We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Items in this session
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Before I call on the Leader to outline the Order of Business, I welcome to the Gallery a group of students and their teacher from Scoil Chóca Naofa in Kilcock, County Kildare. They are most welcome to Seanad Éireann. I thank them for being here. Anois, the Leader.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach. The Order of Business is No. 1, motion re the proposed approval by Seanad Éireann of the marine planning policy statement, to be taken at conclusion of the Order of Business, without debate; No. 2, the Gas Safety and Miscellaneous Amendments Bill 2026, changed from the Gas Safety (Amendment) Bill 2026 - Second Stage, to be taken at 1.30 p.m. and to adjourn at 2.30 p.m. if not previously concluded, with the time allocated to the opening remarks of the Minister not to exceed ten minutes, group spokespersons not to exceed eight minutes, all other Senators not to exceed five minutes, and the Minister to be given no less than ten minutes to reply to the debate; No. 3, the Industrial Development (Amendment) and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2026 - Committee Stage, to be taken at 2.30 p.m. and to adjourn at 4 p.m. if not previously concluded; and No. 4, Private Members' business, the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (Extreme Weather) Bill 2026 - Second Stage, to be taken at 4 p.m., with time allocated to this debate not to exceed two hours.

Comment on this

I would like to talk about the waste we have in relation to prescription medication. Earlier this year, I welcomed the launch of the MediBack scheme, a highly positive initiative where people could bring back unused medication. A national audit done a few months ago, however, highlighted that €37.5 million worth of prescription medication goes unused in Ireland annually. The majority of that waste comes from items that are automatically dispensed but ultimately not collected. A major driver of this is what I would call inertia in our current system whereby once an item is added to a repeat prescription, it is too often left there indefinitely, continuing to be generated month after month even when it is no longer needed by the patient. I have spoken to a number of people, particularly older people, who have found this to be the case. We have to look to improve efficiency and ensure that the return process remains fully accessible, especially to those who are older or housebound and cannot easily travel to a pharmacy. We need to integrate secure home collection options. More importantly, we need to ensure there is a more responsive electronic prescribing system that actively prompts the removal of unneeded drugs from patient charts. It is really important. This type of waste is simply not good enough and I would like to see a debate with the Minister for Health on this.

I also want to mark the significant development in the UK courts where Russell Brand has been sentenced to ten years and six months in prison following his conviction for rape and sexual assault. Harrowing details emerged from this trial, spanning offences against four women. We have to highlight the bravery of the victims who came forward but we must also look at the systemic failures within the media and the entertainment industry, where predatory behaviour was heavily protected and enabled. There was a continuum of offences in plain sight and this conviction is sending a very unambiguous message across jurisdictions that time does not diminish accountability and that we need to act.

This is in no way is to excuse Russell Brand's behaviour, but I read that his father introduced him to porn magazines and porn films at a very young age and that when he was a teenager, his father brought three prostitutes into a room for himself and his son. This is completely shocking. Because of that, Russell Brand had a completely abnormal view of sexuality and relationships. As I said, that is in no way to excuse him, but it just shows that we have to be so conscious and careful of exposure to porn at a young age.

Comment on this

I want to raise three things. I thank and congratulate all sides on the agreement reached overnight in the public sector pay talks. Second, I congratulate the students, teachers and staff of Saint Patrick's National School in Drumcondra on the raising of their green flag for global citizenship yesterday.

Ahead of the Dublin Central community safety plan consultation night that will take place in Smithfield this evening, I ask the Leader to arrange a debate with the Minister for justice, Deputy O'Callaghan, on the need for consistent and visible community policing across Dublin, particularly in light of the national community safety strategy that the Minister launched last week. Recently businesses on Capel Street described to me the threatening and intimidating antisocial behaviour that is confronting their customers and their staff. The Leader will agree that nobody should go to work wondering whether they will have to face such intimidation.

Residents of Fairview, Glasnevin, Stoneybatter and Drumcondra are all asking one simple question: where is the visible Garda presence in their neighbourhood? While local initiatives matter, whether you live in Glasnevin, Phibsborough or Arbor Hill, you should expect the same commitment in terms of prevention, visibility and a reliable presence of gardaí. This requires clear commitments on Garda allocations. Particularly with the new gardaí coming out of Templemore in mid-December, I want to see a clear increase in allocations for the Bridewell and Mountjoy policing districts. We have seen good resources going to Store Street and over to the south side in Pearse Street, but that commitment they have got must extend across our communities.

Community consultation should lead to action that people can see, such as gardaí on our streets, relationships with businesses and residents and, most important, confidence that reporting intimidation will actually bring a response. We can all agree that community safety is central to the common good, including in Dublin. During Commencement matters earlier, I listened to Senator Scahill talking about Roscommon and Longford. Our citizens deserve to feel safe in their own neighbourhoods and we need to make sure this expectation becomes a reality.

