We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Items in this session

The Order of Business is No. 1, motion regarding the report of the Joint Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation, and Taoiseach under Standing Order 127 on a proposal for a Council directive amending Directives Nos. 2003/49/EC, 2009/133/EC, 2011/96/EU, (EU) 2016/1164, (EU) 2017/1852, and (EU) 2025/50 as regards the simplification of the Union framework on direct taxation and supporting the growth and competitiveness of the EU, COM (2026) 560, reasoned opinion, to be taken without debate on the conclusion of the Order of Business; No. 2, motion regarding the orders of reference for the Joint Committee on Preventing and Responding to Domestic, Sexual and Gender-Based Violence, to be taken without debate on conclusion of No. 1; No.3, motion regarding the Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund Regulations 2026, referral to committee, to be taken without debate on the conclusion of No. 2; No. 4, motion regarding Protection of Young Persons (Employment in Food and Beverage Services Sector) Regulations 2026, referral to committee, to be taken without debate on the conclusion of No. 3; No. 5, statements on disability matters, to be taken at 3.45 p.m. and to conclude at 5 p.m. if not previously concluded, with the opening remarks of the Minister not to exceed ten minutes, group spokespersons not to exceed eight minutes, all other Senators not to exceed five minutes, and the Minister to be given not less than ten minutes to reply to the debate; No. 5a, Employment Equality and Institutional Burials (Amendment) Bill 2026 - all Stages, to be taken at 5 p.m., and the proceedings thereon shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion at 7 p.m. by the putting of one question from the Chair, which shall, in relation to amendments, include only those set down or accepted by Government, with the time allocated to the opening remarks of the Minister during the debate on Second Stage not to exceed ten minutes, group spokespersons not to exceed eight minutes, all Senators not to exceed eight minutes, and the Minister to be given not less than ten minutes to reply to the debate, with Committee and Remaining Stages to be taken immediately thereafter; and No. 5b, motion regarding the earlier signature of the Employment Equality and Institutional Burials (Amendment) Bill 2026, to be taken without debate on the conclusion of No. 5a.

Comment on this

Vaping is a serious public health concern in Ireland, particularly for young people. It is an issue that has been raised in this House on many occasions. I commend the Government on the work it has done to prohibit the sale of vapes to people under the age of 18, the advertising restrictions it has brought in, the introduction of a retail licensing system for vaping, the prohibition of single-use vapes, and packaging and display regulations.

However, there is another vaping-related issue that we can no longer ignore, which is the proliferation and density of vape shops in town and city centres right across Ireland. I am sure everyone here can relate to that. In any town or city in Ireland, all one sees is one vape shop after another. This concentration of shops dedicated to selling vaping products really is destroying village, town and city centres. They are often in prominent locations close to schools, youth facilities and sports clubs. That is very wrong.

The shops are also making our town centres less attractive. Their shopfronts, bright lighting and garish displays can undermine the character of our towns and cities at a time when we are trying to make them attractive places for people to socialise and shop, rather than shopping online. The proliferation of vape shops is counterproductive to that aim.

I am really concerned about the way some vaping products are presented. Fruit imagery, cartoon-style graphics, bright colours and eye-catching window displays can make them especially appealing to children. This is a very serious public health concern. It is completely and wholly unacceptable that vape shops are making these products more attractive to young people. I am particularly concerned about the existence of American candy shops that are selling vapes alongside their other products. That is really wrong and it must be addressed. Schools' youth facilities and sports clubs should be places where young people are encouraged to pursue healthy activities, not environments where vaping is normalised by the nearby visibility and concentration of these retail outlets.

I call for a debate in the House with the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage on the urgent need to introduce planning regulations governing vape shops across Ireland. I ask the Minister to work with local authorities to introduce a clear national planning framework for vape retailers. First, we should establish a distinct and dedicated planning use category for vape shops such that applications to open a new outlet or change an existing premises into a vape shop can be properly assessed by the local planning authority. Second, we need to introduce clear rules on proximity to schools, youth centres and sports facilities, with appropriate exclusion distances supported by public health evidence. Third, we must address the density of these outlets. Fourth, we should introduce appropriate standards for shopfronts, signage, lighting and external displays. Town centres should be places where healthy lifestyles are supported, not locations for the proliferation of vape shops, which are destroying the fabric of our towns and cities and damaging public health.

Comment on this

I acknowledge the very real concerns that exist regarding access to the HSE school dental service. The purpose of the service is prevention. Children with dental problems should be identified early in order that treatment can be provided before the problem becomes serious. The established national programme provides for examination of pupils in second, fourth and sixth classes. The service has come under massive pressure, mainly because of difficulties in recruiting and retaining dental staff. The impact of that pressure has been compounded by the disruption of services during the Covid period. In Donegal, there are children who have waited well beyond the timeframe intended under the school dental programme. This is concerning because early dental assessment is a priority to prevent problems developing and becoming more serious.

I do not want to minimise the problem and I want to be clear that the response simply cannot be to accept a reduced service as normal. The HSE must continue to recruit and retain dental staff to address and work through the vacancies. The objective must be clear, namely, to restore school dental services that identify the problem early, provide appropriate treatment and ensure children do not fall through the gaps because of a capacity problem.

Not a week goes by without a parent in Donegal approaching me about the school dental service. Will the Leader ask the Minister to come to the House for a debate on the issue? I would like to ask the Minister whether private dentists could be availed of to clear the waiting lists.

It really is a matter of priority. It seems to be swept under the carpet in Donegal but it needs to be sorted.

Comment on this

I propose an amendment to the Order of Business that No. 13 on the Order Paper be taken before No. 1. I will be introducing the Patient Safety (Right to Escalation and Clinical Review) Bill 2026. I understand that Senator Conway will formally second the amendment shortly.

