We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Enterprise and Economic Strategy

SECTION 8.

Contributions 1–168 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We are dealing with section 8, amendments Nos. 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12. In the discussion on those amendments a number of questions were raised and it was agreed I would request the Minister of State to provide the necessary information at this session. I call on the Minister to address the queries raised by Deputy Brennan and Deputy Molloy in particular.

Comment on this
Emmet Stagg Minister of State at the Department of Transport, Energy and Communications (Mr. Stagg) Labour Party

During the debate last Wednesday two issues requiring clarification came to my attention. First, there was uncertainty as to when Report Stage would be taken in the Dáil. I confirm that Report Stage will be taken on Wednesday, 6 November.

The second matter raised was the Telecom Éireann strategic alliance process. A number of Deputies sought information on certain aspects of the alliance process. I am happy to oblige the committee by providing a brief account of that process.

The alliance process began formally in July 1995 with the issue of the Mandate for Strategic Alliance Negotiations by the Government. The mandate set out the overall national policy objective for the telecommunications sector and the Government's requirements of a strategic partner for Telecom Éireann. In addition the mandate detailed Government policy on the liberalisation of the sector up to the year 2000 and the Government plans for the establishment of an appropriate regulatory regime.

The preparations for the launch of the formal alliance process were completed in January this year when the Government approved a number of measures to facilitate the next stages of the process. The first milestone was reached with the issue of an invitation for proposals from the prospective strategic partners with a confidential information memorandum which set out detailed information on the company, its performance and future prospects and the Government's policy and regulatory proposals for the future development of the sector.

Preliminary proposals were received from two parties on 15 March. The parties concerned were Teledanmark and a consortium of KPN and Telia. The bids were evaluated in accordance with predetermined criteria by representatives of the Department of Transport, Energy and Communications, the Department of Finance, Telecom Éireann and the advisers to the strategic alliance process.

On the basis of this evaluation, the Government decided that both the proposals should be admitted to the second stage of the process. The second phase involved extensive discussions with both bidders and a thorough disclosure and due diligence process.

On 24 June final proposals were received from both bidders. On 26 June, following an intensive evaluation process, the Government approved the commencement of exclusive negotiations with the KPN and Telia consortium. This negotiation period was to take 30 days.

Following this period, a final set of transaction documents was agreed between the parties and submitted for Government approval. The share purchase agreement was signed on 26 July 1996. The alliance transaction is subject to the standard competition clearance procedures of the EU. This process is ongoing. I re-emphasise that the alliance process was open, competitive and conducted on a scrupulously fair basis.

I wish to clarify a minor matter raised at the meeting last week, the statement attributed to me in The Examiner that a commercial quantity of oil had been discovered in the basin off Belmullet. In fact, the editorial in the newspaper had the correct story. In deference to the serious point made by Deputy Molloy, I have since written to The Examiner outlining the facts of the case.

Comment on this

The Minister of State said the share purchase agreement was signed on 26 July 1996. Is it proposed to place that agreement in the Dáil Library or to release its contents?

Comment on this

My advice is that this is a confidential document. It is commercially very sensitive and, therefore, will not be published.

Comment on this

Therefore, the public is not to know the details of the contract.

Comment on this

I am advised its contents are commercially sensitive and that it would put the company at a disadvantage if the details were published.

Comment on this

What about the taxpayers who gave it away for nothing? The Minister said an exclusive negotiation period of 30 days was given to the successful consortium. I thought the Government was committed to tendering State assets in a proper open market system. An exclusive negotiating deal for 30 days with one company is hardly the open tender system to which the Minister of State and the Minister, Deputy Lowry, seemed very committed last summer.

Comment on this

I understand bids were received in advance and those two bids were evaluated. The procedure was proper and open and is subject to EU approval. The EU stringently ensures that such procedures are proper and open.

Comment on this

This was a negotiated sale with one company after an exclusive period of 30 days. It was not a sealed tender bid where the envelopes were opened, as would happen in the normal sale of a State asset.

Comment on this

The tendering system was as I have described it and is subject to approval by the EU. That process is ongoing and is the acid test of whether it was a proper tendering system. I am confident the EU will approve the decisions made.

Comment on this

Surely it has nothing to do with whether the EU approves it.

Comment on this

The EU has very stringent regulations and requirements.

Comment on this

Do we not?

Comment on this

We do as well.

Comment on this

I do not want to go down the line of argument rather than debate. I had to say that the last day as well. This is not the kind of debate I will tolerate.

Comment on this

I just want to make the point under amendment 9 to section 8 that this derisory price — one third its value — was achieved by negotiating with one partner in a secret share document which will not be released to the public. It is news to me if that supports developing State companies.

Comment on this

The Deputies opposite and I simply have a different attitude to the public sector. We want to support and develop the public sector.

