An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business
- Order of Business 1 speech
The Leader sets the schedule for a motion on employment regulations and Second Stage debate on the Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill.
Garret Ahearn
- Community safety and policing 3 speeches
Senators call for a debate on community safety and its national strategy, raising concerns about agency engagement, antisocial behaviour orders and private security. McAdam also requests a debate on access to specialist mental health services.
Mary Fitzpatrick, Ray McAdam, Michael McDowell
- Property tax errors and tax surcharges 1 speech
A Senator says erroneous Revenue records showing property tax arrears can trigger a 10% income-tax surcharge, and that taxpayers must contact Revenue themselves to correct the mistake.
Pauline Tully
- Subminimum pay for young workers 9 speeches
Cosgrove seeks to amend the motion on employment regulations, arguing that young people should not receive subminimum rates when doing the same work as adults. She cites a report on young people’s employment and financial pressures.
Nessa Cosgrove, Maria Byrne
- Malicious referrals to Tusla 4 speeches
Keogan says repeated malicious or unfounded referrals to Tusla can abuse the child-protection system and calls for a way to identify and address them, while maintaining that genuine concerns must be investigated.
PJ Murphy, Evanne Ní Chuilinn, Sharon Keogan, Margaret Murphy O'Mahony
- Public health nursing vacancies 1 speech
A Senator warns that unfilled nursing posts and staff absences are overloading community nurses, increasing waiting lists and delaying patient care.
Manus Boyle
- South Dublin family facing eviction 1 speech
A Senator raises eviction cases in south Dublin, including a mother of three whose specially adapted home supports children with serious disabilities and is at risk of being lost.
Chris Andrews
- Permanent contracts for student nurses 1 speech
A Senator welcomes the offer of permanent contracts to 184 student nurses in the west and north west, saying it will help retain trained graduates.
Anne Rabbitte
- Kristian Jubani 1 speech
After welcoming two work-experience visitors, the Senator begins raising Kristian Jubani; the specific concern is not clear from the available speech.
Evanne Ní Chuilinn
- Rising rents and poverty 1 speech
A Senator cites sharp increases in rents, including a 36% rise over five years, and warns that housing costs are increasing poverty risk.
Laura Harmon
- Cocaine treatment demand 1 speech
A Senator highlights Tiglin’s report that cocaine, including crack cocaine, accounts for 50.4% of people presenting to its rehabilitation centres, describing a serious national crisis.
Aubrey McCarthy
- Support for the ICA 1 speech
A Senator seeks a debate on funding and recognition for the Irish Countrywomen’s Association, highlighting its contribution to rural communities.
Eileen Lynch
- Disability residential placement delay 1 speech
A Senator says repeated attempts to contact the HSE about a constituent’s residential placement have gone unanswered, leaving an elderly parent caring for a person with a severe disability.
Sarah O'Reilly
- Spiking legislation 1 speech
A Senator welcomes the Spiking Bill’s passage through the Seanad and its progression in the Dáil, praising Young Fine Gael and those who advanced it.
Garret Kelleher
- Ballyheige water contamination 1 speech
A Senator calls for urgent action on the Ballyheige do-not-consume notice, which has affected more than 3,500 customers since 7 October.
Mike Kennelly
- Moyross community CCTV funding 1 speech
A Senator seeks an open debate on sustaining Limerick’s extensive community CCTV network as regeneration funding is wound down.
Dee Ryan
- Spiking Bill in the Dáil 1 speech
A Senator commends Young Fine Gael for advancing the Spiking Bill and says the legislation shows how party members can bring ideas into law.
Cathal Byrne
- Live cattle exports 1 speech
A Senator congratulates those behind the Spiking Bill, then raises concerns about live cattle exports.
Paraic Brady
- Commercial rates for businesses 3 speeches
After a brief welcome to school visitors, a Senator asks for a debate on commercial rates and the effect of local authority budgets on SMEs and rural businesses; the Chair calls the Leader to respond.
Maria Byrne, Gareth Scahill
- Leader’s response on community safety 1 speech
The Leader says the Minister for Justice will be in the House the following week for a community-safety discussion and notes proposals for a safety-warden scheme in Dublin.
Garret Ahearn
The Order of Business is No. 1, motion re the Protection of Young Persons (Employment in Food and Beverage Services Sector) Regulations 2026, back from committee, to be taken on the conclusion of the Order of Business without debate; and No. 1a, the Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026 – Second Stage, to be taken at 11.45 a.m., with the time allocated for the opening remarks of the Minister not to exceed ten minutes, group spokespersons not to exceed eight minutes, all other Senators not to exceed five minutes and the Minister to be given no less than ten minutes to reply to the debate.
Comment on this
I attended yesterday evening the first public meeting of the Dublin Central Community Safety Partnership. Community safety partnerships were set up under legislation in the last Oireachtas. I supported that legislation, and that is why I went along to the meeting to see how the partnership is being run. The community safety partnerships are intended to increase community safety and they are meant to engage all of the statutory agencies to work with residents and businesses, the Garda and the local authority to improve safety. Last night, we had Dublin City Council and the Garda. Senator McAdam was there with me but there were no other representatives of statutory agencies present. I did not see anyone from the HSE or Tusla and I did not see anybody from education and from welfare. I did not see any of the four local TDs, many of whom have been on social media this week complaining about the Garda arrangements in Dublin Central. None of them was interested enough in community safety in Dublin Central to attend the community safety partnership meeting.
The Garda gave a very comprehensive presentation. It talked about high-visibility policing, community policing, drones, body cams, Tasers and helicopters. It gave a very fine presentation on Garda operations. Every single resident raised antisocial behaviour of all descriptions. I am not going to get into the details here, but there are genuine concerns.
