Staffing and patient safety at Cork University Hospital
Harmon said CUH’s staffing shortages put patient safety at risk, citing concerns raised by its CEO, including an unstaffed CT scanner and vacant trauma bays. The Chair cautioned her about her language; Harmon defended the seriousness of the allegations.
For the third time in the last two weeks, I am going to raise the issue of Cork University Hospital. The staffing situation at CUH is extremely alarming. We have seen a very brave and competent CEO, Jennifer Kearney, raise issues with the Government at the highest levels and she has essentially been gaslit by the HSE and the Government, in my view. Essentially, she was told at a HSE meeting by the regional boss that he was coming under pressure from the Taoiseach's office and the Minister for Health's office. The Taoiseach was asked about this in the Dáil and he said that did not happen. There was then a recording at the weekend which proved that this conversation did happen, and that the offices of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Health were invoked in that meeting.
I have serious questions. Why did Andy Phillips initially lie about this? Why did he not give the correct information to the Taoiseach? What was the Taoiseach told? Why was Jennifer Kearney put in this situation for raising serious issues?
Comment on this
I want to be clear in relation to Standing Orders. If the Senator is accusing somebody of doing something, she must be careful about the language she uses.
Comment on this
That is fair enough, but it is on record. Somebody said they did not say something and there is then a recording proving that they have said it. I ask for some time to be allowed here, as we have allowed to others in relation to this.
Comment on this
This is a very serious issue because we have had whistleblowers in this country in other areas and we have seen what has happened when they have not been listened to. Jennifer Kearney is essentially like a whistleblower, and we need to learn from this. I believe the way she has been treated has been utterly unacceptable. The reality is that patient safety is at risk.
Jennifer Kearney has raised issues again this week in a letter to her staff that says because of staffing issues there are no staff to man a CT scanner in the hospital. There are two trauma bays that are vacant because there are no staff there to open them. We saw on Monday that no ICU beds were available and there was no resuscitation capacity at the hospital. Meanwhile, the Minister engaged over recent months in sparring with CUH through the media saying that, by comparison, Dublin hospitals were performing better. In reality, when we look at the figures, in the intensive care unit at CUH, there are 5.27 beds in the ICU per 100,000 population and they take in serious trauma cases from all across Munster. In Dublin, the average in the ICU is 10.27 beds. Those are the 2024 figures. We know Dublin has nearly double the bed capacity for the ICU, so that is not comparable.
When we talk about hospital figures, behind every statistic there is a patient who needs care, there are family members who love them and there are staff who are working above and beyond. I ask this Government to engage meaningfully with the hospital. I know the Minister for Health has engaged with this House. I ask her to engage in a fulsome debate, not only on the overcrowding and understaffing issues but on the mishandling of what the CUH CEO has raised. These are very serious issues, and I hope that other CEOs of hospitals will be able to speak out if they need to because, in my view, there is a culture within the HSE of silencing people. That culture needs to be blown wide open and out of the water because we cannot have that in our health service. It is not productive for patients, society or the staff that work in our hospitals.