Comment on this

The Minister of State is selling it cheaply to foreigners.

Comment on this

The chairman said we should not argue but should debate the issue. I am prepared to debate the issue for as long as necessary. The Government's position concerning State enterprises is quite different from that of the Deputy's party. It wants to sell them all off.

Comment on this

Very much so.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy is confirming they want to sell them all off.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I said our attitude is different from that of the Minister of State.

Comment on this

His party leader said it.

Comment on this

The Government has privatised 20 per cent——

Comment on this

It is time we moved on; we have had a fair exchange.

Comment on this

We should recognise there is a difference between us——

Comment on this

Yes, the Minister of State sells to foreigners.

Comment on this

——and that we will not convert one another in this room.

Comment on this

The Minister of State sells to foreigners for nothing.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

He has just done it in this Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of information——

Comment on this

Will Fine Gael say something in this debate?

Comment on this

It is ironic to see Deputy Brennan attacking the method in which semi-State bodies have been sold off, considering the manner in which he dealt with the B & I which was sold to a foreign company, and not only for nothing, £38 million was contributed by the State——

Comment on this

That is not correct. On a point of information, it was sold to a company on the Irish Stock Exchange.

Comment on this

His whole approach is ironic.

Comment on this

I stand over that sale. It saved the taxpayer £30 million. It was sold to an Irish company.

Comment on this

He paid a company £38 million——

Comment on this

The Deputy's party did not oppose the sale in the Dáil. Why did his party back it in the Dáil?

Comment on this

My party did not back it in the Dáil.

Comment on this

It did not oppose it.

Comment on this

If Deputies persist with this I will have no hesitation in adjourning the business.

Comment on this

Let us get some facts.

Comment on this

I have not done it before but I will.

Comment on this

The Deputy's party did not oppose it in the Dáil.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Molloy pressing amendment No. 8?

Comment on this

I have not spoken yet but I will be pressing the amendment. I thank the Minister of State for clarifying the position in regard to the alleged commercial find and for withdrawing the inaccurate report in The Examiner.

Comment on this

I can give the Deputy up-to-date information on it if he wishes.

Comment on this

I would be delighted to have it. I would also be delighted to have up-to-date information on the details of the sale of Telecom Éireann which the Minister of State is refusing to give the select committee and is, therefore, refusing to give to the Oireachtas. I wonder what the basis is for his decision.

I have a copy here of an article in The Irish Times which goes into great detail and quotes its source as Mr. Ron Bolger, the chairman of Telecom Éireann, and Mr. Alfie Kane its chief executive. Will the Minister of State confirm if the details in that article are correct and whether the chairman and chief executive are authorised to brief the media on the details of the strategic alliance? Why is the Minister of State claiming that the matter is confidential and cannot be disclosed? Are we to take it that the information in the media is not correct?

What arrangement did the Government enter into when it agreed to sell off 20 per cent of Telecom Éireann for much less than its market value with an option to buy another 15 per cent? The House should be made aware of the details in regard to this. This Bill is a mechanism to authorise the Minister to undertake commercial decisions in regard to the sale and purchase of share capital. In this case the Minister is selling to a foreign consortium at a price which most commentators have heavily criticised.

Comment on this

The main terms and features of the strategic alliance agreement were made public when it was signed at the end of July. The detailed alliance agreement is confidential to the Government, Telecom Éireann and KPN-Telia. This is normal commercial practice in such arrangements.

Comment on this

It is a public company and the details should be public.

Comment on this

The company is being told it must be commercial. The Deputy wants to denude it by giving all its commercial information to its competitors.

Comment on this

The deal should be public.

Comment on this

It has no competitors. The Minister has decided to sell it to one company and that is it.

Comment on this

Competitors are lining up for more of its business.

Comment on this

What is the arrangement in relation to the phased payment of the amounts?

Comment on this

It may be useful to remind members of the main financial terms of the strategic alliance deal agreed with the KPN-Telia consortium. The price paid for the initial 20 per cent stake in the company provides the strategic partner with an entry ticket to the full provision of the deal. The financial structure is in three parts; first, initial proceeds from the sale of 20 per cent will be £183 million. Second, the partners have committed to an option to purchase a further 15 per cent within three years which, when exercised, will yield a further £200 million, bringing the total by then to £383 million.

The final payment will come from establishing the market value of the company, based on the public offering or other agreed valuation in three years time and applying that valuation to the full stake, whether 35 per cent or 20 per cent, purchased by the partner. The increase in value above a threshold based on an agreed rate of return on the purchaser's initial investment of the 20 per cent stake and the option price on the 15 per cent stake is shared 60:40 between the State and KPN-Telia. The overall proceeds from this calculation depend on the success of the strategic alliance in increasing company value. Total proceeds, based on a 35 per cent sale, are expected to amount to approximately £550 million.

