An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business
- Order of Business 1 speech
The Leader set the sitting’s business, including a motion on arrangements and timed statements on the local democracy task force.
Garret Ahearn
- Waterford house fire tragedy 1 speech
The Senator expressed sympathy for the Waterford family and community affected by the fatal house fire and referred to the Lights of Hope campaign.
Fiona O'Loughlin
- Ballyheigue wastewater notice 1 speech
The Senator raised disruption caused by a do-not-consume notice affecting Ballyheigue and surrounding north Kerry communities.
Mike Kennelly
- Death of a homeless café regular 1 speech
The Senator mourned Daniel, a young friend and regular at the Lighthouse homeless café.
Aubrey McCarthy
- Garvaghy Road parade decision 1 speech
The Senator welcomed the decision to end the proposed parade on Garvaghy Road, saying the community felt relief after the delay.
Conor Murphy
- Debate on flooding and drainage 1 speech
The Senator called for a debate on flooding, river management and the legacy of the Arterial Drainage Act amid rising climate risks.
Malcolm Noonan
- Coco’s Law amendment scheduling 1 speech
The Senator proposed taking her bill to strengthen Coco’s Law before the first item and sought support for its introduction.
Eileen Flynn
- Dense breast awareness 1 speech
The Senator condemned the Waterford fire and highlighted breast cancer awareness, including concerns about dense breast tissue.
Alison Comyn
- Mental health stigma 4 speeches
The Senator praised Shine’s green ribbon campaign and urged efforts to reduce mental health stigma. Other Senators and the Cathaoirleach supported his message and stressed the value of speaking up and offering help.
Garret Kelleher, Senators, Maria Byrne, Mark Daly
- Justice for survivors of abuse 1 speech
The Senator supported Senator Flynn’s bill, expressed sympathy to Waterford, and welcomed George Gibney’s sentence as some measure of justice for survivors abused as children.
Tom Clonan
- Horse Sport Ireland examinership 1 speech
The Senator said Horse Sport Ireland’s examinership must protect jobs without shielding senior management, and sought clarity on its survival plan and breeding-service tender.
Joe Flaherty
- Assistive technology eligibility rules 1 speech
The Senator said a student obtained a needed laptop after intervention but questioned whether the assistive technology scheme’s eligibility rules have changed.
Linda Nelson Murray
- Children’s disability and mental health services 1 speech
The Senator called for a debate with the Minister on poor primary care, CDNT and CAMHS services, citing a parent’s difficulties obtaining an assessment.
Pauline Tully
- BreastCheck screening delays 1 speech
The Senator raised concern that more than 50,000 women are waiting beyond the target period for repeat BreastCheck screening.
Robbie Gallagher
- Tobacco and nicotine retail bill 4 speeches
The Senator proposed taking a bill regulating premises selling tobacco and nicotine products before the first item; the amendment was seconded, amid brief well wishes for the ill Minister.
Maria Byrne, Tom Clonan, Mark Daly, Linda Nelson Murray
- Public service strike 1 speech
The Senator blamed government delay and poor leadership for an impending strike by public servants, including nurses, teachers and local authority workers.
Gerard P. Craughwell
- Independent grocers’ financial pressures 1 speech
Citing an RGDATA survey, the Senator said only four in ten surveyed independent grocers expect to make a profit and called for urgent engagement with the sector.
Mary Fitzpatrick
- Next national sports policy 1 speech
The Senator thanked the Minister for attending a sports policy workshop and stressed the importance of preparing the next national sports policy.
Evanne Ní Chuilinn
- Household energy prices 1 speech
The Senator welcomed promised winter price freezes but argued the Government should act on energy costs given the State-owned ESB’s profits.
Sharon Keogan
- Captain Wafer Hall reopening 2 speeches
The Senator celebrated the reopening of Captain Wafer Hall in Enniscorthy after community-led restoration; the Cathaoirleach also welcomed visitors to the Gallery.
Cathal Byrne, Mark Daly
- St John’s Ambulance abuse survivors 3 speeches
The Senator supported calls for justice for St John’s Ambulance abuse survivors and criticised Noel Wynne’s apparent escape from justice. A brief congratulations to Ballinteer St John’s camogie team followed.
Chris Andrews, Tom Clonan
- Retail and hospitality workers’ concerns 1 speech
The Senator said retail and hospitality workers feel overlooked in public policy and that average-wage discussions fail to reflect their lower earnings.
Sarah O'Reilly
- Robert Pether’s return from Iraq 1 speech
The Senator welcomed Robert Pether’s return to his family after five years’ arbitrary detention in Iraq and acknowledged those who supported his release.
Gareth Scahill
- Rural electric vehicle charging 1 speech
The Senator cited a Garda vehicle running out of charge and idle electric buses as evidence of inadequate EV charging infrastructure, particularly in rural areas.
Paraic Brady
- Leader’s response to contributions 2 speeches
The Cathaoirleach invited the Leader to respond; the Leader acknowledged the Waterford tragedy and expressed hope for the Minister’s recovery.
Mark Daly, Garret Ahearn
- Order of Business amendments agreed 1 speech
The Cathaoirleach recorded agreement to the amendments moving the two bills ahead of the first item and welcomed a visitor and guests.
Mark Daly
The Order of Business is No. 1, motion regarding arrangements for the sitting of the House, to be taken on conclusion of the Order of Business, without debate; and No. 2, statements on the local democracy task force report and implementation plan, to be taken at 4 p.m. and to conclude at 6 p.m., if not previously concluded, with the opening contribution of the Minister not to exceed ten minutes, all Senators not to exceed five minutes and the Minister to be given no less than ten minutes to reply to the debate.
Comment on this
I start by extending our very deepest sympathies to the members of the community in Waterford who woke up to the awful news that Philip English, his partner, Kim, and two of their children had died in a fire at their home in Birchwood Estate. Two other children are fighting for their lives. Our thoughts and prayers are with them, the community, the first responders, the firemen, the gardaí and everybody who attended the scene. We are thinking of them all this afternoon.
As civic buildings are lit in purple this week for the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre's Lights of Hope campaign, we must mark a historic moment of vindication following the 15-and-a-half-year sentence handed down to George Gibney. This landmark conviction sends an unequivocal message that victims are believed, that shame rests solely with the perpetrator and that justice has no expiration date. I pay tribute to the awe-inspiring courage of survivors like Orla Poole, Chalkie White and Tric Kearney. For over 50 years, they and many others have carried a very heavy burden, yet their tireless pursuit of accountability has shattered decades of historical impunity. As these purple lights shine, let this House stand in absolute solidarity with them to ensure that no survivor is ever left to carry their trauma in the dark.
