Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (Extreme Weather) Bill 2026: Second Stage
Senator Nessa Cosgrove’s Bill would require employers to assess and plan for extreme-weather risks, protect workers who reasonably stay away from unsafe work or travel, and require the Health and Safety Authority to publish incident data. Supporters argued that worsening weather demands clearer protections and that workers should not have to choose between safety and pay. The Government opposed the Bill, saying existing workplace-safety law already covers these risks and that HSA guidance and forthcoming EU proposals are preferable to new requirements.
No. 103 of 2026 ›
I move: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State to Seanad Éireann. The combined time for the opening speeches of the proposer and seconder is 16 minutes. All other Senators have six minutes. The Minister has 15 minutes to reply and can indicate to reply at any time during the debate, and the proposer has five minutes to reply. I call on the proposer, Senator Cosgrove.
Comment on this
I am sharing time with Senator Harmon, who is on her way.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. Before I start, I welcome the representatives of the trade union movement who, due to restrictions, are unfortunately not able to make it in here but are watching online. I also want to thank John in my office, who has done a huge amount of work on this, Hector, a student on placement with us, and Finbarr O'Malley, who has worked very closely with Unite the Union in writing this Bill.
This Bill was inspired and informed by the publication, Workers in the Eye of the Storm. A significant amount of work went into this document, which Unite the Union published in the aftermath of Storm Éowyn in December 2025. We had a really interesting presentation in the audiovisual room last Wednesday which outlined the background and rationale behind this Bill. Rhona McCord and Tom Fitzgerald from Unite laid bare the case for this legislation, which I am going to come to in a minute. I say a big thank you to the Senators and TDs who attended the briefing in the audiovisual room, and to those from across the political spectrum who made up the expert group and assisted me in the drafting of this Bill. I thank TDs and Senators from Sinn Féin, the Green Party, the Social Democrats and People Before Profit who all made considerable contributions. This Bill was also signed before submission by a number of Independent Senators as well as members of the Civil Engagement Group. I am really grateful for all of that support.
A considerable amount of time has been spent on the drafting of this Bill and, as I said, Finbarr O’Malley offered invaluable legal advice to work out the practicalities of it. I particularly thank Rhona McCord from Unite for her consistent advice and guidance. There was a lot of going over and back, and she kept very focused and kept me very much on track. I am especially grateful to my cross-party colleagues, Senators Laura Harmon, Malcolm Noonan, and Patricia Stephenson for allowing me to take up this Private Members' time for this important Bill.
Regarding the intent of this Bill, it is not an exercise in performative politics. If anything, it is the opposite. It is intended to deliver results, not a political message. The Bill has been written with a very simple and clear concept behind it: no worker should have to choose between their safety and their job. Workers deserve to be protected from identifiable risks while at work, whatever the weather. The main intent of this legislation is that employers are required to make a weather-focused risk assessment of each workplace and that the vulnerability of particular groups of workers be assessed.
Too many workers have been seriously injured and even killed while at work or while attempting to get to work because they felt they had no choice. This Bill is not asking too much from employers. It is merely asking them to consider extreme weather to be a specific factor when carrying out their standard risk assessments, which they do in many areas of the workplace. It introduces protection for workers who make a reasonable decision to not attend work or to travel because of dangerous weather conditions.
As we all know at this stage, extreme weather events are becoming more common as a result of climate change. Scientists are warning that we are reaching tipping points in so many climate and environmentally related areas. The El Niño of this year has been identified as possibly the strongest event since 1877 to 1878, which resulted in the death of 4% of the global population. This year, 50 million people are likely to experience extreme hunger as a result of El Niño. We will see a spike in temperatures worldwide to approximately 1.75°C above the pre-industrial level, well beyond the 1.5°C target. This warm winter weather in the tropics will fuel extreme weather events worldwide and in Ireland we will not be immune from this impact. In future weather we can expect to see will include periods of colder, calmer and drier weather alternating with stormier, windier, wetter and wilder weather. It will be completely unpredictable.
While last summer seems a distant memory, we can all remember the discomfort of having to work during the hottest weather. The Guardian newspaper reported this July that across Europe it is estimated that approximately 230 workers die each year as a result of heat stress. As Irish summers become hotter, we are likely to see tragedies occur here. While there have been no recorded workplace deaths in Ireland as a result of the hot weather, we cannot say for certain that death or serious accidents have not occurred. The Health and Safety Authority is not compelled to gather statistics related to death or serious injury resulting from a weather event and this omission is addressed in the Bill, which will require the HSA to collect and publish information relating to the impact of extreme weather.
At the other end of the scale, the reality of winter storms is still very fresh for people like me living in the north west. Storms Darragh and Éowyn, which hit counties Sligo and Leitrim and the south of Donegal exceptionally hard in the winter of 2024-25, were memorable examples of the kind of storm that climate chaos might regularly unleash. Most employers, to be fair, behave responsibly during red weather events and advise workers to stay at home. However, during Storm Éowyn, Unite received some very concerning calls from members. It heard from workers who had received no guidance from their employer as to whether their workplace was open and whether they were expected to attend work. It was contacted by members who were told to report for duty, even sometimes the night before the storm was due to hit, in order to avoid disruption to their work. During the audiovisual room briefing last week, we heard about ambulance drivers sent out in high-sided vehicles, expected to make their own risk assessments on the road.
