Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
International Bodies
Ireland strongly condemned US sanctions against the International Criminal Court, warning they threaten the Rome Statute system and the court’s independence. The Government is pursuing diplomacy and EU coordination during its Council Presidency, while urging the Commission to be ready to activate the EU blocking statute if the sanctions are not withdrawn.
I am delighted the Minister is here for this so I was very happy to wait. She met the President of the International Criminal Court, Tomoko Akane, in Dublin earlier this month. Ireland has been consistently vocal in its support for the ICC and the Minister's Department regularly talks about the importance of the rule of law and international accountability. I share these sentiments. As part of our international accountability and justice mechanisms, the ICC is key and, crucially, the independence of the ICC is fundamental. We have seen the most egregious attacks on the very existence of the ICC by the Trump Administration over the last year, with the sanctioning of judges and prosecutors. Last week, those attacks escalated, with the sanctioning of the institution of the ICC itself. Marco Rubio said, "We will ban transactions with this rogue court, cutting off their resources and crippling its ability to operate". The only rogue actor in this context is the US Administration.
The US wants to intimidate the court and its allies. Worse still, the Trump Administration's sanctions on the court could effectively stop it working altogether. It seems that Trump is trying to protect himself and Netanyahu from future cases at the ICC. He is weaponising the US sanctions regime to protect allies from accountability and place powerful countries beyond international justice. It is despicable and it must be called out in no uncertain terms.
The Minister may already know that less powerful countries have explicitly said they will consider pulling out of the ICC due to external pressures from the likes of the US and Russia. Chad has left the ICC. Burundi has made statements indicating an intention to leave. What we are seeing is the destruction of systems of accountability in real time and it is hugely alarming. The actions of the Trump regime are having a direct chilling effect on countries in the likes of sub-Saharan Africa, which are hugely dependent on the US for support. These sanctions will bring the work of the court to a halt if we do not act. Europe's banking and computer systems, as the Minister well knows, are entirely reliant on the US, whether it be Mastercard, Visa, Microsoft or Google. We completely rely on these US companies and depend on them to do our daily work. We depend on them here in the Oireachtas to do our daily work.
It is utterly unacceptable that what is effectively a rogue US Administration can sanction an institution of international justice and prevent its work from going ahead because of Europe's reliance on these systems. There are steps we can take, specifically the EU blocking statute. I have been calling for Ireland to push for this to be implemented for the last year. I am not sure exactly what action the Department has taken to further this. Words of support are fine but they just are not enough any more in this instance. We need to take action. We need to be putting international law front and centre of the EU Presidency when such attacks are taking place. We are seeing a very selective approach by the EU to international law, particularly over Palestine, and it has damaged the EU's credibility. This is an opportunity for the EU to demonstrate an iota of credibility when it comes to defending international law.
Has the Minister called for the EU blocking statute to be enacted? This would shield the ICC and its officials from the impact of the US sanctions. If we do not do it now, it may never recover. I would like to know what concrete steps the Minister's Department is taking during the Presidency of the Council of the EU and how the Minister's Department is advancing a dedicated protective mechanism to shield European nationals and ICC personnel? Irish companies in the supply chain to the ICC via services or goods may also be directly affected by these blatant attempts to protect Trump and his cronies from accountability. It is really important that we are conscious of that in the context of any company providing services to the ICC. The US sanctions against the ICC are wrong, extraterritorial and outside the bounds of international law, and threaten the frameworks designed to keep us safe. They will have far-reaching consequences beyond the ICC itself.
US lawfare against the entire international justice system threatens all accountability mechanisms because of the chilling effect it is having and is designed to have. We need to publicly and unequivocally condemn the actions of the US when it comes to the ICC. With that in mind, I would like to know if the Minister has written to the US ambassador outlining Ireland's horror at the decision made and demanding those sanctions be revoked.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for raising this matter, which she has raised on a consistent basis. We share the same view and opinion when it comes to the actions of the US and, in particular, the actions it has taken against the International Criminal Court. I will use this opportunity to restate the Irish Government's position and our steadfast support of the International Criminal Court and the Rome Statute framework. We consider the court to be the cornerstone of the international criminal justice system and, indeed, an essential institution in the global fight against impunity.
I, as a Minister, and we, as a country, including many in this House, expressed profound regret following the recent decision of the United States to impose sanctions on the ICC as an institution, on its officials and on those who co-operate with the court. We consider that such measures risk undermining the international system of accountability established under the Rome Statute.
The Government has been consistent in calling for all measures against the ICC to be withdrawn. I personally took the opportunity to reiterate this position on several occasions during the recent UN high-level week in September. The most recent move had not taken place at that point, but there was an anticipation that there would be a move against the court.
