We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FAMILY, COMMUNITY AND SOCIAL AFFAIRS

Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 2002: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–213 of 422. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2002
Enacted

No. 8 of 2002 ›

I welcome the Minister, Deputy Dermot Ahern, and his officials.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 1 and 14 may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 4, before section 2, to insert the following new section:

"2.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the increase in the consumer price index since the commencement of the Act of 2001 and especially the increase consequent on the introduction of the euro currency and shall compare those increases with the increase in payments under the Act of 2001.".

This amendment refers to an issue which the Labour Party and our colleagues in Fine Gael have raised continuously. Looking back over the various Social Welfare Bills there was a general feeling that the impact of inflation on social welfare recipients has not been adequately measured at any stage. It is now quite clear that the introduction of the euro coincided with a major rip-off by certain greedy firms of consumers in relation to some of the basic necessities of life. We have heard of many examples and as I said on Second Stage there was very significant inflation in relation to groceries and services in the latter part of 2001. This was not measured by anybody because the survey carried out on behalf of The Irish Times at Christmas was a meaningless exercise in relation to the multiples. In the last nine or ten weeks since then, many constituents feel there has been major inflation of prices in services and in groceries and clothing. This Minister and this Government made no effort to prevent this inflation. Our partners in the European Union seem to have different regimes in place to deal with this which include a threat of price freezing and very close monitoring of prices. The Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Deputy Kitt, has not addressed the problem seriously. The content of the Social Welfare [No.2] Bill, 2001 and this Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 2002, have been seriously eroded by what has happened in recent weeks.

Many of us were talking to constituents in the last few weeks about this and other issues. I was told of many examples of inflation in the price of goods and services which people believe was happening under the cloak of the euro. The Minister sanctioned increases in invalidity benefits and in pensions which were backdated and the famous Government €10 is probably already worth less than half of what the Minister gave. I regret this Bill and the Pensions Bill, both of which are crucial, are being guillotined. I hope we will all be Members of the next Dáil and we should aim to discuss the Estimates for 2003 in the following summer or early autumn so that Opposition Deputies in particular are given the chance to make an input. This committee will be examining last year's Estimates in the final days of this Dáil. It is in a sense a total waste of time.

The euro was arguably the most important event in our economic history since 1922 and it has huge implications for this country in the context of European development. I ask the Minister to consider my amendment and the Department to examine the real impact of euro inflation on social welfare recipients. I commended the Minister for granting basic increases last year. In that context, I ask the Minister to accept the amendment. I commend Deputy Brian Hayes for introducing a similar amendment.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

My amendment No. 14 is similar to Deputy Broughan's amendment. The Minister will be aware that we had an opportunity to deal with this matter during Priority Questions last week. I wish to tease out a number of issues to which Deputy Broughan has already referred. There is a direct responsibility on this select committee to closely monitor price inflation because it affects people on low incomes. As I have told the Minister on numerous occasions since I took over this brief, the effects of inflation are much more detrimental on such people because a substantial part of their incomes is spent directly on food. Poor people spend a much larger slice of income on basic necessities such as food and other household items than people on higher incomes. Therefore, this committee has a direct responsibility to closely assess the effects of the CPI and price inflation on the level of payments made by the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs.

One of the issues raised by several commentators, NGOs and others, including Deputy Broughan in remarks to the House last week, is that price inflation did not arise at the end of the Christmas period as we transferred to the euro banknotes and coins. Since September and through October and November, people have observed a substantial rise in prices in the shops. Many unscrupulous businesses, particularly shops, used the introduction of the new currency to heap additional costs on to customers. What we observed during the past six months was an incremental increase in prices which ate into people's basic social welfare payments.

Again, I highlight the report published last week by the Consumers' Association of Ireland which contained a further tranche of work assessing the price of a basket of items before and after the introduction of the euro. The organisation reached fairly startling conclusions in respect of price increases. The Minister informed me in the House last week that the Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Deputy Kitt, has asked an organ of the Government to investigate the matter. I am prepared to withdraw my amendment if the Minister gives a commitment to conduct his own investigation within a month to six weeks into the effects of the introduction of the euro on people who depend on social welfare payments.

This would be a good way to proceed as there needs to be exclusive research carried out on the effects of the euro on social welfare recipients, notwithstanding other work which may be taking place in other Departments. It is important because, as the Minister will be aware, his social welfare increases are predicated on a number of factors, including price inflation and general wage levels, coming together. We need to hear exactly what his plans are in respect of investigating the matter.

Although this problem may not be picked up directly in the CPI figures released today, it is certainly a problem on the streets because people say they have seen a dramatic rise in prices during the six months leading up to the introduction of the euro. I commend amendments Nos. 1 and 14 to the select committee.

Comment on this
Dermot Ahern Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs (Mr. D. Ahern) Fianna Fáil

I thank Deputies for giving me the opportunity to discuss some of the issues surrounding inflation vis-à-vis the euro and increases in social welfare payments. The fundamental point is that the social welfare increases are way ahead of and in many cases double the anticipated rate of inflation. It is important to provide figures to support this contention. Last year the inflation rate was 4.9%, down from 5.6% in 2000. Given that the main social welfare rates increased by 10.3% and 10.4% in April 2001, there were real increases of 5.1% and 5.2% last year in respect of the main rates. The CPI fell by 0.2% in January with the projected annual rate of inflation now 4.2% so, while people may say there has been an increase in the rate of inflation, we must rely on the CPI. Deputies who ask the Department to carry out its own investigation should note that we are not nor have we ever been in the business of doing this. We must, in effect, proceed on the basis of the benchmark agreed over the years, namely, the CPI.

Comment on this

On a point of information, one could consider, for example, the report by the Vincentian Partnership which examines the real case of the basket of goods bought by a woman in Tallaght and the income on which she lives. We all have questions about the CPI, which does not measure such things. I ask the Minister to measure this basket and inform the committee of the results.

Comment on this

No, this is not the remit of the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs. Organisations such as the Vincentian Partnership are entitled to carry out these kinds of studies, but the most comprehensive by far is the CPI. In 2002 if the average rate of inflation turns out to be 4.2%, one will again have real increases of between 5% and 6.9%.

Another issue which I must mention is the dramatic increases in child benefit in the past two years which, for some reason, are never considered when weekly incomes are being calculated. Last year the increase was above 50% and it will be in the region of 37% to 45% this year.

The change to the euro banknotes and coins has been raised. There is no evidence of an inflationary effect in the months preceding their introduction. Inflation was 0.8% in the three months to December 2001 which was less than the inflation rate of 1.2% for the equivalent period in 2000. As I stated earlier, inflation in January was down by 0.2% and the level of social welfare increases are roughly twice the anticipated rate of inflation, even more in many cases.

With regard to the survey by the Vincentians, the CPI is a comprehensive, professionally produced report based on the collection of more than 55,000 prices covering more than 1,000 items. As the prices of individual items rise and fall from month to month, it is a little misleading to use CPI figures when it suits and ignore them when it does not as some Deputies have done. According to the CPI, the price of a number of essential items has declined dramatically. I am sure the Deputies will agree that clothing and footwear are essential items, the price of which has fallen by 11.5% in the past month, 11.2% in the past three months and 3.1% in the past year. This is a fairly dramatic decline.