Comment on this

Will virtually all the initial payment of £183 million go into Telecom Éireann?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If that is the case, the consortium which will buy 20 per cent of the company for £183 million will in effect get back 20 per cent of £183 million as an immediate gift because it will now own 20 per cent of the £183 million. It will hand over £183 million and get back 20 per cent because the money will go into the company.

Comment on this

The Deputy is playing with figures. The consortium will pay over the money and how it is reinvested is a matter——

Comment on this

Regarding my amendment relating to the price of the company, I understand the Minister to say that £183 million will be handed over and will go into the company, but the consortium will get back 20 per cent of that, which amounts to approximately £30 million. In effect, the price is £153 million and not £183 million. By putting the money into the company, it is automatically returned to the shareholder. I am not arguing the point with the Minister but the derisory price of £183 million is less; it is £153 million.

Comment on this

Every independent financial adviser said this was a good deal.

Comment on this

That is not the case.

I have a stack of newspaper cuttings and although some or most said it was a good deal, not every one did so.

Comment on this

I am satisfied this is a good deal and that it was done properly. Good value was received for the share being disposed.

Comment on this

That is a different statement.

Comment on this

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 8, subsection (1), between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following:

"(c) The initial 20 per cent. shareholding of the Minister in the company shall not be disposed of by sale, transfer, exchange or otherwise for any sum less than the sum of £300,000,000.".

Comment on this

Amendment No. 9 was discussed with amendment No. 8. Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

Is the Chairman putting amendments Nos. 9, 10, 11 and 12 now?

Comment on this

Yes. I am obliged under Standing Orders to proceed to take the vote on all the amendments in the group and the section. Is the Deputy pressing amendment No. 9?

Comment on this

Yes. I must do so, given the price.

Comment on this

I move amendment No 10:

In page 8, subsection (1), between lines 18 and 19 to insert the following:

"(d) The minimum price at which the Minister may dispose of shares in the company by sale, transfer, exchange or otherwise shall be the market value of such shares as determined by a panel of independent experts comprised of stockbrokers and shall take account of the value of any offer made for such shares in the three years immediately preceding such intended disposal.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 8, lines 19 to 29, to delete subsection (2).

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In page 8, subsection (2), between lines 21 and 22, to insert the following:

"(b) The Minister may not dispose of any shares in the company other than as provided for in subsection (3) (a) without the terms of such sale being laid before and approved by Dáil Éireann.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:

In page 8, subsection (3), between lines 38 and 39, to insert the following:

"(c) Shares representing not less than 15 per cent. of the total shareholding in the company shall be made available, by issue, transfer or otherwise, to one or more employee shareholding scheme, subject to such terms and conditions as may be approved by a majority of the shareholders in the company.".

This proposal seeks to give the staff of Telecom Éireann 15 per cent of the shares of the company. The Government provides for 5 per cent in its proposals although I understand that is not definite. What is the present position on the workers' shares? Is the 5 per cent proposal agreed? What is the status of that decision? Will the Chair allow a debate on this?

Comment on this

The amendment is in the Deputy's name and he is free to speak on it.

Comment on this

It is clearly our intention to engage in good faith with employee representatives with a view to charting the best structure for the future participation of employees in the ownership of the company. Any further comment would prejudge the negotiating process and I will not engage in megaphone negotiations.

Both Deputy Lowry and I enjoy excellent relations with the employee representatives and we have no need for megaphone negotiations.

Comment on this

This is another secret, like the document of 26 July which is the share agreement the Minister of State refused to give to the committee. The Minister of State is now saying there are confidential talks between him and the unions. He is unwilling to tell the public what percentage of the Telecom Éireann shares he will keep for the workers.

Comment on this

It is not yet decided and is a matter for negotiation.

Comment on this

We are being asked to pass legislation disposing of shares in a company without being told who will own the shares. If we on this side of the House proposed it the Minister of State would be the first to protest in the strongest possible terms. He wants a blank cheque to sell what percentage shares he likes to workers and will not tell us the percentage, the price or the terms for those shares. Will they be individually held by workers or in trust? Where is the information?

Comment on this

I will give the information shortly.

Comment on this

If that is so, I will withdraw those statements.

Comment on this

On amendment 13, section 8(3) provides that the company can issue and the Minister or Minister for Finance may sell or otherwise transfer shares "to one or more employee shareholding scheme, subject to such terms and conditions as may be approved by a majority of the company's shareholders". It is an enabling clause.

