Student Support Bill 2008: Committee Stage
Contributions 174–341 of 341. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 2008 ›
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 6, subsection (3), lines 41 to 43, to delete paragraph (a) and substitute the following:
"(a) whether the institution receives one or more than one payment out of moneys made available by the Oireachtas and the amount of the payment;”.
This is a technical amendment, which changes the wording of a more standard drafting construction and it eliminates any confusion that might arise if the word "grant" is used in the provision instead of the word "payment". The significant of this is that "grant" is defined in section 2 as a student grant. This is not to be confused with grants or payments as they are now described from the State to the institutions.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 28, 29 and 31 are related to amendment No. 27 and all may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 7, subsection (1), line 35, to delete paragraph (b).
My amendment is technically out of order because it implies a charge but I suspect the thrust of the Minister of State's amendment attempts to meet the same aspirations. Is that correct?
Comment on this
In that case, I will withdraw my amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 7, subsection (1), line 35, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:
"(b) requires full attendance by a student in a—
(i) full-time course, or
(ii) should circumstances allow and with the consent of the Minister of Finance, part-time course,
and".
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept the amendment on the basis that it will not be necessary because amendment No. 31 provides for a new subsection to be inserted in the section, which gives the Minister the power to prescribe a part-time course as an approved course in certain circumstances. This is an enabling provision, which will be activated when resources allow and, as proposed by the Deputy, which will also require consent from the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
If the courses are provided, the enabling provision will be in place and it will have to be brought into effect.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 7, subsection (1)(b), line 35, before “requires” to insert “subject to subsection (3),”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:
In page 7, subsection (2)(b), line 43, to delete “commencement” and substitute “coming into operation”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In page 8, between lines 46 and 47, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) (a) Notwithstanding subsection (1)(b), the Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, may prescribe a course that does not require attendance by a student on a full-time basis to be an approved course.
(b) A course prescribed pursuant to this subsection shall be a course that—
(i) is provided in the State, and
(ii) is an undergraduate course.
(c) The Minister, in prescribing a course pursuant to paragraph (a), shall have regard to the following matters:
(i) the matters referred to in subsection (2) (other than paragraph (k)(ii) of that subsection);
(ii) the extent to which the prescribing of the course would assist in addressing educational disadvantage;
(iii) the extent to which the prescribing of the course would assist and encourage participation by persons from sections of society significantly under-represented in the student body availing of higher education;
(iv) the number of modules that may be completed and the extent of educational attainment in each academic year of the course;
(v) the amount of work and contact with teachers and tutors in relation to the course required of a student;
(vi) the period of time required to complete the course when compared to a course that requires attendance by a student on a full-time basis;
(vii) whether the course takes place on the premises of the approved institution;
(viii) any other matters which in the opinion of the Minister are proper matters to be taken into account having regard to available resources and the need to promote access to higher education by persons who suffer educational disadvantage.".
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 33 and 35 are related to amendment No. 32 and all may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 8, lines 47 to 49, to delete subsection (3) and substitute the following:
"(3) For the purposes of this Act, and subject to subsection (4), any postgraduate course that may be prescribed pursuant to subsection (1) shall only be a postgraduate course that is provided in the State.”.
These are all drafting amendments. The intended provisions are not changed in any way.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
In page 9, lines 1 to 5, to delete subsection (4) and substitute the following:
"(4) Notwithstanding subsection (3), where the Minister is satisfied to do so because he or she considers that it is necessary having regard to any of the relevant purposes mentioned in subsection (8), he or she may prescribe a postgraduate course that is provided in Northern Ireland as an approved course.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:
In page 9, subsection (6)(a), line 15, to delete “immediately” and substitute the following:
"following a notice period of not less than 30 days".
Comment on this
The amendment will not be necessary, as the provision causing concern for the Deputy - immediate withdrawal of the grant - is moderated considerably by section 9(7), which provides that nothing in section 9(6) shall prevent a student from continuing to receive the grant until he or she has completed the relevant course.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 9, subsection (8), line 27, to delete "shall have regard when prescribing postgraduate courses" and substitute the following:
"shall have regard when prescribing any postgraduate course".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
In page 9, before section 10, to insert the following new section:
10.—(1) The Minister may—
(a) having taken account of the matters referred to in subsection (4),
(b) having consulted with the relevant Minister, and
(c) with the consent of the Minister for Finance,
by order appoint a body (in this section referred to as an "appointed awarding authority") to perform any or all of the functions of an awarding authority (in this section referred to as a "transferring awarding authority").
(2) Notwithstanding the generality of subsection (1), an order of the Minister under that subsection may provide for one or more than one of the following:
(a) different appointed awarding authorities to perform different functions;
(b) different transferring awarding authorities for the purposes of transferring those different functions;
(c) the coming into operation on different days for different purposes or different provisions.
(3) An appointed awarding authority may be one or more than one of the following:
(a) a vocational education committee;
(b) a local authority;
(c) a board, authority or other body established by or under an enactment (other than the Companies Acts) whose functions include the support of, or the promotion of participation in, higher or further education or the administration of schemes of payments;
(d) a company under the Companies Acts, in which all the shares are held by or on behalf of or jointly with—
(i) the Minister or a relevant Minister, or
(ii) directors appointed by the Minister or a relevant Minister, or
(iii) a board, authority or other body referred to in paragraph (c), and whose functions are conferred by or under an enactment and include the support of, or the promotion of participation in, higher or further education, or the administration of schemes of payments.
(4) Before making an order under subsection (1), the Minister, taking account of the need for efficiency, effectiveness and economy, shall have regard to following matters:
(a) capacity of and resources available to awarding authorities for the purposes of performing functions conferred on them by or under this Act;
(b) the resources available for provision of student support;
(c) administration costs;
(d) the desirability of uniformity of standards;
(e) where applicable, any report furnished to the Minister under section 10(5).
(5) Where a function of a transferring awarding authority is transferred pursuant to an order under subsection (1), the function shall no longer be under the direction, control or supervision of that transferring authority after the order is made.
(6) Nothing in subsection (5) shall prevent the Minister from directing by order under subsection (1) that a transferring awarding authority shall do one or both of the following after the order is made:
(a) perform a function referred to in section 11(2)* and contained in the order;
(b) continue to pay grants, specified by the Minister in the order, to students or a class of students so specified and for a period so specified.
(7) An appointed awarding authority and a transferring awarding authority shall be such appointed awarding authority and transferring awarding authority for the purposes of each order made under subsection (1) and nothing in this section shall prevent—
(a) a transferring awarding authority in an order made under subsection (1) from being an appointed awarding authority in any subsequent order made under that subsection, or
(b) an appointed awarding authority in an order made under subsection (1) from being a transferring awarding authority in any subsequent order made under that subsection.
(8) In this section "relevant Minister" means—
(a) in the case of an appointed awarding authority that is a local authority, the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, and
(b) in the case of any other appointed awarding authority, each Minister of the Government who performs functions in relation to that body.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 9, before section 10, to insert the following new section:
11.—(1) An order under section 10(1) may provide for—
(a) such matters as appear to the Minister to be necessary or expedient for the transfer of functions from the transferring awarding authority to the appointed awarding authority, and
(b) such other matters as may be incidental to or consequential on such transfer.
