Employment Equality and Institutional Burials (Amendment) Bill 2026: Second Stage
The Bill requires employers covered by gender pay gap reporting rules to submit information through a central portal, and allows first cousins to join DNA identification programmes under the Institutional Burials Act, including programmes already under way. Senators broadly supported both measures, while calling for stronger action on pay inequality and wider investigations of sites such as Bessborough and Sean Ross Abbey. The Minister said recovered infant remains in the excavated Tuam area had been found in coffin-type structures; work elsewhere on the site is ongoing, and participants will be told if a familial link is established. She also cited €12.8 million for Tuam in Budget 2027 and said the Government would seek High Court approval to publish technical documents on Bessborough burials.
No. 95 of 2026 ›
I welcome the Minister and her officials to the House.
For the information of the House, there is an error on page 1 of the Bill whereby the word “An” has been omitted before “Bille” in the “As passed by Dáil Éireann” version of the Bill due to a typographical error in the production process. The error has been brought to the attention of the Clerk of the Dáil and has been corrected.
I call on the Minister to open the debate.
Comment on this
I am pleased to introduce this Bill to the Seanad and to have the opportunity to speak on Second Stage of this important legislation. I thank Senators for facilitating the taking of all Stages of the Bill in the House today. The Bill provides for two separate but important issues.
First, the Bill introduces amendments to the Employment Equality Act 1998. The proposed amendments and subsequent regulations to be made under them will legally oblige employers in scope of the legislation to report their gender pay gap information via the gender pay gap portal. The Department of Children, Disability and Equality first introduced gender pay gap reporting in 2022 following the enactment of the Gender Pay Gap Information Act 2021. Reporting was introduced on a phased basis. As of 2025, employers with over 50 employees must report on their gender pay gap by publishing it on their own website or making it otherwise publicly available. The Department has now developed a centralised database called the gender pay gap portal which launched on a voluntary basis last year. The amendments to the Employment Equality Act 1998 contained in this Bill, which are purely technical in nature, will make the use of this portal mandatory for all employers in scope of the legislation.
I emphasise that the use of the gender pay gap portal is not an additional burden on employers and SMEs. Employers with over 50 staff are already obliged to report on their gender pay gap and publish the report on their own website. Mandatory use of the portal will provide this information in a centralised manner, allowing employees, researchers and the general public to view and compare gender pay gap information across year, employer and sector.
I am pleased to say that, throughout the development and voluntary launch of the gender pay gap portal, our social partners have been incredibly supportive. IBEC has been a key partner in promoting the portal to its members. I also note that this legislation, while not directly transposing elements of the pay transparency directive, will assist with its transposition. I will be bringing further legislation to the Houses in the coming months to complete the transposition of the directive.
However, this legislation is not just about collecting the data. We need to act upon it. That is what our National Strategy for Women and Girls 2025 to 2030 aims to do. The strategy and its action plans aim to address the issues that cause the gender pay gap. This includes addressing childcare and care issues, supporting family leave and ensuring the place of women in decision-making and leadership roles. Mandatory use of the portal for employers who fall within the scope of the legislation and having this information available in a centralised database will help us to progress our efforts to close the gender pay gap by highlighting the difference to make a difference.
The Bill also includes amendments to the Institutional Burials Act 2022 to include first cousins as eligible family members who can participate in an identification programme under the Act. The 2022 Act provides for the excavation, recovery, analysis, identification and reburial of remains which have been buried in a manifestly inappropriate manner on land associated with a former residential institution in which a public body had or has a relevant role.
Part 4 of the Act provides for an identification programme. It allows for samples to be taken from eligible family members who wish to participate in a programme and for their DNA profiles to be compared with DNA profiles from recovered remains. The Act currently defines an eligible family member as a person who has reasonable grounds to believe that they are the child, parent, sibling, half-sibling, grandparent, grandchild, aunt, uncle, niece, nephew, half-niece, half-nephew, grand-niece or grand-nephew of a person who is buried at the intervention site. The policy intention of this definition was to enable participation in as inclusive a way as possible by a range of relatives where the available technology was capable of establishing a familial link.