We were told about early years educators being instructed to report to work to carry out cleaning or paperwork, despite employers being informed by the Department of children that their settings were to close to children. Thank goodness, none of these instances ended in tragedy. Sadly, the same cannot be said for 24-year-old Matthew Campbell, a Unite member who died while performing his work duties during Storm Ali in 2018. Matthew was an electrical contractor who was finished in work in Slieve Gullion park in County Armagh when he was crushed by an uprooted beech tree. A subsequent court case found that both the local authority that owned the park and Matthew's private employer were liable for not having carried out a relevant risk assessment. No legislation exists in either jurisdiction on this island which prohibits an employer from instructing their employees to attend work when it is not safe to do so. Matthew was an electrical engineer who left behind a family, loving parents, a fiancée with whom he was planning a future and many friends. Matthew's loss was an accident. It was a tragedy and it should never have happened. His former teacher recalled that Matthew never missed a day of school. It was this kind of work ethic that led him to stay on the job when it was no longer safe to do so. Matthew should never have been put in that position.
Under this Bill, an employer would be required to assess the risk posed to any particular class of worker, taking into consideration factors such as the level of experience of an employee, those who have health conditions or are pregnant, and the task they are expected to undertake. It does not necessarily mean that work needs to stop entirely. If travelling to work is the risk identified, the opportunity to work from home might be the solution. If working outdoors is the risk, the solution might be to negotiate different working hours or identify alternative tasks which can be undertaken in a safe location. It is no different from any other risk assessment carried out by employers every single day.
The Bill embodies the core labour movement values of care within the workplace. These values inspired many of us here towards activism, politics and the wider trade union movement. Our concern for our fellow worker demands that we extend basic protections to all. The responsibility to provide a safe workplace is well established at this stage. All this Bill does is to extend what common sense already dictates. Employers should take the weather into consideration when deciding if it is safe to ask their employees to attend work.
In drafting this Bill, I was constantly aware of the need to avoid placing unnecessary burdens upon employers. Introducing a requirement for an employer to identify and assess a risk based upon weather does not place an undue burden upon them. It is something that responsible employers should be doing, and many are doing so already. No employer wants to see their staff injured or killed. By requiring risk assessments to be carried out, the Bill will protect employers also from an admission which would cost them in every possible way.
We are now seeing the consequences of inaction on climate change. We need to take measures to mitigate the increased risk of extreme weather. The time to prepare is now - bí ullamh. As the seanfhocal says, ní hé lá na gaoithe lá na scolb. Today is the time to do it, before we head into the winter. The recent warning that Storm Chloe is due to hit Ireland next week is the exact prompt we need to put in place these very modest measures, which could provide a layer of protection for vulnerable workers. We should not wait for another tragedy such as that faced by Matthew Campbell's family before we act. I am hopeful that my colleagues from all parties in the Seanad and the Dáil will agree to this Bill. Matthew's law fills a real void in current legislation. The Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (Extreme Weather) Bill 2026 will, I hope, become law.
Comment on this
I support the Bill. I support Senator Cosgrove and thank her for leading out on this Bill and for all her work on it as the Labour Party workers' rights spokesperson. This is not the first Bill she has tabled in respect of workers' rights and I am sure it will not be the last. It will be very disappointing if the Government does not support this. It will send out a message to workers across the country that their safety and welfare are not a priority.
We know that adverse weather is becoming more and more of an issue, not just in Ireland but across the world, and we need to plan for that. Safety of workers has to be paramount. The Bill is not just about workers; it is about employers as well. I am sure they want to keep their workforce safe and ensure that people arrive at work safely and do not die during work or on their way to work. Unfortunately, as Senator Cosgrove has said, this has happened. We need to guard against it.
I cannot understand why anybody would not support this legislation. Senator Cosgrove had legislation previously on ensuring young workers are paid properly, which was voted down by the Government. It sent out a really negative message to young workers in Ireland. This Bill is trying to support workers of all ages in terms of their safety. My colleagues in the Gallery, Deputy Eoghan Kenny and Deputy Mark Wall from the Labour Party, are proud of the work Senator Cosgrove is doing. We are proud to have worked with other parties and trade unions on this. I acknowledge our colleagues in the cross-party group, Senator Malcolm Noonan from the Green Party and Senator Patricia Stephenson from the Social Democrats. The Civil Engagement Group has signed up to the Bill, as have Sinn Féin, Independents and others. It is great to see that there is support for it across parties.
I was really struck by the report from Unite the Union, Workers in the Eye of the Storm, as well as the survey that was conducted in connection with it and the urgent need for this legislation. The Bill was informed by workers and unions, the ones who are actually working in the eye of the storm. We are expecting another storm in the coming weeks. We are just going into the winter now. Every winter there are more storms. We have to plan for the future. This is the reality of the world we live in now. Employers were making people come to work or telling them that if they did not come in, they would have to take annual leave, use up time in lieu that they had already accrued or take unpaid leave. That is not acceptable when the situation is absolutely not the fault of the workers themselves.
If offices are closing with no pay, we must have legislation in place to protect workers. They need to have their salaries protected. There should be regulation of communication. Employers cannot, at the last minute, be telling workers who might already be on their way to work that the office is closing. When we have weather warnings, we should be able to plan to give workers as much notice as possible about whether an office or workplace will be open.
