Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 2002: Committee Stage.
Contributions 214–422 of 422. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 2002 ›
I suggest we take a short break and then continue until 5.55 p.m. as there will be a vote at 6.50 p.m.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 5, subsection (2), line 8, after "into" to insert "effective".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 5, between lines 8 and 9, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of bringing child benefit for twins into line with the provision for multiple births of 3 or more children.".
For the last time in this Dáil I table this amendment on behalf of the parents of twins. I am informed that the Minister has still not lived up to his election promise in 1997.
Comment on this
That is not the case. We delivered on our pre-election commitment in our first budget. We delivered on the commitment made.
Comment on this
That is not correct. I sent a letter and a copy of the documents that we issued before the election to her, where we gave specific commitments to increase it by 50%. We delivered that in the first budget. I indicated that, in the lifetime of the Government, I would like to bring it up but given that we have had such substantial increases in the past two years, which would have particularly benefited families with twins, to a certain extent that issue is off the agenda because of the increases across the board in child benefit.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the introduction of a non-means tested carer's allowance.".
This is an area we have discussed many times. It gives us a final opportunity to tell the Minister that, despite the improvements he has introduced in the incomes disregard for carer's allowance and despite the welcome respite increases in section 3, about 20,000 of the minimum of 50,000 carers identified in the Minister's Department's 1998 report are covered by the carer's allowance - just 40%. I tried to say on Second Stage that a number of carers, people with disability and leaders of the organisations representing them are considering standing as Independent candidates in the general election because there is a perception that the Government failed in a central part of its remit in relation to the 1997 programme for people with disability. The Government is leaving office without having brought forward a disability bill. There is a general perception that we have failed carers of people with disability.
Before Christmas, when we had the famous meeting, Deputy Wade was witness to an emissary from the Taoiseach arriving hotfoot in Limerick to say that the disregards would be brought up to average industrial wage in the budget. Sadly, this did not happen and although we reached the £300 or £150 mark, we still have a problem. The central point is an issue, not so much of the money but of recognition. Two weeks ago in the Labour Party parliamentary room, I met a delegation of 40 carers from Cork city. The problem was that they were not getting sufficient recognition in Irish society despite the improvements that have admittedly taken place in the past five years. They felt strongly about small issues such as those in the community care areas. One woman mentioned the provision of knee and elbow pads for her severely disabled daughter. They had a pad that adhered to her body and remained intact overnight but an official, on cost grounds, decided to introduce another pad which does not adhere properly. Some people who are full-time carers do not qualify for the allowance because of the means test. They feel this should be independent of means testing and that there should be a simple carer's payment payable to anyone who is caring on a full-time basis.
Why are people who are on a course for perhaps 20 hours per week not allowed more time? The definition of a carer which the Department of Health and Children gives is full time. This will become an issue as we approach the election. People feel that the whole Oireachtas has failed them, which is why they are standing as Independents. There is a feeling that the Minister has not delivered on this issue and that the improvements have not addressed the central point of recognition.
We have had a referendum today which the Taoiseach may be conceding on as we speak. We have had many constitutional referendums and it may go to that point in relation to needs assessment and recognition. It is bigger than money but as the Minister rightly says, money is the most important issue in terms of income maintenance. I hope the next Government will have a carer's payment which is not means tested for full-time carers because that is what people deserve.
Comment on this
It is an important issue, particularly in relation to widows and lone parents, where it is not dealt with in having two benefits. What people are asking for is a carer's payment which acknowledges the role people play. I am aware of the financial aspects of this. We were talking about benchmarking and making commitments into the future and it is interesting that the Comptroller and Auditor General referred to the carer's allowance in his last report which I always read with interest because I was a member of the Committee of Public Accounts in the last Dáil. One always remembers its operation in relation to public expenditure. Everybody is watching the amounts of money that are spent. I commend the Minister for increasing spending rapidly in the area. Nonetheless, there are fundamental aspects of our society which we should address. In the past, up to 20 years ago, we treated carers disgracefully and we still treat them far less well than they should be treated. Perhaps this is one amendment the Minister should accept and allow pass so it is on the record as an issue we have tried to grapple with and that the Government is leaving for consideration.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Broughan's comments. The most glaring inequity in respect of dealing with carers is that someone who has an existing social welfare payment cannot get a half rate carer's allowance or some contribution in recognition of the fact that he or she is doing such a huge job in looking after a loved one or friend. This is an area in which we have seen no progress. The Minister regularly tells the committee that one cannot get two social welfare payments but carers regard this as a recognition of the work they are doing. It is not a monetary payment because we could not pay for the amount of work people are doing. This is an area we should focus on. People on social welfare payments should be entitled to a half rate carer's allowance or equivalent amount in recognition of what they are doing. That has been the biggest failure because while improvements have been made in the carer's allowance and the income threshold each year, we are still not getting close to the 50,000 that the Minister's Department estimates are providing full-time care. The new income thresholds which have been announced will bring the figure up to 25,000 this year——
Comment on this
We are still a long way short of the 50,000 who need to be supported. I support these amendments.
Comment on this
The Deputies are correct in that much has been done, and I accept and thank them for their compliments for what I have done during my stewardship. We all accept that more can be done.
