Student Support Bill 2008: Committee Stage
Contributions 1–173 of 341. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 2008 ›
The reason I am in the Chair is that the Chairman of the committee has resigned. We will deal with finding his replacement at the next meeting of the joint committee. This is the select committee which deals with legislation and comprises Deputies only.
The meeting has been convened for the purposes of the consideration by the committee of the Student Support Bill 2008 which was referred to the select committee by order of the Dáil on 30 April 2008. I welcome the Minister of State at the Department of Education and Skills, Deputy Haughey, who has responsibility for lifelong learning issues and his officials. It is the collective decision of everyone present to proceed as quickly as possible with the work of the committee today. I know this will distress the Minister of State immensely.
Comment on this
I suggest we consider the Bill until 1 p.m. and break until 2 p.m., if necessary. Is it agreed in principle that we will conclude Committee Stage today? Agreed.
Before proceeding to our consideration of the Bill, I would like to be excused from chairing the meeting. I ask Deputy Flynn to propose a replacement.
Comment on this
I nominate Deputy Wallace to chair the meeting.
Comment on this
As agreed, we will proceed as quickly as possible. I refer members to the grouping of amendments for the purposes of debate. It is proposed to group amendments as follows: amendments Nos. 1, 20, 21 and 30; Nos. 2, 84, 85 and 97; Nos. 3, 77 and 78; Nos. 4 to 7, inclusive, 15, 16, 36 to 38, inclusive, and 56; Nos. 8, 57, 62, 63 and 72; Nos. 9, 11 and 69; Nos. 27 to 29, inclusive, and 31; Nos. 32, 33 and 35; Nos. 38a, 59a and 78a; Nos. 39 and 40; Nos. 42 to 53, inclusive; Nos. 60 and 74; Nos. 61 and 65; Nos. 66 to 68, inclusive; Nos. 70 and 76; Nos. 79 to 81, inclusive; Nos. 82 and 83; Nos. 86 to 88, inclusive; Nos. 89 to 92, inclusive; Nos. 95 and 96. All other amendments will be discussed separately. Are the groupings agreed to? Agreed.
I advise members that four amendments have been ruled out of order - amendments Nos. 23, 25, 26 and 58 - as they involve a potential charge on the Exchequer. We will now proceed with our consideration of the Bill.
SECTION 1
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 3, subsection (2), lines 17 and 18, to delete all words from and including ", except" in line 17 down to and including "Act," in line 18.
This is a textual change to make the meaning of the provision clearer. Are we also discussing amendments Nos. 20, 21 and 30?
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 20, 21 and 30 provide for the deletion of the word "commencement" and its replacement with the term "coming into operation" to ensure consistency with the proposed amended wording in amendment No. 1.
Comment on this
Are we moving away from the Latin tradition that we were all so proud to inherit towards everyday bog English?
Comment on this
Yes. It is considered to be more up to date.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 2, 84 and 85 are related. As an alternative to amendment No. 84, amendment No. 97 is also related. They may all be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 3, to delete lines 24 and 25 and substitute the following:
" "Appeals Board" shall be construed in accordance with section 22(2);”.
This amendment provides for the deletion and substitution of text. The amended provision states "Appeals Board" shall be construed in accordance with section 22(2) which provides for the inclusion of the name of the Student Grants Appeals Board in Irish, An Bord Achomhairc i Leith Deontas Mac Léinn. Amendments Nos. 84, 85 and 97 also provide for the inclusion of the name of the board in Irish.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 3 and 77 are related. Amendment No. 78 is an alternative to amendment No. 77. They will all be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 3, to delete lines 26 and 27 and substitute the following:
" "appeals officer" means a person designated under section 17(1);”.
This is a textual amendment. Amendments Nos. 77 and 78 provide for the designation, rather than the appointment, of one or more members of an awarding authority's staff to perform the functions of an appeals officer. The amendment provides that an awarding authority shall designate such and so many members of its staff as it considers appropriate to be appeals officers under the section. A person so designated shall be an appeals officer for such a period as the authority may determine. The new wording makes it clear that the processing of appeals is a function to be assigned by the awarding authority to an existing member of staff, rather than a new post or position to be filled by appointment by an awarding authority.
Comment on this
If the person concerned is in the same section of the Department, how independent will he or she be? Will he or she solely deal with appeals? Sometimes the processing of appeals in the public sector can be fraught because appeals officers differ in their opinions. I have examined issues surrounding community welfare officers and appeals. In some famous cases the appellant has never been successful, while in others, they are generally more successful. What criteria will be applied? Will appeals officers use independent standards to benchmark the appeals process? How objective will the process be and how will we ensure the removal of subjectivity?
I have this year's figures for grants broken down by county council and vocational education committee. There are significant differences between grant applications that have been processed in full and those that have been refused. This might warrant an analysis of the structures used. Why do more people get through in some counties than in others? I am not suggesting there is anything untoward in the process, but I cannot believe there is such a great disparity between counties. A significant number of applicants might be rejected in one county. Therefore, something is amiss. While I welcome the appeal provisions in the Bill, the structure needs analysis.
Comment on this
The aim of the Bill is to bring to the system clarity, certainty and consistency for all students. To respond to the Deputy's specific query, under the new arrangements, the same person will not process an appeal. There will be a service level agreement with the awarding authority, as a result of which the person who will process the appeal will be different.
Comment on this
The standards applied by the various awarding bodies appear to differ significantly. One would anticipate that the demography and incomes are similar across counties but that does not appear to be the case. Perhaps the Minister of State would do a desktop analysis of the statistics I received from his Department.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy asking about the existing position?
Comment on this
There are 33 local authorities and 33 VECs, so there will be discrepancies. I acknowledge the Deputy's argument but the purpose of the Bill is to eliminate inconsistencies by establishing a single grant awarding authority.