It is worrying that 59% of respondents to the survey said that their employer did not have any policy at all in respect of extreme weather. Employers need to have these policies in place. It is good practice to have them. I say that as someone who has managed people previously in other roles. We need to have these policies in place. Workplaces adapted to Covid during the pandemic. They need to be able to adapt to this now. This is life-saving legislation. It would save lives if implemented. If we do not pass it, we risk not making workplaces safe enough for people. We do not want to see these stories again of people who are injured, sometimes fatally, because they are travelling to work when it is not safe to do so. If an employer can guard against that by giving clear guidelines, that should be absolutely necessary.
The booklet from Unite the Union outlines that of those who had to work during Storm Éowyn, whether they were working from home or active in the workplace, 24% said they did not feel safe when they working during that time. It should be the right of every worker in this country to feel safe when they are doing their duties.
Obviously, we have workers in our emergency services who will make those calls and they will be working in particular conditions but, ultimately, we need to legislate for the safety and welfare of workers. As this is what this Bill is about, I cannot understand why any Senator in this House would oppose Senator Cosgrove's legislation this evening. I urge them to pass this Bill.
Comment on this
This is a hugely important issue as we have seen too frequently in recent years. While we certainly welcome the debate, Fianna Fáil is not in a position to support this Bill at this time for a number of reasons. First, the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 already provides a framework for managing these risks. Employers have a duty to manage extreme weather risks as part of their duties to manage and conduct work activities in such a way as to protect the safety, health and welfare at work of their employees. Weather-related risks affecting the workplace are, therefore, not outside the existing Act. Sections 8,19 and 20 of the 2005 Act provide the foundation for risk assessment and review and the implementation of necessary measures and improvements. Section 8 and section 3 establish general principles of prevention, including combating risks at source and prioritising collective over individual protection while section 11 requires emergency plans and arrangements. Consultation and training are also covered and self-employed persons and contractors already have statutory duties. The provisions within the 2005 Act are intended to be broad and cover all forms of employers and workplaces to ensure that there is flexibility to respond to the varied occupational safety and health considerations and requirements for different workplaces, including reasonable environmental controls and temperatures.
There is also a European aspect to this, as it is expected that proposals regarding extreme weather and work temperatures are likely to be included within the European Commission's forthcoming Quality Jobs Act proposal, which is expected to be published in December 2026. While details of what may be included in a potential regulation or directive are not currently known, the protection of workers from extreme heat and other climate-related occupational health and safety risks has been noted as a key priority for the European Commission. Furthermore, there are ongoing discussions on climate change and occupational health and safety in the European Commission's advisory committee on safety and health at work. This committee is also considering a future strategic framework on occupational health and safety that will consider on a tripartite basis the changing nature of work. The provisions in this Bill seek to address similar areas currently being considered by the Commission. It is important to ensure that Irish legislation remains consistent with EU law so in that regard, legislating in advance of the publication of the proposal would be premature and may subsequently require amendment.
It should also be noted that many of these provisions could be included in a code of practice published by the Health and Safety Authority, HSA, under section 60 of the 2005 Act. This would also allow the HSA to provide guidance to employers and workers with regard to risks presented by extreme weather in a manner that can be easily amended and adapted in the future. It will also prevent setting a precedent wherein specific narrowly defined risk considerations are provided for in primary legislation that would require amending legislation in situations where these specific considerations need to be changed to reflect the ever-changing requirements in workplaces. It has been confirmed that the officials in the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment have discussed this option with the HSA, which has advised that it can explore the development of such a code of practice.
Finally, I should note that certain provisions of the proposed Bill extend beyond the usual scope of occupational health and safety legislation, particularly with regard to commuting to and from work. Currently, ordinary commuting is generally distinct from work activity and protection for travel to and from normal workplaces extends beyond the usual driving for work framework subject to exceptions. These risks often lie outside the employer's control. Public road conditions and transport disruption differ from risks arising from work activities and workplace access, which employers must manage. The Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act would, therefore, not be appropriate legislation in which to include provisions regarding commuting. To conclude, Fianna Fáil appreciates the importance of this matter but is not in a position to support the Bill for the reasons I have outlined.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Cosgrove for bringing forward this Bill and giving me the opportunity to speak on it. I would like to thank her for telling us about Matthew. I probably would not have known about that situation if she had not raised it. I offer my condolences to his family. That must have been very tough.
I begin by saying that the safety and well-being of employees must always be a priority. Nobody should be expected to put himself or herself at risk travelling to or from work or carrying out his or her duties during dangerous weather conditions. Equally, employers have a responsibility to provide a safe working environment. However, I do have concerns about whether the additional legislative requirements proposed in the Bill are necessary, particularly when we consider the existing obligations, as Senator Crowe mentioned, under the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005. The legislation already requires employers to identify hazards, assess risks, put public safety measures in place and maintain safety statements. The existing legislative framework already provides robust safeguards for workers in this regard. Extreme weather is not something that employers can simply ignore under the current legislation. They already have a responsibility to consider risks to their employees and to take appropriate action.
Our responsibility also is not simply to make sure workers are protected when extreme weather strikes but to make sure that we have done everything reasonably possible to prevent those workers being placed in danger in the first place. That is also why the electricity (supply) (amendment) Bill 2026, which will come before this House soon, is important. It is an area that my colleague Senator Scahill has repeatedly raised.