I do not make this as a political point, but by far the most amendments to the carer's allowance scheme have been made during my stewardship. We gave a commitment that over time we would increase the means disregard to the average industrial wage. That is still the view. I do not accept we should abolish the means test. I would have a problem with that. I said previously it would mean people on relatively high incomes would get the exact same amount as those on low incomes. That would not be fair or equitable. I have always seen the limitation of the carer's allowance scheme on its own, in that the social welfare system is only designed to give low income families a basic income. The carer's allowance was not designed to pay people for particular caring duties. Given add-ons such as respite care, free schemes and so on, fortunately, we are reaching a stage where we can assist people.
It is the duty of all Deputies to plan how we will look after the elderly and infirm as the population gets older. The sooner we do so the better. That is one of the reasons the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, and I in the context of the health strategy are already taking part in discussions as to how we can put together all the strands in regard to financial support for people who are caring, whether it will mean a dove-tailing of schemes such as home help, nursing home subventions and carer's allowance. I accept there also needs to be a broader look at the other supports to which Deputy Broughan referred. These are small things which cause people difficulty. One of the reasons we looked at the issue of needs assessment, piloted by the Minister of State, Deputy Moffatt, was to give people a non-means tested care allowance. When looking at the needs assessment of both the carer and the person being cared for, many other aspects must also be considered.
I do not accept that we do not have a non-means tested payment. We have the carer's benefit which I set up and which over time will become an extremely beneficial scheme. Much has been done in this area but more can be done. I would like to think more can be done in regard to not just income and financial help but also other aspects. Perhaps we can marry many of the supports and try to address some of the gaps.
Comment on this
The Minister has made the point down through the years that he felt there should be a payment in relation to the Department of Health and Children and health boards. I can see where he is coming from in that regard. I note what the Minister for Health and Children has done in regard to long-term care. All the political parties were looking at the figures with great interest. The Comptroller and Auditor General began the debate on this issue. The report indicates that there is an insurance based system in Germany whereby we would all be compelled to provided for our own long-term care. On average, 40% of the current generation will need a period of care before we die. Would the Minister envisage a package of supports at local level such as a carer's payment for a job being done in each household and each locality which would not be part of the social welfare budget? In other words, traditional social welfare payments might not be used.
Comment on this
I envisage something along those lines in the future. Perhaps it might not necessarily be linked to social welfare. There might be an onus on us to put an onus on families, as in the German model, over their working lives to provide for when they may need care. We have already reached a situation where the extended family is no longer available to look after members of families. There is an onus on those of us in our middle years and in good employment to provide for our care in the future because we cannot rely on other people. That is why we need to consider issues of equity such as the release of property. The vast majority of Irish people own their houses. We should consider whether there is some way to assist people who become infirm in that respect? Perhaps we should consider a model such as the German one whereby we would make deductions from people's salaries. I agree with the Deputy that we must consider these aspects.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the need to extend the free telephone allowance to elderly persons living in nursing homes, either for a fixed line or a mobile phone, particularly in cases where the allowance was previously obtained.".
This matter is regularly put to the Minister by way of written and oral parliamentary questions. It relates to elderly people living in nursing homes or other institutional care or people who are hospitalised for a period of time and can no longer get the free telephone allowance. The aunt of a woman in my constituency is 89 and was in receipt of the telephone allowance. When she went into a nursing home, not having received a huge subvention from the health board, her telephone allowance was taken from her. She wrote to me stating that the free telephone allowance scheme was seemingly introduced to encourage people to stay in their community. That would suggest that people, family and outside contacts would also keep in touch with their loved ones. As this lady moved to a community where she could only have daily contact and care, she is now being penalised as it appears the free telephone allowance is not available to elderly people living in such places of residence. It seems the free telephone regulations are being interpreted and enforced by the authorities in a most uncaring and discriminatory way. One must consider a situation where a well heeled couple, over 70, living with family members, is entitled to this allowance and someone living in a nursing home is not.
The free telephone allowance scheme is very good because it helps to connect people with their family and friends. However, just because one moves into a nursing home should not mean that person automatically loses the allowance. It is very important for someone living alone in a separate room in a nursing home to be able to keep in touch with family and friends. I do not think it would take a huge amount of imagination to change the scheme. I put this to the Minister on numerous occasions. I have received a considerable number of representations from people in nursing homes on this issue. As people are living longer and seeing the benefit of the scheme, I think we should extend it to nursing homes. Therefore, I ask the Minister to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I have a great deal of sympathy in regard to this issue and it is not that we are uncaring in the Department. The free schemes share common objectives in relation to the whole issue of social inclusion. They provide assistance to people living alone by targeting them for specific benefits and providing both income and social inclusion gains. They support older people and people with disabilities in their wish to remain in the community as opposed to in institutional care. They are also designed to support Government policy, which seeks to acknowledge the contribution of older people to society. The original objective of the telephone allowance is to provide an element of protection in their own home for older people and those with disabilities who are either living alone or with people who are unable to summon help in an emergency.
A second objective of the scheme was to encourage social contact and to assist in the prevention of social isolation for those living alone. Those living in nursing homes or other residential institutions have daily contact with and receive support from other residents and nursing staff. They are also in receipt of other State supports, either through the public health system or, in some cases, the nursing homes subvention scheme. In the circumstances, the proposal to extend the telephone rental scheme to residents in nursing homes does not fit easily with the objectives of the schemes which are, as already stated, to provide an element of personal security and assist in the prevention of isolation for those living alone.
Even if we wanted to brush aside the matters to which I have referred and proceed to extend the scheme to these people, there is the practical difficulty that other individuals could access these people's telephones.