The mandate given to Telecom Éireann for the negotiation of the alliance provided that subject to certain conditions, up to 5 per cent of the issued share capital could be made available to the employees as one of the elements of the strategic alliance. Recently the Minister indicated that the Government is open to practical and feasible proposals by the staff to purchase shares in excess of 5 per cent at full value when it is satisfied this will assist the future development of the company. The political conversion here to a minimum employee shareholding figure of 15 per cent is rather opportunistic and it stands in stark contrast to the reticence applied to share disposal in the case of the alliance transaction. If this amendment was accepted, it would oblige the employees of Telecom Éireann to purchase the shares. Given Deputy Brennan's evaluation of the 20 per cent share, this would cost each employee £16,000. Where does the Deputy suggest they get the money?

Comment on this

Is the Minister of State proposing to give the shares away free?

Comment on this

No. We are providing enabling legislation to have employee shareholding schemes put in place. Normal negotiations are ongoing. They are not secret. They are between the shareholder and employee representatives.

Comment on this

The Minister of State has charged me with wanting to sell the shares to the employees. I have no intention of giving them free shares. Does the Minister of State intend to give them free shares?

Comment on this

We have been accused repeatedly of selling the company short to various people——

Comment on this

Foreigners.

Comment on this

Anyone not from Ireland could be so described. The Deputy is, I assume, not suggesting we should confine sales, if they are desirable, to Irish nationals only. The Deputy is saying we did not get enough for the shares we sold and that now we should give a tranche of shares away for nothing.

Comment on this

I am not saying that. The Minister of State said my amendment says shares should be sold. He cannot now say he wants to give them away for nothing if my amendment says they should be sold. He cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

The Minister of State has not given any information on the Government's intentions as to the percentage of shares in Telecom Éireann that they intend to make available to the employees of the company. Yet a communication from the Communication Workers' Union by David Beck which was sent to the Minister on 24 September, a copy of which was circulated to all Members of the House, argued a case for worker representation at a higher level than is proposed in the Bill. He refers to the inequitable situation that would arise if an employee benefit trust "holding 14 per cent of the shares had no representation on the board". The strategic partner would have three directors. The Minister of State refers to 14 per cent of the shares. Has the Government discussed that figure with the CWU in regard to the Government's intention once this section is passed? Where has the figure 14 per cent come from if not in discussion between the workers and the Government?

Comment on this

The make up of the board is dealt with in section 10. It is Government policy that the Government should hold 51 per cent of the shares. Telia has an option on 35 per cent. That leaves 14 per cent. There is no magic in guessing that figure because that is what is left.

Comment on this

The concept of share options for workers should be encouraged. I welcome it. In Aer Lingus it was welcomed by the staff as they had a greater input into the running of the company. In the Bill's context, Deputy Brennan refers to the strategic partner who will have available to it up to 35 per cent. In the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Semi-State Bodies, Deputy Brennan gave the impression that selling shares to a strategic alliance was part of Fianna Fáil policy. From this Bill, there is a minimum 5 per cent share for the workers and a commitment to enabling legislation allowing the workers, the Minister or the Department of Transport, Energy and Communications officials to negotiate meaningfully. This is an alliance of everyone to ensure Telecom Éireann can compete, the maximum number of jobs can be maintained and that we get into activities to provide extra jobs. These can be provided in the context of the 5 per cent. My understanding of the document and the remarks Minister of State is that there will be more than 5 per cent for the workers although that will be subject to negotiation. It is mind-boggling to hear Deputy Brennan questioning the concept of negotiations between the parties to arrive at a suitable ratio of shares to enable the future of Telecom Éireann to be assured.

Comment on this

My amendment seeks to give the workers 15 per cent. The record will show that Deputy Ryan, if he votes, is voting against that and supporting the Government's intention to commit 5 per cent.

Comment on this

That is not my reading of it. It could be more than 5 per cent.

Comment on this

The Deputy should vote for the amendment.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I am not haggling about the figures. I accept that negotiations must take place with workers about whether it is 5 per cent or 15 per cent. However, I do not understand the secrecy——

Comment on this

There is no secrecy.

Comment on this

—— and the retrospective blank cheque the Minister of State seeks. He wants the Bill to be passed and signed by the President without telling the Legislature exactly what is involved. This is Ireland's largest State company and 1 per cent of it is gold dust; it is enormously valuable. It includes Cablelink, Eircell and Kelly Communications. Irish taxpayers have put £2 billion into this company, yet the Government values it at £800 million.

Comment on this

The Deputy has already put those figures on the record. He did so eloquently last week.

Comment on this

It is not a matter of just discussing with workers whether it is 5 per cent or 15 per cent. If one accepts the £2 billion value of the company it means the 10 per cent, about which the Minister wishes to negotiate after the Bill is passed, is worth £200 million. The Minister wants a blank cheque for £200 million in negotiations without saying what percentage of it he will give away. My amendment proposes that the workers get the shares and pay for them. However, I object to the fact that the Minister wants to do that in secret.

Comment on this

They do not have to pay for them.

Comment on this

They do pay for them.

