SECTION 8.
Contributions 169–335 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Therefore, the Minister of State opposes the proposal put forward by the Telecommunication Workers' Union on this point?
Comment on this
That terminology was already used on two occasions. I must inform the committee that the Telecommunication Workers' Union and any other union or body outside is not entitled to table an amendment. They are entitled to put suggestions to Members regarding formats to deal with specific issues. It must be clearly recorded that this is not a union amendment. The amendment was put down in the name of Deputy Brennan on his party's behalf.
Comment on this
I do not wish to be in conflict with the Chairman but his statement is hardly necessary. The amendment was tabled in my name and I stand over it.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is grasping at straws. I remind him that Deputy Brian Fitzgerald asked the same question during the morning session.
Comment on this
He stated that he was unhappy and wanted clarification on the Government's position. What is the position of the Minister of State on the amendment?
Comment on this
We are at present involved in negotiation with the union. I am confident that we will arrive at an agreement and I will table amendments on Report Stage which will reflect much of the content of the amendment and, in some cases, go beyond it.
Comment on this
I am aware that the amendment was tabled in Deputy Brennan's name. Everyone received correspondence from the union and we are aware of its ideas. There is no disagreement between Deputy Brennan and myself.
Comment on this
It is obvious that if the union is putting this issue forward through correspondence to all Members, it is one of the items under negotiation with the Minister of State. The amendment was tabled for the purpose of discussion and probably reflects the direction the negotiations are taking at present.
Comment on this
We are merely trying to tease out the issue. I previously worked for a semi-State body and many people would raise serious objections about this matter. I am trying to advise the Minister of State that the view of full-time union representatives might not reflect that of the worker-directors and I urge him to be cautious. There might be give and take at the negotiating table but that may not necessarily reflect the opinion of the majority. The fact that this matter was the subject of correspondence from the union means it was discussed during the negotiations. The Minister of State should make his own independent checks because many workers would feel differently about this issue from their union representatives.
The introduction of any reduction will lead to a situation where might is right and the major union will take over all responsibilities. Members are aware that, in all semi-State bodies which have worker directors, the last seat on the board is usually given to the coalition of the smaller unions. The Minister of State will be obliged to introduce an innovative solution to protect their position. It is not a case of making a deal with the major player and throwing everyone else to the wolves.
Comment on this
The Minister of State will make a brief reply because the discussion is becoming repetitive. The matter was already discussed before during the morning session.
Comment on this
I take Deputy Ahern's advice regarding the concerns that may exist outside union officialdom. I met representatives of the worker-director group at the congress committee and we discussed the entire gamut of issues. I reiterate that the amendment reflects an opening position by the union in the area of negotiations on this issue.
Comment on this
Those points have been made. The amendment was discussed during the morning session and the debate is becoming repetitive.
Comment on this
Deputy Ahern's point about this matter being premature mirrors what I stated this morning. The negotiations should have been concluded so that the country could be informed of the position. During the morning session, we discovered a long litany of matters which must remain secret. This discussion is premature and we should not have reached this stage before the negotiations were completed.
Is it the opinion of the Minister of State that, subject to the outcome of the negotiations, his Report Stage amendment will be better than amendment No. 14? Can he assure the committee that the proportion of worker directors on the board of Telecom Éireann will not be diluted? Is there any question of a dilution of the current proportion of directors? If he can assure the committee that no such dilution is envisaged, we can proceed to consider the amendment.
Comment on this
I would be pre-empting the negotiations, which were welcomed by the other side of the House, if I were to attempt to provide such details. It is not a question of the legislation being premature; it is quite in order to continue negotiations during the legislative process and table amendments on the various Stages. If Deputy Brennan withdraws the amendment, he will have an opportunity, if he is not satisfied with the amendments I table, to re-enter it on Report Stage. I suggest he will be happy with the amendment I intend to put down.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 9, between lines 21 and 22, to insert the following subsection:
"(1) In the event of the sale or transfer of shares in the company, the proportion of employee directors in relation to the total number of directors on the Board shall remain fixed at not less than the proportion of employee directors at the date of the passing of this Act.".
