We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation Bill 2026: Second Stage

Summary

The Bill completes transposition of the EU anti-SLAPP directive and extends protections to domestic as well as cross-border civil and commercial proceedings, including early dismissal of manifestly unfounded cases, costs and damages remedies, and support for defendants. Senators broadly supported it, while raising concerns about preserving access to court for genuine claims, practical support for targets and whether wider defamation-law reforms are needed; Committee Stage is scheduled for next Tuesday.

Bill Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation Bill 2026
Current

No. 76 of 2026 ›

Jim O'Callaghan Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Fianna Fáil

Ba mhaith liom comhghairdeas a ghabháil leis an Seanadóir nua, an Seanadóir McAdam. Bhíomar ag obair le chéile i gComhairle Cathrach Bhaile Átha Clíath agus níl aon dabht agam ach go mbeidh sé ina Sheanadóir an-éifeachtúil ar fad.

I will start by congratulating the new Senator, Senator McAdam, and I wish him many happy years in the Upper House. I am sure he does not want to spend all of his years in the Upper House but I wish him well in this House and any other House he gets elected to.

I am pleased to present to Seanad Éireann the Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation Bill 2026 and I look forward to hearing the contributions of Senators. The Bill introduces protections for those targeted by strategic lawsuits against public participation, commonly known as SLAPPs. They are abusive legal proceedings brought not to vindicate a legitimate right or obtain genuine redress but to deter, restrict and prevent public participation. They are often characterised by an imbalance of power, with one party using the significant resources at its disposal to exert significant pressure on another through lengthy or complex legal processes.

Those targeted by SLAPPs can include journalists, environmental rights defenders, media outlets, civil society organisations, human rights advocates or any person who contributes to public discourse. This can have a very negative effect on public interest reporting and debate, undermining freedom of expression, public access to information and democracy itself. The harmful impact of SLAPPs has been recognised at EU level, reflected in the adoption of the Commission's anti-SLAPP recommendation in 2022 and the entry into force of the anti-SLAPP directive in 2024. Together, these measures reflect a growing recognition of the need to protect public participation from abusive litigation.

This Bill will complete transposition of the anti-SLAPP directive, which requires member states to introduce minimum procedural safeguards to combat abusive proceedings against public participation. While the directive is limited to civil and commercial proceedings with a cross-border element, the Bill takes a broader approach. It extends the same safeguards to all civil and commercial proceedings, whether cross-border or domestic in nature, thereby ensuring a consistent level of protection for individuals and organisations that may be subjected to SLAPPs.

A number of the safeguards required by the directive have already been included in relation to defamation proceedings in Part 7 of the Defamation (Amendment) Act 2026, enacted by the Oireachtas earlier this year. Part 7 amended the Defamation Act 2009 to provide specific protections in defamation cases, an area in which SLAPP litigation can commonly arise. The Bill builds upon these protections and completes transposition in relation to both defamation proceedings and all other civil and commercial proceedings. For the purpose of consistency across all forms of civil and commercial proceedings, the Bill consolidates the legislative framework governing SLAPP protections. It repeals Part 7 of the Defamation (Amendment) Act 2026 and directly amends the Defamation Act 2009. This will ensure that the key protections against SLAPPs are referred to in the same legislation.

I will now address the main provisions of the Bill. Sections 1 to 3 provide for the short title and commencement of the Bill, definitions and the repeal of Part 7 of the Defamation (Amendment) Act 2026.

Section 4 outlines that Part 2 applies to proceedings brought against a person on account of his or her engagement in public participation.

Section 5 provides for an obligation on the part of the defendant to inform the court where they consider that proceedings have been taken against them on account of their public participation. This ensures that the court is aware of the potential for proceedings to be abusive proceedings against public participation and that the procedures and protections of the Bill apply.

