An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business
Governor Spencer Cox and a Utah delegation were welcomed, with praise for their work strengthening Ireland–US ties. The Cathaoirleach highlighted the historic transatlantic relationship and US support for the Good Friday Agreement.
- Order of Business 1 speech
The Leader sets out the Seanad’s scheduled business.
Fiona O'Loughlin
- Menopause awareness and health education 1 speech
Senator Fitzpatrick seeks a debate with the Health Minister on menopause and persistent gaps in public and medical awareness.
Mary Fitzpatrick
- Crumlin shopping centre development 1 speech
Senator Ní Chuilinn highlights the nearly completed Crumlin shopping centre and its planned facilities.
Evanne Ní Chuilinn
- Mental health and neurodiversity services 1 speech
Senator Conway cites warnings about pressure on England’s mental health and neurodiversity services, including rising youth distress and demand.
Joe Conway
- Visas for Palestinian students 2 speeches
Senators Murphy and Cosgrove raise rising refusals of type D visas for Palestinian applicants, including a student whose financial-ground rejection may jeopardise his studies despite university support.
Conor Murphy, Nessa Cosgrove
- British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly debate 2 speeches
Senator Blaney seeks time for a House discussion on the Assembly’s work; the Leas-Chathaoirleach also welcomes visiting guests.
Niall Blaney, Maria Byrne
- BISS and CRISS payments 1 speech
Senator Scahill welcomes the release of delayed farm-support payments, noting their importance to rural economies.
Gareth Scahill
- Consent video and family relationships 1 speech
Senator Keogan criticises a Cuan video about consent and grandparents hugging grandchildren, arguing that family relationships should not be subject to State interference.
Sharon Keogan
- Motor insurance and claims awards 2 speeches
Senator Comyn contrasts high insurance costs for young drivers with lenient penalties for uninsured motorists. Senator Nelson Murray briefly echoes concerns about the consent video, then cites new claims data on premiums, payouts and injury awards.
Alison Comyn, Linda Nelson Murray
- Preparing for winter storms 1 speech
Senator Murphy O’Mahony urges households and local authorities to prepare for severe winter weather.
Margaret Murphy O'Mahony
- State-funded consent advertisement 1 speech
Senator McDowell condemns public funding for an advertisement suggesting grandparents should seek consent before hugging grandchildren.
Michael McDowell
- Infrastructure investment and Virginia bypass 3 speeches
Senator O’Reilly welcomes increased capital spending and calls for investment to deliver results, particularly progress on Virginia’s long-promised bypass; brief interjections support the point.
Joe O'Reilly, Michael McDowell
- Animal cruelty case involving Felix 2 speeches
Senator Harmon describes the torture and death of a family cat in Cork and calls for an animal-welfare debate; the Chair acknowledges departing school visitors.
Laura Harmon, Maria Byrne
- Class discrimination and GPO payments 1 speech
Senator Ruane seeks debate on class discrimination after reports that social-welfare payments at the GPO were linked to antisocial behaviour.
Lynn Ruane
- Paul Killeen’s recovery and marathon 2 speeches
Senator McCarthy pays tribute to Paul Killeen, who overcame decades of heroin addiction and is now preparing to run the Dublin marathon; the Chair welcomes his guest.
Maria Byrne, Aubrey McCarthy
- Who is the consent video for 1 speech
Senator Davitt questions whether the controversial grandparents-and-consent advertisement is directed at children or grandparents.
Aidan Davitt
- Menopause education and HRT 2 speeches
The Leader agrees that more menopause education and health-service training are needed and undertakes to seek a debate; Senator McDowell asks about the cost of free HRT.
Fiona O'Loughlin, Michael McDowell
- Consent and respect advertisement 2 speeches
The Leader says consent and respect matter but notes that the funding Department has asked the agency to remove the disputed video; an interjection follows.
Fiona O'Loughlin, Michael McDowell
- Virginia bypass delay 2 speeches
The Leader acknowledges that Virginia’s lack of a bypass has stymied the town and suggests a Commencement matter to obtain detailed information.
Fiona O'Loughlin, Joe O'Reilly
- Animal welfare and Felix 1 speech
The Leader expresses sympathy for Felix’s owner and says the House will again seek an animal-welfare debate with the Minister.
Fiona O'Loughlin
The Order of Business is No. 1, motion regarding proposed approval by Seanad Éireann of the Regulation (EU) 2025/2082 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 October 2025 amending Regulation (EU) 2018/1727, as regards the extension of the timeframe for the establishment of the Eurojust case management system; No. 2, motion regarding proposed approval by Seanad Éireann of the Regulation (EU) 2023/2131 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 October 2023 amending Regulation (EU) 2018/1727 of the European Parliament and of the Council and Council Decision 2005/671/JHA, as regards digital information exchange in terrorism cases; and No. 3, motion regarding proposed approval by Seanad Éireann of the Directive (EU) 2017/541 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 March 2017 on combating terrorism and replacing Council Framework Decision 2002/475/JHA and amending Council Decision 2005/671/JHA, to be taken together at 11.45 a.m. and to conclude at 2.45 p.m., if not previously concluded, with the time allocated to the opening remarks of the Minister not to exceed five minutes and that of all Senators not to exceed five minutes and the Minister to be given no less than five minutes to reply to the debate.
