An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business
- Order of Business 1 speech
The scheduled business is a motion to refer the young persons’ employment regulations to committee without debate; the ambassador is welcomed.
Garret Ahearn
- Withdrawal of Sally Rooney’s novels 2 speeches
O’Loughlin criticises the withdrawal of Sally Rooney’s books from sale in the UK as a troubling precedent; the Chair calls for silence.
Fiona O'Loughlin, Mark Daly
- Crowded trains and station facilities 2 speeches
O’Loughlin seeks a debate on overcrowded trains, delays and inadequate passenger facilities, including locked waiting rooms and toilets.
Fiona O'Loughlin, Mark Daly
- Western Development Commission campaign 1 speech
Scahill welcomes the “It’s Happening Here” campaign promoting opportunities in the west and north west.
Gareth Scahill
- British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly 1 speech
Boyhan discusses the Assembly’s recent meeting in Sheffield and says he will ask the Leader to promote awareness of its work.
Victor Boyhan
- Cavan school building delays 1 speech
Tully says school extension projects in Cavan are progressing too slowly despite schools submitting the required information.
Pauline Tully
- Ardara park refurbishment 1 speech
Flynn says Ardara’s run-down park is unsafe and seeks funding to refurbish it, or closure until it can be made safe.
Eileen Flynn
- Mullingar Hospital diabetes service 2 speeches
Flaherty warns that the withdrawal of diabetic nursing services threatens the paediatric diabetes unit at Mullingar Hospital for the third time in five years.
Mark Daly, Joe Flaherty
- Sports capital fund and boxing club 1 speech
Duffy welcomes the new sports capital fund and celebrates the community-led opening of Knockmore-Foxford Boxing Club.
Mark Duffy
- Barriers facing European tech start-ups 1 speech
Keogan argues that regulatory barriers, rather than a lack of talent or initiative, make it harder for European founders to launch AI and technology start-ups.
Sharon Keogan
- Berkery report and fishing industry 1 speech
Boyle calls for publication of the Berkery report and says Ireland’s fishing industry is in severe decline after losses linked to Brexit and EU negotiations.
Manus Boyle
- Supports for terminal illness and cancer care 1 speech
Byrne calls for automatic medical cards for people diagnosed with terminal illness and raises free hospital parking for people receiving cancer treatment.
Maria Byrne
- Criminal legal aid fees 1 speech
McCarthy says legal aid fees need reform and urges a fair compromise in the dispute.
Aubrey McCarthy
- Fireworks safety at Halloween 1 speech
Kennelly appeals to parents, young people and communities to prevent dangerous fireworks and keep Halloween safe.
Mike Kennelly
- Bessborough records and student visas 1 speech
Harmon welcomes Cabinet approval to seek release of Bessborough burial records and calls for prompt clarity for survivors; she also raises Palestinian students’ visa cases.
Laura Harmon
- Deprivation in Bailieborough and Mullagh 1 speech
O’Reilly highlights concentrated deprivation in Bailieborough and Mullagh, citing analysis showing that 26% of Bailieborough households are in highly disadvantaged areas.
Sarah O'Reilly
- Leader’s closing response 1 speech
Ahearn thanks the contributors, says the UK’s decision on Rooney’s books risks setting a dangerous precedent, and congratulates Síofra O’Leary on her appointment to the Court of Justice.
Garret Ahearn
I also welcome the Austrian ambassador to the Chamber and congratulate her on her national day. The Cathaoirleach spoke about our history and ties. We also have an important match next month, and I am going over to Linz for it. I have one or two colleagues in this Chamber who might be going as well. We will not be supporting Austria that day but in general, our friendship is hugely important.
The Order of Business is No. 1, motion regarding the Protection of Young Persons (Employment in Food and Beverage Services Sector) Regulations 2026, referral to committee, to be taken without debate on the conclusion of the Order of Business; No. a2 on the Supplementary Order Paper, motion regarding the Media Regulation Bill 2026, instruction to committee, to be taken without debate at 1 p.m.; No. 2, Media Regulation Bill 2026, Committee Stage to be taken on the conclusion of No. a2 and to adjourn at 3 p.m. if not previously concluded; No. 3, Public Health (Tobacco Products and Nicotine Inhaling Products) (Amendment) Bill 2026, Committee and Remaining Stages, to be taken at 3 p.m. and to adjourn at 4.30 p.m., if not previously concluded; and No. 71, motion 6 on the Supplementary Order Paper, Private Members' business, regarding fuel costs, to be taken at 4.30 p.m. and with time allocated to this debate not to exceed two hours.
Comment on this
I also add my voice of welcome to Ambassador Schubert. It is lovely to see her in the Chamber.