Section 6 enables a court, at its discretion, to allow a person or body with a legitimate interest in safeguarding or promoting the rights of persons engaged in public participation to make submissions to the court and to assist the defendant in proceedings alleged to be a SLAPP. This seeks to ensure that SLAPP targets can obtain assistance from persons or organisations with relevant experience and expertise throughout proceedings that may be lengthy, complex and overwhelming.

Section 7 provides that a court may, on application by a defendant, require a plaintiff to provide security for the defendant's costs or any damages claimed by the defendant if the court is satisfied that there is a prima facie case that the proceedings are abusive court proceedings, and that the requirement is in the interests of justice.

Section 8 allows a defendant to seek early dismissal of proceedings relating to their engagement in public participation on the basis that those proceedings are manifestly unfounded. Where an application for early dismissal is made, the plaintiff is obliged to substantiate their claim so the court can determine whether or not it is manifestly unfounded.

The striking-out of SLAPP proceedings at an early stage will ensure that SLAPP targets are not forced to ensure the lengthy and costly extent of a full trial. At the same time, the requirement that proceedings be "manifestly unfounded" mitigates the risk that those with genuine claims will be denied access to the courts.

Sections 9 and 10 allow a defendant to apply to the court at any stage of proceedings, including where early dismissal of sought, for a declaration that proceedings taken against them are SLAPP proceedings. Where a court issues such a declaration, the court must take that declaration into consideration when making orders for costs. The Bill requires the court to consider the issue of costs as expeditiously as possible and allows the court to order the plaintiff to pay costs to the defendant on the more generous legal practitioner and client, or legal practitioner and own client, basis if it considers this to be appropriate.

Section 11 enables a target of SLAPP proceedings to seek damages for an injury, loss or harm suffered as a result of those proceedings. Damages may be sought at the time an application for a declaration was made under section 9 or 10, or following the making of a declaration. This is a significant provision that recognises the extraordinary and abusive nature of SLAPP proceedings.

Section 12 requires a court that has made a finding that proceedings are a SLAPP to direct that its written judgment be published on the website of the Courts Service, or, where there is no written judgment, that its order be published. In addition to having a deterrent effect, this will give greater clarity on the frequency of SLAPPs in Ireland and the types of proceedings used as vehicles for SLAPPs, data on which is currently limited. The publication of such judgments is not dissimilar from the legislative provision I introduced in respect to the Domestic Violence Judgments Register Act, which was enacted by the Houses of the Oireachtas earlier this year.

The Bill also contains provisions to protect public participants domiciled in Ireland from SLAPP proceedings taken against them in non-EU countries. Section 13 prohibits the recognition or enforcement of judgments made in third country proceedings that will have been considered abusive court proceedings against public participation or manifestly unfounded if they had been initiated in this State.

Section 14 allows targets of third country SLAPP proceedings domiciled in Ireland to seek a declaration that those proceedings are abusive proceedings against public participation within the meaning of the legislation. Where such a declaration is made, a defendant may also seek compensation for damages and costs incurred in the third country proceedings.

Section 15 inserts a new Part 4A into the Defamation Act 2009. It replaces section 19 of the Defamation (Amendment) Act 2026, which is repealed by section 3 of the Bill. Part 4A consists of 12 provisions to be inserted into the Defamation Act 2009. Section 34A is an interpretation provision similar to that contained in section 2 of the Bill. Section 34B clarifies that Part 4A applies to defamation proceedings. Section 34C, 34CA, 34D to 34I, inclusive, and 34IA and 34IB mirror the provisions contained in sections 5 to 14, inclusive, which I have outlined. The distinction is that these provisions will apply specifically to defamation proceedings.

This Bill will provide significant protections for those who engage in public debate and contribute to matters of public interest. It strikes an important balance, strengthening protections against abusive litigation designed to suppress public participation while safeguarding access to justice for those with legitimate claims. I am hopeful that, with the support and co-operation of the House, we can progress the Bill as quickly as possible, secure its enactment at an early date to bring these protections into force, and complete the transposition of the directive. Therefore, I commend the Bill to the House.