I also wish to raise a specific issue regarding St. Brigid's Primary School in Kildare town. The school has 1,031 pupils across three separate campuses in the town and serves a DEIS community. Despite its exceptional size and complexity, however, it receives the same administrative deputy principal provision as schools with almost half its enrolment. We have been seeking engagement with the Minister for education but have not had it. We want an exceptional interim staffing arrangement.
Also, I feel there should be a review - this is what I am calling for a debate on - in relation to leadership provision in exceptionally large primary schools. That is really important.
I know many of us got to read the excellent article in yesterday's Irish Independent about Edel Murray and her son Jack who has special needs and cannot get a school place. I have sat in Edel's kitchen, I have met Jack and I have seen first-hand how he really wants to go to school. To be fair, the Minister of State, Deputy Michael Moynihan, has rung Edel and spoken to her. We are all working to try to get a place for Jack. I believe the problem is in the long-term planning so we need a debate about the National Council for Special Education, NCSE, and how it does its planning based on the populations and areas it serves.
Comment on this
I offer my deepest sympathies to the English family and the community in Waterford this morning on that very disturbing news we all woke up to. We send our thoughts to the whole area.
I wish to raise an ongoing issue over the past ten days that is affecting the Ballyheigue wastewater treatment area and the surrounding communities in north Kerry. On 7 October, people got a "do not consume" notice, which has led to families, farms, businesses and community organisations facing significant disruption. The affected areas beyond Ballyheigue include the western catchment of the Clanmaurice group water scheme. It is out on the coast, on Kerry Head, and seemingly has been contaminated by seawater getting into the system. This is affecting 3,527 households this morning in a huge area that includes Cleandries, Dromnacarra, Ballinclemesig and Rathmorrel. In the Ballyheigue Community Centre area alone, there are 70 meals on wheels going out every day and the people there are surviving on the bare essentials.
Uisce Éireann has indicated the problem is linked to suspected contamination by saltwater ingress into the raw watercourse. While public health must always come first, the people of north Kerry deserve clear answers as to how this happened, why safeguards did not prevent it and, most importantly, when they can expect a full resolution. There is also growing concern among families. Many are asking what impact elevated salt levels may have on farm machinery, milking equipment, water pumps, storage systems, washing machines and showers. Everything is affected here. Unfortunately, there is no end in sight because of a communication obstacle put up by Uisce Éireann at this time. The information those affected are getting is not adequate. The issue is enormous.
I therefore call on the Minister with responsibility for Uisce Éireann, Deputy Browne, to intervene ASAP in this serious issue for the people of north Kerry to ensure Uisce Éireann provides regular public updates, a realistic estimated timeframe for restoring a safe drinking water supply, and clear guidance concerning any risks to household equipment, farm infrastructure and livestock operations. This is a serious issue. In the same locality, there was a boil water notice in the Ballyduff area six weeks ago so there is a sequence of events going on here as regards under-maintenance and undervalue of the finance and investment being put into this area. In another part of north Kerry, the Lixnaw-Finuge area, which is fed from the Uisce Éireann depot in Listowel, it is their third weekend without water. I am calling on the Minister to come to the House to debate this issue straight away and get Uisce Éireann to give a response to the people of north Kerry this afternoon as to what actually is going on. The last time seawater got introduced into a local water supply, it took 33 days to sort it out.
Comment on this
My heart also goes out to the people of Waterford because of the news we woke up to today, as my colleagues have mentioned. It is horrendous and I give condolences to all of the families involved.
I also want to send condolences to the family of a good friend of mine, Daniel. He used to come to our Lighthouse homeless café over the last number of years. Every day, Daniel would come along. He was in his 30s; he was a young guy.
I had a wonderful friendship with him, as did many of those involved in the soup runs on the street. He had the whole world ahead of him and was full of ambition and full of life. Unfortunately, he had an underlying alcohol problem and, behind his smile, we knew there were deeper issues. We were hoping over time that we would be able to help him with those. Unfortunately, last week he collapsed on the street from cardiac arrest. People thought he was sleeping, so they avoided him and walked by. Nobody rang 999 so Daniel suffered oxygen starvation to the brain. A decision was made at the weekend to turn off his life-support machine. I just want to mark him in this House and say he was an amazing man. He will be missed. I know that Colette and Gina from Mo Chara Homeless Support, those who do the Sharing is Caring soup run and all of us at the Light House will certainly miss Daniel.
Last year, 15,422 cases were treated for problem drug use in this country. That is up 73% since 2017. Treatment for cocaine alone has gone up by 336%. Today the Minister for Health, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, and the Minister of State, Deputy Murnane O'Connor, have launched the national drugs strategy. One thing I welcome is a health-led approach whereby somebody can be stopped and, instead of being penalised criminally, offered a connection with the health services. Eighty-seven percent of those who responded to the public consultation backed that approach.
I have worked in this area for 20 years and I have never met anybody who actually said he or she wanted to get into addiction. The Health Research Board states 60% of people in treatment are unemployed and almost one in eight is homeless. They are not people to be blamed. They are people who have to be offered a chance.
I welcome the increased funding in the drugs strategy for each task force. I am chair of the South Western Regional Drugs and Alcohol Task Force and the work that has been done on the ground all over Ireland by the different task forces. I ask the Leader to invite the Minister of State, Deputy Murnane O'Connor, to the House to tell us how many new treatment places the strategy will deliver. The health-led approach is good, but it is only as good as the door it opens. We need more treatment places. Drug addiction has grown exponentially, certainly over the last number of years. I have been involved in this for 20 years and have seen the waiting list grow exponentially.
Comment on this
I concur with the remarks of previous Senators on the tragic news from Waterford.
I was on Garvaghy Road last Friday evening when the announcement came through from the Secretary of State in relation to the ending of the parade. I have to say the overriding emotion was one of relief for people there that this prospect of a nightmare had been brought to an end. It was unfortunate that it took 13 days for the Secretary of State to come to the only conclusion that was possible after the very incomprehensible and reckless decision by the Parades Commission to approve a march down Garvaghy Road. The solution we had been suggesting from day one, which was to issue a ban on it, was not overly simplistic, as the Taoiseach had suggested. It was the only solution possible and that came through. We need to be clear, however, that this is not just about 35 men marching down a road. This was an idea that was conceived more than 18 months ago to reignite a conflict around the parade at Garvahy, and from Drumcree, by a rump of rejectionist unionists who are hell-bent on destroying power sharing and subverting the Good Friday Agreement.
