Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill 2026: Second Stage
The Bill broadly won support as a long-overdue reform to restore trust in public service media and adapt regulation to digital content. It strengthens RTÉ and TG4 governance and financial oversight, assigns the Comptroller and Auditor General as RTÉ’s auditor, and creates a platform-neutral fund for public-service content, alongside a 25% independent-production requirement for RTÉ. Senators also raised concerns about sustainable funding, rising levies on local radio, Irish-language broadcasting and access to RTÉ content in Northern Ireland. The Minister of State said amendments would address levy transparency and the needs of smaller broadcasters; discussions with UK counterparts and regulators would continue on geo-blocking.
No. 54 of 2026 ›
I am pleased to have the opportunity to introduce the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill to the Seanad following its recent passage through Dáil Éireann, and to participate in this debate on behalf of the Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, who is carrying out the functions of the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport as required during the recovery of the Minister, Deputy O’Donovan.
The Bill is a comprehensive legislative proposal which aims to enhance accountability, transparency and value-for-money in our public service media providers, namely, RTÉ and TG4, and to establish a new statutory framework to support the provision of quality programming and public-interest journalism by the wider media sector. The Bill will also equip Coimisiún na Meán, as our independent media regulator, with additional information-gathering powers to oversee our online safety framework.
The Bill implements the key legislative recommendations of two expert-led reports: the Report of the Future of Media Commission and the review of governance and culture in RTÉ. After being considered by Government, the Report of the Future of Media Commission was published in July 2022. It contains 50 wide-ranging recommendations aimed at ensuring the media sector in Ireland remains sustainable, independent and capable of serving the public. The Bill gives legislative effect to 14 of the recommendations.
As Senators will recall, following the revelations regarding presenter payments and other governance failings in RTÉ, two expert advisory committees were appointed to carry out reviews of governance and culture and of contractor fees, HR and other matters. The reviews were considered by Government and published in May 2024, containing 116 recommendations in total. Eight of the recommendations of the review of governance and culture require legislative change, most notably the assignment of the Comptroller and Auditor General as auditor of RTÉ. Those changes are provided for in this Bill. The Department of Culture, Communications and Sport is continuing to monitor the implementation of the recommendations of the expert advisory committee by RTÉ.
The Bill also gives effect to Article 5 of the European Media Freedom Act, which requires member states to put in place measures to safeguard the independence of public service media providers.
In terms of our own legislative process, I would like to express my appreciation for work undertaken by the Oireachtas Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport on the development of the Bill. The detailed pre-legislative scrutiny of the Bill was instrumental in its development and the Bill takes account of 34 of the recommendations. A further recommendation will be addressed by way of a proposed amendment on Seanad Committee Stage and will provide that the regulatory documents provided for in the Bill be published in both the Irish and English languages.
The Bill is composed of three Parts. Part 2 of the Bill provides the entirety of the substantive amendments to the Broadcasting Act 2009, while Part 3 provides for necessary technical amendments to the Comptroller and Auditor General (Amendment) Act 1993 to allow for the assignment of that office as auditor of RTÉ.
Turning to the main provisions of the Bill, sections 25 to 34 provide for reforms to the corporate governance of RTÉ and TG4. Sections 25 to 31 of the Bill expand and clarify the functions and duties of the board, and the level of expertise required by board members, in line with the recommendations of the expert advisory committee on governance and culture at RTÉ. The Bill provides that a clear delineation is made between the functions of the board of RTÉ and TG4, set out in section 25, and the duties of board members, provided for in section 30. As a consequence, duties are now aligned with the duties of a company director under the Companies Act 2014, and, in light of the nature and remit of public service media providers, include a duty to represent the interests of the people of the island of Ireland and of Irish communities outside the island of Ireland.
The duties, functions, accountability and rules around the appointment and dismissal of the directors general of RTÉ and TG4 are provided for in sections 32 and 33 of the Bill. Section 32 provides that the director general is expressly accountable to the board for the effective and efficient management of the provider and the performance of his or her functions. It expressly prohibits them from taking part in any board deliberations regarding their own performance, removal or replacement. Section 33 gives effect to Article 5(2) of the European Media Freedom Act by providing for requirements for an open and transparent process for the appointment and, subject to an exhaustive list of circumstances, removal of a director general. The role of Government in consenting to the appointment of a director general is being removed, although the approval of the relevant Ministers is still required for the remuneration and terms and conditions of employment of a director general. Given the seriousness of a decision to dismiss a director general, the section provides that the board must provide the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport with a statement of the decision and the reasons for it, which must be laid before the Oireachtas.
Section 33 of the Bill provides for the distinctive role of a director general as editor-in-chief by specifying that it is the director general who determines the public service media provider's overall editorial policies, standards and priorities. RTÉ and TG4 will remain accountable to Coimisiún na Meán for the providers’ compliance with media service duties and codes.
Sections 15 to 19, inclusive, and 21 to 23, inclusive, provide for the extension of the duties and codes which currently apply to broadcast and video-on-demand content to all public service content made available by RTÉ and TG4, such as podcasts and content on their websites. This will bring all of RTÉ and TG4’s public service content under the regulation of Coimisiún na Meán and enable audiences to make complaints to Coimisiún na Meán regarding such content.
Sections 35, 41 and 62 of the Bill provide for the appointment of the Comptroller and Auditor General as auditor of RTÉ - one of the key recommendations of the expert advisory committee on governance and culture. Section 35 will ensure that the directors general of RTÉ and TG4 are accountable to the Committee of Public Accounts for both the audited accounts and the economy and efficiency of the providers. The Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General has been engaging with RTÉ ahead of enactment, and it is important it is provided with full statutory authority as soon as possible to enable its audit of RTÉ’s 2026 financial statements.