Similarly, price increases for many of the other items have not been significant, except health which rose by 2.7%. The price of clothing and footwear, as I said, fell by 11.5%, household equipment declined by 2.1%, communications increased by 1% and recreation and culture, which is not really an essential item, rose by0.9%. Generally speaking, therefore, prices of essential items have fallen.

I turn to the report of the Consumers' Association of Ireland to which Deputies referred. It is my understanding that it has not issued a report. All it has issued is a press release. Regarding the basket of goods it checked, which was last logged in December 2000, the average increase was 5% which is less than the increase of 6.1% recorded by the Central Statistics Office. I give a warning in respect of these types of surveys but the Deputy should not just take my word for it. There was a report in The Irish Times recently regarding the examples of the Consumers’ Association of Ireland and it said there was much less convincing evidence of price increases being slipped in during the currency changeover.

We have to go on the yearly consumer price index. I have said many times on Committee Stage of Bills that it is a case of swings and roundabouts. If people lose out one year, they gain in another and that losses will be taken into account in the calculations for the following year. It is a fact that people have gained dramatically in recent years from the increases in social welfare which have been way ahead of the rate of inflation, and that they have received real increases every year the Government has been in office.

Comment on this

Perhaps this is the type of area in which the Combat Poverty Agency, which made a submission to the committee recently, might engage. I referred to the Vincentians because the point they made at the end of their report was that it was not through inadequate management that the family of three I mentioned was not able to survive but because their welfare benefits were much too low, perhaps even by as much as €100. Even with the increases in child benefit, that family is probably still struggling. It could be within the remit of the Department to examine this.

The Minister referred to The Irish Times. It is a europhile newspaper and one of those media outlets which is desperately concerned in case the people vote “no” a second time to the Nice treaty. I take a slightly more sceptical view of some developments in Europe.

I also note that recreation and culture are not considered essential. I would have thought they would be.

Comment on this

They are not essential in the same sense as food, clothing and footwear.

Comment on this

Children might like to go swimming or play games.

Comment on this

Perhaps they should do what we used to do and go in the tide.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister is not recommending that.

Comment on this

I am. My children do it all the time.

Comment on this

Is this not the issue?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

They could go out with the tide.

Comment on this

This discloses a certain attitude. For example, one child in the family to which I referred might not like the Celtic football team's away strip.

Comment on this

That is hardly an essential. It is changed almost every three months.

Comment on this

I am not aware it is. However, this is about quality of life in the community.

Comment on this

I would rather see them wearing a Dundalk FC or a Louth jersey. It would be cheaper too.

Comment on this

There is a fundamental difference between us on this. I am still of the opinion that the Minister should accept the amendment. It would be helpful to the next Administration if he took this issue more seriously.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It is good to hear that inflation is falling and that, on the recreation and culture front, I can tell my constituents in west Tallaght to go to the ballet or the National Concert Hall in the next few weeks. The reality is that people are telling us that, in their own experience of shopping, they have seen an incremental rise in prices. I accept that is not reflected in the CPI.

Does the Minister have any input into the work the Minister of State, Deputy Tom Kitt, is undertaking? He is conducting the most extensive survey since the introduction of the euro. Would it be possible for part of that work to relate exclusively to social welfare payments? It would have some effect. I do not suggest it should be the most rigorous survey, but the committee would learn a great deal from part of the Minister of State's work being directly related to social welfare payments and how those have been affected by the introduction of the euro.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

For the Minister to say he has given a net increase of 5% to social welfare recipients after a boom should not be a source of pride for him. Even in tough times Ministers gave increases in social welfare. We hear about the large increases people received, but 5% of £70 or £80 is nothing. The Minister has rattled out figures for all that social welfare recipients have received in recent years but this was at a time when we were able to repay our national debt. Whatever Minister is in office next year would do a marvellous job if he gave a net increase of 5% given that we do not appear to have the great economic boom we once had.

I support what my colleagues said. I do not know if people exaggerate because I do not go shopping. I met a couple last week who told me that, as far as they were concerned, their money was gobbled up by the increases. That might be a slight exaggeration but people are convinced prices have increased. The surveys conducted by the Vincentians and others are much like the argument which has been ongoing in recent weeks in that one can take one course of action or another and achieve the same end. Perhaps these surveys are confusing us as to what price increases have taken place in that they have their own slant.

Comment on this

As regards what the Minister of State, Deputy Kitt, is doing, I know both he and the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment will answer questions today relating to this issue. They say the figures clearly do not support suggestions that there has been widespread or excessive increases in prices during the changeover to the euro or because of its introduction. They also make the point that the Director of Consumer Affairs received 293 complaints in the first week of the changeover but these had reduced by the middle of February to 17 a week. Only 40 of these related to the implementation of the euro. No Government since the early 1980s has introduced price controls. They have tended to allow the competitive element of the market dictate prices.

Deputy Browne may find fault with that I say, but it is a fact that there have been real increases in social welfare payments, something which has not been the trend over the years. He may say more money was available, but it depends on how spending is prioritised. The Government has had the opportunity in its lifetime to prioritise substantial amounts of money for the social welfare budget which has increased from £4.5 billion to the equivalent of £7.5 billion today. This has meant more money in people's pockets.

Much of what people feel about price rises could have been engendered by certain media comments and by people who do not have any empirical evidence. The best evidence and indicator we have is the CPI which is time-honoured. No Government of whatever political hue has adopted any other yardstick. I gave the figures earlier for the CPI which were the result of a comprehensive survey. That is the best we can go on. I cannot stop the Combat Poverty Agency or anyone else conducting their own surveys, but I hazard a guess that they would not be as comprehensive as the CPI.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister of State, Deputy Tom Kitt, is replying to a question in the House today. I thought he was conducting some research over the next two or three months in this area. Is the Minister saying this the outcome of the research?

Comment on this

No, it is in relation to the trends they have been looking at over the last three months of last year.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Can the Minister ensure in his discussions with Deputy Kitt that part of that work will relate specifically to the effects on social welfare recipients?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy could table a parliamentary question to Deputy Tom Kitt and ask him that but we would not have any involvement in that because we are responsible for provision of social welfare. All income would be treated the same by a Department like his in connection with the examination of the CPI. There would be no difference and I do not know how they could pick it out.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Consumption patterns among social welfare recipients are totally different to others.

Comment on this

The items are food and alcoholic beverages, tobacco, clothing and footwear, housing, water, electricity, furnishings, health, transport, communications, recreation, culture and education, restaurants and hotels - which could be excluded - but it is swings and roundabouts. If one excluded non-essential items one would find that the CPI would go down much faster.

Comment on this

The proportion of income spent on basic items in the CPI basket is huge for families on low incomes. That is the problem. There are questions to be asked about the way the CPI measures housing costs and I have always had grave concerns about it, particularly when they moved to Cork. It would be a good exercise for Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs to take a special look at that area. How can they adequately advise the Minister on income increases if they do not look at the direct impact on the general groups of social welfare recipients and what has happened in the past year? There are countless examples.

From monitoring groceries I noted last summer and autumn the way prices increased. Some of the people working on the dispensing machines in various hotels and so on showed me how operators were adding two or three cents to the basic price of a given product. This was entirely due to the euro and was a totally unnecessary rip off. The Consumer's Association of Ireland, the Irish Independent and the Sunday Independent, who have been following this issue, are referring to “rip-off Ireland” and it is not just because we can at last see that the price of a pint is in Brussels is about half what it is in Dublin.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy saying the price of a pint in Brussels is half what it is in Dublin?