(2) Notwithstanding the generality of subsection (1) an order under section 10(1) may provide for one or more than one of the following:
(a) a direction to the transferring awarding authority to provide to the appointed awarding authority such records, data or information as relate to a function referred to in the order, or a class of such records, data or information, and within such period, as is specified in the direction;
(b) in relation to land and property—
(i) that such land (or a part thereof) as relates to a function referred to in the order which, immediately before the order is made was vested in the transferring awarding authority and all rights, powers and privileges relating to or connected with that land shall without conveyance, transfer or assignment stand vested in the appointed awarding authority for all the estate and interest for which it was vested in the transferring awarding authority but subject to all trusts and equities affecting that land subsisting and capable of being performed,
(ii) that some or all of such property other than land (including choses-inaction), as relates to a function referred to in the order which, immediately before the order is made, was the property of the transferring awarding authority shall, without any transfer or assignment, stand transferred to the appointed awarding authority,
(iii) that a chose-in-action referred to in subparagraph (ii) may after the order is made, be sued on, recovered or enforced by the appointed awarding authority in its own name and it shall not be necessary for the appointed awarding authority to give notice to the person bound by any such chose-in-action of the transfer effected by the order, or
(iv) that moneys, stocks, shares or securities referred to in subparagraph (ii) and which, immediately before the order is made are in the name of the transferring awarding authority shall be transferred, at the request of the appointed awarding authority, to the name of the appointed awarding authority;
(c) that some or all of such of the rights or liabilities as relate to the function referred to in the order may, on or after the date of the order, be sued on, recovered or enforced by or against the appointed awarding authority without the necessity for the appointed awarding authority to give notice of the order to the person whose right or liability is transferred;
(d) in relation to some or all of such contracts or agreements as relate to a function referred to in the order—
(i) the continuance in force of the contract or agreement made between the transferring awarding authority or any trustee or agent of the authority acting on its behalf, and any other person which is in force immediately before the day of the making of the order, or
(ii) the construction of the contract or agreement as if the appointed awarding authority were substituted therein for the transferring awarding authority without the necessity for the appointed awarding authority to give notice of the order to the person whose right or liability is transferred;
(e) the continuance of some or all of such legal proceedings as relate to a function referred to in the order and pending in a court or tribunal before the making of the order to which the transferring awarding authority is a party, by the substitution of the name of the appointed awarding authority for the name of the transferring awarding authority and that the proceedings shall not abate by reason of such substitution;
(f) the preparation by the transferring awarding authority of such final accounts of that authority as relate to a function referred to in the order within a specified period and submission of same to such persons as may be specified in the order including the Minister, the Minister for Finance, the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, a relevant Minister, the Comptroller and Auditor General or the appointed awarding authority;
(g) subject to section 12—
(i) the transfer of an employee who, immediately before the making of the order is an employee of the transferring awarding authority performing duties related to a function referred to in the order, to the appointed awarding authority;
(ii) the transfer of the contract of employment of a person who, immediately before the making of the order is a fixed-term employee of the transferring awarding authority performing duties related to a function referred to in the order, to the appointed awarding authority.
(3) In this section "fixed-term employee" has the meaning given to it by the Protection of Employees (Fixed-Term Work) Act 2003.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
In page 9, before section 10, to insert the following new section:
12.—(1) Save in accordance with a collective agreement negotiated with any recognised trade union or staff association concerned, a person referred to in section 11(2)(g) shall not, on the making of an order under section 10(1), be brought to less beneficial conditions of remuneration than the conditions of remuneration to which he or she was subject immediately before the coming into operation of this section.
(2) The previous service of a person referred to in section 11(2)(g) shall be reckonable for the purposes of, but subject to any exceptions or exclusions in the following enactments:
(a) the Redundancy Payments Acts 1967 to 2007;
(b) the Protection of Employees (Part-Time Work) Act 2001;
(c) the Protection of Employees (Fixed-Term Work) Act 2003;
(d) the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997;
(e) the Terms of Employment (Information) Acts 1994 and 2001;
(f) the Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Acts 1973 to 2005;
(g) the Unfair Dismissals Acts 1977 to 2007;
(h) the Maternity Protection Acts 1994 and 2004;
(i) the Parental Leave Acts 1998 and 2006;
(j) the Adoptive Leave Acts 1995 and 2005;
(k) the Carer’s Leave Act 2001.
(3) Any superannuation benefits awarded to or in respect of a person referred to in section 11(2)(g) and the terms relating to those benefits shall be no less favourable than those applicable to or in respect of that person immediately before the making of an order under section 10(1).
(4) The pension payments and other superannuation liabilities of the transferring awarding authority in relation to a person referred to in section 11(2)(g) who is given a position in the appointed awarding authority under an order under section 10(1) become, on the making of the order, the liabilities of the appointed awarding authority.
(5) In this section "recognised trade union or staff association" means a trade union or staff association recognised by the Minister for the purposes of negotiations which are concerned with the remuneration or conditions of employment, or the working conditions of employees.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38a:
In page 10, subsection (1)(e), line 5, to delete “section 19(10)” and substitute “section 19(4)”.
These are technical amendments. This group of amendments provides for the correction of cross-referencing in the published Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 10, lines 10 to 12, to delete subsection (2).
Amendment No. 39 provides for the deletion of subsection (2) which provides for the outsourcing of work by a grant awarding authority. It is proposed to delete the subsection on the basis that the issue is now provided for more comprehensively in a new section to be inserted entitled, "Agreements relating to performance of certain functions", provided for in amendment No. 40. The purpose of the proposed new section is to provide, where necessary, for the outsourcing by an awarding authority of functions in relation to the administration of student grants. This would be done by way of an agreement which would specify terms and conditions and be subject to the superintendence and control of the awarding authority.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 40 has already been discussed with amendment No. 39. I advise members that acceptance of the amendment involves the deletion of section 11 of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:
In page 10, before section 11, to insert the following new section:
11.—(1) Subject to subsection (7), an awarding authority may by an agreement in writing entered into with any person, upon such terms and conditions as may be specified in the agreement, provide for the performance by such person, subject to such terms and conditions (if any) as may be so specified, of such functions conferred on the awarding authority by or under this Act as may be so specified.
(2) An agreement under this section may include provision for the payments (if any) to be made to and the disposal of such payments by the person concerned for the purpose of the performance of a function specified in the agreement.
(3) An agreement under this section shall operate, so long as it continues in force, to confer on and vest in the person concerned, to the extent and subject to the terms and conditions specified in the agreement, the function so specified.
(4) A function conferred on a person by an agreement under this section shall be performable by the person in his or her own name but subject to the general superintendence and control of the awarding authority.
(5) A function conferred on a person by an agreement under this section shall, notwithstanding the agreement concerned, continue to be vested in the awarding authority but shall be so vested concurrently with the person on whom it is conferred by that agreement and so as to be capable of being performed by either of those persons.
(6) The conferral on a person by an agreement under this section of a function of the awarding authority shall not remove or derogate from the authority's responsibility to the Minister for the performance of the function.
(7) Before entering an agreement under subsection (1) an awarding authority shall, in relation to the agreement and any terms and conditions contained therein—
(a) consult with the relevant Minister, and
(b) obtain the prior approval of the Minister and the Minister for Finance.”.
Comment on this
I will not go further into this issue now, but I would like to put down a marker to the effect that I may come back with an amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 11, line 23, after "State," to insert the following:
"and has been previously so ordinarily resident for such period if any as may be prescribed,".