Comment on this
Shane Curley Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I thank the Minister. Before we proceed, I welcome Keegan Hanley to the Gallery today. He is doing transition year work experience with me this week. It is great to see a young person from my former school of St Brigid's College, Loughrea, up doing work experience in Leinster House. Tá fáilte roimhe.

We welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Ardagh. Anois, glaoim ar an Seanadóir Gallagher.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte mhór roimh an Aire Stáit chuig an Teach seo inniu. On behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party, I welcome this debate and support the Bill, an important step in protecting press freedom, freedom of expression and our democratic values.

Our democracy was hard won and should never be taken for granted. A free press and open public debate are fundamental to a modern democracy. Those who speak out, expose wrongdoing or contribute to matters of public interest must be able to do so without fear of intimidation or costly legal action.

Strategic lawsuits against public participation, commonly known as SLAPPs, are abusive legal proceedings designed not to secure genuine justice but to silence critics, intimidate journalists and discourage public participation. They are often brought about by powerful individuals or organisations with significant financial resourcing, placing enormous financial and psychological pressure on those that they target. The consequences can be very serious indeed. SLAPPs can prevent important stories from being published, discourage legitimate criticism and create a chilling effect on public debate. Ultimately, they threaten press freedom, public access to information and democracy itself. The consequences of SLAPPs have been recognised at EU level.

The Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation Bill will transpose the requirements of the EU directive in relation to this area. The directive requires member states to introduce minimum procedural safeguards to combat abusive proceedings against public participation in civic and commercial cases which have a cross-border dimension. Those protections include the early dismissal of proceedings that are clearly or manifestly unfounded and the ability for the target of SLAPPs to seek more generous costs and damages, as well as security for those costs and damages. These aim to protect persons who engage in public participation against court proceedings initiated to deter them. This is considered necessary to allow active participation in public debate and the provision of reliable information without undue influence. The protections of SLAPP will apply to domestic as well as cross-border proceedings. They will avoid a situation where lower levels of protection apply domestically.

The directive will also allow judges to impose penalties or other equally effective measures on those initiating SLAPP cases as a matter of deterring such a form. It is also incumbent upon EU member states to refuse to recognise or enforce judgments from third countries that are manifestly unfounded or abusive. The Bill also builds on the protections already introduced though Part 7 of the Defamation (Amendment) Act 2026, extending these safeguards beyond defamation cases to all relevant civil and commercial proceedings. It consolidates the protections within the Defamation Act 2009 to ensure consistency.

This legislation is about ensuring that the law cannot be weaponised to silence those who speak out on matters of public importance. It is about protecting journalists, media organisations, human rights defenders and ordinary citizens who contribute to public debate. It is equally important that these protections do not undermine the legitimate right of individuals to access the courts and pursue genuine claims. We in Fianna Fáil support the Bill because a healthy democracy depends on people being free to question, criticise, investigate and hold those in positions of power to account without fear of being silenced through abusive legal action. We look forward to this Bill progressing through the House in due course.

Comment on this

I favour the introduction of this Bill. It is strange indeed that the directive, which gave rise to an amendment to the Defamation (Amendment) Act, which was passed this year, was not confined to simply defamation and that this Bill effectively acknowledges that, even though it does make specific provision toward the end of the Bill for defamation cases.

I have a few things to say about SLAPP-type proceedings. It was hugely important that the present President of the United States, Donald Trump, decided to sue the British Broadcasting Corporation for a programme in relation to American politics, which he claims defamed him.

He claimed to sue the BBC for a sum of $10 billion in the American courts. His clear purpose - and it was not the only time he has done this; he has threatened sections of the America media with similar claims - was to silence his critics. It struck me at the time that, if he persuaded a jury somewhere in America to uphold his claim of $10 billion, depending on how the BBC fared in defending the case, the decree would effectively be executed against the BBC in many different ways, for instance in relation to copyright entitlements arising in America and the like. His intention was clearly to intimidate the BBC. The BBC is not infallible and it apologised for an editorial error in relation to the particular complaint President Trump brought.