Comment on this
I commend the Cathaoirleach and his office for their extensive work and exhaustive efforts to foster and grow relations between the Irish Legislature and the American legislature. I welcome our guests from the United States. We have deep and rich ties going back decades and centuries. I hope they have a great visit.
October is menopause awareness month and I call on the Minister for Health to come to the House to have a debate on what actions her Department is taking to address the alarming and dangerous levels of ignorance that continue to persist in men, women and medical professionals around menopause. Despite the introduction of free HRT by the previous Government, which has been transformative for those women who have managed to access it, still today women in their 30s, 40s and 50s are being misdiagnosed, abandoned and left to struggle, fade and disappear in broad daylight. I would appreciate if the Leader could arrange a debate with the Minister for Health on this matter. Specifically, I would like her to address what she is doing to ensure that medical professionals in Ireland are being trained on current learnings and teachings on menopause treatment.
I want to give a big shout-out to all of the cultural and community groups that might be interested in taking up the OPW's offer for meanwhile use of the GPO. I know Sinn Féin had a lot of concerns about our General Post Office on O'Connell Street in the past, and I am sure they are hugely relieved to know the Government has allocated more than €500 million in the national development plan for its redevelopment. While these plans are being developed, the OPW has issued a public call to all community groups to submit expressions of interest on using it for cultural, creative and vibrant activities, and all of the information is available on its website. It is a great opportunity for meanwhile use in the GPO and I encourage everybody to take an interest in it.
While I am on the subject of the OPW, I must acknowledge the very significant progress being made at the former Magdalen laundry site on Seán McDermott Street in the creation of a national centre for research and remembrance. I had the great privilege this week of accompanying the Taoiseach on a progress review of the work being done on Seán McDermott Street at the former Magdalen laundry site to create a national centre for research and remembrance. The history of this site and of Magdalen laundries is horrible and painful, and most painful for the survivors, but it is a history we must never ignore or forget. The OPW and the National Museum, in partnership with survivors, are working to create on Seán McDermott Street a national centre for research and remembrance. This will be a great affirmation of the State's recognition of the wrongs done to those women and children and an opportunity for us never to forget, to learn from the past and to make sure we never repeat these mistakes again.
Comment on this
I wish everybody competing in the Dublin City marathon the best of luck on Sunday. Parts of the city obviously will close down, including my part of the city. I encourage everybody running the marathon on Sunday to keep an eye out for our brand spanking new, almost ready Crumlin shopping centre. It is flying up and hopefully it will be ready next summer. It is going to be fantastic and looks absolutely gorgeous. It will be a flagship centre, with a medical centre, a gym, shops and everything. It is absolutely stunning. However, right next door, those running towards the shopping centre will see on their right a derelict swimming pool that has been out of use for ten years. There is some black netting on the roof, which I presume is to make sure that if slates become loose they do not go flying. It is an eyesore and a danger. It has been derelict for years but imagine my surprise when I checked the derelict sites register to find it is not on it. This means we have not been collecting any levy from the site.
As far as I know, and I have made inquiries to the developer for information, it is not part of the redevelopment of the beautiful shopping centre right next door. I ask people to go to Google Maps and have a look. Beside the beautiful spaceship-looking shopping centre it looks absolutely awful. This swimming pool was in use until ten years ago and there is no reason it cannot be refurbished, particularly given the Swim Ireland report on the provision of swimming pools in the country. This is a very good example of why we need the derelict site tax, which was introduced as part of the budget. This site could have collected thousands of euro in levies over the last ten or so years as it has been out of use. It is a really positive move that we are moving towards a tax but I would like to know whether there is any way, while developers are on site at the beautiful shopping centre, that they could refurbish, repurpose or knock this dangerous building that has been derelict for ten years.
Comment on this
I dtús báire, ba mhaith liom comhaontú leis an bhfáilte mhór a cuireadh roimh Governor Cox agus a fhoireann a tháinig ó fada i gcéin. Tá súil agam go mbainfidh siad taitneamh as a gcuairt chuig Éirinn.
The independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism, chaired by Professor Peter Fonagy and published on 9 October 2026, refers to the situation that prevails in England. It makes some stark warnings about the National Health Service's mental health and neurodiversity services and the challenges due to surging demand, rising youth distress and heavy reliance on formal diagnosis to access support. Why would I be raising something done in another jurisdiction in this House? It is a very long report, with 607 pages, and I have to confess I am at page 250 and it is tough going. I hope that during the recess I will get to the end of it. I am struck by the large number of resonating parallels in what I see in our own system with autism and ADHD.
