We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Leader’s response on community safety

Summary

The Leader says the Minister for Justice will be in the House the following week for a community-safety discussion and notes proposals for a safety-warden scheme in Dublin.

I thank the, I believe, 20 Senators who made contributions.

Senators Fitzpatrick, McAdam and McDowell touched on community safety, particularly in inner city Dublin and a meeting that was held recently that no agencies attended, which does not seem to make sense. We have the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, in next week on community safety, so there will be an opportunity to speak on that. There is a business group, We Are Dublin Town, that is seeking establishing a safety warden scheme, similar to the pilot scheme that the Minister, Deputy McEntee, supported. What is important is that it is not used as a political opportunity, but that all public representatives come together and see this as an opportunity to support the inner city. The Minister will be in next week and there will be an opportunity for a debate on that.

Senator McAdam spoke about mental health and access to services. This is an issue across the country. In fairness to the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, she has done an awful lot of work and increased the amount of funding year on year in mental health. She brought one of the biggest Bills - the Mental Health Bill - through both Houses, but it is not enough and more needs to be done. People need to be supported. It seems strange that people are turned away if they have referral letters. I will take that up with the Minister of State and we will have an opportunity to see what is happening there because that does not seem right.

Senator Tully spoke about self-employed tax returns. I will speak to the Minister. Revenue is normally a very good organisation. In fairness, it is one of the best public bodies to deal with. It is a small issue, but it can be very frustrating for a client when they are dealing with their tax return at this time of year.

Senator Cosgrove spoke about the subminimum wage. This has been there for a period. We as a Government have always tried to support employment and opportunities. The Senator spoke about how it was a challenge for young people in particular to get on the working ladder. One of those issues is the cost for employers to employ people. One of the opportunities to bring someone up from an intern or a young age to get onto the working ladder is that subminimum wage. It is not something that the Senator agrees with, but it is something that has been quite successful. It does employ people. There are a lot of young people who are not on the minimum wage and are on higher wages. However, the Senator is talking about a particular cohort and we are more than happy to have a debate on the matter. As a Government, we are always happy to have a debate on employment. The one thing that the Opposition cannot criticise us for relates to employment and the number of people who are employed in this country, with an increase of 1 million people in the past 15 years taking us from 1.8 million to 2.8 million. The foundation of any family unit or young person is to have a job. Let us talk about the details of it in a debate.

Senator P. J. Murphy spoke about Paul Conroy. What a career Paul has had. It is important to acknowledge it. I hope that even though he has retired, he will continue to inspire young people in his club of St. James's and his parish going forward. I have no doubt that he will.

Senator Keogan spoke about the referrals to Tusla that were unfounded. I am aware that it is likely that it happened, but I am not aware of any particular case. I have no doubt that it happens and that referrals go to Tusla that are found to be not true. I can see why records have to be kept of such cases, but as the Senator said, there needs to be a distinction made between cases that Tusla deals with and situations where referrals are put in that are just not true. It does not seem right that it should be on someone's record for 24 years. Data protection means that people should not be able to see any of that, but I take the Senator's point. I will speak to the Minister about it.

Senator Murphy O'Mahony spoke about World Kindness Day, which is tomorrow. I could not think of a better Senator to raise it. She acts as though it is World Kindness Day every day. It is important that we all be conscious of spreading a little bit more kindness, particularly in this Chamber. Actually, this Chamber is good, but maybe the other Chamber needs to learn that lesson a bit more.

Senator Boyle spoke about the public community nursing challenge. If there are only two nurses dealing with 1,000 kids in Donegal, that is impossible. No matter how good those two nurses are, they cannot manage that to the requisite a level. I will speak to the Minister about that.

Senator Andrews spoke about two evictions. Senator Clonan spoke about the issue yesterday. In my response, I asked Senator Clonan to send me the information on the single mother with kids. I do know what can be done, but I will see what I can do. If Senator Andrews has the information, I ask him to pass it onto me. I ask him to send the second case on to me as well because an 82-year-old woman should not be evicted and have her belongings taken from her or not given to her, essentially. If the Senator has those details, I would more than happy to put further representatives on his behalf.

Senator Rabbitte spoke about the 184 student nurses who are getting permanent contracts. I agree with her, in that this should be done in other areas in health as well. We should encourage people who go into education in health to remain and work in Ireland, and particularly to give them the opportunity to be able to work outside of Dublin and in the areas they want to live in, whether that is Galway, Limerick, Tipperary or wherever.

Senator Ní Chuilinn spoke about Kristian who is fighting in the Youth Olympic Games in an hour’s time. We all support him. He has done incredibly as a 17 year old from Crumlin in Dublin. The Senator told us privately yesterday that the whole community was all behind him. We wish him well in an hour’s time.

Senator Harmon spoke about rent increases. Rent increases are a challenge. It is part of the housing challenge that we have. Luckily, our housing numbers are increasing every year. We are looking at 40,000 houses at the end of this year. One of the reasons for that is the increased build in apartments, which helps in terms of rent. It is all about supply. Increasing supply manages rent more. I am more than happy to have a debate on that. The Senator is correct in saying that people who live in rented accommodation have a greater possibility of poverty. We need to be able to support them more. Luckily, a lot of measures have been put forward at the moment. We will see it in the development waiver scheme for developers to try to speed up building.

That scheme was brought in two years ago. It was criticised by pretty much everyone in the Opposition that we were supporting developers, but look at what it is doing now. Developers are trying to finish their builds by the end of the year so that they can avail of the waiver scheme. That is good for people right across the country. They are getting more houses and apartments. Taking that into account, however, I am more than happy to have a debate with the Senator in this regard.