The vast majority of parades in the North across any given year are unionist parades. Only a tiny number of them have any restrictions and an even smaller number have route restrictions placed on them. This is not about anti-Orange sentiment; this is about people who are trying to use the vehicle of the Orange Order in Portadown to subvert the peace process and the Good Friday Agreement. The only response for those of us who value the Good Friday Agreement and the progress was have made – there are people from all parties and all communities – was to face that down. Whatever the personal consequences for any of us from doing that, it was the correct stance to take, not just for peace in Portadown but also for peace right across the North and across the rest of the island, and for the progress that has been made.
One positive element – we always have to seek some positivity in these matters – was the evidently low level of support from within the unionist community for what people were trying to engineer at Garvaghy Road. More than 1,000 people from that tradition signed an open letter to the Orange Order imploring it to walk away from this situation and to de-escalate it. That sort of approach, in such a public fashion, would probably have been inconceivable ten years ago.
It demonstrates a strong desire from within that community to protect the progress that we have made and to build a better future for all of our children and our grandchildren.
Brendan McKenna's words at the end, when he stood beside us making his remarks to the media, were that this is not about victory, what we need to do now is move on to reconciliation and what we need to do is build reconciliation in this area of Portadown, but also across the North, with communities. That is the work. That is the challenge for all of us but a positive that we can take from it is that the vast majority of the community across the political spectrum are on the same script. We want to see a better future, we want to see peace between people, we want to see respect, tolerance and equality, and we want the space to create a better future for all of our children.
Comment on this
The Arterial Drainage Act 1945 was of its time. It was largely a labour activation measure that was introduced then and it had a significant impact on watercourses across the country since that time. Since then, we have had many challenges in relation to water management and management of our rivers and heavily modified water bodies, and the significant damage caused to our waterways, which has led in some cases to flooding in many areas. We now have increased risks around climate change and communities impacted by flooding. It would be timely to have a debate in this House on flooding more broadly, but also on a commitment that had been put into the 2024 Water Action Plan to review the Arterial Drainage Act. It would be useful, perhaps, if the Minister of State, Deputy Moran, were to come to the House and have a debate at this time of the season because as we head into the winter, there is no doubt that flooding events will happen and rainfall events will create challenges in terms of inundating communities. So much has happened since that time. We have had the birds and habitats directives, the water framework directive and now we have a nature restoration plan. It would be important, first, to ascertain where we are, with the interrelatedness of these plans and with phase 2 of the land use review, as to how it all fits in with an Act that was brought in in 1945, and now is not fit for purpose and requires a significant review in the lifetime of the Government.
Comment on this
I propose an amendment to the Order of Business, namely that No. 11, the Harassment, Harmful Communications and Related Offences (Amendment) (No. 3) Bill 2026, be taken before No. 1. I am asking the House to allow me to introduce this important and urgently needed legislation. I am asking Members to support an important urgent strengthening of Coco's Law and I look forward to discussing my Bill in-depth next week.
Comment on this
I also roundly condemn what happened in Waterford. What appears to have been an arson attack, which is being investigated as such, has claimed the lives of Philip English, his partner, Kim, their two children and, of course, has left two children fighting for their lives. It is deeply shocking to the entire community and I hope whoever has carried this out will be brought to justice as soon as possible.
Senators will see, perhaps from my pink attire, that it is October, which is Breast Cancer Awareness Month. I have just come from a presentation on dense breast - the issue that women who have dense breast tissue have in finding out whether they have got cancer or not. A debate is urgently needed the Chamber on the necessity to tell women at mammogram stage whether they have dense breast tissue because that can mask incidents of breast cancer. Lobular breast cancer Ireland has just informed me of some really shocking statistics from a study carried out in the United States. Some 43% of women in this study had dense breast tissue and up to 50% of diagnoses could have been missed. I thank the women who came in who told their stories of, unfortunately, missed diagnoses.
I am somebody who likes to think they religiously go and get their mammogram when it is needed. We do get a letter, thankfully, in some cases, saying that we have not got a diagnosis. What we might not know is that the knowledge is there at that stage that we have dense breast tissue and it may be masking something else. We really need to find out at that stage. I think there is a duty for a woman to be told, and sometimes a man as well, that this result may not necessarily be the actual result. Let us bring in the Minister for Health or any Minister of State who can assist with this. We need to have a clear timetable for when this can take place. This group has been asking since 2016, for ten years. We do not know how many lives have been lost because of that. I certainly would like to see no further loss of life because of this issue.
Comment on this
I wish to discuss the topic of World Mental Health Day, which was raised on Thursday's Order of Business by our colleague, Senator Murphy O'Mahony. I would like to pay particular tribute to the Shine mental health support and advocacy group, which does tremendous work through its green ribbon campaign in destigmatising mental health. Shine's campaign tells us that the stigma associated with mental health leads to discrimination, social exclusion and lack of support, all of which can exacerbate mental health challenges. It is our shared responsibility to destigmatise mental health and to foster a more compassionate and supportive society. I remember being a young boy in Ovens National School in the 1980s. Our teacher, a man by the name of Donnchadh Ó Loinsigh, used to refer to how mental health was discussed in euphemistic terms. I remember one term that he used to describe somebody in our area in mid-Cork who might have been in need of mental health. It was: "Tá sé i gCill Airne". That was sufficient for everybody to know that this particular individual was engaging with the services. I remember him on one occasion telling us about a man from Baile Bhuirne who emigrated to London and had difficulty with mental health. That was described as: "Tá sé i gCill Airne i Londain." The whole topic was avoided. It was not spoken about. There was no compassion or support.
A Threoraí, it gives me no pleasure at all to say it but I will say it nonetheless that, on one occasion, I picked up the phone and dialled 116123, the number for the Samaritans, and got enormous help from a volunteer in relation to an issue that I was having. That, combined with support from family and friends, helped me to realise that what I then thought was an issue that might have been close to insurmountable was not as big an issue as I had thought. I would like to give credit to the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, for the tremendous work she does. While acknowledging the fact that Ireland has become a far more inclusive, tolerant and supportive society since the days I was in primary school when we were talking about mental health in euphemistic terms, we cannot pat ourselves on the back and congratulate ourselves on getting so far. The whole process of destigmatising mental health is an ongoing work in progress. Only by enabling and empowering people to come out and speak about difficulties that they have, and to be comfortable doing so, will we be doing them justice.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Kelleher for sharing his story. As he said, it is important that people talk about it, which gives others the power to talk about it as well. His doing that helps to raise people's eyes to look at other people and say that they need help. That is the important part of it. That simple phone call that people like the Senator and others have made can often be transformative and life changing, in making sure that they get the help that they need.
Comment on this
I begin by seconding the introduction of Senator Flynn's Bill.
I express my sympathies and deep regret to the people of Waterford and that family and their neighbours and friends on an appalling tragedy.