Comment on this

Last evening, we were in this Chamber discussing the new anti-SLAPP Bill, which, as colleagues may know, seeks to protect people who speak out in the public interest from punitive and malicious lawsuits. Given that debate and the number of developments over the past week, I thought I would use my time this morning to speak on the issue of free speech. There was some welcome news from Europe this week. The proposal to add so-called hate speech and hate crime offences to the list of EU crimes, alongside terrorism, human trafficking, drug trafficking and organised crime, has been withdrawn by the Commission.

That is a good development, because whatever one's view of offensive speech, there is a world of difference between a foolish remark and a terrorist bombing. There is a world of difference between an online insult and human trafficking. It is deeply worrying that anyone would think to propose this at all. While I am proud to say we put up a strong fight for freedom of expression in this country against the hate speech Bill in this House, and now against the EU Commission's demands that we enact such laws in the court in Luxembourg, the broader pressure on freedom of expression has certainly not disappeared.

We see it in the growing influence of the Digital Services Act. We see it in the increasingly blurred lines between illegal content and unpopular opinions. We see it in the tendencies of regulators to assume that every societal problem can be solved by creating another speech restriction and nowhere is that concern more apparent than in the ongoing investigation involving the Leader's own Tipp FM and South East Radio. The investigations are still ongoing and it would be inappropriate for me to comment on matters that have yet to be resolved. However, what is deeply troubling is the sheer scale of potential penalties compared to the alleged infractions, which appear somewhat trivial. We are talking about radio stations that are part of the very fabric of rural Ireland, that is, stations that cover local sport that nobody else covers, that discuss planning issues, community festivals, local tragedies and local triumphs and that give voice to ordinary people far beyond the orbit of Dublin media. Yet somehow, we have arrived at a situation where an apparent lapse of judgment or a broadcasting gaffe could expose small local stations to a €20 million penalty. That is not regulation. It is a sword hanging over local media. One does not need to excuse wrongdoing to recognise the absurdity of that situation. Indeed, the lesson of the anti-SLAPP debate is that free speech is often not destroyed by censorship itself. More often, it is chilled by fear of ruinous legal costs and fines. When the potential punishment becomes sufficiently extreme, people self-censor. That should concern every person in this House, regardless of political persuasion.

Comment on this

I seek an update from the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality on the application opening date for the €2 million 2026 autism innovation fund, AIF. The funding for this was announced in the budget last year, that is, the budget that was passed in October 2025. We are nearly in the middle of November and an opening date for the AIF fund has not even been announced, and no clarification has been given. We need to see this money spent. Another €2 million has been allocated for next year but we need to see the €2 million allocated for this year opened up and spent.

The second issue I want to raise is around dental procedures that must take place under general anaesthetic. I was contacted by the family of a woman with Down's syndrome. She is non-verbal. She has a decayed tooth that requires extraction but it must be done under general anaesthetic and she would be due to go to Cavan General Hospital for this procedure. She was brought in for a pre-assessment, to ensure she would be suitable, in September. She was told it was urgent at that stage yet when the family inquired, they are told there is no date between now and Christmas for this procedure. The family were also told that they only see one patient a month for extraction under general anaesthetic.

Comment on this

I have written to the HSE and have sought clarification. I have also made representation with this particular case but one extraction per month under general anaesthetic, I am sure, is not enough. I am sure there are many people with intellectual disabilities who require this procedure. This young woman has been in pain since the middle of June. She has had three courses of antibiotics in that time, she has had an abscess, she has had to be admitted to accident and emergency because she was unwell as a result of the tooth, and she has been told it is urgent because she could develop sepsis as a result. It is urgent. She needs to be seen to, but if it is only one per month, we need to look at that and see, if she cannot be seen there, whether she can be seen in another hospital that is not too far from her, such as Navan. If one per month is the case, that also needs to be addressed because I am sure there are many people depending on this service and one a month is not sufficient.

Comment on this

I want to bring to the attention of the House the review of Ireland's human rights record that took place in Geneva on 10 November as part of the United Nations universal periodic review. This universal periodic review is a process through which every UN member state has its human rights record examined by other states approximately every four and a half years. Ireland's previous reviews took place in 2011, 2016 and 2021.

The review matters because it provides an opportunity for independent scrutiny of how Ireland protects human rights in practice. It creates a public record of the concerns raised and the commitments made, which the Oireachtas and civil society use then to assess the progress in years ahead.

During this fourth review, a number of countries commended Ireland on the progress it has made in relation to sexual and reproductive health and rights, in particular, the free contraception scheme and period poverty initiatives. However, at the same time, nine countries called for stronger access to abortion care, namely, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Mexico, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden and Switzerland.

The concerns raised this year deserve the attention of the House. Canada and Sweden called for the removal of the mandatory three-day waiting period. Iceland called for the full decriminalisation of abortion. The Netherlands and Norway called for the full implementation of the independent review of Ireland's abortion care, chaired by Marie O'Shea and published in 2023.