The reason I am bringing this Bill is that a number of months ago we had Professor Steve Kerrigan before the petitions committee on the topic of sepsis, and he brought in family members of people who had died from sepsis. One lady was Sinéad O'Reilly, who has been in this House with me before. She spoke about her sister-in-law Sarah, who had two young kids and who died after failures to recognise and treat sepsis on time. We also had Ciarán Staunton, whose 12-year-old son Rory had been playing basketball, got a knock and was brought to hospital, and he was dead within a number of hours. Professor Kerrigan reminded us that we are seeing more and more sepsis in sicker and older populations, and that there are fewer effective drugs to treat it.

With my Bill, the idea is to see sepsis as a medical emergency where time is absolutely of the essence. Statistics show that sepsis is one of the leading causes of preventable death in healthcare systems around the world. The tragedy is that many patients show warning signs long before they become critically ill. The Bill is aimed at ensuring protocols are in place and are acted on immediately. It will give patients and families a statutory right to trigger an urgent clinical review. In the case of sepsis, delay costs lives. Early recognition and response will save lives. Also, families often spot signs of sepsis long before the medical profession because they know the patient well. They notice changes in behaviour, colour of skin, alertness, pain levels, etc. Many families affected by sepsis have spoken about raising concerns, yet the concerns were not acknowledged because medical treatment was being given and sepsis was not considered. This Bill empowers families to escalate such that sepsis must be considered urgent review. Families are a valuable early-warning system for sepsis.

Furthermore, the Bill seeks to introduce a culture of sepsis awareness in every hospital in Ireland. The legislation goes beyond creating rights; it requires every hospital to maintain 24-hour critical review teams that would implement a sepsis-response protocol. The objective is very simple: regardless of where a patient presents in Ireland, there should be a clear pathway for recognising sepsis quickly and responding without delay. Every family who have lost a loved one and have been in here to give evidence have said that intervention, if it had happened sooner, could have saved lives. This Bill seeks to ensure that when warning signs appear, voices are heard, reviews are triggered and action is taken. It is about turning lessons learned from tragedy into a system that gives every patient the best possible chance at survival.

Comment on this

I raise the issue of Dublin City Council's maintenance service for residents in flat complexes. The response that Dublin City Council delivers to residents in flat complexes really is disastrous. Recently, there was a rent increase for tenants. It was suggested that there would be some sort of increase and improvement in maintenance services but that has absolutely not happened. There has been no improvement in maintenance services for council tenants, whether they live in Beech Hill in Donnybrook, on Rathmines Avenue, in Pearse House or in Markievicz House. I have named a few complexes there, and I know residents in other places will be giving out that I have not mentioned their flats. I can guarantee, however, that in every single flat complex belonging to Dublin City Council on the south side, there are serious maintenance issues the council is not responding to. There has been no improvement.

I suggest what is needed now is that rent hike to be reversed, particularly with the cost of living and the lack of improved maintenance. There is no justification for a rent hike. It is completely unacceptable.

I was contacted by a number of residents over the past week. For whatever reason, it seems to be that replacement boilers are needed. There has been a spike in the need for replacement boilers. The boilers have gone. They are being told that it will take ten weeks to get a new boiler in. With the weather getting increasingly cold, it is particularly difficult for families and older people who need the heat. Ten weeks is a ridiculous and completely unreasonable time to have to wait for a replacement boiler. At the same time, the rents are going up. It is really rubbing their noses in it and it is very unfair. There has to be an investment in maintenance and regeneration plans. It is not just boilers. There is dampness and mould. Rats are running around and having the time of their lives while residents have to put up with it and tolerate it. It is completely unacceptable. There needs to be a dedicated maintenance team. To be fair to maintenance staff, they are overwhelmed because of the state of the housing stock, and they have to repair that.

In many of the complexes, for example, Pearse House, residents feel unsafe daily. An example of that is where the archway into Pearse House is a centre for crack cocaine deals. In fact, there was one poor woman who did not have enough money for her crack and she slit her wrists. The ambulance service was involved and the fire brigade had to come down to wash down the walls. That area is unsafe for residents from Pearse House, including older residents and residents with families, coming through and in and out of that area. There is a real concern that there is a lack of safety within the inner city, in particular at the moment into Pearse House through the archway.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh Cameron Sheldon atá san Áiléar Poiblí. Tá sé liom ar thaithí oibre i m’oifig. I welcome Cameron Sheldon. He is on work experience with me from Coláiste Pobail Osraí in Kilkenny.

I raise the issue of the accommodation recognition payment, ARP. There is deep concern by many of the humanitarian organisations here in relation to the intention of the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, not to seek a further extension of the scheme beyond 2027. The ARP provides an invaluable support to households around the country who have opened their doors and homes to accommodation for beneficiaries of temporary protection, BOTPs, following the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. We can see on our TV screens every night that the conflict is deepening and worsening by the day.

The ARP is currently issued to over 22,300 homeowners and supports accommodation of over 39,000 BOTPs. The intention of the Minister is to withdraw this at a critical time. I call on the Minister to extend the ARP to March 2028 in line with the extension of the temporary protection directive. The ARP must be extended. The scheme should remain in place as long as the temporary protection directive continues to apply and is needed. A wider review of the ARP should be carried out to explore how legislative change might broaden the scope of the scheme to benefit more cohorts. This is something that those in receipt of the ARP would welcome. BOTPs facing homelessness should also be eligible to declare themselves as vulnerable for the purpose of applying for continued State-provided accommodation. Eligibility for the temporary protection transition scheme should allow those residing in ARP-supported accommodation to apply.

There is no evidence to suggest that the ARP is having a negative impact on the private rental market. The vast majority, 91%, of those signing up for the scheme are not landlords. I express deep concern. I would welcome an opportunity for the Minister to come in and talk to the House in relation to it. We are going to create another homelessness crisis here if this is to proceed in its present form. I ask the Minister to give consideration to extending the scheme beyond March 2028.

Comment on this

This week is Invisible Disabilities Week, from 18 to 24 October.

Invisible disabilities can include neurological disorders, chronic illness, mental health conditions and other conditions that affect daily life like autism or special needs. It is a time to raise awareness, challenge misconceptions and show support for people living with these conditions that are not always visible to others.