Comment on this

The word "secret" has been used a number of times and I have twice asked the Minister of State to respond to it. The Deputy should desist from repetition. The committee has work to do and calling on the Minister of State to reply to the same question a number of times is a negative way to proceed.

Comment on this

The allegation of repetition could equally apply to the Minister of State. I do not know why the Chairman applies it to us.

Comment on this

I appeal to both sides. I will not accept repetition. We are having a rehash of many of the statements made last week.

Comment on this

It is a different amendment.

Comment on this

Section 8(3)(b) proposes to give the Minister the power to sell or otherwise transfer shares as part of one or more employee shareholding schemes. That could be interpreted to mean that the Minister could transfer the shares free to the employees.

Comment on this

This is enabling legislation; the provision is required.

Comment on this

Will the Minister of State give the committee more information about the Government's intentions?

Comment on this

The amendment would have the effect of concluding negotiations before they start. That cannot be done and nobody would seriously expect us to do it. Without a legislative framework, which we are seeking in this Bill, negotiations would be impossible. We are asking for a framework to be provided so that negotiations can take place. We should not pre-empt in the Bill the outcome of the negotiations.

Comment on this

Will acceptance of this amendment mean the arrangement with the consortia would have to be reduced from a possible 35 per cent to 34 per cent?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 15, 16 and 17 are alternatives to amendment No. 14. It is proposed that amendments Nos. 14 to 17, inclusive, will be discussed together. Deputies will have an opportunity to speak on each amendment. Is that agreed?

Comment on this

Amendment No. 17 is a technical amendment. The group of amendments should comprise amendments Nos. 14 to 16, inclusive.

Comment on this

That is fine. I will take it separately.

Comment on this

On a point of procedure, I agree with the amendment of the Minister of State. However, I wish to deal with amendment No. 14 alone.

Comment on this

The Deputy is entitled to do that.

Comment on this

I am not trying to be awkward but it is an important amendment.

Comment on this

I have no problem with that under Standing Orders. Grouping amendments is a means of avoiding repetition. When amendments are similar or related it avoids a rehash of the same debate under each amendment. We will take amendment No. 14 alone. Is it agreed that amendments Nos. 15 and 16 be taken together followed by amendment No. 17?

Comment on this

There was agreement that we would take amendments Nos. 14 to 16, inclusive, together and I have prepared myself to respond to them collectively.

Comment on this

Where was that agreement?

Comment on this

If they are taken as a group the Deputies can speak to each amendment. It means that each amendment would have to be put to the committee separately. There is nothing to stop Deputy Brennan from addressing amendments Nos. 14, 15, 16 and 17.

Comment on this

I am not trying to be difficult. I wish to debate amendment No. 14 fully and vote on it alone.

Comment on this

You have proposed the amendment so I am obliged to allow you to do that.

Comment on this

That makes life difficult for this side of the House.

Comment on this

That is my job.

Comment on this

It was indicated to the Department that the amendments would be taken together because they are related. It is a matter for the committee to decide whether they should be taken together.

Comment on this

If there is disagreement I will have to put the proposal and call a division on it.

Comment on this

Is that the procedure under Standing Orders?

Comment on this

I would have no alternative if there is disagreement. The Minister of State says that as the amendments are related they should be taken together. The Deputy has the right to move each amendment in his name, to speak on each of them and have them voted on if necessary. However, if the Deputy insists on putting amendment No. 14 separately and the Minister of State disagrees on the basis that they are related, I must put the question to the committee. It would be better if we got agreement on it. I will allow, within reason, the maximum scope for discussion on each of the amendments.

Comment on this

I understood the Chairman's earlier ruling to mean that I had the right to insist on speaking on each amendment separately.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's right.

Comment on this

I now understand it is my right, subject to a vote of the committee.

Comment on this

I have never had a disagreement on that. I would have to refer to Standing Orders.

Comment on this

My response to amendment No. 14 covers amendments Nos. 15 and 16 also because it is the same argument. I have no difficulty in giving the response three separate times.

Comment on this

As the amendments in the group are interrelated it is normal practice for the Minister to reply to the amendments together. However, Deputy Brennan has the right to insist on putting amendment No. 14. Does the Deputy agree to the grouping on the basis that he deals with each one and puts them separately?

Comment on this

I will only agree to that if the alternative is that the Chairman calls a vote. I do not want to hold up the committee with a vote I will not win.

Comment on this

This is an unusual procedure. Normally we do not disagree on groupings because I allow full debate and discussion on each amendment and each one is put separately in accordance with Standing Orders.

Comment on this

The difference is I want the right to comment on amendments Nos. 15 and 16 after we have voted on amendment No. 14. If the Chairman adopts the usual procedure, I will not be able to speak on amendments Nos. 15 and 16 after I know the result on amendment No. 14.