Sections 36 to 39 of the Bill will strengthen the role and independence of the audience councils with more clearly defined roles and remits, as recommended by the Future of Media Commission. To this end, section 37 provides for the express independence of the councils from RTÉ and TG4 and section 38 provides that the members of the audience councils will be selected by Coimisiún na Meán following an open selection process, rather than by RTÉ and TG4.
One of the key obligations imposed by the code of practice for governance of State bodies on non-commercial State bodies is for the anonymised disclosure of employee remuneration reported by reference to defined monetary bands which shall be determined by the Minister. Notwithstanding the commercial operations of both RTÉ and TG4, sections 42 and 43 of the Bill formally extend this requirement to both providers. Furthermore, the requirement will extend to the remuneration of both relevant contractors and employees.
Section 44 of the Bill will reform the process by which the performance and funding needs of RTÉ and TG4 are assessed by Coimisiún na Meán, based on the recommendations of the Future of Media Commission and the requirements of Article 5(3) of the European Media Freedom Act. In so doing, the Bill will both strengthen and simplify the assessment of RTÉ and TG4.
In terms of measures to simplify the process, the Bill is removing the requirement on RTÉ and TG4 to publish annual performance commitments and reviews of whether they met their commitments in the prior year. Performance commitments will instead ultimately be determined by Coimisiún na Meán in the course of three-year appraisals of performance and public funding. The Bill is also abolishing the requirement for providers to publish a separate public service statement every three years.
Instead, this function will be fulfilled through the three-yearly appraisal carried out by Coimisiún na Meán, as well as three-yearly statements of strategy prepared by RTÉ and TG4 on foot of the appraisal.
To strengthen the appraisal process, Coimisiún na Meán will be required to adopt, following a public consultation, the methodology that it will use to carry out the three-yearly appraisal. This is aimed at ensuring a standardised and transparent approach to the measurement of performance commitments and outputs on the one hand and the financial inputs necessary to achieve them, on the other, which is clear to RTÉ, TG4 and the public. Coimisiún na Meán will make a public funding recommendation in respect of RTÉ and TG4 for each of the three years of the appraisal period.
The first three-year appraisal will cover the period from 2028 to 2030 and Coimisiún na Meán is due to submit the appraisal and public funding recommendation to the Minister on 30 June 2027. The Government will be obliged to respond to this appraisal within six weeks after the publication of the Estimates on budget day.
In addition to the three-yearly appraisal, section 44 also reforms the annual review undertaken by RTÉ and TG4 by Coimisiún na Meán by splitting the annual review into two annual reviews. The first yearly review, due on 30 June of each year, will focus on the extent to which RTÉ and TG4 have achieved their performance commitments and the degree to which they have received adequate funding to achieve those commitments and fulfil their public service objectives. The second review, due on 31 October of each year, will review compliance with EU state aid requirements, including whether the providers were overcompensated.
The starting point of the three-yearly appraisal and annual reviews will be the statutory public service remit of RTÉ and TG4 so it is important that the remit fully reflects the activities of both providers. Amendments will be proposed on Committee Stage in the Seanad to specifically refer to the role of both RTÉ and TG4 in providing original children’s programming and the particular role played by TG4 in promoting the Irish language in schools, communities and Gaeltacht areas.
Sections 45, 46 and 48 provide for reforms to the RTÉ's independent programme account, and reporting by RTÉ and TG4 on the commissioning of audiovisual and audio programming from the independent production sector. Sections 45 and 46 will require RTÉ to allocate a minimum of 25% of public funding to the independent programme account. Sections 46 and 48 will require RTÉ and TG4 to publish additional information on each programme commissioned from the independent sector, including on the cost of production and total public funding contribution. The 25% target will no longer be confined to broadcast material but will also cover podcasts and audiovisual programming to be made available via on-demand players.
In addition to significant reforms to our public service media providers, the Bill provides for a new framework to support the provision of what the Future of Media Commission defined as “public service content" by the wider media sector, with a particular focus on the needs of underserved audiences. Section 4 defines public service content as an audiovisual or sound programme, as well as anything published in a press publication and types of online content that inform, educate or entertain and which relate to an exhaustive list of categories of interest to Irish audiences. Such public service content can only be made available by a public service content provider, as defined by section 3 of the Bill. Public service content providers may be either regulated entities, such as a broadcaster regulated by Coimisiún na Meán, or an entity subject to a recognised self-regulatory regime, such as a newspaper regulated by the Press Council. Section 4 also provides for a definition of ‘"under-served audience", which refers to audiences who may be underserved by virtue of a particular characteristic such as age, disability or geography.
Section 54 contains the three primary building blocks of the new framework. First, Coimisiún na Meán will undertake three-yearly reviews of public service content to assess gaps in the provision of public service content on a local, regional and national level and will then recommend measures to address those gaps, having particular regard to the needs of the underserved audiences. Running concurrently with the three-yearly appraisals of RTÉ and TG4, the first review will be submitted to the Minister by 30 June and will cover the period from 2028 to 2030.
Second, the broadcasting fund will be converted into a fund known as ciste na meán, which will continue to be funded annually by 7% of net TV licence fee receipts and an Exchequer allocation. As flagged during the Dáil Committee and Report Stages, an amendment will be proposed on Seanad Committee Stage to ensure that RTÉ and TG4 cannot apply directly to ciste na meán to avoid the risk of dual funding our public service media providers.
Third, using the funds paid into ciste na meán, Coimisiún na Meán will prepare and operate public service content funding schemes to support the production of new public service content, measures to develop the capacity of public service content providers and measures to support the archiving of public service content.
