Malicious referrals to Tusla
Keogan says repeated malicious or unfounded referrals to Tusla can abuse the child-protection system and calls for a way to identify and address them, while maintaining that genuine concerns must be investigated.
I want to take this opportunity to pay a brief tribute to my neighbour, friend and a man who has been an outstanding ambassador for Gaelic football and Gaelic games in Galway. Yesterday, Paul Conroy retired from what has been an outstanding and successful career as a senior footballer with the Galway senior football team. As a father, husband, neighbour and a man who represents the very best of us as Irish people, I wish Paul and his wife, Caroline, all the very best in his retirement from intercounty football. I hope that he enjoys many years to come playing senior football with his club, St James's.
Comment on this
I rise this morning to raise an issue that has been brought to my attention by a number of families across the country; namely, the handling of malicious, vexatious and repeated unfounded referrals to Tusla. Genuine concerns about a child's welfare must always be reported and investigated. Child protection must come first but we must also recognise that the system can be abused. At present, there appears to be a gap in how repeated malicious referrals are identified and addressed. While attention is rightly focused on the child who is the subject of the report, it appears that there is no system of procedure for identifying those who repeatedly make allegations that are found to be unfounded. The result is that innocent families can be subject to repeated investigations and disruptions, while the person making the allegations effectively faces no scrutiny. This places a burden on families and diverts scarce resources away from the children who genuinely need protection.
There is another concern and I want Members to listen to this very carefully. Even where a referral is found to be unfounded, records can remain on file until the child is 24 years old. While these records may not always affect employment, they remain with the child protection system and can be viewed by many other State workers in the future. Human nature being what it is, the reality is that a history of referrals, even unfounded ones, creates an assumption of "where there is smoke, there is fire". Demonstrably false and malicious allegations should be taken off the record and there should be consequences for the accuser. Other jurisdictions, like Canada, America, Australia and the UK, have adopted sophisticated approaches that distinguish between good faith reports that prove unfounded and reports that are malicious and knowingly false. Some have systems for identifying repeat vexatious reporters, while others provide mechanisms for sealing or removing records where allegations are proven false.
I call on the Minister for children to examine and adopt these proposals. It is very concerning for children and their families when false reports are made.
Comment on this
I would like to start by welcoming our new colleague Ray McAdam. I have done so privately, but I would like to officially congratulate him and say that I am very much looking forward to working with him. This is a great opportunity for him and a lovely time for him and his family. I wish him well.
A little kindness goes a long way. Tomorrow is World Kindness Day. I would like to encourage everyone here, not just for tomorrow - but maybe especially for tomorrow - to spread a little kindness. If they see someone with a nice jacket, they should tell them that it is nice. It does not matter if the person is a stranger. Maybe they should pick up the phone. If they have been meaning to call a friend for the past few months and they have not got around to it, they should do it tomorrow. They should ask someone if they are okay, and not only ask them but listen to what they say. We all have a habit of saying "How are you" and going off. They could say "Oh, I feel like blowing up". Sometimes people do not listen. We should spread a little kindness here and everywhere else and be very conscious of doing so, and not just tomorrow. We should smile or say hello to a stranger. As a society, we have become very judgmental. We never know what someone is going through, so we should scatter a bit of gold dust tomorrow and every day.