Comment on this

One of my colleagues said that a pint of lager is €1.80.

Comment on this

I will have to call witnesses who are in Brussels more often than we are.

Comment on this

We can see that many products - although cars are a special case - are more expensive here that in the UK and they have had numerous campaigns about "rip-off Britain". I do not want to continue with this subject because it is going into other territory but the Minister has responsibility.

Comment on this

Deputy Broughan mentioned the UK. I live five miles from the Border and I can assure him that about one in three people who shop in my town are from the North and they are shopping for petrol and other goods. The range of items that the CPI examines is very comprehensive. Health has gone up 2.7% - people on social welfare will inevitably have a medical card. Recreation and culture is significant, and alcohol is up 9%. They are all fairly dramatic increases. Tobacco is up 5%. Generally the ones showing a higher increase do not necessarily - this is not exclusive - refer to people on social welfare.

Comment on this

Insurance does.

Comment on this

Insurance is not included in the CPI and people on social welfare would not have major insurance costs in any case.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 2 and 25 are related and may be taken together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 4, before section 2, to insert the following new section:

"2.-The Minister shall report to both Houses of the Oireachtas on a proposal that social welfare increases shall not be taken into account for income assessment purposes in medical card applications.".

This relates to the concerns everybody in this House has particularly for older medical card holders. For a considerable time it seemed the increases in social welfare were taking people above the upper limits for their family size in relation to medical cards. The Minister made a statement on this and we spoke about poverty proofing. As I said when we were talking about the Social Welfare (No. 2) Bill, the only poverty proofing exercise we got in the budget was the two pages that were stuck in the middle of the Budget Statement which were very uninformative. The Minister, in his review of the NAPS plan, has made a specific commitment to have a more serious poverty proofing exercise across the Government with social inclusion units in each Department led by the Minister's own office for social inclusion. I welcome that but it is a pity it has not operated up to now.

Medical card applications are at the discretion of the chief executive of the health board and various expenses can be taken into account. We saw many examples of this as the media covered pensioners in Dublin's south inner city who felt very hard done by in this regard. In future, the Minister might accept that the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs will not introduce increases - welcome as they are - without ensuring the Department of Health and Children and the health boards are up to speed and moving at the same pace towards improving people's entitlements.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I referred to this in the course of my remarks on Second Stage and there was a great deal of confusion, largely because of a failure by the Department of Health and Children to issue exact guidelines. In that respect, the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs has a responsibility when he is increasing social welfare rates. Clearly there is a responsibility on all Departments in terms of new guidelines to ensure secondary benefits, such as medical cards, which are so important to poorer people are not lost. The fact is that for the first two months, they were. Relate published by Comhairle and sent to our offices has medical card income guidelines in the back and it says that "in practice the chief executive officers of health boards in consultation with the Department of Health and Children draw up income guidelines each year." There is, therefore, a direct responsibility on Government. Some weeks ago, when this hit the fan, there was an attempt at the heart of Government to dump on the health boards. The Department, which set the guidelines in the first week of January and issued them to the 11 health boards, got it wrong. Someone must take responsibility for that, either the Minister for Health and Children or the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs who is responsible for social welfare increases.

I join Deputy Broughan in congratulating the many organisations who contacted my office in early January. Members may be aware of a europhile paper in which Fintan O'Toole wrote about this issue referred in glowing terms to the Minister, as usual. As the Minister is aware, this was a real problem in January because of the failure of the Department of Health and Children to clarify the matter. There are three examples of this. Let us first look at the carer's allowance for people under 66 years of age. Prior to 1 January 2002, payment was €112.37 while the medical card income limit for single people aged up to 66 years and living with families amounted to €113.01. Prior to 1 January that person was entitled to a medical card. Subsequently, when the carer's allowance for people under 66 was introduced the Government stated that the new guidelines would be for a payment of €117, even though the social welfare increase had brought the payment up to €122. This is a classic example of where people lost out. Prior to 1 January, the old age contributory pension for people aged 66 to 69 was €134 but, as the medical card income limit was €138, these people qualified. Since 1 January, the payment increased to €147.30 while the new income threshold is €144.

This has caused absolute confusion. I echo Deputy Broughan's comments. Who is responsible for this? Is it the case that the Minister announces the new rates of social welfare and no one in his or other Departments are aware of the secondary benefits? This causes untold confusion and hardship for people with these important secondary benefits. I welcome the opportunity to flesh out this serious issue for people on small incomes who are discommoded as a result of this bureaucracy, which is what it is. I would be interested to hear the Minister's reply in this regard.

Comment on this

The increases were too generous. Does the Minister not realise all the trouble he caused?

Comment on this

I was just coming to that point. One the one hand, Deputies are complaining about the large increases being eroded by inflation and, on the other, that this has only become an issue in the last number of years because the increases have been way ahead of the rate of inflation. It is a fact that last year and this year there was agreement among the two Departments, including the two Ministers, that the impact of social welfare increases, which were twice the rate of inflation this year and more or less the same last year, would not impact on anyone's medical card. The Government's decision in this regard both last year and this year was communicated to the health boards. Unfortunately, there was some confusion. It probably came about because there had to be some balance in media reports. The news was so good in regard to the large increases and lump sums that the media almost felt honour bound to include some negativity. Therefore, they fleshed out and door-stepped a number of people who obviously did not know what they were talking about.

Comment on this

It seems like the Minister is saying people were invented.

Comment on this

As a result of those media reports the Minister for Health and Children decided to put out a statement from his Department confirming that the recent social welfare increases would not lead to the loss of medical cards for anyone. He basically said that medical card coverage would continue as set out under the national health strategy. I had a suspicion that some people in my constituency might have been affected. However, they did not come to anything because, in effect, the health board did not take these medical cards just as a result of the social welfare increases. I accept there was some confusion but people have a responsibility to check the facts before they put on air people who obviously do not know what they are talking about.

Comment on this

We all had people coming to us in regard to the renewal of their cards.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy allayed their fears.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy told themthe dramatic increases the Government introduced——

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The difference is they do not believe the Minister.

Comment on this

Obviously officials would listen to representations from politicians, some of whom might be members of the board in question. This is a grey area which is why some people, including my party, believe the system should be changed dramatically. The net point is that there should be clear guidelines regarding increased income limits from the Department of Health and Children, which is what members on this side are asking for. Apparently the Minister for Health and Children had a big row with the Minister for Finance on what should be done in regard to the health system prior to the general election. Clearly this is the number one issue. It is an issue for another committee because the bickering is continuing. The Minister, Deputy McCreevy, put his foot down in regard to the cost of medical services for medical card holders, as we know from meeting people on a weekly basis. My demand before Christmas was for a basic social welfare payment of €127. The Minister, Deputy Martin, should have indicated clearly all the rates, including carer's allowance, contributory pensions for people aged over 66 and so on.

The review of the NAPS programme, which is an interesting document, indicates that the office for social inclusion should have a remit which would ensure this type of thing would never again happen. I believe people got on to the newspapers complaining they had lost their medical cards and that the Minister, Deputy Ahern, had left them in a worse off position. That is the bottom line. These people would have been worse off after receiving the €10 increase, which is not acceptable.