I have come from a very informative talk in the audiovisual room on the ministerial launch of the report on On Feirm Ground 2, OFG2. Coming from a rural community and a farming background, it is clear the issue of farmers’ mental health is growing daily. The statistics for so many, whether male or female, are increasing across the country. OFG2 is run by the Men’s Development Network. It takes a practical approach and is a very successful programme. It trains the people the farmers are already meeting daily, whether the farm inspector, the Teagasc adviser, the nurse from the vet or the vet himself, in a way that enables them to see the distress, stress and anxiety the farmers may be under. They are trained to start up a conversation and to know and highlight the supports and services that are there for the members of the farming community.

This week I am asking people to reach out to those in our communities. Winter is coming, the evenings are getting shorter and life can be difficult for so many. We do not know what the illness is that can be with anybody. Just because we do not see it and it is not physical does not mean it does not exist. We are very lucky in our country to have our own Minister of State with responsibility for mental health who has increased the budget for the sixth consecutive year. Extra hours have been allocated for counselling services. For those who are in distress or looking for support, reach out, connect and link in.

Comment on this

I raise the topic of the Government’s plans for the Defence (Amendment) Bill and, in particular, its decision to guillotine the debate on the Bill in the Dáil tomorrow. It is very worrying. The Bill removes the triple lock and requirement of a United Nations mandate before Irish troops are sent overseas in military missions, and for deployments of 50 or fewer it removes the need for a Dáil vote at all. This is one of the most significant changes to Irish foreign and defence policy in a generation and it goes to the heart of our neutrality. It is very worrying that the Government proposes to cut short time and not allow our elected representatives in the Dáil to examine it properly. I ask for an assurance that when the Bill comes to this House, it would not be rushed in the same way and that Senators would be given the full time needed to consider it properly.

We should remember where the triple lock came from. In 2002, after the people rejected the first Nice treaty, the State gave a solemn commitment in the national declaration. The triple lock was part of that promise. It was given to the people and it should not be taken from them by a whipped vote and a guillotine. The Government says the triple lock hands a veto to other countries, but our existing law already allows for missions authorised by the General Assembly where there is no veto. The real question is who decides if the UN does not. Under this Bill it would be the Government of the day with less oversight from the Oireachtas and not more. Irish neutrality is definitely not a weakness. It is why our peacekeepers are trusted in places where others are not and it is why our voice is listened to. We are one of the most respected countries in the world because of our neutrality. That reputation was built by members of the Defence Forces who served under the blue flag, some of whom never came home. If the Government is confident in its case, let it make that case fully in both Houses with the time it deserves. Better still, let us put the question to the people. I think we definitely need a referendum on this.

I ask the Leader to arrange an urgent debate in this House on Irish neutrality before the Bill is rushed through. The people we represent deserve to hear that discussion in full and this House deserves the chance to have it.

Comment on this

I acknowledge the presence in the Public Gallery of Maeve Kenny and her mother. Maeve works in my constituency office and I am very grateful for the work that she does day in day out. It is fantastic to be able to host the two of them here in Leinster House. I hope they have a very enjoyable day.

Five months on from the shocking arson attack, I raise the current situation of Blackwater Garda station. On 26 May, an arson attack was carried out that has left Blackwater Garda station closed for the past five months. At the last meeting of Wexford County Council, Councillor Oliver Walsh, as the local councillor from Blackwater, put forward a motion urging the Garda Commissioner and the OPW to reopen the station which was supported unanimously by the members of Wexford County Council. Does the OPW have a clear timeline for when Blackwater Garda station will be reopened?

It is important to recognise that an arson attack at a Garda station is an attempt to undermine the work of An Garda Síochána. It was very fortunate that nobody was burnt or killed in this incident which has not got the media coverage it warrants and deserves. It is important we recognise that an attack on a Garda station by fire is an attack on the institution of An Garda Síochána and it must be condemned from the highest possible level.

It is important for a rural village 15 km east of Enniscorthy to have a Garda station. It does not just serve the immediate village but other villages in the region, like Kilmuckridge, Screen, Curracloe, Blackwater, Oulart and the Ballagh. I would like to get a commitment that the OPW will reopen the Garda station and that there will be a full and thorough investigation into the security of our Garda stations. Five months on, I have been informed that while the investigation is still under way, no arrests have been made on this yet.

Comment on this

Tacaím leis an mBille atá á thógáil isteach ag an Seanadóir McCarthy. I am seconding his Bill, which is extremely timely. I do not want to paraphrase what Senator McCarthy said, but we all need to be able to respond to the signs, heed the warnings and trigger action when this very serious condition strikes.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I welcome the guests of Senator Cathal Byrne, Maeve Kenny from his constituency office, and Etty Kilbride. I hope they enjoy their visit to Leinster House and especially here to the Seanad.

Comment on this

I wholeheartedly support the comments made by my colleague Senator Clifford Lee on vape shops, something I raised here only two weeks ago. That debate is urgently needed. It is not just the scourge of how many there are and the aesthetic problems we have with them, it is also that they are selling HHC which is illegal. They are selling to under-age individuals which is illegal and they are also stocking marijuana products which are highly addictive and also illegal. We need to have that debate urgently. On Friday, I had a meeting with Louth County Council on this particular issue to see what we can do to assist the council with planning issues. The fact that they are calling them lower order retail and they want different retail gives a real indication of how everybody feels about them.

At the very same meeting with Louth County Council executives on Friday, at the top of my list of requests was of course the proposed northside railway station in Drogheda. I was heartened to hear that Louth County Council is now holding a feasibility study for this station. It shows the level of commitment that there has been right along for this vital infrastructure.

It was quite amusing that one of the first local representatives out of the traps to spread this news had always said there was a lack of commitment to this, calling it an orphan project, while everybody else was beavering away in the background. I met with the transport Minister in March 2026 and rather than what was reported last week - that it was the first time he had commented publicly on this possibly going ahead - back then, in March, he said it made absolute sense but that it needed a business model. There will be a feasibility study. It will be the first step towards that model and making it happen. As for a commitment from Government level, the €24 million that had been given by my colleague, James Browne, in the housing Department as part of the housing activation fund will support the bridge, which will also support the rest of that. I am very pleased to see that feasibility study and the firm commitment to make this vital piece of infrastructure happen.

