We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Leader’s response to Senators’ contributions

Summary

The Leader began responding to the contributions, praising the MediBack scheme while promising to seek a Health Minister debate on prescription medication waste; he also referred to Keogan’s remarks.

Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I now call on the Leader to respond to the Order of Business.

Comment on this

I thank the 18 Senators who contributed to this morning's Order of Business.

Senator O'Loughlin spoke about the MediBack scheme, which is a really good scheme, but it shows up some of the inefficiencies we have in the system where medication is being produced but not being used. I will ask the Minister for Health to have a debate on that. In relation to Russell Brand, without getting into the case too much because I have read stories but do not know it in depth, as the Senator said, sometimes the raising of someone has a huge impact on how they act in future life. There are loads of things, from what I have read, that he did wrong. It goes back to how you are raised. What your values are when you are a child become the same values you have as an adult.

Senator McAdam acknowledged the public sector deal, which is hugely welcome for over 400,000 people across the country who have certainty now for the next 30 months. That is certainty for them and their families, which is hugely important. It is lovely to acknowledge a green flag in a school. It is one of the nicest days you can have, whether it is St. Patrick's in Drumcondra or any other school that raises a green flag. Regarding community policing, I will speak to the Minister on that. Whether you are from Dublin Central or Tipperary South, even though some Senators here say there are no constituencies, there are areas we prioritise. Community policing is very important.

It does not matter what area you are from, we need more gardaí. Luckily, over the next number of years under this Government, we are going to see a record number of gardaí come through Templemore. We will be north of 15,000, which we have never been at before, but that is still not enough. We need more gardaí because we have an increased population right across the country. There are areas that need to be targeted and Dublin Central is clearly one of them. I know the Senator is working very hard to make sure that is the case and I will try to bring the Minister in for a debate.

Senator Keogan spoke about free speech. As she said herself, we cannot talk about it too much because there is a court case ongoing but from my experience with Tipp FM, which I have been on numerous times, I have never found the debate easy but I have always found it fair. I have always found the morning show with Fran Curry extremely challenging but fair. The Tipperary news is the lifeblood of County Tipperary. It is where people get their information. As the Senator said, people rely on it and trust that information, often more than they trust national or international news. They trust the local news station because they know the presenter or they know the person who is reading the news. We need to make sure that those news outlets are protected. I cannot speak on the specific situation. I do not know whether it was a presenter or guest who spoke or said something, but guests cannot be controlled fully. Lots of local radio stations bring on local guests who would not be used to being on radio or national television, or anything like that, where there are restrictions or cautions in place regarding how they speak. There is a little bit more freedom within local radio stations but that is why people listen to them and love them. As the Senator said, it is so important that we protect them. I agree with almost everything Senator Keogan said on the matter.

Senator Pauline Tully spoke about the €2 million autism innovation fund and asked about the opening date for that. I will speak to the Minister for children and try to get an answer for the Senator. In relation to dental procedures for children with disabilities, it seems strange that Cavan hospital was not able to facilitate those. You would think that the hospital would prioritise children with disabilities in particular. I do not know why the hospital only does one per month. I suspect that it cannot be because only one person per month comes to the hospital. I do not know why they cannot go to the hospital but I will speak to the Minister about it on behalf of Senator Tully.

Senator Clifford-Lee spoke about the human rights record of Ireland which was independently scrutinised recently. It is positive that it has been acknowledged that progress has been made in the sexual health and reproduction areas. In fairness to the former Minister for Health, Stephen Donnelly, he did incredible work around women's health, sexual reproduction and a lot more. The Senator referred to the Bill that is before the health committee at the moment dealing with the three-day wait for terminations. That Bill will come to this House at some point but I am not sure exactly when. I had thought it might be here before Christmas but I suspect it will not be. It could be stalled or stopped at committee but assuming it comes out of committee, it will come to this House and we will have ample time to debate it. Obviously, people have very passionate views on that.

Senators P. J. Murphy and Rabbitte spoke about the meeting in Gort attended by over 200 people who were hugely frustrated with the fact that an anaerobic digestion facility has been in planning for eight years. Essentially, for the last eight years the people of Gort have been waiting to see if this monstrosity of a facility is going to be built, which does not seem fair. You would like to think there would be public consultation on it but I suspect there has been very little, judging from what the Senators said. I will ask the Minister to come in. We have not had a debate on energy in general so I will ask the Minister to come in to have such a debate. That will provide an opportunity for both Senators to directly outline to the Minister the views, concerns and real disappointment of the people of Gort they represent.

Senator Clonan spoke about a single mother of two 16-year-old boys with severe autism who, unfortunately, is being evicted next week. Obviously, he did not give the details on the floor of the House but if he forwards them to me privately, I am more than happy to speak to the Minister for housing on it. There are always very difficult cases but this one seems to be a particularly sad case that should be prioritised for the sake of the children to make sure that they have some sort of stability, as the Senator said. We all know, from dealing with constituents, that stability and continuity are so important for children with autism.