I will not go on at length but I hope I can join Senator Fitzpatrick in asking for the Minister for Health to come to the House. The Seanad and its Members should get a chance to discuss and debate the very stark findings made in the report and the implications, if any, for us here in Ireland. As an investigation and a work of academia, it is a very important document in this whole business, which is a vexed question for both legislatures. One of the findings is that in the UK, one in four of those aged between 16 and 24 now has a mental health condition. This has gone up from one in six in 1993. There were 800,000 people on the ADHD and autism mental health waiting list at the end of 2025.
The annual cost to the British Exchequer is reckoned to be £300 billion a year to address mental health issues and 1,000 days is the average waiting list time. I am not sure if these are replicated in Ireland but there are parallels. We can learn a lot from the great research work that has been done by Professor Fonagy and his team. I would like the Minister for children and disability and the Minister for Health to do a double gig here with us at some stage. It would be helpful for the whole question.
Comment on this
Before I speak to the matter I wish to raise, I understand that Senator Blaney is going to raise a matter relating to the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly. I fully endorse the proposition that he will be putting to the Seanad.
I want to raise the issue of visas for Palestinian applicants, particularly type D visas. Thus far in 2026, we have seen a 53.7% increase in rejections for type D visas for Palestinian applicants compared with 2025. These visas are long-term and typically used by students from other countries who want to undertake third level study in Ireland. My office has been contacted by a number of these prospective students. They say that the funding and all other criteria have been met, yet the Department is refusing to issue the study visas. Some students risk losing their places on courses due to delays within the Department of justice. The deadline for some is 2 November. Afterwards, they will lose their eligibility to study at their institutions. I ask the Leader to raise this matter with the Minister for justice urgently and ask him to focus on this issue ahead of the 2 November deadline.
As we all know, the situation in Gaza remains dire and the silent genocide continues. Across Palestine, Israeli settlers continue to steal land owned and farmed by generations of Palestinians. The Government must show compassion to these young Palestinians who are trying to rebuild their lives, in many cases following unspeakable tragedy, and they are to be commended for that. I am aware that Deputy Gibney is hosting a briefing on this topic today in the audiovisual room at 2 p.m. I hope that the Minister for justice and the wider Government will respond with the urgency that is required.
We cannot stop talking about Palestine. The genocide continues and we must do all in our power to help. It would be a tragedy if people who had the opportunity to escape those conditions, if only for a number of years, and improve their lives here in Ireland while studying were held up in some kind of bureaucratic logjam and did not get to study in our country. I urge the Leader to engage with the Minister for justice and see if we can resolve this matter speedily in the time ahead.
Comment on this
I, too, raise the topic of Gaza students and their visas. As Senator Murphy outlined, there is an audiovisual room presentation on this afternoon outlining the plight of the Palestinian students who are looking to get their visas cleared. The reason that I am bringing it up today is because this is our last opportunity to do so. One young man has contacted me, and everyone has probably got similar emails. Three of his colleagues have been granted visas but his application was rejected on financial grounds. The university that he is attending has come back and said that he will get full financial assistance for the whole duration of his stay here under his scholarship programme. He has got a place in computer science in UCD, but his place is going to be rescinded on 2 November. He managed to get his application in using a borrowed laptop with a cracked screen, limited Wi-Fi and intermittent electricity. His whole house has been destroyed.
I saw the High Court's decision last week. People were refused visas but appealed that decision, and their refusals were overturned except in the case of this young man, who has not been successful. I have written to the Minister for justice. I urge everyone to do so. As Senator Murphy said, the application is caught up in bureaucracy. The Department of foreign affairs has issued these visas, yet it seems that they are getting clogged up within the Department of justice. We have such a good reputation in Ireland for our education system. This young man is trying to rebuild his life. This is our last opportunity because we are going to be gone for the recess. There is a flight leaving Gaza on 26 October and he needs to be on it.
Comment on this
The Leader joined us in Sheffield on Sunday, Monday and part of Tuesday where we had a very good conference with the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly. I thank Senator Murphy for raising it here this morning. I spoke to a number of parties in the House, including Senator Kelleher from Fine Gael, Deputy Sheehan who was at the conference, Senator P.J. Murphy and a number of Independents, including Senator Craughwell. There is agreement across the House that we would ask the Leader to make space on the agenda over the next number of weeks or months for a proper discussion on the workings of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly, BIPA, and on British-Irish and North-South relations. BIPA has been an extremely important body since it was founded in the 1990s, then known as the British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body. It was reconstituted in the past 15 years and renamed as the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly. It is a fantastic body. It has done an awful lot for relations on this island. If we want to establish the full implementation of the Good Friday Agreement, we have to do everything that we can to use that body to its full potential. That involves more discussion in this House. I would like to see the British ambassador, H.E. Kara Owen, here for that occasion, if possible. Relations on this island and with the UK are on a much better footing under the current three Administrations and I would like to build on that.
Comment on this
Before I move on to the next speaker, I welcome Finglas Sister Shed, whose members are guests of Deputy McAuliffe. I hope that they enjoy their visit to Leinster House. They are very welcome.
Comment on this
I welcome the basic income support for sustainability, BISS, and complementary redistributive income support for sustainability, CRISS, payments that have been released today by the Minister, Deputy Heydon. I am glad we got over that little delay because this is a very important fund that has a huge impact all across rural economies in the country. Thankfully, it has been resolved and those payments have been hitting accounts today.
