Leader’s response to contributions
The Cathaoirleach invited the Leader to respond; the Leader acknowledged the Waterford tragedy and expressed hope for the Minister’s recovery.
I am conscious we are out of time so I will be as brief as I can.
I acknowledge all the contributions of Senators about the tragedy in Waterford. I read, before I came in, that a Garda criminal investigation is happening. Let us wait to see what happens. In any case, it is an awful tragedy to see four people, in particular two children, lose their lives and two other children fighting for their lives. This morning is a difficult time for people in Waterford.
As a few people said, the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, was taken ill a few hours ago. We hope he is well in hospital and is being taken care of. Deputy O'Donovan has a wife, Eileen, and three young boys. We can all empathise. This job is stressful at the best of times. I have no doubt Deputy O'Donovan will come back strong and healthy and do what he always does, which is work hard for his community.
Senator O'Loughlin spoke about the lights of hope campaign and the sentence that was handed down to George Gibney, which is long overdue. I acknowledge the bravery Orla Poole has shown in recent years.
She also spoke about St. Brigid's Primary School. It is an ongoing issue in several primary schools that no leadership provision is put in place for large primary schools in particular, compared with much smaller primary schools. I will speak to the Minister about that.
Senator Kennelly spoke about Ballyheigue water treatment plant. I am delighted he brought it up because I sympathise with him massively on this. My area of Tipperary is now on a do not consume notice, like Kerry. I have never seen a do not consume notice in my area, Ardfinnan. The Senator outlined exactly what it means for people, that they cannot consume water in any way. They cannot brush their teeth with the water.
We are going upstairs every evening at the moment with a little jug of water for Jamie and Daniel in order that they can brush their teeth. The problem, as the Senator outlined, is that no realistic timeframe has been put forward. People are just told they have to manage. Tanks are put in villages to support people. There is a facility, which we have used in the past number of days, to support vulnerable people who live on their own, especially elderly people, to register to receive water at their homes. All that is okay, but this never happened when water services were the responsibility of the council. I did not know that there was a do not consume notice in Kerry pretty much the same week that we in Tipperary had one for the first time ever. This is wholly unacceptable. People seem to think that it is only going to last a day or two, but I have been informed it will be a good number of weeks for the Ardfinnan plant to resume operations and that they may be a need for a boil water notice. That is incredibly difficult for schools in particular to deal with. I will talk to the Minister, Deputy Browne. He should come to the Chamber. I assumed it was only my area in Tipperary that had a do not consume notice. I will make sure that the Minister tries to make himself available as a matter of urgency. When people say that it will be a couple of weeks, we in politics know how long what is happening could actually go on for. We do not want it to go on until Christmas.
Senator McCarthy spoke about Daniel, a very good friend of his who was in his 30s and who passed away last week. He collapsed and passed away, unfortunately. The Senator gave a really good account of what a decent man he was, despite living with challenges in his life. Obviously, Senator McCarthy and the people who work with him did good work to try to support that man. In the wider context, the Senator referred to drugs and the fact that drug use has increased. We had a drugs committee that produced a report. In fairness, Senator Ruane asked for a debate on that report before the summer recess. I said at the time that I would be happy to facilitate such a debate. That remains the case, because it is an important debate to have in this House.
Senator Murphy spoke about the Garvaghy Road. That matter has been raised in the House a number of times. We might have an opportunity at some point to have a full debate on it rather than discussing it on the Order of Business. Considering that decisions have been made and some form of peace has been restored, there is an opportunity in that regard. However, we need to have a debate about the future of Northern Ireland and about what we all want to see, which is a united Ireland. We need to learn from the past two weeks and what has happened.
Senator Noonan spoke about the Arterial Drainage Act 1945 and requested a debate on flooding with the Minister of State, Deputy Moran. It is a good idea to have a debate on flooding before flooding happens. The Minister of State has a significant amount of money available in his Department to try to manage floods that happen across the country. I will speak to him on Senator Noonan's behalf in the context of having a debate on that matter.
