Horse Sport Ireland examinership
Flaherty questioned whether Horse Sport Ireland disclosed its financial and PRSI difficulties when bidding for the equine breeding services contract. The Chair cautioned against discussing an ongoing court case; Flaherty said the examinership proceedings could be discussed.
We heard mention of the Horse Sport Ireland, HSI, examinership case in the High Court again this week. A barrister for the organisation explained that any survival plan during examinership for the body will be predicated on the agency retaining the €6.5 million-----
Comment on this
It is okay. It is an examinership case, so it is fine. The €6.5 million national equine breeding services tender was awarded earlier this year. If the agency's survival is dependent on this contract, we need to address a series of important questions. Earlier this year, HSI lost its appeal against the Department of Social Protection’s determination for €67,000 relating to PRSI. It failed to pay this by 31 May and missed a further deadline of 31 July. I need to know whether it made the Department of agriculture aware of this situation when it submitted the tender. The national equine breeding services tender process clearly stipulates that where the applicant is aware of such a breach, or the outstanding liability has not been paid or made subject to a binding agreement, exclusion from the tender process is mandatory. HSI has been under the protection of the examiner process since 24 August, and the tender process clearly provides for the exclusion of any applicant subject to insolvency or an arrangement with creditors.
Did HSI advise the Department at any stage that it was at risk of examinership, or did it wait until it had secured the €6.5 million contract before going into examinership? The tender process required turnover figures for 2023 through to 2025, as well as audited accounts for the last three years. HSI had no audited accounts for 2025. However, its own management accounts showed net liability in excess of €1 million at 31 December 2025, and negative net assets on 30 June 2026 of €364,000. HSI's own accounts have shown serious concerns - we now know that they are alarming concerns - from 2022 onwards. The management accounts dated 4 March 2026 showed that the cash had fallen from €1.8 million to €400,000. The tender process deadline of 15 May required HSI to confirm that it has met all its tax and social security liabilities. If it did not advise the Department of the outstanding €67,000 liability to social welfare, we have to ask why not. I have the height of respect for the staff working for HSI, but senior management has serious questions to answer in this case. I am under time restrictions, but I have many more questions relating to this organisation. I will be returning to them in due course.