We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Defence Bill debate guillotine

Summary

Black says guillotining debate on the Defence (Amendment) Bill would curtail scrutiny of major changes to overseas deployments and Ireland’s neutrality.

I raise the topic of the Government’s plans for the Defence (Amendment) Bill and, in particular, its decision to guillotine the debate on the Bill in the Dáil tomorrow. It is very worrying. The Bill removes the triple lock and requirement of a United Nations mandate before Irish troops are sent overseas in military missions, and for deployments of 50 or fewer it removes the need for a Dáil vote at all. This is one of the most significant changes to Irish foreign and defence policy in a generation and it goes to the heart of our neutrality. It is very worrying that the Government proposes to cut short time and not allow our elected representatives in the Dáil to examine it properly. I ask for an assurance that when the Bill comes to this House, it would not be rushed in the same way and that Senators would be given the full time needed to consider it properly.

We should remember where the triple lock came from. In 2002, after the people rejected the first Nice treaty, the State gave a solemn commitment in the national declaration. The triple lock was part of that promise. It was given to the people and it should not be taken from them by a whipped vote and a guillotine. The Government says the triple lock hands a veto to other countries, but our existing law already allows for missions authorised by the General Assembly where there is no veto. The real question is who decides if the UN does not. Under this Bill it would be the Government of the day with less oversight from the Oireachtas and not more. Irish neutrality is definitely not a weakness. It is why our peacekeepers are trusted in places where others are not and it is why our voice is listened to. We are one of the most respected countries in the world because of our neutrality. That reputation was built by members of the Defence Forces who served under the blue flag, some of whom never came home. If the Government is confident in its case, let it make that case fully in both Houses with the time it deserves. Better still, let us put the question to the people. I think we definitely need a referendum on this.

I ask the Leader to arrange an urgent debate in this House on Irish neutrality before the Bill is rushed through. The people we represent deserve to hear that discussion in full and this House deserves the chance to have it.

Comment on this