The intention of this amendment is to allow the detail regarding ordinary residence for three of the five previous years to be specified in regulations rather than in the Bill. If the amendment was accepted, some of the detail in the section could be deleted. The test, if it did not apply inflexibly, could cause hardship, for example, for an Irish family which moves out of Ireland for the four years immediately prior to the student going to college. I am interested to hear what the Minister and his colleague have to say on the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept the amendment as the period of residency introduced under the student grants scheme for the 2010-11 academic year is set out definitively in subsections (4)(a) and (b) of section 12. The residency requirement - three of the past five years in the State - must be met by the student himself or herself.
Comment on this
I may come back to this issue on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 42 is in the name of Deputy Quinn. If it is agreed to, amendments Nos. 43 to 50, inclusive, cannot be moved. Amendments Nos. 43 to 50 are related and alternatives to amendment No. 42. Amendments Nos. 51 to 53, inclusive, are also related. Therefore, amendments Nos. 42 to 53, inclusive, will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:
In page 11, lines 24 to 49, to delete all words from and including "and" in line 24 down to including "who—", in line 49, to delete page 12, and in page 13 to delete lines 1 to 8 and substitute the following:
"and is an Irish citizen, a non-national who is lawfully present in the State and is likely to remain lawfully in the State for the duration of the course in question, or such other person as may be prescribed by the Minister.".
The purpose of the amendment is to give a right to apply for a grant to anyone lawfully resident in the State. The Bill, as drafted, leaves the right to apply of non-EU nationals largely up to the Minister to prescribe. This provides for too much discretion.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept the amendment as the advice received is that it is necessary, for the avoidance of doubt, to include detailed provisions with regard to the definition of "student", the prescribing of a person or class of person as a family member and the prescribing of a class of persons with permission to reside within the State. I am advised that detailed provisions on these matters are necessary to ensure the Minister will have adequate guidance from the Oireachtas on these issues.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
In page 11, subsection (1)(c)(i), lines 36 and 37, to delete ““Justice, Equality and Law Reform” and substitute “Justice and Law Reform”.
This is a technical amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 44:
In page 11, subsection (1)(c)(ii), lines 40 and 41, to delete “Justice, Equality and Law Reform” and substitute “Justice and Law Reform”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In page 11, subsection (1), lines 44 to 47, to delete paragraph (d) and substitute the following:
"(d) a person who, in relation to a person referred to in paragraph (a), is a family member prescribed, subject to subsection (2) for the purposes of this paragraph, or”.
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In page 11, subsection (1), to delete lines 48 to 49 and substitute the following:
"(e) a person, other than a person to whom paragraph (a), (b), (c) or (d)* refers, who—”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
In page 12, subsection (1)(e), lines 5 to 7, to delete subparagraph (ii), and substitute the following:
"(ii) is of a class of persons prescribed by the Minister, subject to subsection (3) and with the consent of the Minister for Finance, for the purposes of this subparagraph.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:
In page 12, lines 8 to 23, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following:
"(2) Where the Minister is prescribing a class of persons as a family member for the purposes of subsection (1)(d)*, he or she shall have regard to all or any of the following matters:
(a) the relationship that the family member has to the person referred to in subsection (1)(a);
(b) whether the family member depends on the person referred to in subsection (1)(a);
(c) whether the family member has a right of residence in the State by virtue of being the spouse, civil partner or a child of a person referred to in subsection (1)(a).”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:
In page 12, subsection (3), to delete lines 24 to 26, and substitute the following:
"(3) Where the Minister is prescribing a class of persons for the purposes of subsection (1)(e)(ii)* he or she shall have regard to all or any of the following matters:”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:
In page 13, subsection (3), lines 3 to 8, to delete paragraphs (g) and (h) and substitute the following:
"(g) resources available for the provision of student support.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51:
In page 13, lines 9 to 19, to delete subsection (4) and substitute the following:
"(4) For the purposes of subsection (1), a person shall be ordinarily resident in the State if the person—
(a) has been resident in the State for at least 3 years out of the period of 5 years ending on the day before the relevant date, or
(b) if not resident as described in paragraph (a)—
(i) is temporarily resident outside of the State by reason of pursuing a course of study or post-graduate research at an educational institution outside of the State but within a Member State leading to a qualification that is recognised in accordance with the laws of the Member State concerned for the recognition of qualifications that correspond to the arrangements, procedures and systems referred to in section 9(2)(k)(i), or if such recognition is not provided by those laws in that manner then otherwise in accordance with the laws of that Member State, and
(ii) was resident in the State for at least 3 years out of the period of 5 years ending on the day before he or she commenced such course of study or post-graduate research.".
The amendment at subsection (4)(b)(i) is necessary to ensure the course of study or research being undertaken by the student in another member state is properly recognised and leads to a proper qualification.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 52:
In page 13, subsection (6), to delete lines 25 to 27, and substitute the following:
"(6) The determination of the question referred to in subsection (5) shall not relate to a person who is either—
(a) an Irish citizen, or”.
This is a technical amendment which provides for a new paragraph (b) to be inserted and ensures our obligations under EU law are met.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 53:
In page 13, lines 43 to 49, to delete subsections (8) and (9) and substitute the following:
"(8) For the purposes of subsection (7), a tuition student shall be ordinarily resident in one of the states referred to in subsection (1)(a) if the student was resident in any of the states for a period of not less than 3 years out of the period of 5 years ending on the day before the relevant date.
(9) In this section, in relation to an approved course in respect of which a person referred to in subsection (4) or a tuition student may apply for a grant, “relevant date” means the date on which a year of study commences on the approved course.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:
In page 14, before section 13, but in Part 2, to insert the following new section:
13.—(1) The Minister may, subject to such conditions as he or she considers appropriate, in each financial year advance to an awarding authority such sum as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas and which is not greater than the sum required for the purpose of defraying expenditure incurred by the awarding authority in the payment of a grant.
(2) The Minister may, subject to such conditions as he or she considers appropriate, in each financial year advance to an awarding authority, where the awarding authority is a vocational education committee, such sum as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas and which is not greater than the sum required for the purpose of defraying expenditure incurred by the awarding authority in the performance of any of its functions (other than the payment of a grant).
(3) The Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government may, subject to such conditions as he or she considers appropriate, in each financial year advance to an awarding authority, where the awarding authority is a local authority, such sum as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas and which is not greater than the sum required for the purpose of defraying expenditure incurred by the awarding authority in the performance of any of its functions (other than the payment of a grant).
(4) The relevant Minister may, subject to such conditions as he or she considers appropriate, in each financial year advance to an awarding authority, where the awarding authority is an appointed awarding authority, such sum as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas and which is not greater than the sum required for the purpose of defraying expenditure incurred by the awarding authority in the performance of any of its functions (other than the payment of a grant).".
This amendment provides for the insertion of a new section entitled, "Advances to awarding authorities". The new section replaces the existing section 4(1), "Grants to awarding authorities". Section 4(1) deals with funding for grant awarding authorities to carry out their functions. It is proposed to delete this subsection in its entirety and replace it with the new section. When section 4 was originally published, it was envisaged that the number of grant awarding authorities would be reduced from 66 to 33. It is now proposed to make provision for a single grant awarding authority and the existing 66 grant awarding authorities to remain operational for a limited interim period. In the circumstances, it is necessary to make proper provision in the Bill to reflect this position vis-à-vis funding arrangements. It is proposed to insert the new section before section 13, in lieu of section 4(1), to reflect the need to meet funding requirements for both the payment of grants and the administration of the system in relation to existing grant awarding authorities and the new single grant awarding authority.