It is interesting that Senator McDowell is here now because of the statistics that were put up. The Senator was the Minister for justice 20 years ago who introduced antisocial behaviour orders, ASBOs. In the 20 years since then, fewer than 50 of them have been issued right around the country. In Dublin Central, my constituency, my home, where there is now a proposal to put private security on the streets to deal with antisocial behaviour, there have been zero antisocial behaviour orders issued. How can that be? I cannot understand it and it is not good enough.
I want a debate with the Minister for justice on what the purpose of the legislation is if it is not being used. Why is it not being used? Is it a policing matter? Is it a courts matter? Is it an evidence matter? What is it? This House needs to debate why there are zero antisocial behaviour orders in Dublin Central. Communities deserve to know that when we pass laws, those laws are going to be used and are going to be effective. I would appreciate it if the Leader could arrange the debate.
Comment on this
I echo and second the calls by my learned colleague, Senator Fitzpatrick, for a debate on community safety. I reiterate the calls in this regard that I made to the Leader yesterday. I understand the relevant Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, will be in the Chamber next week for a considerable period, so he might afford us a couple of hours to discuss community safety and the national strategy that he launched last week.
I ask the Leader today to arrange for a debate with the Minister of State with responsibility for mental health, Deputy Butler, to discuss access to specialist mental health services. I am calling for this debate because of the huge impact of suicide that we are seeing now on the streets and across the communities of the north inner city. We have had too many families grieving. There are too many people struggling and there is a growing fear that those who reach out for help cannot access the help and support they need. We are seeing a growing potential for an epidemic of suicide, particularly among young men in the north inner city.
We are seeing reports of people experiencing serious mental health difficulties being turned away from key services despite having referral letters from their GPs. These are reports that need to be examined. We need to have clear answers about the referral process, how people are being assessed and what support is available when a service cannot accept them. We all know that for someone experiencing a mental health crisis, asking for help takes enormous courage. That moment must be met with compassion and a service that is capable of responding.
I want the communities of the north inner city to have a co-ordinated response, a response that reflects the needs of our communities and one that listens to the personal experiences on the ground. I ask the Leader to liaise with the Minister of State to arrange for an early debate so we can examine these concerns, establish where exactly the gaps lie and secure practical action to ensure people receive the help they need when they need it and when it matters most.
Comment on this
I empathise completely regarding the points made by the last two speakers. On ASBOs, which Senator Fitzpatrick raised, it has always amazed me that the careful legislation that was put in place when I was Minister for justice has never, in fact, been operated effectively throughout the country. I know there were safeguards attached to it that made it slightly more difficult to obtain an ASBO than was the case in Britain. In England and Wales, ASBOs were effectively dropped because they were being used excessively and impractically.
The suggestion that there should be private security guards on the streets is wholly unacceptable. Whereas whoever made it was probably motivated by the best of intentions, the simple fact is that if we need more gardaí on the streets, we have to ask what has happened to the Garda Reserve. It had around 1,100 or 1,200 members but this number has gone down to around 300 or fewer now. The Government has said on a number of occasions that it would increase the size of the reserve to 2,000, but nothing has been done on that front.
I support the suggestion that we should have a debate on justice policy as well because it is now well over 20 years since the decision was made to build a new prison at Thornton Hall to replace Mountjoy. It was not just my project. A later Minister, Alan Shatter, seemed to suggest that he was in favour of doing it. Nobody in the Department of justice has ever said that it is off the agenda, but Mountjoy Prison needs to be replaced. Despite the valiant efforts of people like Eddie Mullins to make it as humane as possible when he was the governor of that prison, it is wholly unsuitable for the purposes for which it is currently used. We have a crisis of accommodation. We have people sleeping on floors. We have multiple occupations of prison cells in squalid circumstances. We have United Nations observers telling us that what is happening in our prison system is wholly unacceptable by international standards. We have the Inspector of Prisons saying the same, yet this Government has not said that it is proceeding with the Thornton Hall project.
If it is ever to happen, the planning for it should be there now. If the planning for it is to be done now, it means that a decision has to be made and the public has to understand that it is happening. Only when that has happened will it be possible to have drug-free areas in our prisons, genuine rehabilitative programmes, reasonable exercise facilities for prisoners and the like. The same applies to the women's prison which is grossly overcrowded. Every time a woman is put into jail, and it is rare enough that it happens, some serious offender is let out to make space for her. All of that is wholly wrong. It is about time that the Government as a whole, and it is not just the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, because his predecessors bear the same responsibility, and all of the parties in Government come to this House to explain what they are going to do about the massive holes that are present in our criminal justice system and ensuring the safety of communities.
This is a matter of life and death. There are people, not merely those who may commit suicide, and families who are in terror of drug gangs extracting money from them and threatening to burn their houses down. We have seen it with our own eyes. Something must be done and it requires a new degree of vigour on the part of the Government.
Comment on this
At this time of year, self-employed people are making their tax returns. An accountant contacted me to say that on a regular enough basis when he goes to make the tax returns for his client, it mistakenly shows up that they have not paid their property tax. It is in cases where they have paid it but it shows up that they have not, and a 10% surcharge therefore ensues on their income tax. The accountant cannot contact Revenue to ask it to rectify the mistake; it has to be the client. The accountant will ask the client to do so and if they do, it is rectified, no problem. However, if the client does not or is too late doing so, the 10% applies. They will get their tax back, but they have to go through the procedure of applying for that with form-filling and so forth. He says that it is a regular enough occurrence and he has checked with other accountants, who said that it is happening and is really annoying. It is obviously a glitch in the Revenue system. Even though Revenue has been made aware of this, it still has not been rectified.