The inclusion of first cousins was raised during the passage of the legislation through the Houses. However, the scientific advice provided at the time highlighted challenges with the inclusion of first cousins due to greater variability of DNA, which would make it notably more difficult to draw conclusions about a familial link than with the other third-order relatives. Earlier this year, however, Forensic Science Ireland informed me of new scientific developments since the enactment of the legislation that allow for DNA matching of sufficient quality to support the inclusion of first cousins in the identification programme. On foot of this updated advice in April, Government approved my proposal to amend the Act to include first cousins. I was keen to move quickly because I know there are first cousins who are interested in participating in the identification programme currently under way in Tuam. I am now introducing the amendments to the Houses at the earliest opportunity as the age profile of some of those who wish to take part in the Tuam identification programme means that time is of the essence to them.
I will now outline the key Parts of the Bill as initiated. Part 1 contains the Short Title and details regarding the Bill's commencement, with Part 2 coming into operation following a commencement order and Part 3 coming into operation upon enactment.
Section 2 amends the Employment Equality Act 1998. Subsections (a), (c) and (e) insert the requirement for employers to publish their gender pay gap information directly to me, as Minister for Children, Disability, and Equality. Subsection (b) allows me to make regulations as to how, where and when employers should report this information to me. As previously mentioned, employers will report this information directly to me via the gender pay gap portal. Subsection (d) provides for the pseudonymisation of information reported to me in adherence with GDPR and data protection legislation. Subsections (f) and (g) insert a number of new sections that provide for a number of measures relating to the information to be reported and its publication.
Regulations made under this section, which are currently being drafted, will lay out the criteria it must comply with, such as ensuring the information is accurate and that the employer's statement does not contain any personal data or offensive or discriminatory language. In addition, the regulations will allow comparisons to be made with the statistical information submitted. The new subsections will allow me to publish the information employers have already submitted to the gender pay gap portal during the voluntary reporting period, which began with the portal's launch in November 2025, and also allow for the unpublication of information that may directly or indirectly identify a person.
Part 3 amends the Institutional Burials Act 2022 to provide for the inclusion of first cousins in an identification programme conducted under Part 4 of the 2022 Act. It also provides for transitional arrangements so that first cousins can participate in an identification that has already commenced under the Act, as in the case in Tuam. Section 3 is an interpretation section that defines the Act of 2022 as the "Institutional Burials Act 2022". Section 4 expands the definition of "eligible family member" to include first cousins. It includes the first cousin of a deceased person in the category of "eligible family member" whose participation in an identification programme can be objected to by a child, parent, sibling or half-sibling of the same deceased person. It also adds a first cousin to the list of family members for the purposes of making final arrangements for recovered remains of a deceased relative.
Section 5 contains a number of transitional provisions. First, subsections (1) and (2) provide for transitional arrangements to allow first cousins who may have previously applied to participate in an identification programme to reapply following the legislative amendments in this Bill. This is particularly relevant in the context of the ongoing Tuam identification programme. Subsections (3), (4) and (5) provide for situations where a first cousin applies to participate in an identification programme and an eligible family member of the same deceased person has previously objected to another person's participation in that identification programme. In such circumstances, the director will make reasonable efforts to contact the previous objector to ascertain if they also wish to object to the participation of the first cousin. Subsection (6) defines "identification programme" for the purposes of this section.
I thank colleagues for their attention. I look forward to hearing their thoughts on these important amendments. I commend the Bill to the House.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Employment Equality and Institutional Burials (Amendment) Bill 2026. Fianna Fáil welcomes this debate and supports the Bill. This is important legislation that addresses two distinct but significant issues. First, it amends the Employment Equality Act 1998 to provide a legal basis for mandatory reporting of gender pay gap information to the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality. Second, it amends the Institutional Burials Act 2022 to allow first cousins to participate in identification programmes established under that Act. While these amendments may appear technical at first glance, they are actually practical and meaningful changes. They strengthen transparency, improve accountability and demonstrate the importance of ensuring our laws evolve in response to changing societal needs and developments in scientific knowledge.
Turning first to the employment equality provisions, while considerable progress has been made in recent years, a gap remains between women and men in terms of pay and participation at senior levels across many sectors. Fianna Fáil is committed to addressing these inequalities and ensuring that opportunities are available to all regardless of gender. The gender pay gap does not simply reflect differences in pay for the same work. Rather, it highlights wider structural issues that continue to affect workplaces across society. These include the under-representation of women in senior leadership positions, occupational segregation in certain sectors, barriers to career progression and the continuing reality that caring responsibilities often fall on women. For many women, these factors can have a cumulative impact over the course of a career. They can influence decisions around working hours and promotion opportunities and long-term earning potential. Addressing the gender pay gap requires more than a narrow focus on wages alone. It requires us to confront broader inequalities and to ensure workplaces support equal participation and advancement for everyone.