As well as the very strong Irish-Austrian links, County Kildare had the good honour of being twinned with Austria during the EU Presidency. I look forward to meeting the ambassador later tonight, when we will have the opportunity to continue the conversation.
I wish to speak about the recent withdrawal of Sally Rooney's novels from sale in the UK. Sally Rooney is an incredible, very accomplished author, and this is an unprecedented situation that highlights the extensive reach of British anti-terrorism legislation. Following Rooney's commitment to donate her book royalties to Palestine Action, her publisher is now legally barred from processing her UK earnings. This outcome is fundamentally wrong, as it uses state anti-terrorism powers to effectively censor contemporary literature and restrict non-violent expressions of political will. The government maintains the ban and it is wrong. There has been an overreach in relation to a number of areas. While generally we do not comment on other government and state legislation, when it is impacting Irish authors, business people and indeed Irish people living in the UK, it sets a very dangerous precedent. We need to have a debate in relation to it.
I warmly congratulate Dr. Síofra O'Leary on her Government nomination to the Court of Justice of the European Union. She is a person of the highest international calibre and historically she was the first female as well as the first Irish president of the European Court of Human Rights. She brings unparalleled experience to Luxembourg and we take immense pride in her continued leadership at the very apex of European jurisprudence. We wish her the best. I had the opportunity to work closely with Dr. O'Leary during the Irish Presidency of the Council of Europe, and it is important that we note it here.
I wish to speak very briefly about the issue facing Kildare commuters of severe train overcrowding. At least once a week, I get the train from Newbridge-----
Comment on this
I see first-hand how absolutely cramped the trains can get, particularly in the morning. This really is a safety issue because commuters are packed very tightly in the corridors and where people exit from doorways. I would like to have a debate on plans for the future. There are carriages coming down the line, but we need to have better facilities if someone cannot get on a train, or if they are delayed, as one train was the week before last by 55 minutes in Newbridge with people waiting in the rain while the waiting rooms and toilets were locked. We need to have proper facilities and carriages with space for our commuters.
Comment on this
Before I call on the next speaker, I welcome guests of Deputy Moynihan from the Balgaddy Parish Group. They are most welcome to Seanad Éireann. Glaoim ar an Seanadóir Scahill.
Comment on this
I welcome a new campaign launched last week by the Western Development Commission called "It’s Happening Here". It is a campaign that highlights the enormous opportunity that exists across the west and north west, including in my own county of Roscommon, if I have not mentioned it before.
It is an important message. Often the conversation about rural Ireland has focused on what we do not have rather than what we do have and what we can achieve. The figures behind the campaign by the Western Development Commission are very impressive. Businesses supported by the commission have generated €6.3 billion in exports. Almost one in six people across the region volunteer in their communities and, remarkably, 28% of Ireland's social enterprises are based in the west and north west. We also have one third of the country's connected hubs, providing opportunities for people to work remotely, build businesses and raise their families in their own communities. In Roscommon, we are seeing the potential at first hand. Look at the investment secured recently by Novo Nordisk in Monksland, the investment put in by Harmac Medical Products in Castlerea, the innovation at the Aurivo centre in Ballaghaderreen - with a €12 million investment and the first of its kind, a wood-pellet burner and boiler system at its dairy ingredient facility - and the opportunities that are being created on a daily basis by small businesses and entrepreneurs right across the region.
Promoting the region is only part of the equation. We must also invest in making it possible for people to live and work there. That means continuing to deliver on things like housing, which the recent housing and infrastructure investment fund will help to do; childcare, like the recent announcement in Boyle of a State-led facility; and the national broadband plan, under which Roscommon was recently completed, following an investment of €76 million. However, we still have to be ambitious. We could still do with better roads and I will continue to call for a ring road for Castlerea and Roscommon town to be submitted as part of the regional economic spatial strategy. We need accessible transport, which is something I highlighted again yesterday during the debate on disabilities in this Chamber. We also need to look at regional education and apprenticeship opportunities. I was delighted last Friday to be in the company of Senator Duffy and the Minister of State, Deputy Dillon, at the sod-turning of the Pro Rail Academy in Kiltimagh, County Mayo, which is going to open up rail and engineering training opportunities for the whole mid-west region. We should not expect people from the west or Roscommon to leave home in order to build careers when they have the potential to create those opportunities locally. We should be encouraging those who have left to come home.
I commend Mr. Allan Mulrooney and his team at the Western Development Commission on a very positive campaign. Rural Ireland does not need sympathy. It needs the opportunities, investment and the confidence to promote what it has on offer. I believe that is what this campaign has. I encourage businesses, local authorities and community organisations right across the region to get behind this campaign because the message is very simple: you do not have to leave the west to get ahead. It is happening here and, with the right investment, we can make more happen.