The Minister quite properly made a request that I withdraw the previous amendment. I appreciate that his request was genuine but I was unable to accede to it because I could not obtain a commitment similar to that reflected by amendment No. 15, which concerns the proportion of worker directors on the board. If I had received such a commitment, I would not have pressed the amendment to a vote.
Amendment No. 15 states: "In the event of the sale or transfer of shares in the company, the proportion of employee directors in relation to the total number of directors on the Board shall remain fixed at not less than the proportion of employee directors at the date of the passing of this Act." The amendment represents a line in the sand. If the Minister of State has no agenda to reduce or dilute the proportion of worker directors on the board, he should have no difficulty in agreeing to the amendment. I will press the amendment to a vote because it goes to the nub of the issue. Diluting worker representation on the new board at the expense of Swedish and Danish interests is the wrong route to take. I will not restate the reasons the dilution is unfortunate. However, with the Programme for Competitiveness and Work, the social partnership and our method of managing change in State companies, there must be change in State companies. Such change can be managed between unions, management and the Government.
The Minister of State is aware that substantial changes were made in the ESB. While I criticised the price of those changes, I did not criticise the methodology employed which involved a tripartite arrangement for negotiations between the workers, management and the Government. Changes were managed without the loss of a single day's supply of electricity. I see no reason for breaking that social partnership approach at this juncture. If this proposal had originated with a Fine Gael Minister, I would have understood his motivation. However, it originates with a Labour Party Minister of State and I find it inexplicable that he will not accept an amendment to ensure a dilution will not occur. That will not damage the negotiations. If such negotiations began from that position, the Minister of State could accept the amendment. Otherwise, the workers will conclude, before the Report Stage debate, that it is his intention to give way and permit a dilution. If there is a hidden agenda that he may dilute their stake, he will reject the amendment and that agenda will become clear during the negotiations.
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State reply to amendments Nos. 15 and 16 as they are being taken together?
Comment on this
It is almost impossible to separate amendments Nos. 14, 15 and 16. I dealt with this matter during my earlier contribution and I will briefly repeat my arguments. Before doing so, I reassure the committee that the Labour Party and the Government have a clear policy to allow for the protection and development of State companies. This Bill forms part of that strategy. I am adamant that that continues to be the case, as are my senior colleague Deputy Lowry, the Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications, and the Government. There is no question that there is a policy of doing less than protecting and developing the companies. Other parties who expressed an opinion on this subject stated that they want to sell the companies to whoever wishes to buy them.
Comment on this
The party leader recently said something very close to that. I know there was confusion about what was stated. We have an agreement with a company which proposes to purchase a 25 per cent share in Telecom Éireann. As part of the agreement the company will receive three seats on the board. The Government is adamant that it will retain a majority shareholding — seven seats — which leaves two further places on the board.
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State explain the arithmetical formula used to arrive at that position?
Comment on this
Three seats will go to the company and the two remaining places will go to worker directors. This is contained in the Bill as it now stands but amendments will be tabled at a later stage. It is very hard to separate the amendments.
Comment on this
The amendments are so closely related that will end up discussing amendment No. 14 again.
Comment on this
It was suggested that additional members could be added to the board to solve the problem. However, a large number of additional places would have to be made available to achieve the same proportionality. I understand that, in such a scenario, the smallest number of seats on the board would be 19 or 20. Such a large body would make effective governance of the company by the board impossible. It would be broken down into various committees where the worker directors or representatives would have less input or may not be represented at all. There would be effective governance of the company by its executive which is not desirable. For that reason, the size of the board will remain at its current level. As far as I am concerned, this answers the argument and I am not prepared to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
We are involved with the Committee Stage debate on the Telecommunications Bill but the Minister of State made a statement on behalf of the Labour Party to the effect that it is committed to the protection and development of State companies. That is fine but a company is being partially privatised. Other companies under the remit of the Minister of State, such as CIE, are also being privatised. I understand the Minister of State recently made a public statement to the effect that he had not been informed by his senior colleague, the Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications, that part of CIE is being privatised.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that the policy of the Labour Party is to protect State companies and on Sunday he stated that he was not told that CIE was privatising a section of its company. If things are happening without the Minister's knowledge these statements do not count for much. There is validity in laying down a minimum number of four worker-directors on the grounds that it is usually the last position that goes to the coalition of smaller trade unions and if it is not four, the bigger unions are inclined to come in and take the main positions. Their position must be protected. It is important that all employees can claim ownership of the worker directors and see that there is potentially a major problem there. I want the Minister to agree to the amendment and accept it as a statement of fact that the numbers will be——
Comment on this
I am confused by the arguments. Amendment No. 14 advises me to have two worker-directors while amendment No. 16 advises me to have four. The Deputy has to make up his mind about what he wants.