Comment on this

Deputy Séamas Brennan has that right and I have to rule accordingly and ask the Minister to reply to the motions individually.

Comment on this

This amendment is unique in the sense that the Opposition parties were asked to support it by the Communication Workers' Union. The motion I read in Deputy Séamas Brennan's name is identical to the amendment proposed by the CWU. Deputy Séamas Brennan should be allowed exercise his discretion to have this matter debated separately from amendments Nos. 15 and 16.

Comment on this

I propose to take amendment No. 14 separately, amendment Nos. 15 and 16 together and amendment No. 17 separately because it is a technical amendment put down by the Minister. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

What time does the Chairman intend to adjourn?

Comment on this

I suggest we adjourn not later than 1 o'clock, resume at 2.30 p.m., proceed to 5 o'clock and then examine the situation.

Comment on this

Would it be possible for the committee to resume at 3 o'clock?

Comment on this

I have no problem if the committee wishes to resume at 3 o'clock and continue to 5.30 p.m. Agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:

In page 9, before section 10, to insert the following new section:

"11.—(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Worker Participation (State Enterprises) Acts, 1977 and 1988, or any other Act, where an order is made under section 23(1) of the Worker Participation (State Enterprises) Act, 1977, fixing the appropriate number, within the meaning of section 23(2) of that Act, in relation to the company, the appropriate number specified in any such order shall not exceed one third of the number that the Minister is otherwise entitled to appoint under the articles of association of the company plus one substitute who will be entitled to attend and participate at Board meetings but not to vote except in the absence of one of the Employee Directors.

(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Worker Participation (State Enterprises) Acts, 1977 and 1988, or any order or warrant made thereunder, or any other Act, the 1996 election as regards the company shall be deferred by one year or such shorter period as may be specified by the Minister by order and subsequent elections shall be held each fourth year thereafter. Candidates nominated by trade unions need not necessarily be employees of the Company.

(3) Not later than the holding of an election pursuant to subsection (2) and notwithstanding anything contained in the Worker Participation (State Enterprises) Acts, 1977 and 1988, or any order or warrant made thereunder, or any other Act, the term of office of such directors of the Company appointed under the Worker Participation (State Enterprises) Acts, 1977 and 1988, shall expire on such date as the Minister may by order specify so as to ensure that the number of directors remaining appointed under those Acts shall be the number specified in order made under section 23(1) of the Worker Participation (State Enterprises) Act, 1977.

(4) Where an Employee Benefit Trust is established pursuant to section 8 (3)(A) of this Act the Minister will appoint an additional director to represent the employee shareholders on the nomination of the Trust.".

I thank the Chairman and Minister for agreeing to the procedure on which I insisted as this is a central amendment. As Deputy Molloy said, this is the amendment that mirrors the proposed amendment from the CWU. It is important for the company both politically and commercially that the Government makes a clear statement and decision on this section. The trade unions in Telecom Éireann are concerned by the wording of this section which will have the effect of reducing the number of worker representatives on the board from four to two. The ability of the workforce to influence the strategic direction of their company would be seriously weakened by section 10.

A change in circumstances whereby the representation of workers on the board is altered from being one third of the total board to one third of the Minister's nominees, has serious implications in the event of any further dilution of the State's shareholdings in the future. This restructuring of the board runs contrary to commitments in the Programme for Competitiveness and Workand the programme for Government, which extend social partnership arrangements in industry. Such a serious reduction in worker representation is not essential to the protection of the strategic interests of either shareholder in the new company. These interests can and are adequately protected by the corporate governance arrangements in the shareholder’s agreement.

Section 10 does not make any provision for the representation of employee shareholders, in the event of an employee benefit trust being established under section 8. It would be inequitable to have the employee benefit trust holding, for example, 14 per cent of the shares with no representative on the board, while the strategic partner will have three directors.

Under current arrangements, the normal expectation in an election is that the nominees of the CWU would win three seats and the candidate nominated by the other five unions would secure the fourth seat. In the event of a reduction in the number of seats, the five unions would not have a quota between them. Therefore, the effect of the proposed restructuring of the board will be to permanently disenfranchise members of these unions. Cutting the worker representatives of the board in half to accommodate the strategic partner will be seen in a bad light by the staff and will undermine the capacity of the trade unions to secure support for the strategic alliance and the transformation of Telecom Éireann in an emerging competitive marketplace.

This amendment fully reflects the CWU's requirement. The statement I have made is a paraphrase of a letter sent to the Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications by the CWU general secretary, David Beggs, on 24 September 1996, which I am sure members of the committee have received. I would like to hear the Minister's view on this amendment.