Comment on this
I wish to raise one issue here today, which is in relation to the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly. There were a number of Senators there, as I was, for the past few days in Sheffield, discussing many issues around the agenda of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly. For those in this House who do not know what the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly is, I am going to spell it out. It was clearly very much talked about in the past few days on how we need to go back to our respective Parliaments and talk about the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly. I will be asking the Leader if we could arrange something in collaboration with a number of Senators. Indeed, there are Dáil Deputies but, for the purposes of this exercise today in the Seanad, I believe we need a two-hour session, possibly inviting people in from the Department of foreign affairs, to talk about the assembly and its work. We need a greater connection between each of our respective Parliaments and the work of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly.
The British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly was founded to promote co-operation between political representatives of both Britain and Ireland for the benefit of the people they represent. The assembly was established in 1990 as the British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body, to provide a link between the two Houses of Parliament in the UK and the two Houses of our Oireachtas here. In pursuit of that aim, the membership was extended for that body, enlarging it to include the Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Parliament and the Northern Ireland Assembly. That is important because we talk a lot about devolved powers. We have a lot to learn about the recent developments in regard to devolved functions of the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh Parliament. That is an important thing and it is also important that we clearly understand and have greater accountability in regard to our roles. We are there as representatives of this Parliament in the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly. I ask that between us, the Leader and I could work together on an informative and interesting agenda we could use to showcase the work of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly in this House. It is very important that we do so.
I also wish to acknowledge our new ambassador, H.E. Ms Sonja Hyland, who is in London, and also H.E. Ms Kara Owen, who is over here as the British ambassador to Ireland. They both came to Chatsworth House. We had a dinner on one of the nights and they both came. Unusually, both of them addressed the full delegation and they are two very impressive ambassadors. What was very clear from their engagement is that they collaborate and work closely together. Both embassies work exceptionally. I acknowledge that because it is an important point. I said at the assembly yesterday that it was important we celebrate how far we have come. Who would have thought so many jurisdictions with so many historic conflicts could sit together, co-operate and advance the causes of all their peoples?
It is a good organisation. We need to do more and engage with it more, and what better place to showcase and talk about the work of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly than in Seanad Éireann.
Comment on this
I wish to raise my concern about the slow pace, or possible deliberate delaying, of essential school building projects. I have been contacted by several schools in Cavan, both primary and secondary, which are in the middle of the process of getting an extension. They feel the whole process is not progressing at all. It is an extremely slow pace. They have submitted their information, drawings, all they need for the school and so on. They expect to progress to the next stage. Some of them hope to go to tender and start the building project this year with completion sometime next year but then they are told they are not in the national development plan, so they cannot progress and are not seen as a priority. In some cases, they are waiting years for these extensions. They have applied years ago. The needs of the schools have even changed and they may need additional space at this stage but that is always used as an excuse then to delay the project further, because they have to submit new drawings and information. You would expect that but it should not delay the project from going ahead.
In one school, they seven classes and two special education classes. That is nine in total. There are six classrooms. No matter how bad your maths are, nine into six does not go, so they are using every other available space in the school to accommodate their students. They have no staff room for 18 staff. They have no physical education, PE, hall. They are even using corridor space. Another school has been five years without a staff room for 28 staff. We are not talking about a small number of staff who could maybe go into an office and use it as a staff room on a temporary basis. There are 28 members of staff in total who have had no staff room space for a period of five years. Again, every available space is being used and some of the classes are operating out of temporary accommodation. We are told that the Department prioritises where there are children with additional needs in the school. All of these schools have special classes, and more than one; they actually have two or three. They are not being prioritised.
The demographics for that age group are decreasing and some wonder if the Department is playing a waiting game in the hope that there will be spaces available. However, for each of these schools, the projected enrolment is increasing and it will increase for the next few years, because there is a quite a lot of house building going on in the area, with new families moving in. I am looking for the Minister to come into the Chamber and discuss this because being told you are not a priority, even though you are operating with very limited space and no comfort in the school, is a horrible place to work out of. If you know there is a building project coming on stream very soon, you will put up with that for a period of time, but when you do not know how long this is going to take, it is very frustrating. I would appreciate if that could be factored in.
Comment on this
There is a park in Ardara, County Donegal. It is 26 years since it was opened. The park is now very run down and it is not a safe space for our children. In 2023, I contacted the council for the first time. The council is willing to do up the park but, unfortunately, it cannot get the money. Just before I came in here, I wrote to the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage. I also wrote to the Minister, Deputy Foley. The community is looking for a safe space. The park needs to be closed down permanently until they can refurbish it.