However, let us be clear about one thing. Analysing Donald Trump, his personality and position in politics and so on, whether he has a reputation worth saving is something I have few doubts about. There is the matter of his personal behaviour, his behaviour towards women, opponents, the people of Gaza and the people of the West Bank, his behaviour in seizing the Head of State of Venezuela and his offer to bribe American voters with a cheque for the sum of €5,000 each if the Republicans won the recent mid-term elections. His character is pretty worthless and I am glad to say in this House that I have complete contempt for him. Some of my friends say they hope I am not hoping to travel to the United States in the near future. Maybe the mid-term elections will make it possible for me to travel to America. I do not know whether they will, but it is terrible, for instance, that the phones of Irish students proposing to go to the US to work on J1 visas are searched to see whether they have anything on their phones that is critical of America or its President. That shows how far American democracy had plummeted in terms of the protection of people's rights, the right of people in Ireland to have and express views about America and the like.

The second thing about the Bill is that the European directive required us to introduce this protection against SLAPPs in respect of cross-border litigation in the European Union and from outside it. The curious thing about that is that, if it were simply implemented via a statutory instrument, it would have ended up with us having a two-tier system of protections. A wealthy Irish person, corporation or foreign corporation that carries on business here could engage in SLAPP litigation with impunity against Irish citizens, whereas someone abroad with a cross-border element as far as EU law is concerned would not be able to do so with immunity.

A number of issues need to be thought through, such as the extent to which litigation would be regarded as SLAPP-type litigation of a domestic kind. Let me take a simple example which might touch a raw nerve for some people.

The recent fuel protests brought into sharp focus the capacity for, say, an oil company to bring litigation against individuals who are organising blockades of its premises. The question would arise whether its claim for injunctions and damages would amount to abusive litigation for the purposes of this section. It could be said the kinds of people who threatened litigation in those circumstances could come up against a defence that oil protests, blockades and the like were legitimate public demonstrations of a defensible kind and were concerned with protecting the public interest. We can imagine the kind of dispute there could be in court. By making this into a domestic remedy as well as a cross-border remedy, we should be careful not to rob legitimate people of legitimate protections from the court simply because the defendants cast themselves as the victims of SLAPP litigation.

The whole area of injunctions is something I would like to see discussed on Committee Stage. If somebody is seeking an injunction against, for instance, people taking direct action in respect of political aims such as afforestation in the mid-west or data centres, whether those people will be in a position to avail of the defences in this Bill is a matter of concern to me. There are people who abuse their rights in order to injure the economic interests of others.

In general terms, I am in favour of the Bill for the reasons set out by other speakers. Protecting free speech and taking a stance against Trump-like litigation are worthwhile. I am glad we have the opportunity to legislate to protect those rights. I will be supporting the Bill.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit, an Teachta Ardagh. Gabhaim buíochas léi agus leis an Aire, an Teachta O'Callaghan, as ucht teacht isteach chuig an Seanad chun an Bille seo a phlé. Ar son Sheanadóirí Fhine Gael, cuirim fáilte roimh an mBille agus tugaimid ár gcuid tacaíochta dó.

At its heart, this legislation is about protecting people who speak out on matters of public interest and ensuring those in positions of power cannot exploit the justice system to silence, restrict or punish them. The goal of a SLAPP is not necessarily to secure a legitimate legal result but to intimidate, financially exhaust, harass or silence someone who has spoken out. Imbalance of power is central to this issue. Those with significant financial resources can use the threat of lengthy and costly legal proceedings to bully individuals who may not have the means to defend themselves. The right to take legal action must never be used as a weapon to silence those who hold power to account.