Comment on this
I appreciate that the official sitting beside the Minister of State agrees with what I am saying. We need to ensure the system is professional, fair and independent. I do not doubt that is the Minister of State's intention but it might be helpful to analyse the figures.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 4 to 7, inclusive, are related and amendments Nos. 15, 16, 36, 37, 38 and 56 are alternative amendments. Amendments Nos. 4 to 7, inclusive, 15, 16, 36, 37, 38 and 56 will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 3, between lines 28 and 29, to insert the following:
" "appointed awarding authority" shall be construed in accordance with section 10;”.
When the Bill was originally published it was envisaged that the awarding authority would be either a vocational education committee or, where section 11 applied, a person specified in an order made under that section. On foot of a Government decision, dated 26 July 2010, to make provision for the centralisation of the student grant function and provide for a single grant awarding authority, the definition of "awarding authority" needs to be amended to include existing awarding authorities and the newly appointed awarding authority provided for in amendment No. 36.
Amendment No. 4 provides for the insertion of an additional definition of "appointed awarding authority" in section 2. Amendment No. 5 provides for the amendment of the existing definition of "awarding authority" in section 2. Amendment No. 15 provides for the insertion of an additional definition of "relevant Minister", which is needed in the context of amendment No. 36. Amendment No. 16 provides for the insertion of an additional definition of "transferring awarding authority" in the context of amendment No. 36.
Amendment No. 36 provides for the insertion of a new section after section 9 allowing the Minister to appoint an awarding authority. The purpose of the proposed new section is to give the Minister the power to appoint an existing body as an appointed awarding authority to take on the responsibility of central administration of the student grant system. This is one of the most critical amendments introduced on Committee Stage as it reflects a change of policy on the part of the Government in regard to centralising the entire grant administration function rather than administering grants across 66 awarding authorities. In the current economic and budgetary environment, it is desirable and necessary to revisit this issue as part of the Government's programme of public sector reform and our exploration of cost-effective administrative solutions. The centralisation of the administration of grants has the potential to deliver significant efficiencies and economies of scale.
The Government took account of the message that emerged from its ongoing consultations, namely, that a centralised awarding authority would greatly benefit the student as end user. It would result in greater consistency in interpretation, information and decision making. In addition, the uncertainty about payments inherent in the current system and its 81 different paying agencies will be removed and monthly payments by electronic funds transfer will become the norm. The proposed new section provides that the appointed awarding authority will be an existing awarding authority, a local authority or VEC or any public body whose functions include the support or promotion of participation in higher or further education or the administration of grant schemes.
The appointed awarding authority will be in a position to outsource particular functions to private sector operators where it is cost effective to do so and a better level of service can thereby be provided. This is provided for in a new section providing for agreements relating to performance of certain functions, which will be inserted after section 10. In appointing the new awarding authority, the proposed amendment requires the Minister to have regard to a range of matters, including the need for efficiency, effectiveness and economy in the delivery of grants administration functions.
Amendment No. 37 provides for the insertion of a new section which sets out by order any matters necessary for the transfer of functions to the appointed awarding authority and other matters incidental to or consequential on the transfer.
Amendment No. 38 provides for the insertion of a new section dealing with employees of appointed or transferring awarding authorities. As it is proposed to amend the Bill to allow the Minister to appoint a single grant awarding authority, consequential provisions are required in this new section to protect the terms and conditions of employment of staff who relocate to the appointed awarding authority. This is a standard provision in legislation to ensure we meet our obligations under EU law relating to the transfer of undertakings and fixed term workers' rights.
Amendment No. 56 inserts a new subsection 2(c) to provide that a scheme shall specify the awarding authority that will perform the grant functions.
Comment on this
The entire process is increasingly in turmoil but I welcome in principle the proposed new awarding authority. The need for such a change is demonstrated by the fact that 13,000 applications for third level grants were not processed by the end of October. In Cork County Council, 55% of applications were not processed, which means 885 applicants still do not know if they will get grants. The percentage of unprocessed applications in other authorities were as follows: County Dublin VEC, 52%; Kildare County Council, 52%; Fingal County Council, 51%; Limerick County Council, 51%; and County Sligo VEC, 50%. The current system is inefficient and unacceptable. In my constituency, Louth County Council and VEC are doing their best but they lack manpower.
I understand the Government intends to reduce the student grant allocation by €22 million in 2011 and €51 million in a full year. Families dealing with reduced incomes will be placed in a very difficult position. The heavy boot of Government is pressing down on the students who will lead our country in the future. It is not acceptable that these delays are allowed to continue. Will the Minister of State intervene with those local authorities which have not been able to process more than half of the applications received by this late stage of the year? He has stated he will make provision in the Bill to bring in others to help. I suggest he immediately find out what are the staffing requirements of the local authorities and VECs concerned and ensure they will be able to take on the staff they need, on contract if necessary, to process the outstanding applications, or else instruct them to put everything else aside in order that the students affected will have something on which to live. They are penniless, while their families are in desperate circumstances. We receive telephone calls from individuals throughout the country who are in distress. Immediate and effective action is needed. The Minister of State could take such action today.
Comment on this
The Department is very familiar with this problem and accepts there is a problem in a number of local authorities. It is in regular contact with local authorities and VECs and constantly monitoring the situation which is not acceptable. Some grant applications are very straightforward and processed in the normal way. In many cases there is no delay. Delays mainly occur in dealing with more complex or complicated grant applications, in respect of which further information is required. Deputy O'Dowd will appreciate that there has been an increase in the number of grant applications received as more and more people return to further and higher education because of current circumstances in the economy. This is another factor to be taken into account. We must recognise that there is a moratorium on public sector recruitment which is causing problems in some awarding authorities. We are endeavouring to improve the position by putting service level agreements in place. I accept that there is a problem. The Department is in contact with the local authorities in the areas in which there are problems to try to speed up the process by introducing new procedures. We will just have to work our way through the problem. While the Bill will not do anything for students who have submitted applications, its purpose is to eliminate delays and create greater efficiencies in the system resulting in a more user-friendly system.