I thank Senator Comyn for her Commencement matter this morning highlighting vape shops. They have been repeatedly raised in the House. The Leader of the House, Senator Ahearn, has spoken repeatedly about them recently. There are a number of councillors nationwide repeating this. In the UK, these vape shops and nail bars are being linked to human trafficking, money laundering and drug distribution. We would be very naive to think that it is not the very same situation here. We are trying to regulate - that was the subject matter of the Senator's Commencement matter - the number of these premises that are popping up all over the country, but we have to look a little bit deeper. We would be very naive to think that something that they know is happening in the UK is not happening here in Ireland. That is the essence of everyone highlighting that issue.
I commend the Department of justice on engaging with the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre in removing an ad campaign that surfaced this week with regard to concept. The "We-Consent" campaign is teaching a lot of lessons and is a very important campaign to continue to support, but the suggestion this week that grandparents and their grandchildren should be seeking consent before hugs is a step too far. For God’s sake, somebody had a budget that they felt they needed to spend and wondered what would be a bit of clickbait. It is a ridiculous thing. It needs to be called out. I welcome the Department of justice's quick movement on this to try to remove it and investigate it. How it even got to this stage is ridiculous.
Comment on this
Fair play to my colleague in government who raised that matter. I feel compelled to speak on the Order of Business today after viewing that recent video by Cuan about consent. We have to remember why Cuan set up. It was set up to tackle domestic abuse and sexual and gender-based violence in Ireland. The video depicts grandparents arriving at the house and leaning in for a hug to kiss their granddaughter. The girl pulls an uncomfortable face. The viewers are informed that we ought to obtain explicit consent for such interventions and interactions. While respecting personal boundaries is important, there are deeper issues beneath the surface with this campaign. Why is this the business of the State? Why are we are funding public service announcements through a taxpayer-backed agency to lecture families on basic manners?
A culture of consent is vital when discussing sexual intimacy and preventing assault, but applying it to a family greeting is absolute lunacy and that should not require elaboration. This is a matter of etiquette. The Irish people are warm, pragmatic and considerate. They are entirely capable of navigating family dynamics subtly and cleverly without State-issued instructions. It is not our duty to legislate awkward or uncomfortable moments out of existence. We do not need Committee Stage debates for three hours on whether we should criminalise saying you are five minutes away when you are actually 15 minutes away, or the penalties for smiling at a funeral. More concerning is the subliminal message that advertisement sends. Depicting a loving hug from a grandparent with a grimace is a sad reflection of certain people's priorities. In a time when we are all miserable enough, this ad implies that ordinary family affection carries the same heavy legal weight as sexual intimacy and consent.
For many, this campaign will simply make our country feel a little colder and more atomised as we head into winter. For the vast majority of citizens watching on their screens wondering how they need legal consent to hug their own grandchild, the takeaway will be clear. It is yet another sign the Government has completely lost the plot and of how anti-family it is. Go raibh maith agat. It is a waste of money.
Comment on this
I am blessed with two wonderful children. They are aged 22 and 24 and they are safe drivers. They have no penalty points, no tips or whatever. However, when I tried to insure them on my car yesterday, I was quoted €480. It is a lot. They will be getting the bus. Why am I raising this First World problem? I was alerted to a random courts page in the Drogheda Leader by a journalist, Pat Flanagan. On it you will read about a speeding, uninsured driver who was spared a ban and got a rap on the knuckles and a €101 fine. A man who drove without insurance was late for work and got a rap on the knuckles and a €101 fine. Another one got insurance the following day and received a rap on the knuckles and a €101 fine. What is my point? It costs less to be fined for not having insurance than to insure your car. Some 6.5% of vehicles in this country are not insured. That is one in 15 vehicles, which may not be on the road but they are certainly uninsured. That is 211,000 uninsured vehicles. Maybe this is one particular court, but the enforcement and the fines are not a deterrent. What is the deterrent for my children to drive uninsured? There is not one. It is €480 to get insured on their mum's car, but it is only €101 to be fined if they are caught without insurance. We need a debate in this House with the Minister for Transport on whether the enforcement and penalties are enough and whether there is enough of a deterrent to stop people driving uninsured in this country. Let us be honest. What is it costing us who have insured cars and who have to spend rather a lot of money for ourselves, never mind for our children, to be insured? It is time for a debate on whether there is enough of a deterrent for people because they are clearly driving uninsured right across this country.
Comment on this
I briefly concur with what Senator Scahill and a bit of what Senator Keogan said about grandchildren. I have two girls, aged ten and 11, who adore their nana and grandad on my husband's side. Their grandad adores giving them hugs. If I thought for a second that had to be questioned or that permission had to be gained, then we are in a sad state of affairs. I want to say that.