Comment on this

I want to follow on from Senator Imelda Goldsboro and Senator McCarthy about hidden illness and illnesses we cannot see. I contacted the Minister for Health earlier today to ask her to immediately roll out a national education campaign on endometriosis. Endometriosis impacts your physical and mental health. You can experience cramping, bloating, pelvic pain, bowel issues, extreme fatigue, depression and problems with fertility, and that is not even the full list of symptoms. I have heard in recent months from so many women who feel completely let down by the health system. They have presented to different GPs or consultants with serious health concerns only to be misdiagnosed or just prescribed antidepressants and sent on their way.

RTÉ has been doing a great job on this recently. It has aired a few programmes and since it has done so, I have had women come to me. It is a good thing that people are getting to know what endometriosis is. There are young girls and women going into school or work every day in pain and they cannot understand why. They are being gaslit and are often told it is a bad period or probably a hormonal issue that will sort itself out. I hear from people contacting me that this seems to be a trend among them all - they have been told that it will sort itself out. There seems to be a pattern between neglect and being ignored.

What is even more worrying is the lack of knowledge within the medical community itself. I have heard many women got a diagnosis only because their sister, a friend or somebody on Facebook had said something about this. Women have to share their own personal experiences in the hope that they will find out what is wrong with them. These women have spent many years being made to feel crazy or that there is something wrong with them in their heads. The fact that endometriosis has been spoken about more recently on RTÉ and in the mainstream media is a good thing, but the framework the Minister has set out is that an information campaign will be rolled out. I would like to get an update on that because I do not see anything about it. Similar to sepsis, in the doctor's waiting room, all you need is a poster.

Sarah O'Reilly, who died of sepsis, was from Bailieborough, the same town I am from. She had twins, she had sepsis after the twins were born and she died when they were just a few weeks old. Her month's anniversary mass was on Sunday. I just wanted to remember Sarah today.

Comment on this

Today marks the 19th anniversary of the brutal murder of Paul Quinn from County Armagh, who was murdered near Oram in County Monaghan. This young man suffered a horrific death. He was apprehended by up to ten men, who spent half an hour beating him with iron bars and nail-studded bars. They broke every single major bone in his body. Today I think on his mother Breege and on his father Stephen, and indeed the wider family. They are still seeking answers. Not alone are they trying to come to terms with that brutal death and the loss of their son; they would like to finally bring closure to his death. I echo the appeal they have out today, and the appeal the Garda the PSNI have out, for anyone with any information whatsoever, no matter how insignificant they may feel it is, to please come forward in order that this family finally can have closure.

I would also like to raise, as many people have in this House, how fortunate we are as a State to have the men and woman of Óglaigh na hÉireann serving this country. Today, the Representative Association of Commissioned Officers, RACO, is holding its annual conference. It has indicated a number of asks it would like addressed. These are historical asks that have gone past any person's definition of a reasonable timeframe before being addressed. I ask that the Minister for Defence, Deputy McEntee, might come to the House at her convenience so we can discuss issues that have been outstanding for too long so that we can give the respect the men and women of the Defence Forces so richly deserve.

Comment on this

I want to raise an issue about UHL in Limerick. I attended a briefing for Oireachtas Members by HSE Mid West yesterday. To be honest, I was quite shocked coming out of the briefing. The situation in UHL was described as "dire" and it was said there was a "possibility of threat to life" over the winter season. We have heard for the past couple of years that something will be done with UHL, that we have the HIQA report with the three options and that more investment will definitely be put into it.

At present, there are 160 vacancies just for community posts. They are not even for acute care. It is also constrained from using community services so it cannot discharge patients because the funding has been stopped. There is an overflow in the hospital and there are constantly trolleys in all the wards. We know there is an issue with overcrowding in UHL, yet the funding has been stopped. It is not allowed to use community services. There are elderly people there who could be discharged to community services, and people with disabilities who should be, but they are kept there because UHL's hands are tied - funding has been stopped. This needs to be raised with the Minister for Health. We cannot go into another winter season and see UHL back on the news every day.

In 2020, 64,000 people went through accident and emergency. This year, it is looking at 102,000. It is shocking. We heard from the head of UHL who told us she feels there will be a risk to life. She has given us plenty us plenty of notice. This needs to be looked at. The mid-west is constantly in the news whether it is because we do not have the funding, the willpower or political will to do this. This needs to be done. We cannot have another case like we did last year and the year before of death in the hospital when it could have been prevented.

Comment on this

It is a week on since the tragic deaths of Philip and Kim English and their two sons. I remember them there today. I think it is fair to say the country has been reeling ever since the events in Waterford and a similar incident in Offaly approximately two years ago. If anything good is to come out of this, it shines a light on what has been almost normalised as drug debts. There is no such thing as a drug debt. The sale of drugs in this country is illegal. Anybody involved in the sale of drugs is committing an illegal act. Anyone who owes them money is not in debt. For too long, we have allowed it to be brushed under the carpet. We have not given the people caught in this constant spiral the support and help they need at the most difficult times.

I would like the Minister for justice and the Garda Commissioner to convene at the highest level to finally take this scourge to task. We saw the effects CAB had on the drug dealers in that it went after their money. We should go after this money as well and after the pain and the anguish they are unleashing across the community.

This is not just confined to Dublin and the big cities like Waterford and Galway. It is across rural Ireland. I will tell the tale, with his permission, of a small farmer and his wife who have two sons. The two of them got caught up in a spiral of drugs which the parents never would have thought would happen. Suddenly, calls started coming to the door, cars coming into the yard late at night looking for money, demanding money with menace and constantly putting the family under fear and intimidating them. Ultimately, that man was forced to sell off all his cattle to pay off the drug debts. There is no human way those two boys could have consumed the amount of drugs the drug gang claimed in the value of that money.