Comment on this
With respect, I ask the Minister of State to reply to the questions asked. Two issues have been raised. One relates to a case in which an applicant has not provided full information or perhaps does not have his or her tax certificate. However, for 13,000 applicants, the first page of the application form has not been opened and these are the cases about which I speak. No work has been done on them and processing has not commenced. I accept and acknowledge that applicants have difficulties in producing income certificates and know there are problems with existing certificates, but I am not speaking about these cases, rather I am speaking about those in which the application forms have not yet been opened. I do not accept that this is good enough and do not accept any of the answers given by the Minister of State. The people concerned applied in good faith. In some counties, including Clare and Mayo, the processing of applications has finished; it has almost finished in County Roscommon. Applications in counties Sligo, Meath, Longford and Kilkenny have also been processed. Would it make sense for the Minister of State to send staff from these countries to the local authorities which have not had the staff required to do the job to work overtime in the coming weeks to process the applications? The manpower is available, but it is not being used. This would make much sense. Will the Minister of State tell me why he will not do this?
Comment on this
The Deputy should accept some, if not all, of the answers I have given. Up to 60% of the applications received in some areas are incomplete. This causes-----
Comment on this
The Deputy stated he did not accept the explanations given.
Comment on this
I am distinguishing between applications that are being dealt with and those in respect of which processing has not yet commenced. I am speaking about the latter.
Comment on this
I am surprised to hear the Deputy tell me that some application forms have not yet been opened.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste would have issued that reply.
Comment on this
I am taking the Bill on behalf of the Tánaiste.
Comment on this
I do not intend to avoid it. It is important to put the Deputy's query in context and I hope he will allow me to do so. It is important to state there has been a huge increase in the number of applications received. There was a 20% increase this year, which created a huge challenge for the awarding authorities, with which the Department is in contact on a weekly basis to try to solve the problems. I will certainly take on board what the Deputy stated and raise the issues mentioned by him in our interaction with the awarding authorities.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has the information on which local authorities have finished the processing of applications. The competent staff which have done the work could very easily do the work other local authorities cannot do and do it immediately. It is just a matter of using the post.
Comment on this
I would not underestimate the challenge presented by the moratorium on public sector recruitment.
Comment on this
This would allow existing staff who are qualified and have dealt with applications in their own counties and VECs to be used. Where work has been completed, why can the Minister of State not ask staff to work on other applications which, if need be, could be sent to other local authorities? It could be done very quickly.
Comment on this
Before the Minister of State replies, Deputy Quinn wishes to speak on the same matter.
Comment on this
This is the largest body of related amendments to the legislation. There are ten related amendments, including those tabled by the Minister, and the first of them all point in the same direction. Three issues are raised. I cannot recall in all my time in the House waiting two years between the completion of Second Stage and the arrival of amendments. We were told there were great legal impediments and difficulties in the Department that required the seeking of legal advice. Perhaps as we go through the Bill we might see the amendments that caused such a delay, but it is a condemnation of the capacity of the Department of Education and Skills to produce legislation. Let us face it, if it was doing the leaving or junior certificate, its parents would not be happy with its results.
This has not been a victim-free two year period, as students have been forced out of college in some cases. Representatives, in the main of student unions throughout the country, are in the Visitors Gallery because they have an acute interest in this matter. I can tell the Minister of State - I am sure Deputies O'Mahony and O'Dowd can confirm this - that individual student unions and the USI have communicated with us on this matter. Part-time work commitments and family home financial circumstances have altered dramatically in the past two years. Trying to get cash while waiting for a grant to come through has been difficult compared to previous years.
The Department's internal legislative process needs to be examined. This is a matter for review by the Department in terms its own efficiency. Yesterday some of us met the organisation and review group from the Department of the Taoiseach. Across the party political spectrum there was unanimous agreement in relation to the performance of the Department of Education and Skills.
To turn to the measure in question, I will allow the Minister of State to explain why these things cannot be done, but, as someone who regards himself as being in the public service, if the Croke Park agreement is to mean anything, the forms had better be cleared soon-----
Comment on this
-----otherwise all bets will be off in terms of not touching salaries between now and 2014. This is the message I will send to the public service. There are two sides to the equation - salaries will not be touched further between now and 2014 in return for an increase in productivity which is measured and quantifiable. Deputy O'Dowd has received a chart from the Department, not necessarily from the section of the Minister of State, that quantifies it in stark terms. The moratorium has nothing to do with this.
Comment on this
It is a matter of productivity within the local authorities and a glaring indictment of them. The same information is being processed in a range of local authorities, in some of which staff have cleared their desks, while in others, they have not opened the files. The Minister of State is in charge for the time being and it is the Department's responsibility to deal with the backlog.
The purpose of the amendment in my name is to facilitate the greater centralisation of power to award grants, rather than establishing the awarding status of the VECs in the Bill for all time. This is a welcome step. Some comments were made in this regard on Second Stage and I am delighted the Department has accepted their thrust. It has clearly given the matter proper thought. With regard to the 16 new VECs, the Labour Party supports in principle the integration and amalgamation of VECs. As far as I am concerned, although I do not have responsibility for the matter, a number has been arrived at and I do not think the discussion should be reopened. Procedures should be established for the amalgamation. This will affect the section within the Department which will be administering the grants.
The reason we tabled the amendment is that applications should be processed by one VEC only. I envisage that each VEC will check applications submitted in its own area to avoid the problem of their being incorrectly filled in or incomplete. A young person in County Roscommon or County Clare, or his or her parents, will fill in the form and the local VEC will check to ensure all of the information required is contained in the form and then forward it to the authority designated by the Minister. The designated authority should be one of the larger VECs with the capacity to deal with applications.
I do not know whether the Minister of State wishes to discuss the later amendments. Perhaps we might comment on them as we go along. Is it the procedure that if we agree to this block of amendments, all of the consequential amendments will not be discussed?