In the next town of Killybegs, there is a top range park for the children. What is wrong with the young kids in Ardara? It is very rural community. The park is a place where 13-year-olds and 14-year-olds would hang out as well. The park needs to be refurbished and done up with the support of the community.
I ask the Leader to support me in my ask for a better playground for the children in Ardara. We must also make sure that the playground is suitable for children with additional needs because mothers and fathers in Ardara have to travel to Dungloe for their children to get included in outdoor play.
Comment on this
I welcome a guest of the Leader, Senator Ahearn. Aaron Doran from Dunlavin, County Wicklow is here for a week's work experience. You are most welcome. I hope that the Leader is not working him too hard. Anois, an Seanadóir Joe Flaherty.
Comment on this
Sometimes we must marvel at the HSE. It gets criticised an awful lot but what really plagues me is that when it gets something right that it cannot maintain it and I will talk about the diabetes unit located at Mullingar hospital. For the third time in five years, a question mark hangs over the future of this excellent service as the withdrawal of diabetic nursing services almost brings the service to a standstill.
Dr. Michael O'Grady is a paediatrician and a leading light in the treatment of diabetes in young people. He is the clinical lead for the HSE in the delivery of these services and in Mullingar has built up a fantastic service over the years. Before this unit existed, this service could only be attained by people from County Longford and the midlands travelling to Dublin. The expertise of diabetes nurses cannot be underestimated. They educate patients about their condition and how to monitor it and prevent admissions to hospital and attendances at the emergency department. I cannot countenance or understand how for the third time in five years we again have staffing issues in this service, especially because the unit works very well. This service has a feel-good factor and is a good story for the HSE to tell yet we are back here three times in five years.
Ireland is leading the way in terms of diabetes through the likes of Dexcom and Abbott, which has a facility in Longford town, in terms of detection and the monitoring of diabetes. Yet, something as basic as delivering a diabetes clinic in Mullingar is again thwarted and, indeed, there are doubts over its continuation as a result of an inability to staff that service.
I ask that the HSE tackles this issue once and for all. The current situation is simply not good enough. It speaks volumes about the ineptness of HSE management that they have allowed this to happen for the third time in five years, and are unable to future-proof a service that works very well and is a benchmark for the delivery of diabetes care in this country. If it was happening in any other organisation in the private sector, and the same thing was let happen three times in five years, there would be a problem. Certainly, if I did not put out the rubbish three times in five weeks I would be out the door.
Comment on this
I wish to highlight and welcome the new sports capital fund that will become operational this week.
Recently I attended the official opening of the Knockmore-Foxford Boxing Club. This is a brilliant example of a community-led project for young people and boxers of all ages in the area and, indeed, the wider area of Ballina and Swinford. I acknowledge the leadership of Billy Rice who drove the project from start to completion. It was brilliant to see the project come full circle. The Minister, Deputy Dara Calleary, performed the official opening. I also acknowledge the support given by local representatives. Councillor Neil Cruise helped secure funding of €30,000 to secure the site at the beginning of the project and supported, with another €12,000 in funding, to provide ducting for the ESB connection and, indeed, Councillor Joe Faughnan in Knockmore who supported with another €10,000. I was delighted to support the club along the way in getting planning permission over the line in time for grant applications.
The club is a brilliant amenity and asset for the area and its environs. It would not have happened without Billy Rice and a team of volunteers who drove on the project to completion. I acknowledge and thank them for their contribution to the community. I encourage everyone to support them as they are still raising funds because they finished the project to such a high specification.
Finally, I lend my support to the Horkan family. Detective Colm Horkan was tragically killed. His family and his brother, Dermot, have called for a public inquiry into the death of Colm and I lend my support to that call. This was an attack on a member of An Garda Síochána. It is an attack on us all and deserves a full inquiry because there are more questions than answers. The family deserves answers. It is the least that the State can give them considering that Detective Colm Horkan made the ultimate sacrifice defending us all and defending the community.
Comment on this
I attended the International AI Summit that took place in Dublin on this day last week and listened to an insightful address by Eileen O'Mara. She spoke candidly about a frustrating reality, namely, the immense difficulty of getting an AI or tech start-up off the ground here in Europe. I entirely agree with her core message. There is absolutely no difference between Americans and Europeans when it comes to raw initiative, work ethic or innovation. The difference is the system. European founders are suffocated by invisible domestic barriers with regulatory differences from one member state to the next. Most emphatically, they lack somewhere to mobilise real large-scale capital.