We have many vile crimes in this country but this is one of the most heinous crimes because it preys on that bond between parents and their children. Nobody wants their children to go out and take drugs, nobody wants their children to be intimidated and nobody wants their children to be at risk. Beyond doubt, we are failing these families because they have no support. I am tired of parents coming to me to tell me they are in this situation and there is no point going to An Garda Síochána. In fairness, An Garda Síochána says there is very little it can do. We have to put a structure in place once and for all and we need a national initiative from the Government, the Taoiseach and the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration down, along with the Garda Commissioner, to tackle this scourge that is plaguing the country and crippling and killing families. It is a silent killer that is worse than the drugs themselves.

Comment on this

I raise a proposal that was suggested to me recently. It has come up a number of times with hauliers in County Mayo and I know it is felt across industry and throughout the country. It concerns the introduction of a traffic commissioner and I call on the Minister for Transport to consider it. I have also raised it in the Oireachtas Committee on Transport.

There is a disparity on this island between the two jurisdictions, North and South, in terms of how drivers from the Republic of Ireland are treated in the North versus how Northern Irish drivers coming into the Republic are treated. There are limits on the amount of drop-offs that can be done by drivers in the UK jurisdiction before they have to re-enter the Republic of Ireland and it causes a lot of difficulty. The fining of different vehicles happens in the North where levies on Irish drivers are paid but there is no corresponding case with UK drivers in the South. There needs to be parity across both jurisdictions. The introduction of a traffic commissioner to oversee and implement rules and regulations that are standardised would be a big help for hauliers. I know the Road Safety Authority and other State entities would support this proposal.

I again call on the Minister for Transport to support further funding for the local improvement scheme and road safety schemes. I was contacted by residents of the Colony in Dugort on Achill Island about road safety issues as Kinturlin Road and Spout Lane are in a serious state of disrepair. The LIS funding is important for rural communities as it allows roads to be resurfaced. The notice of motion funding and the low-cost safety funding are really important in terms of improving road safety and signage because many of these roads are affected by tourists travelling through and animals passing on commonage land. We need to have a conversation on this and support the residents in Dugort and the rest of Achill Island. I call on Mayo County Council to engage with them.

Comment on this

I will talk about the legal aid dispute and the consequences we are starting to see in terms of accessing justice. The Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan, needs to resolve this crisis, which is escalating to the extreme. We are seeing harm being inflicted on victims in the wider justice system as a consequence. The consequences are growing every day. Thousands of criminal cases have been adjourned.

The withdrawal of legal aid services has widened to include cases involving people in custody with children. The impact on access to justice is becoming serious. Last week, a case was reported involving a woman being cross-examined by her former partner who is alleged to have threatened to rape and kill her. Anyone of us can imagine how utterly appalling it is to be cross-examined by the alleged perpetrator of a crime against us. The incident arose because the woman's former partner could not secure legal representation during the solicitors' strike. I do not know how that was allowed to happen. From a victim-centred approach, it is utterly outrageous. No person - no woman - should have to face the ordeal of being questioned directly by the person accused of such threats without appropriate safeguards being considered, and it feels in this case as if nothing about the victim was considered. This case brings into sharp focus what is at stake when it comes to the legal aid dispute and what could happen if we allow it to continue escalating.

Adjournments lead to disruption and huge personal and financial costs for someone waiting for justice, often in circumstances of enormous distress and vulnerability.

I do not know if the Minister is really acknowledging the seriousness of this situation. It seems like he is playing chicken, to a certain extent, with the solicitors. Without proper mediation and engagement, this dispute is not going to end in a productive way. It is, first and foremost, the victims in these cases who are losing out. We talk about the awful violence, including drug attacks, and all the other terrible things that are happening. In the cases before the courts, it is the victims who will not get justice in a timely way if this dispute is not resolved.

Comment on this

I will talk today about the continued failures in women's healthcare. We held a health summit this weekend in response to a survey of 6,500 women on the failures they are experiencing in women's healthcare in Ireland. It was disturbing to listen to the stories. Women described having to go on the Paddy bus out of Ireland because they cannot get the healthcare they need here. We saw recent "Prime Time" documentaries and last night, on Virgin Media, we saw the documentary, "Health Hysteria: Are Women Being Gaslit?" We need to believe women and listen to them. I acknowledge that after a long campaign for women with endometriosis, the Minister for Health announced a framework, but this framework is not making a difference to women on the ground.

I call for an urgent debate in the House on women's healthcare and access to healthcare right now. All the frameworks, plans and strategies are clearly not making a difference to how women are experiencing healthcare in Ireland. The responses of 6,500 women to the survey are absolutely stark. The issue is not only endometriosis. I asked last week for a debate on breast density following a presentation in the audiovisual room at which we heard from women who have been failed. Some 43% of women have been failed in areas across women's healthcare. Women are not being believed; they are being gaslit. It is misogyny. We need to put plans in place, once and for all, that will lead to action for women, not just plans that are not filtering down into their real lived experiences.

Comment on this

I am sure the Leas-Chathaoirleach can guess what issue I will raise this afternoon. As Oireachtas Members in the mid-west, the Leas-Chathaoirleach and I, along with Senator Collins who was online, attended a briefing yesterday morning in Limerick by the HSE Mid West regarding its winter plans. It was an alarming meeting. We were advised at the meeting that despite the HSE leadership in the region flagging significant concerns about the operation of University Hospital Limerick over the coming months, and given that we had 26 days in September in which there were over 300 presentations in accident and emergency, with projections flagged to go to 400 in the coming months, the hospital has not received the support it has identified would mitigate the avalanche of cases that will come through its doors.

The hospital has flagged with the HSE leadership nationally that it needs to acquire 80 sub-acute beds from a nearby facility. This would give it some small additional surge capacity. We should remember that it is operating at 135% capacity right now and it is moving into a period where there will be 100 additional presentations per day. It needs to acquire those 80 sub-acute beds as a matter of urgency. The hospital also flagged to us that it needs staff and highlighted about 35 different categories of doctors for which it has requested approval. Those two measures are really the only measures the hospital can take as matters stand because there is no further capacity to put in temporary beds. Very little else can be done at this point.