What he and I are asking for is that the Leader contacts the Minister for Finance and asks him to instruct Revenue to address this glitch in its system. It is something that is coming up every year for different clients and it is totally unnecessary. It puts extra work on the accountant, the client and Revenue personnel because they then have to go and return the tax if it has already been paid.
Comment on this
I propose an amendment to the Order of Business. In this day and age, the fact that young people under 20 are being paid a sub-minimal rate of pay is archaic. I brought forward legislation last year to try to abolish-----
Comment on this
I am speaking during the Order of Business on this.
Comment on this
It is the amendment to item No.1. We tabled an amendment to No. 1 on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the Order of Business and not the motion at the moment. It is later on that the motion comes up.
Comment on this
I am speaking about the motion as part of my Order of Business because I just want to raise it. I will not refer to the motion, but I want to bring up the issue of subminimum rates of pay for young people. We have heard stories. A report was published by the National Youth Council of Ireland this year about how young people are struggling to gain employment, and struggling to live on the employment they have, because they are still being paid subminimum rates of pay. We have 20-year-olds working in exactly the same situation as adults. The 20-year-olds are adults. They can vote, drive and get married, but they are being paid less. It is an archaic system. I know that the Low Pay Commission advised abolishing this in 2024 but nothing has happened towards it. That is why we have put it in the amendment today.
Comment on this
I want to take this opportunity to pay a brief tribute to my neighbour, friend and a man who has been an outstanding ambassador for Gaelic football and Gaelic games in Galway. Yesterday, Paul Conroy retired from what has been an outstanding and successful career as a senior footballer with the Galway senior football team. As a father, husband, neighbour and a man who represents the very best of us as Irish people, I wish Paul and his wife, Caroline, all the very best in his retirement from intercounty football. I hope that he enjoys many years to come playing senior football with his club, St James's.
Comment on this
I rise this morning to raise an issue that has been brought to my attention by a number of families across the country; namely, the handling of malicious, vexatious and repeated unfounded referrals to Tusla. Genuine concerns about a child's welfare must always be reported and investigated. Child protection must come first but we must also recognise that the system can be abused. At present, there appears to be a gap in how repeated malicious referrals are identified and addressed. While attention is rightly focused on the child who is the subject of the report, it appears that there is no system of procedure for identifying those who repeatedly make allegations that are found to be unfounded. The result is that innocent families can be subject to repeated investigations and disruptions, while the person making the allegations effectively faces no scrutiny. This places a burden on families and diverts scarce resources away from the children who genuinely need protection.
There is another concern and I want Members to listen to this very carefully. Even where a referral is found to be unfounded, records can remain on file until the child is 24 years old. While these records may not always affect employment, they remain with the child protection system and can be viewed by many other State workers in the future. Human nature being what it is, the reality is that a history of referrals, even unfounded ones, creates an assumption of "where there is smoke, there is fire". Demonstrably false and malicious allegations should be taken off the record and there should be consequences for the accuser. Other jurisdictions, like Canada, America, Australia and the UK, have adopted sophisticated approaches that distinguish between good faith reports that prove unfounded and reports that are malicious and knowingly false. Some have systems for identifying repeat vexatious reporters, while others provide mechanisms for sealing or removing records where allegations are proven false.
I call on the Minister for children to examine and adopt these proposals. It is very concerning for children and their families when false reports are made.
Comment on this
I would like to start by welcoming our new colleague Ray McAdam. I have done so privately, but I would like to officially congratulate him and say that I am very much looking forward to working with him. This is a great opportunity for him and a lovely time for him and his family. I wish him well.
A little kindness goes a long way. Tomorrow is World Kindness Day. I would like to encourage everyone here, not just for tomorrow - but maybe especially for tomorrow - to spread a little kindness. If they see someone with a nice jacket, they should tell them that it is nice. It does not matter if the person is a stranger. Maybe they should pick up the phone. If they have been meaning to call a friend for the past few months and they have not got around to it, they should do it tomorrow. They should ask someone if they are okay, and not only ask them but listen to what they say. We all have a habit of saying "How are you" and going off. They could say "Oh, I feel like blowing up". Sometimes people do not listen. We should spread a little kindness here and everywhere else and be very conscious of doing so, and not just tomorrow. We should smile or say hello to a stranger. As a society, we have become very judgmental. We never know what someone is going through, so we should scatter a bit of gold dust tomorrow and every day.
Comment on this
I want to raise the issue of staffing shortages in public health and community nursing. I have serious concerns about the failure to replace public health nurses and community registered nurses who are on maternity leave or long-term sick leave or who are retiring or moving to other posts. This is putting huge pressure on existing staff, increasing the workload and leading to longer waiting lists and delays relating to patient care in our community. In one local network that has five vacancies or absences, it has been left to two public health nurses to manage a caseload of approximately 1,000 children alongside their other duties. This is simply not sustainable. Children, vulnerable people and families are at risk of not receiving the timely care and support they need. Staff are struggling to access annual leave or other leave entitlements. We cannot continue to expect fewer nurses to deliver the same level of service. Urgent action is needed to fill these vacancies, support staff and protect essential community nursing services. What I am afraid of due to what I have heard in Donegal is that there are so few community my concerns up the line, because this is an urgent matter that we need to look at.
Comment on this
In the past week, two shocking eviction cases in south Dublin were brought to my attention. The first, as Senator Clonan outlined yesterday, involves a mother of three children, two of whom have serious disabilities. The family is about to be thrown out on the street, through no real fault of their own, as a result of a very unpleasant legal dispute involving an ex-partner and a vulture fund. They are being thrown out of a home that has been specially adapted to the needs of the children. This will deprive them of their critical disability support overnight. Tragically, there is a real likelihood that the children will have to go into State care because they cannot receive the care they need in emergency accommodation. The other case involves an 82-year old woman who was suddenly evicted from the home she has lived in for decades, despite co-operating fully with the sales process. The sheriff appointed seven men to enter her home. They did so while she was in the bath. She was removed without being given an opportunity to collect any of her belongings beyond the clothes on her back. Three months later, she has still not been able to access her belongings. The financial institution responsible for her eviction has ceased all contact with her and has not given her any clarity regarding the six-figure settlement from the sale of the house that she is due.