Comment on this

No one lost the medical card as a result of the social welfare increases. I challenge the Deputy to name someone who has lost the medical card purely as a result of the social welfare increases. In regard to the disparaging remarks about the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, it was a Government decision. He was adamant that the increases this year and last year, over twice the rate of inflation, would not have an impact on people with medical cards. Rather than showing negativity in regard to this matter, and adding to the confusion engendered by certain people, the Deputy should assure people they will not lose their medical cards. I accept people were worried. However, when the matter was looked into it was obvious people were not losing their medical cards.

Comment on this

I recall someone who had a heart transplant being concerned about this matter, which is unbelievable.

Comment on this

I cannot stop people being concerned. It is up to politicians to reassure people as to the facts. The facts are that people will not be deprived of their medical cards solely on the basis of the dramatic social welfare increases. There may be circumstances where other pensions or incomes may have increased but people will not lose their medical cards solely as a result of social welfare payments increasing by twice the rate of inflation.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

As I said on Second Stage, the home carer's tax credit is a direct example of where people up to now——

Comment on this

That is a different issue.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It is an example.

Comment on this

That is a different issue.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It is not the same, but increasing social welfare rates, particularly in respect of the home carer's tax credit, means that some lose the credit which their spouse could get through their income. In respect of that credit, income from part-time work has put people over the limit. The income limit for the home carer's tax credit was not increased by the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy. It is not true to say that no one has lost out, because they have. I can provide the Minister with cases in point.

Comment on this

I expressed my opinion in relation to medical cards, about which we were talking.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

On the issue of medical cards, the Minister has accepted that someone somewhere got it wrong. Presumably, he is pointing in the direction of the Department of Health and Children. As his own Department's publication states, the income guidelines are drawn up in consultation with the Department of Health and Children. Therefore, someone is responsible. We have tabled the amendments to highlight the fact that we do not have a sophisticated interdepartmental mechanism to work on issues such as this. We are also highlighting the need for greater prudence and concentration by all concerned to ensure this does not recur.

Comment on this

The only ones responsible for people being worried are those who engendered the confusion by incorrect information.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Is the Minister suggesting that the information given to me from the organisation in question was incorrect?

Comment on this

Which organisation?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It was the South Inner City Community Development Association which wrote to me, on 14 January, citing three specific cases where the income threshold was actually lower than the new rates of social welfare as outlined in the budget.

Comment on this

I do not know about the three individual cases, but the Government decision was that no one was to lose out. I expect that decision would have been transmitted to the health board. In my constituency I was contacted by a number of persons who believed they were going to lose out as a result. However, when I got down to the nitty-gritty I found that they were not losing out. If any of them did - I think one or two might have - it was not because of the increase in social welfare, but because of the increase in their additional income.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Does that not emphasise the point - first made by former Senator Joe Lee when I was a Member of the Seanad - that Government policy initiatives do not involve one Department, but frequently two, three or four?

Comment on this

It is really only relevant to last year and this year because the increases in social welfare were much larger than they had been prior to then. That is the reason the Government made a decision that it would not have implications for the secondary benefit of a medical card.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Clearly, that has not been communicated down the line.

Comment on this

I am responsible for social welfare. If the Deputy has any queries relating to other Departments, he should make them elsewhere.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 4, before section 2, to insert the following new section:

"2.-The Minister shall report to both Houses of the Oireachtas on a proposal that social welfare increases shall not be taken into account for income assessment purposes in assessing local authority differential rents.".

This is closely related to the previous amendment. It concerns complaints that I frequently receive from constituents that what the Government gives with one hand, local authorities take away with the other. The Chairman and I are members of the same local authority and are well aware of how the system works. We had an input into framing the current differential rents scheme which operates at about 15% of an income increase. A significant part of a social welfare increase for low income families is diluted each year by additional housing costs. This applies, in particular, to constituencies on the north side of Dublin, even though the rent added to a local authority house could amount to a lot of money. In other words, the community significantly subsidises the rent of such properties in particular areas. Members of my party around the country believe the annual impact of housing costs should be re-examined because local authority housing departments are quick to jack up rents. On Dublin City Council there used to be an annual ritual when Deputy Gregory and others had a heated debate about rent increases. However, that does not happen any more since we introduced the current system. Nonetheless, rents do rise and can pose a serious problem to large families. The Minister should take this matter into account.

The Department of the Environment and Local Government and local authorities should take cognisance of this problem also. In the NAPS report the Minister made the point that social inclusion units were to be incorporated in local authorities. Over the past six months some authorities, including my own, Fingal County Council, have begun to deal with social inclusion issues in a coherent way. I welcome this work. When departmental officials are framing social welfare increases for next year they should liaise with local authorities, particularly concerning areas of grave deprivation in cities, towns and even rural areas. In that way the problems facing particular areas could be more readily identified. The situation is somewhat different in Dublin City Council which covers a population of 500,000. Perhaps the same regime does not suit all categories. I have moved the amendment because a number of my colleagues wished the Minister to consider it.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I tabled this amendment last December when we discussed the matter, but have not resubmitted it for Committee Stage. I agree with Deputy Broughan that the differential rents scheme does not make any difference to those on low incomes. The amount of rent an unemployed person pays can vary from one local authority to the next. Even though people receive universal benefits from the social welfare system, in many cases they lose out because of rent differences. This problem arises every year at local authority level. As it can take an inordinate amount of time to alter rents due to changed circumstances, those on low incomes can face huge rent arrears. The differential rents scheme operated by local authorities is very unsophisticated, which is a problem. At one level there is increased income, yet at another people lose out due to increasing rents.

As the Minister will be aware, for quite some time there has been a proposal that responsibility for the operation of the health board rent supplement scheme should be transferred to local authorities. However, because of IR difficulties that has not yet happened. That would be the most sensible route to take in order to bring housing benefits, whether in the public or private rented sector, under the one roof. It should happen in local authority housing departments. I support the amendment.

Comment on this

On the latter issue, the Government made a decision some time ago to transfer part of the responsibility for rent allowance or mortgage supplements to local authorities. However, as the Deputy said, there are major difficulties.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

For four years.

Comment on this

No matter who is in government after the next general election, it will probably take even longer to resolve because they are quite difficult issues. One is dealing with two different cohorts of civil servants, public servants who are not on the same rate of pay and have different conditions. I raised the issue with the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. I understand that in general, differential rents represent less than 11% of the social welfare payments. His Department has advised local authorities to ensure that rent increases do not absorb an excessive amount of increase in income from tenants on low incomes, in particular, old age pensioners. As a general guideline, local authorities were advised that no more than 15% of any increase in such pension income should be absorbed by an increase in rent.

There are nine social inclusion pilot project areas in tandem with the RAPID programme and they set out the strategic objectives relating to the issue of social inclusion strategies at local level. I agree with Deputy Broughan that it is probably the best way to ensure that people on low incomes and low rents enjoy as much of the benefit of the social welfare increases as is possible. One of the driving forces behind my view in backdating the payments to 1 January was that it would help social welfare recipients on differential rents. This would provide them with some additional income.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

The Minister refers to bringing back the payments to 1 January. What will be the effect next January? Will it be necessary to bring it back to November in order to show a gain or is this just a once-off gain as it was a once-off loss when it was postponed to October? The impression is given that this will be a permanent gain but it will only be a gain in this year, provided the payments are made from January again next year. January to January is a twelve-month period as is April to April. I asked this question in my speech on Second Stage but the Minister did not explain that at the time because he was telling us about what he did as Minister.