Comment on this
I would like to have extended the entire scheme of free telephone rental to mobile phones but that is easier said than done. There would be a number of major difficulties involved in extending the scheme to mobile phones. One would think it would be quite simple to do so, but it is the opposite. There would be enormous difficulties involved in extending the scheme to people in institutional care. I accept that people lost their free telephone rental when they entered homes.
Comment on this
As already stated, however, there would be practical difficulties in allowing such telephones to be placed in a room or rooms in institutions, particularly in terms of the fact that they would be accessible to other people.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report in relation to increasing the weekly allowance to those seeking asylum in this country.".
Amendments of this nature arise on a regular basis and relate to support given to asylum seekers. We have been dealing with this issue for approximately two and a half years. I have only been a member of the committee for a year but I read the reports of its previous proceedings and it is clear that we have made no progress on significantly increasing the rate of benefit payable to asylum seekers. I am aware that these people are entitled to claim child benefit and have, therefore, benefited from the increases provided in the past two budgets.
The Department produced a report on this matter on foot of a direction from the Minister. It is not good enough that, while welcome increases in the rates payable on many schemes were provided in the budget, the rate of payment on this scheme was not increased. It is time we took action on this issue. When officials of the Department appeared before the committee they pointed out that the rate is tied to the level of support given to people in institutional care, which has its own connotations.
There is a need to take action in respect of this matter because the level of payment these people receive is extremely low. There has been no movement in this area since the introduction of direct provision. It is time to act. Where is the report we were promised? For as long as I have held this portfolio on behalf of my party I have been hearing about the report but I have not seen the conclusions that were reached in it.
Comment on this
We expect to have the report in the near future. I accept that the working group has been going about its business for some time but, as the Deputy stated, under direct provision people receive their bed, board and lodgings. They are entitled to the payments but they are also entitled to exceptional needs payments. I understand that most of them receive such payments. As the Deputy also stated, many of them will have benefited from the increases in child benefit. Obviously we must wait until the report of the working group, comprising membership from my Department, the Departments of Finance, Justice, Equality and Law Reform and the Environment and Local Government and representatives of the chief executives of the health boards, is presented before we take action.
Comment on this
I support this amendment. Is the Minister in a position to indicate the average period people must wait before decisions are made on their cases?
Comment on this
I understand it is down to six months, which is a great deal better than in the past.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the need to provide-
(a) a pension supplement to those pensioners who are solely dependent on either a contributory or non-contributory pension, and
(b) increased support for pensioners under the living alone allowance.”.
I tabled this amendment to draw the Minister out in respect of the substantial group of pensioners who are solely dependent on State pensions, contributory or non-contributory, and who do not have other occupational pensions. We will be dealing with this matter tomorrow and for the next number of weeks in the deliberations on the Pensions Bill. However, I want to discover what is the Minister's view about paying an additional pension supplement to those people who do not have another income through an occupational pension scheme.
It could be argued that the living alone allowance is a supplement of one type or other, albeit to people who are living on their own irrespective of whether they are in receipt of two pensions. However, this allowance has not been increased in recent years. In my opinion, it is time we gave consideration to this issue. Those people who are on contributory pensions have benefited from significant increases and we have reached the 32% threshold in this regard. Many of these people are also in receipt of occupational pensions. However, there are substantial numbers of people who are only in receipt of State pensions. We need to consider establishing a system under which a supplement could be given solely to these people, which would significantly increase their level of income.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. I do not want to pre-empt the debate tomorrow. As I informed the Taoiseach this morning, we are unhappy with the short period we have been given to prepare for the debate on the Pensions Bill. The Minister stated last July that it is the most important item of legislation that will come before the current Dáil and now the debate on it will be guillotined. We will be put to the pins of our collars in terms of trying to draft amendments we wish to table in respect of it. Anne Vaughan and the staff of the Department have done an outstanding job in relation to preparing the Bill. However, there are many fundamental issues which arise and the point made by Deputy Hayes will form part of the general debate.
We have all received the submission made by the Jesuit Centre for Social Justice which carried out an economy study that drew attention to the fact that tax relief on occupational pensions or the new PRSAs should be taken into account by comparison with the amount of money we spend on social welfare payments. In other words, we should be looking at the total pension package of society in general. Regardless of how one considers this matter, provision for pensions, whether it is what we will do tomorrow in respect of PRSAs or what we do today in relation to social welfare payments, is a charge on society. It is, therefore, as Deputy Hayes points out in amendment No. 12, the position of the most vulnerable pensioners at which we should look.
I understand our colleagues in the UK have been severely criticised because they introduced a draconian means testing system. What Deputy Hayes is seeking in this amendment is a pension credit system that would ensure that the poorest pensioners would be given that little bit extra. To be fair to the pensioners' representative bodies, particularly the trade union group, which is represented by the former Labour politician, Mick O'Halloran, the late Mattie Merrigan and others, they always drew attention to the fact that they represented workers who had occupational pensions. Deputy Hayes's amendment deals with those who are solely dependent on either contributory or non-contributory pensions. In particular, it relates to the situation of women who, in the past, were forced to leave work under a different and more sexist regime and pensioners on home duties who were left in a very vulnerable position. I refer to those in the non-contributory category. The Government deserves to be commended for reaching the target of £100 which it set in 1997 and perhaps it is now timely to deal with the situation to which I have just referred, either through the pension credit or some such device in accordance with amendment No. 12.