Comment on this
I have given enough scope on this. I know Deputy Ahern's keen interest in this but he will appreciate that we had a lengthy discussion on this subject earlier and I will not allow repetition. Is Deputy Brennan pressing his amendment?
Comment on this
This is major legislation and it needs to be teased out. Why is the company getting three out of 12 seats? That is 25 per cent of the seats but it is only buying 20 per cent of the shares. Is that yet another sweetener for the foreigners?
Comment on this
That was the agreement arrived at and the company has an option on a further 15 per cent with 25 per cent of the shares.
Comment on this
The Minister is still sticking to his guns by saying that talks are going on, but in section 10 of the Bill he proposes to halve the number of the worker-directors.
Comment on this
I do not accept that the proposal I put forward which mirrors what the unions put forward has the effect of two.
Comment on this
The Minister of State said that if the company take up this option and buys the additional 15 per cent, it will not get an extra place on the board. If the workers take up the option and these negotiations work out where they get extra when they buy shares will they get an extra position based on their shareholding? If they get it, who do they take it from?
Comment on this
The level, if any, of representation arising from shareholding by trust on behalf of the workers is subject to negotiation.
Comment on this
To be eligible for election as a worker-director does that worker have to be a shareholder?
Comment on this
I simply do not understand the question. Is the Deputy talking about the potential of the trust which will be the holding body for the workers' shareholding having a right to have a director or is he talking about the ordinary worker-directors?
Comment on this
There is no question of a requirement to be a shareholder. At present a 5 per cent shareholding is spread among all company employees. This is in the Bill and may well be enhanced so I assume that all workers are shareholders. I have made no proposal that anybody other than workers would be shareholders but the Deputy's colleague has come forward with a proposal that people who are not employees of the company or even shareholders could become worker-directors.
Comment on this
That was a proposal from the Communication Workers' Union which Deputy Brennan put before the Minister of State to establish his views on it.
Comment on this
I note Deputy Molloy did not vote. Deputy Brennan, do you wish to press amendment No. 16?
Comment on this
Yes. I move amendment No. 16:
In page 9, between lines 21 and 22, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection 1 the number of employee directors shall not be reduced below 4.".
The Select Committee divided: Tá, 10; Níl, 12.
Tá
Ahern, Noel. | Kitt, Tom.
Brennan, Séamus. | Leonard, Jimmy.
Foley, Denis. | Molloy, Robert.
Fox, Mildred. | Nolan, M. J.
Keaveney, Cecilia. | Power, Seán.
Níl
Bell, Michael. | Finucane, Michael
Boylan, Andrew. | Fitzgerald, Brian.
Broughan, Thomas. | Flaherty, Mary.
Byrne, Eric. | Kenny, Seán.
Connaughton, Paul. | Sheehan, P. J.
Crawford, Seymour. | Stagg, Emmet.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 9, subsection (2), lines 33 and 34, to delete "or such shorter period as may be specified by the Minister by order" and substitute "(or such shorter period as may be specified by the Minister by order)".
This is a technical amendment. Section 10(2) provides for the deferment of the 1996 elections for Telecom Éireann employee directors by one year or such shorter period as may be specified by the Minister by order. The intention is that the elections should be deferred by one year unless the Minister makes an order specifying a shorter period. However, the current text could be read as requiring the Minister to make an order even if a one year deferment was planned. The amendment will make clear the intention outlined.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 19 to 22, inclusive, are related to amendment No. 18 and they may be taken together, Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 13, paragraph 1, lines 3 and 4, to delete "a position in the Civil Service and shall be".