Subsection (1) of this new section provides for the funding of awarding authorities for the purpose of paying grants. Subsection (2) provides for the funding of VECs for the administration of the grants function in advance of the introduction of a single awarding authority. Subsection (3) provides for the funding of local authorities for the administration of the grants function in advance of the introduction of a single awarding authority. Subsection (4) provides for the funding of the new single awarding authority for the administration of the grants function.
Comment on this
Did the Minister of State say there were 66 original awarding authorities?
Comment on this
They were VECs and local authorities.
Comment on this
Of course, yes. I thank the Minister of State.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
In page 14, subsection (1), line 4, to delete "may prescribe a scheme" and substitute "may make a scheme".
The proposed change to subsection (1) is a drafting amendment to delete "may prescribe a scheme" and substitute "may make a scheme".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56:
In page 14, subsection (2), between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following:
"(c) specify an awarding authority or classes of awarding authorities who shall perform functions conferred by or under this Act in relation to specified grants or classes of grants;”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:
In page 14, subsection (2), lines 14 to 22, to delete paragraph (d) and substitute the following:
"(d) specify criteria to be considered by an awarding authority in determining whether an applicant is eligible for a grant including the following:
(i) conditions to be complied with by an applicant, his or her parents, spouse or civil partner as the case may be, in order that the applicant may be so eligible;
(ii) the manner in which the income of an applicant, his or her parents, spouse or civil partner as the case may be, shall be determined;".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 58 is deemed out of order as it involves a potential charge on the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I realise that technically speaking it implies a charge, but I ask the Minister of State to outline his thinking or the departmental thinking on the matter. The placement students have particular costs which are not adequately met, for example training teachers, nurses and radiographers. Does the Department recognise in principle that some courses have by virtue of their requirements additional equipment costs or placement costs of one kind of another? If a student qualifies for a student grant in the first instance on the basis of household income and means assessment, the additional costs associated with participation in that course should be recognised. There should be some discretion to the Minister or the awarding authority to provide funding for those costs. That is the thrust of the amendment, which I accept is technically out of order because it would imply an additional cost on the Exchequer, but the Minister of State or his Department may have a view on it.
Comment on this
Under the current schemes we meet additional costs, including, for example, field trips. The Deputy may not be aware that some work placements are paid and this may involve taking into consideration the pay received by a student on a work placement when calculating his or her grant.
Comment on this
I will move the amendment, and I may come back on Report Stage.
Comment on this
It cannot be moved, but it is noted that the Deputy might come back on Report Stage. That is fine.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:
In page 14, subsection (2), between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
"(f) specify conditions the continued compliance with which is required in order that an applicant shall remain eligible to receive a grant awarded to him or her;”.
The insertion of subsection (2)(f) provides for the specification of conditions that must continue to be met by a student to remain eligible for a grant.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59a:
In page 14, subsection (2), lines 30 to 32, to delete paragraph (h) and substitute the following:
"(h) provide for the manner in which an application for a grant is to be made and the information to be furnished by an applicant in relation thereto.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:
In page 14, subsection (3), line 34, to delete "in prescribing a class" and substitute "in specifying a class".
Amendments Nos. 60 and 74 are drafting amendments for the purpose of clarity.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 61:
In page 14, subsection (3), between lines 39 and 40, to insert the following:
"(c) whether he or she has dependents who he or she is required to support;”.
This amendment originated with discussions I had with the Union of Students in Ireland. The emphasis in the Bill is on whether the student has family members who could support him or her. The students seek clearer references to whether a student has dependants that he or she needs to support given the changing nature of society and the different participation levels in education. It is not just the child of parents who may be the student; it could be the reverse. The amendment would give legislative clarity to this fairly rare but nevertheless possible event. I understand that there are a few cases where this has arisen and the primary legislation should be clear.
Comment on this
I can allay the Deputy's concerns. I do not propose to accept the Deputy's amendment on the basis that it proposes to provide for a situation already covered under the preceding section 13(3)(b), which already lists family or personal circumstances as a matter to be considered in determining whether an applicant is a student of a particular class.
Comment on this
Does the reference to his or her family or personal circumstances cover the concerns?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In page 15, subsection (4)(a)(iii), line 23, to delete “her spouse,” and substitute “her spouse or civil partner,”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:
In page 15, subsection (4)(a)(iv), line 27, to delete “her parents or spouse,” and substitute “her parents, spouse or civil partner,”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:
In page 15, subsection (4)(a), between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:
"(vi) where the parents of a dependent student or other dependent children reside in separate households, the manner in which and purposes for which account shall be taken of arrangements in place relating to the dependent student or other dependent children;".
The purpose of this amendment is to accommodate dependent students whose parents may be separated or living apart. The amendment enables account to be taken of such situations in assessing the means of a student.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 16, subsection (4), lines 1 to 3, to delete paragraph (b).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In page 16, subsection (4), lines 5 to 9, to delete paragraph (d).
Subsection(4)(d) regarding the prior holding of a grant is no longer considered to be necessary. I do not propose to accept amendment No. 68 as amendment No. 67 provides for a reworded section 13(4)(e) which essentially has the same intent as the original text. This is to provide for a criterion that may be specified by the Minister to be considered by an awarding authority in determining grant eligibility. In other words the provision simply provides guidance on the issues that may be taken into account in drawing up a scheme of accounts. The detail of the treatment of other awards or funding will be dealt with in the scheme itself.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 67:
In page 16, subsection (4), lines 10 to 13, to delete paragraph (e) and substitute the following:
"(e) whether the applicant is already in receipt of or likely to receive funding, an award or stipend, for the purposes of assisting him or her in pursuing his or her education;”.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 68 was discussed with amendment No. 66, but I will let the Deputy comment on it when I come to amendment No. 68. For the moment I would like to get agreement on amendment No. 67 and the Deputy can then comment on amendment No. 68 if he wishes.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Mahony would like to speak on amendment No. 68 and while he cannot move it, he may speak on it.
Comment on this
I just wanted to make a point about high achieving students. We should not punish those who are awarded scholarships on the basis of high achievement by disallowing their grants. We should not punish them for being high achievers.
Comment on this
We allow for some awards to be recognised. The Government of Ireland scholarship is recognised. It is a postgraduate scholarship.
Comment on this
A postgraduate scholarship is of no use to students doing undergraduate degrees. Lottery winnings are exempt from tax. The same thing should apply to scholarship moneys. The purpose of this trust is to distinguish between earnings and rewards for excellence in fields of scholarship. Why would one work one's backside off to get good marks and a scholarship if one knows one's personal income circumstances mean one will be disqualified from adding this to one's grant?
Comment on this
We allow for awards from institutions-----
Comment on this
I refer to all sorts of awards, at every level, made by institutions.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is proposing that the awarding authority be allowed to take into consideration "whether the applicant is already in receipt of or likely to receive funding, an award or stipend, [other than the grant] for the purposes of assisting him or her in pursuing his or her education". If the authority can take that into account, it can decide to subtract it from the value of the grant. That is why I suggest the Minister of State's amendment has the potential to introduce a disincentive.
Comment on this
Some awards from external authorities can be quite high. We do not have to take them into account. This legislation will enable us to do so.
Comment on this
Some awards are less than the grants provided under the system. To take account of such awards when making decisions on grants would be to penalise students for high achievement.