Yesterday, George Gibney, formerly of Swim Ireland, was sentenced to 15 and a half years in prison for abusing up to 37 children, between the ages of eight and 13, over a prolonged period. Eventually, after 33 years of waiting, the survivors at least got some measure of justice. I want to quote Senator O'Loughlin, who said, "Nobody should have to walk in the dark like that and carry that burden." In that spirit, I want to mention a very good friend of mine, Mick Finnegan, who has been an advocate for survivors of sexual abuse at St. John Ambulance. As a young boy, Mick reported his abuse by a senior officer in St. John Ambulance to An Garda Síochána in 1999 and it was reported to Tusla. Tusla adjudicated that the complaint was founded, but no prosecution was entered into. Fast forward to 2023 and Dr. Geoffrey Shannon's report shows that St. John Ambulance was a place that facilitated the grooming of children and vulnerable young adults. It is interesting that in the period from 2003 to 2023 on the Courts Service of Ireland's online portal - it is published and publicly available for everybody to view - one can see the survivors of the sexual abuse scandal in St. John Ambulance. They take case after case against St. John Ambulance and against other named co-defendants like Noel Wynne and John Hughes. Over 20 years, they struggled to get answers to their questions. On last Tuesday, 6 October, the group of survivors was told in the Central Criminal Court that no criminal proceedings would issue in the case of Noel Wynne; that he would face no criminal investigation. This is an absolute scandal. This Chamber voted for a public inquiry into the sexual abuse in St. John Ambulance. I am asking that this be progressed. Finally, Orla Poole, one of the survivors of George Gibney's abuse, said, "You know now that you don't have to carry the burden of this abuse." I would say to the survivors of the St. John Ambulance abuse - notwithstanding a failure to criminally prosecute Noel Wynne - you do not have to carry the burden of this appalling injustice any more.
Comment on this
The examinership of Horse Sport Ireland, HSI, continues. Understandably, there is widespread concern and worry within the sector. Any solution brought forward by the examiner must safeguard as many of the 47 jobs as possible. However, this process cannot be a get-out-of-jail card for senior management. What will inflame this valuable and important sector further will be a Government bailout for this agency. I said last week that any survival plan for the body was clearly predicated on the agency retaining the €6.5 million national equine breeding service tender. One week on, and nobody has been able to convince me that the timing of the examinership process was not stalled until after the award letter for the €6.5 million contract on 31 July 2026.
The Department of agriculture has significant questions to answer as regards the awarding of this contract. Was the Department aware that HSI had lost an appeal against the Department of Social Protection determination for €67,000 in relation to PRSI? The tender guidelines are very explicit. Where such a liability exists, and in the absence of a binding payment agreement, the exclusion from the tender process was mandatory. HSI has been under the protection of the courts and the examiners since August 2024. The tender process clearly provided for the exclusion of any applicants subject to insolvency or an arrangement with creditors. At any stage, did HSI advise the Department that it was at risk of examinership, or did it wait until it had secured the €6.5 million contract before going into examinership? Surely the Department could not have issued this tender if it had prior knowledge of the examinership plans. Also, we need to ask whether Horse Sport Ireland management reached out to the Department at any stage to request temporary funding to ease the cash flow situation, knowing that any such request would in fact be in breach of State funding rules.
The tender process also required turnover figures for 2023 through to 2025 and audited accounts for the last three years.
HSI has no audited accounts for 2025 and its net liability was in excess of €1 million at the end of December 2025. If audited accounts for 2025 were not available, why did the Department allow the tender process to proceed?
For the past four years, Members in both Houses have voiced concerns as to the efficiency and value of HSI. This examinership process offers a unique opportunity to press the restart button in the best interests of the staff, breeders and competitors. A bailout of Horse Sport Ireland may well be the easiest and most obvious solution for departmental officials, but it would not be in the best interest of the sector, nor would it be the best use of taxpayers' money.
I thank the Chair for indulging me.
Comment on this
A few months ago, I raised the assistive technology scheme. At the time, I mentioned a mother who had come to me about her little daughter, who had dyslexia and needed to get a laptop in school. She had an IQ of 89 and the rules around getting assistive technology are that you must have an IQ of 90. It was a crazy situation. I tabled a Commencement matter and the Minister of State, Deputy Michael Moynihan, was here for that. He and the National Council for Special Education, NCSE, were very helpful and we were able to get that laptop for that girl.
We were assured at the time that the new circular on assistive technology would be out in September, get rid of a lot of those strict rules and put the decision-making on the school as opposed to the special educational needs organiser, SENO, or the NCSE, with the school deciding who it thought would benefit from getting the laptops and assistive technology. However, we have not seen that yet.
A mother wrote to me yesterday about her daughter. Again, this girl did not score correctly to get it. The mother has been fighting for a laptop for two years. Parents of children with dyslexia do not need to be fighting for two years to try to allow their children to learn in a classroom like their peers. They need to be able to get their laptops and move on with it. I ask that the Leader write to the Minister of State and ask where we are on the circular and the scheme that were supposed to be out in September. We are in the middle of October now. The circular would be so beneficial. I had hoped that we would have it for the start of this school term. Let us hope we can have it for the start of January, because these kids cannot wait.
Comment on this
I want to raise the issue of children's services again and reiterate my call for a debate in the House with the Minister for children and disability around the very poor service being provided by primary care, by children's disability network teams, CDNTs, and by child and adolescent mental health services, CAMHS. A mother contacted me during the week telling me that she had left it for a few days because she was so annoyed and frustrated with the way she was being treated by primary care. One of her children was on the list for primary care. It had referred her for an assessment of need but then removed her from the list for absolutely no reason before that assessment was completed, which makes no sense. Now, the mother is trying to fight to get her child back on that list.
What annoyed her more was that her younger son then got an appointment for speech and language therapy, but before the appointment would be honoured, she would have to undergo a two-hour training course for parents or else the appointment would be cancelled and the child would be discharged from the service. She said that any parent would do whatever they needed to do to support their child, but the child needs this therapy. As she said, there are parents who have more than one child with additional needs, have already undergone this course and know exactly what is on it, yet they are forced to undergo the course again regardless.
No account is taken of childcare needs. If you have a child with additional needs, it is not always easy to get someone to mind them if you have to go to undertake a course, especially if you are a single parent. A child with additional needs will not take to everybody and not everybody will be confident in minding that child either. I often find that the CDNT or primary care organises meetings or training during school holidays when the parent definitely does not have any care for their child because the child is out of school.