The purpose of my amendment is to ensure that the person appointed as a regulator does not have to be a civil servant before his or her appointment. A member of the Civil Service could by all means apply for the post and there is no reason to suggest he or she would not do an excellent job. Once appointed the job should be independent under statute. The purpose of amendment No. 21 is to ensure that established civil servants will be eligible for appointment and, in the event of such appointment, their pensions, benefits and entitlements will be as if they were members of the Civil Service. However, they should not be full members of the Civil Service on being appointed regulator.
To have a regulator who is a full member of the Civil Service responsible to a Minister of the day would not lend itself to the regulatory system we are trying to put in place. There are many public servants who would make excellent regulators but they should be in a statutory position out of the Civil Service.
IBEC and other groups have made the point that the Bill is weak in the independence it seeks to give the regulator. The regulator should be in a more independent and stronger position. In correspondence to members of the committee, IBEC points out that the task of the regulator should include determining interconnection arrangements; commercial and technical arrangements between operators; the agreement of tariff policies, particularly in the case of a dominant operator; the establishment of numbering plans and developing a system of number portability; administering licences for providers and users of telecommunications services; a role in ensuring fair competition and management of radio frequencies allocated for public telecommunications purposes. I share IBEC's view that there are serious omissions in the Bill, particularly on the issue of interconnections, in regard to the regulator's strength.
It is possible the regulator would be a civil servant with limited powers according to IBEC's analysis with which I agree. The regulator would be a toothless wonder. My amendments will ensure that the regulator, once appointed, will be independent of the Civil Service and the Government.
Comment on this
On Second Stage the Minister gave a brief outline of the current position on telecommunications and the main features of the Government's programme for the achievement of their objectives in the sector. He referred to
. . . the further development of Telecom Éireann as a major player providing high quality telecommunications services in both monopoly services and emerging competitive markets; the establishment of an independent regulator for the telecommunications sector; and the liberalisation of the market to allow full competition.
He further stated: "With the emergence of competition in the Irish telecommunications market, it is appropriate that the regulation of the sector be seen to be independent from the Minister's shareholding and sectoral development functions". One can infer that the Minister indicated the necessity that the regulator would be independent. However, this section of the First Schedule states that the director shall be a position in the Civil Service and shall be appointed by the Minister with the consent of the Minister for Finance. Obviously, the appointment can be made by the Minister with the consent of the Minister for Finance but why is there a stipulation that the director would have to be a position in the Civil Service? This seems to run contrary to the Minister's objective that the person who holds the office will be independent of the Minister and the industry and would be seen to be in a position to act independently.
It is difficult to understand why this requirement was included in the Schedule. My amendment, in addition to a similar amendment tabled by Deputy Brennan, suggests that the first paragraph of the First Schedule should be removed. I will be interested to hear the explanation of the Minister of State of how the director, whose position will be in the Civil Service, will achieve the independence sought by the Minister, which everyone agrees is absolutely necessary.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 18 and 19 propose that the office of director will not be a civil servant and that the provisions of the 1956 and 1958 Acts will not apply to the officer of Director of Telecommunications Regulation. The Bill does not provide that a civil servant must be appointed to the position of director but merely that the position is one within the Civil Service. Civil servants and others are equally eligible to be appointed and will receive the same consideration. The functions being transferred are those which were hitherto performed within the Department and are purely regulatory in nature. Only the price capping function is new. In that regard, I remind the committee that under the Act the Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications will make a price capping order, the effect of which will be that prices for telecommunications services will be reduced by 6 per cent for the entire range of services provided by Telecom Éireann which are not subject to competition. Those services include line leasing and——
Comment on this
There are working analogues — for example, the Director of Consumer Affairs, the Valuation Commissioner and the Registrar of Titles where, either in law or in practice, the position is within the Civil Service.
In respect of the application of the Acts of 1956 and 1958 to the office of director, the provisions of the First Schedule, taken in their entirety, including the appointment and removal provisions relating to the director are designed to ensure the appropriate balance is achieved between independence on the one hand and accountability on the other. An important vehicle in ensuring that balance is transparency and fairness in any competition for the post of director. By maintaining the office within the scope of the Civil Service Commissioners Act, 1956, in particular, the Minister is in a position to request the Civil Service Commission to arrange a competitive process to identify the person to be appointed. This will be an important safeguard in ensuring that the best person is appointed to do the job and that there are no grounds for allegations of bias towards any particular interest group. I can give an assurance that the Members of this House will have the capacity to review the operations of the office of the Director of Telecommunication Regulation.