I am sceptical of unifying Europe to the point of eroding our national sovereignty but the emerging EU Inc. framework is an idea that has some merit. By acting as an optional digital-first corporate layer that sits alongside our national laws, without replacing them, it unifies fundraising and equity across the Continent. It unlocks the American-level scale that we need to compete globally without centralising domestic political power.
In the meantime, Ireland has a critical self-inflicted crisis with capital mobilisation. On one side, archaic domestic regulation, like deemed disposal, is actively punishing local investment, forcing people to liquidate multi-asset funds every eight years and driving private wealth out of our domestic ecosystem. On the other side, we constantly laud ourselves with the establishment spin that Ireland is a great place to start a business. The reality, on the ground, is that we are not. Ireland's small businesses face some of the most expensive commercial bank loans in the eurozone. Better still, our State has failed to build the basic reporting infrastructure to even enable banks to issue informed risk-assessed business loans efficiently. We must stop the administrative complacency, scrap deemed disposal and cut this redundant red tape.
Comment on this
Today, I call for the Berkery report, concerning the budget ask, to be published. The Berkery report is in three parts. The first part is the financial path of each section, which was done in the budget.
As the Leader will know, having listened to me in here week after week, the Irish fishing industry is on its knees. We lost the Hague agreement last year for the first time ever when a voting bloc was put up against us. We lost 26% with Brexit while other countries lost very little. We have been left with nothing but a steady decline. They talk in Europe about a fair playing field. It is the unfairest field that I have ever encountered because we seem to be up against it all the time.
I am not here giving out about the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, or the Minister, Deputy Heydon. In fairness, the two men have worked very hard. I thank them for the budget. They kept me in tune with what was going on. They had a massive ask to get €20 million for the fishing industry. They really fought hard and I wish the amount was more. They did their bit and €20 million is a start.
The first stage needs to be implemented as soon as possible. We need to get money into people's pockets. We cannot live on fresh air alone like we have been doing. In particular now, with the way the cost of fuel and bait have increased, it is out of our hands now.
The fisheries committee heard yesterday from onshore pelagic fishermen who said that, across the board, boats are being tied up because it is not viable to go to sea. I never thought I would hear fishermen say it was not viable to go to sea, but I heard it yesterday. We need to roll out a financial package right away. I have been told a lot of work has been done on the Berkery report. He was very fair and travelled the country to listen to everybody in the marine industry. The report needs to be published immediately. It cannot lie on the shelf like all of the other reports we have heard about down through the years. I ask the Leader to help. Time is running out. We are hanging on by our fingernails.
Comment on this
I want to raise something I have raised on previous occasions. Those who receive a diagnosis of a terminal illness should automatically qualify for a medical card. The matter was raised with the Department, which said it would review it, but that does not seem to have gone anywhere. I have dealt with a number of young families recently where a parent has received a terminal diagnosis. It causes stress and strain, not only to the young couple and their family. The Irish Cancer Society in its pre-budget submission sought free car parking for people in receipt of cancer treatment in hospitals. University Hospital Limerick provides parking spaces for people who are having treatment, but not enough of them are available. In some hospitals, people are charged to premium rates when having treatment. A terminal diagnosis is something that causes a lot of stress and strain. Another issue is that those with an end-of-life prognosis should qualify for the fuel allowance. Many people who are seriously ill have their heating running constantly. Some support should be put in place for them. I would like the support of the Leader on that and perhaps he could ask the Minister to come to the House for a debate on the issue.
Comment on this
I want to raise an issue regarding the criminal legal aid dispute. I want to be constructive about it. Reform of legal aid fees is definitely needed and we all know that. The Law Society accepts that. I have known the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, since I became a Senator. I believe he wants a system that is fair and gives value to the taxpayer. Through Tiglin and having worked with the legal profession in Wicklow, Kildare and Dublin, I find people from the legal profession very fair. When there are fair people on both sides, a compromise is possible.
The figures we are presented with are stark. Around 3,400 certificates have been issued under the new scheme, roughly a tenth of the volume this time last year. The number of adjournments sits at an all-time high and includes offences such as robbery, assault, sexual assault and drugs cases. Every case has a victim waiting. We are told that 75% of cases finish in one appearance, but the Minister's letter in September said only a quarter of cases had concluded - three quarters of a quarter is one in five. After 20 years of working with people who have addiction and complex needs, I can tell the House that somebody who is in active addiction arrives at the point of a criminal conviction with more than one charge. They could have four or five different charges in different districts. If they plead, they need time with the Probation Service, the drug treatment court and services like our own. If those cases are not viable, they will be closed with no rehabilitation. The person then goes straight back into the cycle.