In both these cases, the evictions were pushed by vulture funds, with no regard for the people living in the properties those funds are profiting from. It is really sickening that financial institutions can have such power over vulnerable people, particularly in circumstances where children and elderly people are involved. Vulture funds and big developers are given every favour and advantage by the State, yet vulnerable people are left to sort out their own issue. There is no regard had for the catastrophic consequences. Evictions like these need to be addressed by the Minister for justice. The Minister needs to intervene because these evictions have ruined people's lives. He needs to show what side he is on and stand up for ordinary people over the vulture funds.
Comment on this
I welcome the announcement from the Minister for Health, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, yesterday evening that 184 student nurses will be offered the opportunity of permanent contracts in the west and north west. That is an absolutely fantastic intervention by the Minister. It is the mature thing to do here because, ultimately, all of the students have graduated in the west. They are from all over the country; they are not just Galway kids. It is absolutely brilliant to think that good practice is going to prevail here in order that when we train young people and if they so wish, they can be kept on in the hospitals where they have trained. It should be standard practice right around the country that when students graduate, they are offered the opportunity to hold on to their permanent contracts. I applaud the Minister on that.
In the same way, occupational therapists, physiotherapists and speech and language therapists should also be given the opportunity to stay in their regions. Unfortunately, we do not have the same level of opportunity for those who graduate in the west at the moment. Perhaps we are over budget in our region, in the mid-west and in the south, so the only opportunities are on the east coast. Occupational therapists, physiotherapists and speech and language therapists are getting opportunities to work in the HSE in the midlands and in north-west Dublin. When young people graduate, if they choose to stay in a region, we should offer them the opportunity to do so. They learnt how to work in those places. Let us not be constrained by budgets. While I understand that is the case, there is a huge need for therapists to be retained. I have no doubt that the Minister will take that on board. It is a practical intervention that would make a seismic difference.
Comment on this
I have two guests in the Public Gallery this morning who I want to mention and welcome. The first is Ella Fitzsimons, my husband's niece, but I claim her as my own. Ella is with me on work experience today. She is from Templeogue and goes to the High School in Rathgar. I have Tiernan Simonieu as well, who is an older brother of my daughter's gymnastics buddies Ava and Ben. Tiernan is from Crumlin, which is beside where I live, and goes to Templeogue College. They are with me for the week and they have been a wonderful addition to my office.
I want to talk about Kristian Jubani. He is going to do, and already has done, something significant. We have only ever won seven Youth Olympic Games medals. Kristian will arrive home to Dublin tomorrow. The colour of the medal is still up in the air but he will have an Olympic medal when he comes home. He will arrive into Dublin Airport at 1 o'clock. He fights for gold at 12.30 p.m. Irish time today. He will bring home silver anyway, but it could be gold. The final fight is today. Kristian is a 17-year old from Crumlin. He has been boxing his whole life. He is amazing. His speed and power are frightening. He says himself that he is going for gold today, and I would back him 100% to do that. He has done something extraordinary. We do not send many young people to the Youth Olympic Games. We do not send a huge team. We send a very select few. We sent three athletes across all our sports to the Youth Olympic Games in Dakar this week, and Kristian is one of them. He is bringing home a medal. That is a huge deal. I will read a short quote before I finish up. He said, "I am just a young fella from Crumlin. I'm at the big stage, and I'm putting Crumlin on the map, so I'm happy about that.” Everybody in Crumlin is so happy about that. He has done an amazing thing in his career so far.
He has been an amazing boxer. His parents have supported him the whole way, his club in Crumlin has supported him the whole way, but he has made this happen. He is bringing home at least a silver and maybe a gold tomorrow. I would encourage anybody who is available at 12.30 p.m. to watch the live feed of the fight. He deserves all the support he can get.
Comment on this
I want to talk about rent increases. We have seen some very worrying statistics published recently. Just yesterday, the Central Statistics Office showed that rents have increased by 36% in the last five years, and this is the highest that rents have ever been in this country since they were first recorded in 1996. What we are dealing with here is poverty and an increased risk of poverty across the country. In the last year alone, on average, in the private rental sector and across the board, rents have increased by 7%. When it comes to local authority housing, rents have increased by 12.7% in the last year, which is the highest increase in local authority rents that we have seen in ten years.
We also know that one in four people living in rented accommodation in Ireland is at risk of poverty. We know that 40.6% of those living in social housing are at risk of poverty after rent is taken into account. For those who are on social support payments, such as HAP, when we take rent out of their deductions, they are at risk of poverty at a rate of 58%, which is higher again. At a time when 5,830 children are living in emergency accommodation in Ireland, we should have a debate with the Minister for housing on how the housing crisis is impacting people in terms of poverty in this country. I looked on yesterday as I saw Spain having a national strike, which included housing because of the cost of housing and rents in that country. This is one of the biggest issues of our time in Ireland and we need to address it.
Comment on this
I would like to mention a report that is about to be published by Tiglin. My colleague, Senator McDowell, has already spoken about drug-related intimidation this morning. Tiglin is about to publish its report on Tuesday, when its representatives will be in the audiovisual room in Leinster House. What they are finding is that over half of the people now presenting to Tiglin do so due to cocaine. There is a huge cocaine crisis in Ireland. Cocaine, both powder and crack cocaine, now accounts for 50.4% of all the people who come in through the rehab centres at Tiglin. The last few weeks have shown us, in the hardest way, how addiction affects not only the individual who takes the drugs, but also families, parents, partners and whole communities. We have also seen how it can take lives.