Comment on this

January is still three months earlier than April and it will be the same next year.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

How will that be? Perhaps the Minister will explain.

Comment on this

We are dealing with something which will be the subject of amendment later on. I wonder if the Deputy cannot see the benefit for people in budget year. I know the Deputy is retiring and he will not have to worry about the issue of budget year increases but I can assure him that it costs the taxpayer money to do what we have done. When I came to office the payments were made in mid-June. In my early years as Minister I had to battle with the Minister for Finance and his Department in relation to budget year costs. It cost about £80 million to bring the payments back to January this year. That money must be found in order for the payments to be paid at the earlier date. It will mean that when there is a budget takes in December of this year, people will be paid for 52 weeks of the year in the first year and thereafter for every 52 weeks of the year. People are gaining from this measure. If a future Government decided in the budget at the end of the year that the payments would be put forward again, then, obviously, the recipients would lose out.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil did that before.

Comment on this

So did the Deputy's Government. I remind the Deputy that the only time the Christmas bonus was ever interfered with in a negative way was when his party was in office. The Deputy should therefore not lecture me now.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

Clearly the Minister did not listen to what I said. I pointed out that there was a gain in the first year only. It cost the State money to bring the payments back from April to January. Many of the Minister's colleagues are giving the impression that this will be a bonanza every year. A payment from April to April is a twelve month payment.

Comment on this

It is being paid earlier.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

It is being paid earlier this year but next year will not count as an earlier payment because the year will be from January to January. It is a great cock and bull story. A twelve month period of time is always twelve months.

Comment on this

The people who got the payments do not see it that way.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

I acknowledge that they gained this year.

Comment on this

We were making that point in the year we did it.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. J. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

The Minister did not hear what I said.

Comment on this

Deputy Ring was shouting too much at the time.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. J. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

No, it was because the Minister was not listening.

Comment on this

The next Government will bring child benefit back to 1 January.

Comment on this

The Deputy's record is not great on that issue.

Comment on this

That is a pledge to the electorate.

Comment on this

The Deputy's record on child benefit payments is not one to be shouted from the rooftops.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I have only been here a few years but there is a presumption that there are votes to be got from this. I have long since come to the conclusion that there are no votes in this matter, one way or the other.

Comment on this

I suggest the Deputy has a little word with some of his pollsters doing private polls.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I speak to them all the time.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 4, before section 2, to insert the following new section:

"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing a system of benchmarking or indexation of all social welfare payments and benefits as advocated by the Final Report of the Social Welfare Benchmarking and Indexation Group.".

This amendment offers a last opportunity to ask the Minister about his position on the final report of the benchmarking and indexation group. I am interested to hear the Minister's views on the benchmarking of social welfare payments. A very serious proposal for the introduction of a basic income was put forward by Father Seán Healy and CORI in the period before the 1997 general election and different economists have passed judgment on that proposal. The Attorney General rubbished the concept that every citizen - man, woman and child - would start off with a basic income. It has been sad to watch how that proposal has been kicked around and every time it fell into the Minister's hands he kicked it into touch, as they say in rugby parlance.

The Minister at one stage mentioned a Green Paper on the subject. We on the Opposition benches have much less research resources to call on and it is very difficult to study how other countries have chosen to deal with this issue. We were looking forward to a Green Paper and a White Paper but at the end of five years nothing has happened except the report under the aegis of the PPF. I understand the voluntary sector and the trade unions insisted on the 27% target.

The Minister and the Taoiseach advocated a very low rate of basic social welfare increase by the year 2007. The trade union movement will enter the next partnership agreement - if there is one - with very strong demands and we will hear their opinion on last year's euro inflation when negotiations begin on the next programme. Despite the wails from IBEC there will be significant wage increases. What is the outgoing Government's commitment in this regard, given that it wasted five years and did not take seriously the proposal for a basic income. Basically, the Administration rejected it out of hand and only in its final weeks does it appear to be giving some commitment in this area.

I have given the Minister credit. I believe, for instance, that his allocation of social welfare increases has improved matters. As Mr. Jim Walsh and his colleagues in the Combat Poverty Agency informed the committee a few weeks ago, if the measures on poverty in this year's budget had been introduced in each of the past five years, the Minister would be fondly remembered. However, given that he let three and a half to four years pass before introducing these baseline figures, the overall result can be described as foot dragging and a disappointment.

What are the Minister's views on the fundamental benchmark? The positive feature of the measures he introduced this year and last year is that it will be very difficult for the next Government to introduce an annual increase of less than €10. This applies to every Government of whatever shape, including a Fianna Fáil-Fine Gael coalition with myself in opposition again, having been lucky enough to get re-elected. I give the Minister full credit for this because, clearly, every party in opposition will go ballistic if the €10 target is not reached. To that extent, he has established, at long last, something of an income related benchmark.

Nevertheless, the overall effect of the measures is somewhat disappointing given that Father Healy of CORI, the ESRI and other independent economists indicated beforehand that it was necessary to try to close the gap between the diverging sections of our society. While I do not what to stray from the matter in hand, the real issue the Minister failed to address in building an inclusive society is relative poverty. Unlike consistent poverty, which appears to be on the way out, relative poverty was not addressed. Is it possible he will accept this and give a clear indication, in the last weeks of the Administration, of where he stands on the issue of benchmarks for the next five years?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

May we discuss amendmentNo. 5?

Comment on this

I have no objection.

Comment on this

As it is not officially linked to this amendment, we cannot discuss them together even though I accept they touch on one another.

Comment on this

The Deputy must promise not to speak on amendment No. 5.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I will speak on amendmentNo. 4 and refer to amendment No. 5 because they relate to the same issue. I agree with Deputy Broughan that the proportion of spending on social welfare this year was much higher than in other years. The reason was that the Government finally got the message, such was the outcry about many of the regressive tax proposals it has adopted to date.

During my Second Stage speech, I said we should recognise that the Minister managed to obtain greater funding for the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs this year. However, this occurred in the last year of the Government and, while we all recognise the radical reductions achieved in consistent poverty levels in the past five years or thereabouts, the big challenge facing the country in relation to poverty is the dramatic increase in relative income poverty.

As the Minister will be aware, two of his Cabinet colleagues dumped on the benchmark report when it was published. We then had a kind of interregnum period during which no decision was taken on the matter. On the face of it, the formulation on the commitment to achieve the 30% threshold between now and 2007, as outlined in the new national anti-poverty strategy, Building an Inclusive Society, seems clear, but on delving into it, one requires further clarity. We need to address the issue of potential growth in income because, until now, social welfare increases have been predicated on projected inflation over a defined period.

In his speeches to the House this year and last year, the Minister addressed wages for the first time. The problem is whether we will reach the 30% benchmark by 2007. As I understand it - perhaps the Minister will clarify the matter - the latest figures on the composition of average industrial earnings relate to September 2001. The lowest rates of social welfare payments on that date amounted, I believe, to about 25% of gross average industrial earnings. We need to increase this to about 30% by 2007 which, according to the NAPS review, would be between €148 and €154 in 2002 terms. The question is whether it is possible to reach the 30% threshold without a guarantee of a year on increase in social welfare payments in excess of the growth in industrial earnings. In other words, if wage inflation is supposed to be 8% or 9%, the Minister would have to commit himself to frame increases of 10% or 11% in social welfare payments in the budget to arrive at the 30% figure.