Comment on this
In effect, what is being suggested is the introduction of a pension supplement. That would involve additional means testing of people who are on contributory pensions, in their own right, based on their stamps, at a time when we are trying to get rid of means testing from the system. Over time, as the generation moves on, most people will qualify automatically for a contributory old age pension. While I introduced a change in the living alone allowance by extending it to people on invalidity pensions who were living alone - bringing in approximately an additional 11,000 people - I am not particularly in favour of bringing in the type of supplement which has been suggested, because it would bring in a whole new regime of means testing for people to whom it does not now apply. I would rather increase their pensions exponentially, as we have done.
Comment on this
The problem is that the poorer pensioner is not really being targeted. If a person has another pension to which he or she has contributed over X years, he or she has another income source, whereas those who are solely dependant on contributory pensions do not have that.
Comment on this
During our visit to Sweden last year, we saw another approach to this matter. Due to a shortage of workers, a new option had been introduced whereby people could either retire at age 66 or continue working for another year or two, with a deferred pension arrangement which provided for an increase equivalent to about £5 per week for each additional year of service. For example, a person could retire at 66 with a pension of £116 per week or at 68 with a pension of £126 per week.
Comment on this
Some EU background material available to us in relation to the Pensions Bill indicated that any form of ageism in relation to jobs is likely to be banned. It may be already in conflict with the Constitution and some aspects of the equality legislation. The concept of compulsory retirement at a certain age may be in its last few years of operation. Options will have to be available to people who wish to continue working.
Comment on this
Yes, but they cannot get insurance cover after age 66. My father continued working after 66 but he had no additional stamp contributions and no increase in pension.
Comment on this
Under the Swedish system, the pension payment was deferred until actual retirement, at which time it was increased by the equivalent of £10 or £15, in accordance with the number of years additional service.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say how many or what percentage of pensioners are solely dependant on the State pension as their only source of income?
Comment on this
The increase in old age pensions is very good but it does not target those who need it most.
Comment on this
The increases given over a number of years would benefit the less well off pensioners proportionately more than those who have additional income.
Comment on this
A significant number of senior citizens are still living in poverty and they are one of the most vulnerable groups, despite what has been done so far.
Comment on this
Their income has reduced in relative terms as incomes in the economy generally have expanded rapidly.
Comment on this
That was bound to happen. However, the increases which we have specifically targeted to old age pensioners are a recognition that they are a very deserving category. They generally appreciate what has been given. While I agree there may be difficulties, what has been suggested in terms of a supplement would set up a whole new system of means testing and I am not sure that would be appreciated by old age pensioners.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the need to provide a report on increasing the contributory widow's pension to the same rate as the contributory old age pension.".
We discussed this issue on a previous Social Welfare Bill and the Minister has made progress on the position of widows over 66 years, in bridging the gap between the contributory old age pension and the contributory widow's pension. The difference is currently in the region of €3 or €4. What would be the total cost of bringing the contributory widow's pension up to the same rate as the contributory old age pension? If one spouse dies early, that person has been paying insurance, through PRSI, for a number of years. This is an unexpected event and there should be no distinction between the contributory widow's pension for over 66 and the old age contributory pension.
Comment on this
I will have that figure checked. I recall, from a previous occasion, that it was a very substantial figure. I do not accept any suggestion that I have done nothing for widows under 66 years. I introduced the widowed parent grant which is now quite substantial, in addition to the bereavement grant. On the Deputy's question, the widow's contributory pension, under 66 rate, is now €2.5 per week less than the old age contributory pension. The cost of equalising the two rates would be €9 million. I would have liked to bridge the gap in this year's budget but the money was not available.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the existing social welfare benefits and social insurance protection afforded to job sharers so as to reduce a number of anomalies that exist for job sharers in respect of PRSI contributions.".
If we are to encourage a more family friendly working environment, job sharing will have to be more widely used by families who wish to move in and out of the labour force as they choose. The difficulty is that, where people are working half time over a period of years, depending on their working conditions, they lose out on many benefits. For dental and optical treatment benefit, one must have 39 PRSI contributions paid or credited in the governing contribution year. Some job sharers may find they do not have the required number of contributions and, therefore, they cannot get the benefits.
The Minister has made a commitment, under the PPF, to establish a working group to look at these proposals. However, this issue has to be raised because, if one is trying to marry work and family requirements and encourage people to take up job sharing options, one cannot and should not offer the people concerned any reduction in the potential benefits they could get under the PRSI system. That point has to be made very strongly. Can the Minister indicate what is the time schedule of the working group? Can we take it that there will not be a two year delay, as in the case of the asylum workers? Do I understand correctly that there is a commitment, under the PPF, to establish a working group to look at the benefits given to job sharers?
Comment on this
I have a reply to a Parliamentary Question as follows:
In line with the commitment to PPF, a working group will be established this year to produce proposals for the development of a fully inclusive social insurance model, which would facilitate combining work and family responsibilities.
Comment on this
It is up and running and doing very good work. It is looking at the issue of coverage and contributions and the average test. There are big issues involved; it is not just about job sharers, who will be looked at and will be involved and in regard to whom, we have made some changes during the years. They can change their work pattern to ensure they work in every PRSI week and, therefore, obtain the 52 contributions required in a full year. They also qualify for the majority of social insurance benefits. The note states it is necessary to find the balance between the payment of sufficient contributions and the entitlement to benefits. It is believed that the current arrangements represent such a balance. If anyone has any difficulty in regard to what their entitlements are, they are advised to contact the Department's information section, which would give them further details.