I have mentioned many times my work in the Lighthouse on Pearse Street. Behind every person and behind every statistic that Tiglin has in its annual report, there are talents, gifts and abilities that seem to be lost sight of. That is why Tiglin works with the whole person. It works with their physical and mental health, but also their relationships, family supports, housing and so on, because addiction hits the whole family and the whole community. The report that is being published shows that 112,000 meals have been served in the last year at the Lighthouse, but also that 388 family support sessions have taken place. Some 111 third level certificates up to degree level have been given out through SETU. The numbers that have been fed and the families supported, and the people finding their way back into society, show that it actually works. However, services are being stretched and the crisis is pushing them to the limit.
It is not a problem for somebody else. It is not a problem just for NGOs. It is a problem for the whole society. We need a national response. I ask the Leader to bring to the House the Minister with responsibility for the national drugs strategy to discuss it. Behind every addiction, there is a person and a family, and the ability to change their lives.
Comment on this
I rise to speak about a very important organisation across rural Ireland, the Irish Countrywomens Association, ICA. I ask that we arrange a debate with the Minister for rural and community affairs on funding and support for the ICA. I have received correspondence and been in contact with the Boherbue guild in my constituency of Cork North-West. It is raising what I think is a very fair question: are long-established organisations such as the ICA receiving recognition and support that reflects the work they do in our communities? As I mentioned in the House last week, I recently attended the 90th anniversary of the Cork federation of the ICA. For many years, ICA guilds have given women opportunities to learn, to develop skills, to build friendships and to take an active role in their communities. In rural areas in particular, that regular meeting can be an important source of company and support for somebody who may otherwise suffer from rural isolation. The ICA also preserves skills and protects heritage and native crafts, such as lace making and felt making. It supports local causes and provides a strong voice for women.
Behind that work are volunteers who are giving their time, paying membership fees and fundraising to keep their guilds going. We cannot afford to take that commitment and their role in our communities for granted. Those in the Boherbue guild make an important distinction in that being eligible to apply for a competitive grant does not by itself provide sustainable support. Meeting room hire, heating, insurance, transport and materials are recurring bills, and they have to be paid whether the guild succeeds or fails in a grant application. I believe their request is constructive. They want fair consideration for funding. They also want a voice in consultation and recognition of the community networks they have maintained over decades. They also see opportunities to work with newer organisations and to share knowledge, facilities and experience.
I ask the Minister to engage directly with the ICA, examine access to funding for core running costs and consider how greater certainty can be provided for local guilds. The ICA’s contribution is undoubtedly still needed today, and our support and funding should reflect that.
Comment on this
I want to raise the issue of trying to secure a residential placement for one of my constituents with a disability. Over the last few weeks, my office has tried to contact the HSE every single day on behalf of this constituent. We have called and left messages, but we have not received one callback or response to the case. I find it completely unacceptable for a public body to just let the phone ring or to pass the buck and not have the decency to explain if a placement for this person is available. The person has a severe disability and is being cared for by their elderly parent, who is unable to continue with care. The family was told over a year ago by the HSE that a placement was in the pipeline, yet the case was only logged in September of this year. Members can imagine the shock when the family heard this latest update. Now, they have discovered through RTÉ that the HSE has no plans to offer any new residential placements for the remainder of this year.
Some 2,000 children and adults are awaiting residential care nationwide, which is heartbreaking. The HSE will not fund alternative respite, offer jobs to graduate nurses or provide residential care for people with disabilities. Our health service is not fit for purpose, in my opinion. Money is being flittered away through layers and layers of management and outsourcing. There is an unexplained €784 million overspend this year, yet there is apparently no more money for residential care. All the disability action plans in the world sound great, but the reality is that elderly parents are trying to provide care for children with severe disabilities until their deathbed. It is a disgrace. Disabled people need to know where they will live and who will support them when a parent dies or is no longer able to provide care. This is not happening. We need the Minister in here to answer questions.
Comment on this
I wish to speak about the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person (Amendment) (Spiking) Bill 2023, which will progress through Second Stage in the Dáil this evening. I commend Young Fine Gael in particular on bringing this forward, as well as the Senators of the 26th Seanad, including the now Deputy Barry Ward but also the Ceannaire and the Leas-Chathaoirleach, on listening and taking this important legislation through every Stage in this House.
This Bill is about recognising spiking as the serious crime that it is and ensuring those who are responsible are held to account. Spiking is defined as administering a substance to someone without their knowledge or consent. This can include putting a substance into somebody's drink, injecting them with a drug using a needle or giving someone a larger quantity of alcohol than they were aware of. The intention is to overpower or sedate a person, cause harm, facilitate rape or sexual assault or to commit another offence. It is an act of abusing power over another person. It can leave a devastating and long-lasting impact on victims. Spiking is not currently a stand-alone criminal offence in Ireland and while existing offences such as poisoning can apply, they do not provide the specific legal recognition that the crime of spiking requires.
Between 2021 and the end of 2025, An Garda Síochána received 339 reports of spiking. This amounted to an average of one incident every six days, but we know that many incidents go unreported and it is fair to say that this number equates to only a very small fraction of what is actually happening. We have become accustomed to taking our own precautions against spiking. Parents warn their children to be careful of their drinks while they are out and friends keep an eye on each other's drinks. We have the responsibility to protect ourselves but we must also ensure that legislatively the law protects people from the offence of spiking. This is why this Bill matters. It creates a specific criminal offence for spiking and recognises the danger in its own right, sending out a clear message.