Virtually all parliamentary questions asked in relation to director's functions can be taken by the Minister. Additionally there is no reason that the director cannot be made answerable to a committee of this House — this is simply a matter for the organisation of the House. Telecom Éireann will remain accountable to the Oireachtas Joint Committee on State-Sponsored Bodies. Therefore, I oppose the proposed amendments.
Amendment No. 20 proposes that there should be no provision for reappointment of the director, as provided for in paragraph 2 of the First Schedule. There are obvious reasons for the Minister, with the Minister for Finance, wishing to retain the power to reappoint the director. The provision is permissive rather than mandatory and its removal makes no sense in practical terms. There should not be a bar on anyone having a second contract, particularly if they have done a good job. The proposed amendment would be a disincentive to attracting persons of the right calibre. Accordingly, I oppose the proposed amendment.
Amendment No. 21 proposes that established civil servants shall be eligible for appointment to the office of director and deals with the preservation of benefits and entitlements in such circumstances. While the sentiment is welcome, this provision is unnecessary. It would not be the intention of Government to bar established civil servants from applying for and being appointed to the post. It would be most undesirable and unconstitutional to have such a discriminatory recruitment procedure in place. As stated already, civil servants and outsiders are equally eligible to be appointed and will receive the same consideration. With respect to the staffing of the office itself, the Government has decided that staff will be seconded from the Department to meet the immediate requirements of the office. I confirm that the appointment procedure for the regulator will be as follows: it will be open to both civil servants and candidates from the private sector; it will be undertaken by either the Civil Service Commission or the Top Level Appointments Commission and is likely to take place before the end of the year. Accordingly, I oppose the proposed amendment.
Amendment No. 22 proposes that paragraph 9 be deleted. This paragraph should be read in conjunction with paragraph 8 of the First Schedule which provides that a person who has held the position of director is prohibited from taking up a position, where he or she may use information acquired as director, for 18 months following the termination of his or her position as director. This provision is based on the fact that the position of director will be a commercially sensitive one. The incumbent will have access to commercially sensitive information on service providers. If a person who held the post of director took up a position within the sector shortly after leaving the post, such information could be of commercial value and its use could affect the competitive position of companies in the sector. However, there is a balance to be struck here between the right of a former director to pursue a career in an area of his or her choice and the concerns already outlined. The advice I received is that a period of 18 months during which the former director is prohibited from taking up a post in the industry is reasonable.
Paragraph 9 sets out an exemption from the provisions of paragraph 8 by allowing a former director to take up a post in the Civil Service or act as a consultant to any Minister within 18 months of leaving the post of director. In this way, the expertise and experience of the director could be used without detriment to the commercial interests of any participant in the sector. Therefore, amendment No. 22 essentially prevents a former Director of Telecommunications Regulation from holding office or engaging in any employment in the Civil Service or acting as a consultant to the Minister. The impact of this provision would be to deprive the Minister of the accumulated expertise of the director if this is was what the Minister wished to employ. It would also substantially increase the impact of the bar on employment contained in paragraph 8 of the Second Schedule.
The amendment would effectively achieve nothing at the cost of a diminution in both the attractiveness of the position of director and the potential cooperation and understanding between the policy role of the Minister and the regulatory role of the director. The position of the State is different in that it represents the public interest which encompasses the entire sector, private and public. Therefore, the same conflict of interest cannot arise. There is also the consideration that it will be difficult to attract someone of the right calibre to this position if he or she cannot work in the industry after their contract expires, without a further bar on employment in the Civil Service. If the director was a civil servant before taking office, it would be especially perverse if he or she could not then return to the wider Civil Service when the contract ended. Accordingly, I oppose the proposed amendment.
On the question of the independence of the director, the most important guarantors in this regard contained in the Bill are: a statutory requirement to act in an independent manner, paragraph 10 of the First Schedule; a provision for independent exercise of virtually all regulatory functions, sections 3 and 4; a provision for the right on the part of the director to specify and receive resource requirements, section 5; a provision for funding of the regulatory office by the industry, section 6 and a capacity for the director to appoint staff to the office of the director, paragraph 12 of the First Schedule.