The O'Shea report recommended the removing of the mandatory three-day waiting period and removing criminal sanctions from medical practitioners. A Bill to remove the three-day waiting period is currently before the Oireachtas. These are issues that affect people's everyday lives. Delays in accessing care can place additional pressures on women who are arranging travel, taking time off work or managing caring responsibilities. The O'Shea report is a reminder that access to healthcare must be considered in terms of people's actual lived experience.

The universal periodic review gives Ireland the opportunity to recognise and address the concerns that remain. It is important that these recommendations are considered carefully and that this House follows their progress. I note this periodic review recognises that the maintenance of the mandatory three-day waiting period is a serious breach of human rights.

Comment on this
PJ Murphy Senator P. J. Murphy Fine Gael

I wish to speak about a meeting that I attended in my local town of Gort last Monday evening. I attended with approximately 200 of my friends and neighbours and members of my own south Galway community. We discussed the dark cloud of uncertainty that has hung over the town of Gort in the south Galway area for the past eight years due to a colossal-scale anaerobic digestion biogas facility that is proposed to be built on the very edge of our town.

From the outset, let me say that south Galway is a grass-based agricultural area and we are not opposed to the idea of supplying grass and the generation of power through anaerobic digestion. In fact, we would favour the construction of a number of small facilities in the area. However, what is proposed for Gort is on a mega scale and it is proposed, very inappropriately, on the very edge of the town.

The amount of time - eight years - that this process of planning has been going on for is providing massive uncertainty to the people of the area as to what may come down the road for the town.

Here today, I call for the Minister with responsibility for planning to include clear and definitive guidelines for the scale and location of anaerobic digestion facilities in the national planning strategy that is currently being produced in order that no other town or area will suffer the uncertainty that we have felt over the past eight years in Gort and south Galway.

Comment on this

I want to raise a distressing issue here this morning. I do not know where to begin. I have been contacted by a single mother. I am not going to identify the family or the children's names. She is a single mum with two 16-year-old boys. They both have very complex needs associated with autism and under a section 32 assessment of need, they have been recommended, as a long-term pathway, residential care. These boys are non-verbal. She also has a daughter. Next Tuesday, they are going to be evicted from their home and they are going to be put out onto the street. This woman says that she is crushed, that she is heartbroken and asks what will she do with her little girl. She says that this is going to break her. She wants to know what will she do with all of her sons' possessions; their little toys and the things that they cling to.

Any of us who have any experience of autism will know that consistency is key to stability. This single mother is literally going to be on the street next Tuesday. Her home is being repossessed by a vulture fund, notwithstanding the recommendation that she have long-term residential care for her sons. How will she cope with these two young boys? How will she explain to two non-verbal boys that they are no longer in their home and are literally on the street? As a parent of a disabled adult, I wonder how they will toilet. How will she look after her daughter? They are going to be extremely vulnerable. To think this is happening in this day and age. If we could put aside our political differences, if there is some way - I appreciate the work of the Seanad Office and hope to have a Commencement matter this week - I beseech my colleagues to see if something can be done in this regard.

Comment on this

I would like to raise the issue of our live export trade, particularly recent developments whereby we have lost the export of bulls to Algeria. This is through no fault of anybody. There is a foot and mouth disease outbreak in Algeria and, as a result, they have stopped shipping coming in. It means that for the quality of bull that was going to Algeria, the farmers who are selling them now are talking a hit of up to €300 per head. With the average size of a suckler farm in Ireland being 16 cows, that is 16 calves, and given that 50% of them would be bulls, that is eight, so it is €2,400 of a hit, just like that. I am not going to ask for a debate here because there is no point in us having an over-and-back with the Minister. I ask the Leader to use his influence, if he can get the Minister to give us an update on when he thinks we might be able to get back into Algeria or, if it is going to be a prolonged absence, the alternatives we can put in place. Also, the calving season will be taking off from January and we still have no update on replacements for the loss of ferries into France. Both Brittany Ferries and Stena have said they will not be bringing any live exports. I know that when we mention live exports there are people who jump up and down about the whole animal welfare issue. We have excellent animal welfare standards in Ireland, as well as very strict and stringent rules governing transport. That is not an issue. The issue is that we are an island nation and our agriculture sector is dependent on our exports, both live and otherwise. We need an update and a strategy. If the Algerian issue is going to be long term, we need some kind of strategy and clarification so we can bring confidence back into the sector. The farmers I mentioned who are losing money here and now might be able to hold on and maybe feed for a month or six weeks, if they know there is light at the end of the tunnel and that the track into Algeria will be open again. If it is going to be long term, we need an alternative.

Comment on this

I congratulate Hugh Brendan McDyer, a proud Glenties man, who received the Donegal carer of the year award at the beginning of the week. He looked after his wife, Rose, and still looks after her 35 years in. I remember the day when I started with my father, my uncle Thomas and John Duddy loading containers. Hugh was the man organising stuff there along with Peter Dollard and Eoin Harkin. After that, sadly, Rose got sick. Hugh left what was at that time Polar Fish. He was a great friend of mine and always remained a great friend down through the years. We met up again at the harvest fair in Glenties just a couple of weeks ago. I wish him the heartiest congratulations. It is well deserved. He deserves everything he gets. He is one good person and he really looked after Rose so well.