This is a very strong example of how youth political organisations can bring about meaningful change in public policy. I commend all of those involved in this positive and effective campaign to date.
Comment on this
I wish to again raise the Ballyheige water supply line that has been affecting over 3,500 customers since 7 October with a do-not-consume notice. This is still ongoing. I have raised this and have asked the Ministers concerned for updates. I have asked Uisce Éireann to come and sort out the issue as soon as possible. While I respect the work that has been done on the ground, we are over five and a half weeks into this do-not-consume notice. Some of the 3,500 customers have had a temporary supply and 200 customers are on the Listowel line now. There is a Glenderry issue that Uisce Éireann has taken five and a half weeks to check. This would supply another 180 of the 3,500 customers but it still has not been done.
I understood from the Minister's office that €5 million was set aside to connect the line from Ardfert to Ballyheige. It is a long-term solution. I brought that solution to them three weeks ago and, as of today, nothing has happened in relation to starting the works to complete that project. The money is there. We have been told that the boreholes have been dug in the last three weeks and that samples have been taken. This is total disrespect for the people in Ballyheige and north Kerry. Uisce Éireann is refusing to meet the community in a public meeting to express where this issue is currently at, what Uisce Éireann has done, what the cause is and what the solutions are. What Uisce Éireann is getting away with down there is totally unacceptable. It is pitting councillors, Deputies and Senators who are bringing back information. I brought that information back three weeks ago and nothing has been done about it. I ask that the Minister for housing and local government visit Ballyheigue and the area and to give us the work we were promised three weeks ago to solve this issue for the people of north Kerry.
Comment on this
I wish to raise a very serious and important issue that is ongoing in Limerick. That is the matter of the CCTV centre at Moyross. In Limerick, we have a very unique system. We have the largest network of community CCTV in the country. We have almost 400 cameras across our city and county. That is unparalleled anywhere else in the country. It emerged from a huge need we had for enhanced community safety in areas that were suffering really badly from feuds and criminality 15 years ago. It has been funded through regeneration in Limerick. Regeneration funding is being wound down and all the schemes that are currently funded through it are being mainstreamed into their home Departments. Unfortunately, this particular project, which is of vital importance to people living in the city and county, has kind of fallen between two stools. There is no clear and definable area or funding stream where it can move to.
Last year, the Mayor of Limerick stepped in and bridged the gap in funding as it was being reduced but this year, regrettably, he says he is unable to do so. I wish to thank the Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Services, Reform and Digitalisation, Deputy Chambers, and the Taoiseach for their responses to calls for intervention that have been made across the House and by me and my colleagues in Fianna Fáil in recent weeks. They have acknowledged the importance of these community cameras and have indicated their willingness to try to help resolve the issue. I also urge the Mayor of Limerick, and the Departments of justice and housing, to meet in the subgroup the Minister for justice, Deputy O'Callaghan, and the Minister for housing, Deputy Browne, agreed to commit to in order to find a sustainable ongoing solution for funding for this important service in Limerick. Regrettably, that subgroup has not convened in the last 12 months. However, I urge all parties to get together to find a sustainable solution to this funding, so the workers in the community centre who operate this CCTV scheme and the communities that benefit from it are not faced with the uncertainty and precipice we are now at.
Comment on this
I join with colleagues in speaking about the importance of the spiking Bill that passed this Chamber. It is important for young people who are becoming interested in politics to know that if they do join a political party, whatever that party might be, there are opportunities to put forward ideas. In this particular instance, this was an idea that came from Young Fine Gael. As Senator Kelleher mentioned, it was supported and passed in this House. It is important, as the Bill is now making its way through the Dáil this afternoon, to recognise that achievement and to thank the members of Young Fine Gael who presented the idea in recognition of a serious problem that is happening up and down the country.
I acknowledge the decision of the board of the HSE to give approval for the New Ross primary care centre. This is a very significant milestone in the journey to ensuring that New Ross town, a town of 9,000 people, has its own primary healthcare centre, as exists in other places like Enniscorthy and Wexford town.
Comment on this
I wish to also congratulate Young Fine Gael, Regina Doherty and everybody associated with the spiking Bill going through the other House today. I speak as a father, but I also had a family member who had their drink spiked a number of years ago. It is very worrying to see it take so long to get to this stage today. It is an offence and should always be treated as an offence for anybody to spike the drink or inject anybody in order to take advantage of them on a night out or at a social occasion.
I want to raise an issue about the live exports of cattle in this country. We have seen live exports to Algeria cease over the last number of weeks. We have seen our exporters with in excess of 13,000 calves held up in lairages at a huge cost to them. In marts, we saw that type of animal drop in price by almost €300.
When a farmer has 30 cows and they are selling 30 calves and they are losing €300, the maths for the year are very easy to add up. They are into a negative. If it is €300 for any one animal and ten animals are €3,000, then it is €9,000 for anyone who has a small herd of 30 cattle. It is a huge loss. I urge Bord Bia to come out and give us a statement of where it is looking at other markets because we have to keep that market open. Our local farmers and farming economy depend on live exports leaving the country.
Comment on this
I welcome the school completion programme from St. Catherine's National School in Dublin 8. They are guests of Deputy Cummins. They are all very welcome. I hope that they enjoy their visit to Leinster House.
Comment on this
It is fitting that the visitors, who are the guests of Deputy Cummins, are in the House because I would like to call the Minister, Deputy Browne, into the House to have an open debate about commercial rates. It has been raised repeatedly in recent weeks. We are seeing local authority budgets coming up all over the country at the moment. It is about supporting our SMEs. A lot of our rural businesses do an awful lot of planning and forecasting. A lot of what they have been told in recent years has been to the effect that we will make this increase now and then it will be set for the next three or four years for the term of the local authority. Unfortunately, every local authority at this moment in time appears to be looking at getting an increase in rates.
