We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Criminal legal aid fees

Summary

McCarthy says legal aid fees need reform and urges a fair compromise in the dispute.

I want to raise an issue regarding the criminal legal aid dispute. I want to be constructive about it. Reform of legal aid fees is definitely needed and we all know that. The Law Society accepts that. I have known the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, since I became a Senator. I believe he wants a system that is fair and gives value to the taxpayer. Through Tiglin and having worked with the legal profession in Wicklow, Kildare and Dublin, I find people from the legal profession very fair. When there are fair people on both sides, a compromise is possible.

The figures we are presented with are stark. Around 3,400 certificates have been issued under the new scheme, roughly a tenth of the volume this time last year. The number of adjournments sits at an all-time high and includes offences such as robbery, assault, sexual assault and drugs cases. Every case has a victim waiting. We are told that 75% of cases finish in one appearance, but the Minister's letter in September said only a quarter of cases had concluded - three quarters of a quarter is one in five. After 20 years of working with people who have addiction and complex needs, I can tell the House that somebody who is in active addiction arrives at the point of a criminal conviction with more than one charge. They could have four or five different charges in different districts. If they plead, they need time with the Probation Service, the drug treatment court and services like our own. If those cases are not viable, they will be closed with no rehabilitation. The person then goes straight back into the cycle.

The Law Society is not asking to scrap the flat fee. Rather, it proposes two modest changes, namely a further certificate after ten appearances for genuinely complex cases and separate certificates for separate prosecutions, capped at five per client per day. That answers the Minister's concern about outlier cases. I ask the Leader to invite the Minister to the House and encourage him to sit down with the Law Society. I know letters to and fro will not resolve the dispute, but a conversation between two reasonable parties will.

Comment on this