Last week, we learned that the Central Bank's national claims information database produced another informative report on where we are when it comes to insurance premiums and payouts for injuries and awards. We learned that premiums again rose by 4% in the first half of 2025 and have risen by 18% since 2022. I am glad to say they came down slightly in the second half of 2025, and let us hope they keep doing so. We also learned that injury awards for minor back and neck injuries were 3.9 times higher than in England and Wales. Importantly, we found out that €19,600 was the average award through litigation and €19,734 through the minor injuries unit. Legal costs through litigation were €19,900, but only €792 through the minor injuries unit. We really need to keep emphasising the great work the minor injuries unit is doing. We need to promote it as much as possible, and we need to give it greater powers such as mediation and extra control, especially when deciding awards on soft tissue injuries.
With all this information I ask two things. The first question is for the Minister, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan. The next statutory review of the personal injury guidelines is in March 2027. We need to pass the Judicial Council amendment Bill as soon as possible. I know he has taken this on as something important, and it is on the priority list for the autumn. I would not like to see it go past autumn because it is important for stakeholders that we look at the market and the awards other countries are taking into account before we decide what we think personal injury awards should be.
Here is my second question. The other night, I was with the Historic Houses of Ireland. It had its conference yesterday, and an evening the night before. Chatting to them, like me in business, they have only one insurer to choose from, and they are in a group scheme. They should not have to be in a group scheme, as I keep saying. Where is the competition in Ireland? We have not had a public liability insurer come into Ireland in 11 years. There is something wrong here. We have done all the reforms. We can see premiums in many cases coming down and we do not have enough competition in the market. I ask the Minister of State, Deputy Robert Troy, to have an in-depth look at why we are not seeing more competition coming into the Irish market on the public liability side.
Comment on this
As we look out the window, it is the calm before the storm, but the impending Storm Austen should serve as a warning to us all that the winter is coming and the saying bí ullamh is important. The local authorities need to get ready, and we personally need to get ready, for what we hear is going to be a bad winter. Coming out of a fine summer sometimes makes us think that the bad weather will never come again. We have plenty of time to get ready. I do not think today's storm will be too bad but all of us need to be ready, bí ullamh. The local authorities in particular need to be organising sandbags, clearing drains and doing anything that will stop the effects of the bad weather.
Comment on this
I join other Members in this House at expressing my shock at the advertisement about grandparents not hugging their grandchildren. This was subsidised by the State and paid for by NGOs who are using our taxpayers' money to interfere with relationships within families, which are perfectly normal, natural and to be encouraged. Instead of this, a ridiculous idea is being introduced that before you hug your grandchildren, of whom I am blessed with some, you should worry as to whether consent is an issue in such cases. It is not the function of the State to run advertisements of this kind preaching to people like me. I am perfectly capable and so is everybody else in this House, of whatever kind, of making up my own mind on that. I do not need somebody, especially agencies with a role in combating domestic violence, to suggest that somehow spontaneous, kind and loving gestures within a family could be inappropriate and that we should ask ourselves questions before we show affection to family members.
We are coming to the end of the woke era, thank God. You do not see preferred pronouns any more on the back of letters. They are disappearing like snow off a ditch in spring. There are a lot of issues we now have to address. I will instance one of them. When the former Leader of this House went to the Scottish Parliament, she told them that the Irish point of view was that there were nine genders. Those of us who are liberal and voted for the marriage equality referendum did not vote for excessive ideologies that endanger children and expose them to medical treatments that are irreversible.
We did not vote for these things and we cannot have them rammed down our neck by a group of ideologists who are well placed in NGOs. The time has come to do something. We need the Minister who is responsible for the funding of that advertisement to come to this House so that he can hear what people in this House - decent, ordinary Senators whose judgment is to be preferred to activists in these organisations - have to say. We need to hear what the Minister has to say and to stop this waste of public money and interference in family relations on the basis of some perverted ideology.
Comment on this
I welcome the remarks from Senator McDowell. I know the Leader will respond.
All of us in the House were happy to see an increase of over €1 billion in infrastructural spending in the budget. Infrastructure is almost like repairing one's family home. It is an investment in our future, in the country and in its functioning. All other things - a functioning economy and quality - flow from that. Everything flows from good infrastructural investment. There has been an increase in good capital expenditure. In that context it is important that the capital expenditure would show results right across the country. I want to draw attention to the very beautiful town of Virginia, as one enters County Cavan from Meath on the N3, which is set in a lovely area of lakes. It has great potential for residential housing development and it is also within commuting distance of Dublin. The town is totally choked at the moment for the want of a bypass. The promise of a bypass goes back something like 50 years. There is an anecdote locally of somebody being refused planning permission 50 years ago on the grounds that their proposed development would interfere with the route of the bypass. It is that old and has been going on that long and something needs to be done. I would like the Leader to get me a response on the up-to-date situation with the bypass and how the increased capital expenditure in this budget will be reflected in projects like that in a dispersed use across the country. That is the biggest need in the area. The Leader may even know it himself. It is a pity, as it is choking the commercial life of the town. It is also destroying all the side roads as people divert to try to avoid being held up for an hour, which is often the queue into the town. To avoid traffic they are using side roads, which increases the risk of an accident and it is destroying those roads. All in all, it is a kind of horror story in a town with such potential and beauty. It used to win the all-Ireland Tidy Towns competition repeatedly, and now it has just become a car park, so we need to deal with it.