Comment on this
We will discuss the related amendments. Only amendment No. 4 has been moved, but we can discuss the others.
Comment on this
I just wanted to confirm the procedure.
I welcome the thrust of what the Department is trying to do. As I said, I deplore the delay in taking Committee Stage, although I accept that people in this room may not necessarily be responsible for this. However, there is a lesson to be learned by whoever will be in charge of the Department in the future, including the permanent staff: the need for productivity is not confined to the VECs, it extends also to Marlborough Street. In the meantime, some students have been forced out of the education system because of our collective inability to get our act together.
Comment on this
Local authorities should learn from what happened last year in the processing of grant applications. We were assured by the Minister that it would not happen again, but it is and something needs to be done about it. I do not want to hold up the proceedings, but I must express my support for the comments made.
Comment on this
As there is a vote in the Dáil, we will wait until we return to hear the Minister of State's reply.
Comment on this
There were reasons for the delays in bringing the Bill to the committee. There was a legal challenge and the financial situation of the county council changed in the meantime. Deputy Quinn suggested VECs should receive the applications and do the initial application work, but that system would not work, as it would introduce an extra layer of bureaucracy. We are trying to proceed with a single awarding authority to make the system more efficient. The matter can be looked at when we call for expressions of interest, but would it take away from the objective of the Bill.
Comment on this
I realise everyone is now expected to book airline tickets and so on online, but the reality is that in many parts of the country parents who must provide the information on income which may be sensitive from the point of view of the applicant student will not be able to talk online with whomsoever the person will happen to be. I had it in mind that there would be one central awarding authority but that in each VEC someone could present the form as filled in and ask someone to check it. The real waste happens when the form is formally submitted. It is like a planning application; the entire system is engaged before rejection. If someone could look at the form and point to any missing items or additional documents needed, it would facilitate applicants. There would still be a single awarding authority but the 16 new VECs could have a customer service function within their remit in respect of either the applicant or the parents or guardian of the applicant to ensure all the necessary documentation was provided before the form was sent to the awarding authority. I am not seeking a formal, two tier structure.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste has said she would like to see some local presence as part of the process. The matter can be looked at when seeking expressions of interest.
Deputy O'Dowd proposed that staff of other local authorities could work on applications. There could be data protection issues or issues of confidentiality; I would have to look into the matter.
Comment on this
That is rubbish. With respect, I have never heard such waffle, even from Fianna Fáil. Everyone trusts the local authority or VEC official in any county to do his or her job. There is no question about the integrity of the process; the point is that it does not work. There are staff sitting in offices in VECs in Carlow, Clare, Donegal, Dún Laoghaire, Galway city, Longford, Mayo, Offaly and Roscommon who have either finished their work or who had less than 20 applications to process at the end of last month; they are ready to help staff in other counties. Why does the Minister of State not insist on this being done? I am sure they would be willing to help. I respect the Minister of State's point; I am not being personally critical, but he represents the Government and the staff concerned work in the public service. This job is not being done when there are others who could do it and who are sitting doing nothing somewhere else. A total of 13,000 students have not had their application forms opened, some 20% of the total number who applied. The resources are available and the Government should use them.
I support the idea of a local service, but Fine Gael is stating there should be a one stop shop for everything. If I lose my job, I should not have to go to the labour exchange, then FÁS, the HSE for my medical card application form and the local authority for my rent adjustment form. Why should someone in the VEC assess a person's income while someone in the local authority or the HSE is carrying out a different means test for the same family? There is no joined-up thinking. We need a one stop shop to process social welfare, third level grant, housing, employment training and medical cards applications. It should be done locally in order that there would be a stream of activities that could be engaged in. One application form should suffice for most agencies. Bringing everything together would save money and be more efficient, eliminating half of the delays in the process. I accept the importance attached to online applications, but, as Deputy Quinn says, there should be a way to handle queries locally. I do not care who would provide the service, be it the VEC or another office, as long as it was done for everyone. We must shake up local government processes and this is the way to go.
Comment on this
The Deputy is mainly concerned to ensure clarity in respect of what will happen with unprocessed applications this year. The Bill is concerned with what will happen in the future.
Comment on this
The Bill does not go far enough. Wider legislation is needed to provide for the establishment of a one stop shop for all services. I have no problem with the Bill, but I do have a problem with the lack of action, urgency and change. There are 13,000 people waiting at home for the cheque in the post, wondering if they will be able to do their exams, use the library or attend lectures.
Comment on this
This is an administrative matter related to the subject of the Bill, although it is not necessarily the responsibility of the Minister of State. As Minister of State with responsibility he could give an undertaking that arising from this exchange, that the chief executive officer either of the VEC or of the county council, whichever is relevant, would be directly contacted by his Department. He has the information, he has already supplied it, particularly for those who have serious arrears. He should seek an explanation as to the reason for the delay, when it will be cleared and when the applicants will be notified as to where they stand vis-à-vis the application.
Comment on this
If there are resources in the counties I mentioned they should finish the job. Can we send 20 applications to the Minister of State or can the five people come to Dublin County Council for a week to clear the 1,483 applications it has been unable to open? Let us get at it.
Comment on this
To clarify, we need a response in respect of what will happen with this year's applications. That is really what members are concerned about and also Deputy Ruairí Quinn's suggestion that the Department would write to the chief executives. The support of the Oireachtas committee might strengthen the Department's hand in that.
Comment on this
I think everybody in the room accepts that this Bill will improve the position. In regard to sharing of information, as raised by Deputy O'Dowd, that issue is being looked at a higher level in the context of transforming public services but there are data protection issues involved in that also. I do not accept that is waffle. I know the Deputy did not mean to be personal. There are data protection issues and very strict laws are in place.
Comment on this
They were never intended by the drafters of that legislation.
Comment on this
The director is interpreting it to enhance his profile and to create more work so he can get more staff.
