We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Community safety and policing

Summary

Senators call for a debate on community safety and its national strategy, raising concerns about agency engagement, antisocial behaviour orders and private security. McAdam also requests a debate on access to specialist mental health services.

I attended yesterday evening the first public meeting of the Dublin Central Community Safety Partnership. Community safety partnerships were set up under legislation in the last Oireachtas. I supported that legislation, and that is why I went along to the meeting to see how the partnership is being run. The community safety partnerships are intended to increase community safety and they are meant to engage all of the statutory agencies to work with residents and businesses, the Garda and the local authority to improve safety. Last night, we had Dublin City Council and the Garda. Senator McAdam was there with me but there were no other representatives of statutory agencies present. I did not see anyone from the HSE or Tusla and I did not see anybody from education and from welfare. I did not see any of the four local TDs, many of whom have been on social media this week complaining about the Garda arrangements in Dublin Central. None of them was interested enough in community safety in Dublin Central to attend the community safety partnership meeting.

The Garda gave a very comprehensive presentation. It talked about high-visibility policing, community policing, drones, body cams, Tasers and helicopters. It gave a very fine presentation on Garda operations. Every single resident raised antisocial behaviour of all descriptions. I am not going to get into the details here, but there are genuine concerns.

It is interesting that Senator McDowell is here now because of the statistics that were put up. The Senator was the Minister for justice 20 years ago who introduced antisocial behaviour orders, ASBOs. In the 20 years since then, fewer than 50 of them have been issued right around the country. In Dublin Central, my constituency, my home, where there is now a proposal to put private security on the streets to deal with antisocial behaviour, there have been zero antisocial behaviour orders issued. How can that be? I cannot understand it and it is not good enough.

I want a debate with the Minister for justice on what the purpose of the legislation is if it is not being used. Why is it not being used? Is it a policing matter? Is it a courts matter? Is it an evidence matter? What is it? This House needs to debate why there are zero antisocial behaviour orders in Dublin Central. Communities deserve to know that when we pass laws, those laws are going to be used and are going to be effective. I would appreciate it if the Leader could arrange the debate.

Comment on this

I echo and second the calls by my learned colleague, Senator Fitzpatrick, for a debate on community safety. I reiterate the calls in this regard that I made to the Leader yesterday. I understand the relevant Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, will be in the Chamber next week for a considerable period, so he might afford us a couple of hours to discuss community safety and the national strategy that he launched last week.

I ask the Leader today to arrange for a debate with the Minister of State with responsibility for mental health, Deputy Butler, to discuss access to specialist mental health services. I am calling for this debate because of the huge impact of suicide that we are seeing now on the streets and across the communities of the north inner city. We have had too many families grieving. There are too many people struggling and there is a growing fear that those who reach out for help cannot access the help and support they need. We are seeing a growing potential for an epidemic of suicide, particularly among young men in the north inner city.

We are seeing reports of people experiencing serious mental health difficulties being turned away from key services despite having referral letters from their GPs. These are reports that need to be examined. We need to have clear answers about the referral process, how people are being assessed and what support is available when a service cannot accept them. We all know that for someone experiencing a mental health crisis, asking for help takes enormous courage. That moment must be met with compassion and a service that is capable of responding.

I want the communities of the north inner city to have a co-ordinated response, a response that reflects the needs of our communities and one that listens to the personal experiences on the ground. I ask the Leader to liaise with the Minister of State to arrange for an early debate so we can examine these concerns, establish where exactly the gaps lie and secure practical action to ensure people receive the help they need when they need it and when it matters most.

Comment on this

I empathise completely regarding the points made by the last two speakers. On ASBOs, which Senator Fitzpatrick raised, it has always amazed me that the careful legislation that was put in place when I was Minister for justice has never, in fact, been operated effectively throughout the country. I know there were safeguards attached to it that made it slightly more difficult to obtain an ASBO than was the case in Britain. In England and Wales, ASBOs were effectively dropped because they were being used excessively and impractically.

The suggestion that there should be private security guards on the streets is wholly unacceptable. Whereas whoever made it was probably motivated by the best of intentions, the simple fact is that if we need more gardaí on the streets, we have to ask what has happened to the Garda Reserve. It had around 1,100 or 1,200 members but this number has gone down to around 300 or fewer now. The Government has said on a number of occasions that it would increase the size of the reserve to 2,000, but nothing has been done on that front.

I support the suggestion that we should have a debate on justice policy as well because it is now well over 20 years since the decision was made to build a new prison at Thornton Hall to replace Mountjoy. It was not just my project. A later Minister, Alan Shatter, seemed to suggest that he was in favour of doing it. Nobody in the Department of justice has ever said that it is off the agenda, but Mountjoy Prison needs to be replaced. Despite the valiant efforts of people like Eddie Mullins to make it as humane as possible when he was the governor of that prison, it is wholly unsuitable for the purposes for which it is currently used. We have a crisis of accommodation. We have people sleeping on floors. We have multiple occupations of prison cells in squalid circumstances. We have United Nations observers telling us that what is happening in our prison system is wholly unacceptable by international standards. We have the Inspector of Prisons saying the same, yet this Government has not said that it is proceeding with the Thornton Hall project.

If it is ever to happen, the planning for it should be there now. If the planning for it is to be done now, it means that a decision has to be made and the public has to understand that it is happening. Only when that has happened will it be possible to have drug-free areas in our prisons, genuine rehabilitative programmes, reasonable exercise facilities for prisoners and the like. The same applies to the women's prison which is grossly overcrowded. Every time a woman is put into jail, and it is rare enough that it happens, some serious offender is let out to make space for her. All of that is wholly wrong. It is about time that the Government as a whole, and it is not just the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, because his predecessors bear the same responsibility, and all of the parties in Government come to this House to explain what they are going to do about the massive holes that are present in our criminal justice system and ensuring the safety of communities.

This is a matter of life and death. There are people, not merely those who may commit suicide, and families who are in terror of drug gangs extracting money from them and threatening to burn their houses down. We have seen it with our own eyes. Something must be done and it requires a new degree of vigour on the part of the Government.

Comment on this