Coimisiún na Meán was established as Ireland’s online safety regulator three and a half years ago on foot of the Online Safety and Media Regulation Act 2022. That Act gave Coimisiún na Meán extensive powers to require information from a provider following the opening of a formal investigation. Sections 20 and 60 of this Bill will provide Coimisiún na Meán with the power to compel the provision of information by providers pursuant to supervisory activities, building on existing powers which apply to designated online services.
On Committee Stage in the Dáil, amendments were made which aimed to reduce the cost of the Coimisiún na Meán industry levy on the commercial radio sector. A number of further amendments will be proposed on Committee Stage in the Seanad regarding the operation of the Coimisiún na Meán levy. The amendments will include: a requirement that Coimisiún na Meán, when preparing a levy, has regard to whether a broadcaster is a micro, small or medium enterprise; and a requirement on Coimisiún na Meán to publish the methodology used to calculate the levy and to separately identify the costs incurred in respect of each regulated sector, such as the radio sector.
Sections 56 to 59 provides for reforms to the European works levy, which is commonly referred to as the Netflix levy. Section 56 provides a European works levy may only be made following a ministerial direction, on the basis that a charge of this nature should be subject to democratic oversight. Section 58 provides that an ex-ante review and an ex-post assessment of the impact of a levy will be conducted by Coimisiún na Meán every three years.
The guiding principles that underpin this Bill are transparency, accountability and value for money. It will provide for fundamental reforms to the governance of the public service media providers, the process by which their funding and performance is assessed, and in support of the provision of public interest journalism and high-quality programming by the wider media sector.
This is a very important Bill and the Minister looks forward to working with all Members of this House as they progress the Bill.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for outlining the Bill and I call Senator Ní Chuilinn.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit anocht. I understand that he is taking the Bill on behalf of his colleague and I appreciate him being here tonight.
This Bill is an important milestone for restoring trust and safeguarding the future of public service media in Ireland. There now have been several years of discussion, reports and much commentary on the direction, sustainability and future of public service media with much of that centring on RTÉ's future.
This Bill provides for more robust corporate governance in our public service broadcasters and more transparency, as has been said by the Minister of State. It ensures value for money in public investment in broadcasting while expanding the reach of public investment in broadcasting by ensuring more media organisations are supported in their ambition to deliver quality public service broadcasting.
While there has been considerable focus on the future of RTÉ over the last few years, and many provisions of the Bill strengthen the governance of RTÉ, this Bill marks a shift in our outlook on public service media and will recognise to a much greater extent the contribution of many other media organisations to public service broadcasting.
The Bill implements many of the recommendations of the Future of Media Commission, the most wide-ranging analysis of the needs of the media sector in a generation. The Bill also puts on a statutory basis many of the recommendations of the Brennan report on the governance and culture of RTÉ in a welcome measure to improve the governance of the organisation. While the Media Regulation Bill will deal with the implementation of the European Media Freedom Act, this Bill will implement the provisions relating to independence and funding of public service media providers.
As the Minister of State has said, the Bill incorporates many of the recommendations contained in the report by the Oireachtas joint committee on media following pre-legislative scrutiny of this Bill in which we engaged with many media stakeholders. One of the major concerns which was identified during the payments controversy in RTÉ a number of years ago was that there were very clear failures of governance at the organisation which, in turn, led to financial mismanagement. This Bill makes significant improvements in this area by assigning the Comptroller and Auditor General as auditor of RTÉ, a measure which will ensure robust financial oversight and provide more rigorous accountability of financial management at RTÉ.
The Bill also provides much stricter requirements for RTÉ and TG4 board appointments ensuring that only qualified individuals will oversee the operations of RTÉ and in which the Oireachtas joint committee plays a role to provide democratic oversight of these board appointments. I acknowledge my fellow committee members who have joined the sub-committee to consider and interview potential candidates this month.
In addition to the appointment of the Comptroller and Auditor General as auditor of RTÉ, the Bill provides for an enhanced framework for Coimisiún na Meán to assess the performance and funding needs of publicly-funded broadcasters to ensure value for money of public investment, and that public broadcasters meet targets in the area of public service media provision, regulatory and governance compliance, and that they meet their independent production commitments among other targets.
These measures are important, not only in their delivery of value for money in our public service media, but in restoring trust in public service broadcasters after several years of declining licence fee receipts and an associated perceived decline in trust of public service media. One of the changes I welcome most as part of this Bill is that it represents a fundamental shift in how we define public service broadcasting and public service media. We all know that the media landscape has and continues to change rapidly as services increasingly digitise. There is also increasing competition in the sector and a decline in traditional sources of revenue for media providers, which has put public service media under significant pressure. It recognises that our State-funded broadcasters are not the only media providers that fulfil and produce public service media any more and that the previous model of funding public service broadcasters alone is outdated.
It is for these reasons that the new platform-neutral ciste na meán is a very welcome measure in this Bill. Ciste na meán will open funding to media organisations that were previously precluded from public funding but that fulfil and provide public service media. It is a new model that embraces modern media trends and ensures that trustworthy, quality public service content is supported irrespective of its medium.
One final measure from the Bill that I would like to discuss is a requirement for RTÉ to commission a minimum of 25% of independently produced media. Public service broadcasters like RTÉ and TG4 produce excellent, high-quality public service media. However, considering their position in the media marketplace and especially that of RTÉ's, they have the opportunity and power to promote quality, local, independently produced media and give a platform to emerging talent across the broadcasting sector, whether that be news media, entertainment or any other form of independently produced content.
I would go one step further, however, in reminding RTÉ that independently produced content in the IP sector is not simply buying in formats like "The Traitors" or "The Voice", both of which are from the Netherlands. It is in backing and commissioning independent ideas by Irish production companies. Contrary to what RTÉ may counter, Ireland does not need BBC-scale resources to build original, unscripted, independent productions. Belgium, Denmark and Norway are more useful benchmarks - relatively small domestic markets in which broadcasters have repeatedly given local producers room to originate, test and prove new formats.