The Law Society is not asking to scrap the flat fee. Rather, it proposes two modest changes, namely a further certificate after ten appearances for genuinely complex cases and separate certificates for separate prosecutions, capped at five per client per day. That answers the Minister's concern about outlier cases. I ask the Leader to invite the Minister to the House and encourage him to sit down with the Law Society. I know letters to and fro will not resolve the dispute, but a conversation between two reasonable parties will.
Comment on this
I wish to highlight the dangers of fireworks in our communities in the very long lead up to 31 October, the official Hallowe'en night. With Hallowe'en fast approaching, I want to make a simple appeal to parents, young people and communities across the country. Let us use a bit of common sense and make sure everyone can enjoy the occasion safely. Hallowe'en should be about fun - it was always about fun for children - dressing up, meeting friends, going trick or treating and people enjoying themselves. It was never about frightening elderly neighbours, intimidating vulnerable people or creating extra work for gardaí and emergency services.
Every year, we hear the same complaints about fireworks and bangers going off from the start of October. It is like Christmas now; you hear the first cracker going off three months before Hallowe'en. It is intimidating vulnerable people and, as I said, creates extra work for gardaí. Last year, in Listowel a firework was dropped through the letterbox of a resident's home. Thankfully, not a lot of damage was done and things could have been a lot worse. A village in north Kerry was torn apart two years before that by a mob of youths who had a firework fight in the middle of the street. We also need to think carefully about bonfires and the dangers of fireworks. There are public awareness campaigns, but unfortunately the message is not getting through to kids and people using fireworks. In Listowel responsible adults behind the wheels of cars are dropping kids off to let off fireworks around the area.
This time of the year highlights the need for CCTV coverage in our towns. I highlighted the village in north Kerry when I first came to the House two years ago. My first contribution was about protecting the people because it was a war zone that night. I am still seeking CCTV for the area. It is a deterrent for the people who drive those kids around and allow them to cause anxiety for pets, elderly people and the whole community. Let us make Hallowe'en memorable for the right reasons. Let us respect our neighbours and gardaí, look after our pets, mind our own safety and let the children enjoy Hallowe'en without becoming it another story of controversy.
The text alert system number for gardaí in Listowel is 50555. It is anonymous and safe. I ask people to report incidents as soon as possible because the gardaí need to know what is happening. Often it is the case that people leave it to others to report incidents. If people see something they need to say something to save the community.
Comment on this
I want to raise a number of issues. First, I want to raise the issue of Bessborough in Cork. I want to welcome the fact that the Minister, Deputy Foley, got Cabinet approval this week to make an application to the High Court to release burial records relating to the site. Survivors and their families have a right to know the truth regarding these records. This needs to happen without delay. The Minister should outline clearly to survivors and their families the steps being taken.
The second issue I want to raise is student visas. We know a number of cases relating to Palestinian students who have applied to study in Ireland are currently under judicial review. They were accepted onto fully funded courses, but the Government is denying them visas. We need information from the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, and his Department on the process under which these visas have been dealt with. This should not have ended up in court. I want to commend the lawyers who have worked closely with these students.
Related to that, I want to request a debate with the Minister on student visas in general. I was alarmed to hear at the further and higher education committee last week from University College Cork that it is currently down €3.7 million in income this year because of international students who did not take up places at the college due to the fact that their visas were being delayed. We need full transparency from the Government on its visa processes and how that might have changed in terms of delays or how they are being granted.
This is affecting different sectors of society and it is affecting the income of the colleges. If UCC is down €3.7 million, I would like to know what the other higher education institutions are down in revenue because of changes to visa situations. This is a significant impact on our higher education institutions which are already underfunded.
Comment on this
I want to talk about a meeting I attended on Monday about community needs analysis for Bailieborough and Mullagh in County Cavan. It was sobering to hear some of the statistics that were given to us from the analysis. The information was shocking but the issues have been there and I have been raising them since I was first elected ten years ago. One statistic is that 26% of households in Bailieborough live in the most disadvantaged areas of minus 10 or greater on the deprivation score. That is a very sobering statistic to be told. The deprivation is highly concentrated and based in individual areas. There have to be targeted supports. This is what the analysis has shown us. I tried to get a Commencement debate today and yesterday but I was not picked. Bailieborough is badly in need of a family resource centre. We need services and we need a building to house those services. One of the issues is that if services like Youthreach, addiction services or counselling services want to come into the town, there are no buildings available for these services to work from. The report also found that referrals to Tusla for child welfare concerns were 40% higher than the national average and 35% higher than the whole of Cavan and Monaghan. This too is shocking. These are stark figures. As public representatives we needed to hear these figures but it was not easy listening. There are high numbers of single parent families in the area as well who are trying their best but who are struggling. They need these services too.