The explanation of this in the NAPS review is quite clumsy. Although the Minister has not stated whether he supports the majority recommendation, we know two of his colleagues do not. The formulation he used is neither clear nor to the point. He has an opportunity to inform the committee of his position. Unless there is an annual increase in social welfare rates ahead of projected growth in earnings for next year, we will not achieve the 30% threshold and we need further clarity on the matter.

While I recognise the improvements which would be brought about by the Minister's proposals to do something additional for people on the lowest rate of social welfare, that is, those on unemployment assistance, unless there are commitments for the next four to five years, we will not reach the 30% threshold.

Comment on this

The debate on my attitude to benchmarking has been described as the "phoney war". The big report was in December and fed into the NAPS as we were developing it. The Government very wisely chose the benchmark people who understand - the €150 in 2002 terms for 2007 - because generally speaking the ordinary punter does not understand percentages. It is very clear to people who have responded to the NAPS review, for instance, Father Sean Healy, who described it as a major breakthrough, and the National Women's Council, that the Government deserves to be complimented for, in effect, benchmarking social welfare payments. It is a fairly dramatic move and will, as Deputy Hayes stated, mean substantial increases in social welfare in the next few years, regardless of who is in government.

In recent years all social welfare payments, in particular pensions, have increased ahead of average industrial earnings. I have figures on the CPI which show, for example, that the income of a couple with two children who are receiving social welfare and child benefit has risen from a baseline of 100 points in 1992 to 183.1 points in 2002, whereas the CPI has risen to 132 from a baseline of 100 during the same period. This is a dramatic increase and I reiterate that the major increases in social welfare have occurred in the past four to five years and did not increase during the previous period.

On the issue of the national anti-poverty strategy and the direction we should take, it is very ambitious and I imagine that not even Opposition Deputies would have thought that we would have chosen what is, in effect, the equivalent of a 30% benchmark. I understand Fine Gael at one stage suggested that it would opt for 27%, but was perhaps outsmarted by the Labour Party which opted for 30%. No matter what Government is in office after the general election, I hope it accepts this benchmark, much as we did with the national anti-poverty strategy and the conservative benchmarks or issues targeted in that, although I accept that it was, to a certain extent, manoeuvring in the dark. Obviously the national anti-poverty strategy review target will form part of any renegotiation of or any new partnership agreement which will be put together at the end of the year or into the new year.

One aspect of the national anti-poverty strategy review which has not received much publicity is the issue of child income support, the appropriate equivalence level of which would be at 35% of the minimum adult social welfare payment rates. This again is a significant commitment over and above an already significant investment in the form of the three year programme on child benefit increases which has been implemented over the past two years and, I hope, will be next year.

I am not at odds with the Deputies. I agree with what they say. It will be a matter for the Government of the day to increase social welfare up to the level - €150 in 2002 terms - by 2007.

Comment on this

What does the Minister expect the figure to be in 2007? What is his best guess at this stage?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It will be 30% of gross average industrial earnings.

Comment on this

The estimate of costs is in the region of £1.5 billion for the overall rates. I am unsure as to the cost of child benefit, but it is not as large.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Can we take it from the Minister's reply that the Government agrees with the majority recommendation of the social welfare benchmarking report?

Comment on this

That is £1.5 billion in 2002 terms.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It is the issue, is it not?

Comment on this

We cannot forecast.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

That is the problem.

Comment on this

It is not possible to forecast regarding 30% of average industrial earnings. Those may decrease. I would have thought the commitment of an actual equivalent amount in 2007 is a much more definite commitment than 30% of average industrial earnings. If we go into recession, which I do not believe we will, the increase in average industrial earnings would fall and people would lose out. The figure of €150 is a much higher bar for any Government to reach.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Is it correct that the Government accepts the majority recommendation of the benchmarking report?

Comment on this

The major report fed into the national anti-poverty strategy review and that document will supersede any other report which has been published.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Does the Government accept the recommendations?

Comment on this

Our benchmark is €150.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Is that in 2002 terms?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

They are not the same. This is the point I have been making, that the Government's recommendation may not take into consideration the year-on-year uprating in the increase in gross average industrial earnings whereas the majority recommendation in the benchmarking report did. Is that not the difference?

Comment on this

That is why the Minister put it in euro. That was very clever.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to the fact that we put the target into actual amounts?

Comment on this

We did so because ordinary people would understand it, just like they understood the commitment we gave prior to the previous election that we would——

Comment on this

They also understand percentages.

Comment on this

I am not sure they do. Fr. Seán Healy does not have a problem, and stated as much in an article he wrote. The Deputies present have often waved his yellow sheets at me after the budget. I remember in the first budget that I had to point out to him that his yellow sheets were wrong and that he had misread the budget. To be fair to the man, he accepted he had miscalculated.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Is this the article in the europhile newspaper?

Comment on this

He obviously misled the Deputies opposite by his miscalculation. They are quick to use his critique of the budget. He said the key target on income in NAPS states that the lowest rates of social welfare will reach €150 in 2002 terms by 2007. I hope the Deputy understands that.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I thank the Minister for sending me the report three days afterwards.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy had the opportunity of a day to examine this document. He whittled out a press release, obviously without reading the contents of the report.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I did not receive a copy of the report. The Minister did not invite me to the launch. I would have been present.

Comment on this

The Minister did a Tánaiste on it.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I received it three days later. When did the Deputy receive it?

Comment on this

Deputy Hayes would have had an opportunity to examine my statement. Fr. Seán Healy said that, in 2002 terms, the sum of €150 euro is equivalent to 30% of gross average industrial earnings. Fr. Seán Healy accepts that.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

If Fr. Seán Healy were present, we would ask him a few questions, but the Minister is present, so we will ask him instead. Does the Government accept the majority recommendation of the benchmarking report?

Comment on this

No, the Government has subsumed that document into its commitment to €150 euro which it believes——

Comment on this

That is how one makes changes in the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

We do not just blandly——

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

Why does the Government not accept the recommendation?

Comment on this

That is because certain views were expressed on different issues in this regard. There was not unanimity. The Government must ultimately make decisions. Many reports have fed into the national anti-poverty strategy, not all of which have been blandly accepted. That is perhaps the difference with this Government. We make our own decisions based on advice.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It should just keep doing that.

Comment on this

We do not blandly accept advice or suggestions given by outside bodies.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Am I correct in saying that, based on September figures, the lowest rate of social welfare at present represents 25% of average industrial earnings?

Comment on this

It was 25%.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Therefore, we must increase one percentage point each year for the next five years to get to 30%. There is a problem which begs a question, and if Deputy Broughan were to be the next Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs, I would ask him the same question.

Comment on this

That would be great.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

Deputy Hayes would be in charge of the Department of Finance and would not give him the money.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

In the words of another, I will probably be growing chrysanthemums.

