We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Horse Sport Ireland examinership

Summary

The Senator said Horse Sport Ireland’s examinership must protect jobs without shielding senior management, and sought clarity on its survival plan and breeding-service tender.

The examinership of Horse Sport Ireland, HSI, continues. Understandably, there is widespread concern and worry within the sector. Any solution brought forward by the examiner must safeguard as many of the 47 jobs as possible. However, this process cannot be a get-out-of-jail card for senior management. What will inflame this valuable and important sector further will be a Government bailout for this agency. I said last week that any survival plan for the body was clearly predicated on the agency retaining the €6.5 million national equine breeding service tender. One week on, and nobody has been able to convince me that the timing of the examinership process was not stalled until after the award letter for the €6.5 million contract on 31 July 2026.

The Department of agriculture has significant questions to answer as regards the awarding of this contract. Was the Department aware that HSI had lost an appeal against the Department of Social Protection determination for €67,000 in relation to PRSI? The tender guidelines are very explicit. Where such a liability exists, and in the absence of a binding payment agreement, the exclusion from the tender process was mandatory. HSI has been under the protection of the courts and the examiners since August 2024. The tender process clearly provided for the exclusion of any applicants subject to insolvency or an arrangement with creditors. At any stage, did HSI advise the Department that it was at risk of examinership, or did it wait until it had secured the €6.5 million contract before going into examinership? Surely the Department could not have issued this tender if it had prior knowledge of the examinership plans. Also, we need to ask whether Horse Sport Ireland management reached out to the Department at any stage to request temporary funding to ease the cash flow situation, knowing that any such request would in fact be in breach of State funding rules.

The tender process also required turnover figures for 2023 through to 2025 and audited accounts for the last three years.

HSI has no audited accounts for 2025 and its net liability was in excess of €1 million at the end of December 2025. If audited accounts for 2025 were not available, why did the Department allow the tender process to proceed?

For the past four years, Members in both Houses have voiced concerns as to the efficiency and value of HSI. This examinership process offers a unique opportunity to press the restart button in the best interests of the staff, breeders and competitors. A bailout of Horse Sport Ireland may well be the easiest and most obvious solution for departmental officials, but it would not be in the best interest of the sector, nor would it be the best use of taxpayers' money.

I thank the Chair for indulging me.

Comment on this