I would like to debate the consistency of the service that is being provided across local authorities. While we all welcome the public realm works that are taking place, including on accessibility and maintenance, and I have to compliment the local authority staff, especially in my own home area of Roscommon, there needs to be a lot more engagement with our businesses. We need to support them. The Minister has acknowledged that a modernisation needs to take place. We could have a very constructive conversation in this House if we were given the opportunity. I would like to call for that, if possible.
Comment on this
I thank the, I believe, 20 Senators who made contributions.
Senators Fitzpatrick, McAdam and McDowell touched on community safety, particularly in inner city Dublin and a meeting that was held recently that no agencies attended, which does not seem to make sense. We have the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, in next week on community safety, so there will be an opportunity to speak on that. There is a business group, We Are Dublin Town, that is seeking establishing a safety warden scheme, similar to the pilot scheme that the Minister, Deputy McEntee, supported. What is important is that it is not used as a political opportunity, but that all public representatives come together and see this as an opportunity to support the inner city. The Minister will be in next week and there will be an opportunity for a debate on that.
Senator McAdam spoke about mental health and access to services. This is an issue across the country. In fairness to the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, she has done an awful lot of work and increased the amount of funding year on year in mental health. She brought one of the biggest Bills - the Mental Health Bill - through both Houses, but it is not enough and more needs to be done. People need to be supported. It seems strange that people are turned away if they have referral letters. I will take that up with the Minister of State and we will have an opportunity to see what is happening there because that does not seem right.
Senator Tully spoke about self-employed tax returns. I will speak to the Minister. Revenue is normally a very good organisation. In fairness, it is one of the best public bodies to deal with. It is a small issue, but it can be very frustrating for a client when they are dealing with their tax return at this time of year.
Senator Cosgrove spoke about the subminimum wage. This has been there for a period. We as a Government have always tried to support employment and opportunities. The Senator spoke about how it was a challenge for young people in particular to get on the working ladder. One of those issues is the cost for employers to employ people. One of the opportunities to bring someone up from an intern or a young age to get onto the working ladder is that subminimum wage. It is not something that the Senator agrees with, but it is something that has been quite successful. It does employ people. There are a lot of young people who are not on the minimum wage and are on higher wages. However, the Senator is talking about a particular cohort and we are more than happy to have a debate on the matter. As a Government, we are always happy to have a debate on employment. The one thing that the Opposition cannot criticise us for relates to employment and the number of people who are employed in this country, with an increase of 1 million people in the past 15 years taking us from 1.8 million to 2.8 million. The foundation of any family unit or young person is to have a job. Let us talk about the details of it in a debate.
Senator P. J. Murphy spoke about Paul Conroy. What a career Paul has had. It is important to acknowledge it. I hope that even though he has retired, he will continue to inspire young people in his club of St. James's and his parish going forward. I have no doubt that he will.
Senator Keogan spoke about the referrals to Tusla that were unfounded. I am aware that it is likely that it happened, but I am not aware of any particular case. I have no doubt that it happens and that referrals go to Tusla that are found to be not true. I can see why records have to be kept of such cases, but as the Senator said, there needs to be a distinction made between cases that Tusla deals with and situations where referrals are put in that are just not true. It does not seem right that it should be on someone's record for 24 years. Data protection means that people should not be able to see any of that, but I take the Senator's point. I will speak to the Minister about it.
Senator Murphy O'Mahony spoke about World Kindness Day, which is tomorrow. I could not think of a better Senator to raise it. She acts as though it is World Kindness Day every day. It is important that we all be conscious of spreading a little bit more kindness, particularly in this Chamber. Actually, this Chamber is good, but maybe the other Chamber needs to learn that lesson a bit more.
Senator Boyle spoke about the public community nursing challenge. If there are only two nurses dealing with 1,000 kids in Donegal, that is impossible. No matter how good those two nurses are, they cannot manage that to the requisite a level. I will speak to the Minister about that.
Senator Andrews spoke about two evictions. Senator Clonan spoke about the issue yesterday. In my response, I asked Senator Clonan to send me the information on the single mother with kids. I do know what can be done, but I will see what I can do. If Senator Andrews has the information, I ask him to pass it onto me. I ask him to send the second case on to me as well because an 82-year-old woman should not be evicted and have her belongings taken from her or not given to her, essentially. If the Senator has those details, I would more than happy to put further representatives on his behalf.
Senator Rabbitte spoke about the 184 student nurses who are getting permanent contracts. I agree with her, in that this should be done in other areas in health as well. We should encourage people who go into education in health to remain and work in Ireland, and particularly to give them the opportunity to be able to work outside of Dublin and in the areas they want to live in, whether that is Galway, Limerick, Tipperary or wherever.
Senator Ní Chuilinn spoke about Kristian who is fighting in the Youth Olympic Games in an hour’s time. We all support him. He has done incredibly as a 17 year old from Crumlin in Dublin. The Senator told us privately yesterday that the whole community was all behind him. We wish him well in an hour’s time.
Senator Harmon spoke about rent increases. Rent increases are a challenge. It is part of the housing challenge that we have. Luckily, our housing numbers are increasing every year. We are looking at 40,000 houses at the end of this year. One of the reasons for that is the increased build in apartments, which helps in terms of rent. It is all about supply. Increasing supply manages rent more. I am more than happy to have a debate on that. The Senator is correct in saying that people who live in rented accommodation have a greater possibility of poverty. We need to be able to support them more. Luckily, a lot of measures have been put forward at the moment. We will see it in the development waiver scheme for developers to try to speed up building.