Comment on this
I want to challenge the Minister of State on what he said. He said there are data protection issues - what are they?
Comment on this
The Deputy is raising a bigger issue about the sharing of information.
Comment on this
Not necessarily, what I am saying is that I can come in from Meath County Council or Meath VEC, where I finished all my applications, and into Dublin and sit at the desk and process the applications. What is the problem?
Comment on this
We must allow the Minister of State to reply. The Minister of State to reply without interruption.
Comment on this
The situation is unacceptable at the moment, as I said at the outset. Members have provided useful information here. I accept it is as a result of a parliamentary question and they have highlighted the problems in various local authorities. The Department is very much aware of those problems and the particular awarding authorities that have difficulties. We have issued strongly worded letters and we are in contact with those authorities on a weekly basis. Arising from the discussion this morning, we will identify those local authorities again where there are difficulties and endeavour to sort out the problems as soon as possible, by whatever means is necessary.
Deputy Ruairí Quinn spoke to amendment No. 6. I think he accepts that I cannot accept the amendment because the issues has been addressed by amendment No. 5, which has been proposed by the Tánaiste and Minister for Education and Skills, and the Deputy said that.
Comment on this
May I get back to the point about the data protection issue? Either the people come to the application forms or the application forms go to the people who process them. If I make application to Louth VEC, the data might be sent to Donegal VEC. There is no issue with a person from Meath VEC who has finished processing all their applications coming to Dublin VEC and sitting at the table and processing applications. I do not see any protection issue there.
Comment on this
The director of data protection says there is an issue.
Comment on this
The problem is no civil servant can contest it. It is nonsense.
Comment on this
Perhaps it can be resolved by Deputy Ruairí Quinn's proposal. The concerns of members have been highlighted and we ask the Minister of State to take this back and as a follow up Deputy Quinn suggested writing to the chief executive officers. Whatever members believe is the appropriate way to follow this through, it is clear the committee wants this issue raised.
Comment on this
What about my suggestion as well - not just writing to chief executive officers but to consider transferring temporary staff.
Comment on this
I realise the Deputy is being constructive and helpful. In the interests of the students, under the provisions of the legislation each public body is its own controller of data, so there are issues. In any event, we will look into it further.
Comment on this
If one goes to the public body there is no issue. If I go from Meath County Council to Fingal County Council for a week there is no issue.
Comment on this
There is an issue here that needs to be examined.
Comment on this
We move to amendment No. 5. If amendment No. 5 is agreed, amendments Nos. 6 and 7 cannot be moved.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 3, to delete line 31 and in page 4, to delete lines 1 to 3 and substitute the following:
""awarding authority" means-
(a vocational education committee,
(b ) a local authority, or
(c ) an appointed awarding authority;”.
This amendment provides for the amendment of the existing definition of "awarding authority" in section 2, the interpretation provision.
Comment on this
If the question on amendment No. 5 is agreed, amendments Nos. 6 and 7 cannot be moved.
Comment on this
The Deputy can discuss amendment No. 7 at this stage but he cannot formally move it.
Comment on this
I propose that we have a payments and entitlements service, not withstanding all the rules and regulations.
Comment on this
The principle is that it is a one-stop shop for everything. I think the Minister of State said that it is being considered at a higher "level", - I do not mean that rudely. The Minister takes on board the fundamental principle of citizens' entitlement available locally and universal application across all bodies, VECs, county councils, FÁS, - a one-stop shop for all one's needs locally. This would do away with a vast bureaucracy and bring the heart of government to the main street of the town. It would do away with faceless bodies and faceless bureaucrats. It would go through one's needs, educational attainments, the jobs likely to be in one's ken and the courses one could do. It would make contact with the course providers and look after children's needs in respect of third level grants, medical cards and local authority needs. One of the major frustrations for people who come to me if they are unemployed is that they have to trot around the towns of Drogheda or Dundalk to all the different agencies and experience the frustration, anger and resentment. We are wasting a good deal of resources. A much better service could be provided by adopting amendment No. 7.
Comment on this
While that amendment cannot be moved, certainly we understand the intention behind it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 4, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the following:
" "civil partner" shall be construed in accordance with section 3 of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010;".
Amendment No. 8 provides for the insertion of a new definition in section 2 as follows:
"civil partner" shall be construed in accordance with section 3 of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010.
Comment on this
On a point of clarification, should we discuss the amendments grouped with amendment No. 8 first.
Comment on this
We will discuss them seriatim when we come to them. We cannot make a decision because they are basically decided on by accepting amendment No. 8. It is about consistency in the legislation following, I suspect, the enactment of the civil partnership legislation.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 8, 57, 62, 63 and 72 are being discussed together. Does the Minister of State have anything else to say on those amendments before I move on?
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 57, 62 and 63 provide for inclusion of a reference to civil partners under the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010 in specifying criteria, including the treatment of income for determining grant eligibility.
Amendment No. 72 brings greater clarity to the requirements for the provision of evidence and information by the student to the awarding authority and the obligation on the awarding authority to notify the applicant of its decision as well as advising on the right of appeal. This amendment also provides for the inclusion of a reference to civil partners in accordance with amendment No. 8.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 11 and 69 are related to amendment No. 9 and they will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 4, to delete lines 5 to 18 and substitute the following:
" "dependent child" shall be construed in accordance with section 13(7);
"dependent student" means an applicant or class of applicant specified as a dependent student in a scheme made by the Minister under section 13;
"educational disadvantage" means the impediments to education arising from social or economic disadvantage which prevent students from deriving appropriate benefit from education;".
Amendment No. 9 provides greater clarity in regard to the existing definition of a dependent and states that a dependent child shall be construed in accordance with section 13(7). It also provides for the insertion of a definition of a dependent student in accordance with section 13 and the insertion of a definition of educational disadvantage as follows: "educational disadvantage" means the impediments to education arising from social or economic disadvantage which prevent students from deriving appropriate benefit from education.
