We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Consent video and family relationships

Summary

Senator Keogan criticises a Cuan video about consent and grandparents hugging grandchildren, arguing that family relationships should not be subject to State interference.

Fair play to my colleague in government who raised that matter. I feel compelled to speak on the Order of Business today after viewing that recent video by Cuan about consent. We have to remember why Cuan set up. It was set up to tackle domestic abuse and sexual and gender-based violence in Ireland. The video depicts grandparents arriving at the house and leaning in for a hug to kiss their granddaughter. The girl pulls an uncomfortable face. The viewers are informed that we ought to obtain explicit consent for such interventions and interactions. While respecting personal boundaries is important, there are deeper issues beneath the surface with this campaign. Why is this the business of the State? Why are we are funding public service announcements through a taxpayer-backed agency to lecture families on basic manners?

A culture of consent is vital when discussing sexual intimacy and preventing assault, but applying it to a family greeting is absolute lunacy and that should not require elaboration. This is a matter of etiquette. The Irish people are warm, pragmatic and considerate. They are entirely capable of navigating family dynamics subtly and cleverly without State-issued instructions. It is not our duty to legislate awkward or uncomfortable moments out of existence. We do not need Committee Stage debates for three hours on whether we should criminalise saying you are five minutes away when you are actually 15 minutes away, or the penalties for smiling at a funeral. More concerning is the subliminal message that advertisement sends. Depicting a loving hug from a grandparent with a grimace is a sad reflection of certain people's priorities. In a time when we are all miserable enough, this ad implies that ordinary family affection carries the same heavy legal weight as sexual intimacy and consent.

For many, this campaign will simply make our country feel a little colder and more atomised as we head into winter. For the vast majority of citizens watching on their screens wondering how they need legal consent to hug their own grandchild, the takeaway will be clear. It is yet another sign the Government has completely lost the plot and of how anti-family it is. Go raibh maith agat. It is a waste of money.

Comment on this