Senator Paul Daly spoke about the live export trade, shipping to Algeria and the massive impact on farmers right across the country in terms of the reduction of €300 per cow. As he said, the average is about 16 cows, which equates to over €2,000. Some farmers have even more animals and the impact on them is massive. Again, we have not had a debate with the Minister for agriculture for quite a while. He is coming to the House in a week or two on a separate debate but I will speak to him in relation to this matter. He has been quite vocal on it and has been working hard on it. I will see if I can bring him in to discuss it.

Senator Boyle spoke about Donegal courthouse. He has raised this matter a number of times and it is incredibly frustrating for him. I will speak to the Minister directly to see if I can get an update on whether works are going to happen, what those works are and, most importantly, when they are going to happen and be completed. The situation is not right for the people of Donegal.

Senator Craughwell spoke in relation to energy planning, co-operation and security. As he was speaking about aircraft and air defences, I heard a helicopter above us. I take his point on board. Every single country within the European Union needs to co-operate with their colleagues and allies around sea and air defences and Ireland is no different. He is right that there should be clarity on exactly what is being done. I will speak to the Minister for foreign affairs and for defence on that issue.

Senator Duffy spoke about Achill Island landowners and 400 acres that seem to have been compulsorily purchased 56 years ago but is only being enacted now. Most landowners would have assumed during that time, across one, if not two, generations, that the CPO that happened back then had just gone away. If something like that is going to be enacted, conversations have to happen and time must be given to those landowners to get clarity on where they go next. I agree with the Senator that there should be an opportunity to pause and have some sort of dialogue between Mayo County Council and the residents.

Senator Cathal Byrne spoke about a Bill that he hopes to bring forward next week. It is a timely and hugely important Bill. Both Senator Byrne and Senator O'Donovan, from past experience as a member of An Garda Síochána, want to make sure that our gardaí can do their job without fear of it impacting on them and their own private lives. Hopefully, next week we will be able to provide time and as Leader, I will try to make that possible for the Senator.

Senator Andrews spoke in relation to the animal welfare strategy. As I said a minute ago, the Minister for agriculture will be coming to the House in a couple of weeks and I am sure the Senator will figure out a way to bring animal welfare into the discussion. It is not on the agenda but I am sure the Senator will be able to bring it in. What I will say about sulky racing is that it is a real stain on the country. As the Senator said, those involved have zero regard for the horses or for people on the roads. Some of the worst crashes have happened because of sulky racing. We have it on a daily basis in Clonmel and it causes huge fear for people driving that road, including mothers bringing their children to school in the morning and collecting them in the afternoon. The sulky racers have no regard whatsoever for safety. I totally understand the point the Senator is making. On the wider field of animal welfare, some of the issues he talked about have been spoken about in this House previously. I am not in a position to comment on them, as the Senator will understand, but his genuine care and love for animals are recognised. We will have an opportunity to debate that.

Senator Nelson Murray spoke about work that is being done in the enterprise committee today in relation to pregnancy leave.

This has been a cross-party initiative between an awful lot of people. Senators Nelson Murray and Ryan have worked extremely hard to try to bring forward legislation to support people who have lost children through miscarriage. It can be a hugely challenging time for families. They cannot tell work why they need a couple of days off. There is a sense of loss. There are feelings that the mother and father could not carry the pregnancy for whatever reason. There is a fear of added health problems. All of that has to be dealt with in secrecy in a lot of ways. This is a really good initiative that has been brought forward by people in both parties. It is to be hoped it will come through the enterprise committee and onto the floor of the House.

Senator Aubrey McCarthy spoke about a number of people who struggled to get employment even though they are fully qualified and have first-class honours and serious degrees. If they are not getting interviews, it seems strange in terms of their CVs. I cannot speak about it on an individual basis because I do not have the information. I am happy to have a debate with the Minister for higher education on the pathway from education and college and graduating with a degree to getting into a first workplace. Many companies now use AI to decide who they interview in the first place. As the Seanator said, there may be questions about that. I am more than happy to have a debate with the Minister.

Senator Harmon spoke about Cork University Hospital, something she has spoken about on a regular basis, and rightly so. As she said, the hospital is excellent. I have experience of it. The staff are phenomenal, but the hospital is obviously understaffed and staff need more support. The leader of the hospital has spoken out, and should be listened to and respected. I do not know what conversations have happened between the Taoiseach and the HSE. The Taoiseach can be asked what he said or did not say every single week. The leader of the Senator's party can question him if she wants answers. I am a spokesperson for the Government in the Seanad, but cannot answer for what the Taoiseach said in a private meeting. I am sure the Senator will appreciate that. I am more than happy to have a debate on Cork University Hospital. We have had debates on University Hospital Limerick when Private Members' motions were brought forward. We can do the same for Cork University Hospital.

Senator O'Reilly spoke about the Be Emergency Ready booklet. She started by saying that the booklet was not totally useless, which I took as a massive compliment. She gradually got back into her usual political position, and gave out about the cost and asked whether the booklet was value for money. I would not say €1.2 million to inform 6 million people across the country of how to protect and support themselves and be ready in case an emergency happens is a waste of money. A lot of people and families have spoken about the booklet since it went to their homes. Numerous people have contacted me to ask questions. Some have asked me when the emergency we seem to be talking about is coming. In terms of giving people information, it is money well spent. Almost every other country in the world, in particular those in the European Union, do that.

Comment on this