We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Free speech and EU hate-crime proposals

Summary

Keogan raised concerns about threats to free speech, noting that a proposal to add hate speech and hate crime to EU crimes had been withdrawn.

Last evening, we were in this Chamber discussing the new anti-SLAPP Bill, which, as colleagues may know, seeks to protect people who speak out in the public interest from punitive and malicious lawsuits. Given that debate and the number of developments over the past week, I thought I would use my time this morning to speak on the issue of free speech. There was some welcome news from Europe this week. The proposal to add so-called hate speech and hate crime offences to the list of EU crimes, alongside terrorism, human trafficking, drug trafficking and organised crime, has been withdrawn by the Commission.

That is a good development, because whatever one's view of offensive speech, there is a world of difference between a foolish remark and a terrorist bombing. There is a world of difference between an online insult and human trafficking. It is deeply worrying that anyone would think to propose this at all. While I am proud to say we put up a strong fight for freedom of expression in this country against the hate speech Bill in this House, and now against the EU Commission's demands that we enact such laws in the court in Luxembourg, the broader pressure on freedom of expression has certainly not disappeared.

We see it in the growing influence of the Digital Services Act. We see it in the increasingly blurred lines between illegal content and unpopular opinions. We see it in the tendencies of regulators to assume that every societal problem can be solved by creating another speech restriction and nowhere is that concern more apparent than in the ongoing investigation involving the Leader's own Tipp FM and South East Radio. The investigations are still ongoing and it would be inappropriate for me to comment on matters that have yet to be resolved. However, what is deeply troubling is the sheer scale of potential penalties compared to the alleged infractions, which appear somewhat trivial. We are talking about radio stations that are part of the very fabric of rural Ireland, that is, stations that cover local sport that nobody else covers, that discuss planning issues, community festivals, local tragedies and local triumphs and that give voice to ordinary people far beyond the orbit of Dublin media. Yet somehow, we have arrived at a situation where an apparent lapse of judgment or a broadcasting gaffe could expose small local stations to a €20 million penalty. That is not regulation. It is a sword hanging over local media. One does not need to excuse wrongdoing to recognise the absurdity of that situation. Indeed, the lesson of the anti-SLAPP debate is that free speech is often not destroyed by censorship itself. More often, it is chilled by fear of ruinous legal costs and fines. When the potential punishment becomes sufficiently extreme, people self-censor. That should concern every person in this House, regardless of political persuasion.

Comment on this