The other issue I want to pick up today is the Donegal courthouse. It has been closed for some time now. This matter is a concern to the people across Donegal. A courthouse is an essential public service and its closure creates difficulty for people attending the court. Legal people and professional staff depend on the service. I would like to ask the Minister for an update on the current situation. What repair works are needed? Have any works been approved? When will we expect them to begin? The people of Donegal deserve answers and clarity on this matter. We have been waiting a long time. I think this is the third or fourth time I have raised the matter since I came to the House. I have tried with Commencement matters. The Leader might get me an answer to see what is happening here.

Comment on this

I welcome Senator McAdam and congratulate him on his win. It is always good to be here. I remind him that we do not have geographical constituencies here. We are national politicians above the local rantings that go on. Anyway, the Senator is welcome. We have had a lot of talk about emergency planning in this country. The first time we were confronted with an emergency situation where our national broadcaster was put off the air, we found out they had one hour of diesel in the roadcaster to broadcast. People are being told to buy transistor radios and have cash and food in the house. We rely on communications to keep us apprised of what is going on. There should be an emergency broadcast station in an Army barracks, possibly Cathal Brugha or McKee. That emergency broadcast station should be able to override every national and local radio station in the country in the event of a national emergency so the public can be kept informed as to what is going on.

On other matters of emergency planning, we are told that the Royal Navy is 12 miles out to the east and the French Navy is 12 miles out to the south east. That is for constitutional purposes, of course. There is lots of talk about co-operation and what is and is not going to happen. There is not one word about who is looking after our sky. I wonder why that is. What do we do if there is a threat 35,000 ft up in the air? We cannot go up because our aircraft cannot climb that high. Even if we could climb that high, we cannot fly that fast. There is a little bit of sliding mirrors and smokescreens going on here. We are rightly co-operating with our near neighbours. We need to co-operate in an open and transparent way. As Senator McDowell said on Saturday on the radio, the public have a right to know how we are being protected. We are getting vague references to memorandums of understanding. We are told there is an MOU and that it will be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. It has not been laid before the Houses. I wonder why that is. Perhaps the Leader can shed a bit of light as to where precisely we are and how our citizens are being protected. This is the most dangerous time this country has ever faced. We have leaders from over 30 nations coming in. I know that An Garda Síochána and our Defence Forces will do everything to protect them but we need to know exactly where the MOU is and why it is not available to Members of this House.

Comment on this

I speak in support of landowners on Achill Island in the Keel Sandybanks area. An issue has come to light in the past weeks. Mayo County Council has indicated that a compulsory purchase order that was signed off by the Minister 56 years ago is now being brought to a head and that vesting is to take place. The understanding of all the landowners and farmers who have used this area down through the generations was that it was in their ownership, and they have the documentation to prove it. These are livelihoods. I have engaged with the Irish Natura and Hill Farmers Association, INHFA, on it recently and have spoken with landowners affected. It has caused a lot of fear, confusion and distress to those who have used the commonage down through the years. It is a way of life and livelihoods for them. I call on the support of the Leader to ensure there is a pause on any vesting to allow landowners and representatives to discuss it and ensure these livelihoods are protected. It is 400 acres of commonage. It is very important for the farmers in the Keel Sandybanks area that they are protected, not just for this generation but for future generations to come.

I ask for the Leader's support on that and acknowledge Councillor Paul McNamara's great work engaging with the landowners in that area. I want to make sure we have the support of this House on it.

Comment on this

I note the clock did not run for my colleague, Senator Duffy, and I would be grateful for the same indulgence. I want to bring to the Leader's attention legislation that will shortly be introduced to the House by me and Senator O'Donovan. It is to do with the legislative gap around how serving members of An Garda Síochána are looked at when they pursue suspects in the course of their duty. We are all aware of the case from May 2024 where a garda who pursued two masked suspects was convicted of dangerous driving. I know how dangerous it can be for an on-duty garda. Twelve months ago in Enniscorthy a car broke through a checkpoint and rammed a patrol car. After it was stopped, the car was found to have in it a pistol, €40,000 worth of drugs and €8,000 in cash. A member of An Garda Síochána should never be in a situation where they are concerned about being prosecuted for dangerous driving when pursuing somebody. Absolutely, there should be legislative standards but the current system is not working. We will bring forward that legislation and I ask that we be facilitated with time to debate it when it comes imminently.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I apologise for the clock. There is something gone wrong with the atomic clock somewhere in the world and it has put our clock askew.

Comment on this

Can I come back in for 30 seconds? I only got a minute.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The clock was not working.

Comment on this

I know. That is what I mean.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

You cannot come back for 30 seconds, sorry. I was going off a different clock and it was not working either. My apologies. I cannot get the atomic clock to work, lads, good and all as I am.

Comment on this

The Government animal welfare strategy that was published a couple of weeks ago does not mention that the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine has any intention of banning puppy farming, which is rampant, or sulky racing, which is dangerous and horrific; nor does it propose banning the killing of foxes using dogs or reducing the amount of greyhounds culled in Ireland. Thousands of greyhounds are culled every year.