Comment on this
The Senator needs to hold the Ryder Cup there.
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. We would take that.
Comment on this
This morning I would like to raise a very important issue about a recent case in Cork city which relates to animal welfare. We have seen headlines across the country about this particular case. A cat called Felix was taken from outside its home and it was basically mutilated and tortured and left to die. It was found days later in a cemetery unrecognisable to its owner, Tracy Finnegan, to whom I have spoken. She and her family are deeply traumatised by this act. The cat, unfortunately, was so damaged and hurt that it had to be put to sleep. This was a much-loved family pet. Unfortunately, we see cases of animal cruelty happening throughout the country. It is very worrying. In this particular case, while there was CCTV footage, it has not been made available. I believe that footage needs to be made available in such cases. We also need to have better protection for animals. I spoke to the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, NSPCA, in relation to this and animal welfare in general. I was informed - using Cork as an example - that the NSPCA has only two animal welfare inspectors for the whole county of Cork, the biggest county. One of them has to cover parts of Tipperary and Limerick as well. If you call an animal welfare inspector, they could be at one end of the county and it could take them hours by the time they get to the area if they are dealing with other work. We need to invest more heavily in this. The lack of gardaí is also tied into this issue and in terms of training for gardaí as well. The NSPCA has told me that there is minimal training for the guards on how to deal with these cases. We need to have more education - from primary school all the way up - in caring for animals, the importance of animals and also information on what is legal and what is not and that these people will face the might of the law. I wanted to put that on record.
Comment on this
I want to acknowledge that pupils from Harold's Cross school were in the Gallery up to a second ago.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Leader saw the headlines in The Irish Times in relation to Arnotts asking the Dublin revamp tsar to move GPO social welfare payments to reduce antisocial behaviour from the GPO. I cannot believe that people actually put this stuff down in emails. We still do not have socio-economic grounds as a ground of discrimination in this country. I would love if the Leader could look at having some statements on the issue of class discrimination. If this was said about any other group collecting social welfare payments from a particular place, there would be uproar, but when it is a group of people that is relying on support from the State for whatever reason - whether they are one-parent families, jobseekers or on a pension - they are now being framed by Arnotts as basically unwelcome and a problem to the city centre in terms of collecting their social welfare payments. The suggestion is that we look at alternatives for people to collect their payments where they never have to leave their communities. God forbid the tourists would ever see them when they come to look at the GPO for whatever historical reason. It seems to Arnotts that the GPO is for tourists, and not the actual people who live here and rely on its services and like to come into the inner city.
My nanny and granda, even when they moved out to Finglas when they were first building the houses there, liked coming into town once a week. Whether it was to the bank or to the GPO to pay a bill, it got certain people out of their communities, into the city centre to use their own centre. We should have another conversation. It has been a long time since we had a public conversation, legislation or just a debate in general on the importance of the Equal Status Acts and the issue of discrimination based on class and socio-economic need. Classism is out in the open in Ireland. I would love to understand why people are so okay with classism in comparison to many other things that we rightly stand up for when people are being discriminated against. It is a shame on Arnotts to even put that on paper. It is in the middle of being investigated following a Congolese man being killed outside its department store by its security, yet it has the absolute audacity to even think that as a retail store, it deserves to have a public voice in relation to where people do and do not receive their social welfare payments.
Comment on this
Before I call an Seanadóir McCarthy, I welcome his guest, Robert Cullen from Success Stories. I hope he enjoys his visit to Leinster House today.
Comment on this
There is an article by Kitty Holland on page 3 of The Irish Times today, which pays tribute to a friend of mine called Paul Killeen. Members have met Paul in this House. He is going to be running the marathon on Sunday.
I first met Paul in 2019. He came to the Lighthouse service on Pearse Street. If you had told me that he would be running a marathon, I would have told you that you needed to have your head tested. Paul is from the Liberties. He is a character and a wonderful guy but he started using heroin at the age of 14 and spent the next 40 years in addiction. He was in and out of prison. His own story is well detailed. He left school unable to read or write and ended up on the streets of Birmingham. His mother went over and pleaded with him to come back to Ireland because he was living on the streets. In 2021, his consultant in St. James's told him that if he did not stop, he had six weeks to live. I am thankful that he listened. He came and did a residential programme. He worked with a Tiglin key worker who loved running, so Paul started to run with this key worker. He says that he cannot do the recovery meetings or AA meetings and that his meeting is running. On Sunday, he is going to run the very same streets where he used to use drugs and where a lot of his friends died. The day after, Monday, he is going to South Africa to lead a team of people from Tiglin to work on the streets of South Africa. He is five years clean and his children are back in his life. His mother, who rescued him, is now 88 and is absolutely delighted.
Paul's story shows that recovery actually works. After 40 years in addiction, many of us would have written him off as a lost cause. I ask the Deputy Leader to arrange a debate on residential rehabilitation so that the next Paul is not left waiting 40 years. On behalf of the House, I just want to say that we are all behind him and will support him in the marathon. Go n-éirí leis.