Comment on this
Brian Fitzgerald Mr. B. Fitzgerald Labour Party

I do not have major concerns about the first section of Deputy Séamas Brennan's amendment. I do not know what stage are the negotiations between the unions and the Minister. I have serious reservations with subsection (2) of his amendment where he says candidates nominated by trade unions need not necessarily be employees of the company. This would be a major shift in what I and others believe about worker participation. It does not say who should nominate that person or persons. Is it the national executives of the various unions? It is right that whoever is on the board of any State company as a worker representative should be nominated and voted for by the workers of that company. That person must be a member of that company. I would have serious reservations about changing that.

Comment on this

There is some overlap and inconsistency between amendment No. 14 and amendments Nos. 15 and 16. Amendments Nos. 15 and 16 provide for the maintenance of the status quoregarding employee directors on the board of the company. On the other hand, amendment No. 14 sets out a different arrangement for employee representation on the board. This amendment, coincidentally, corresponds to proposals made by the Telecom Éireann trade unions as their opening position in our discussions with them. Matters have moved on considerably since then.

Section 10 modifies the Worker Participation (State Enterprises) Acts of 1977 and 1988 in relation to Telecom Éireann to provide that the number of employee-directors to be appointed under these Acts shall not exceed one third of the number that the Minister is otherwise entitled to appoint under the articles of association of the company. These Acts currently provide that the number of employee directors which the Minister may appoint under these Acts is one third of the total number of the directors of the company. The purpose of this provision is to accommodate the appointment of directors to the board of Telecom Éireann by a shareholder pursuant to any share transaction agreement entered into by the Minister and the company.

This section also provides that the Minister may, by order, postpone for up to one year the Telecom Éireann employee-director elections to be held in 1996 pursuant to the worker participation Acts. The purpose of this provision is to allow for the establishment of a new board structure of the company following a strategic alliance before the next worker director elections take place. This section further enables the Minister to specify a date on which the terms of office of a number of existing employee directors expire before the next worker director elections in order to ensure that the number of employee directors remaining matches the number provided for in the new board structure.

The section provides, therefore, for the changes in the board's structure that are necessary for the strategic partner to be represented at board level. It does so while maintaining a strong employee presence at board level and maintaining the State's voting majority. The Minister's position was set out in his Second Stage speech on the Bill. He said:

. . . this solution was driven by the need to preserve effective control of the State's majority shareholding, the representational interests of the strategic partner, the objective of maintaining a small to medium sized board for the purpose of effective governance and the need to have meaningful employee representation at the key decision making forum in respect of company operations.

The Minister also stated:

I am, however, open to any suggestions, proposals or amendments that may emerge from consultations with the trade unions involved and interested parties as to how the employee issue could evolve. If agreement is reached and if such agreement requires changes to the text of the Bill, new proposals could be introduced on Committee Stage or, if some form of agreement could not be reached quickly, the matter could be dealt with in subsequent legislative proposals during 1997.

These discussions are proceeding and I hope a solution acceptable to all sides can be achieved. I am confident that the use of the alternate or substitute director concept will be acceptable to all parties. It is my intention to table amendments on Report Stage to reflect the agreements which I am confident will be reached and which will exceed the proposals made by Deputy Séamus Brennan in his amendment.

Comment on this
Brian Fitzgerald Mr. B. Fitzgerald Labour Party

Is the Minister of State effectively accepting section 2?

Comment on this

For the reasons I have outlined I oppose the amendments.

Comment on this

On Second Stage I raised the unions' concerns about the number of workers' representatives. I felt there was a need for further negotiations. I accepted to an extent the Minister's points about the need to have an efficient board and that the interests of the shareholders and the staff would be represented properly. I took on board the Minister's view that he was prepared to have further negotiations with the unions to reach a compromise on the matter. On the basis of the Minister of State's indication that the negotiations are ongoing there may be further scope on Report Stage to deal with the issue and there is no need at this stage for Deputy Séamus Brennan's proposed amendments.

Comment on this

I am annoyed at the tenor of this legislation. We are asked to agree to section 10 on the basis that the Minister will deal with certain matters later. The section provides that the number of worker directors shall not exceed one third of the number the Minister is otherwise entitled to appoint. At present one third of the directors of Telecom Éireann are worker directors and this section proposes to reduce that to one sixth.

The Minister of State indicates that he will have some proposals on Report Stage to alter that but in the meantime he wants agreement to section 10. This puts the committee in a difficult situation. This is the third occasion today we have been asked to leave the matter to the Government while it gets on with the negotiations. In the meantime, however, it wants us to pass the legislation. That is the attitude adopted with regard to price, the shareholding and the worker participation. I protest at this manner of passing legislation. It is clearly designed to get Government backbenchers on board on the basis that the legislation does not really mean what it says and matters will be fixed up later. It has clearly worked because Deputy Seán Ryan has come on board on the basis that the matter will be dealt with on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I can only deal with the business on the basis of what is before me. If a Minister or Minister of State indicates something may or may not be done on Report Stage that is a matter for the Minister or Minister of State. It is not a matter for me.