I welcome this Bill and the steps it takes to restore trust in our public service media. We all want to see a strong, robust media environment and we all want to see public service broadcasting thrive. This Bill implements a number of welcome new measures that will ensure our public service media providers, irrespective of the platform, are supported through the new ciste na meán; publicly funded broadcasters have more robust governance and oversight; public investment in our national broadcasters reflects the goals we set them; and value for money is delivered by these broadcasters as well as ensuring that publicly funded broadcasters have a downstream, positive effect in media by promoting independently produced Irish media.
I know that the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, has worked hard to progress this legislation to this point. I thank the Minister of State for taking this debate this evening on his behalf and on behalf of the Minister, Deputy Burke. Of course, I extend by best wishes to my colleague, the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, and his family as he recovers. We look forward to welcoming him back to Leinster House very soon.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit, an Teachta O’Donnell. Cuirim leis an méid atá ráite ag mo chomhghleacaithe faoin Aire, an Teachta O’Donovan. I want to take this opportunity to wish the Minister the best. I look forward to welcoming him back to the House in due course. Tá súil agam go mbeidh sé ar ais ar a sheanléim go luath.
There is plenty to note and welcome in this Bill. The Minister has a lot of important things in it. I welcome in particular the provisions in relation to the reporting of employee remuneration according to defined monetary bands. I do wonder, harking back to my own legislation in this area a few years ago, why it is not intended to provide in law for upper limits to salaries in State-funded broadcasters, which is something that was contained in the Private Members' legislation that I introduced a couple of years ago. That is something that should be looked at. I do not think it is appropriate to use the language of the past of "top talent" and this, that and the other. There is plenty of talent in the country, and I think that language was used to let salaries get out of control. Presumably, it is anonymised disclosure according to defined monetary bands, but I would like to see talk of an upper limit. There is widespread recognition in this country that spending in a lot of areas has got completely out of control. That does not just relate to Government spending of taxpayers' money but to the spending by organisations that receive considerable amounts of taxpayers' money. As we know, RTÉ received a commitment of getting €750 million in taxpayers’ money over a three-year period. There is, therefore, an ongoing concern to make sure there would be an upper limit of salaries. I proposed at the time that it would be tied to a ministerial salary or top civil servant salary at a certain grade.
There is a lot of commentary at the moment on the decline in the popularity of traditional mainstream media in Ireland, the shift to digital platforms and rising rates of news avoidance. Online outlets and websites have overtaken TV and print as people's main news sources. Traditional formats like print newspapers have dropped to single digits or low-digit weekly reach and circulations are in a long-term slide. There is much that is bad about that, but there is a lot that is good about the democratisation of the sourcing of news where people who perhaps feel that mainstream media have not been sufficiently fair in covering all aspects of different questions now have a place to which they can go. The good side is that we have this greater democratisation. Of course, we have the emergence of a certain amount of citizen journalism. The bad side, of course, is the difficulty in maintaining standards. Just because mainstream media has not always maintained good standards is no reason to embrace a free-for-all in the online world. We should all be concerned by, for example, the report from Coimisiún na Meán that active news avoidance has reached a record high of 47% among Irish consumers. Trust in most news, most of the time, has dropped to 42%. It is probably fair to say that a lot of mainstream broadcasters have given up on youth listening or reaching out to a youth audience. Certainly, the general trust in most news is just 33% among people aged 18 to 24. There is an overall loss of trust in general news. Broadcasters like RTÉ and local radio retain high trust ratings of around 70%. That may be of some concern, for example, to a big organisation like RTÉ, but I would say that it cannot be a cause for complacency. It has to be accepted that one reason for high degrees of trust can also be a certain conditioning of public opinion and that same conditioning of public opinion, where it happens, can cause minorities who dissent from conditioned or curated opinion to become further alienated.
I often recall my own experience as a student in Dublin City University, DCU, doing a master's degree in journalism. I hope people will forgive that I have referred to one particular issue from my main experience back in the 1990s. There was a poll or informal poll of the 25 or 30 of us in the class on the abortion issue and who had a pro-life sentiment and who would have described themselves as pro choice or pro abortion. I remember being in a minority of one or two in that class at a time when that would have in no way reflected the state of opinion in the country. I remember thinking that that was a concern for the future. Ever since then, I have always had this question in my mind as to what extent there is a hegemonic, dominant view on various issues in mainstream media that does not reflect the difference of opinion in society generally and to what extent media professionals see themselves as there to manage or curate public opinion as opposed to holding the mirror up to Irish society, in our case, in all its diversity. What we are seeing these days is a certain disgust among some people with being preached at subtly and not so subtly. That is why, in recent engagements at the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport, I have pressed the director general of RTÉ, Mr. Kevin Bakhurst, in particular, on the need to address this question of diversity and the need to ensure that RTÉ, in its personnel, has regard to the fact that there are different points of view on many different issues and to ensure there is not a dominant groupthink around certain issues.
It is always difficult to prove, and people should never just confine themselves to the issues in which they are interested themselves. However, it is a problem that has been going on for a long time whereby many people feel alienated and have felt preached at or that there was a conditioning of public opinion. I am thinking in particular in the past in the run-up to the referendums, for example, on marriage, family and pro-life issues, but other people may have a heightened sensitivity about where the domination of the expression of viewpoints has gone on in in relation to other issues.