My concern is that we could be introducing another a layer of regulation, paperwork and administrative responsibility without necessarily delivering a better outcome for workers. I am particularly conscious of the impact this could have on small businesses. I know I go on a lot about small businesses but a large company may have a dedicated health and safety officer or HR department to prepare detailed response plans, undertake additional assessments and maintain records but what about the small retailer, the family-run business, the café or the activity centre employing five or six people? In many cases, the business owner is already managing staffing, finances, insurance compliance and the day-to-day running of the business. We must be very careful that we do not continue adding regulatory obligations without properly considering the cumulative cost and administrative burden on those businesses.
I also want to discuss the raised proposed maximum indoor workplace temperature of 24°C. While we all recognise the importance of appropriate and comfortable workplace temperatures, I would question whether a fixed limit is practical across every type of workplace. A busy kitchen like the one in our business where we prepare hot food all the time, a manufacturing facility, a retail premises, a welder and an office are very different working environments. We need a sensible evidence-based approach that recognises those differences.
With the European Commission expected to bring forward its Quality Job Act proposals apparently by the last quarter of this year, which are likely to address extreme weather and working temperatures, I believe we need to be careful about legislating now only to potentially have to revisit it. I suggest that the HSA could develop a code of practice, as suggested by the Minister. I believe this offers a more practical and flexible approach. It would provide employers with clear guidance, help them understand their responsibilities and allow advice to evolve as weather patterns and workplace conditions change. Workers have to be safe but businesses need to be able to operate, employ people and remain sustainable. I believe we should build on the strong protections already in place, ensure employers have practical guidance and avoid imposing unnecessary costs on businesses, particularly on small and medium enterprises. I thank Senator Cosgrove, who always puts a lot of work into these things, and Senator Harmon and offer my apologies that we do not agree on this Bill today.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin is happy to support our colleagues with this Bill today. I know Teachta Rose Conway-Walsh was involved along with other Opposition colleagues and union representatives in the initial discussion of the Bill and we are very happy to be involved and to co-sponsor any legislation that will enhance workers' rights and safety
The Bill is not dissimilar to legislation introduced by my party colleagues, former Teachtaí Gerry Adams and Imelda Munster, in 2018. That came on foot of a young man from County Louth, Fintan Goss, tragically losing his life as he was driving to his workplace during Storm Ophelia, which was the first red weather alert in this State. That legislation was rejected by the then Government, largely, I believe, due to potential adverse effects on company productivity. However, the Government put forward numerous other issues that I believe could have been worked through had it been willing.
With regard to the Bill before the House four key measures are proposed. Employers will be required to assess extreme weather risks and to introduce workplace response plans. Workers cannot be penalised if they reasonably decide not to attend or travel to work due to dangerous weather conditions. The Health and Safety Authority will be required to collect and publish annual data on extreme weather related workplace incidents, and it will introduce a maximum indoor work space temperature of 24°C so far as is reasonably practical.
Essentially, the Bill aims to ensure workers are not forced to choose between their safety and their employment during extreme weather events. We know that, globally, extreme weather events are becoming more frequent due to the failure of the international community to address climate change adequately. In Ireland we are lucky not to be nearly as badly affected as some other countries. That said, we still experience extreme weather in the form of storms, flooding, forest fires and increasingly hot weather. My understanding is that these events are likely to increase in frequency so it is prudent and sensible that we prepare in every way we can in order that people's lives and livelihoods are affected as little as possible. It is a sensible proposition that workers should stay at home during red weather events. There will be questions to be considered in the cases of emergency services and hospital staff, but I think these situations can be overcome, and I look forward to working more fully on this Bill.
I also praise Unite the Union for spearheading this campaign. Its Workers in the Eye of the Storm research has been instrumental in bringing this legislation to the point it is at today. I am also pleased that the campaign is all-island in its nature, and Senator Cosgrove referenced an incident in my part of the world, in Slieve Gullion Forest Park, where a young man was killed tragically. Extreme weather does not adhere to borders as we know. My colleague in the Assembly, the Minister Caoimhe Archibald, spoke at the launch of the report in the Assembly last year and has pledged that the Department for the Economy in the North will continue to work with Unite on this. On behalf of Sinn Féin we are pleased to support the legislation.
Comment on this
I worked as a landscape gardener for over 20 years. I worked in all weather conditions: in the rain, in heat and cold and lots of different conditions, but we also knew when to down tools and when the game was up. I was self-employed and if I did not work, I did not get paid. That is the way it was. Those were different times. I could see from the weather patterns during my time working that things were changing and weather was changing. Extreme weather events were happening more frequently with the ferocity of storms, intensity of rainfall events and extremes of heat. They are our new reality and countless workers across the country do not have the choice to down tools like I did. Earlier today in the climate committee we had the ICARUS climate centre from Maynooth and the Irish Centre for High-End Computing. They presented to us pretty shocking maps of some of the extreme rainfall and heat events that will be part of Ireland's normal weather patterns in the coming three or four decades. Indoor work spaces will be affected. The outdoor working environment will be affected. Adaptation and mitigation need to be a core tenet of Government policy, particularly now that the Minister has given up the ghost on tackling climate breakdown and nature loss. Workers out in the field, particularly emergency workers, fire crews, ambulance personnel, gardaí, local authority staff, National Parks and Wildlife Service staff in our national parks, and OPW, Defence Force and navy personnel will all be impacted. There are also people working in care homes and hospital settings. We heard that, during the heat stress of the summer events, they were all significantly impacted. As we were told this morning, that was the first of what will be our new normal.