Comment on this

The Deputy is getting as bad as Senator O'Dowd.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

When the Minister is framing——

Comment on this

Obviously my charms put a spoke in the wheel. All politics is local, obviously.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

When the next Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs frames his budget——

Comment on this

Or her.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

——for the package of measures in social welfare, it will be predicated on the growth in industrial earnings for the next year. Is that not correct? Until now the package has been framed on the basis of the expectation for inflation. If we are to be serious in our commitment to this new benchmark, from now on, when the Minister makes his predictions for next year, he will have to include projected average industrial earnings increases for that year, if he is logical about the benchmarking. Is that not correct?

Comment on this

Sorry, what was the Deputy saying?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The point I make is that, when the Minister frames increases in future, it will not just be on the basis of the consumer price index but also on the projected increases in average industrial earnings for the year ahead. For example, if wage inflation is 8%, the Minister will have to give increases to the lowest social welfare recipients of more than 8%, that is, 9% or 10%. Is that not the logical consequences of what he said if one accepts the benchmark?

Comment on this

We estimate the increase in the cash target will, in effect, mean a 26% increase on the current level to be achieved over five years.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 4, before section 2, to insert the following new section:

"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implementation of the review of the National Anti-Poverty Strategy 'Building an Inclusive Society'.".

Comment on this

This relates to the new approach with the national office and so on. The Minister is probably the longest serving Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs in history. Since Deputy McCreevy is determined to get back into Finance——

Comment on this

We will not allow him back into the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs.

Comment on this

This could turn out to be a ten year term for the Minister of Social, Community and Family Affairs.

Comment on this

By public acclaim.

Comment on this

Many aspects of this strategy, which as the title suggests is a concise statement of the elements involved in building an inclusive society, are welcome. Is there any inclination in the Department, or was the Minister tempted to direct it, to make inclusion its central mission rather than administration, which consumes much of its time? There are 50 or so benefits, and rather than hiving NAPS into a special office, was there an effort to operate from the basis of an inclusive society? This is an area where the report is deficient. The issue of relative poverty is not addressed. If we are to have an inclusive and egalitarian society, why did the Minister not give any thought to that being the central mission?

People like Father Healy might not be familiar with spatial disadvantage but people around this table are. I was disappointed that there are pockets of grave deprivation around the country despite the increases of recent years. These are concentrated in urban areas and some rural areas, including in the midlands. Should we not give more attention to the spatial issue? I raised this last year in relation to the island grant. Maybe people in certain areas should receive a supplement because of their particular problems. Since all politics is local does the Minister regret not addressing the spatial issue?

It is disappointing for me and others in terms partnership and local development boards. The Chairman has a similar role to myself - I think the Minister is the only person here who——

Comment on this

I was on one of the first area partnerships, which was very successful one. I attended a meeting there last week.

Comment on this

It concerns everybody here in that case. There is concern among the very able workers that many of the RAPID programme developments in the 25 RAPID areas are not funded. This should not have been a separate programme but should have been run within the local government infrastructure. I was looking at my own RAPID report for part of Dublin north east and part of Dublin north central and it struck me that many of the plans had no funding - it is all in the remit of the next Government.

Should the mission of the Department have the theme of NAPS as its core value and should we have an increasingly spatial approach?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I will not labour the amendment but I wanted an opportunity to discuss it with the Minister since the NAPS report was published. He referred to Father Healy. Who once said "Who will free me from the turbulent priest"?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy saying I said that?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

No, was it not King Henry who said it? On this occasion he was throwing a few bouquets in the Minister's direction. He also said a number of other things about the report and, given that the Minister referred to some of the positive things, I will outline the negatives.

Comment on this

Is this relevant to the amendment?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Yes, very much so - we are talking about the NAPS. He described it as vague and very general in some areas and as leaving a great deal to be decided in the coming years. He went on to say:

While we welcome the recognition of social, economic an cultural rights contained in the review, we are very disappointed by the narrow application of these rights in the remainder of the document . . . Ireland has very high levels of relative income poverty, with one in five people living in households with an income below the 50% relative income poverty line.

It was not all plaudits in the Minister's direction. There is good work in the NAPS on which to move forward but - this is true whoever is in Government - unless one Minister or the Cabinet subcommittee on social inclusion drives this programme over the next five years we will not see an appreciable difference for people at the margins of society.

One of the points I raised on Second Stage was that we still have 50,000 council houses without central heating which is quite Victorian. The figure is much better in Dublin City Council, I admit, but not so much in the new local authorities. It is appalling that 50,000 households have no central heating. I would like to see nugget issues like this resolved over the next three or four years. If we are part of the next Government, I will not sign up to any programme for Government unless there is a commitment——

Comment on this

The Deputy should not emulate Deputy Pat Rabbitte in that context.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

A commitment must be given to ensure that over three years, every house is fitted with a decent heating system. Every household must have a heating system to take it out of poverty.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean private as well as public houses?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

There are far more private houses without central heating.

Comment on this

The Deputy should check his figures before he starts——

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I have, it will cost €200 million. Those issues affect poverty sometimes more than others. I welcome the Cabinet subcommittee on social inclusion chaired by the Taoiseach, but one Minister must drive the programme and pinpoint 50 or 60 actions over the lifetime of the NAPS. One of the good things about the health review was that it set out actions to be achieved over years one, two and three. We do not have that in the NAPS. This is something the Minister could consider because we have had increases in social welfare in recent years but in 1997 one could get a council house much easier, one could better afford to rent in the private rented sector and one had a better chance of getting a public bed in hospital than now. All these issues, and not just social welfare rates, relate to poverty. It is essential that the new NAPS, in order to be successful, is driven by one Minister, presumably the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs.

Comment on this

Regarding the new structures added to the significant existing structures, sometimes I wonder if we are - in deference to Deputy Broughan's party - tending to examine and contemplate our navels too much on issues. I would rather go and do it.

Comment on this

I want to clarify that. That is the first point I asked the Minister. In a sense it is another office but it should be the Department's role.

Comment on this

This followed the consideration of the social partners in the NAPS review where six different working groups fed into the framework document. I may have had some reservations about one or two aspects. However, I agree with Deputy Hayes that one Minister needs to drive it and that Minister should be the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs. It is a bit like when the National Anti-Poverty Strategy began where one had to walk before running. Similarly in regard to driving NAPS through the various Departments, it has been good in some cases but patchy in others. To a certain extent the new national social inclusion committee, which will take over the functions of the NAPS unit, will still report to me. It will probably have a much higher profile than the NAPS unit within my Department, which is probably a good thing. That it is overseen by a management group of assistant secretaries from the relevant Departments is also a good thing. As the matter is not dealt with in some Departments at that level, perhaps assistant secretary level is probably a good level at which to drive it in the various Departments.

On the mission of the Department, my Department's mission statement is to promote social well-being through income and other supports which will enable people to participate in society in a positive way. I do not know how that can be improved on in regard to the social inclusion aspect referred to earlier. It has a social inclusion aspect, except that it is mainly driven by income. However, at the end of the day, a bit like Fr. Seán Healy's references to vagueness in his critique, the fact is that the key issues on which he and others have been fighting and the key targets we have picked out are the very ones that specifically matter to people. These are very significant targets which will demand very significant investment over the next five years.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 6, 7 and 26 are related and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 5, between lines 7 and 8, to insert the following subsection:

"(2) The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare a report for both Houses of the Oireachtas on the implications of having the same commencement date for child benefit increases as for all other increases in benefits and assistance rates.".