I raise this matter today, as I am sure others have done, and ask that we have an urgent debate on the development of an urgent temporary plan to support University Hospital Limerick in light of the buckling it is experiencing due to demand.

Comment on this

Today, I wish to speak on the proposed roll-out of the shingles vaccination. I very much welcome the Government's decision to introduce a national shingles vaccination programme from 2027. This is a significant and very positive step forward for preventative healthcare, particularly for our older population and those living with underlying health conditions. Up to 10,000 people in this country contract shingles each year. For too long, access to the shingles vaccination has depended largely on a person's ability to pay. The vaccine currently costs in the region of €450 to €480 for the two required doses. For an elderly couple - pensioners living at home - that is up to €1,000, which places it beyond the reach of many people, particularly pensions living on fixed incomes.

Shingles is often dismissed as simply a rash but anyone who has suffered from it knows the reality is very different. It can cause severe pain, prolonged illness and, in some cases, lasting nerve damage that continues for months or even years after the initial infection has cleared. Older people and those with weakened immune systems are particularly vulnerable to these complications. I particularly welcome the fact the roll-out will prioritise those who need it most. The programme is expected to begin in 2027 with immunocompromised individuals, followed by those aged over 80 before gradually extending to all people aged 65 years and over on a phased basis. The vaccines will be delivered through GPs and pharmacists, making it more accessible within communities across the country. This programme represents an investment not only in preventing illnesses but also in reducing pressure on our health services.

Every case of shingles prevented means less suffering for patients, fewer GP visits, fewer hospital admissions and a better quality of life for our older citizens. I welcome the fantastic work done by the Minister for Health, Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, on this and I am hopeful that the roll-out can proceed as quickly as possible so that all eligible people can benefit from this protection without unnecessary delay. This is a very sensible preventative health measure that will improve the lives of thousands of people.

Comment on this

On Saturday, I attended the official opening of Daoine Beaga, which is a new community-run preschool in the Arva area of County Cavan. It was started by seven mothers who were told the previous April their preschool would close. They did not want to separate the children and they wanted something in their area so they put their heads together and organised and opened a community-run childcare facility. They undertook all of the paperwork required to engage with Tusla but they said everybody in the community worked together to get this open. They identified a building, the former Corratober National School which had been closed for 11 years but was still in quite good condition, and the Gowna parish council, the neighbouring parish, gave them the use of the premises. The community got behind them and did all of the work around the school; 90% of the people who did work on the school did it voluntarily. They held fundraisers and raised €27,000 in the community as well. They did not get one cent of Government funding and did all of this work themselves. I commend them.

We talk about the lack of childcare and preschool places in our country and community-led facilities like this are the way to go if we can get communities to come together, which they will, to provide what is needed to get it up and going. I am not saying it is easy - it is not - and the seven mothers who undertook this did great work themselves. They got all of this done in about four months and had it open on 26 August. I commend them for the work they are doing. It is a lovely facility and I visited it on Saturday. The children are so happy there. Since I mentioned Gowna parish council, I had better mention Gowna won the Cavan championship and I congratulate them on their senior championship win, along with my own club, Crosserlough, who won the senior camogie championship the week before. I had better not forget them.

Comment on this

I support Senator McCormack's call for a discussion in the House on women's health. It is something I have spoken to the Leader about and raised previously. It is definitely something we need to have an open discussion about here. It adds to it if the men in this House support that call as well.

Today, I want to speak about the water supply in Cloonfad in west Roscommon. It was the first one I raised back in February 2025. I have raised it repeatedly and have had good engagement with the Department. The Minister, Deputy James Browne, issued a letter to me and other Oireachtas Members in June 2025, stating that a 5 km stretch of new piping would be laid.

Thankfully, two kilometres of that work has been completed and it is hoped three will be completed between now and Christmas, but the community down there is still repeatedly affected by outages. Every time a new piece of pipe goes down, pressure builds up in an older piece, and there is a blowout there as well. I commend the community, both domestic and business users, on their patience during the whole process. I know there was a major outage again last week, and Uisce Éireann had to bring additional water to the village to support those communities.

There were always local water schemes in the area, and a lot of people signed up to them. It seems that the message might not be landing home that Uisce Éireann is looking after this, because I know the managers of the community water schemes are the ones feeling the pressure. I would love and call on Irish Water to go out and actually explain that it is responsible for those community water schemes and take responsibility for them.

Uisce Éireann made us aware last April of a potential investment in the water treatment plant in Castlerea in County Roscommon, and it was great to see it go forward yesterday. Over €13 million is being invested in Castlerea. It is well worth it and will ensure there are no more boil water notices in that part of Roscommon.

Comment on this

I welcome the complementary redistributive income support for sustainability, CRISS, scheme and basic income support for sustainability, BISS, scheme payments to our farmers this week. They are very welcome. I thank all associated with the roll-out of that payment because it caused a lot of anguish last week when it was said it was going to be delayed until the end of the month. I congratulate anybody in the Department who was involved in it.

I also raise the issue of arson attacks in our towns and villages, something that is linked to Senator Flaherty's comments earlier. We have seen a number of arson attacks in the county of Longford where cars have been burned. It is basically a turf war between drug families. We have seen these people decimate cars and vehicles, and it certainly links into what Senator Flaherty said about people coming to families looking for money for drug debts and one thing or another. There is also another part of it where young people run up a debt and they then have to deliver drugs for these people with their own private cars. If they get caught, they are charged rather than those who supplied them with the drugs. It is a huge problem, and it also links into our free legal aid system. These people who supply the drugs are getting free legal aid. A lot of them have made money from the drug trade and are driving around in relatively new vans and cars worth in excess of €80,000 or €100,000, and yet they can still seek free legal aid. Where has the Criminal Assets Bureau, CAB, gone to? Is there any way we can strengthen CAB and start hitting these people where it hurts? The first place we should hit them is in the free legal aid system. They should not be allowed free legal aid. We should also look at the amount of money going into these homes in social welfare benefits. Maybe that is where we should start hitting these families, and we need to raise this issue in this House, because it sends out the wrong message to the hard-working and decent people of Ireland that crime actually pays for these people. This is something that we have to stamp out. We have to stand up and be counted. I would like to see exactly where CAB has gone, and we might see a couple of raids coming into the Longford area in the not-too-distant future.