I want to discuss all of these issues with the Minister. We need to come up with a better way of looking at how we provide services to our children. It is not a box-ticking exercise where a letter, a training course or a phone call to a parent is taken as an actual intervention. It is not an intervention. It is necessary, but it is not an intervention, and we need to see more interventions with the children face to face.
Comment on this
Today, BreastCheck is a very important service. In fact, it is a vital service. Early detection of breast cancer can make a significant difference to both treatment and outcomes.
That is why I was deeply concerned about statistics released in response to a parliamentary question from our colleague, Deputy Pádraig O'Sullivan, in the Lower House. Over 50,000 women are waiting longer than their prescribed targeted period for repeat screening. It is deeply concerning because behind every one of those statistics is a woman and a family, and, potentially, a life depending on early detection.
I appreciate that there has been a significant increase in the eligible cohort entitled to this screening. It is up 19%. Having said that, it is deeply concerning that the delay here is due to the fact that there are a lot of vacancies yet to be filled. This is why I ask that the Minister expedite the filling of those vacancies urgently. The last thing we need is to have women concerned and fretting about not being called back for a repeat screening. Additionally, it is important that any woman out there who has any concerns should be free to contact BreastCheck and get her concerns addressed. Ultimately, this is a matter of life and death. I ask the Leader to contact the Minister for Health to mark it as urgent that all those vacancies be filled as soon as possible.
Comment on this
I propose an amendment to the Order of Business, "That No. 10 be taken before No. 1". I am referring to the Public Health (Tobacco Products and Nicotine Inhaling Products) (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill 2026. The Bill is entitled, "an Act to regulate, in the public interest, the number of premises in the State that are being used for the purpose of the sale by retail of tobacco products or nicotine inhaling products, for that purpose to amend the Public Health (Tobacco Products and Nicotine Inhaling Products) Act 2023 and to provide for related matters".
I note as well that the Minister, Deputy Patrick O'Donovan, took ill during the EU Presidency debate in Limerick and has been moved to hospital by ambulance. I think it would be appropriate for this House to wish him all the best with his recovery.
Comment on this
I and, I am sure, all of us here, join the Senator in wishing the Minister the best in making a speedy recovery.
Comment on this
I second the proposed amendment.
Comment on this
Tomorrow's strike did not have to happen. Hundreds of thousands of public servants will walk out tomorrow, including nurses, teachers, civil servants and local authority workers. The people who keep this country running will stop work. Let us be clear that this strike did not fall from the sky. It was manufactured by delay, dithering and a failure of leadership at the Department of public expenditure. It had the money and the mandate and it had months to prepare. The previous pay agreement expired in June. Yet when autumn arrived, there was still no credible successor deal on the table. There was no clear offer, no real sequencing and no confidence that the Government would put the workers' pay first.
What did unions get instead? They got a lecture about affordability, productivity and fiscal responsibility from a Department that set a €1.2 billion pay allocation while the clock ran down. This is not negotiation; it is stalling. Public workers are not asking for the moon. They are asking to keep pace with the cost of living. They are asking for respect after years of carrying the State through crisis after crisis. Instead, they were treated as a line item to be managed and not as the people who staff our hospitals, teach our children and deliver every public service this Government claims to value.
Let no Minister stand up this week and say the strike is unnecessary. It was unnecessary, but it became inevitable because the Department of public expenditure failed to do the basic work of government: to talk early, negotiate honestly and offer a framework workers could believe in. This is not about one day of action.
It is about a breakdown of trust, and 300,000 workers concluded that their employer will only move under pressure. That is political failure. It sits squarely within the Department responsible for public expenditure. The Government can still avoid this. It can come to the table with a real offer, real urgency and real respect, but it must stop pretending that the crisis appeared from nowhere. It did not. It was caused by hesitation, deepened by delay and will only be resolved by DPER. Both Houses of the Oireachtas close tomorrow. That is unprecedented in the history of this country. We should be here holding Government to account. I fully respect those who want to be on the street with workers. They should do that, but we should be here holding Government to account and not closing the Houses of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Last week, Government announced its budget for 2027 and we had debates on the issue. Today, I want to return to the subject on behalf of RGDATA. The Leader will be aware that it nominated me to contest the Seanad election and represents more than 3,000 independent, largely family-owned, food-based groceries. There are RGDATA members in every town and village. It recently carried out a survey that indicated that only four in ten of its members surveyed expect to make a profit this year. The Leader will not be surprised that it is calling for the Minister for enterprise to urgently reconvene the cost of doing business forum, a call I want to support. It is essential that the forum is reconvened as soon as possible by the Minister.
Independent retailers around the country are struggling with increased energy costs, increased insurance costs and next year will face an increased minimum wage bill, which equates to over €1,700 per year for each employee. It is utterly unrealistic of the Minister or anybody else to expect independent family-owned businesses to continue to absorb costs like this, not make a profit and stay in business. That is not going to happen. I would appreciate if the Leader could contact the Minister and express to him the need for an urgent reconvening of the cost of business forum. I ask him to ask the Minister to come to the House to update us on the actions he is taking to address the out-of-control cost of doing business.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister, Deputy Patrick O'Donovan, for his involvement in my sports policy workshop last Saturday in Kilmainham, Dublin. Since I came to the Chamber, I have learned he has taken ill in Limerick. I want to express my concern and hope that he recovers well. He had a busy week last week and I was very grateful that he got into his car first thing Saturday morning and came to Dublin to speak at a policy workshop I held ahead of the drafting of the next national sport policy.
This is an important policy. We have only ever had one sports policy, which has lasted ten years and will finish next year. Given that the sports landscape has changed so drastically in the past 15 years, it is important that we get the next one right and get it as right as we got the first one, because it was a very good policy. There were 47 actions and only five saw no movement. The policy has been transformative for the sports sector. The next national sports policy needs to improve on a couple of areas, such as inclusion in sport, safeguarding, what it means to be involved in Irish sport and the definition of Irish sport. We need to ask whether we are doing outreach and reaching all of the different communities in the country. These are things that came up at the meeting on Saturday. The meeting included members of Sporting Pride. We spoke about going into the Travelling community, ethnic minorities and, of course, women. The next national sports policy is an important piece of work. I am grateful to all of the CEOs, and the Minister, who came to the policy event I held on Saturday. I encourage all Senators to take part in the process because there will be ongoing consultation. It is important that Senators speak to their family members and anybody involved in sport about what they want to see in the next national sports policy. It is their policy as much as it is the sector's policy.
Comment on this
I welcome the news that Prepay Power and Electric Ireland have promised a winter price freeze. This will benefit 1.5 million households across the Republic and I commend them for providing certainty. Let us be entirely honest: private companies are stepping in with temporary fixes because the Government has completely failed to act. The simple fact is the State owns the ESB. It is not a passive bystander. The Government is the sole shareholder of a utility infrastructure that recorded a staggering €377 million in after-tax profits in just the first six months of this year. The claim hands are tied by retail market rules is a convenient political fiction. If the State wants to alleviate the crisis, it must take direct action at the source.