That, of course, has contributed to this enthusiasm in some quarters for alternative media. As I have said, the downside of that is that people are not necessarily going to where they can find a greater diversity of viewpoints and instead end up, with good reason, going where they can see and hear the world examined through the lens of their own viewpoints. Of course, if everybody does that and retreats to their own silo, the consumption and expression of opinion is going to become more polarised and, unfortunately, more extreme. Even if it may seem like legacy media are holding the centre, they need to ensure that they are not enjoying their last hurrah. It may be that things are going to become more polarised and there will be a greater sense of alienation in the future. That is why there is a considerable responsibility on the leadership of RTÉ, in particular, to test for diversity within its ranks on a range of issues. There is also a responsibility on Coimisiún na Meán to ensure that this happens.
We hear so much about misinformation, disinformation and even malinformation. What about non-information, whereby some issues or points of view are simply not raised because they somehow come outside of the Overton window of what is considered to be permitted discourse? Take, for example, trans issues. There was a big debate on Joe Duffy's "Liveline" a few years ago and then it seemed like it was all closed down. We have not heard the arguments against surrogacy in the media for a long time. There has been the facilitation of one side through a focus on human interest and soft stories rather than the other.
There is also the neuralgic question of the relationship between immigration patterns or the management of immigration and crime statistics. People run away from discussing these issues. We have to be careful, it is true, but there is a duty to ensure that all concerns are heard and issues are properly tested even when it is uncomfortable.
I will leave it at that, other than to say that at a later point in this debate, perhaps on Committee Stage, we can return to consider - this is not an easy issue to resolve - how we can achieve the necessary diversity within the ranks of the media so that the full range of public opinion is properly served.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for coming to the House. I am glad to have the chance to speak on this Bill on behalf of Fianna Fáil. I extend my best wishes to Deputy Patrick O'Donovan and wish him a speedy recovery.
There is a lot to unpack in the Bill and much of it has already been mentioned. I do not wish to repeat too much. However, I will say that having spent most of my earlier working life in journalism and broadcasting, I care deeply about what we are discussing. I know the work that goes into getting a programme on the air, including the research, preparation, fact-checking and editorial judgment, and the responsibility of knowing that people are trusting you to get it right. That trust is hard-earned. It can take years to build and very little to destroy. Rebuilding trust requires more than assurances. That is what we need within this Bill. It requires clear responsibilities, honest answers and a willingness to be held to account. That is why this legislation matters and Fianna Fáil supports it.
I am also a member of the media committee and we have welcomed RTÉ before us on many occasions. We will have its representatives before the committee again tomorrow. They are open, but we are looking for more clarity, transparency and scrutiny. We will continue to do that. Public service broadcasting has an extraordinary place in Irish life.
I am not sure if this is true of the Minister of State, but I am of the age to know a time when there were only four channels. "Roll it there, Colette" and "Stop the lights!" were well-known catchphrases. Those media bring us the moments we celebrate and help us to make sense of those we would rather not see but must make sense of. I agree with Senator Mullen that we must ensure it is relevant, and continually relevant, to our young people and diverse new residents.
Of course, quality broadcasting asks uncomfortable questions of people in positions of power, including those of us in the Chamber. I did it for years, and perhaps I should have been a little lighter on some people, but we all must be open to scrutiny. A strong democracy, as we know, needs journalists who have the time, resources and independence to chase a story. It needs editors who can make decisions without wondering whether a politician, advertiser or powerful vested interest will approve. It also needs a public who can have confidence in the organisations doing the work.
It will not come as a revelation that RTÉ did enormous damage to that confidence. People paying their TV licences were entitled to feel angry, although boycotting payment has done serious damage. Staff who were doing their jobs professionally, and often under considerable pressure, also had a right to be angry, when decisions elsewhere in the organisation fell far short of the standards expected of a public institution. The responsibility for those failures must be faced squarely. I also believe that we should recognise the many people across RTÉ whose integrity and commitment were never in question. They deserve proper governance as much as the public does.
As we know, public money must be open to rigorous, independent scrutiny. People should be able to understand how it is spent and have confidence that someone is asking the difficult questions. The clear responsibilities for boards and directors general matter for exactly the same reason.
We all need to know that when something goes wrong, accountability cannot fall between the stools of the board, senior management and a committee. I found that to be happening over the years. There must be clear delineation. We need to know who is doing what and who is accountable to what. I felt that at times, they were not even certain who was accountable. People need to know who is responsible for what, the information they must provide and what happens when they fail in those duties. Legislation can establish a structure but the people working within it must make that structure mean something. It has to be put into practice.
A board needs members who will challenge, insist on clear information and recognise that an awkward question or two asked early can prevent a serious problem later. Of course, the test of that reform will be whether that becomes normal practice. As we mentioned, the greater transparency across remuneration and independent commissioning in this Bill is welcome.
We know that there will always be a competitive market for talent and that broadcasting involves people with very different skills and responsibilities. The public generally get that. What people struggle to accept is being given half the story or only a little of the picture, or finding out that the explanation they got bears little resemblance to the actual arrangement. My daughter says to me all the time that something is the bare minimum, and that should be true of transparency. It should not depend on a controversy forcing information into the open. We keep seeing that happen. It is lessening as the current structure goes on, but we must ensure that everything is out in the open. Alongside accountability, we must protect editorial independence. Both of those aspects are essential to public service media.
We all have a responsibility to ensure that public funding is properly used and to respect the freedom of journalists and programme makers to do their work. Stable, predictable funding helps to support that freedom. It allows an organisation to plan, invest in its people and undertake work, the value of which may be considerable even when its commercial return is limited. When a commitment is given to funding, a plan is put in place years in advance, and that is needed. Whatever is promised needs to be delivered. As we all know, thorough journalistic investigations or documentaries can take months. They often require infinite patience and meticulous research. That planning and funding need to be there. These are exactly the kinds of choices that public service broadcasters must be able to make.