Comment on this
The officials from the Department will be aware that a recent RTE television programme focused on students who are brilliant to the point where they get bullied. We often focus on disadvantaged students, including those with learning difficulties, but we pay little or no attention to the nerd factor. Some children hide their natural ability because they are concerned about being hassled. If we want to recognise such people, we need to provide for something more explicit than simply saying awards can be taken into consideration. Decisions on whether to participate in college are often driven purely by money. One might be concerned that one's household income, one's parents' income or one's own income would cause one to be prohibited from getting a grant. There is a principle at stake. If we want to ensure we do not discriminate against excellence and genius, this provision should not be made. I invite the Minister of State to introduce an amendment to it on Report Stage. The amendment that has been made does not look at the other end of the spectrum. We need brilliant students, with all their idiosyncrasies, to come through the system just as much as we need to facilitate children with special needs.
Comment on this
We need flexibility within the scheme. As I have said, the Bill provides that these matters "may" be taken into account. I will look into it further in advance of Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 68 cannot be moved today. The matter can be discussed on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:
In page 16, lines 42 to 45, to delete subsection (5) and substitute the following:
"(5) The Minister may specify, in the scheme concerned, criteria additional to criteria referred to in subsection (3) or (4) to be considered by an awarding authority in order that it may determine whether an applicant is eligible for a grant to attend an approved course prescribed under section 9(3)*, and the criteria may include all or any of the following:
(a) the employment status of the applicant, including the level of his or her remuneration or that he or she—
(i) has involuntarily been made redundant,
(ii) is involuntarily unemployed, or
(iii) has involuntarily had his or her working hours reduced;
(b) the inability of the applicant to attend higher education on a full-time basis by virtue of being wholly or mainly responsible for the care of a person requiring full-time care and attention;
(c) that the applicant suffers from a disability (within the meaning of the Disability Act 2005) and by reason of the disability is unable to attend higher education on a full-time basis;
(d) that the applicant has suffered educational disadvantage;
(e) the previous academic attainment of the applicant including previous pursuit of third level education;
(f) any other matters which in the opinion of the Minister are proper matters to be taken into account having regard to the resources available and the objective of enabling persons to attend courses of higher education.
(6) For the purposes of specifying criteria or providing for matters to be specified or provided for under subsection (2), (3), (4) or (5) different criteria may be specified or matters provided for by the Minister as respects different classes of grants or applicants.
(7) (a) In this section “dependent child” means a child, including a foster child, of a person referred to in paragraph (b) which child, on a day to be prescribed—
(i) has not attained the age of 16 years, or
(ii) has attained the age of 16 years or more, resides with a person referred to in paragraph (b), and
(I) is pursuing a full-time course of education, or
(II) is certified by a registered medical practitioner (within the meaning of section 2 of the Medical Practitioners Act 2007) as being permanently unfit to work by reason of a medical condition.
(b) A dependent child shall be the child of and, shall reside with one or, as the case may be, more than one of the following:
(i) an independent student;
(ii) the spouse of an independent student;
(iii) a dependent student;
(iv) one parent or both parents of the dependent student.
(c) A day prescribed for the purposes of paragraph (a) shall be a day that is not earlier than 12 months before the day on which a student, in relation to whose application for a grant a dependent child is relevant, commences a year of study in any year at an approved course.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:
In page 17, lines 1 to 20, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following:
"(2) Without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, regulations under subsection (1) may provide for one or more than one of the following matters:
(a) the awarding authority to whom an applicant shall make an application;
(b) the date by which an application shall be made;
(c) the information to be made available by an awarding authority to an applicant in relation to an application for a grant, schemes of grants, obligations including those arising under section 16(2)* or 16(4)*, the circumstances in which, pursuant to this Act payment, in whole or in part, of a grant may cease, penalties for offences under this Act and liability, under section 21, to repay a grant;
(d) the submission of information required by or under this Act to an awarding authority by an applicant in respect of an application for a grant;
(e) the submission, by an applicant, of further information that may be required by an awarding authority;
(f) the production of evidence to verify particulars of information given to an awarding authority by an applicant;
(g) the periods of time within which the information, further information or evidence shall be submitted or produced to the awarding authority;
(h) the manner of notification of its decision by an awarding authority;
(i) any other matter that appears to the Minister to be necessary or expedient.”.
This amendment proposes the replacement of section 14(2) of the Bill, which outlines the matters for regulation with regard to applications. It provides for a simplified text. Amendment No. 76 proposes the replacement of section 16, which sets out the provisions with regard to changes of circumstances. It is a technical rewording of the section and does not substantially alter its substance.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:
In page 17, subsection (2), line 24, after "time" to insert the following:
"but shall not be precluded from applying from other awards or stipends".
Comment on this
Unfortunately, I do not propose to accept this amendment. The use of the word "grant" in section 15(2), as it stands, refers to student grants within the meaning of this legislation. Section 15(2) does not preclude students from applying for other awards or stipends. Therefore, the amendment proposed by the Deputy is not necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:
In page 17, lines 25 to 42 and in page 18, lines 1 to 16, to delete subsections (3) and (4) and substitute the following:
"(3) An applicant shall furnish an awarding authority with the personal, family, financial and other information that the authority may seek in relation to the applicant, the applicant's spouse or civil partner, each parent of the applicant, and any dependent child and shall produce evidence, in such form as may be prescribed, to verify the information, in order that the authority may determine whether or not the applicant is eligible to receive a grant."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:
In page 18, lines 17 to 20, to delete subsection (5) and substitute the following:
"(5) An awarding authority shall determine whether an applicant is eligible to receive a grant, having regard to—
(a) information furnished by the applicant pursuant to this section,
(b) any other information in relation to the application, as appropriate, and
(c) such criteria as are specified in the relevant scheme of grants.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:
In page 18, subsection (6), line 24, to delete "be prescribed" and substitute "be specified".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:
In page 18, lines 25 to 34, to delete subsection (7) and substitute the following:
"(7) Where the awarding authority determines—
(a) that the applicant is eligible for the grant for which he or she has applied, it shall give notice in writing informing the applicant of the determination and arrange to pay the grant, or
(b) that the applicant is not eligible for the grant for which he or she has applied, it shall give notice in writing to the applicant of the determination and the reasons therefor and of the applicant’s right to appeal the determination to an appeals officer.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:
In page 18, before section 16, to insert the following new section:
"16.—(1) An awarding authority shall consider information relating to a student who is in receipt of or is to receive payment in respect of a grant in relation to which a determination was made under section 15(7)(a)* and shall determine, having regard to such criteria as are specified in the relevant scheme of grants, if the student remains eligible for the grant in any of the following circumstances:
(a) the awarding authority is notified under subsection (2),
(b) the student has furnished information under subsection (4) or has, without a satisfactory explanation, failed to furnish that information under that subsection,
(c) the authority is furnished with a report of an inquiry officer under section 19**, or
(d) relevant information relating to the student comes into the possession of the authority.
(2) A student shall immediately notify the awarding authority in writing—
(a) if the student becomes aware that, by reason of any material change in the circumstances of the student or, as the case may be, spouse, civil partner or parent of the student—
(i) any information furnished by the student in his or her application, under section 15, for the grant concerned, which could reasonably be considered to have a bearing on the award of the grant to the student is no longer correct, or
(ii) it is no longer possible to comply with conditions the continued compliance with which is required in order that the student remains eligible to receive the grant concerned,
or
(b) if the student becomes aware that any information furnished by him or her in relation to himself or herself or, as the case may be, spouse, civil partner or parent of the student, which could reasonably be considered to have a bearing on the award of the grant to the student was incorrect, of the material change in circumstances or incorrect information.