Comment on this
I concur with what Senator McDowell said this morning. I believe a few other Senators have also raised the same issue. I was at a meeting but I saw some of it coming through on the screen. I refer to the disturbing advert being run on TV. I am curious as to who this advert is directed towards. Is it being directed towards children or grandparents? That is the core of what I would like to know. Who is the person who thought this concept was a good idea directing the advert at? As I said, I did not hear those who have spoken here before me. Perhaps this has been aired already. I would like that person to be accountable for themselves and to give us an answer to that. It just happened to come on the TV either before or after the news. My kids, an eight-year-old and a ten-year-old, happened to be on the couch with me. I just looked at them. It was the first time I had seen the ad. I immediately looked at my kids to see their response. The two kids were just bemused by the ad. They were looking at me as I was looking at them. I do not know. I cannot see what it is trying to hit at. I would not even like to say what I am thinking about it at this time.
On a separate matter, CIÉ will imminently have to carry out a cost analysis of the double rail line opening from Maynooth, where it is presently discontinued, to take in Enfield, Mullingar and wherever else. The demand at Mullingar is so high at present that extra trains are being run but there is only one line and trains have to wait in Enfield. That is a factor. We have great talk about making Athlone a huge satellite town but we have one with a great train connection. The existing line needs to be upgraded. There is no reason it cannot be upgraded. In an hour and ten minutes, you can reach Dublin city centre from Mullingar town. I can be on Dawson Street in an hour and 20 minutes. It is worth CIÉ doing a cost analysis and coming back to the Minister. It is something we could move on.
Comment on this
I thank all 17 Senators who contributed this morning. Senator Fitzpatrick spoke about October being menopause month. She was looking for a debate with the Minister for Health, particularly with regard to the education that GPs and those within the health services need. Unfortunately, that is still an issue. It is really important. We owe a huge debt of gratitude to the former Minister for Health, Stephen Donnelly, in relation to free HRT for women, which has been transformative, but it is clear that more education and training is needed. We will certainly look for that debate.
Senator Fitzpatrick also highlighted the fact that the OPW has issued a public call for organisations and cultural groups to use the GPO. All of the details are available on its website. It is important that groups know that they can use the GPO in Dublin city centre. The Senator also spoke about progress on the former Magdalen site on Seán McDermott Street and the important work going on there to create a national site for research and remembrance.
Senator Ní Chuilinn spoke about all of those who will be running the marathon this weekend. We wish all of them well, particularly Paul Killeen, whom Senator McCarthy spoke about. Senator Ní Chuilinn spoke about the route going past Crumlin Shopping Centre. I drive by the shopping centre twice every day. I have been looking at it and it is a beautiful building so I am looking forward to seeing it opened. There are going to be a medical centre and a gym there. The Senator spoke about the derelict swimming pool beside the centre not being on the register. The first port of call obviously needs to be the local authority. It operates the register. I suggest that the Senator speak to some of the local councillors she works with, her colleagues, to ensure it gets on the register. I agree with the Senator that this is the way forward.
Senator Joe Conway spoke about an independent review into mental health in the UK, which comes to 607 pages. I am very impressed that he has got through 250 of them already. He spoke about links with neurodivergent people, the dual diagnosis situation. He gave us some figures from the UK and expressed concern that the figures here might be similar. We will look for a debate with the Minister of State with responsibility for mental health, Deputy Butler, in that regard. If possible, we should also have the Minister of State with responsibility for disability attend because this is a matter that concerns a lot of us.
Senator Conor Murphy spoke about visas for Palestinian students, as did Senator Cosgrove. We have all received emails on this. These students are in very difficult circumstances. I know we are all very compassionate and want to support them in every way we can. The date 2 November is an important one that is coming up. It is particularly difficult for that fourth student who has been left out. I know that many people are doing a lot of work. In particular, Angie Gough is doing a lot of work with these students. Funding has been put in place. I have been in touch with the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, myself. In fact, I raised this issue at our party think-in. I personally feel that we should be doing more. I know there was a Commencement matter on the topic earlier this morning. Many people feel that there has been a policy change in relation to visa applications. There absolutely has not. Palestinian nationals still require a visa to travel to Ireland. Applications for study visas are assessed under the same immigration framework and requirements that apply to everybody else. Every application and every appeal must be considered individually. I have written on behalf of some of those who have contacted me. A lot of very generous people have put money aside to support these students and have organised scholarships and accommodation. Fair play to them. In one of these instances, the university had not made any contact at all with the Department of justice. It is really important that the universities work with the Department before putting programmes in place to make it easier and clearer for everybody involved. It is an urgent issue and we will contact the Minister about it.
Senator Blaney spoke about the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly and the cross-party agreement on holding a debate in the Seanad on what happens in the assembly.
I commend Deputy Brendan Smith, who is co-chair of the assembly, and Senator Blaney, who is chair of one the subcommittees. It is important to make space on the agenda. British relations and North-South relations are very important, and they are certainly in a good place now. We will look for that space.