Ireland has undoubtedly made progress in this area. Successive Governments have introduced measures to improve gender equality and many employers have taken positive steps to foster more inclusive workplaces. However, progress cannot be taken for granted. The evidence shows that gender disparities continue to exist, in particular at senior management and executive levels where representation remains uneven in a number of sectors. That is why transparency matters so much - what gets measures gets addressed. Reliable information allows policymakers, employers and the wider public to understand where improvements are being made and where challenges still remain. Transparency creates accountability, encourages reflection and supports informed decision-making.
The original intention behind the Gender Pay Gap Information Act 2021 was that employers would ultimately submit their gender pay gap information to a central government portal. While the gender pay gap has already been developed and has opened successfully on a voluntary basis, there is no legal basis that requires employers to provide this information directly through that system. This Bill addresses that gap. Importantly, it will enable mandatory reporting through the gender pay gap portal from 1 November 2026 for the 2026 reporting cycle. This will result in a more streamlined, accessible and consistent reporting framework. The benefits of a centralised reporting system are significant. Information will be easier to access, compare and analyse. Member of the public, researchers, policymakers and employers will be better equipped to assess trends and identify areas requiring attention. Just as important, the portal will enhance confidence in the reporting process and support evidence-based policymaking into the future.
It is also important to note that these provisions should not create an excessive administrative burden for employers. The information submitted is information employers are already required to circulate and publish. This amendment simply ensures that the information is collected in a more consistent and effective manner. It is a practical reform that strengthens accountability without imposing unnecessary additional obligations.
I will now turn to the second element of the Bill, which concerns the Institutional Burials Act 2022.
This aspect of the legislation deals with a profoundly sensitive issue. The 2022 Act established an important framework for the excavation, recovery, analysis, identification and reburial of human remains found at former institutional sites. The legislation sought to provide a mechanism through which families could participate in identification programmes and, where possible, obtain answers that have been sought for generations. The impact of institutional burial practices continues to be felt by very many families throughout Ireland. For those affected, the search for truth, recognition and closure is deeply personal. The identification process is not simply a scientific exercise; it is about dignity, respect and ensuring that families have every possible opportunity to learn about what happened to their loved ones.
The list of eligible family members contained in the existing legislation was based on the scientific advice available at the time of the Act. While every effort was made to adopt as inclusive an approach as possible, concerns existed regarding the reliability of using DNA from first cousins to establish family connections. For that reason, first cousins were not included at the time among those eligible to participate. However, science continues to evolve and we evolve with it. Advances in forensic technology and additional validation testing have provided greater confidence in the ability to use DNA evidence from first cousins within identification programmes. This updated scientific understanding has informed the amendments before us today. This Bill, therefore, represents a sensible response to that progress. It broadens participation in identification programmes by extending eligibility to first cousins and ensures that legislation reflects the most up-to-date scientific evidence available. For some families this change may be particularly important. In many cases, immediate relatives may no longer be alive or may not be in a position to participate. The inclusion of first cousins may, therefore, provide the only realistic opportunity to contribute to the identification process. It increases the possibility of obtaining answers and allows more families to engage with a process that is of profound significance to them.
The Bill includes practical transitional arrangements to ensure that those who were previously excluded can now apply to participate, including in identification programmes that may already be under way. This is a welcome and compassionate provision that ensures families are not disadvantaged because eligibility criteria have changed following scientific advancements. Ultimately, this section of the Bill demonstrates the importance of responsive legislation. As our understanding evolves so, too, must our laws. When new evidence becomes available, this can assist families and improve outcomes. It is right that we act upon it.
In conclusion, this is a thoughtful, practical and necessary Bill. It strengthens transparency and accountability in relation to gender pay gap reporting and the ongoing efforts to achieve greater equality in our workplace. At the same time, it responds to scientific developments in a way that expands opportunities for families' participation in the identification programme and supports those seeking long-awaited answers. Both sets of measures reflect a commitment to fairness, dignity and good governance. For those reasons, Fianna Fáil is pleased to support this legislation and I commend the Bill to the House.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister. My contribution at this point will be limited to the Tuam excavations aspect of this legislation. As I understand it, the purpose of the amendment in that respect is, as has been said, to extend the possible number of persons from whom reference samples of DNA can be taken to include first cousins. Am I right in that?