The Bill strengthens protections for journalists, investigative reporters, whistleblowers, human rights defenders, researchers, academics and individuals who participate in public debate. It protects our right to freedom of speech. I particularly welcome that the legislation goes beyond the requirements of the EU directive by extending safeguards to domestic, civil and commercial proceedings. It provides broader protection for the people of Ireland. It also introduces important practical protections. Courts can now permit third party organisations, including those with relevant human rights expertise, to assist defendants. There are provisions for security for costs and defendants can apply to have unfounded claims struck out without having to endure a full trial. They can also seek damages where abusive proceedings have caused them injury, loss or harm.

I emphasise that this legislation does not prevent someone from taking legitimate legal action to protect their reputation or assert their rights. Rather, it targets proceedings whose principal purpose is to prevent or restrict public participation. Ultimately, the Bill is about protecting the democratic process, addressing imbalances of power and ensuring that people can speak out on matters of public interest without fear of being targeted and financially punished for doing so. I welcome the Bill and support its passage through the Seanad.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on the Bill. We support the introduction of legislation to strengthen protections for individuals and organisations who find themselves facing abusive legal proceedings simply because they have spoken out to challenge wrongdoing or sought to hold those in positions of power to account. Some of these proceedings have had a chilling effect on public debate, journalism, environmental activism and the work of human rights organisations. We must ensure that our legal system cannot be misused as a means of silencing legitimate criticism or preventing matters of public interest from being brought out into the open.

We welcome the additional protections in the Bill which build on the anti-SLAPP measures already introduced through the Defamation (Amendment) Act 2026. I particularly welcome the provisions around defence to seek the early dismissal of proceedings that are clearly unfounded. That is important because the financial and emotional burden of defending a case can, in itself, become a form of punishment regardless of the eventual outcome.

We also welcome provisions allowing the courts to require security for costs, provide remedies in cases of abusive proceedings and facilitate interventions by human rights organisations and other bodies with relevant expertise. These organisations play an important role in defending fundamental rights and supporting people who may otherwise lack the resources to defend themselves. However, we must recognise that many of these organisations operate with limited funding. If we expect them to play a greater role in protecting people from abuse of litigation, we must consider how they can be properly supported.

There is a wider issue here about access to justice. The courts must be accessible to everyone, not simply to those with the deepest pockets. In this State concerns have been raised about the financial and emotional burden faced by families who have had to take legal action to vindicate the rights of their children, including cases involving assessments of need. These families do not engage in litigation lightly. They are often parents who have exhausted every other avenue and feel they have no option but to turn to the courts to secure the services and supports their children need. I accept that such cases are not necessarily SLAPP proceedings, but they highlight a much wider issue about the imbalance of resources that can exist when ordinary people find themselves in legal proceedings against bodies with significantly greater financial resources. It is important that the Government reflect on this.

It is also important that the protections contained in the legislation are effective in practice. People must have confidence that the legal system is fair, independent and accessible, regardless of whom they are challenging. Ultimately, the Bill must strike the appropriate balance between protecting people from abusive litigation and preserving the legitimate right of individuals and organisations to seek justice through the courts. The intention is not to prevent genuine legal claims from being heard. It is to prevent legal proceedings from being misused to intimidate, silence or financially overwhelm those participating in matters of public interest.

We support measures aimed at strengthening protections against abusive legal proceedings. We welcome the objectives of the Bill and the additional safeguards it seeks to introduce. We also believe there is an opportunity as the legislation progresses to examine whether further improvements are needed to ensure the protections are practical, accessible and effective. Nobody should be afraid to speak out about wrongdoing, challenge powerful interests or raise legitimate concerns because they fear the financial consequences of doing so. A functioning democracy depends on people who question decisions, expose wrongdoings and participate freely in public debate.

We support the passage of the Bill through Second Stage and look forward to engaging constructively as it progresses through the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

I welcome the passing of this Bill and its objectives. At the heart of this legislation it is about protecting fundamental human rights, the right to freedom of expression, the right to participate in public life and the right to hold those in positions of power to account without fear of intimidation. SLAPPs are not simply ordinary legal disputes. They can be used, and have been used, as a means of silencing those who speak out, particularly human rights defenders, journalists, whistleblowers and campaigners. These are all people who play an essential role in protecting our democracy and exposing injustice. Yet, the threat of lengthy legal proceedings, mounting costs and personal stress can be enough to force them into silence. We have seen that in the past. The legal process itself should not become the very punishment.