We have already discussed this issue. Given the current rates, if the Government decides to bring next year's child benefit increases back to 1 January, what exactly will that cost given that we are coming towards the end of the three year programme of major increases in child benefit?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I spoke about this issue on Second Stage. I want to insert the word "effective" in line 8 because there is an element of play-acting going on in regard to child benefit. As I said on Second Stage, and I repeat it now, at no stage during the debate on this matter on the last Social Welfare Bill did the Minister tell the Dáil or the select committee exactly when the back-dated payment would be made. When I asked him directly at the select committee on 12 December when would this come about he said it would not make a difference because the payments would not be made until 1 April, and the budget dictated that. He did not say it would be May, even though the question related specifically to that matter. Similarly, on Second Stage in December he said the effective date of payments for child benefit would go from September 1997 to be effective from April 2002, the earliest date from which it was administratively possible to introduce these increases. The Minister for Finance, in his Budget Statement in December, did not refer to the back-dated May payment.

Comment on this

Was that the budget fact sheet?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Not exactly. Irrespective of the budget fact sheet, I would have thought that full and accurate information would be given by all concerned during the debate in the select committee or in the House. This matter was not referred to at any stage. The Minister is stringing out these increases as we approach a general election. We had his St. Valentine's Day love-bombing just two weeks ago and on the first Tuesday of May we will have this back-dated increase for the additional amounts of money for April and May, which is not the way to do business. The Minister said it could not be done any earlier. Why could he not introduce the back-dated payment by cheque on the first Tuesday in April? Why is it being delivered in May and not April? I accept what he said about the May-June timeframe for the books, but the additional back-dated payment could be paid in April, not May. That will not be the case because a general election is looming. It would be wrong of me not to highlight that fact. This is using taxpayers' money in a less than honest way and playing around with social welfare dates. There have been other examples in regard to tax this year. I am correct to highlight this fact by way of my amendment because it is possible for the Minister to deliver the increases in April and not May. As a member of the committee, I want to know why he has chosen May and not April.

Comment on this

To answer a number of specific questions, the cost of bringing forward child benefit payments by two months from June to April this year was €70 million. I said the first pay day in May would be the earliest day on which it would be possible for my Department to pay the increased rates. The extra cost of making them effective from the same date as the social welfare increases, that is, 1 January, is €103.5 million at the current rates.

Bringing back the payments to 1 January - this was the same in regard to bringing it back to 1 April and paying it in May - would have caused serious administrative difficulties for my Department. As my officials explained to members of the committee last November, the book-based system is the chosen payment option for the majority of pensioners and other long-term beneficiaries. As the majority of families receiving child benefit, almost one million recipients, are paid by this method, it is less flexible than other payment methods and requires a longer lead-in time to implement increases. Over a period between December and March and up to May, family income supplement books amounted to 11,500; lone parents and widows, 280,000 books and old age retirement pensions, 260,000 books. There are approximately 550,000 child benefit recipients. This is a fully crowded schedule into which the production of single vouchers for arrears of budget increases had to be squeezed. It was only as a result of significantly extra overtime that staff of the Department were able to deal with the February payments and the child benefit arrears. There were 380,000 child benefit vouchers. This is not playing around with money. There was a desire to pay people effective from 1 April. From a political point of view, it may have suited better if we were able to pay the money in April but it is not physically possible. I spent a long time discussing the matter with my officials who informed me that it was not possible to pay it earlier than June, even if we backdated it to 1 April.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

To the first Tuesday in May.

Comment on this

The computer system used to pay child benefit, probably the oldest in the Department, is being replaced. One of the causes of the industrial relations problems in Letterkenny was the introduction of the new service delivery model to allow changes in child benefit to be made much quicker than has been the case heretofore. I reiterate that the earliest date for payment is in May.

Comment on this

Having gone to all this effort, what will happen if the Government collapses over the national aquatic centre and the general election is held earlier than May? The Minister's best laid plans will have gone astray.

Comment on this

I agree. My official informs me that this is the reason the Bill must be passed irrespective of who is in office. The Government has stated its intention to go to the country in the summer. The reason for the Department's action is to bring back the payment date of child benefit. With more money, we could have tried to backdate payments to 1 January. Given the huge administrative problems it would have caused, it may have proved impossible and we would have ended up making the payments in May. To backdate them by just two months would cost €70 million, a huge sum of money.

It is my intention to progressively bring back the payment date for increases. Like Opposition Deputies, I would like to bring it back further if returned to office. We have already shown cause by bringing it back from September to an effective date of 1 April. I state categorically that there was no machiavellian plot. The date chosen was the earliest at which the Department could pay the increases effective on 1 April. If the Deputy does not accept my word, I will ask my officials to make themselves available to the committee to explain the nuts and bolts of delivering on this issue.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

On increased payments, if one is paid by means of the book, will the May payment include the new rate together with the additional amount for April or will the backdated payment for April and May be on a separate leaf?

Comment on this

My understanding is there will be a separate page.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I saw a pension book recently with the backdated payment on a separate leaf. Why not pay the increase for April and May on the first Tuesday of April? While I accept that the Bill must pass through the House, there was no question, given the numbers available to the Government, that it was going to happen. If it was possible to do it in May, why not do it in April? I have taken a great interest in child benefit in recent months and have become quite knowledgeable on the subject.

Comment on this

The Deputy should note that my wife's child benefit belongs to her alone and I do not interfere with it. He should not interfere with his wife's child benefit either.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I thank the Minister's officials for expediting my claim recently.

Comment on this

I asked them to do so.

Comment on this

When were the increases in child benefit and old age pensions paid in 1997? As they were so low then, I suppose it is very hard to remember.

Comment on this

This is the History Channel.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It is the Discovery Channel.

Comment on this

It does no harm to find out. Deputy Brady is absolutely correct, the meagre £1 increase for the first two children in 1997 was paid in September.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Does Deputy Brady know the price of nappies?

Comment on this

With regard to the child benefit arrears from early March to 26 April and payable on 7 May, the supplier has been working overtime every weekend since the start of the year to facilitate the production of 380,000 single vouchers and renewals and will be required to continue working overtime to enable production of the single voucher in time for May.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Did the industrial relations problem in some post offices which occurred on the first Tuesday of this month make it difficult for those who claim child benefit using the book to receive their payment? Has the matter been brought to the Minister's attention?

Comment on this

I presume the Deputy is referring to the industrial relations problem in An Post.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Yes, is it widespread?

Comment on this

I understand it is selective. In my local post office in Dundalk, for example, the stoppage began at 3.30 p.m. on Monday, whereas the office in Drogheda did not start until 11 a.m. It is a pay claim by the Communication Workers Union.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I understand the industrial relations problem in Letterkenny is connected with the change to a system which would ensure more prompt payment in a more effective manner. When the process is complete, will it be possible——

Comment on this

The process is still in train. The industrial relations problem was related to staff seeking promotions because of the work involved in the process.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

When we have concluded the process surely it will be possible for me to collect my money from any post office on any day of the month using my book rather than being confined to one specific day in a month?

Comment on this

I suggest that the Deputy has the money paid into his bank account.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I will follow that advice.

Comment on this

Excuse me, his wife's bank account.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It is a joint account.

Comment on this

I would not allow it, I would make everyone collect it.

Comment on this