Comment on this
As I understand it, civil servants and non civil servants are eligible to apply for the post and I have no problem with that. The person appointed by the Minister will then become a civil servant in the event that the person appointed was not already one. Is that the position?
Comment on this
That is not the right way to do it. The independence of the office should be established under statute with proper pension and retirement facilities. The Minister of State should rethink this issue before Report Stage. It is better for the person if he is a civil servant to retire from there and take up the new statutory post under proper legislation which gives him protection. A certain loyalty to the Civil Service and one to the new office is not needed to confuse the mind of the person in charge of that office.
The Minister of State said the Minister will answer questions in the Dáil for this regulator. Is it his intention that the Minister of the day will answer in the Dáil for the regulator or will the regulator be independent of the Minister? If the Minister is to answer for him in the Dáil how can the person be independent?
The Minister of State said the Civil Service Commission will conduct the interviews. I do not follow that reasoning. The commission quite rightly interviews people for admission to the Civil Service. Why involve them with a post which should be a separate statutory post outside the service? The new director should have all the benefits and security of a civil servant.
Comment on this
I detailed how the Bill provides for the independence of the director. On the issue of Parliamentary Questions, I am worried about us, as public representatives and legislators, removing from the ambit of the House the possibility of information being sought by elected Members of the House on the operations of the director or any other such person where authority is now being shifted from the Minister to another independent person and that Deputies would be unable to ask questions in the House. It is not that the director has to report to the Minister or that the Minister has to report to the House on behalf of the director but that the Minister should be enabled to bring information to the House which he will receive from the director.
Comment on this
We are creating new animals. As a public representative, I want to have the right to raise questions in the House about the functioning of this office.
The Civil Service Commission with a long record for its transparent manner of appointing people is a good vehicle, not necessarily to do the interviews, but to arrange for the competition if the Minister so requires and this is the intention.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has not given a satisfactory explanation for seeking to ensure that the director when appointed shall hold a position in the Civil Service. We understand, as politicians and former Ministers, the traditional relationship that exists between the civil servant and his Minister and vice versa. It is stretching the imagination to expect one to accept that the Minister is transferring regulatory functions and the new function of capping with regard to prices which had been his up to now to a director-regulator of the telecommunications industry and at the same time requiring this new person to hold a position in the Civil Service. It is also stretching the imagination to expect us to accept that that person would be a free agent in the exercise of his functions. Human nature and other factors which come into play with regard to future career prospects lead one to the conclusion that it is wrong to retain this position within the Civil Service. If we are seeking independence for the person who will have to perform these functions, he should be seen to be completely free from influence, direction and suggestion of the Minister in charge of telecommunications policy. I reject the Minister’s suggestion that anybody who holds this office will be 100 per cent independent of influence from the political head of the Department if we retain this system.
The suggestion that the person who held the post is eligible for reappointment suggests that could have an influence. We have to put in as many safeguards as possible. It is dangerous to structure the position in the way suggested, and also in section 9 to suggest that the person who has held the office may gain employment in the Civil Service afterwards and could even act as a consultant to the Minister. That suggests the person can have close political association with the Minister after he has completed his term as a director of telecommunications. This person will be appointed to a position which is independent in name only and will not be independent in practice unless the person is perfect or is a saint where ordinary pressures will not have an influence on him.
I reject the Minister of State's arguments as does Deputy Brennan and IBEC which has taken a particular interest in telecommunications developments and legislation in this area. The content of this Bill and the way in which it is structured is not widely known to the general public. The general public, having carefully considered the proposals from the Minister of State, would agree with us that it should not be retained as a position in the Civil Service or that a person should be eligible for reappointment to the position. The job should be carried out independently and the person should move on when his time expires. He should not be qualified to move to a position as a consultant to the Minister immediately after completing his work. It reduces one's belief in the independence of the person holding the office. I appeal to the Minister of State to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I have not heard new arguments. It is the same argument again. The First Schedule, paragraph 10 says that the position is legally independent. It is no less than that. It is clear and it will be the law when the Bill is passed by the House. I think it is widely accepted that successive Directors of Consumer Affairs have been independent in the exercise of their duties. The Director is a civil servant, independent and seen to be so.