This welfare strategy is cynical and, ultimately, a waste of money. There is no evidence the Government is serious about improving animal welfare. We just have to look at dog and animal rescue centres around the country, which are bursting at the seams and picking up the tab for Government failure in relation to animal welfare. If the Government was concerned about animal welfare, it would have a ban on puppy farms in the strategy and would introduce a cap on the number of breeding females in a dog-breeding establishment. I welcome the agriculture committee's proposing such a cap in its recent report. Unfortunately, the Minister is not listening. The welfare strategy should also have a ban on surgical artificial insemination of greyhounds. That is long overdue. It has been looked at inside-out.

The Government should also have banned the horrendous and dangerous practice of sulky racing in the welfare strategy. Sulky racers have zero regard for their horses and little or no care for motorists or pedestrians. This practice needs to be banned as a matter of urgency. Sulky racing is completely intolerable and dangerous to everybody. The poor horses that are subjected to it need to be looked after. If there was a real commitment to the welfare of horses, there would be a ban on sulky racing in the strategy but there is not. The Government would also have a ban on fox hunting with dogs in the strategy if it was serious about animal welfare.

Comment on this

I am raising this issue today for the fourth time. I am calling for a debate and conversation around energy generation, whether wind farms, solar farms or anaerobic digesters. There has to be an honest conversation here about it. I do not know which Minister the Leader will wish to call before us, but it has to be one of them. Senator Murphy and I attended the meeting on Monday of last week. This meeting and this conversation has been going on for eight years. For the people of Gort who live within 900 m of the proposed site for the anaerobic digester, it is not acceptable.

What upsets me most is it will be grass we will be feeding into it. If grass is not going into the bellies of cattle, there is something wrong. We should not be powering energy from our grass. Our grass should be about ensuring we have proper food security. The same conversation is to be had about putting solar farms on good, arable south-facing land.

I do not want to continue sending in objections or observations to the local authority because I believe in the need for food security. We need a mature, reflective conversation in this House. We agree we need energy and energy security but we need to balance that with the need for food security.

Comment on this

I did not get a chance yesterday to welcome my colleague, Senator McAdam. I know he will be great for national legislation and his local area.

I would like to talk about miscarriage leave. Can you imagine being 12 weeks pregnant, looking forward to having a brand-new baby in a few months, and you start to bleed and to miscarry, and the following day you have to go to work? At the moment in Ireland, there is no miscarriage leave.

On a much more positive, brighter note, today in the enterprise committee we will scrutinise new legislation on pregnancy loss leave. Pregnancy loss before 24 weeks is the most common adverse outcome in pregnancy.

Some may wonder what work we can do here in the Seanad. Only a year and a half ago, a pregnancy loss Bill was brought into the Seanad by my colleague, Senator Nicole Ryan, as part of our cross-party group on pregnancy and infant loss. A year and a half later, we are almost ready to show what this legislation looks like. We had a meeting with the Minister, Deputy Burke, in the past half an hour and we will be showcasing this - "showcasing" sounds like the wrong word - showing this in January and hopefully we will see miscarriage leave early next year. What a welcome leave that will be for people who suffer a miscarriage and have to go into work. We get a lot of work done here together. I thank Dr. Marita Hennessy and Professor Keelin O'Donoghue for all their work. They are from the pregnancy loss research group and have come to every meeting we have had. We have had meetings every month for the past year and a half. It goes to show what work can be done.

Today we got an update from the Minister, Deputy Calleary, on a pregnancy loss certificate. When someone loses a baby, they will not only get a little bit of leave but also a pregnancy loss certificate to acknowledge there was a baby growing inside them. They have lost that baby but they have a certificate to show. That is progressing nicely and hopefully we will see it next year. It is amazing what we get done in these Houses. Well done to everybody involved.

Comment on this

A few weeks ago a young woman came in to see me in the House. She had a degree from University College Dublin and a master's degree from Trinity College Dublin. She had applied for 83 jobs and she had them all done out on a spreadsheet. She had 83 refusals and not one interview.

I looked into this and it seems she is not alone. The latest CSO figures show that youth unemployment has gone up to 11.5% and is three times the rate for those aged 25 and over. Last month, a parent wrote to The Irish Times about a son with a first-class honours degree who had not received a single job offer. There seems to be a gap there. Yet, I also read that employers are saying they cannot find staff and nearly seven in ten are saying it is impossible to recruit people with the right skills. We have qualified young people who, it seems, cannot get a job, and we have employers who cannot seem to get workers. Something seems to have happened in between.

Part of the problem is that the first rung of the ladder seems to be disappearing and employers are asking whether AI can do the job. They are also using AI to go through CVs before the applicant even gets to a job interview. As a university Senator, I want to say that the generation who are graduating deserve more than just a parchment and a handshake. I am asking the Leader to arrange a debate with the Ministers for higher education and enterprise to see if we can do something practical to plug this gap. Is it possible to do what has been done in other jurisdictions, where they have a state-backed paid graduate placement scheme? We also need transparency when it comes to automated screening of CVs and to ask what AI does. There were 83 candidates refused without any feedback. We also need stronger links between universities and the employers who say they cannot find staff.