As the majority owner, the Government could mandate the ESB to slash its wholesale generation margins to a strict cost recovery baseline for the winter. Instead, the State absorbs hundreds of millions of euro in State dividends, a portion of which is then inefficiently redistributed back to the consumers in the forms of credits and subsidies. I do not necessarily support radical State interventionism but in this case, the Government's control of the ESB ought to be used for the benefit of the public.
I again raise the issue of Escort Ireland and the open operation of prostitution in this country. As I have said before, it is absurd this open mockery of our laws is tolerated. In my home county of Meath, open reporting shows that 12 women, mainly from Brazil and Romania, and most of whom we can assume have been trafficked, are advertised at any time. This equate to over 100 offences a day. This in turn means that brothels and pimps are making tens of thousands of euro every single week, yet only one offence was recorded by the Garda over 90 days. I urge the Leader to call for the Minister for justice to come before the House to discuss this issue.
Comment on this
I join with colleagues in sending best wishes to the Minister, Deputy Patrick O'Donovan. I will speak for a moment about an event I attended yesterday morning in Templeshannon, Enniscorthy. That was the reopening of the Captain Wafer Hall. Captain Wafer has such a strong historical connection to Enniscorthy and it is fantastic to see a building that bears his name being brought back into use off the back of quite a substantial amount of work done by a local community group, namely, the Enniscorthy Community Alliance. There is a real lesson for all of us in this Chamber and that is how important it is to support community groups that want to take a disused, old community building and bring it back into use.
In this case, the group received grant funding of €100,000 from the community recognition fund. Given that fund has concluded, it is important that something similar, which would enable projects like Captain Wafer Hall, be extended and rolled out throughout the country. There were quite a lot of people at the opening, given the fact it used to be a community centre. For quite a while, it was a dance hall and there were couples who had originally met there back in that building. It was then turned into a social protection office unit and then lay dormant for quite a while. It is right in the heart of the Templeshannon side of Enniscorthy. I encourage the Leader to take it up with the Minister for community and rural development that a similar grant scheme be made available for 2027.
Comment on this
I welcome guests of the Leas-Chathaoirleach to the Visitors Gallery. They are retired staff of Limerick City and County Council. They are most welcome to Seanad Éireann and I am sure they will enjoy the rest of their day and evening in Leinster House.
Comment on this
I wish the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, a speedy recovery. I also agree with Senator Clonan. The survivors of abuse in the St. John's Ambulance have walked in the darkness for long enough and it must be really upsetting and difficult for them to watch Noel Wynne to walk away from justice.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Clonan on that.
On a more positive note, I congratulate Ballinteer St. John's on winning the Dublin camogie club championship final on Friday night. It was a fantastic final against Good Counsel, and they both played with huge pride and no little skill. They would not be there if it was not for the sacrifices, commitment and hard work they put in over the years. It was great to see both under 11s teams playing there as well at half time. I acknowledge the work of Dublin camogie, which set up that final in Parnell Park. Neither team would have reached the final and none of this would have happened if it had not been for the mentors and volunteers who put in incredible work not just this year but over generations. Many of the girls have been playing in Ballinteer St. John's since they were six years of age and they have developed as players and people. It is great to see. Friday night was the culmination of those years playing camogie and being part of your tribe. This would not have happened without volunteers like Shane Adderly; Peter O'Shea; Malcolm Dalton; Brian O'Rourke, the physio; Adam Kelly, the strength and conditioning coach; Eoin Moran; Louise Kellegher; and Lorna Doran. None of this would have happened without all these people and the volunteers in the club itself committing to camogie and the players who have made sacrifices for many years. It was great to see them crowned as Dublin senior camogie champions.
Comment on this
I want to follow on from Senator Fitzpatrick, as I am still stuck on the budget. Today, I want to speak about the people working in retail and hospitality who have contacted me since the budget. They feel ignored, unseen and like they do not exist when it comes to public policies. We see this - perhaps unintentionally - in media broadcasts like "The Tonight Show" on Newstalk when people consistently talk about the average industrial wage being €54,000 to €56,000. That is out of touch with the people who have contacted me, as they do not earn even close to that. People who work in areas like retail and hospitality are caught in a real poverty trap. Some 1.5 million people in this country earn less than €44,000. Increasing the 40% tax band is welcome, but it does little for those who do not even reach it or come near it. The majority of people I know who are earning €25,000 to €30,000, or less, do not come within an ass's roar of the higher threshold. It is as if there is a belief that no one in this society earns under €55,000, when the complete opposite is true. There are people working very hard day in, day out who cannot catch a break at all. They are trying to manage rent, energy bills and groceries while taking home less than €500 per week. People understand paying tax for public services, but those services are so stretched and understaffed that they wonder what they are paying for. Most of these people do not qualify for medical cards, housing support or SUSI. There is a deep feeling of inequality and unfairness, and it seems that those people who need support most were more or less invisible during the budget.
Comment on this
Today I wish to mention the plight of Robert Pether from Elphin in County Roscommon. I warmly welcome him home and to his family yesterday after five long years of an unimaginable ordeal. Mr. Pether, an Australian engineer, was detained in Iraq in April 2021 following a contractual dispute involving his employers and the Iraqi Central Bank. His detention was subsequently deemed arbitrary and contrary to international law by the United Nations. Throughout those five years his wife, Desree, and her children endured extraordinary uncertainty and hardship. I acknowledge the efforts of former Senator Eugene Murphy, who raised their plight in this House on numerous occasions. I believe Senator Noonan might have been one of the last people to respond to him in that regard.
He pressed previous Ministers for foreign affairs, including Simon Coveney. He continually raised it with the Taoiseach of the time, Micheál Martin, to secure Mr. Pether's release. Deputy Kerrane also raised this on numerous occasions in the Dáil, while local representatives, such as Councillor Valerie Byrne in Elphin, kept the family's plight to the fore. I acknowledge the current Minister for foreign affairs, Deputy McEntee, and officials in her Department for their diplomatic efforts, alongside their international counterparts, to finally bring Mr. Pether home yesterday. Above all, I recognise the extraordinary determination of Ms Desree Pether and her family who never gave up hope. After five years apart, Mr. Pether is finally home where he belongs with his family. I wish them every happiness as they begin to rebuild their lives together.