Senator Flynn proposed an amendment to the Order of Business. I am happy to agree to that proposal in the context of strengthening Coco's Law. We will have an opportunity to discuss that when it comes before the House.
Senator Comyn spoke about breast density. It is very important to discuss that matter. I will see if the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, can come in. We have had real success in the past 20 or 30 years. I spoke in this Chamber last week, when Senator Scahill raised this matter, about my mother, who passed from breast cancer 26 years ago. If she were alive now, she would not be in danger of passing. That is because of the success of various Governments over the past 20 to 30 years. Checking breast density provides a really good opportunity for early detection of breast cancer in women and men. As the Senator said, there are 30 or 40 men a year who contract the disease. Early detection is key to everything so let us try to have a debate on that.
Senator Kelleher spoke about World Mental Health Day. The Senator and I have spoken privately about this matter. I do not think we have spoken in this Chamber about it, but people like him who are able to give accounts of their personal experiences encourage others to stand up and do it. I commend him on that because it is not an easy thing to do. When you speak with emotion and from experience in here, whatever side of the House you are on, people sit up and listen. Senator Kelleher spoke about the green ribbon campaign. As he knows, my younger brother Scott was one of the founders of the see change green ribbon campaign after leaving college. He is so proud of it and of how far it has come.
There has been so much work done in Shine to encourage people to do exactly what the Senator did today, which was to have the courage to stand up and speak and encourage other people to do it. I commend the Senator massively on it and we will try our best to have a debate on that.
Senator Clonan spoke about the sentencing of George Gibney to 15 years and how up to 37 victims suffered at his hands. Justice prevailed, which is welcome, but it would be much better if justice had prevailed a long time ago.
The Senator spoke about Mike Finnegan. The former Leader, Regina Doherty, did an awful lot of work with Mike at the time and that is what ignited the pursuit to have a public inquiry. I will follow up with Regina Doherty MEP on it and see where that is at the moment. She spoke numerous times in this Chamber about Mike and his courage to speak out against an organisation that went against him in what he was doing. I will do that for the Senator.
Senator Joe Flaherty spoke again about Horse Sport Ireland. He has raised this issue a number of times. There is an examinership at the moment. We want to protect jobs as best we can but that is a matter for the examiner to do rather than this House. However, I acknowledge the contribution made by the Senator.
Senator Nelson Murray spoke about the assistive technology scheme. She gave a very good example of a school where one child was one number below the IQ level of 90 to qualify, but as the Senator does, she managed to find a way around that. However, it brings into discussion the new regulations and changes because now a school can make the decision instead of the SENO. As the Senator requested, I will contact the Minister of State to see when that will be done. One would have thought this could have been done by the start of the school year but I will talk to the Minister of State about it.
Senator Tully spoke about the assessment of need and primary care. Obviously, there is a real challenge in terms of the number of people awaiting assessments of need. An awful lot of money has been put in place over the last number of years in relation to Cara's fund, which is named after Cara Darmody from Tipperary. Last year, €20 million was allocated. In the budget last week, another €20 million was allocated to the fund. That is an improvement, but in terms of the number of people who need assessment, the funding needs to improve even further, so I take the Senator's comments on board.
Senator Gallagher also spoke about BreastCheck and to the Minister filling vital vacancies so that people could get breast checks. As I said to Senator Comyn, I will try to arrange a debate with the Minister in the near future.
Senator Maria Byrne spoke about the proposed amendment, with which I am happy to agree. It is good legislation that she is looking to bring forward. Her party and I are fully behind the Senator in terms of bringing that forward and I have no doubt that we will have an opportunity in the next number of weeks to tease through the legislation and discuss it as a House.