I am particularly interested in the Bill's recognition that public service content comes from a much wider media community. My experience taught me the value of local journalism and regional news. In Drogheda and across Louth and Meath, local radio and newspapers provide a connection that a national newsroom simply cannot reproduce. They follow council decisions, school campaigns, local court cases and community organisations trying to keep their doors open. They know why a particular story matters because they know the people affected. They are embedded in the community. That work takes time and costs money. We cannot assume it will continue indefinitely simply because communities need it. The local democracy schemes have boosted employment and quality reporting across the country. Consistency is needed in that type of funding.
The move towards a platform-neutral media fund is welcome. Public interest journalism should be supported in the places where people find it. I ask the Minister of State to ensure that the schemes developed under this framework are accessible to local and regional providers, with application and reporting requirements proportionate to their resources. We need good journalism that is reaching communities and we need journalists spending their time producing it.
As arts spokesperson, I want to make a point about the place of culture in public service broadcasting. Our musicians, writers, actors, film-makers and artists contribute enormously to our culture, how Ireland understands itself and how we are understood across the globe. Their work requires a regular place in our coverage. There is a lively cultural scene in towns and communities across the country. Broadcasting can help people to discover that. I would also welcome an update from the Minister of State on how the commitment to strengthen arts coverage will be progressed while respecting editorial independence.
It is fantastic that one quarter of RTÉ's annual public funding goes towards independent commissioning. As we know, that can provide a much stronger foundation for creative companies and the people they employ. With that commitment to deliver, producers need fair commissioning processes, timely decisions and reasonable time to plan ahead.
The Minister of State himself mentioned that TG4 has shown the cultural value of having a distinctive public service voice. The ambition across our media system should be to ensure we are able to make more people feel that their language, community and experience belong in our shared national conversation.
To sum up, I wholeheartedly support this Bill. The public deserves institutions that spend responsibly, explain their decisions and earn trust through their everyday conduct. The people working in these institutions deserve clear leadership and the freedom to do their jobs well. This legislation gives us an opportunity to strengthen both. Its success will be measured by how those commitments are put into practice. We must keep an eye on that constantly and ensure our scrutiny remains up to date. I commend this Bill to the House.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin broadly supports this legislation, which should have been introduced and implemented long ago. A number of the measures in the Bill were previously proposed by Sinn Féin but, unfortunately, were not supported by the Government at the time. Bringing RTÉ under the remit of the Comptroller and Auditor General is long overdue, as are other aspects of this legislation, and is a meaningful step in ensuring the future of our broadcast media.
The media committee made 85 recommendations concerning this legislation. It is disappointing that the Government has shown no interest in engaging with many of them. Likewise, several proposals originally identified by the Future of Media Commission remain outstanding, with little sign of urgency from the Government. Despite an urgent need for reform, important recommendations continue to be left on the shelf to collect dust.
In particular, the recommendation to end geo-blocking in the North of Ireland has been completely ignored by the Government. It makes no sense that Irish citizens living in Ireland should not have access to their national broadcaster. When our football team plays, when our President is inaugurated and when national events, large and small, are broadcast, one fifth of our country is blocked from watching. This is shameful and it should have been done away with a long time ago. It is pure partitionism, and the inaction of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael is reflective of the Free State mentality. Irish people living north of the Border are no less Irish than those living in the South, yet the Government seems happy to apply different restrictions. Sinn Féin has consistently argued that people in the North should be able to access RTÉ content without unnecessary restrictions. The Minister's refusal to act on this recommendation is deeply disappointing. When the legislation was before the Dáil, the Government gave commitments to engage on this issue. It is very disappointing that there has not yet been any follow-through.
The Government has a responsibility to engage with broadcasters, regulators, internet service providers and the British Government to find practical solutions to this problem. Choosing not to proceed with this recommendation sends the wrong message to people in the North who simply want to access the same services enjoyed elsewhere on the island of Ireland. I look forward to the debate on Committee Stage and sincerely hope the Government will support our amendments to finally end geo-blocking or submit its own amendments to the same effect.
Comment on this
The Labour Party also broadly supports this Bill. It is important legislation to modernise our broadcasting and public service framework for a digital age that has changed fundamentally since the enactment of the Broadcasting Act 2009. It contains many of the recommendations of the Future of Media Commission and of the independent review of governance and culture of RTÉ. It also implements provisions of the European Media Freedom Act not dealt with in the Media Regulation Bill 2026.
We believe effective public service media are a central pillar of our democracy. In a fractured media and information environment, we need to support our public service broadcasters all the more. After a period in which public trust in public broadcasting has shown worrying signs of beginning to fray, this Bill represents an attempt to address three core issues. First, it strengthens governance and accountability at RTÉ and TG4. Second, it broadens and modernises the definition of "public service media" to include a framework for public service content. Third, it seeks to protect editorial independence and democratic discourse in accordance with European standards. We believe these objectives deserve support across this House.
This Bill acknowledges that public service content now exists not only on television and radio but also through digital publications and platform-based services such as podcasts. This is an important shift in legislation. It recognises that Irish public service content should reflect the full diversity of life in this country, including our culture, language, history, sport, arts, environment, science, education and communities at home and abroad. Importantly, it introduces the concept of under-served audiences.
Requiring stronger Irish-language competence among board and audience council members reflects the unique cultural role TG4 plays in Irish society. We must ensure that the Irish-language competence requirements for board members are set at the appropriate level. I know this was debated in the Dáil, and it would be worth considering in this House. The former Labour Party Minister for the arts, and former President, Michael D. Higgins proudly launched TG4 agus táimid an-bhródúil as seo sa Pháirtí an Lucht Oibre.