Amendment No. 11 provides for the insertion of a definition of an independent student as follows: "independent student" means an applicant or class of applicant specified as an independent student in a scheme made by the Minister under section 13.
Amendment No. 69 provides additional criteria to criteria referred to in subsection (3) or (4) to determine eligibility and provides for the Minister to specify additional criteria to be considered by an awarding authority to determine eligibility and as respects different classes of grants or applicants. It also provides for a definition of a dependent child.
Comment on this
This is a very serious issue. I welcome the fact amendment No. 69 considers the employment status of applicants and states: "(i) has involuntarily been made redundant, (ii) is involuntarily unemployed, or (iii) has involuntarily had his or her working hours reduced;". There are key issues here.
All members would agree that an increasing number of people who have lost their jobs are trying to return to third level education, get into PLC colleges and so on. Many of them face grave difficulties. I am very concerned about the proposal in the four year plan announced yesterday to place a €200 levy on students attending PLC colleges. In my experience - I do not know if it is the experience of other members - many people who go to PLC colleges are level three or level four and might not have their leaving certificate. They are trying to move on and to acquire a trade or a skill or knowledge in order that they can prepare for the new economy. The people who come to see me are generally dependent on social welfare, the back to education allowance or whatever. It is increasingly difficult for them. I am deeply concerned about the charge the Government proposes to place on those students.
More students attending VECs and institutes of technology get grants than those attending the universities. More students from lower income households attend institutes of technology than universities. I do not like that bias and am concerned about it. The breakdown between universities and institutes of technology should be even.
I am concerned low incomes families and those whose educational attainment is lower than average are being squeezed. The Government is putting pressure on them; it is putting its foot in the neck of these people. The four year plan proposes to reduce grants for all students by €22 million next year and €51 million in a full year but, proportionately, the people who will suffer most are those who are least able to suffer because they have lowest income, are getting the grants and are attending colleges on which the Government is placing a barrier on entry.
How will this be done? Will the Government cut the rate of student grant support across the board or will it change income thresholds? The fact is that it is preparing to annihilate the chances of people entering education to improve themselves at a difficult time when it should be opening the doors to them. It will impact particularly on the tens of thousands of students trying to get into PLC colleges where there are not places for them. We are in a real crisis and the Government is compounding it with its policies.
Comment on this
I would like to make it very clear to the Acting Chairman that I am not straying into this House not knowing what I am talking about. The Acting Chairman might say I am straying. Amendment No. 69 deals with the category about whom the Minister of State spoke and the employment status of applicants, whether they have been involuntarily made redundant, are involuntarily unemployed or have had their working hours reduced. I am talking about people who are looking for education. I do not accept the word "straying".
Comment on this
I did not accuse the Deputy. I said I wondered if he was straying. I wished to clarify if he was speaking on amendment No. 69. That is what I said.
Comment on this
This is a democratic Parliament and I am delighted to have the opportunity to make these points and to repeat them as we go through the Bill. The message must get through to this Government that people are fed up to the teeth with what is happening. People who are unemployed and have no chance of a future come into my office and ask what they will do because they cannot go to the PLC colleges because there are no places or they cannot afford to go because they have no income.
Comment on this
I wish to clarify that the Chair was simply clarifying that the Deputy was speaking to amendment No. 69.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 69 is interesting because it is related to the area of providing grants to part-time students. It allows that to happen should it be decided in due course. The reason for a grant system is to facilitate people in difficult circumstances to proceed to higher or further education. That is the whole raison d’être for a student grant scheme.
We are living in difficult financial times. As Deputy O'Dowd said, the national recovery plan published yesterday indicates that the Government intends to save €22 million on student supports and €51 million in a full year. However, the details of that will be announced in the budget so it would be premature for me to say anything in that regard.
As I said, we face a very difficult budgetary situation and everyone knows that. I am a great believer in the PLC system of further education and the €200 charge indicated in the national recovery plan will cause difficulties for some students.
Comment on this
There are some fees in place currently for materials and so forth on some PLC courses. Hard choices had to be made and difficult decisions taken. However, I would point out that a PLC student can also apply for a student grant.
Comment on this
I accept that, but the Minister will take money off them simply to go in the door. They will not be able to. The people who are talking to me cannot do so. Where will they get the €200?
Comment on this
There has been much media speculation about what would be in the national recovery plan and what would be in the budget, and a figure of €500 was talked about at one stage.
Comment on this
That is the usual kite-flying to soften up the Opposition and then state it is not as bad as it could have been. We all are around the block a long time.
Comment on this
Deputy Quinn has been around here too long.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Dowd has to decide his approach to the national recovery plan.
Comment on this
I want to make the point that getting into education and re-training is critical. The facts show that there are nearly 200,000 who have lost their jobs and need to be upskilled and re-trained, and I cannot see this happening the way the systems are presently organised. I put it to the Minister of State that there is a need for root and branch reform of FÁS. I do not know whether or not he agrees to that.
The key point is that it is not acceptable for the Minister of State to put financial barriers in the way of people improving themselves. The Minister of State needs to fast-track getting people into those courses that upskill them. Generally, most of them would be qualified at FETAC level 3 and it is a matter of getting them up to FETAC levels 5 and 6. That is one of the key needs in the economy and that is where PLCs and FÁS can work together.
The Minister of State needs to take an entirely new look at all of this. Education and training needs to be totally re-jigged, as does what they call vocational training, which is what vocational education committees were about initially. The Minister needs to look at all of that and needs to reform it so that people have choice and get courses that they can go on.
I honestly believe that somebody at Cabinet suggested that a charge of €500 per head should be imposed on those going to colleges. That is not good enough. The Minister of State needs to re-think the €200 penalty for improving oneself that he is putting on these people because they are a special category. Many of them have lost their jobs and they would only have the equivalent of the junior certificate. They might have been working in child care or in a hair dressing shop or wherever, and they are trying to improve themselves. It is unbelievable what the Minister of State is doing.