In relation to what has happened to date, can the Minister indicate to us, because there is conflicting commentary on social media, whether it is the case that so far infant remains located have been in coffin-type structures before burial? Is that case at the moment? Is there any indication of non-coffin disposal of infant remains either in the subterranean chamber, which is referred to in the technical reports, or elsewhere on the site?
On another issue, at what point will the comparison of DNA from remains recovered be compared with the reference samples that have been gathered? As I understand it, about 74 people have provided reference samples with a view to identifying whether relatives may or may not be interred in the area in question. At what point will comparisons be made with a view to ascertaining whether the concerns of those who are providing reference samples as regards burials which are identified will be addressed? At what point will they be carried out? Will there be transparency? I am not asking for people's privacy to be interfered with in any way. Will there be transparency, in anonymised form, of those samples which have yielded a positive identification? Perhaps the Minister could confirm that to us.
Finally, in relation to the projected costs of the entire excavation which has been carried out, what is the most up-to-date estimate of what will be expended across the lifetime of this excavation?
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister to the Chamber. My colleague went through the Bill in detail. We are dealing with an important issue this evening. We are dealing with two very different elements but both need amendments and adjustments in order to make things more transparent, I suppose. The first addresses the legal gap that prevents Government from compelling employers to submit information through centralised reporting systems. The second responds to scientific advances that now allow first cousins to participate in DNA identification programmes with sufficient reliability.
I am all for creating the right environment in terms of the gender pay gap. The whole objective of the Employment Equality Act 1998 was to make the differences between men's and women's average earnings more transparent. Some employers have been able to publish information publicly on their website while others have been able to keep that information and have it available for inspection. This new section will allow the Department of Children, Disability and Equality to utilise that information properly to ensure that the gender pay gap is addressed, highlighted and moves in the right direction. We all want to see it moved forward.
Like Senator McDowell, I want to refer to the amendment to the Institutional Burials Act 2022. I can understand why cousins were excluded from that previously. Obviously, as advancements continue, we find an increasing amount of available information and it is prudent to now include cousins. The real story is that, potentially, an aunt of someone may have had a child in an institution many years ago and that child was stillborn and buried but, without any family members available at this moment in time, that child is unnamed and unrecognised. Especially in cases like Tuam, where people are looking for closure, acknowledgement and recognition of these deaths, anything that the State can do to identify and recognise those babies is very important. I acknowledge the time sensitivity of this. Obviously, in Tuam specifically, an awful lot of the people who may have had links at the time will have reached a significant age at this stage. Therefore, it is very important that this provision is done as quickly as possible. We support the Bill in its current form and I support everything that was previously said on this by my colleague.
Comment on this
Senator Stephenson and I are sharing time.
Comment on this
I am speaking on behalf of Senator Laura Harmon, who cannot be with us this afternoon. I will make a couple of points about both elements of this Bill.
In relation to the gender pay gap reporting, it is very much welcome to see that the Government is moving to establish a central reporting portal, but we need to see more urgency on pay transparency. It is disappointing that the Government missed the deadline to transpose the EU pay transparency directive, which should have been legislated for by June of this year. That is four months ago. Even once this Bill is passed, there will remain several key provisions of the directive that will not have been transposed into Irish law. Under the terms of the directive, employers will need to inform prospective employees of the pay or pay range for particular roles before any interviews and they will not be permitted to ask interviewees about their salary history. Why is the Government dragging its heels on this? It has had three years to get it done and still managed to miss the deadline.
A survey in September 2026 found that just 20% of employers said they always post salaries in their job ads at present. It also found a rise in the number of employers opposed to the reforms. The Government should be making a considered argument as to why this directive is good for workers and for businesses. ICTU has shown that the Government's failure to transpose the directive on time will cost working women more than €570 million this year in lost wages.
The directive's measures on tackling the gender pay gap are not limited to reporting. Under the directive, where the gender pay gap persistently exceeds 5%, the employer will be required to consult with unions or employees' representatives on the measures required to address the situation. The Government needs to spell out what policy responses will be put in place to give real teeth to the reporting requirements in this Bill. It is all well and good having a report and a portal, but that will not address the problem on its own. The Government talks a good game on European credentials but needs to follow up on this European directive.