This Bill is an important milestone in trying to recognise that workers have rights when it comes to climate breakdown. When we are faced with these challenges as policymakers, it is important for us to respond with this practical set of measures for workers. I commend my colleague, Senator Cosgrave, and the Unite trade union on the research conducted and on the response to that by Senator Cosgrove in producing a comprehensive and practical set of measures in this Bill. We are disappointed. I share the disappointment of my colleagues that the Government has chosen not to support it. I accept the rationale and the reasons outlined, but there are elements of this Bill that need to be given consideration. We are in different times from my days as a landscape gardener, and workers and crews need to be protected. The best way to do that is through enabling legislation. We should not be waiting for the European Union to develop operational health and safety legislation and laws. We should be doing it here. This is a matter of national priority. It is critically important that we be first movers in this regard. Perhaps other states are doing it too. However, I urge the Minister of State to reconsider. I urge the Government to reconsider and take a look at this legislation. Yes, like all legislation it will need improvement and tweaking and that can be done on the following Stages of the Bill. We are in a new and challenging reality for us all. It is incumbent on all of us here to respond in kind and ensure that workers at the front line of this climate crisis feel they are supported by the State.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. I commend Senator Cosgrove on bringing forward this legislation. I am delighted to be a co-sponsor of it. I am incredibly disappointed we are not moving forward with it, particularly for the month that is in it. We have seen the public sector pay deal expire. We have seen a huge amount of dissatisfaction among workers. This is something that will tell workers we believe in the dignity of the work they do and we want to support that.
I understand there are other directives coming and reasons we are not doing it, but the reality is that today there are people who choose to go to work in adverse working conditions because they have no other option. They are worried about extreme penalties from their employer. They are making choices to leave their home and there have been the most tragic deaths of people forced out in Storm Éowyn. This will be a recognition and will give them legal assurance that their job and pay would be protected and that they could stay home in the worst conditions imaginable. People who have kids and whose child's day care shuts because of adverse weather conditions cannot go to work. They have to stay at home with their children and that comes out of their annual leave entitlement. It is just not fair. Our pay continues if the Oireachtas is shut down because we cannot get in because of the trains. Imagine the worst conditions. If I get stuck up the hill I live on in January because I am snowed in, my pay continues. However, we are telling other people we are not going to provide them with protections in those conditions. That is the impact. We know that, under the current framework, people have gone into work when they have not feel it was safe to do so.
We know about the hot weather we saw over the summer. We have outdoor workers, construction workers, agricultural workers and delivery drivers. These are people who face risks from direct sunlight, like dehydration, heat exhaustion and the risk of heat stroke. We need to do so much more when it comes to sun protection. That is a serious occupational risk. Sun protection should be treated as a workplace safety responsibility. That also extends to ventilation in buildings, kitchens, factories and warehouses. They can be incredibly dangerous during hot weather that, unfortunately, because of climate change, we are going to have more of. We see workers travelling on overcrowded and inadequately ventilated public transport. They are exposed. This is particularly true of people who might have additional vulnerabilities such as being pregnant, unwell or older. Similarly, when we come into winter, we have dangerous cold storms and the incredibly dangerous storms we have seen over the past few years.
Unite has been leading on this for a long time. Senator Cosgrove picked up the mantle because the appropriate legal protections do not currently exist. I am sure Senator Cosgrove spoke about this manual I am holding.
If the Minister of State gets a copy of this, there is a whole load of really relevant and impactful testimony from people who talk about the difficult position in which they find themselves in the workplace environment and how they are making difficult decisions between their own physical safety and continuing to work. If it is the case that the Minister of State is saying the legal protections already work, then we need to give guidance to employees because employees across the board do not know that. Not everyone has an employer that is going to make them come in. Some people will just say, "Look, no don't worry." Lots of business owners will say they are shutting the shop today and they are not going to be doing what they do. Unfortunately, that is not always true. Not every employer is a good employer. We have some fantastic employers but not every employer puts the well-being of their workers at their heart. That is why we need the Bill. No one should be choosing between earning a living and protecting their health. As climate change intensifies these risks, employee protections must keep pace. It is our job to ensure there are adequate safeguards.
I also want to mention Spain, which introduced climate leave following the flooding in Valencia last year. Annual leave specifically for major climate catastrophes is something we are going to have to seriously consider. Like it or not, this is what, sadly, is unfolding in our future.
Comment on this
I am very happy to have co-signed this legislation, which is really important. Health and safety at work is a fundamental issue. I was struck by the recent Brazilian elections. In one of the many turning point debates between Lula and Bolsonaro, the latter called Lula "nine fingers" to try and discredit him. Lula pointed out that he had lost his finger in a workplace accident at the age of 17 because of the lack of regulations and the fact that there was a failure to protect workers in the workplace, and is a marker and a reminder of the importance of protecting workers. It was an interesting moment in terms of the debates there.