(3) An awarding authority may at any time give a notice in writing to a student who is in receipt of or is to receive payment in respect of a grant requiring the student to furnish such information specified in the notice as the authority considers appropriate, within the period so specified, for the purpose of determining if the student remains eligible for the grant concerned.
(4) A student shall furnish the information required by the authority within the period specified in the notice.
(5) An awarding authority may, where it considers it appropriate in all the circumstances, cease payment, in whole or in part, in respect of a grant notwithstanding that it has not yet made a determination of the kind referred to in subsection (6).
(6) In making a determination under subsection (1) an awarding authority may determine that a student—
(a) remains eligible for the grant in relation to which a determination was made under section 15(7)(a)*, and accordingly shall continue to pay the grant and arrears, if any, due to the student in respect of any period under subsection (5) during which payment ceased,
(b) is not eligible for the grant in relation to which a determination was made under section 15(7)(a)* but is eligible for another grant and accordingly shall, as appropriate—
(i) pay the grant for which the awarding authority determines the student is eligible, if necessary taking into account moneys paid to or on behalf of the student in respect of the grant for which it determines the student is not eligible and paid to the student while he or she was so eligible, and arrears if any, due to the student in respect of any period under subsection (5) during which payment ceased, or
(ii) request from the student return of any moneys paid to or on behalf of the student in relation to the grant for which it determines the student is not eligible during the period the student was not so eligible, where the grant in respect of which the student is not eligible exceeds the grant for which the student is eligible, taking into account arrears, if any due to the student in respect of any period under subsection (5) during which payment ceased,
or,
(c) is not eligible for the grant in relation to which a determination was made under section 15(7)(a)*, and accordingly if the authority has not already done so under subsection (5) shall immediately cease paying the grant and request from the student return of any moneys paid to or on behalf of the student in respect of the grant during the period while the student is not so eligible.
(7) The awarding authority shall as soon as practicable, give notice in writing to the student of the determination under this section and the reasons therefor and shall inform the student of his or her right to appeal the determination to an appeals officer.
(8) A determination of an awarding authority under this section shall come into effect on the giving of a notice under subsection (7).”.
Comment on this
I would like to put down a marker that I may revisit this substantial new amendment on Report Stage. It is unlikely, but I would like to retain the right to do so. I will have to satisfy myself that the amendment represents an improvement on what we have already.
Comment on this
If amendment No. 77 is agreed, amendment No. 78 cannot be moved. Both amendments have already been discussed with amendment No. 3.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:
In page 20, lines 5 and 6, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:
"(1) An awarding authority shall designate such and so many members of the staff of the authority as it considers appropriate to be appeals officers under this section and a person so designated shall be an appeals officer for such period as the authority may determine.".
Comment on this
The Minister of State's proposal is acceptable. We now have a clear categorisation of appeals officers. That was the thrust of what I was trying to do in amendment No. 78. We are ad idem on this matter.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 78a:
In page 20, subsection (2), lines 10 to 13, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:
"(b) a student is aggrieved by a notice from an awarding authority under section 16(3) requiring information or a determination of an awarding authority under section 16(6)*,”.
Comment on this
As amendments Nos. 79 to 81, inclusive, are related, they may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:
In page 20, subsection (4), line 24, to delete "45 days" and substitute "30 days".
This amendment relates to the period of time within which an appeal can be determined. I suggest that 30 days is quite a long period within which to decide whether someone is eligible for a grant. If we had a more felicitous experience of the administration of the grants system by the Department of Education and Skills and the subsidiary bodies, perhaps we would have a different attitude. The issues we have discussed, including the figures Deputy O'Dowd mentioned earlier in this debate, are indicative of students' lousy experience of the administration of the current grants system.
One of the best initiatives taken in the legislative history of this State was the introduction by the former Minister, Mr. Neil Blaney, of a requirement that local authorities issue planning decisions within eight weeks or two months, failing which the application would be approved by default. Such a measure would never enter the system now but it was a legendary exhortation to public service bodies. It is interesting that this requirement has never been challenged, although it has been overcome in certain respects by officials seeking additional information. It established a sound principle that if the system does not work within a specified period, a person's application is granted.
The measure is proposed in this instance because the Blaney provision in the 1963 Local Government (Planning and Development) Act was extraordinary. In this instance, what we propose is that cases may not be open for 45 days. The natural human reaction where a period of 45 days is set down is to believe one does not have to make a decision until day 41. If officials believe they must deal with an application by day 29, a decision would be made in the case of the student in question a fortnight earlier than under the current wording. That is not an unreasonable request.
Comment on this
I concur with Deputy Quinn. This is a self-explanatory amendment. Under the current provisions, a student could wait for 90 days to have an appeal heard. We all agree it is necessary to make the system more efficient. If that is the position, changing the timeframes to 30 days or 45 days should not be an issue.
Comment on this
I emphasise that the timeframe set out in the Bill for appeals is the absolute maximum limit. It is envisaged that the majority of appeals will be considered in a much shorter timeframe. The service level agreements with the awarding authority and the procedures to be set down for the appeals board will reflect this. In interim appeals there will also be cases where complex matters may need to be considered and information or documentation may be required from other parties, including State agencies, to reach a conclusion.
Having said this, I am advised that some drafting issues in sections 18 and 22 on the appeals board are under consideration and may need to be revisited on Report Stage. In that event, I propose, without prejudice, to examine the Deputy's proposals regarding the period of determination of appeals.
Comment on this
The Minister of State will return on Report Stage with a proposal for limits of 30 and 60 days, as appropriate. It is in the spirit of the Croke Park agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 80:
In page 21, subsection (4), line 14, to delete "90 days" and substitute "30 days".
I expect the Minister will return to the matter on Report Stage on the same basis as on amendment No. 79.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 81:
In page 21, subsection (4), line 14, to delete "90 days" and substitute "45 days".
The position in regard to this amendment is similar to that pertaining to the previous amendments.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 82 and 83 are related and will be discussed together. Acceptance of amendment No. 82 would result in the deletion of section 19.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 82:
In page 21, before section 19, to insert the following new section:
19.—(1) An awarding authority may appoint a member of its staff or, with the consent of another awarding authority, a member of staff of that other awarding authority to be an inquiry officer for the purposes of this section.
(2) Every inquiry officer appointed under this section shall be furnished with a warrant of appointment and shall, when exercising any power conferred on him or her by this section, if requested by a person affected, produce to that person the warrant of appointment or a copy of it and a form of personal identification.
(3) An appointment under this section as an inquiry officer shall cease—
(a) if the awarding authority revokes the appointment,
(b) if the appointment is for a fixed period, on the expiry of that period, or
(c) if the person appointed ceases to be an officer of the awarding authority.
(4) An inquiry officer shall investigate and may, and if so directed by the awarding authority shall, make interim reports, and, on the conclusion of the inquiry shall make a final report to the awarding authority in relation to—
(a) an application for a grant, or
(b) any question arising on or in relation to a grant, which may be referred to him or her by the awarding authority.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (4) an inquiry officer may, at any time in the course of the investigation, without the necessity of making an interim report, inform the awarding authority of matters coming to his or her knowledge as a result of the inquiry tending to show that an offence has been committed.
(6) A student who receives or is to receive a payment in respect of a grant, or an applicant shall—
(a) produce to an inquiry officer all books, documents and other records concerning any question arising on or in relation to the grant or application for a grant that are in his or her possession, under his or her control or within his or her procurement,
(b) attend before an inquiry officer, and
(c) give to an inquiry officer all assistance in connection with the investigation which he or she is reasonably capable of giving, when required to do so by an inquiry officer.