In relation to the institutional burials, the second element of the Bill closes an important gap in the 2022 Act by allowing first cousins to take part in the identification programme. This is a welcome change. We are glad to see this will apply retroactively in order that first cousins can apply to take part in an identification programme that is already under way. We all know the horrors that went on behind the walls of the institutions in so many cities, towns and villages across the country during the last century. The vital work of people like Catherine Corless laid this bare and made sure that we as a society could no longer turn away and ignore the wrongs that were done. The 2022 Act was the response we took as legislators. It was not perfect but it was important that we took the step to legislate for cases where we know that inappropriate burials took place inside institutions, many of which had shockingly high mortality rates.
One such institution was Bessborough mother and baby home in Cork. The Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes estimated that 923 babies died in Bessborough but just 64 burial locations could be identified. Burial records for 859 children and 19 women were missing. According to the commission, it is highly likely that some of these babies are buried in unmarked graves on the grounds. That is why such a deep dismay was caused when An Coimisiún Pleanála granted planning permission to build on the site last year. Bessborough should be a place of memorial and a site of conscience. It is completely unacceptable to even countenance that any building work should go ahead while there are still so many unanswered questions. The State has the power to act and it is long past time the Government stepped in. Bessborough should be secured through compulsory purchase, and I commend the work of my colleague Senator Harmon on that.
It is welcome that the Government is closing the gap in the 2022 Act through this Bill, but if it is serious about doing so by the families and survivors of the institutions, it needs to step in and make sure that the Bessborough site is protected.
Comment on this
I will first talk about the equal pay part of this Bill. As we all know, equal pay is fundamentally about fairness, equality and economic independence. Every person deserves to be paid fairly for the work they do, regardless of their gender. Transparency around the gender pay gap is an important first step. We cannot address the inequalities that remain hidden without it. Reporting figures is not enough. The information has to lead to meaningful action, accountability and lasting change. We have to recognise the value of women's work, challenge the inequalities that persist in our workplaces and ensure that equality is not simply a promise on paper but something people experience in their everyday lives. Fairness has to be reflected in pay, opportunity and respect.
When we speak about institutional burials, we are speaking about children whose lives were cut short, mothers who suffered unimaginable loss and families who have spent decades searching for answers. Their need for truth has not diminished with time; if anything, the urgency has grown. In Tuam, families have waited far too long to learn what has happened to their children and to have the opportunity to identify and recover their remains. Expanding DNA identification opportunities to include first cousins is a really important step. It recognises that there is a very real problem: many of the closest relatives who could have helped to identify these children have already died. Time in this instance really matters. It is a matter of urgency. Every year that passes risks closing another door on a family searching for answers. Families must be supported throughout this process, treated with the utmost compassion and kept informed. The importance of trauma-informed care should be at the forefront of all this. They should not have to fight repeatedly for the basic right to know where their loved ones are buried.
My problem is that this cannot end with Tuam. Excluding any site is wrong. Any arbitrary decision to exclude sites is not trauma informed and, ultimately, creates further trauma to those outside of Tuam. At Bessborough in Cork, for example, serious questions remain about the burial places and the fate of children and women connected to that institution. The burial places of 859 children and 19 women have been unaccounted for. I pay tribute to my colleague Noelle Brown and many others who have campaigned relentlessly for those numbers because these are individual lives, families and generations who have lived with uncertainty. The situation at Bessborough demands the same urgency, seriousness and commitment that we rightly expect in Tuam. There must be a thorough and transparent investigation, and every possible effort must be made to establish where these children and women were buried, what happened to them and what led them to that place. There are serious concerns about protecting the Bessborough site, particularly where development risks compromising the opportunity to investigate and to establish the truth. There must not be one standard for justice for Tuam and another for Bessborough or any other institution. Every child mattered, every mother mattered and every family deserves to know what happened to their loved ones, regardless of where they lived or which institution was involved.
We cannot undo the suffering that has taken place but we can now decide how to respond to it. We can choose transparency and dignity over indifference. These families have waited long enough. They deserve answers, they deserve dignity and they deserve the truth. I ask the Minister to seriously consider amendments to this legislation around the inclusion of Bessborough.
Comment on this
I am sharing time with Senator McCormack.