On Irish-language broadcasting, is mór an trua nach bhfuil aon consultation with Coimisiún na Meán on the broadcasting services strategy which seems to rule out the possibility of a national Irish-language FM radio station for young people. It is so disappointing that Coimisiún na Meán would take a backward step like this while this legislation is trying to recognise the importance of Irish-language broadcasting. We all, including the Minister of State, know that Raidió Rí-Rá has operated for more than 20 years. Its continuing goal is to broadcast on FM full-time so it can receive support comparable to stations such as Beat and SPIN FM and ensure young people throughout the country can listen to the radio as Gaeilge all the time. That is very important. My party will make a submission to Coimisiún na Meán on this issue. We deserve to have this service. Under the Coimisiún na Meán draft strategy, there is a serious risk that there will never be an opportunity to secure an FM licence for an Irish-language radio station. Coimisiún na Meán has already granted 56 FM licences, none of which is broadcasting entirely through Irish. This is important and I hope the Minister of State will take it into account.
In recent years, we have seen serious controversy concerning governance and financial oversight within RTÉ. Public confidence has been badly damaged as a result. This Bill responds to that reality by strengthening board responsibility, clarifying the role of the director general, increasing transparency around remuneration and allowing greater scrutiny. All those measures are very welcome. What the Labour Party believes is not in this legislation, however, is any provision to address the fundamental problem facing public service media, namely, funding. In 2023, RTÉ received some funding certainty through Government funding, but it was not clear before budget 2027, and is certainly not clear now, that a reformed long-term funding model will be introduced. Public broadcasting matters, but it needs adequate funding.
It is vital, of course, that RTÉ delivers on the reforms it agreed to implement. That is 100% the case. However, the arbitrary reduction in its funding announced in budget 2026 does not appear to have had any objective basis or to have followed engagement with RTÉ. It looks very much like the decision was motivated by a funding shortfall in the Minister's Department. I wish the Minister, Deputy Patrick O'Donovan, the very best in his recovery.
Whatever anyone thinks about RTÉ, a public broadcaster cannot plan, reform or maintain its independence if promised funding can disappear on budget day with no warning or explanation. Questions have to be answered about this aspect. This is not just a matter of good practice but one of law. The European Media Freedom Act requires Ireland to have funding procedures in place for our public service media broadcasters based on transparent and objective criteria laid down in advance. It is time to have a serious conversation about a sustainable funding settlement for RTÉ and TG4. My party supports a content levy, in the context of a provision containing proper safeguards to protect consumers. An audiovisual media levy of 5% would help to raise €50 million. We think it is perfectly possible to support Irish creativity and public service broadcasting, hold major streaming platforms to account and ensure consumers are protected.
Before I finish, I want to raise the issue of independent broadcasters. I have spoken about this issue here previously. Under section 21 of the Broadcasting Act 2009, Coimisiún na Meán imposes levies on television, sound-broadcasting and on-demand services to meet the cost of its statutory functions. In April, Coimisiún na Meán notified services of the proposed levy rate for 2026.
The 2026 levy for radio is 2.8% of turnover. The rate for TV is 1.21%. The rate for online services is at 1.25%. The rate for hosting services is 0.54%. Where I live - it is probably the same in the Minister of State's area - we rely a great deal on local media and broadcasters, particularly Ocean FM, Highland Radio, Shannonside FM and Midwest Radio. These stations provide a public service in areas where RTÉ probably does not reach as much as we would like. They have said that the hike in the levy will mean an average increase of 39% for its members year on year. Stations will have to pay €3.7 million to Coimisiún na Meán this year. That is €1 million more than last year. Since 2024, the levy on radio stations has increased by 61%. They provide a vital service but they are going to be priced out of business because of spiralling costs. They have said this. In my area in particular, they employ a lot of local staff. Because the rise in the levy has massively outpaced the increase in direct Exchequer funding or advertising funding, these radio stations are being left with a black hole. We cannot afford to lose them. We need some common-sense thinking around this from Coimisiún na Meán. In our alternative budget, we committed €1 million from direct Exchequer funding to the independent broadcasters to fill the shortfall. I hope the decision can be revisited.
Comment on this
I thank all Senators for their important contributions on the Second Stage debate on the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill. I am replying on behalf of the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport. Like everyone else, I wish the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, the best. The Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, is taking over his responsibilities during his recovery. We wish the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, well and hope that he will be back as quickly as possible.
The constructive approach taken by the Senators is to be admired. I will go through a couple of items people raised. Senator Ní Chuilinn has great experience in the area, as has Senator Comyn. I was struck by her thoughts on independent producers and the wealth of talent that is out there. This would put in structured revenues of 25%. That is something that would make an enormous difference.
Senator Ní Chuilinn also made reference to the Brennan report. I was struck by the fact that so many good people are working in RTÉ and it has been a very difficult time for them. The important thing is that RTÉ comes out of this stronger. The Government can assist in that regard with legislation and so forth.
Senator Mullen raised two points. First, he referred to the remuneration limit. Kevin Bakhurst, the director general of RTÉ, committed that his salary would remain the highest at the broadcaster. That is to be welcomed. The Bill provides that the remuneration of the director general must be approved by both the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport and the Minister for public expenditure.
Senator Mullen also referred to diversity. There are three aspects to that. He asked that as part of the statutory public service remit of RTÉ we would request it to make a broad range of programmes available to the whole community of the island of the Ireland and that Coimisiún na Meán is required to uphold its statutory media service duties of impartiality, fairness and objectivity. It is important to note that audience councils selected by Coimisiún na Meán must reflect the diversity of the people of the island of Ireland.