(7) If an inquiry officer considers that a person (other than a student who receives or is to receive a payment in respect of a grant or an applicant) is or may be in possession of information concerning any question arising on or in relation to the grant or the application for the grant concerned the inquiry officer may require that person to—
(a) produce to him or her all books, documents and other records relating to the grant or application concerned that are in his or her possession, under his or her control or within his or her procurement,
(b) attend before him or her, and
(c) give to him or her all assistance in connection with the investigation which he or she is reasonably capable of giving.
(8) An inquiry officer may examine on oath an applicant, a student who receives or is to receive a grant, or a person referred to in subsection (7), in relation to an application for a grant and may administer an oath accordingly.
(9) A person who contravenes this section or who fails to comply with a requirement under this section is guilty of an offence and is liable, on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding €5,000 or imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or to both.
(10) A statement or admission made by a person pursuant to a requirement under this section shall not be admissible in evidence in proceedings brought against that person for an offence (other than for an offence under this section).
(11) In proceedings brought against a person for an offence under this section consisting of a failure by him or her to produce a book, document or other record it shall be a defence for the person to prove that the book, document or other record was not in his or her possession, under his or her control or within his or her procurement when he or she was required to produce it and that at that time it was not reasonably practicable for him or her to comply with the requirement.
(12) Nothing in this section shall operate to require a person to produce to an inquiry officer books, documents or other records, or to provide any information, that he or she would be entitled to refuse to produce or provide on the grounds of legal professional privilege or authorise the taking of possession of any such books, documents or records.
(13) The expenses of and incidental to an investigation by an inquiry officer shall be paid by the awarding authority concerned.
(14) Where a person is—
(a) convicted on indictment of an offence in proceedings for an offence, or
(b) ordered to pay sums to an awarding authority in proceedings under section 21(3),
brought as a consequence of an investigation under this section the court in those proceedings may order the person to pay to the awarding authority such sum as it shall specify not exceeding any amount paid by the awarding authority under subsection (13) in respect of that investigation.”.
It is proposed to amend in its entirety section 19 which provides for the appointment of inquiry officers to carry out investigations under the Act. The amended section seeks to set out more clearly the duties of an inquiry officer, the obligations regarding production of documentation concerning a grant application and related matters. In particular, the amended version places substantially more emphasis on the provision of relevant documentation or records to an inquiry officer rather than immediate recourse to a hearing. This is considered to be a more practical approach and is likely to be more efficient. If the circumstances warrant, an inquiry officer may still call witnesses to a hearing.
Amendment No. 83 provides for a more standard approach to outlining the actions and omissions that may be deemed an offence in relation to applications for student grants.
Comment on this
The amendments appear to be satisfactory. However, as they were provided at a late stage, I reserve the right to study them and return to the matter on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 83:
In page 23, lines 1 to 10, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:
"(1) A person who—
(a) furnishes information to an awarding authority, inquiry officer, appeals officer or the Appeals Board which is false or misleading, knowing it to be false or misleading in a material respect or being reckless as to whether it is so false or misleading,
(b) fails to comply with section 16(2)(a)* or 16(2)(b)*, or
(c) furnishes information in purported compliance with section 16(2)(a)* or 16(2)(b)* knowing it to be false or misleading in a material respect or being reckless as to whether it is so false or misleading, is guilty of an offence.”.
Comment on this
Again, I reserve the right to address this matter on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 84:
In page 23, subsection (2), lines 40 and 41, to delete all words from and including "stand" in line 40 down to and including "Board")" in line 41 and substitute the following:
"stand established a body to be known as an Bord Achomhairc i Leith Deontas Mac Léinn, or, in the English language, the Student Grants Appeals Board (to be known and referred to in this Act as the "Appeals Board")".
Comment on this
Amendment 86 is consequential on amendment No. 87 and amendment No. 88 is related. The amendments will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 86:
In page 24, subsection (6), line 6, to delete "The Appeals Board shall consist of a chairperson" and substitute the following:
"Subject to section 23*, the Appeals Board shall consist of a chairperson”.
The amendment provides for the inclusion of additional text. A new section to be inserted after section 22 entitled "Temporary Appointment to Appeals Board" provides for temporary appointments to the appeals board. In outlining the composition of the appeals board, the addition of the words "Subject to section 23” provides for the temporary appointments which may be made under the new section. This is a reasonable amendment.
Comment on this
I will explain the reason I have tabled amendment No. 87. The section provides that the appeals board shall not exceed 11 persons. The purpose of amendment No. 87 is to ensure that at least two representatives of the Union of Students of Ireland are appointed to the appeals board. Like Soviet sailors, students need a witness.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept amendment No. 87. The issue of the involvement of student representatives in an appeals board was raised on Second Stage and has been given careful consideration. The appeals board is not a representative entity and it is not envisaged that appointments to the board should be made on that basis. Rather, the appeals board requires a membership based on knowledge or expertise in the area of education or grants. On that basis, the appointment of student representatives is not by any means precluded by the current wording of section 22(7).
Comment on this
Not every future Minister for Education and Skills may be as reasonable as the Minister of State. If the legislation is silent, there is no obligation on a future Minister to express the view the Minister of State has taken. In theory, an informal consultation with the Union of Students of Ireland could take place in the current circumstances, as occurs in the case of many other bodies, and the USI could suggest four or five names for the Minister's consideration, from which two appointments could be made. However, there is no obligation on future Ministers to pick up a telephone to speak to student representatives. The USI has contemporary experience of the vagaries of trying to survive as a student at a third level college on baked beans and toast. The world would not collapse and Marlborough Street would still stand tomorrow if the Minister of State were to provide for the inclusion of representatives of the student body on the appeals board.
Comment on this
There is an obligation that the persons would have a special interest in or expertise or knowledge of matters regarding education or administration of schemes of payments. All Ministers for Education and Skills, certainly in recent times, have had a very good relationship with the Union of Students in Ireland, USI. It does very constructive work and engages with the Department on all manner of issues. I do not propose to change the situation.
Comment on this
We had a situation a couple of weeks ago where a responsible demonstration by students, which is their right in this Republic to express their sentiments, got hijacked by extraparliamentary bodies. The Parliament should recognise the current status of USI or other bodies which are taking responsible leadership positions. That is an extension of the principle of social partnership. I respect the fact that the Minister of State might not wish to give an indication now, but I suggest he should consult with his senior Minister. The provision could be made as loose as possible but in the current conditions USI needs to be able to say it has made progress in terms of having a direct influence on legislation. It is not trying to run the country, it is seeking to be recognised as a partner in education. If ever there was a relevant place to have a representative of students knowledgeable about what happens if one loses one's appeal for a student grant, this is it. We are not looking for appointments to the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
I reiterate, it is not meant to be a representative entity. I cannot give a guarantee that I will come back with a change on Report Stage but I will bring Deputy Quinn's remarks to the attention of the Tánaiste.
Comment on this
Does the Minister of State wish to say anything about amendment No. 88, as we are discussing the three amendments together? We have discussed amendments Nos. 86 and 87.
Comment on this
This amendment provides for the insertion of a new section entitled "Temporary appointment to Appeals Board". This amendment allows for the Minister, with the approval of the Oireachtas, to make temporary appointments to the appeals board to enable it to perform its functions. This may be necessary, for example, where a substantial number of appeals require to be dealt with within a tight timeframe. In those circumstances a new section will provide for additional capacity to examine and decide on appeals.