Senator Scahill spoke about the delay in payments to farmers finally being resolved. The payments are being issued today. That is really important. He then spoke about the issues with vape shops and suggested that we need to carry out review into them.
Senator Scahill and a number of other Senators spoke about an advertisement that I have not seen. When I was listening to "Morning Ireland" on the radio this morning, I heard quite a few people talking about it. Not everybody was in agreement - there are two different sides to it - but I have to say I was quite surprised and shocked. The relationship between grandparents and grandchildren is such a special one. I did not know all my grandparents because they passed away before I was born or when I was very young, but I was envious of others who had that relationship. It is something we have to nurture and support. I know that the Department of justice has contacted the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre and has requested that the advertisement be removed. That is important. People have asked for Government action, and Government action has been taken in relation to it.
Comment on this
Senator Keogan also spoke about the video and about the culture of consent and respect. The culture of consent and respect is obviously important in every single relationship that we have. Again, Senator Keogan expressed her disquiet and disgust at seeing this video. She also said that those relationships have nothing to do with the Government. The Government and the State are not trying to control that. It is a separate agency that gets Government funding. To be fair, the Department that funds that agency has contacted it to ask it to remove it.
Senator Comyn spoke about car insurance and the fact that 6.5% of cars in this country are uninsured. She said she saw an article recently about three court cases - I think they were in Drogheda, but they were certainly in Louth - that resulted in fines of a measly €101. I agree with her that the punishment does not fit the crime. We have to make sure that the fines are definitely steeper than that. We will look for a debate with the Minister of State, Deputy Troy, and the Minister for justice, Deputy O'Callaghan, in relation to ensuring that our cars are insured and that at a judicial level they are dealt with in the urgent manner that they deserve to be dealt with.
Senator Nelson Murray raised injury awards and the minor injuries unit. She mentioned that personal injury awards are going to be looked at in March 2027 and said that we need to prepare for that review. She is looking for a debate with the Minister of State, Deputy Troy, on this issue and on the fact that Historic Houses of Ireland can only get public liability with one insurer. She said we need to see more competition.
Senator Murphy O'Mahony spoke about the impending storms and said how important it is for local authorities and individuals to "bí ullamh" in relation to what we need to do to secure our homes, communities and towns.
Senator McDowell also referred to the advertisement featuring grandparents. I am not sure what he was referring to when he spoke about a former Leader of the House addressing the Scottish Parliament. I will chat to him afterwards because I am interested in knowing what that referred to.
Comment on this
She is in the European Parliament now.
Comment on this
Okay. All of us who spoke agreed with the sentiments and we welcome the Minister for justice stepping in.
Senator Joe O'Reilly highlighted the increase in infrastructural expenditure, particularly in relation to Virginia. I agree with him that it is a beautiful town. It is a shame to hear it is being stymied by not having a bypass that has been promised for over 50 years. I do not know the up-to-date situation. I think that a Commencement matter would probably get the level of detail that the Senator requires, but it is a shame when we see a town being stymied in this way.
Comment on this
The Deputy Leader might bring it to the attention of the Minister.
Comment on this
Senator Harmon spoke about animal welfare and mentioned a recent case involving a cat called Felix in Cork city. I heard the cat's owner, Tracy, on the radio. It was heart-rending to listen to her and to hear the story. It was shocking. We have been looking for a debate on animal welfare with the Minister, Deputy Heydon, for quite some time, and we will look for that debate again. It is really important. Senator Harmon also mentioned the lack of gardaí, and the lack of training for gardaí. It is important to mention that we have more gardaí in the State than we have ever had. However, we will ask about the training for gardaí in respect of animal welfare.
Senator Ruane raised an article in The Irish Times. I did not see the article but what she said is shocking in relation to Arnotts writing to ask about social welfare recipients. I do not know the actual wording of what it said, so I need to be careful. What the Senator spoke about concerns me. We certainly do not want to see any discrimination whatsoever. We will ask the Minister, Deputy Calleary, who deals with those payments, to come in and have a conversation on this matter. It is very regrettable.
Senator McCarthy drew our attention to an article about Paul Killeen in The Irish Times. I remember meeting Paul with Senator McCarthy. He is an inspirational individual. What a wonderful mother he has. She went over to Birmingham to rescue him from the streets and now, at the age of 88, she is seeing her son run his first marathon. I am sure Senator McCarthy will be running alongside him. It is a really good news story. Fair play to him, and the best of luck to him. He is going to South Africa the following day with others. We will look for a debate with the Minister in relation to residential rehabilitation.
Senator Davitt also mentioned the advert. He also spoke about asking CIE to carry out a cost analysis in respect of train journeys, particularly those to Mullingar. Many of our counties have become commuter counties now. Mullingar is disadvantaged by the fact that it only has one track. We are lucky in Newbridge that we have more than that. We still have problems with overpacked trains, etc. It is important that we have a debate in relation to rail travel, the facilities that are there and how we can extend two tracks to towns such as Mullingar.