The fully inclusive social insurance model is about to start. My staff were more heavily involved in the issue of the administrative individualisation model which is now well advanced.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the need to provide a derogation for those born between January and April 1936 or 1937 as such persons may be adversely affected, in terms of social welfare benefits, by the alignment of the contributory year with the calendar year.".
One of the aspects of being Opposition spokesperson on social welfare is that colleagues regularly send me information on perceived anomalies that they wish me to raise in the context of Bills, on the basis that the Minister, or whoever will be in his shoes next year, might bring forward enlightened legislation free of such anomalies. This is one such case where the Minister has brought forward payments to January this year. The amendment asks that a derogation be provided for a very small group of people born between January and April 1936 or 1937 on the basis that this change could affect their entitlements in terms of social welfare benefits. I am not sure if it was originally the Department's policy to propose a derogation, but it is possible that a small group will be affected by the backdating. I am not sure if any cases have come to light yet.
Comment on this
No cases have been made to date, but there is a possibility that the averages of people who find themselves in this situation may be brought down. The Pensions Board will monitor the situation to see if any changes are necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on improving the income limit for the back to work allowance scheme to account for family size of applicants so that secondary benefits would remain intact for the three years duration of the scheme.".
This amendment relates to the back-to-work allowance, a matter one of my colleagues asked me to raise with the Minister. The back-to-work allowance scheme is successful in that it allows for an additional financial boost for people in the first three years after moving back into the workplace following a period of unemployment. The Minister is aware that there was a commitment given to those involved in the scheme that their secondary benefits would remain intact for its three year duration. In the small print there is a clause whereby one's income must not exceed £250 per week. This income limit is in no way related to family size. Therefore, one could have one child or five and it would make no difference. A couple with no children could retain their benefits while a couple with five children would be penalised if they earned more than the specified sum. This matter was raised previously. I would be interested in hearing the Minister's views on whether amendments can be made to ensure secondary benefits are not lost for larger families.
Comment on this
I think I understand what the Deputy is saying, but I am not sure if my note addresses the point. Long-term unemployed persons who avail of the back-to-work allowance can retain their secondary benefits, provided their gross household weekly income does not exceed £250, €317.43. Retention of the medical card is not subject to the income limit in recognition that this income threshold could give rise to disincentives to participation in the scheme. I provided for two key improvements in this area in budget 2000. Provision was made for disregarded back-to-work allowance payments and family income supplement for the purposes of the gross household limit, and the maximum rent allowable of £250 per month was abolished in favour of a tapered withdrawal over a four year period. These measures came into effect in April 2000 to ensure that, in the case of families with children, substantially increased supports are provided in the critical early years of transition from unemployment to employment. Although the income limit does not vary according to family size, the arrangements I have outlined ensure the existence of dependants is taken into account. The question of further enhancing the income limit is a matter for consideration in a budgetary context.
Comment on this
The point is that it does not take account of the number of children in the family. I think I am right in saying that.
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct, but the point is that the disregard for back-to-work allowance and family income supplement is bigger for larger families. By adding them in, as we did in April 2000, that gives them an advantage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on improving the co-ordination of policy between his Department and FÁS so that spouses who are not entitled to unemployment benefit in their own right could be entitled to participate in existing FÁS schemes".
This is in regard to a report calling for co-ordination between the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs and FÁS in order that spouses not entitled to unemployment benefit in their own right could be entitled to participate in existing FÁS schemes. This matter was raised by a number of colleagues in my party who asked me to put it to the Minister again. It is regularly brought to the attention of a number of Departments that a married woman not entitled to sign on is also not entitled to participate in a FÁS scheme because the income of her husband excludes her from participation. Many married women feel aggrieved at this. Clearly, it would require both the Minister and the Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Deputy Harney, to put pressure on FÁS to change these restrictive rules.
Comment on this
A P2000 working group on women's access to labour market opportunities chaired by my Department reported on 13 April 2000. One of its key recommendations was that access to the labour market should be extended to qualified adults or persons eligible to participate in labour market programmes. This recommendation has been implemented. If memory serves me correctly, most of the recommendations referred to the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment. Only two were relevant to my Department which we subsequently implemented.
The Deputy will appreciate that the question of criteria governing access to FÁS courses lies with the Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment, whose Department is responsible. The review of progress on the implementation of the recommendations of the working group is being carried out under the aegis of my Department in conjunction with a number of others. This lateral review will provide an opportunity to improve interdepartmental co-ordination.
A married woman over 35 who has been a dependent of an unemployed person, also over 35, who is in receipt of unemployment assistance or unemployment benefit is eligible to participate on a CE scheme for up to three years.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the need to revise the existing method of assessing pension provision for persons who emigrated, in respect of averaging their contributions.".
This is one of those quirky amendments that is sent to test us every so often. This arises for many people who emigrated. They worked, perhaps, for two or three years in Ireland and worked abroad for a number of years having been forced to emigrate. If they return to Ireland and recommence working here, when they come to pension age they will be assessed with the total years they could possibly have been part of the Irish work force, even though they were out of it for a number of years. I understand this affects quite a number of people who left in the mid-1950s. Their total record is divided by 45 years to give an average and they are awarded a pension at the appropriate rate and based on the average. However, if they did not accumulate any stamps in Ireland before they emigrated and then returned and accumulated stamps, they could qualify for the full rate of pension for very modest contributions because contributions are only averaged over the period in which they worked in Ireland. The Minister has said on previous discussions on social welfare Bills that he would look into this and give a report. I will be interested to hear his reply.