I would urge the Minister of State to look again at the system, to radically reform it and to open the door to these people so that we are ready for the jobs there will be in the years to come. The way we are going will not work.
There is so much money wasted in FÁS and there are so many abuses. I tabled a question to which I did not get an answer yesterday, and I am not blaming the Minister of State for this, about people who were asked to sit repeat examinations in FÁS. I believe a lesser number than were asked turned up to do them but the number of certifications issued afterwards was greater than the number who sat the repeats. That is a joke. The Government is questioning what must be done about some private service providers who are corrupting courses, with the waste of money that is involved. At the same time it is stopping those who want to do better from getting into education by putting barriers in their way, which is totally unacceptable.
The key point about education is that there is a need for radical change. The Minister of State must look at this again because it will not work as it is currently constituted. This is education for book-keepers rather than education for an economy. The proposed penalties to be imposed on low-income families are totally unacceptable.
Comment on this
I did not expect to be dealing with FÁS on the Student Support Bill.
Comment on this
I accept the context in which Deputy O'Dowd speaks. There is major reform underway. Major reform of the VECs and FÁS have been announced. A new strategy plan is to be published in the new year. There is legislation on the transfer of functions going through the Dáil.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, it is at the characteristic Marlborough Street rate of speed.
Comment on this
Whatever. There is major reform underway across the system of the provision of further education, training, etc. Even in the national recovery plan announced yesterday, there is a large section on what needs to be done on employment activation in expanding of schemes, the introduction of new schemes, etc. People should look at that in the plan announced yesterday as well.
We have our national skills strategy. We know what we need from our education and training systems between now and 2020 and all our efforts are going into trying to achieve those targets. There is reform taking place.
Deputy O'Dowd's main point is on the PLC charge of €200 announced yesterday. I repeat that difficult choices had to be made and PLC students can apply for a student grant.
Comment on this
When one does a FÁS course, one is not charged to attend. If I want to do a six-month or annual course in FÁS, that is free to me, and that is the way it should be. Many of the PLC courses are FÁS-type courses. They are FETAC level 5 and level 6 courses. They have the same type of target, in that the student gets a new qualification that enables him or her to get employment. That is where the Government is making the error in its thinking.
The same applies to a FÁS course. It is education to work and it is specially geared towards a particular type of employment, such as child care and hair dressing. I would ask the Minister of State to look again at it. He cannot say to me that a person can do a FÁS course for six months or a year where there will be no charge but if the person goes into the VEC college there will be a charge, and yet both give an opportunity to upskill, get education and get a job. That is at the heart of the mistake. I thank the Acting Chairman for providing such latitude.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 4, between lines 21 and 22, to insert the following:
" "enactment" has the meaning given to it by section 2 of the Interpretation Act 2005;".
Amendment No. 10 provides for a definition of the additional term "enactment" to be inserted in section 2, interpretation. It is a technical amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 4, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
" "independent student" means an applicant or class of applicant specified as an independent student in a scheme made by the Minister under section 13;”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 4, between lines 26 and 27, to insert the following:
" "local authority" means a county council or city council within the meaning of the Local Government Act 2001;".
Amendment No. 12 provides for a definition for the additional term "local authority" to be inserted in section 2, interpretation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 4, to delete line 27 and substitute the following:
" "Minister" means the Minister for Education and Skills;".
Amendment No. 13 provides for the amendment in section 2, interpretation, of the title for the Minister from Minister for Education and Science to Minister for Education and Skills. It is a technical amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 4, line 28, after "includes a" to insert "foster parent or".
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept this amendment as the inclusion of a foster parent would mean that the income of this parent would be taken into consideration for reckonable income purposes when determining eligibility for a student grant.
Fostering arrangements are generally of a short-term duration. Therefore the inclusion of the income of a foster parent would be unfair. If a student failed to get a grant based on the income of the foster parent with whom he or she was residing at the time, the implication is that the foster parent would be supporting the student throughout his or her third level course, which is unlikely to be the case.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 4, after line 47, to insert the following:
"relevant Minister" shall be construed in accordance with section 10(8);”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 5, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the following:
" "transferring awarding authority" shall be construed in accordance with section 10(1);”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
3.—The expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act shall, to such extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas.".
This amendment, which relates to expenses, does not alter the meaning of the provision, as originally published. The new wording is a standard and more concise form which brings greater clarity to the meaning.
Comment on this
I presume that this came about on foot of a change suggested by the Parliamentary Counsel.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 5, subsection (1), line 17, to delete "from time to time" and substitute the following:
"on a specified day, on an annual or quarterly basis,".
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept this amendment. While I appreciate the Deputy's intention, the amendment will not be necessary because amendment No. 54 in the name of the Tánaiste provides for a new section to be inserted before section 13 to deal with advances to awarding authorities. Specifically, amendment No. 54 provides that the relevant Minister may, in each financial year, advance to an awarding authority such funds as are required for grant purposes. I am of the view that this deals substantially with the issue to which amendment No. 18 relates. It is envisaged that issues such as specified days for the advancement of moneys would be dealt with as part of a service level agreement between the Minister and the relevant awarding authority.
Comment on this
I presume the section is being deleted on foot of the new section being inserted later in the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 5, before section 6, to insert the following new section:
6.—Every order, regulation or scheme under this Act (other than an order under section 1(2) or 22(1)) shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made and, if a resolution annulling the order, regulation or scheme is passed by either such House within the next 21 days on which that House has sat after the order, regulation or scheme is laid before it, the order, regulation or scheme shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder.".
The provision in the Bill, as originally published, is being replaced with a more standard form of wording, which is simpler and which makes the meaning of the provision clearer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 5, subsection (2), lines 43 and 44, to delete "commencement" and substitute "coming into operation".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 6, subsection (3), line 11, to delete "commencement" and substitute "coming into operation".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 6, subsection (1)(e), lines 28 and 29, to delete all words from and including “and” in line 28 down to and including “funds,” in line 29 and substitute the following:
"which is maintained or assisted by recurrent grants from public funds of that or any other Member State including the State,".