Also, a road traffic incident took place in Castlerea, County Roscommon on Sunday night in which, unfortunately, a lady who was well known and well respected in Castlerea lost her life. I am doing once again what many other Senators have done in the past, highlighting the need for people to be vigilant and visible, to take their time at this time of year and to be aware of people on the roads.
Comment on this
I raise an issue in the Mayo and Roscommon-Longford Garda division. A garda had to attend an emergency last week and had to abandon his car to hitch a lift to it. He was driving an electric vehicle, EV, which did not have enough charge to get him there and back. It shows again that the services must be put into rural Ireland, especially for renewable energy. A number of electric buses are parked in Athlone and there are no EV chargers set up for them. They are in storage. I would like to get an update on where we are with services for EV chargers going into areas, especially in rural Ireland, where people do not know what mileage they will do on a daily basis. We certainly need an answer from the Minister. He could perhaps address this and say what kind of funding will go into the Mayo and Roscommon-Longford division.
Comment on this
I am conscious we are out of time so I will be as brief as I can.
I acknowledge all the contributions of Senators about the tragedy in Waterford. I read, before I came in, that a Garda criminal investigation is happening. Let us wait to see what happens. In any case, it is an awful tragedy to see four people, in particular two children, lose their lives and two other children fighting for their lives. This morning is a difficult time for people in Waterford.
As a few people said, the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, was taken ill a few hours ago. We hope he is well in hospital and is being taken care of. Deputy O'Donovan has a wife, Eileen, and three young boys. We can all empathise. This job is stressful at the best of times. I have no doubt Deputy O'Donovan will come back strong and healthy and do what he always does, which is work hard for his community.
Senator O'Loughlin spoke about the lights of hope campaign and the sentence that was handed down to George Gibney, which is long overdue. I acknowledge the bravery Orla Poole has shown in recent years.
She also spoke about St. Brigid's Primary School. It is an ongoing issue in several primary schools that no leadership provision is put in place for large primary schools in particular, compared with much smaller primary schools. I will speak to the Minister about that.
Senator Kennelly spoke about Ballyheigue water treatment plant. I am delighted he brought it up because I sympathise with him massively on this. My area of Tipperary is now on a do not consume notice, like Kerry. I have never seen a do not consume notice in my area, Ardfinnan. The Senator outlined exactly what it means for people, that they cannot consume water in any way. They cannot brush their teeth with the water.
We are going upstairs every evening at the moment with a little jug of water for Jamie and Daniel in order that they can brush their teeth. The problem, as the Senator outlined, is that no realistic timeframe has been put forward. People are just told they have to manage. Tanks are put in villages to support people. There is a facility, which we have used in the past number of days, to support vulnerable people who live on their own, especially elderly people, to register to receive water at their homes. All that is okay, but this never happened when water services were the responsibility of the council. I did not know that there was a do not consume notice in Kerry pretty much the same week that we in Tipperary had one for the first time ever. This is wholly unacceptable. People seem to think that it is only going to last a day or two, but I have been informed it will be a good number of weeks for the Ardfinnan plant to resume operations and that they may be a need for a boil water notice. That is incredibly difficult for schools in particular to deal with. I will talk to the Minister, Deputy Browne. He should come to the Chamber. I assumed it was only my area in Tipperary that had a do not consume notice. I will make sure that the Minister tries to make himself available as a matter of urgency. When people say that it will be a couple of weeks, we in politics know how long what is happening could actually go on for. We do not want it to go on until Christmas.
Senator McCarthy spoke about Daniel, a very good friend of his who was in his 30s and who passed away last week. He collapsed and passed away, unfortunately. The Senator gave a really good account of what a decent man he was, despite living with challenges in his life. Obviously, Senator McCarthy and the people who work with him did good work to try to support that man. In the wider context, the Senator referred to drugs and the fact that drug use has increased. We had a drugs committee that produced a report. In fairness, Senator Ruane asked for a debate on that report before the summer recess. I said at the time that I would be happy to facilitate such a debate. That remains the case, because it is an important debate to have in this House.
Senator Murphy spoke about the Garvaghy Road. That matter has been raised in the House a number of times. We might have an opportunity at some point to have a full debate on it rather than discussing it on the Order of Business. Considering that decisions have been made and some form of peace has been restored, there is an opportunity in that regard. However, we need to have a debate about the future of Northern Ireland and about what we all want to see, which is a united Ireland. We need to learn from the past two weeks and what has happened.
Senator Noonan spoke about the Arterial Drainage Act 1945 and requested a debate on flooding with the Minister of State, Deputy Moran. It is a good idea to have a debate on flooding before flooding happens. The Minister of State has a significant amount of money available in his Department to try to manage floods that happen across the country. I will speak to him on Senator Noonan's behalf in the context of having a debate on that matter.
Senator Flynn proposed an amendment to the Order of Business. I am happy to agree to that proposal in the context of strengthening Coco's Law. We will have an opportunity to discuss that when it comes before the House.
Senator Comyn spoke about breast density. It is very important to discuss that matter. I will see if the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, can come in. We have had real success in the past 20 or 30 years. I spoke in this Chamber last week, when Senator Scahill raised this matter, about my mother, who passed from breast cancer 26 years ago. If she were alive now, she would not be in danger of passing. That is because of the success of various Governments over the past 20 to 30 years. Checking breast density provides a really good opportunity for early detection of breast cancer in women and men. As the Senator said, there are 30 or 40 men a year who contract the disease. Early detection is key to everything so let us try to have a debate on that.
Senator Kelleher spoke about World Mental Health Day. The Senator and I have spoken privately about this matter. I do not think we have spoken in this Chamber about it, but people like him who are able to give accounts of their personal experiences encourage others to stand up and do it. I commend him on that because it is not an easy thing to do. When you speak with emotion and from experience in here, whatever side of the House you are on, people sit up and listen. Senator Kelleher spoke about the green ribbon campaign. As he knows, my younger brother Scott was one of the founders of the see change green ribbon campaign after leaving college. He is so proud of it and of how far it has come.
There has been so much work done in Shine to encourage people to do exactly what the Senator did today, which was to have the courage to stand up and speak and encourage other people to do it. I commend the Senator massively on it and we will try our best to have a debate on that.
Senator Clonan spoke about the sentencing of George Gibney to 15 years and how up to 37 victims suffered at his hands. Justice prevailed, which is welcome, but it would be much better if justice had prevailed a long time ago.
The Senator spoke about Mike Finnegan. The former Leader, Regina Doherty, did an awful lot of work with Mike at the time and that is what ignited the pursuit to have a public inquiry. I will follow up with Regina Doherty MEP on it and see where that is at the moment. She spoke numerous times in this Chamber about Mike and his courage to speak out against an organisation that went against him in what he was doing. I will do that for the Senator.
