators for their contributions this morning. A number of issues were raised.
Commencing the Order of Business was Senator Dee Ryan from Limerick. Senator Ryan raised two issues. The first issue is great news for Limerick and the mid-west and very positive news for everybody who has campaigned. The Senator has been a big supporter of the campaign for an eating disorder clinic. It is welcome news. Well done to the Minister of State, Deputy Butler. She is doing great work in the Department. It will be a lifeline for a lot of individuals and families. The Senator rightly pointed out that this completes the commitment of the Minister of State and the Government to ensure there are eating disorder clinics in each of the health regions. It is welcome news.
I also share Senator Ryan's congratulations to Gráinne Seoige and all those who participated in the programme on Virgin Media. It is disturbing for any of us. When our images, as public representatives, are used and abused, it is a form of abuse. It is, as the Senator pointed out, a criminal activity. There can be no room in our society for that level of abuse and antisocial and criminal behaviour. It is not a joking matter. The laws of the land exist and must be enforced.
Senator Boyle is a great champion for Donegal and the coastal communities. It was no surprise for me to hear the Senator raise the issue again about the port licence. It is disappointing that his community is being left without a clear timeline at least. I support his call for clarity from the Department. I do not know whether he has already submitted a Commencement matter. If he has not, I suggest that he does and that we can get the Minister in, so that he can outline on the record of the House what the process is and what the timeline is. The Senator's community deserves that and it is important that there is clarity on that.
Senator Mullen raised the issue of funding for third level education. Education is the root for all of us. This Government and previous Governments placed a significant priority on the funding of education at all levels. At third level, no less than €5.3 billion has been allocated for 2027. By any estimate, €5.3 billion for third level education is a significant statement of commitment from the Government and the State. In this context, I join Senator Scahill in commending the Minister, Deputy Lawless, on the work he and the Department are doing. He has brought an energy and ambition to third level and higher education that is largely unprecedented. That is no disrespect to his predecessors, but he has real enthusiasm and ambition for it, as well as a real energy and drive behind it-----
Comment on this
All that may be true, but what was the point of the Funding the Future document if they were not going to honour it?
Comment on this
I think Senator Mullen will agree that the Minister, Deputy Lawless, and the Department are making unprecedented progress. That is not to say that they can sit on their laurels. They cannot. We have to ensure that there is sustainable funding and that the sector is sustained into the future. I suggest to the Leader that we arrange a debate with the Minister, Deputy Lawless, so that we can fully discuss and explore the progress that has been made, the challenges that exist and the actions he is taking to ensure we have a sustainable third level sector.
Senator Andrews raised the illegal operation of horse carriages in Dublin city. It is a serious issue, a serious road issue and a serious animal welfare issue. I have heard the Senator raise the issue before. It is primarily an issue for Dublin City Council and An Garda Síochána. There are laws in place. The laws need to be enforced. There are by-laws in place as well.
Senator Murphy O'Mahony drew the House's attention to the fact that this Saturday, 10 October, is World Mental Health Day. She very clearly said that it is okay to not be okay, and it is. It is human to not be okay. It is very human to struggle and suffer. We all do from time to time. When we are struggling and suffering, it is okay to say that. It is okay to say I am not okay today. It is good to ask how someone is doing. It only takes a few minutes to listen to somebody, but sometimes that can make the difference. Well done to her for reminding us of that.
Senator Flynn drew the House's attention to the fact there will be industrial action next week on Wednesday.
Senator Scahill spoke at length and in quite detail on the Garda vetting process. I agree with him. He has clearly had constituents come to him, like most of the rest of us have, with the same frustrations. There has to be scope there for better efficiencies. Again, I suggest a Commencement matter with the Minister. It would be a good way to tease that out. It will also put on the record the very practical and pragmatic suggestions he has made.
Senator McCarthy mentioned the value of greenways. They are great. He spoke about them particularly regarding Naas. Here in the city, greenways are fantastic. The Royal Canal comes through my community. It has become a running, walking, cycling and scootering highway all the way from Fingal right down to the Liffey. I agree with the Senator. Again, that is a matter for the local authority in terms of its proposals to Transport for Ireland and the NTA. I suggest that the matter be taken up with the local authority.
Senator Tully outlined the long waiting lists in Cavan-Monaghan for orthodontic treatment from the HSE. It certainly sounds like a suboptimal situation there where they have been recruiting a consultant orthodontist for four years. The positive news is that they have secured a consultant orthodontist. Her suggestion that they might need a second one seems a sensible one. I suggest that the Senator writes to the HSE regarding that matter.
Senator Flaherty raised Horse Sport Ireland issues. He outlined very serious issues around corporate governance, management and fiscal conduct at that organisation. I am sure the Senator will return to the matter. He might consider submitting a Commencement matter and inviting the Minister in to address and air these issues.
Senator Keogan raised the State's requirement to prosecute terrorism. She commended the State on its action in a successful recent prosecution. She reiterated the need for the State to not be complacent and to be ever vigilant. We live in very challenging geopolitical circumstances - largely unprecedented - considering the way the world has changed in such a short period. The Senator is right to suggest that the State needs to continue to be vigilant and ensure our citizens and State are protected. Matters of national security are of the utmost of priority for the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan. I am sure he would welcome the opportunity, if our schedule allows, for a debate on national security in this House.
Senator Conway mentioned Liscannor, which is a most beautiful part of the country. It has a world-class landscape there. It is very upsetting to hear of such antisocial behaviour with the lurcher dogs and the chasing of hares. From what the Senator described, it sounds like there may indeed be trespassing on private property involved there. If the matter has not already been raised with the community safety forum for Clare, I suggest that the Senator writes to the chair of the forum and ask that they put this item on the agenda for their next meeting. It is an issue, as the Senator rightly pointed out, that will require the engagement of the Garda, local authority, landowners and the local community. It certainly is a very serious issue. I thank the Senator for raising it.