We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Motor insurance and claims awards

Summary

Senator Comyn contrasts high insurance costs for young drivers with lenient penalties for uninsured motorists. Senator Nelson Murray briefly echoes concerns about the consent video, then cites new claims data on premiums, payouts and injury awards.

I am blessed with two wonderful children. They are aged 22 and 24 and they are safe drivers. They have no penalty points, no tips or whatever. However, when I tried to insure them on my car yesterday, I was quoted €480. It is a lot. They will be getting the bus. Why am I raising this First World problem? I was alerted to a random courts page in the Drogheda Leader by a journalist, Pat Flanagan. On it you will read about a speeding, uninsured driver who was spared a ban and got a rap on the knuckles and a €101 fine. A man who drove without insurance was late for work and got a rap on the knuckles and a €101 fine. Another one got insurance the following day and received a rap on the knuckles and a €101 fine. What is my point? It costs less to be fined for not having insurance than to insure your car. Some 6.5% of vehicles in this country are not insured. That is one in 15 vehicles, which may not be on the road but they are certainly uninsured. That is 211,000 uninsured vehicles. Maybe this is one particular court, but the enforcement and the fines are not a deterrent. What is the deterrent for my children to drive uninsured? There is not one. It is €480 to get insured on their mum's car, but it is only €101 to be fined if they are caught without insurance. We need a debate in this House with the Minister for Transport on whether the enforcement and penalties are enough and whether there is enough of a deterrent to stop people driving uninsured in this country. Let us be honest. What is it costing us who have insured cars and who have to spend rather a lot of money for ourselves, never mind for our children, to be insured? It is time for a debate on whether there is enough of a deterrent for people because they are clearly driving uninsured right across this country.

Comment on this

I briefly concur with what Senator Scahill and a bit of what Senator Keogan said about grandchildren. I have two girls, aged ten and 11, who adore their nana and grandad on my husband's side. Their grandad adores giving them hugs. If I thought for a second that had to be questioned or that permission had to be gained, then we are in a sad state of affairs. I want to say that.

Last week, we learned that the Central Bank's national claims information database produced another informative report on where we are when it comes to insurance premiums and payouts for injuries and awards. We learned that premiums again rose by 4% in the first half of 2025 and have risen by 18% since 2022. I am glad to say they came down slightly in the second half of 2025, and let us hope they keep doing so. We also learned that injury awards for minor back and neck injuries were 3.9 times higher than in England and Wales. Importantly, we found out that €19,600 was the average award through litigation and €19,734 through the minor injuries unit. Legal costs through litigation were €19,900, but only €792 through the minor injuries unit. We really need to keep emphasising the great work the minor injuries unit is doing. We need to promote it as much as possible, and we need to give it greater powers such as mediation and extra control, especially when deciding awards on soft tissue injuries.

With all this information I ask two things. The first question is for the Minister, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan. The next statutory review of the personal injury guidelines is in March 2027. We need to pass the Judicial Council amendment Bill as soon as possible. I know he has taken this on as something important, and it is on the priority list for the autumn. I would not like to see it go past autumn because it is important for stakeholders that we look at the market and the awards other countries are taking into account before we decide what we think personal injury awards should be.

Here is my second question. The other night, I was with the Historic Houses of Ireland. It had its conference yesterday, and an evening the night before. Chatting to them, like me in business, they have only one insurer to choose from, and they are in a group scheme. They should not have to be in a group scheme, as I keep saying. Where is the competition in Ireland? We have not had a public liability insurer come into Ireland in 11 years. There is something wrong here. We have done all the reforms. We can see premiums in many cases coming down and we do not have enough competition in the market. I ask the Minister of State, Deputy Robert Troy, to have an in-depth look at why we are not seeing more competition coming into the Irish market on the public liability side.

Comment on this