The report indicated that there is very little for teenagers. We need youth services, counselling for addiction and DEIS status for our secondary school. The national school has DEIS status but, unfortunately, after years of writing to Ministers for the secondary school to get DEIS status, it still has not come about. The primary school has six ASD classes, which is more than some special schools in other areas like Dublin, but more services are needed. I need the Minister to come in and answer questions on this in a Commencement debate.
Comment on this
I thank the 14 Senators for their contributions today. Senator O'Loughlin spoke Sally Rooney's books and the decision made in the UK. Obviously, it is a decision for them, not for us, but as the Senator has said, it does start a dangerous precedent that someone's books are not being sold for a reason that is not justifiable in a lot of people's eyes. The Senator also acknowledged Dr. Síofra O'Leary, who was appointed to the Court of Justice. I congratulate her and wish her well in her new role. I know that this is done through the Council of Europe, which is where Senator O'Loughlin would know her from and from where I also know her. We wish her well.
In relation to overcrowding in Kildare, there is huge investment in public transport and trains in particular. Kildare is an area where a lot of people live but travel to Dublin to work. We do need significant investment, which is coming, from a safety perspective, as the Senator has said. We will try to have a debate with the Minister for Transport on that at some point.
Senator Scahill spoke about the Western Development Commission's "It’s Happening Here" project, which is about promoting an area as opposed to talking about what is not in your area. Those things are hugely positive when people come together and actually put a case for why their community and their region is a place to visit and to come to. From the Government's perspective, as it is for the Senator, it is our job to try to promote to people living in rural Ireland. This is why there have been changes made in rural planning guidelines through the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, and that is why there is more investment in rural Ireland such as never before. It is to give people that option to stay and live where they grew up.
Senator Boyhan spoke about the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly that was held in Sheffield. The Senator is right that a lot of good work is done but it is particularly done at an individual level, as the Cathaoirleach will know, with Senators in this House and in the Lower House building up those relationships. We have not had a real debate on that in this House. A lot of Members in this House are on the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly, so I will certainly try to facilitate a debate on that for Senator Boyhan.
Senator Tully spoke about school buildings and slow processes. This is a frustration for all of us. There is a long process when a principal of a school starts to try to build an extension or extra classes onto their school. It is incredibly frustrating for a principal and for a board of management. There is massive investment from the Government. The Minister for Education and Youth, Deputy Naughton, has put huge money into school buildings because of the need and because of the increase in population. That investment will continue but I understand it can be frustrating, from a principal's perspective, in terms of the speed of it. That being said, we do have the money to invest in school projects, which happen on a daily basis. I will ask the Minister to come into the Chamber just to have a debate on that.
Senator Flynn spoke about a park in Ardara that has been run down. The council is willing to support it and to redevelop it but obviously it needs funding from the Department. I suggest the Senator puts down a Commencement matter with the Department to see if funding can be acquired. Councils are always very supportive of doing something, but when it comes to actually having the money to do it, then it is normally the Department they need to get funding from as they have limited resources themselves, from my experience with most Departments.
Senator Flaherty spoke about the diabetes service in Mullingar, which has obviously been very successful over recent years but which constantly has challenges in recruitment. We heard yesterday On the Order of Business that there are recruitment issues in UHL. This morning we have heard of recruitment issues in a very key and important service in Mullingar that serves people in Longford and Westmeath and which is hugely important for the Senator's area. I am well aware. We do not want people to have to go back to what they used to do, which is travelling to Dublin to receive that service.
Senator Duffy spoke about the sports capital fund and the Knockmore-Foxford Boxing Club, particularly Billy Rice and the work that he does there. It is immeasurable the amount of work that volunteers do in organisations, especially in smaller sports like boxing, not the GAA, rugby or soccer but the smaller sports that connect communities and really bring people in who otherwise would not be into sport. The Senator is using Billy Rice as an example of someone who does that work and we see the benefit for the whole community on the back of that. I know that Councillor Neil Cruise is someone who is naturally very good at finding money from somewhere to support a really good cause and he has done that again here, as the Senator said. We also have a sports capital fund coming through, which has been launched and announced. I think it has been said in this House numerous times that we need to prioritise the smaller sports, whether it is boxing, rowing or gymnastics or whatever, and to encourage them to apply for a significant amount of money to support their organisations and their clubs.
I too acknowledge Garda Colm Horkan's family, who have called for a public inquiry. That is obviously a matter for the Minister and for the Government but everyone is very much aware of his case. I think everyone in the country wants them to have answers and have closure. I support that.