Comment on this
The issue the Deputy refers to is one that is currently looked at by my Department in connection with the examination of the whole area of contributions. We are hoping to work on a universal basis rather than an average test because the average test throws up huge inequities in that the earlier one starts work, the more difficult it is over the period——
Comment on this
It is exacerbated if one leaves the country. To a certain extent I have eased the qualifying conditions in recent years. The pre-1953 issue would be somewhat relevant. Of the 18,000 who have qualified, quite a sizeable proportion are resident outside the State. Quite a number of old age pensioners in England have now qualified for a pre-1953 pension as of right. That takes care of some, but not all of the issues. Obviously if one is here one can pay the contribution but cannot do so if one is not here.
Comment on this
If one works in another country and pays contributions there, can those be transferred to help establish the average for the period of time one is there?
Comment on this
We have bilateral agreements with most of the major non-EU States such as the United States and Australia. We are currently drawing up an agreement with South Korea, the signing of which is due to take place in May or June.
Comment on this
I do not think I will be around to sign it. There are reciprocation agreements within the EU.
Comment on this
I said "universal" but I meant "total contributions", people will get credit for their total contributions paid rather than calculating an average. I am not sure when the report is due to be published but it was progressing fairly rapidly.
Comment on this
What is the position for our pre-1953 emigrants to the United States? Has there been much take-up from there?
Comment on this
Yes. I do not know the figures but thousands of people in the UK have qualified while the number is smaller in the US. I would not like to tell the Department of Finance the number of countries where pre-1953 pensioners qualify.
Comment on this
The problem is that the total number of years one might work for is then used to average out one's contributions, even though one could have worked abroad from some of that 45 or 50 years.
Comment on this
Or one could have been working in the home and be affected if one did not get credit from the homemakers scheme. That is a big problem for married women who take time off work to work in the home. My wife started work very early and will have great difficulty qualifying for a pension. That is a bit unfair, but it is a common problem.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 5, before section 3, to insert the following new section:
"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the effects of different stamp contributions, in respect of obtaining treatment benefits, for those under 25 years of age and for those over 25 years of age.".
This is quite a sore issue for many young people who leave college at 21 or 22, and start paying contributions. By age 25 they do not have the requisite number of contributions in order to draw down treatment benefits, particularly dental and optical treatments. There seems to be a considerable threshold when one turns 25 where the stamps required are quite considerable before one can receive treatment benefit. I do not know why that is. This has been brought to my attention by people who have been working for three or three and a half years and have been paying PRSI but when they need the treatment benefit, they cannot draw it.
Comment on this
Persons aged under 21 must have at least 39 weeks PRSI paid since first starting work in order to qualify. Persons aged 21 to 24 must have at least 39 weeks PRSI paid since first starting work, and 39 weeks paid or credited in the relevant tax year. In the case of those aged 25-65, the requirement is that they must have at least 260 weeks PRSI paid since first starting work, and 39 weeks PRSI paid or credited in the relevant tax year. Of the 724,000 claims to both dental and optical benefits received in 2000, some 646,000 - 89% - qualified for benefit. Some 78,000 - 11% - did not qualify because of insufficient insurance records or some other reasons.
There will always be cases where the insured person does not have the required number of minimum contributions. Persons can have gaps in their insurance record for many reasons. In 1999 some 5,000 persons aged 25-30 failed to qualify because of the 260 weeks paid contribution rule. In 1993 the age limit was extended from 23 to 25. There are no specific proposals at present for changing the qualifying conditions. The operation of this scheme is subject to ongoing monitoring by my Department. The question of further improvements would be a matter for budgetary policy changes.
Comment on this
This was last changed in 1993, but it has been brought to my attention as a particular problem for that category of young workers, recently graduated from college, who cannot draw this benefit. The Minister said that 11% of applicants could not qualify. Were the majority of those aged between 21 and 25?
Comment on this
The 78,000 failed applications would come from across the entire age range. I would estimate that only a small proportion of that 78,000 would be people aged 21-25. The vast majority of workers are older than that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 5, before section 4, to insert the following new section:
"4.-The Minister shall as soon as possible after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the extension of social welfare free schemes to widows and widowers with dependant children.".
This is a repeat of an amendment we tabled to the Social Welfare (No. 2) Bill, 2001. At the time the Minister stated it would cost a significant amount of money and could be construed as discriminatory. Nonetheless the fundamental argument for this amendment is that one way of compensating for the trauma experienced by widows, and particularly young widows coping with the educational and other needs of a number of dependent children where previously there was an extra income in the household, is to ensure she would be entitled to the full range of household benefits. I am just reiterating the point in the context of this Bill.
The Minister made the point that household benefit is part of the social insurance fund. Part of the reason we were so vociferously opposed to the raid on the fund which took place last year was that it makes it more difficult to deliver additional benefits such as these.
Comment on this
During my tenure over the past number of years, I tried to see how I could ringfence assistance to widows. We introduced some measures such as the widowed parent grant, which we increased exponentially. The bereavement grant would also help and, in the case of widows over 66, we gave commitments to raise it to the old age contributory pension rate.