Comment on this
If this person comes from the Civil Service, or comes from outside and becomes a full-fledged civil servant, he or she has certain constitutional loyalties, duties and responsibilities to the Government of the day — not to the political Government but the State. This institutional rather than political loyalty to the Minister of the day could come into conflict with the person's independence as regulator, should he or she want to do something contrary to what the relevant Minister, to whom that civil servant reports, wants. Does the Minister not envisage such circumstances?
Comment on this
As with the Director of Consumer Affairs, this person is not a civil servant reporting to a particular Minister. He is a civil servant of the State within that system, which is good. I reject the implications, perhaps not intended, that civil servants are not capable of doing this independent job while remaining civil servants.
Comment on this
The Minister knows I am not saying that. I have worked with the public service for too long.
Comment on this
People are quite capable of being civil servants within the Civil Service system without reporting directly to and responsible for a Minister in this area. That is not the case here — it would be outrageous if it were — and it is not the intention.
Comment on this
Pardon my ignorance — I was in the Cabinet for four years and I should know this. Are there full-fledged, established civil servants who do not report to any Minister?
Comment on this
Is that what the Minister is putting on the record? I would like to hear a view on this.
Comment on this
They would be required to make an annual report and there would be other requirements to report.
Comment on this
It depends on the context in which the Deputy means "reporting to a Minister". They certainly do not take instructions from a Minister.
Comment on this
I presume the Minister's office would be the conduit used by the director in reporting back to Government but such civil servants do not take instructions from Ministers and it is legally stated that they are independent.
Comment on this
In the Oireachtas, civil servants such as those who service this committee do not report to a Minister.
Comment on this
I think I have given enough scope to these questions, which are becoming hypothetical. I will put the question.
Comment on this
Excuse me, Chairman, I have questions for the Minister. We are taking a number of amendments together. This legislation would not be before us but for the fact that EU Directives require us to put these procedures in place to prepare the Irish economy for the fulfilment of Union objectives to liberalise the telecommunications market——
Comment on this
——and to introduce competition. I never mentioned privatisation. To ensure competition, an independent regulator should preside over this industry, rather than a political figure such as a Minister. The Minister of State has access to this information and attends European Council meetings. How many EU member countries have so far established a director or regulator for their telecommunications industry? How many have appointed persons who are and remain civil servants while holding the position of director of telecommunications? As the British Civil Service system is the one to which we are most closely linked, is the British regulator a civil servant?
Comment on this
I understand that few countries have done what we are doing now. We are blazing a trail in this matter and taking charge rather than waiting for examples.
Comment on this
Under Lady Thatcher's Government, the British appointed a regulator who was, of course, from outside the Civil Service.
Comment on this
In the only precedent the Minister has quoted from another member country, the regulator was from outside the Civil Service.
Comment on this
I do not propose, to this committee or to anyone else, that we follow Lady Thatcher's example in this regard or any other. I am sure the vast majority in the House will agree with me. The Deputy might be isolated on this point and I am sorry for his trouble. He will not make me say that Lady Thatcher did the right thing in Britain — she made a mess of the economy and her party is suffering for it now. She sold the refuse service to the French, never mind British Telecom.
Comment on this
I think we should let Lady Thatcher rest in peace and not resurrect her here. She has nothing to do with this legislation.
Comment on this
Excuse me, Chairman, I do not want to raise my voice — I am capable of doing so if I must — but I would rather use the microphone.
Comment on this
The Minister made a statement and I take it we are allowed to respond to it. Historically speaking, one would must accept that in this matter — the introduction of competition to what hitherto was a monopoly service in most country — Europe is following what Lady Thatcher introduced in Britain.
Comment on this
The Minister is introducing legislation to implement a Thatcherite philosophy in the Irish telecommunications industry.
Comment on this
Poor Lady Thatcher is being criticised for something for which she is not responsible, Committee Stage of this Bill. I propose that we now put the question.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 13, paragraph 2, lines 9 and 10, to delete "and he or she shall be eligible for reappointment".