What we are talking about here is a very specific set of circumstances that are accelerating. At the climate committee today, we heard from academics and those who do detailed mathematical modelling in relation to extreme weather events. We heard very detailed and specific information on the increased frequency of these events and the fact that an event that might have happened once every five years might be now happening three or four times a year. They can and should be modelled. We heard about all the different changes that should be done to how we design our buildings, not just our homes but also hospitals and care homes - I would add workplaces - to address those scenarios of greater heat, greater wind speed, increased flooding and saturation. All of these things are very real and extreme physical shifts and changes are happening in our environment. We were told about all the policy changes that need to be made. Part of that policy change is in respect of not just making sure our buildings are better fit for purpose but that our building standards are more appropriate and that how we think about our land use and industry is better and more appropriate to both mitigate and adapt to the climate circumstances.
We also need to think about how our labour relations legislation and workplace legislation adapts to those circumstances. The fact is we have been told the legislation is already there. We have had five of the hottest years ever on record within the last six years. We are seeing wind speeds and flooding in a way that we have not before. The physical circumstances and environment around us are changing, so it is absolutely appropriate that we would get a good faith measure such as this Bill put forward by Senator Cosgrove and her colleagues. I salute it. I am also happy to co-sponsor it to address those issues. The fact is the legislation we have currently does not explicitly require that these issues are addressed.
Looking at the European context, it was mentioned that European legislation may be coming in this area. There were 61,000 deaths in 2022. This is prior to this year's figures, which may be higher. A total of 61,000 deaths in the European Union were attributed to summer heat. Summers have only got hotter since then. The European Environment Agency forecasts a steady rise in average temperatures, increasingly frequent and intense heatwaves, which are described as silent, invisible killers of silent, invisible people. That is how it has been described. These deaths do not even get marked as to what they are, which are deaths in relation to the catastrophic climate change that has been allowed to proceed at pace and, sadly, has been driven by many in the European Union, including ourselves.
According to EUROFOUND, 23% of workers in the EU are exposed to high temperatures in a quarter of their working hours. According to one estimate, 130 million workers are exposed to workplace heat stress in Europe, resulting in 277,000 injuries and 230 deaths every year. That is why the European Trade Union Institute has been calling for things like mandatory heat risk assessments, exposure limit values, mandatory work rest cycles, and the downing of tools in high action and high work intensity activity at particular times. It is not just whether or not people are there and working but what kind of work they are being asked to do. It has also been calling for proper health surveillance.
This Bill is just the beginning of what we need to be doing. It is a very simple thing which says, "Think about it". It creates a requirement to think about extreme weather circumstances, to communicate about it, to acknowledge these circumstances between workers and employers and that there would be proper monitoring of the patterns that are emerging. We do not want to see the situations we have, sadly, seen in the US, for example, whereby Amazon workers were told to stay in the factories at risk to their lives, or where it is left to whether the workplace or employer decides to consider that an extreme weather event is a health and safety issue they want to take on board. We need to be told and it needs to be made clear that it is a national policy that extreme weather events would be a factor to be taken into account when considering health and safety policy.
If there is to be EU legislation in this area, this is Second Stage of an Opposition Bill and having the Bill on the books gives Ireland a credible position going into the negotiations on a new EU instrument. It shows that Ireland is one of the countries that takes this issue seriously. If the Government allows the Bill to go through, it could say it is under pressure from the Opposition to act on this and it would make us a strong negotiator if we want to see decent legislation coming out of Europe. I am sure any amendments would be very well accommodated by the proposer of the legislation if there are new EU innovations in this area.
I do not accept the Government's excuses for not supporting the Bill. I am surprised and disappointed. It is out of line with what we heard from the science, out of line with best practice and out of line with what our workers deserve.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this debate. I acknowledge Senator Cosgrove and those who brought forward this Bill. I also acknowledge the concerns motivating the legislation and the genuine desire to ensure that workers are protected from the risks posed by severe weather events and changing climate conditions. However, as well-intentioned as I believe the Bill is, it is not necessary or proportionate in the context of the existing legislation, as well as forthcoming developments across the EU.
Ensuring that Irish workers and workplaces are healthy and safe is a key priority for my Department. Every worker should be able to carry out their work in a safe environment and to return home safely at the end of the day. A robust occupational health and safety regulatory framework is essential in supporting that priority. The Health and Safety Authority plays a vital role in delivering that. As a Government, we are committed to occupational safety and health and to the Health and Safety Authority.
That can be seen in how the HSA has grown in recent years and how its activities have increased substantially, with annual inspection numbers growing from approximately 9,000 in 2020 to more than 12,000 in 2025. This hard work by the authority, and its commitment to protect workers, continues to be seen not just in its inspections but also in its awareness campaigns and how it engages with and influences businesses to continually improve their health and safety practices. That investment in ensuring the health and safety of workers in Ireland can be seen in how occupational fatalities have trended downward in recent decades from 2.3 deaths per 100,000 in 2016 to as low as 1.3 deaths per 100,000 in 2024.
In reflecting on the importance of keeping workers safe, I emphasise how important it is that the public is not exposed to life-threatening or dangerous situations during extreme weather events. We are all witnesses to, and many of us contributed to the debate on, recent storms, flooding events and periods of intense heat and cold. We have seen how damaging those events can be to infrastructure, homes, businesses and people. Met Éireann's colour-coded weather warning system has considerable merit as it serves to inform the public and business owners when caution is required and certain activities need to be curtailed. The Health and Safety Authority has a further role in this by way of its participation in the national emergency co-ordination group, NECG, which distributes messaging during severe weather events. The authority is also proactive in issuing relevant safety alerts and reminders to workplaces in advance of such events.