Senator Craughwell spoke about the industrial strike by public sector workers. As a Government, we want to see an agreement reached. We have had many negotiations over a long number of years while Fine Gael has been in government. They have been healthy negotiations. I have seen massive improvements in the public sector, and I have seen improvements in and restoration of pay. We can only reach an agreement when people are talking to one another. That is why the Minister, Jack Chambers, issued a final request for people to come and actually talk, with pay being the central theme of that discussion. All I ask is that union representatives come and talk as soon as possible. It seems, at this late stage, that the day of action will take place tomorrow. That has an impact on this House. This House will be closed, which is, as the Senator said, unprecedented. I am not sure whether he asked me if we should be sitting. I do not disagree with him and believe that we should be sitting. I put forward a schedule of three sitting days. It is up to the Leader of the Seanad to decide the schedule. I decided the schedule but, unfortunately, the House is unable to facilitate the schedule. Next week, I will put forward a full schedule for three days. It is up to the House to be able to facilitate that schedule, but let us see where we are. I hope that, by next week, we will be able to come to a decision.
Senator Fitzpatrick spoke about RGDATA. It is amazing that four out of ten businesses have said that they will not make a profit next year. I will speak to the Minister and ask for the cost of doing business forum to be reconvened. The forum has led to a very positive engagement between businesses, the Minister and the Department. The Senator is right to ask for the forum to be reconvened, and I will do that.
Senator Ní Chuilinn spoke about the national sports policy. It is something that she has worked on for a long time. A new policy, which is the second one, will be implemented over the next number of months.
The Senator has prioritised inclusion and safeguarding as part of that policy, which were not in the first one. I know she will work with the Minister, Deputy O’Donovan, on that over the next number of months.
Senator Sharon Keogan spoke about Escort Ireland, which she has done before. I will speak to the Minister for justice about coming in on this. She has asked for it once, if not twice, before already and we will see if there is an opportunity to do that.
Senator Cathal Byrne spoke about Captain Wafer hall, which has reopened in Enniscorthy. It is another example of good community organisations like the Enniscorthy Community Alliance being able to reopen a facility for people in the town. I saw it as well in Adare, where there is a community hall that the community came together to reopen just before the Ryder Cup . It does wonders for a town or a village. He is right in asking for another grant to be made available for 2027.
Senator Chris Andrews spoke about the camogie final and Ballinteer St. John’s victory in it. I congratulate him on that. He named everyone who played a part. I am sure he played some part in supporting them in some way. It is great to see. Camogie has had a good year, particularly at intercounty level. That final was exceptional. I suggest that the Ballinteer team come down to County Tipperary to see real camogie players playing there. We will give them a good lesson in how to get to an elite level of camogie.
Senator Sarah O’Reilly spoke about the budget and how it seems to have been targeted towards people who are better off. That is not true. We have seen yearly increases in the minimum wage, and again this year, following through on recommendations of the Low Pay Commission. We have, I think, the highest minimum wage in the European Union now. That has been done, along with changes in the USC over the past number of years, to support people on the minimum wage. Almost all of the people on the salaries she is talking about pay almost no tax apart from the USC and, because of the changes that have been made in social protection, now qualify for additional supports and lump sum payments because of the salary they are on. I utterly reject that and would welcome the opportunity to discuss the budget. I am more than happy to facilitate an opportunity for people to do it again, even though we had two opportunities with the Minister for Finance and the Minister for public expenditure. If someone in the Opposition wants to talk about the budget again, I am sure my colleagues and I on this side of the Chamber will welcome that opportunity.
Senator Gareth Scahill spoke about Robert Pether, who suffered very challenging times, being detained for almost six years in Iraq. It shows the resilience and never-give-up attitude, as the Senator said, his family had in getting him returned. An awful lot of people played a key role in that. The Minister, Deputy McEntee, would acknowledge that. This went back many years, including local representatives and parliamentarians in County Roscommon and the Minister and the Department. We always say that we have incredible diplomats right across the world. It is at times like this that you really need them to help and support.
Senator Paraic Brady spoke about an emergency a garda was dealing with where he could not use the car because his electric vehicle did not have enough charge. That seems incredible. It would be a good investment to have superchargers in Garda stations for exactly that reason, so that the cars can be charged to 100% in 20 minutes. The new 250 kW chargers are incredibly quick. With regard to security, it is up to the Commissioner but it would seem like an obvious good investment for the future.