In particular, I attended a meeting, led by my colleagues from Austria and Liechtenstein, that brought together not just European colleagues but other members states to reaffirm our support for the ICC and to identify the risks that are starting to play out. As the Senator said, it is clear that certain countries are being targeted, and pressure is being put on them. How, as a collective, we reach out, engage with, support and work with those countries and other member states at risk was very much a focus of the discussions at that meeting.
I also had the honour of depositing lreland’s instruments of ratification for the outstanding amendments to the court’s Rome Statute, which again publicly showed our support while at the UN high-level week in the US.
As the Senator knows, the Taoiseach then emphasised Ireland’s support for the ICC in our national statement to the General Assembly.
I again underlined Ireland’s continued support for the ICC when I met with Judge Tomoko Akane in Dublin only a couple of weeks ago, when she delivered the keynote address at the opening of the Irish judicial year, at which our judicial representative bodies showed their support for her. In particular, she spoke about the possible impact on the financial institutions in one or two member states, such as the Netherlands, and the need for us to provide support to those institutions in a very public way.
In our role as President of the EU Council, Ireland is committed to playing its part in maintaining full solidarity with the court at this crucial moment. We are actively engaged in efforts to ensure that the court can carry out its mandate independently, impartially and, importantly, free from external interference. We have convened a series of additional meetings of the ICC working party group to discuss not just the US campaign against the court but also the more recent announcement of institutional sanctions.
The European Union's blocking statute, as the Senator mentioned, is an important tool available to the EU to protect European economic operators from the extraterritorial application of third country laws. The statute prohibits EU economic operators from complying with the extraterritorial legislation listed in an annexe to the statute unless they are authorised to do so by the Commission. It is for the European Commission to propose or decide when that will be activated. Ireland has been calling on the Commission for some time to be ready and prepared to use it if that decision is taken.
There are different views among member states, and this was expressly stated by a number of my colleagues at the last meeting that Ireland hosted. The sanctions that have been proposed against the ICC have been deferred for six months and, therefore, people see an opportunity within this time to try to reverse them. Imposing the blocking statute means that the institutions themselves have two sets of obligations against them and it creates even more complexities for them, so it is quite a significant move to make.
At the same time, Ireland has been clear that if an agreement is not reached and if the US does not pull back on those sanctions, we need to be in a position whereby the EU can apply them. That is exactly the position we have got to now, where there is a role for diplomacy. In particular, our Dutch colleagues and others have very much been engaged on this. However, we see a role for us during the Presidency in reaching out and engaging with our US colleagues to find that pathway. If it does not happen, we have been clear that the blocking statute should be used, and we have called for that for some time.
Comment on this
It is very helpful to hear about the whole path of the six months' deferral and so on. Has the Minister already spoken to the US ambassador specifically on that dialogue? If she has, what is the feeling?
My concern, which I am sure the Minister shares, is that we have only ever seen the US escalate over the past 12 months. The ramping-up of language towards the ICC has just increased and has not de-escalated.
We have systematically tried to treat the US Administration with kid gloves and to appease it. We have also tried to cajole it, but it is just not interested in that. It is interested in shoring up its base before the mid-term elections in a few weeks, and in sowing chaos on the international stage because it benefits its domestic policies.
I urge the Minister to liaise with her colleagues, the other foreign affairs ministers, in the other member states to question the logic. Appeasement has been shown to fail when it comes to the current US Administration.
Perhaps not today, but it would be great to know a little more about the plans that the Commission is putting in place to diversify our service providers, for example, Mastercard and Visa. Maybe that is a matter for the Department of enterprise to discuss, but we are vulnerable to these types of things because of our dependency on US service providers for every aspect of our daily lives.
Comment on this
This was an issue I discussed with the president of the International Criminal Court, Tomoko Akane. It has been able to diversify and detangle a lot of the instruments it uses but it is limited in how far it can go. There is a reliance there that we need to take into consideration, not just in the context of the ICC but more generally. That is certainly an issue people are aware of.
On the EU's approach, I would say, contrary to the Senator's view, that when there were attempts by the US to specifically target individual member states from a trade perspective, and attempts to suggest a different approach would be taken, the EU was clear in saying that we have quite blunt instruments available to us and if any single member state is targeted, we, as an EU 27, are not afraid to use them. It was not a matter of implementation. It was about being clear that EU members will stand up for each other collectively in response to any particular targeted mechanisms by the US.
The same approach is being applied here but, first and foremost, diplomacy always works better. Ireland knows that. We have a good and positive relationship with the US at many levels. The approach we are taking, to answer the Senator's question, is that we have engaged with the US in a number of different ways to try to get us to the point where we can pull back from any significant mechanism having to be used on the EU side. That would not benefit anybody. It would leave a more difficult position for the court in being able to operate and for those who support it. We will do everything we can and I will work with my colleagues, particularly my Dutch colleague, to provide support and to find a way forward without having to invoke blocking statutes. That would suit everybody better.