We have educated this generation. Ireland is wonderfully educated. We are kicking the ball out of the park on that. However, there is a gap here that needs to be plugged.

Comment on this

For the third time in the last two weeks, I am going to raise the issue of Cork University Hospital. The staffing situation at CUH is extremely alarming. We have seen a very brave and competent CEO, Jennifer Kearney, raise issues with the Government at the highest levels and she has essentially been gaslit by the HSE and the Government, in my view. Essentially, she was told at a HSE meeting by the regional boss that he was coming under pressure from the Taoiseach's office and the Minister for Health's office. The Taoiseach was asked about this in the Dáil and he said that did not happen. There was then a recording at the weekend which proved that this conversation did happen, and that the offices of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Health were invoked in that meeting.

I have serious questions. Why did Andy Phillips initially lie about this? Why did he not give the correct information to the Taoiseach? What was the Taoiseach told? Why was Jennifer Kearney put in this situation for raising serious issues?

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I want to be clear in relation to Standing Orders. If the Senator is accusing somebody of doing something, she must be careful about the language she uses.

Comment on this

That is fair enough, but it is on record. Somebody said they did not say something and there is then a recording proving that they have said it. I ask for some time to be allowed here, as we have allowed to others in relation to this.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I am just pointing that out.

Comment on this

This is a very serious issue because we have had whistleblowers in this country in other areas and we have seen what has happened when they have not been listened to. Jennifer Kearney is essentially like a whistleblower, and we need to learn from this. I believe the way she has been treated has been utterly unacceptable. The reality is that patient safety is at risk.

Jennifer Kearney has raised issues again this week in a letter to her staff that says because of staffing issues there are no staff to man a CT scanner in the hospital. There are two trauma bays that are vacant because there are no staff there to open them. We saw on Monday that no ICU beds were available and there was no resuscitation capacity at the hospital. Meanwhile, the Minister engaged over recent months in sparring with CUH through the media saying that, by comparison, Dublin hospitals were performing better. In reality, when we look at the figures, in the intensive care unit at CUH, there are 5.27 beds in the ICU per 100,000 population and they take in serious trauma cases from all across Munster. In Dublin, the average in the ICU is 10.27 beds. Those are the 2024 figures. We know Dublin has nearly double the bed capacity for the ICU, so that is not comparable.

When we talk about hospital figures, behind every statistic there is a patient who needs care, there are family members who love them and there are staff who are working above and beyond. I ask this Government to engage meaningfully with the hospital. I know the Minister for Health has engaged with this House. I ask her to engage in a fulsome debate, not only on the overcrowding and understaffing issues but on the mishandling of what the CUH CEO has raised. These are very serious issues, and I hope that other CEOs of hospitals will be able to speak out if they need to because, in my view, there is a culture within the HSE of silencing people. That culture needs to be blown wide open and out of the water because we cannot have that in our health service. It is not productive for patients, society or the staff that work in our hospitals.

Comment on this

I want to raise the Be Emergency Ready booklet. Over the last few weeks, people have received a really important booklet telling them how to be emergency ready. This booklet advises people to be aware of potential threats and to make sure they stock up on items like canned goods and water. This booklet is not totally useless. It does make sure to tell people it is very important to be careful and have a plan. That is good generic advice that is not specific to any particular disaster or emergency. After reading it, I still do not know what the Government has done after incidents like Storm Éowyn to strengthen a public service response, but important information like how to take a picture of the booklet and put it in a safe place is included.

I submitted a parliamentary question on this because people contacted me to ask how much this campaign cost them in taxpayer money. So far, the cost is €1.2 million. I am not sure if people will consider that is value for money, given that the majority of these booklets would have gone straight into the bin. To me, it is painful to see another million euro spent on a pig-in-a-poke booklet that could have been used for vital services. If we look at the breakdown of spending, €185,000 went on campaign development and agency services, meaning some media company got a nice lift. A sum of €20,000 was spent on research and concept testing. I wonder where that was for the "do not hug your granny" campaign. I cannot get over the effort and manpower it would have taken the Department of Defence to design, research and distribute this booklet. It is yet another of the many examples of Government initiatives wasting taxpayers' money.

To be storm prepared, we should have road maintenance, drain clearance and tree cutting, and we need more money spent on front-line services and infrastructure. I was speaking yesterday about Little Wonders Early Intervention Centre in Castleblayney, which is a respite service for children with additional needs and special needs. It is faced with closure because of lack of funding from the HSE. That million euro would have gone a long way to that service in Castleblayney, which is the only service available to children in counties Cavan and Monaghan.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I now call on the Leader to respond to the Order of Business.

Comment on this

I thank the 18 Senators who contributed to this morning's Order of Business.