We looked very closely at the issue of free schemes but the strong advice, particularly from the report which was done on the review of free schemes, was that this was, by and large, a scheme designed for people aged 66 and over. Even though widows between the ages of 60 and 65 whose spouses had been in receipt of the free schemes before they died continue to qualify for the free schemes, there is very little scope to give the free schemes to groups such as widows. One might mention recipients of the carer's allowance in this context, but people would accept that their case is different. The problem is that one parent families would all claim that they are entitled to the free schemes and that lone parents would be no different to widows with children. If we were to extend the free schemes to widows, that is the difficulty from the point of view of equity which we would encounter.
Comment on this
Was the Minister thinking at one stage of abolishing the free schemes and replacing them with household benefit? The media picked up a report to that effect. I know the Minister did not intend to do that.
Comment on this
Never. That report was wrong. Unfortunately some person in the media picked up on that and misunderstood what we were saying about pulling them all together in a household budget. I would not dismantle the free schemes.
Comment on this
Was there anybody in the Department thinking in terms of a household benefit which could have gone to all families?
Comment on this
No, it was done by my Department in conjunction with Trinity College. What was picked up wrongly by one person in the media as a result of the launch of that document was that there was a value put on the free schemes. If somebody is in receipt of all the free schemes, the value put on it, if my memory serves me correctly, was between £9 and £10 extra a week. He then multiplied that figure by 52 and came up with a figure of more than £400. That was never the intention and, to the best of my knowledge, within the Department there is no policy even being suggested in that respect.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 5, before section 4, to insert the following new section:
"4.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of relaxing the rule that a recipient of a carer's allowance cannot claim another social welfare payment at the same time.".
I want to make a brief point.
Comment on this
We were discussing it mainly in the context of the carer's allowance means test. We continually come across people, whether they are senior citizens, young people or those on lone parent benefit, who are irate about this. In the 1998 study there was some suggestion that this would not work out as an expensive measure. Has any further research been done since then on the cost of providing a half-rate allowance, such as Deputy Hayes suggested earlier, in addition to lone parent benefit, for example, where the person was looking after a young adult on a full-time basis? Every week we meet such lone parents who feel they are totally excluded. Has the Minister looked again at the issue?
Comment on this
Yes. I am referring to the case of a lone parent, for instance, who would qualify on the means test ground but who already is in receipt of a benefit. She should get half the rate of carer's allowance.
Comment on this
It would be impossible to estimate the numbers concerned. I take it the Deputy is suggesting that the vast majority of existing recipients of the carer's allowance would be entitled to receive a social welfare payment as well.
Comment on this
But then there would be a cohort of people who would never have bothered to apply because they knew they would not qualify for the additional payment.
Comment on this
For additional social welfare. That was the point the Deputy was making. This is the issue which does come up from time to time, that people must accept the higher allowance. What is being suggested is that one would accept the higher allowance and receive half the carer's allowance.
I do not know how often that would happen or what proportion of existing recipients would qualify. However, there would be others who would then apply, even for the basis carer's allowance, if we raised the disregard and they might qualify for other payments.
Comment on this
One could take the figure for the average time of caring. At the time, the authors tried to calculate a net value for the cost of such a scheme. Obviously one could calculate the cost of caring or the cost of disability. It is a difficult question, as the Chairman rightly indicated. To return to the previous amendment, is a caring supplement a more urgent requirement for the more deprived families whose only income is social welfare?
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. That is one of the reasons, as the Chairman has said, that raising the disregard actually favours higher income families, while at the same time people who solely rely on social welfare are being disadvantaged in relative terms. The more we raise the disregard or indeed do away with the means test the less well-off will be the carer's allowance recipients who are relying solely on social welfare.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 5, before section 4, to insert the following new section:
"4.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report setting out the reasons for increasing the earnings disregard for one-parent families.".
I will withdraw this amendment because we had a discussion on it in respect of the last Social Welfare Bill.
Comment on this
The widowed parent grant is an excellent innovation and something that people appreciate.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 5, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"5.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of bringing together the widowed parent grant and the bereavement grant for the purposes of the one application for widows/widowers.".
Is it the case that a widow with a dependant living with her who applies for a bereavement grant will automatically get the widowed parent grant or does she have to make two separate applications?
Comment on this
The amendment makes the point that there should be one. I have come across a significant number of widows who have children who should be getting it, but who are not.
Comment on this
I accept that. We have come across that problem. I do not know if the note addresses it but the Pension Services Office in Sligo and the bereavement grants section in Longford communicate regularly with funeral undertakers nation-wide with the objective of creating greater awareness of the bereavement payments and, from time to time, provide information updates to them. We issue press releases in that respect. The Department is also on the Internet and Aertel - teletext. Comhairle also publicises information. I have come across the issue to which the Deputy is referring.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 5, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"5.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing a new infancy payment to cover the considerable capital and other costs associated with the birth of a child.".
I know we had a discussion on amendment No. 27 at the last meeting of the Committee on Family, Community and Social Affairs when we were discussing the last social welfare Bill. A specific payment should be given to the parents or parent for their first child. Given the excessive costs in respect of the birth of a child we should move in that direction.
With regard to Amendment No. 28, we have huge anomalies in CDAs. The three rates that exist at the moment, applying to three different schemes, do not work to the advantage of people who live on social welfare. There is a need for one child dependant rate because it is still the only form of payment which can directly target people on social welfare who have the lowest income of all. The Minister needs to make improvements in that regard.