Comment on this
There are two very distinct parts to this Bill. The amendment to the Employment Equality Act would legally oblige employers to publish information on their gender pay gap on a centralised gender pay gap portal. That is important. We welcome that. It is important that we address this issue because a significant gender pay gap still exists and it disproportionately affects women, especially as women age. Women may take time out of work to have children, they may end up having to go on shorter time because of childcare issues and so forth, and they end up then losing out in wages, pensions, opportunities for promotion and so forth. It is important that we address that. However, of possibly 6,000 employers who should be engaging with the portal - I know it is on a voluntary basis at the moment - I think only 1,000 have registered and only 410 have submitted information. How will the Department compel employers to engage and upload the relevant information, and what happens if they do not do so?
In addition, the purpose of the information is really important.
It is great to have this information. It is centralised and collected, so we know the extent of the issue, but how is it going to be used to address what is a very serious issue? There have to be real objectives to come out of this that will ensure we can close the gender pay gap forever.
In relation to the Institutional Burials Act, I welcome the inclusion of first cousins in the DNA matching for the identification of remains that were inappropriately buried at the sites of institutions. Anything that can speed up the process is welcome. Time is running out for many people with regard to many of these sites.
I commend all those working at Tuam on the work they do, which is extremely important and difficult. I commend Catherine Corless on her relentless advocacy in this area. However, it cannot just be Tuam. We have to address the issues at Bessborough, where we do not know where 859 babies and 19 mothers are buried. This site cannot be built on until that is addressed. There are many other sites throughout the country where institutions existed and where there are questions about babies and other individuals being buried. That has to be addressed.
I take this opportunity to raise the issue of people who are locked out of the scheme for survivors of mother and baby institutions, for example, those who were less than six months in the institution or those who were boarded out. Millions of euros are returned every year unspent on survivors, yet survivors are omitted from these schemes who should be included. That should be reviewed and changed.
Comment on this
I will speak to the industrial burials amendment part of this legislation. The most basic thing a mother needs and deserves is to know where her child is buried. I also want to talk about a specific baby home because people have reached out to say they feel excluded from this. I do not think it is too much to ask, in Ireland in 2026, that a mother would know where her child is buried. I will speak specifically about Sean Ross Abbey in Roscrea. Between 1931 and 1969, 6,079 babies were born there, and 1,090 of those babies died. That is 1,090 little lives, but the death register handed over by the religious order only contained 269 names. There were 269 names when we know that 1,090 children died, and no proper burial registers were maintained.
Imagine a mother who gave birth to a baby in one of these institutions. Imagine being told your baby had died but never being given the chance to say goodbye, never knowing where your child was laid to rest. This was the case for a lot of these mothers. Imagine spending the rest of your life searching for these answers, which for many mothers is still the case, and it is often family members who are still looking for them. The reality is that families connected to these institutions are feeling this pain and living with this pain, day in, day out.
In 2019, forensic investigators examined part of the children’s burial ground at Sean Ross Abbey and confirmed the presence of infant remains. The investigation could not conclusively establish that every child who died there was buried within that ground, yet the decision was made that further investigation was not warranted. How can that be an acceptable answer to a mother who does not know where her baby is buried? It cannot be acceptable to the brothers, sisters and families who have spent decades trying to find out what happened to their loved ones.
This is not something that happened years ago. As recently as this year, survivors and families connected to Sean Ross Abbey were still calling for further excavation, access to records and answers concerning the children who died there. Further surveys identified anomalies on adjoining land, although the Government’s archaeological review concluded that they did not provide clear evidence of additional burials. That has not resolved the concerns for the families. The State-appointed special advocate for survivors has also called for the burial grounds at Sean Ross Abbey and Bessborough to be revisited.
These are not just numbers on a page. They are babies. They had names. They had mothers. They had families. Those mothers never got to hold their children in many cases, never got to say goodbye and never got a chance to stand at the graveside. We have apologised for what happened in these institutions, we have had inquiries and we have passed legislation. I welcome the provisions in this Bill to allow first cousins to participate in the identification process. That is fantastic. It is a really positive step for the families. However, extending the rights of families to identify remains is only part of the answer. What about the families who still do not know where their loved ones are buried? What good are identification rights if there is no further investigation of the burial grounds they are concerned about?