The number of persons, including the chairperson, appointed to the appeals board will not be allowed to exceed 15 in any event. A person to be appointed temporarily to the appeals board must meet the same requirements referred to in section 22(7), that is, they must have a special interest or expertise in or knowledge of matters regarding education or the administration of schemes of payments.
Comment on this
I will await the Minister's response on Report Stage. I may table a new amendment then.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 88:
In page 24, before section 23, to insert the following new section:
23.—(1) The Minister may by order increase the number of ordinary members of the Appeals Board where he or she is of the opinion that the number of appeals made under section 18 necessitates the appointment of one or more than one member to enable the Appeals Board to perform its functions under that section subject to the Appeals Board consisting, at any time, of not more than 15 persons including the chairperson.
(2) Notwithstanding section 6*, where the Minister proposes to make an order under subsection (1) a draft of the order shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas and the order shall not be made until a resolution approving the draft has been passed by each such House.
(3) Section 22(7) shall apply to the appointment of a person by order under subsection (1) as it applies for the purposes of that section.
(4) An order made under subsection (1) shall have effect for such a period not exceeding 5 years as shall be specified in the order.”.
Comment on this
Do I take it that the purpose of the amendment is that if there are a lot of appeals at any one time that one could sub-divide the board, a bit like the way An Bord Pleanála acts, so that two or three appeals could be processed at the same time?
Comment on this
Yes, we can make divisions within the appeals board. It demonstrates the desire of the Department to deal with those matters in an efficient way.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 89 to 92, inclusive, and 95 and 96 are related. They will be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 89:
In page 24, lines 44 and 45 and in page 25, lines 1 to 15, to delete subsections (1) and (2) and substitute the following:
"(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Data Protection Acts 1988 and 2003 or any other enactment, the data controller of a person listed in Schedule 2, or of a person prescribed for the time being under subsection (2) (in this subsection called “the first named person”) shall on being requested to do so by the data controller of a person so listed or prescribed, process personal data kept by the first named person, or information extracted from such data, to the data controller of the other person so listed or prescribed for the time being, if the data controller of the first named person is satisfied that it will be used for a relevant purpose only.
(2) If a person (not being a person listed in Schedule 2, or prescribed for the time being under this subsection) keeps personal data that is relevant to any of the functions of an awarding authority, inquiry officer, appeals officer or the Appeals Board, and the Minister considers that such supply by the person not so listed or prescribed to a person so listed or prescribed will further the attainment of a relevant purpose, then the Minister, following consultation with the Data Protection Commissioner, may prescribe that person for the purposes of subsection (1).”.
Amendment No. 89 provides for the deletion and replacement of subsections (1) and (2). This is a technical amendment as the Interpretation Act 2005 provides for reference to a "person" as representing reference to a "body".
Comment on this
Yes. Also on amendment No. 89, the new subsections (1) and (2) provide for the use of the term "person" rather than "body". That is consequentially reflected in the amendment of Schedule 2.
Under subsection (5), three further technical amendments have been made, the word "assigned" has been changed to "given" in the meanings outlined for data controller, personal data and processing.
On amendments Nos. 95 and 96, it is proposed to amend Schedule 2 to include reference to persons rather than bodies who may share information for the purpose of section 24, including a person with whom an awarding authority has an agreement on outsourcing of functions under the proposed new section on agreements relating to performance of certain functions. This is a technical amendment as the Interpretation Act 2005 provides for reference to a "person" as representing reference to a "body".
Comment on this
I have no problem with this but it sends a signal to me that the application and the interpretation of the data protection legislation is having unforeseen consequences of an excessively bureaucratic kind. Perhaps it would be appropriate for the Minister of State's senior colleague to leave a memorandum behind her or bring one to the Cabinet on the data protection legislation, because as it is being applied - I have experience of it in other sectors - it is becoming excessive to the point of being counterproductive in terms of bureaucracy. If that is the Minister of State's experience within the context of the administration of education a note should be left in a file to that effect so that we can deal with it. The problem is not confined to education.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 90:
In page 25, subsection (5), line 24, to delete "assigned" and substitute "given".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 91:
In page 25, subsection (5), line 26, to delete "assigned" and substitute "given".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 92:
In page 25, subsection (5), line 28, to delete "assigned" and substitute "given".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 93:
In page 25, subsection (5), to delete lines 39 and 40 and substitute the
following:
"(e) verifying that a student is enrolled or registered, in accordance with the rules of an approved institution, and continuing to attend an approved course at an approved institution.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 94:
In page 25, before section 25, to insert the following new section:
25.—(1) All instruments purporting to be schemes to have been in force prior to the coming into operation of this section and approved by the Minister under section 5 of the Local Authorities (Higher Education Grants) Act 1968 prior to the passing of this Act are hereby confirmed.
(2) All schemes (other than schemes to which instruments referred to in subsection (1) relate) for the purposes of the provision and administration of grants to enable persons to attend courses of higher and further education approved by the Minister and purporting to have been in force prior to the coming into operation of this section are hereby confirmed.
(3) If this section would, but for this subsection, conflict with a constitutional right of any person, the operation of this section shall be subject to such limitation as is necessary to secure that it does not so conflict but shall otherwise be of full force and effect.".
It is proposed to insert a new section entitled "Confirmation of schemes of grants" under section 24, processing of personal data. The purpose of the proposed new section is to confirm previous schemes of grants, including those made on an administrative basis. Following Second Stage an examination of challenges to the existing legislation necessitated an in-depth review of the provisions which permit the Minister to make decisions regarding the approval of institutions and courses for the purpose of student grant schemes. For the avoidance of any doubt in this regard it is proposed to confirm previous schemes of grants in the legislation.
Comment on this
Again, as there are implications and I am not fully aware of what they mean, I might come back to the matter on Report Stage. It is unlikely, but I say that to comply with procedures.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 95:
In page 27, to delete lines 8 to 12 and substitute the following:
"1. The Minister.
2. The Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government.
3. The Minister for Justice and Law Reform.
4. The Minister for Social Protection.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 96:
In page 27, to delete lines 21 to 23 and substitute the following:
"13. A person with whom an awarding authority has an agreement under section 11*.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 97:
In page 3, line 9, before "THE" to insert the following:
"AN APPEALS BOARD TO BE KNOWN AS AN BORD ACHOMHAIRC I LEITH DEONTAS MAC LÉINN OR, IN THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE,".
Comment on this
I agree to the amendment with one proviso. The acronym for the title of the board as Gaeilge is ABAILDMC. I do not believe we will be using this; it is not like FÁS.
Comment on this
Pursuant to Standing Order 127(3), the clerk will report specially to the Dáil that the select committee has amended the Title.
Comment on this
From my point of view, and I suspect that of my colleagues in Fine Gael, I would like to see this legislation enacted as quickly as possible. We will facilitate the Minister of State in so far as this is possible. By that I mean, we will not divide the House on it. The Bill could be taken on a soft day such as a Thursday.
Comment on this
I am more concerned with the students. The Government has enough to carry on the other front. If a discussion is being had with the Whips on this, it could be suggested that we will facilitate the passage of the Bill during a late sitting, if there are to be late sittings between now and Christmas.
Comment on this
I thank the Acting Chairman and Deputies opposite for their co-operation. The USI and students generally are anxious that the Bill be enacted as soon as possible. I appreciate the offer of assistance in that regard from the members opposite.