Senator Joe Flaherty spoke again about Horse Sport Ireland. He has raised this issue a number of times. There is an examinership at the moment. We want to protect jobs as best we can but that is a matter for the examiner to do rather than this House. However, I acknowledge the contribution made by the Senator.
Senator Nelson Murray spoke about the assistive technology scheme. She gave a very good example of a school where one child was one number below the IQ level of 90 to qualify, but as the Senator does, she managed to find a way around that. However, it brings into discussion the new regulations and changes because now a school can make the decision instead of the SENO. As the Senator requested, I will contact the Minister of State to see when that will be done. One would have thought this could have been done by the start of the school year but I will talk to the Minister of State about it.
Senator Tully spoke about the assessment of need and primary care. Obviously, there is a real challenge in terms of the number of people awaiting assessments of need. An awful lot of money has been put in place over the last number of years in relation to Cara's fund, which is named after Cara Darmody from Tipperary. Last year, €20 million was allocated. In the budget last week, another €20 million was allocated to the fund. That is an improvement, but in terms of the number of people who need assessment, the funding needs to improve even further, so I take the Senator's comments on board.
Senator Gallagher also spoke about BreastCheck and to the Minister filling vital vacancies so that people could get breast checks. As I said to Senator Comyn, I will try to arrange a debate with the Minister in the near future.
Senator Maria Byrne spoke about the proposed amendment, with which I am happy to agree. It is good legislation that she is looking to bring forward. Her party and I are fully behind the Senator in terms of bringing that forward and I have no doubt that we will have an opportunity in the next number of weeks to tease through the legislation and discuss it as a House.
Senator Craughwell spoke about the industrial strike by public sector workers. As a Government, we want to see an agreement reached. We have had many negotiations over a long number of years while Fine Gael has been in government. They have been healthy negotiations. I have seen massive improvements in the public sector, and I have seen improvements in and restoration of pay. We can only reach an agreement when people are talking to one another. That is why the Minister, Jack Chambers, issued a final request for people to come and actually talk, with pay being the central theme of that discussion. All I ask is that union representatives come and talk as soon as possible. It seems, at this late stage, that the day of action will take place tomorrow. That has an impact on this House. This House will be closed, which is, as the Senator said, unprecedented. I am not sure whether he asked me if we should be sitting. I do not disagree with him and believe that we should be sitting. I put forward a schedule of three sitting days. It is up to the Leader of the Seanad to decide the schedule. I decided the schedule but, unfortunately, the House is unable to facilitate the schedule. Next week, I will put forward a full schedule for three days. It is up to the House to be able to facilitate that schedule, but let us see where we are. I hope that, by next week, we will be able to come to a decision.
Senator Fitzpatrick spoke about RGDATA. It is amazing that four out of ten businesses have said that they will not make a profit next year. I will speak to the Minister and ask for the cost of doing business forum to be reconvened. The forum has led to a very positive engagement between businesses, the Minister and the Department. The Senator is right to ask for the forum to be reconvened, and I will do that.
Senator Ní Chuilinn spoke about the national sports policy. It is something that she has worked on for a long time. A new policy, which is the second one, will be implemented over the next number of months.
The Senator has prioritised inclusion and safeguarding as part of that policy, which were not in the first one. I know she will work with the Minister, Deputy O’Donovan, on that over the next number of months.
Senator Sharon Keogan spoke about Escort Ireland, which she has done before. I will speak to the Minister for justice about coming in on this. She has asked for it once, if not twice, before already and we will see if there is an opportunity to do that.
Senator Cathal Byrne spoke about Captain Wafer hall, which has reopened in Enniscorthy. It is another example of good community organisations like the Enniscorthy Community Alliance being able to reopen a facility for people in the town. I saw it as well in Adare, where there is a community hall that the community came together to reopen just before the Ryder Cup . It does wonders for a town or a village. He is right in asking for another grant to be made available for 2027.
Senator Chris Andrews spoke about the camogie final and Ballinteer St. John’s victory in it. I congratulate him on that. He named everyone who played a part. I am sure he played some part in supporting them in some way. It is great to see. Camogie has had a good year, particularly at intercounty level. That final was exceptional. I suggest that the Ballinteer team come down to County Tipperary to see real camogie players playing there. We will give them a good lesson in how to get to an elite level of camogie.
Senator Sarah O’Reilly spoke about the budget and how it seems to have been targeted towards people who are better off. That is not true. We have seen yearly increases in the minimum wage, and again this year, following through on recommendations of the Low Pay Commission. We have, I think, the highest minimum wage in the European Union now. That has been done, along with changes in the USC over the past number of years, to support people on the minimum wage. Almost all of the people on the salaries she is talking about pay almost no tax apart from the USC and, because of the changes that have been made in social protection, now qualify for additional supports and lump sum payments because of the salary they are on. I utterly reject that and would welcome the opportunity to discuss the budget. I am more than happy to facilitate an opportunity for people to do it again, even though we had two opportunities with the Minister for Finance and the Minister for public expenditure. If someone in the Opposition wants to talk about the budget again, I am sure my colleagues and I on this side of the Chamber will welcome that opportunity.
Senator Gareth Scahill spoke about Robert Pether, who suffered very challenging times, being detained for almost six years in Iraq. It shows the resilience and never-give-up attitude, as the Senator said, his family had in getting him returned. An awful lot of people played a key role in that. The Minister, Deputy McEntee, would acknowledge that. This went back many years, including local representatives and parliamentarians in County Roscommon and the Minister and the Department. We always say that we have incredible diplomats right across the world. It is at times like this that you really need them to help and support.
Senator Paraic Brady spoke about an emergency a garda was dealing with where he could not use the car because his electric vehicle did not have enough charge. That seems incredible. It would be a good investment to have superchargers in Garda stations for exactly that reason, so that the cars can be charged to 100% in 20 minutes. The new 250 kW chargers are incredibly quick. With regard to security, it is up to the Commissioner but it would seem like an obvious good investment for the future.
Comment on this
Before I put a number of questions to the House, I welcome Senator Teresa Costello and her guests in the Gallery, Niamh McPhillips, Nico Crowley and Ashley O'Donovan. They are most welcome to Seanad Éireann.
Senator Eileen Flynn has moved an amendment to the Order of Business: "That No. 11 be taken before No. 1." It was seconded by Senator Tom Clonan. The Leader has indicated that he is prepared to accept this amendment. Is the amendment agreed? Agreed.
Senator Maria Byrne has moved an amendment to the Order of Business: "That No. 10 be taken before No. 1." It was seconded by Senator Linda Nelson Murray. The Leader has indicated that he is prepared to accept the amendment.