IHREC has rightly emphasised that protecting human rights defenders requires robust measures and meaningful support such as access to legal aid at an early stage in order that costs do not become overwhelming. Human rights defenders need to know things like the legal aid and advice and where information will be available to them.

I understand that IHREC will be considered for the role of the proposed national focus point. It must be properly recognised and adequately resourced so that those who are targeted know where they can turn to for support. We also need transparency and meaningful monitoring so we can assess whether these protections are working in practice. Ultimately, human rights are only meaningful when people can exercise them without fear of financial ruin or intimidation. This Bill is an important step towards ensuring those who defend rights, expose wrongdoing, and participate in public debates can do so freely and safely. I look forward to seeing it deliver meaningful protections in practice.

Comment on this

The Minister of State, Deputy Ardagh, is very welcome to the Chamber today. I welcome the Bill and I intend to support it. The Minister of State is correct to identify the growing problem of SLAPPs and the chilling effect this can have on journalists, whistleblowers, activists and ordinary citizens who seek to contribute to public debate. There is no doubt but that the law can be weaponised. There is no doubt that a legal threat can, in some circumstances, be used to vindicate a genuine right but also to intimidate, to exhaust and ultimately to silence. For that reason I welcome that this Bill seeks to provide the courts with new tools to identify and address abusive proceedings at an early stage.

While I support the Bill I also find myself arriving at a similar conclusion to one I have reached on many pieces of legislation that have come before this House, namely, that we should not allow the perfect to become the enemy of the good but neither should we allow the good to hold us back from the better. Ultimately, this Bill does something important but it does not do enough. At its core, the Bill is procedural. It creates mechanisms, applications, declarations and new questions for courts to determine. The fundamental problem, however, identified by advocates of anti-SLAPP reform is that the process itself is the punishment. The journalists may ultimately win a case after three years, an activist may ultimately be vindicated and a whistleblower may ultimately succeed but if they have spent tens of thousands of euro, endured years of uncertainty and have been dragged repeatedly into the courts before reaching that point, then one must ask whether justice has truly been served.

The current Bill contains provisions that allow for a defendant to apply for the claim to be struck out. I fear there is a danger that we are creating, effectively, a case within a case. We are asking the courts to determine whether proceedings are abusive before determining whether the underlying claim is valid. We are adding procedural safeguards that may indeed be useful but we are not necessarily addressing the broader structural incentives that have made these kinds of actions attractive in the first place.

If we are serious about protecting freedoms of expression then we must be willing to consider larger reforms. For example, should Ireland introduce a statutory serious harm threshold requiring plaintiffs to demonstrate substantial reputational damage before proceedings may continue? Should we strengthen public interest defences for journalists and whistleblowers who act responsibly and in good faith? Should we place greater emphasis on corrections, replies and apologies rather than increasingly large damage awards? Should we more clearly distinguish between public figures and private citizens when assessing what level of scrutiny must be tolerated in a democratic society?

We must also confront a deeper question. Throughout these debates there can sometimes be an implicit assumption that our current balance between freedom of expression and protection of reputation is simply the natural order of things and that we merely need to make occasional procedural adjustment around the edges. I am not convinced that this is true. Our legal structure has, for understandable reasons, placed enormous weight on the protection of reputation. Much of this derives from Article 40.3.2° of the Constitution that obliges the State to protect and vindicate the good name of the citizen. If we find that procedural reforms have not fundamentally solved the problem then we may have to ask more constitutional questions. We may have to examine whether our constitutional framework strikes the correct balance between reputation and expression. We may have to ask whether constitutional reform itself is necessary. If we genuinely believe that free citizens should be able to question powerful institutions, challenge public figures, expose wrongdoing and participate in democratic debate without fear of ruinous litigation, then we must be willing to follow that principle wherever the evidence leads us. This Bill is a step forward but let us not deceive ourselves into believing it is the destination. Rather, it should be regarded as the beginning of a much larger conversation around the future of defamation law, freedom of expression and constitutional rights in Ireland.