Comment on this

I thank the 21 Senators who made contributions. Senator Clifford-Lee spoke about vape shops, a scourge that we are witnessing in our local towns. I was on Newstalk talking about it this morning and on LMFM, which Senator Comyn will be happy to know. There are two very good examples of where, over the past 18 months, vape shops have gone up at an incredibly rapid speed. At the same time, we are seeing rural pubs closing, and there is something not right about it. There is an awful lot that we need to do.

Senator Clifford-Lee outlined many of the issues as they relate to proximity to schools and how these vape shops attract younger people. By "younger people", I mean ten- and 11-year-olds, not even 16- or 17-year-olds, which is totally inappropriate. We need to give more powers to local authorities and councillors to determine how a town centre should be used and how shops should be used to promote the good of a town rather than having a proliferation of vape shops or any other type of shop that is not in the public interest or in the interests of the town as the councillors see it. Councillors want to do that but they need direction from the Department of housing and planning. I have spoken to the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, about the issue. His Department is looking at ways that it could be included in the national planning statement to give guidance to councillors. I hope to bring legislation through the Seanad. Our Leas-Chathaoirleach, Senator Maria Byrne, last week started legislation on vape shops. Many of us in this House are concerned about our local communities in that regard.

Senator Boyle spoke about dental services, particularly in Donegal, and the lack of recruitment within the HSE to make sure that early dental appointments can be made for people in schools, particularly those in second, fourth and sixth classes. I suggested that the Senator puts down a Commencement matter on the issue, particularly as it relates to Donegal. There is obviously a recruitment issue within the HSE. As the Senator said, early treatment is crucial for children at that age.

Senator McCarthy, seconded by Senator Joe Conway, asked for item No. 13 to be taken before item No. 1. I agree to that. It is a new Bill relating to sepsis. The Senator has been in this Chamber previously when I have spoken about sepsis. I was going to say I was lucky enough to have it previously but I certainly was not lucky. I agree with everything he outlined about sepsis and the need for early intervention and education. I would probably not be here today if not for a nurse in Clonmel hospital who detected it within two minutes. Two minutes later, I had ten people around me. I was in the intensive care unit for a week thereafter. I came out of it, which is the most important thing. On the Senator's legislation, early detection is critical. It is sometimes families who notice it first before medical experts. I am happy to agree for that item to be brought forward and to be taken before item No. 1.

Senator Andrews spoke about Dublin City Council and funding and maintenance for flat complexes in the area. He mentioned a rent increase. Many of those questions need to be taken up directly by councillors in the area with Dublin City Council. It is not a matter for this House. I know he is using the opportunity to highlight those concerns. He gave good examples where people need new boilers and support during the winter months and I take that on board.

Senator Noonan spoke about the accommodation recognition payment. He is quick out of the traps on this issue. It comes up in March every year. A yearly decision is made by the Minister for justice in respect of the accommodation recognition payment. It is a payment for people across the country who have taken in Ukrainians since the start of the war. It supports them financially in return for giving a room. It has been successful. As the Senator said, many people who had never before been landlords have taken in people. It has not had an impact on housing in any way whatsoever because these people would never previously have been letting out their rooms. The payment is important. It seems that every year, the decision is made in the last week of March. The Senator is right that things are changing within Ukraine and it is hard to see how people would want to go back in the next couple of months during the winter. I am sure the Minister would be open to a debate and to reviewing that when it arises March 2027.

Senator Goldsboro spoke about Invisible Disability Week. She spoke about farmers, disabilities and mental health issues. It is a matter that the Minister, Deputy Heydon, has been vocal on for a long number of years. One of the reasons that discussion groups were set up for farmers was to challenge or fight against that isolation. Certain elderly farmers would not meet people from one week to the next. They might meet the postman or someone else but they were not meeting their neighbours. That discussion group has been helpful in the sharing of knowledge and education from a farming perspective. It has also been important from a social perspective and the more we can do, the better. The Minister of State, Deputy Butler, has done an awful lot of work on mental health in recent years and in bringing considerations around it into farming.

Senator Black spoke about the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026, which is to be debated in the Dáil tomorrow, in respect of the triple lock. She spoke about how the time given to the debate in the Dáil has been cut short. It is for the Dáil Business Committee to decide how long the Dáil debates matters. When it is finished in the Dáil it will go to the committee. How long it stays under discussion in the defence committee will determine how long we have to discuss it in the Seanad. I would like to think that people know I try not to speed things through this House, as much as possible. I am aware that there many Members in the Chamber will be eager to have enough time to speak on that Bill. I will certainly do my best to make sure it is possible for everyone to debate it and to have adequate time to speak on it.

Senator Cathal Byrne raised the Garda station in Blackwater. His party colleague Councillor Ollie Walsh has also been very vocal on this. It is important that the Garda station is reopened. Small towns and villages need local Garda stations to give reassurance to people and the public that it is safe and that gardaí are present. As the Senator said, an arson attack on a Garda station is an attack on the State and needs to be investigated. I hope arrests will be made.

Senator Joe Conway raised the issue of sepsis, which I have covered already.

Senator Comyn spoke about vape shops, which I have covered already as Senator Clifford-Lee raised the issue as well. In fairness to Senator Comyn, I think this is her third or fourth time raising the matter. I know Dundalk and Louth have seen a proliferation of vape shops in the last 18 months. It is of huge concern. Senator Comyn also spoke about the northside rail station investment from the Department of Transport, which is hugely important and very welcome.