Senator Keogan was at the Dublin AI summit last week. It is a challenge for businesses in Ireland and in Europe in terms of start-up businesses. As we know, there are a lot of supports from the local enterprise offices for small businesses setting up. There are a lot of schemes and a lot of funding out there. I find that a lot of people who are starting up businesses are not actually aware of it. There is, however, more red tape than there is in the US.
There is an argument that this is for a good reason. It depends which way you look at it. There are huge challenges and trying to have a similar system in all 27 states is probably not credible, as was said, but the suggestion the Senator made is not unreasonable at all. Anything we can do to support businesses to get up and going and have the opportunities that we see businesses in America have is good for Ireland and Europe.
Senator Boyle spoke about the Berkery report, which needs to be published. Fishermen need funding and financial backing. They got €20 million in the budget, which is a significant amount of money. Senator Boyle was a key figure in pushing for that for Donegal, and Killybegs in particular. As he requested, I will speak with the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, to see if the report can be published as soon as possible. We have rising costs in all businesses, and fisheries are no different from any other sector, with costs going up on a weekly basis. It needs funding.
Senator Maria Byrne spoke about providing a medical card to people with terminal illnesses. She has mentioned this numerous times. When I started here six years ago, I assumed that people with a terminal illness would get a medical card. It would seem logical but it is still not the case. From her experience in Limerick, the Senator knows the stress a terminal illness puts on an individual but actually more so on the family of the individual. The last things they need to be worrying about are a parking space or a medical card. We should be there, and we can be there, to make sure this process is easy and causes as little stress as possible for someone going through a very traumatic period. I am more than happy to support the Senator on this and I will ask the Minister to come to the Seanad on it. There are a number of requests for the Minister for Health to come in on a number of issues. We will try to have an opportunity over the coming weeks to have a good debate on a range of health issues. Medical cards for people with a terminal illness is a very obvious one on which to to have a debate.
Senator McCarthy spoke in relation to the legal aid dispute, which was raised yesterday as well. I noted in a newspaper this morning comments made by a judge. When we are getting to that stage we just need people to sit down, talk and come to an agreement. There are people being affected by this in court cases through no fault of their own. One side can blame the other, but we need to make sure there is an agreement in place. The Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, has always said he wants to modernise and improve the Courts Service, and I know solicitors want that as well. There has to be some agreement. People just need to sit down to talk and support that. I am happy to have the Minister come into the Chamber as well, which was requested by Senator McCarthy.
Senator Kennelly spoke on fireworks. It is always good when a colleague raises an issue that is going to be an issue in a week's time as opposed to a week after it happens. It is hugely important to highlight that Hallowe'en is a wonderful time. It is a wonderful time for kids and it is meant to be fun and enjoyable, with people dressing up. However, on a yearly basis, we have situations where someone is badly injured or criminal activity happens because of fireworks. We need to make sure that this does not happen. It is important that the Senator highlighted it today.
When Senator Harmon said she had a couple of issues to raise, I knew the first one would be Bessborough because she has spoken passionately about it so often. It is significant that the Minister, Deputy Foley, has got Cabinet approval to release those records because that is part of the closure and acceptance of what happened. I know that once agreement at Cabinet has been secured, the next question is when will it actually be done. We will try to push that as much as we can on the Senator's behalf.
On the issue of student visas, I am happy to have the Minister for justice come here for a debate on this and other issues. As the Senator knows, all applications are processed on an individual basis and I cannot say why one has been denied. From my experience, particularly with Palestinian children, we have tried to bring them in and tried to support them, for obvious reasons. They feel welcomed and supported by the State because of decisions we have made, and they can give back an awful lot. We will do that. I am not surprised that colleges are having issues but, again, each case is dealt with individually. We will bring the Minister in to see if we can identify the problem. If it is happening more regularly than normal, there is obviously an issue.
Senator Sarah O'Reilly spoke about a community needs analysis that was done in Baileborough in County Cavan. In every county we have areas that need extra support and this needs to be highlighted here and in the Lower House. One of the reasons the Department of rural affairs was set up some years ago was to invest in towns in rural Ireland, through the rural regeneration and development fund, RRDF, the town and village renewal scheme and the community centre investment fund, CCIF. These schemes provide funding to towns to bring them up to a standard that people can be proud of. The Senator mentioned no buildings being available. We can also invest in upgrading buildings and then bring in services like Jigsaw and other support services that are starting to be introduced in other counties. I accept that the Senator's concerns are genuine but there has never been more money put into rural Ireland, and that will continue in the coming years.