This is a technical amendment which changes the original form of wording to a more standard drafting construction. Effectively, the phrase "financed essentially" is being replaced with a broader definition which encompasses public funds from "any other Member State including the State. The wording of the provision is being restructured in order to accommodate this change.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 23 is out of order as it has the potential to impose a charge on the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I am prevented from moving this amendment because Opposition Deputies cannot introduce measures which would, de facto, impose an additional charge on the Exchequer. However, perhaps the Minister of State will address the principle of the matter. There is a discrimination between colleges which are run on a profit or not-for-profit basis but which do not come under the remit of the State. I understand this matter was the subject of a legal case, which was settled and which never went to court.
Comment on this
Is the Minister of State in a position to indicate the amount of the settlement involved? I appreciate that he may not have the relevant information in his possession. My net point is that we have a mixed, open society in which certain providers of education operate for profit and seek to establish ideological or spiritual domination or indoctrinate people. Their motives vary and there seems to be a formal divide between those who operate on a profit or not-for-profit basis. In addition, there is no distinction in respect of those whose motives may very well be otherwise. I am of the view that the distinction to which I refer has been drawn in this instance.
I draw the Minister of State's attention to the fact that Hibernia College produces more primary school teachers than any other institution. These teachers are then employed by the Department of Education and Skills. If a student wishes to attend a college which is providing an educational course he or she can access - in respect of which he or she is qualified and which meets his or her vocational and career needs - but does not have the financial means necessary to allow this to happen, I am of the view that he or she is being discriminated against. If the college in question has accepted the individual on the basis that he or she is a worthy student, if a scholarship is available to him or her - as is the case in some colleges and as is certainly the case in colleges in the United States - and if the college wants him or her take up his or her place, I do not believe the Republic of Ireland should discriminate against such a student because he or she cannot afford pay to take up his or her place on the relevant course. The State should not discriminate between students who apply to particular colleges and those who apply to colleges in the public domain which offer similar or dissimilar courses.
I do not know if the Minister of State has any briefing material in respect of this matter. I accept that we are on Committee Stage and I do not want to prolong our deliberations. However, if the Minister of State is in possession of such material, I would be interested in hearing its contents. If he does not have the relevant information, we can return to the matter on another occasion.
Comment on this
The institutions being recognised under the Bill are generally publicly-funded third level colleges which offer full-time courses at undergraduate and postgraduate levels. The Department of Education and Skills provides significant funding to these institutions. This funding is used to provide the very broad range of courses required by society and not just those designed to meet the economic needs of the country. The institutions in question operate for the greater good of the country and act in the best interests of the development of human capital in the State.
The Bill does not forever preclude the colleges to which the Deputy refers from inclusion. Those institutions can be facilitated. However, our current financial situation must be taken into account. That is probably the major consideration in this regard. Hibernia College has not applied for inclusion under the schemes.
Comment on this
That is because it offers a postgraduate course and would probably not qualify, even if it did apply. I cannot see the logic behind what the Minister of State is suggesting. In some instances, students may have applied for courses in the publicly-funded institutions and may not have been accepted because they did not attain a sufficient number of points. Not all of these institutions have objective agendas. One could argue that the four teaching colleges which train primary school teachers have an explicit agenda which is to inculcate a particular set of values and views, including those relating to faith formation within school hours. One could also argue that in a republic such as ours, such an agenda is open to question and there are different views in that regard.
However, the Minister of State is including within the category of schools and colleges that qualify for inclusion in the scheme those that have a specific agenda in teaching a particular set of values. He is including certain colleges that have a particular agenda, that is, making money out of giving skills to students. I do not see that this logic has been followed through. I will not pursue this because I know what will be the outcome but, down the road, a constitutional challenge could be successfully mounted against such discrimination. A case could be argued and if we move towards a republic in reality as distinct from name, such issues will be on the agenda of whoever is in the Department, either as an official or as a politician, and this will need to be addressed.
Comment on this
I accept the Deputy's motive for what he has said but the Department has no say in the operation of private colleges. They are for profit, commercial colleges. They may not meet State objectives. I do not say they do not but we are not involved. The primary consideration is the cost. We would also have to pay tuition fees and the student service charge and we are not in a position to meet those costs.
Comment on this
I will not make a meal out of this. Is it correct that FETAC or HETAC accredit the courses they provide?
Comment on this
Then the Department is involved indirectly, if not directly. Let us be real about this. The colleges are providing certified courses.
Comment on this
Yes, but we are not involved on a financial basis. There is some involvement.
Comment on this
The Department is ultimately responsible for HETAC and FETAC and for quality and, therefore, there is a connection. We do not know on what basis the Department settled the legal case but I suspect it paid the person a great deal of money to go away and, by doing so, it conceded that he or she had won the argument on principle. It was a vista too large to behold and the Department walked away from it but his will not go away indefinitely. Other students will appeal and the Department will have to bite the bullet on this at some stage. This is about pluralism in our education system.
The Bill is about enabling students whose income status is such that they cannot pursue a course in third level education, irrespective of the nature or the motivation of the education provider. A judgment in a constitutional case could say it is wrong for the State to fund colleges that teach, for example, that civil unions and homosexual marriage or gay and lesbian behaviour are unnatural and should be frowned upon. If the Department funds a college that holds those beliefs and inculcates them in people who become teachers and gives public funds to them on the one hand but refuses students a grant to go to a college that is motivated by profit, it faces a conflict in terms of the constitutional provisions of this Republic. It may not be for the Minister of State, myself or other members but, down the road, this argument will have to be confronted and it will go all the way to the European Court of Human Rights. An official should examine the terms and conditions on which the agreement was made privately to pay that student to go away and not go to the courts. The issue has not gone away and it will return.