Comment on this
We have discussed the independence of the proposed director. Paragraph 17 of the First Schedule states that where the director is nominated as a Member of the Seanad or elected to either House of the Oireachtas, he shall cease to be the director. Can I take it that, where the director is selected or nominated as a candidate in a General Election, he can retain his position while a candidate and only ceases to be director if he is elected? That flies in the face of the independence we wish to see attached to the person holding this post. Will the Minister give his thoughts on that?
Comment on this
We have followed the language used in other Bills but I take a strong view on the point made by the Deputy. We will look at that and see if it is necessary to amend the Bill to ensure it is not possible for the circumstances mentioned by the Deputy to occur.
Comment on this
We will return to that on Report Stage. That is the content of paragraph 17(a). Paragraph 17(b) says the same thing in a different way. Why is it necessary to repeat it? There must be some reason and perhaps the Minister could explain.
Comment on this
Paragraph 17(a) applies if this happens while the person is director while (b) provides that one cannot be the director if anything listed in the paragraph has happened.
Comment on this
My party is not happy with the Bill. I wish to record my opposition to the Bill going forward in its present form.
Comment on this
My party totally objects to this Bill, particularly to the price of the shares offered to the two overseas companies and the fact that this Bill, as it now stands, reduces the number of worker directors. I also wish to clarify an earlier comment I made. I said that 20 per cent of the German telecommunications company had been floated on the stock market. Having checked the point since, the multiple achieved there was 11.4 — in other words, the sale of the company's shares realised 12 times its profits. The Minister has received less than 4 times the profits for the sale of these shares in Telecom Éireann, which bears out my point that this is a total sell out at a knockdown price. I predict that within a few years, if not months, German and Swedish investors will make a killing on this abysmal price of £183 million. For that reason among others I am trenchantly opposed to this legislation as a sell out of 20 per cent of this valuable company at one third its worth.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the Title to the Bill and it is not normal to allow a debate on it. We have already debated that subject matter in a number of amendments and Deputies have had ample opportunity to raise those points.
Comment on this
You are, if you are opposing the Title. Points have been made, do you wish to reply, Minister?
Comment on this
Before he does, I concur with Deputy Brennan. My party sees this as a scandalous sell out at a low price of a valuable national asset which has the capacity to make huge profits for the State or the owners of the telecommunications company. In the future, the greatest industrial opportunities will lie in the telecommunications area and we are handing over a substantial section of our national telecommunications company at a price which is grossly below the proper value. We have no confidence in the outcome of the negotiations which took place and the sale agreement entered into by this Government.
Comment on this
I must allow the Minister to reply. It is not normal to have a a summing up debate but having allowed two such contributions I must allow the response.
Comment on this
It was my intention to thank the Deputies opposite for their interest and co-operation in getting the Bill through Committee Stage. I reject the political cases made by the two Deputies, which are inappropriate to the Title. I am happy to stand over the deal we have made on behalf of Telecom, which will guarantee the company's future and the employment within it and will make it capable of dealing with the wolves to whom the Deputies opposite would throw Telecom and its workers, given half a chance.
Comment on this
It is clear from this discussion that the Minister is not even familiar with the terms of the deal. He does not understand the sell out which has taken place.
Comment on this
There is no question of a sell out, we have got a good deal —£530 million will be available to the company and the State arising from it. It is a good deal for the workers and the State.
Comment on this
I propose the following draft report:
The Select Committee has considered the Bill and made amendments thereto. The Bill, as amended, is reported to the Dáil.
Report agreed to.
Ordered to report to the Dáil accordingly.
Comment on this
I thank the two spokespersons, Deputy Brennan of Fianna Fáil and Deputy Molloy of the Progressive Democrats. We had a good debate over two days and I think I gave them every opportunity to express their views in detail. I thank the Minister and his officials for the manner in which his office has dealt with the Bill. I thank the convenors, my colleagues, the Clerk to the Committee and her colleagues on the staff of the House. I do not know when our next meeting will be; I had provided for a meeting tomorrow on this Bill but we have finished it more quickly than anticipated and I thank Deputies for their co-operation in that regard. I also thank colleagues who individually and collectively made excellent contributions.