What concerns me is that the Government has said Sean Ross Abbey does not meet the criteria for intervention under the Institutional Burials Act. Surely we have to ask whether these criteria are fit for purpose when families are still living with uncertainty. We cannot keep telling survivors that we recognise their suffering while leaving them fighting for answers and leaving them living in pain every day. I acknowledge those survivors who constantly reach out to me and the campaigners who have spent years fighting to have these children remembered. They should not have had to spend the rest of their lives fighting for the truth.
I have the following questions for the Minister. First, will the Government commit to renewed engagement with survivors and special advocates and to further investigation at Sean Ross Abbey? Second, will the Minister review whether the current legislation is too restrictive to deal with unresolved questions about institutional burial sites? Third, will the Government ensure that the families have meaningful access to the records and further information they need? An apology is important, the memorials are important and the legislation is important. However, none of these things replace the right of a mother or a family to know where a child is buried so they can finally be at peace. We cannot take away the fact that this is missing in so many of these cases of institutional burials.
Comment on this
I will comment on the two aspects of this legislation. First, with respect to employment equality, I welcome any efforts to increase the transparency and availability of the information, even as I note the components that look for better verification of the basis for the information on employment equality. It is very important at a moment when we have seen quite aggressive pressure against diversity, equality and inclusion measures within employment. For example, in the case of the United States, we have seen very active attempts to almost remove these key terms on equality and gender equality from research and the gathering of data and to really press companies to roll back their diversity, equality and inclusion measures. Anything that gives a clear signal in respect of employment equality as something that is recognised as a public good, particularly in terms of gender equality, and as something that we are seeking to actively monitor and improve as a society, is a very positive thing.
It should be followed through in certain areas, such as how we deploy our public procurement. As well as looking for better information, we should also be looking to apply better standards on equality and to have clear standards in respect of that, not just regarding non-discrimination but also the active promotion of equality as something that gets valued and gets given weighting within, for example, public procurement. It is a tool we have and could use, especially with regard to the public duty on equality and human rights, which extends to procurement, as we know. We should not have a situation where public procurement contracts reward those who may have actively taken steps to roll back equality measures and diminish gender equality when, sadly, certain companies have made that choice.
The part of the Bill that I am really focused on is the second part, which is the amendment of the Institutional Burials Act. When this legislation first went through, Senator Ruane and I highlighted that we had real concerns with the way the institutional burials Bill was framed. We thought that its scope was too narrow and that it would have the effect of exclusion rather than inclusion for many of those who have suffered in institutions and mother and baby homes across Ireland.
There is the concern that we could end up replicating the pattern, a very sad pattern of exclusion, which we have seen. I am not just talking about the core exclusion of women from society that we saw but also exclusions, for example, in relation to the schemes which decided that the woman or the child who spent six months in an institution would not be entitled to any kind of payment or support, as if that six months does not matter when those are the first six months of a child’s life, which, as anybody knows, are so fundamental. There were the decisions to exclude certain categories of survivors, including those who spent certain amounts of time in institutions. There are also the requirements for people to sign waivers, which feel for many like they are signing away the truth of their story and their experience in the past. Some really poor decisions, therefore, have been made in terms of how Ireland reckons with the institutional violence of its past.
There has been a kind of narrowness and not necessarily a hostile attitude, but a constant sense of needing to make sure we do not go too far and that we hold the boundaries as tight as we can. It has been about taking these small steps rather than a very generous, transformative and emancipatory approach to addressing the institutional violence of our past in a significant way that shows society has learned from it. It should be a way that shows we do not regard survivors as a difficulty or people we have to manage, but that we regard them as those people who are witnesses to our worst moments as a State, and who must be valued and listened to in terms of the crafting of paths forward.
In that context, we did warn that the narrowness of the frame was going to be an issue. I am very glad that it is now being expanded to cousins. It was a very narrow frame, though, and we knew it. The expansion to cousins, which emerged from people's experience at Tuam, where we have those whose siblings, or sisters, were placed into institutions and who have gone on to have children themselves. That is another form of family connection.
It would be good if the legislation did not just expand to cousins but maybe allowed for other connections to be added in the future in an easier way that might not require primary legislation. There are other connections that might be there that maybe should be looked to. We have other forms of close relationship for those who are concerned. We know of those many individuals who wrote and wrote and who never gave up on trying to find the connections. I hope the expansion to cousins will give one small extension in terms of those who can try to put together the story of their family and the stories of the injustices experienced by their loved ones, and that it will give peace to some. I will be speaking to this amendment on Committee Stage in this debate.