Senator O'Loughlin spoke about the MediBack scheme, which is a really good scheme, but it shows up some of the inefficiencies we have in the system where medication is being produced but not being used. I will ask the Minister for Health to have a debate on that. In relation to Russell Brand, without getting into the case too much because I have read stories but do not know it in depth, as the Senator said, sometimes the raising of someone has a huge impact on how they act in future life. There are loads of things, from what I have read, that he did wrong. It goes back to how you are raised. What your values are when you are a child become the same values you have as an adult.

Senator McAdam acknowledged the public sector deal, which is hugely welcome for over 400,000 people across the country who have certainty now for the next 30 months. That is certainty for them and their families, which is hugely important. It is lovely to acknowledge a green flag in a school. It is one of the nicest days you can have, whether it is St. Patrick's in Drumcondra or any other school that raises a green flag. Regarding community policing, I will speak to the Minister on that. Whether you are from Dublin Central or Tipperary South, even though some Senators here say there are no constituencies, there are areas we prioritise. Community policing is very important.

It does not matter what area you are from, we need more gardaí. Luckily, over the next number of years under this Government, we are going to see a record number of gardaí come through Templemore. We will be north of 15,000, which we have never been at before, but that is still not enough. We need more gardaí because we have an increased population right across the country. There are areas that need to be targeted and Dublin Central is clearly one of them. I know the Senator is working very hard to make sure that is the case and I will try to bring the Minister in for a debate.

Senator Keogan spoke about free speech. As she said herself, we cannot talk about it too much because there is a court case ongoing but from my experience with Tipp FM, which I have been on numerous times, I have never found the debate easy but I have always found it fair. I have always found the morning show with Fran Curry extremely challenging but fair. The Tipperary news is the lifeblood of County Tipperary. It is where people get their information. As the Senator said, people rely on it and trust that information, often more than they trust national or international news. They trust the local news station because they know the presenter or they know the person who is reading the news. We need to make sure that those news outlets are protected. I cannot speak on the specific situation. I do not know whether it was a presenter or guest who spoke or said something, but guests cannot be controlled fully. Lots of local radio stations bring on local guests who would not be used to being on radio or national television, or anything like that, where there are restrictions or cautions in place regarding how they speak. There is a little bit more freedom within local radio stations but that is why people listen to them and love them. As the Senator said, it is so important that we protect them. I agree with almost everything Senator Keogan said on the matter.

Senator Pauline Tully spoke about the €2 million autism innovation fund and asked about the opening date for that. I will speak to the Minister for children and try to get an answer for the Senator. In relation to dental procedures for children with disabilities, it seems strange that Cavan hospital was not able to facilitate those. You would think that the hospital would prioritise children with disabilities in particular. I do not know why the hospital only does one per month. I suspect that it cannot be because only one person per month comes to the hospital. I do not know why they cannot go to the hospital but I will speak to the Minister about it on behalf of Senator Tully.

Senator Clifford-Lee spoke about the human rights record of Ireland which was independently scrutinised recently. It is positive that it has been acknowledged that progress has been made in the sexual health and reproduction areas. In fairness to the former Minister for Health, Stephen Donnelly, he did incredible work around women's health, sexual reproduction and a lot more. The Senator referred to the Bill that is before the health committee at the moment dealing with the three-day wait for terminations. That Bill will come to this House at some point but I am not sure exactly when. I had thought it might be here before Christmas but I suspect it will not be. It could be stalled or stopped at committee but assuming it comes out of committee, it will come to this House and we will have ample time to debate it. Obviously, people have very passionate views on that.

Senators P. J. Murphy and Rabbitte spoke about the meeting in Gort attended by over 200 people who were hugely frustrated with the fact that an anaerobic digestion facility has been in planning for eight years. Essentially, for the last eight years the people of Gort have been waiting to see if this monstrosity of a facility is going to be built, which does not seem fair. You would like to think there would be public consultation on it but I suspect there has been very little, judging from what the Senators said. I will ask the Minister to come in. We have not had a debate on energy in general so I will ask the Minister to come in to have such a debate. That will provide an opportunity for both Senators to directly outline to the Minister the views, concerns and real disappointment of the people of Gort they represent.

Senator Clonan spoke about a single mother of two 16-year-old boys with severe autism who, unfortunately, is being evicted next week. Obviously, he did not give the details on the floor of the House but if he forwards them to me privately, I am more than happy to speak to the Minister for housing on it. There are always very difficult cases but this one seems to be a particularly sad case that should be prioritised for the sake of the children to make sure that they have some sort of stability, as the Senator said. We all know, from dealing with constituents, that stability and continuity are so important for children with autism.

Senator Paul Daly spoke about the live export trade, shipping to Algeria and the massive impact on farmers right across the country in terms of the reduction of €300 per cow. As he said, the average is about 16 cows, which equates to over €2,000. Some farmers have even more animals and the impact on them is massive. Again, we have not had a debate with the Minister for agriculture for quite a while. He is coming to the House in a week or two on a separate debate but I will speak to him in relation to this matter. He has been quite vocal on it and has been working hard on it. I will see if I can bring him in to discuss it.