Senator Sarah O'Reilly spoke about sepsis and hidden illness.

Senator Gallagher spoke about the murder of Paul Quinn and asked for an appeal for information. As the Senator said himself, for anyone who has any information, no matter how small it is, there is always an opportunity to speak to the Garda. He suffered an horrific death and I have no doubt that his family want and deserve answers.

On the Defence Forces and the RACO annual conference, I will speak to the Minister. There are outstanding issues, particularly in respect of terms and conditions for people within the Defence Forces, that need to be met. We had a significant increase in the defence budget only two weeks ago. I know the Minister is very committed to supporting our Defence Forces and to increasing and investing in them over the next few years.

Senator Joanne Collins raised the number of vacant posts at UHL, which is incredibly frustrating. We have had contributions from both sides of the House on these issues and I am sure the Leas-Chathaoirleach is very aware of the situation. There are not enough beds and there is not an opportunity for people to leave the hospital into community services. Nor are there enough staff in the hospital. This is October and as politicians we know this is only going one way unless serious decisions are made over the next few weeks. A winter plan is always put out, which always sounds good. However, I have not seen UHL benefit from it in the last few years. There has been investment, with more beds being built in Limerick and more planned. If an issue is being highlighted by both sides of House, I do not doubt Senators' sincerity and fear for what the winter brings for people in Limerick and the wider area.

Senator O'Flaherty referred to the English family and drug debt in general. Senator Brady spoke about it as well. It is incredibly scary. Senator O'Flaherty gave an example of a father with two children who ends up having to pay a debt, the fear of it and the fear of what might happen. No family want to end up in that situation, to have to pay criminals and thugs money just so they can feel as though their child will not be terrorised, hurt or murdered. Even when they do pay it, I am not sure they feel that doing so has solved the problem.

That is the biggest issue there. We obviously need a further crackdown on that, and I know the Minister for justice has invested hugely in gardaí and Garda numbers, with an extra 1,000 next year. That is all well and good but we need to have a serious crackdown on what we have seen over the past number of weeks.

Senator Duffy spoke on introducing a traffic commissioner. I think that is a very good opportunity for a Commencement matter with the Minister for Transport. It would make sense, from a haulier's perspective, that in both jurisdictions there would be parity between the rules. The Senator also raised the topic of the local improvement scheme, LIS, road safety measures and extra funding for those. We could increase that funding fivefold and we still would not be able to cover the amount of roads in our areas that need to be done. It is one of the best investments we could possibly make, in my view, but I will speak to the Minister in relation to extra funding.

Senator Stephenson spoke about the dispute around legal aid with the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan. I know he wants to come to an agreement with solicitors on this. It is having an impact on courts at the moment and on cases you certainly would not want to see being stalled or, as the Senator suggested herself, where someone is representing themselves and questioning a person they had incidences with. Everyone wants to see an agreement here. The Minister is very genuine in what he is trying to do. He is trying to change the structure to make it work better for solicitors and the public. We have seen signs of that, in fairness, but people need to come to the table and talk. I am sure the Minister is willing to do that.

Senator McCormack spoke about women's healthcare and that nothing is being done. In fairness, when the former Deputy Stephen Donnelly was Minister, he did an awful lot for women's healthcare, including hyperemesis. I know Senator Clifford Lee used to speak an awful lot about that in this Chamber during the last term. If the former Minister, former Deputy Donnelly, is remembered for anything in the Department of Health, it will be changes to women's healthcare. That is not to say that more does not need to be done but it definitely does not give the right to say that the Government has done nothing. There have been huge changes in cancer treatment, including breast cancer treatment for women, over the past 20 or 30 years. This was predominantly done by changes Ministers have made at the time. It has been requested by many to have a debate in this House on women's health and I am more than happy to do that.

Senator Dee Ryan spoke about UHL as well. I have touched on that. There are 40 cases per day in accident and emergency and they are only going to go up. As the Senator said, we need extra beds and recruitment to manage those. I am more than happy, as the Senator suggested, to have a debate on UHL and having a temporary plan in place for the winter months.

Senator Kennelly spoke about the roll-out of the shingles vaccine, which is hugely welcomed. It is being done the right way in respect of starting next year, looking at supporting vulnerable people and those with other conditions first, then rolling it out to the over-80s and moving along. It is something that has been called for by the Senator and others for quite some time now. It is important to welcome and acknowledge it.

Senator Tully spoke about the preschool, Daoine Beaga, which opened in August. As someone who has a child going to preschool, I can see every day the role they play in the development of children. For a community to come together to make sure they have their preschool for the parents and for those kids to develop is hugely important nowadays. It is so important for kids to have that preschool time before they actually go to school in order to develop and be able to settle in to school. I am sure it is a huge relief to those parents. I do not doubt the Senator when she said it was all done by themselves. You would think we would be able to provide some sort of supports to help them, but credit to them.

Senator Scahill also spoke on women's health, which I have touched on, and the water supply in west Roscommon. I understand that there are upgrades to the water supply in Tipperary, but while those upgrades are happening, there are outages, boil water notices or, as we had last week, "do not consume" notices. It is incredibly frustrating but I hope this will come to an end at the end of the year. Locals in general are very patient but sometimes that patience is tested. It always comes back to communication, and communication from Irish Water. I know Irish Water is coming to these Houses in a couple of weeks for a briefing with Oireachtas Members. I think it is 3 November.

Communication with Irish Water is always an issue for us as public representatives and councillors.

Finally, Senator Brady touched on the payments that were brought through this week for farmers, which is obviously very welcome. We never wanted to see a delay. They are always waiting for payments because they have bills to pay and they have challenges at this time of year. That is hugely welcome. I spoke on the arson attack already. Intimidation has become way more prevalent and something needs to be done about that because it is bringing huge fear into communities with good families and in good areas. It should not be happening.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Aubrey McCarthy has proposed an amendment to the Order of Business, "That No. 13 be taken before No. 1", which has been seconded by Senator Conway. The Leader has indicated that he is prepared to accept the amendment. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this