Comment on this

The Minister of State referred to amendments on Report Stage but did not give us any information on their content that might help with my amendment. He indicated that discussions are taking places with the trade unions and the committee should be privy to those discussions before this amendment is dealt with. As that is probably not possible I will have to press the amendment.

The amendment seeks to ensure the worker-directors of Telecom Éireann are not reduced in number. If the Government wants to vote against that suggestion we will have to wait to see what is proposed on Report Stage. This amendment is similar to a Communications Workers' Union proposal and my arguments for this amendment were the views sent to me in a letter from the CWU of 24 September. I do not see why the workers should be pushed aside at board level to make way for Dutch and Swedish interests which bring nothing to this arrangement.

Over lunch I had the opportunity to read The Financial Times which indicated that the sale of 20 per cent to the German telecom company is being launched today. As I understand it it is getting a multiple of profits of 15 to 20 times. The Government has managed to get three or four times profits from our foreign investors. This relates directly to the number of worker directors on the board because workers are being pushed off the board to allow the Dutch and Swedish interests to take their places. I do not understand why a German telecom company can obtain three times for its shares what Telecom Éireann is receiving for its shares. This is one of the Government’s great financial scandals.

The Government should accept this amendment. If it is having talks with the CWU and can accede to its requests the Minister of State should accept the amendment rather than force his own backbenchers to vote down an amendment seeking to protect workers' rights. Such a vote would receive attention. The Minister of State should accept the amendment and do what needs to be done to improve matters on Report Stage. It would be a turning point in the history of the Minister of State's party to force his backbenchers to vote to reduce the number of worker-directors.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan's amendment reflects the opening negotiating position of the union, no more and no less. Matters have advanced since then. I am responding positively to the suggestions made by the Deputy and the union. I am confident that not alone will we meet the original case made by the union in the amendments I will table on Report Stage, but in some instances we will go beyond that position. We are not opposing the Deputy's amendment because we do not agree with the content. It is premature because the negotiations have not been completed and we will table amendments on Report Stage on foot of completed negotiations which will reflect agreement with the representatives of the workers in Telecom Éireann. There is no question of our pushing aside workers' rights in this matter.

It is Government policy that it will retain a majority shareholding in the company. It will have seven out of 12 places on the board; the new partner will have three places leaving two places. We are looking at how we can enhance that number to make it more meaningful. I am confident the Deputy will accept the amendments tabled on Report Stage arising from the negotiations taking place.

Comment on this

The Minister of State considers Deputy Brennan's amendment premature. Perhaps the legislation itself is premature if negotiations are still taking place. This Bill is on Committee Stage yet there are ongoing talks. I accept there will be a Report Stage but the procedure is strange.

How was the figure of two places arrived at? If outside interests are getting three places I could understand that the number of worker-directors could be reduced to three.

Deputy Brennan's amendment originates from the union side and I presume it reflects what is taking place in the negotiations. I am glad negotiations are taking place. The amendment suggests that in future worker-directors would not necessarily have to be workers. The Minister of State has discussed this matter with the union and I accept its inclusion in Deputy Brennan's amendment. Could the Minister of State clarify the position because it is unnerving that the union is sending out such a signal? It will make many employees in semi-State bodies and trade union officials very nervous. They will wonder about the basis for this suggestion. The fact that a trade union secretary is satisfied does not mean the workers are satisfied. The position of worker-director is sacred to workers and, reading between the lines, I suspect that they are being sold down the river. Perhaps the payback to union officials for agreeing to partial privatisation is that they will replace the workers who will be removed from the board. From my experience, that represents a serious and fundamental change for the workers.

The fact that this suggestion was included in the amendment and originated from the union means that it was not plucked out of thin air. Will the Minister of State inform the committee regarding whether it is under discussion?

Comment on this

The purpose of this enabling legislation is to allow for the agreement and the director of regulatory affairs to be put in place. The amendment to which Deputy Ahern referred was tabled by his party colleague. I did not place this matter on the agenda. Deputy Brennan tabled the amendment and he argued the case for it.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan also stated the origin of the amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan and his party put forward the amendment and I am not arguing the case in question. The matter has not been discussed to date and we are negotiating with the principal union involved.

Comment on this

The other unions were squeezed out.

Comment on this

Approximately 16 per cent of the workers are represented by five other unions and there is a necessity to accommodate their interests within the worker representative system. This is important and will form part of the negotiations. I have not declared any intention that people other than employees should be worker-directors. The Deputy's party is putting forward that proposal, I cannot be blamed for it. Perhaps he should inquire why that is the case.

Comment on this

Does the Minister of State oppose the proposal I put forward?

Comment on this

I am asking that the committee vote down the proposal.

Comment on this