Senator Boyle spoke about Donegal courthouse. He has raised this matter a number of times and it is incredibly frustrating for him. I will speak to the Minister directly to see if I can get an update on whether works are going to happen, what those works are and, most importantly, when they are going to happen and be completed. The situation is not right for the people of Donegal.

Senator Craughwell spoke in relation to energy planning, co-operation and security. As he was speaking about aircraft and air defences, I heard a helicopter above us. I take his point on board. Every single country within the European Union needs to co-operate with their colleagues and allies around sea and air defences and Ireland is no different. He is right that there should be clarity on exactly what is being done. I will speak to the Minister for foreign affairs and for defence on that issue.

Senator Duffy spoke about Achill Island landowners and 400 acres that seem to have been compulsorily purchased 56 years ago but is only being enacted now. Most landowners would have assumed during that time, across one, if not two, generations, that the CPO that happened back then had just gone away. If something like that is going to be enacted, conversations have to happen and time must be given to those landowners to get clarity on where they go next. I agree with the Senator that there should be an opportunity to pause and have some sort of dialogue between Mayo County Council and the residents.

Senator Cathal Byrne spoke about a Bill that he hopes to bring forward next week. It is a timely and hugely important Bill. Both Senator Byrne and Senator O'Donovan, from past experience as a member of An Garda Síochána, want to make sure that our gardaí can do their job without fear of it impacting on them and their own private lives. Hopefully, next week we will be able to provide time and as Leader, I will try to make that possible for the Senator.

Senator Andrews spoke in relation to the animal welfare strategy. As I said a minute ago, the Minister for agriculture will be coming to the House in a couple of weeks and I am sure the Senator will figure out a way to bring animal welfare into the discussion. It is not on the agenda but I am sure the Senator will be able to bring it in. What I will say about sulky racing is that it is a real stain on the country. As the Senator said, those involved have zero regard for the horses or for people on the roads. Some of the worst crashes have happened because of sulky racing. We have it on a daily basis in Clonmel and it causes huge fear for people driving that road, including mothers bringing their children to school in the morning and collecting them in the afternoon. The sulky racers have no regard whatsoever for safety. I totally understand the point the Senator is making. On the wider field of animal welfare, some of the issues he talked about have been spoken about in this House previously. I am not in a position to comment on them, as the Senator will understand, but his genuine care and love for animals are recognised. We will have an opportunity to debate that.

Senator Nelson Murray spoke about work that is being done in the enterprise committee today in relation to pregnancy leave.

This has been a cross-party initiative between an awful lot of people. Senators Nelson Murray and Ryan have worked extremely hard to try to bring forward legislation to support people who have lost children through miscarriage. It can be a hugely challenging time for families. They cannot tell work why they need a couple of days off. There is a sense of loss. There are feelings that the mother and father could not carry the pregnancy for whatever reason. There is a fear of added health problems. All of that has to be dealt with in secrecy in a lot of ways. This is a really good initiative that has been brought forward by people in both parties. It is to be hoped it will come through the enterprise committee and onto the floor of the House.

Senator Aubrey McCarthy spoke about a number of people who struggled to get employment even though they are fully qualified and have first-class honours and serious degrees. If they are not getting interviews, it seems strange in terms of their CVs. I cannot speak about it on an individual basis because I do not have the information. I am happy to have a debate with the Minister for higher education on the pathway from education and college and graduating with a degree to getting into a first workplace. Many companies now use AI to decide who they interview in the first place. As the Seanator said, there may be questions about that. I am more than happy to have a debate with the Minister.

Senator Harmon spoke about Cork University Hospital, something she has spoken about on a regular basis, and rightly so. As she said, the hospital is excellent. I have experience of it. The staff are phenomenal, but the hospital is obviously understaffed and staff need more support. The leader of the hospital has spoken out, and should be listened to and respected. I do not know what conversations have happened between the Taoiseach and the HSE. The Taoiseach can be asked what he said or did not say every single week. The leader of the Senator's party can question him if she wants answers. I am a spokesperson for the Government in the Seanad, but cannot answer for what the Taoiseach said in a private meeting. I am sure the Senator will appreciate that. I am more than happy to have a debate on Cork University Hospital. We have had debates on University Hospital Limerick when Private Members' motions were brought forward. We can do the same for Cork University Hospital.

Senator O'Reilly spoke about the Be Emergency Ready booklet. She started by saying that the booklet was not totally useless, which I took as a massive compliment. She gradually got back into her usual political position, and gave out about the cost and asked whether the booklet was value for money. I would not say €1.2 million to inform 6 million people across the country of how to protect and support themselves and be ready in case an emergency happens is a waste of money. A lot of people and families have spoken about the booklet since it went to their homes. Numerous people have contacted me to ask questions. Some have asked me when the emergency we seem to be talking about is coming. In terms of giving people information, it is money well spent. Almost every other country in the world, in particular those in the European Union, do that.

Comment on this