Senator Comyn raised a couple of points. The first related to a clear delineation of responsibilities. In terms of corporate governance, it is important that the director general, the board and everyone else knows what their areas of responsibility are. This would provide very clear direction in that space. The Bill will ensure that the Comptroller and Auditor General will now be the auditor. RTÉ will have certain areas where it will have privacy but overall the accounts will be audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General. The Senator spoke about trust. There is huge trust in the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Senator Comyn also referred to the need to promote the art of broadcasting in terms of culture and arts. That was raised during the Dáil debate. On Report Stage in the Lower House, the Minister of State, Deputy McConalogue, stated that officials are currently examining possible legislative provisions that would have the effect of promoting coverage of the arts in broadcast media while respecting the editorial independence of the broadcaster. However, given the need to enact the Bill as soon as possible in order to allow for the assignment of the Comptroller and Auditor General as auditor of RTÉ for the 2026 accounts, there will not be a sufficient amount of time to include any such provision. It is expected there will be a need to bring forward media legislation in the coming period and it is envisaged that this issue will be addressed in that context. This is very much taken on board.
Senator Andrews made reference to geo-blocking. There are two aspects to that issue. He asked that in terms of the public service remit of RTÉ it would be requested to make a broad range of programming available to the whole community of the island of Ireland. When the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, was in, he agreed with the point that arose but there are other issues that need to be taken into account. The particular issue was the geo-blocking of certain services in Northern Ireland. This issue was discussed several times during the Bill's passage through the Dáil. As the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, said previously, he shares people's concerns regarding this issue. The Broadcasting Act 2009 provides that RTÉ and TG4 should make their services available to the whole community on the island of Ireland insofar as is reasonably practicable. That would feed into what I stated earlier. However, neither RTÉ nor TG4 can control the pricing of rights nor the geographical or territorial distribution decided by the rights holders.
As discussed in the debate on the Bill in the Dáil, this continues to give rise to circumstances where audiences in the North are unable to access programmes that are broadcast and made available online by RTÉ and TG4. This was particularly frustrating in relation to the Olympics - and more particularly our Gaelic games - where Team Ireland contains athletes from across the island. There is no immediate legislative solution to this problem given the extraterritorial issues at play. Ofcom, the UK regulator, is due to facilitate a meeting in Belfast of the television broadcasters of Ireland group within the next few weeks. I understand that Coimisiún na Meán intends to raise geo-blocking at this meeting and to discuss the various challenges and efforts to explore ways to find a solution. We all want to find a solution. The Minister has discussed the issue with the British ambassador recently. It is the intention of the Minister, Deputy O'Donovan, to write to his British counterpart, the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport as soon as practicable. I have no doubt that is something the current Minister in situ will address. Departmental officials will communicate with their British counterparts on the matter. The Minister and the Government are very conscious of the issue. The Senator raises a valid point. The question is about finding a solution in this area.
Senator Cosgrove raised two issues. The first related to funding. The Senator made a particular point that I want to address. She referred to the awarding of radio licences for young people.
The awarding of licences is a matter for Coimisiún na Meán as the independent regulator. Coimisiún na Meán is due to publish an Irish language action plan in the coming months. The Minister will examine proposals contained in the action plan, including how best to support services for young people. Once again, this is a very good point that has been raised and work is under way with Coimisiún na Meán.
Reference was made to funding and, more particularly, to what local radio stations bring. Everybody extolled their virtues and the work of the people in this area. As I said in my opening speech, this will be very relevant on Committee Stage in the Seanad. On Committee Stage in the Dáil amendments were made with the aim of reducing the cost of the Coimisiún na Meán industry levy for the commercial radio sector. A number of further amendments will be proposed by the Government on Committee Stage in this House regarding the operation of the Coimisiún na Meán industry levy. These amendments will include a requirement that Coimisiún na Meán, when preparing a levy, has regard to whether a broadcaster is a micro, small or medium-sized enterprise. We are talking about local radio stations and each one has a huge role to play. Senator Comyn referred to the power of local media and, more particularly, local radio stations. There will be a requirement that Coimisiún na Meán publishes the methodology used to calculate the levy and to identify separately the costs incurred in respect of each regulated sector, such as the radio sector. This is something Senators will have an opportunity to debate at length on Committee Stage. I can see that it is very important to everybody.
What is coming out of the legislation is that it is about accountability and value for money. The appointment of the Comptroller and Auditor General as the auditor of RTÉ is a progressive move. It is about transparency in reporting. Coimisiún na Meán will oversee RTÉ twice yearly and there will also be three-year assessment plans. The ideas of transparent accounting and value for money in public service media providers are not limited to RTÉ and TG4. Our local, regional and national commercial newspapers also produce public interest journalism and make innovative Irish programming available to the public. This is why we put in place a statutory framework that seeks to ensure the Irish public has access to high-quality, accessible public service content, supplied by RTÉ which has a distinctive role and duties as a public service provider, and by the wider Irish media sector. This point arose in all of the contributions; it is not only about the national broadcasters but also the important role of local broadcasters and media.
The variety of issues raised on the floor of the House highlights the breadth of the framework set out in the Bill. The Bill represents a key milestone in the evolution of the Broadcasting Act 2009 in terms of the regulation, governance and assessment of public service media providers, as well as the assessment and recognition of the role of the wider media sector in providing public service content to the public. The Bill will provide Coimisiún na Meán, as the independent regulator, with enhanced powers to ensure that public service media providers are transparent and independent and provide value for money. It enables Coimisiún na Meán to deal with the continuing changes in how we support and engage public service media and public service content providers in Ireland.
The Bill has a critical EU-law dimension as it will transpose the European Media Freedom Act. Senator Ní Chuilinn made reference to this earlier. The Bill increases public service media independence, strengthens independent regulators and provides for objective assessments of funding needs and appraisal, as required by the European media Act.
I thank Senators for their constructive approach. They have a shared determination not only to improve transparency, accountability and value for money in our public service media providers but also to support the idea of funding public service broadcasts in this country, nationally and locally.