The Bill proposes a series of amendments to the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 and associated regulations. It would require employers to undertake specific extreme weather risk assessments, develop detailed extreme weather response plans, maintain records whenever such plans are activated and communicate weather-related procedures to workers and contractors. It proposes a protection against penalisation for workers who decide not to attend work during extreme weather events. It would require the HSA to collect and publish annual data on weather-related workplace impacts. In addition, it would introduce a maximum indoor workplace temperature of 24°C.
The central question in regard to the Bill is not whether workers should be protected from weather-related risks. They should be and the Government is very much implementing practical protections regarding occupational health and safety. The question is whether the existing legislative framework already ensures effective protection for employees while placing reasonable and practical obligations on businesses and regulators. My view is that the Health and Safety Authority is already doing that. While the Bill proposes to make weather-related duties for employers more explicit, it should be noted that Irish law already places significant obligations on employers. In this regard, the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 provides an extensive framework for managing those risks. Employers currently have a duty to examine any hazards that could threaten workers' safety and health. Managing extreme weather events clearly falls within that category. Employers have a responsibility to manage extreme weather risks as part of their duties. They must manage and conduct work activities in such a way as to ensure, insofar as is reasonably practicable, the safety, health and welfare at work of their employees. Weather-related risks affecting the workplace are, therefore, not outside the remit of the existing Act.
Section 1 of the Bill proposes to insert a new section 20A into the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 creating explicit duties for employers to assess and manage extreme weather events. However, much of this section, in effect, reinstates obligations employers are already required to fulfil under the current legislation. Employers must already identify risks - that requirement is already in place - assess their significance, implement control measures and communicate relevant information to their employees. Creating a bespoke statutory regime for one category of workplace hazard would duplicate requirements and increase administrative burden without delivering materially stronger protections. That is not effective regulation.
Section 2 seeks to protect employees from penalisation where they reasonably decide not to attend work during extreme weather events. However, the current legislation already contains important safeguards in section 27 of the 2005 Act that protect specified responses to danger reasonably believed to be serious and imminent. For that reason, we are not convinced a separate weather-specific provision is required.
Section 3 places unnecessary and burdensome reporting obligations on the Health and Safety Authority. Section 3(1) of the existing legislation already gives the authority a broad research, information and advisory function, including surveys, information exchange and publication. The proposed section would turn that broad function into a mandatory annual weather-specific obligation.
Section 4 proposes that a maximum indoor temperature of 24°C should be achieved and maintained at every workstation. This proposal raises practical and operational questions across many sectors. Different workplaces involve different tasks, equipment, processes and, indeed, environmental conditions. Existing regulations already require workplace temperatures to be appropriate for workers, having regard to the nature of the work being undertaken and the physical demands placed on employees. A single temperature threshold would not be appropriate in some circumstances and would risk displacing the more flexible and risk-based approach currently provided in the legislation.
In addition to what is included in the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005, more detailed requirements are set out in the general application regulations and other sector-specific regulations, including for construction, mines and quarries, which place explicit duties on employers to ensure there are appropriate workplace temperature protections for outdoor workers against adverse weather, access to shields and rest facilities, and measures to mitigate excessive heat or cold. While no maximum workplace temperature is prescribed in legislation, employers must assess risks and take all reasonable practical steps to prevent harm.
The HSA supports employers in meeting these obligations through guidance, tools and targeted communications. That includes guidance on risk assessments, thermal comfort, indoor air quality, driving for work, outdoor work, sun exposure, winter readiness and severe weather management. The authority also issues safety alerts and reminders to workplaces during extreme weather events and participates in NECG arrangements to ensure consistent safety messaging during extreme events. It does all of that within its existing statutory framework, without the need for specific targeted provisions focused on extreme weather. In addition to duplicating existing provisions, the Bill combines workplace safety measures with broader employment protections relating to commuting, non-attendance and remuneration. Those provisions are not, and should not, be within the remit of the HSA.
As noted, the central principle underlying the Bill is nothing new in terms of occupational safety and health regulation. Rather, it reiterates, specifies and complicates obligations employers already have to their staff. If we begin legislating in detail for one specific hazard, we risk unintended consequences by way of a lack of agility to respond in a timely manner to all the workplace risks that may arise in an ever-changing workplace environment. Adding greater specificity to statutory obligations is not always the answer, nor is it how we would ensure better regulation for businesses or for people right across the country. Instead, doing so can often simply complicate existing or established processes and add more ambiguity and confusion for all involved.
That is particularly the case with this legislation, which would duplicate the risk assessment requirements already present in the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005. The existing legislation is intended by design to be general in order to allow different businesses to assess and address the varied risks faced by a broader scope of workplaces right across the country. Occupational safety and health legislation works best when it is flexible and capable of responding to emerging and unforeseeable risks.
Excessive prescriptions can reduce the flexibility in the approach currently taken.
The Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 allows businesses to be adaptive to the needs of their employees but also gives them the freedom to adapt their protective measures to imminent risks. This was clearly indicated in the Act, with the placing of reasonable obligations on businesses to ensure that the highest standards of occupational safety and health are maintained for their employees. It is in this spirit that section 60 of the Act was developed. The section allows the HSA to publish codes of practice that provide practical guidance to employers and employees on specific areas related to safety, health and welfare at work in a proactive, reactive and adaptive way without the need for new legislation.
Extreme weather is an example of an area in which the guidance could be provided by way of a code of practice. It would offer a flexible, evidence-based and adaptable means of providing detailed guidance on managing extreme weather risks. Such guidance could evolve as circumstances, scientific understanding and international best practice develop without requiring repeated amendments to primary legislation. I have asked my officials to explore options in this regard with the HSA. The authority has commissioned a research study to examine climate change and its impact on occupational safety and health in the workplace.
This is happening in the context of significant European changes in this area, with the Commission expected to publish its quality jobs proposal very shortly. That package is intended to modernise worker protections while supporting productivity, competitiveness and the creation of sustainable, future-proofed employment. With publication expected before the end of 2026, the Commission has indicated that matters relating to extreme weather and working temperatures are likely to be addressed as part of the package. Furthermore, there are ongoing discussions on climate change and occupational safety and health at the Commission's advisory committee on safety and health at work. The committee is also looking at future strategic frameworks on occupational safety and health, which will consider, on a tripartite basis, the changing nature of work. Legislating in advance of those proposals would be premature and could well necessitate further legislative amendments to ensure alignment with the EU.
I reiterate that the Government fully supports strong protections for workers and recognises the challenges that can be created by extreme weather events. However, we do not believe this Bill presents a more effective framework than the comprehensive protections that are already provided under the existing legislation. The proposed measures duplicate existing obligations, create unnecessary regulatory burden, risk constraining the flexibility of the current system and may be overtaken by forthcoming European developments. For those reasons, we must oppose the Bill.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for his response. I must say, however, that it is the most watery response I have received from the Government. We put so much consideration into this Bill in the hope it would go forward. We could have proposed amendments to the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997 to provide for climate leave but we decided not to do so. The Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 is 21 years old. Seeking to amend it is not outrageous or irresponsible and would not place any onerous responsibilities on employers. It is a straight-up proposal recognising that adverse weather conditions are a reality and that employees need protection.
All we are asking of employers is that they identify possible risks arising from adverse conditions. That is all that is involved. It is the HSA's job to oversee that and its staff can be upskilled to provide that information. The way climate chaos is going, it is not unreasonable to rely on the authority for information on workplace accidents, or possibly deaths, related to adverse weather events. I do not accept that this legislation is premature or something the Government should in any way be rejecting. We included loads of considerations with that in mind. For example, the Minister of State spoke about maximum workplace temperatures. We already have minimum temperatures, so we included a maximum temperature as a guideline to require employers do something to ensure people are safe to work. That will be included in a risk assessment and safety statement.
The Minister, Deputy Burke, has knocked back any legislation I have brought forward on anything to do with workers' rights. I consider him to be really anti-worker. First, he reneged on introducing a living wage. Then we were told the programme for Government commitment to increase the paid sick leave entitlement from five days to seven would not be implemented. Likewise, he is not proceeding with tackling sub-minimum wage rates of pay for apprentices. Now our Bill is being rejected. The Minister is either completely anti-worker or everyone in government hates to see a united Opposition. A total of 575 people were interviewed by Unite the Union on this issue. Our Bill addresses the real concerns of real workers who have to put their lives at risk going into work. The people in the union did not just do that for the good of their health. They set up an expert group and contacted us in the Opposition parties. We worked really closely together and we came up with a really good Bill.
Would the Government prefer to torpedo very good, reasonable and carefully measured legislation rather than see a united Opposition succeed in getting it through? All it had to do was let the Bill progress to the next Stage but it will not agree to that. We could have worked out any issues on Committee Stage. I was very straight-up in stating that we were very open to amendments. If the Minister had taken the time to come to the briefing in the audiovisual room last week, to which everyone was invited, he would have heard our straight-up statement that we were very willing to work with the Government. I emailed him as well to say we would be delighted to take on amendments.
Nobody should have to risk their life to go to work. One death, such as that of Matthew Campbell in the North, is one too many. People should not have to make a decision to delay going into work, or work from home if their duties allow, until a red warning passes without the protection of knowing they will have the support of their employer on the basis of their safety statement and risk assessment. We included in the Bill that its provisions would align with Met Éireann's weather warnings. These proposals are good for everyone. They are good for employers, who can stand tall in protecting their workers. The Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 already requires employers to undertake a risk assessment. Most good employers, including small businesses, have safety officers. This is not about burdening small businesses.
What we are proposing is not a big deal. It would protect both employers and workers and ensure there are no grey areas. We could have gone down the route of seeking to amend the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997 to make provision for climate leave. As Senator Higgins said, this is probably only the start of the challenges we will face, given the climate chaos and destruction we are already seeing. Climate leave will likely be necessary but any such proposal probably will be rejected as well. Why is the Government burying its head in the sand and waiting for EU legislation? We are an island.
Comment on this
There are codes of practice but the existing legislation is from 2005. Unite the Union would not have set up an expert group and approached us on this issue if it had confidence in the working group and the codes of practice, which it does not.
I am really disappointed by the Government's response. I assumed it would actually support this Bill. More fool me.
Comment on this
Question put
Do you agree with this result?