A huge gap remaining in the legislation, however, is the incredibly narrow definition of what "manifestly inappropriate" means. This was worded in a way where, effectively, it applied to Tuam and has not been usable or applicable in other situations where we have what any clear-minded person would say was inappropriate and appalling treatment of children and their burial. When we brought forward our legislation a year ago to try to amend the legislation and bring in a new definition of "manifestly inappropriate" that would include situations such as Sean Ross, which has been mentioned, and Bessborough, we were told there was no legal obligation in private burial grounds to keep a register of burials. There was then what I think was a bizarre line: "high mortality rates could sadly sometimes be a feature of historic congregated settings". Let us imagine saying that those mortality rates were a feature, with 75% of children dying in one year in Bessborough. I welcome the fact, and perhaps when my amendment is coming through we can discuss it further, that the Government seems to have moved away from that position of it all having been normal for the time and is now applying to unseal some of the burial records in relation to Bessborough. It was on the very day, though, that our amendment was voted down which would have extended this legislation to cover circumstances such as Bessborough that the planning permission was granted to build on and obscure forever a site where so many know that their loved ones are buried and so many burials are unaccounted for.
I know that Patricia Carey, who is the special advocate, has welcomed-----
Comment on this
We are coming to the amendment shortly. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Perfect, so I will go into detail further on this later. I again point out that this is one small step today, but it is a pity this Bill was not used to expand the context further to address the issue of manifestly inappropriate burials.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat. I have one question on the employment equality part of the legislation regarding how it aligns with the Gender Recognition Act 2015 where a man has changed gender under that legislation and received a gender certificate. Does this affect or skew in any way the outcome of the reported pay for women? How does the portal or do employers assess their pay? Is it as men or women? I would like to support the question Senator McDowell asked about the narrative we are hearing about and that I have seen on social media. I have not seen anybody objecting to what some of these people are saying. I refer to the remains found in Tuam so far all having had traces of coffins. Could we get clarification if that is true or not? Go raibh maith agat.
Comment on this
I thank all the Senators for their attention today and their engagement on these important matters. I once more thank all the employers who have made an account on a voluntary basis on the gender pay gap portal, as well as our social partners who, as I said at the outset, have been really very positively disposed in terms of engaging and supporting the use of the portal. Once again, I am grateful to the House for facilitating the timely consideration of the Bill in order that the legislation can be passed in time for mandatory reporting of the 2026 gender pay gap reporting cycle, which begins on 1 November.
As I mentioned earlier, this is not just about mandating reporting, it is about providing the transparency to address those gaps. The work is only just beginning. However, in relation to the other element, time is of the essence in terms of the amendments to the Institutional Burials Act 2022, because of the age profile, as I have already outlined, or health status of some of the first cousins who wish to participate in the Tuam identification programme to help with the identification of their relatives.
In relation to some of the questions specifically in relation to Tuam, I acknowledge and record my gratitude and thanks to the Tuam director, Daniel MacSweeney, who is overseeing this very complex and sensitive intervention in Tuam. He is absolutely committed to working with families and stakeholders in terms of reporting and keeping them updated in relation to information as his work progresses. The director's reports, and the reports he issues bi-monthly, note that coffined infant remains that have been referenced here have been recovered from the area of the site where the work has been completed and this area of the site in historical records has been recorded as a graveyard.
Excavation in terms of the other areas within the Tuam area is yet to be undertaken and I have every confidence that the director will provide updates on his work in that respect as the work is ongoing and completed. We await that.
On the matter of the director informing those who step forward, it is his intention to inform participants if a familial link has been established. On costs, €12.8 million has been set aside in budget 2027 for Tuam.
Members have referred to Bessborough. I acknowledge in particular that Members have previously referred to the issue of access to records within the commission's archive relating to Bessborough. The House will be aware that when the commission was dissolved in 2021, the Department of Children, Disability and Equality received the archive of the commission and is responsible for its safeguarding and maintenance. The Government has no authority whatsoever to disclose material that was not included in the commission’s report and is bound not to disclose it. However, I am pleased to confirm to the House that this morning I received Government approval to seek a direction from the High Court to search for and publish technical, factual documents from the commission's archive that relate to the matter of burials at the site of the former mother and baby institution at Bessborough. Subject to the decision of the High Court, this will, I hope, support transparency and may provide further clarity on the findings of the commission in relation to the former institution. I thank Senators for their engagement.