That scheme was brought in two years ago. It was criticised by pretty much everyone in the Opposition that we were supporting developers, but look at what it is doing now. Developers are trying to finish their builds by the end of the year so that they can avail of the waiver scheme. That is good for people right across the country. They are getting more houses and apartments. Taking that into account, however, I am more than happy to have a debate with the Senator in this regard.
Senator McCarthy raised the report from Tiglin, which will be published on Tuesday in the audiovisual room in Leinster House. I look forward to listening to it. In a way, it is depressing that over half the cases coming forward are cocaine-related. Addiction, as the Senator knows, is a terrible disease. He has asked for a debate on it. The Oireachtas Committee on Drugs Use published a report in this regard. While I am willing to have a debate on that report, we are thinking of giving it a couple of months so that we can see the findings from that report of the committee. Perhaps in the new year – I have spoken to other Senators on this – we can arrange a debate on that report, the issues of addiction and drugs and what can be done going forward. While I am happy to have the debate in two weeks’ time, it will be more beneficial if we have it in the new year.
Senator Lynch spoke about the ICA. It does incredible work across the country. It deserves more recognition for the work it does. It has an opportunity to apply for funding through the Department of rural affairs. It does not seem to get its fair share, however, particularly compared with some other organisations. I will speak to the Minister for rural affairs, Deputy Calleary, in this regard. He should be coming into the Chamber to have a debate on rural affairs. I will speak to him on it. Certainly, I do not want to see the ICA losing out on opportunities that other organisations are getting.
Senator Sarah O’Reilly spoke about the need for a residential place for a constituent and how she is not receiving a response from the HSE. There are a number of avenues available to the Senator. We have a HSE contact for Oireachtas representatives. She could use that avenue. Obviously, she has the opportunity to submit a Commencement matter on the issue. She also has colleagues in the Dáil who could put down a parliamentary question, which requires a response. Parliamentary questions mandate a response. I encourage the Senator to do that.
Senator Kelleher raised the issue of the spiking Bill, as did Senators Byrne and Brady. This was initiated by a youth organisation – it happened to be Young Fine Gael – that identified a loophole affecting young people and students in particular across the country. It is the first youth organisation ever to receive cross-party support in the Seanad. I commend every single Senator who supported that Bill a number of years ago. It was introduced by the Leader of the Seanad at the time, former Senator and current MEP Regina Doherty. It received widespread support in the House. I encourage all Members of Dáil Éireann to support the Bill. It will have a huge impact on young people in the future. I thank the Senators for raising the matter.
Senator Kennelly spoke about the water supply at Ballyheigue. On the same day we started, both our areas had do-not-consume notices. That notice was in effect for approximately two weeks in my area. It is back to a boil water notice at the moment. However, the Senator’s area has had a do-not-consume notice for five and a half weeks. Oireachtas representatives for Tipperary ended up having a meeting with the CEO of Uisce Éireann in Leinster House. I suggest the Senator, along with the other representatives for the area, requests a meeting in this building with the CEO of Uisce Éireann on this issue in order to have a constructive meeting about what is happening. It is utterly unacceptable that 3,500 households are not able to consume water for almost six weeks. We are only five weeks away from Christmas. Are they getting any indication as to whether they will be able to consume water during Christmas? It seems atrocious. The very least the CEO of Uisce Éireann could do is hold that meeting. I suggest to the Senator – his area has similar representatives to my area – to try to make that meeting constructive because the meeting we had turned into a shouting match. It is quite difficult to do that with a number of the representatives from Tipperary. I hope the same does not happen with the representatives from Kerry.
Senator Dee Ryan spoke about the CCTV centre in Moyross and the 400 cameras that are dotted across the city and county. Subgroups are set up for a reason so that people engage and work together for the betterment of the city and the area. I encourage all people to do that. The Senator has not named anyone, but I suspect there are people who are not engaging in that process. It is there for a good reason. I encourage people to engage with it. Funding should be put in place. If people come together, I am sure a solution can be found to make sure those cameras are in place. They are in place for a good reason, that is, to ensure people, especially young kids and elderly and vulnerable people, are protected. I will speak to the Minister for justice, Deputy O’Callaghan, on it. It seems to me that there are people – possibly political or non-political people - who do not want to work with each other on it. I encourage them to do so.
Senator Cathal Byrne spoke about the new primary care centre in New Ross. It is hugely welcome in the area. The Senator has been working extremely hard on this over the past number of months to try to get it over the line. Once approval is secured, it is about moving forward. Now that approval is confirmed, we know that, in time, the residents and people of New Ross are going to have their own primary care centre. That is a huge advantage for the area. I see the benefits in Cahir in my area. We do not have to go to Clonmel or Cork anymore. We have our own primary care centre on the doorstep of a small town. New Ross will similarly benefit.
Senator Brady spoke about live exports. Senator Daly also mentioned this issue yesterday. We need to open up more markets. The Senator is aware of areas around the world where we have opportunities to open up new markets, particularly in Asia and other areas. Bord Bia and Enterprise Ireland need to play a role in widening that market for Irish beef. I will speak to the Minister, Deputy Heydon, in this regard. I spoke to Senator Daly about this issue recently. It is a challenging time when we consider that farmers are losing approximately €300 per cow simply because an opportunity in Algeria is not available at the moment.
Senator Scahill raised the issue of commercial rates and the consistency of service. We have not had the Minister, Deputy Browne, into the Chamber for a while. I will try to bring him in. This time of year is always a challenging time. Councillors are put under huge pressure to agree to budgets that lead to a raising of rates or the local property tax, LPT. It is never a case of reducing the budget. It is an opportunity for the Minister to come into the Chamber to speak on the matter. There is inconsistency in the way councils deliver in this regard. I will speak to the Minister, Deputy Browne, on it.