Senator McCarthy raised the report from Tiglin, which will be published on Tuesday in the audiovisual room in Leinster House. I look forward to listening to it. In a way, it is depressing that over half the cases coming forward are cocaine-related. Addiction, as the Senator knows, is a terrible disease. He has asked for a debate on it. The Oireachtas Committee on Drugs Use published a report in this regard. While I am willing to have a debate on that report, we are thinking of giving it a couple of months so that we can see the findings from that report of the committee. Perhaps in the new year – I have spoken to other Senators on this – we can arrange a debate on that report, the issues of addiction and drugs and what can be done going forward. While I am happy to have the debate in two weeks’ time, it will be more beneficial if we have it in the new year.

Senator Lynch spoke about the ICA. It does incredible work across the country. It deserves more recognition for the work it does. It has an opportunity to apply for funding through the Department of rural affairs. It does not seem to get its fair share, however, particularly compared with some other organisations. I will speak to the Minister for rural affairs, Deputy Calleary, in this regard. He should be coming into the Chamber to have a debate on rural affairs. I will speak to him on it. Certainly, I do not want to see the ICA losing out on opportunities that other organisations are getting.

Senator Sarah O’Reilly spoke about the need for a residential place for a constituent and how she is not receiving a response from the HSE. There are a number of avenues available to the Senator. We have a HSE contact for Oireachtas representatives. She could use that avenue. Obviously, she has the opportunity to submit a Commencement matter on the issue. She also has colleagues in the Dáil who could put down a parliamentary question, which requires a response. Parliamentary questions mandate a response. I encourage the Senator to do that.

Senator Kelleher raised the issue of the spiking Bill, as did Senators Byrne and Brady. This was initiated by a youth organisation – it happened to be Young Fine Gael – that identified a loophole affecting young people and students in particular across the country. It is the first youth organisation ever to receive cross-party support in the Seanad. I commend every single Senator who supported that Bill a number of years ago. It was introduced by the Leader of the Seanad at the time, former Senator and current MEP Regina Doherty. It received widespread support in the House. I encourage all Members of Dáil Éireann to support the Bill. It will have a huge impact on young people in the future. I thank the Senators for raising the matter.

Senator Kennelly spoke about the water supply at Ballyheigue. On the same day we started, both our areas had do-not-consume notices. That notice was in effect for approximately two weeks in my area. It is back to a boil water notice at the moment. However, the Senator’s area has had a do-not-consume notice for five and a half weeks. Oireachtas representatives for Tipperary ended up having a meeting with the CEO of Uisce Éireann in Leinster House. I suggest the Senator, along with the other representatives for the area, requests a meeting in this building with the CEO of Uisce Éireann on this issue in order to have a constructive meeting about what is happening. It is utterly unacceptable that 3,500 households are not able to consume water for almost six weeks. We are only five weeks away from Christmas. Are they getting any indication as to whether they will be able to consume water during Christmas? It seems atrocious. The very least the CEO of Uisce Éireann could do is hold that meeting. I suggest to the Senator – his area has similar representatives to my area – to try to make that meeting constructive because the meeting we had turned into a shouting match. It is quite difficult to do that with a number of the representatives from Tipperary. I hope the same does not happen with the representatives from Kerry.

Senator Dee Ryan spoke about the CCTV centre in Moyross and the 400 cameras that are dotted across the city and county. Subgroups are set up for a reason so that people engage and work together for the betterment of the city and the area. I encourage all people to do that. The Senator has not named anyone, but I suspect there are people who are not engaging in that process. It is there for a good reason. I encourage people to engage with it. Funding should be put in place. If people come together, I am sure a solution can be found to make sure those cameras are in place. They are in place for a good reason, that is, to ensure people, especially young kids and elderly and vulnerable people, are protected. I will speak to the Minister for justice, Deputy O’Callaghan, on it. It seems to me that there are people – possibly political or non-political people - who do not want to work with each other on it. I encourage them to do so.

Senator Cathal Byrne spoke about the new primary care centre in New Ross. It is hugely welcome in the area. The Senator has been working extremely hard on this over the past number of months to try to get it over the line. Once approval is secured, it is about moving forward. Now that approval is confirmed, we know that, in time, the residents and people of New Ross are going to have their own primary care centre. That is a huge advantage for the area. I see the benefits in Cahir in my area. We do not have to go to Clonmel or Cork anymore. We have our own primary care centre on the doorstep of a small town. New Ross will similarly benefit.

Senator Brady spoke about live exports. Senator Daly also mentioned this issue yesterday. We need to open up more markets. The Senator is aware of areas around the world where we have opportunities to open up new markets, particularly in Asia and other areas. Bord Bia and Enterprise Ireland need to play a role in widening that market for Irish beef. I will speak to the Minister, Deputy Heydon, in this regard. I spoke to Senator Daly about this issue recently. It is a challenging time when we consider that farmers are losing approximately €300 per cow simply because an opportunity in Algeria is not available at the moment.

Senator Scahill raised the issue of commercial rates and the consistency of service. We have not had the Minister, Deputy Browne, into the Chamber for a while. I will try to bring him in. This time of year is always a challenging time. Councillors are put under huge pressure to agree to budgets that lead to a raising of rates or the local property tax, LPT. It is never a case of reducing the budget. It is an opportunity for the Minister to come into the Chamber to speak on the matter. There is inconsistency in the way councils deliver in this regard. I will speak to the Minister, Deputy Browne, on it.

Comment on this