Comment on this
Shane Curley Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Before I move on I just want to welcome members of Carne Golf Club in the Gallery. They are guests of Deputy Keira Keogh today. Tá fáilte romhaibh.

Comment on this

It would be remiss of me to let the moment pass without acknowledging my former leader here and long time Member of this Upper House, the Minister of State, Deputy Catherine Ardagh. I have not seen her in the House here as although the Minister of State has been here on a couple of occasions, between one thing and another I have not been here. I congratulate her on her elevation to Minister of State.

I think we have broad support for this Bill and most people have spoken in favour of it. We are not going to please everybody with every little detail but the general consensus is of support, which is good coming from this House.

Comment on this
Catherine Ardagh Minister of State at the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Fianna Fáil

I thank all the Senators who have contributed to the debate today on this very important legislation, namely, Senators Gallagher, McDowell , Kelleher, Murphy, Stephenson, Keogan and Davitt. At its heart the Bill is about protecting our democracy. It is about ensuring that journalists, community organisations, campaigners and ordinary citizens can speak out, challenge those in positions of power and participate in public debate without the threat of costly and intimidating legal proceedings.

I will touch on a few points raised by Senators. Senator McDowell's comments reflect an important consideration, which has been borne in mind by the drafters of the Bill in its preparation, which is the need to ensure the courts ultimately have discretion to adequately balance the right of participation with the ability to pursue genuine claims, and that they are left with a certain amount of discretion. I also note the Senator's comments in relation to discussing injunctions and the applications by plaintiffs to cause economic injury. That will be done at a Committee Stage-type debate.

Senator Murphy addressed a separate issue in relation to costs generally. I note the expansion of the civil legal aid. Also in relation to costs for applicants who are the defendants in this SLAPP-type litigation, section 6 of the Bill and the proposed section 34CA of the Act provide that a third party with a legitimate interest in safeguarding or promoting the rights of persons engaging in public participation may apply to make a submission to the court or to provide assistance to the defendant. That can be very helpful in accessing justice.

As the Bill went through the Dáil, some questions were raised about the scale of the problem in Ireland. The Coalition Against SLAPPs in Europe, CASE, recorded 34 cases between 2010 and 2025. It may seem small but we must be careful not to confuse a lack of reported cases with the lack of a problem. Many people simply do not have the resources to challenge these proceedings and some may be intimidated into silence before a case ever reaches court. A recent High Court decision in Belfast illustrates precisely why these protections are necessary.

In January 2024, the court struck out defamation proceedings against the journalist, describing them as scandalous, frivolous and vexatious, and finding that they bore the hallmarks of a SLAPP. It is a reminder that the threat of litigation can become a means of silencing legitimate criticism and public debate.

I also want to recognise the important role played by civil liberties organisations in defending freedom of expression. I hope that organisations such as the Irish Council for Civil Liberties and all those who advocate for democratic rights will recognise and acknowledge the progress represented by this legislation and by the Government’s actions in this House and the Lower House. We have gone beyond the minimum requirements of the European directive by extending these protections to domestic proceedings. That is a significant step forward, and one that deserves to be welcomed.

Importantly, this Bill does not prevent legitimate defamation proceedings or undermine anyone's right to protect their good name. It gives our courts the tools to identify and dismiss abuse of litigation, while protecting those who participate in the public interest. Ultimately, we should never allow the depth of someone's pockets to determine whether another person is entitled to have their voice heard. A strong democracy must be able to tolerate scrutiny, criticism and challenge. This legislation is an important step.

I thank the Senators who contributed to the debate and commend the Bill to the House.

Comment on this
Shane Curley Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

When is it proposed to take Committee Stage?

Comment on this
Shane Curley Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this