The Minister could have gone the whole hog in respect of amendment No. 30. I know the position in respect of the PPF. I understand that only £1 million is needed to make the commitment to allow CDAs to be extended to people up to 22 years of age. I know we made some improvements in the Bill in terms of this issue of allowing people to go up to a certain age - even if they are over 18 years of age, until the time that they leave the full-time course. With regard to amendment No. 30, relatively small sums of money were involved to make this commitment this year under the PPF. Clearly, it will be made next year as it is the last year in the PPF.
Comment on this
I support the three amendments. Is any work being done in the Department in respect of the target we mentioned earlier, pertaining to child income - the one-third figure given the fact that they were up to €35 or €38 per week through child benefit? In respect of children of the most deprived families in particular, given the unanimous desire not to tax child benefit, does the Minister foresee a——
Comment on this
The Minister can look them up all he likes, but one of the things he has presided over is that child benefit allowances have been frozen in his administration - basically frozen in the mists of time. I wonder if the Minister thinks we should examine this. Particularly after next year's budget, should we look again at enhancing the income of the most deprived children, given that we are working towards having a reasonable children's income?
I know that Minister was asked after the past two budgets by all the various voluntary groups - which were virtually unanimous - if he would consider increasing all the allowances to the highest level and increasing the widow's allowance in particular. This has not been addressed. I support the amendments, which deal with a matter that remains as unfinished business in the Minister's administration.
Comment on this
I will deal with the latter point raised by Deputy Brian Hayes first. I can well recall that in the final hours of my budget preparations this year I would have liked to have extended the benefit to 22 years, but the miracle of the loaves and fishes——
Comment on this
It is not very expensive but I well recall there was a choice between that and the widows allowance, to a certain extent.
Comment on this
What about the jockeys and trainers Deputy McCreevy looked after? They are more important than——
Comment on this
This is out of a budget of £850 million and we worked on the basis that there was a budget left. I would like to think that the next Minister will implement that proposal.
With regard to the CDAs, I am only following a policy of freezing CDAs by the previous Government and Minister, which I agreed to. I said very early on when I became Minister that taking the CDA route, continuing on that route and allocating the increases that pertain thereto would mean that a lone parent would lose out if she married. Somebody entering employment would lose it, whereas he or she would continue to receive it in the case of child benefit. The strong advice, with which I agreed, was that resources should be concentrated on child benefit.
Maybe when the £1 billion investment over the three years is finalised, there will be some room to move in that direction. I would rather give people money in child benefit which would not be taken away irrespective of their life events, as opposed to the CDAs, which are taken away. It is to the disadvantage of people to rely on those payments only to have them taken away.
With regard to the infancy payment, a grant is payable in terms of multiple births at birth and when the children reach the ages of four and 12. Some countries do give birth grants. I do not know how many births there are per annum. Is it 50,000 per year?
Comment on this
The payment on this number would be significant. Given that child benefit has increased fairly dramatically - it has gone up from £400 million to somewhere in the region of £1.2 billion over the past two or three years - the issue of grants at birth might be less on the agenda in years to come. Again, it is a matter of money. Does one put the €25 million or whatever it costs to give birth grants into child benefit or into birth grants directly?
Comment on this
It might seem reactionary to say that many parents who are just above the bread line receiving into their houses either one or two incomes, need a huge amount of money when they have a child. There is a huge resentment against single parents in that there is some provision given to the health boards for prams etc. That is a perceived——
Comment on this
A couple as badly off as the Deputy says is equally entitled to apply for the exceptional payments as the lone parents, probably more deserving because there——
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 5, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"7.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing paternity benefit.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In page 8, before section 10, to insert the following new section:
"10.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the introduction of a parental leave benefit to be funded from the social insurance fund.".
This is a central criticism of the major part of this year's social welfare budget dealt with in the Social Welfare (No. 2) Bill before Christmas. The Minister told me then that to introduce parental leave benefit at the rate of disability benefit for four weeks would cost €28 million, while the payment equivalent in terms of maternity benefit would be in the region of €66 million. Nonetheless, it remains one of the key disappointments for the trade union movement. Having spoken to some senior members of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions yesterday in respect of the pensions Bill, there is still a feeling that, in the spirit of the PPF, some progress might have been made on this matter this year. Also, there was a feeling that the massive resources the Minister had available to him before he broke into the social insurance fund would - as the general secretary, David Begg, said - have provided an ideal opportunity, even in a very small way, to have initiated parental leave benefit. This is because we can give ourselves a pat on the back for implementing European directives in respect of parental leave, but it is pretty hypocritical and derisory in terms of unpaid leave. Many of our other EU partners have parental leave systems that have been established for decades which are well funded and give both parents an opportunity to be present in the early, critical weeks of their child's life. I think this is something that will be done by the next Government. One way or another, maybe we should include it in this year's Bill as an encouragement to its happening.
Comment on this
I have just received the result of the referendum - 50.44% said "No" and 49.56% said "Yes". The difference is tiny.
Comment on this
The working group finalised its deliberations recently. Obviously, the issue of paid parental leave could not really have been addressed until that report was available. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform will publish this report shortly. The issues involved in the report concern the introduction of social welfare payment, including parental benefit, to be funded through the social insurance fund or addressed in the report which will be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. I cannot say any more on the issue than that. All parties are of the view that we should do something in this regard.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 8, before section 10, to insert the following new section:
"10.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of increasing maternity benefit for mothers on the basis of current yearly income as against the assessment of income two years prior to the birth of a child.".
I made this point last year. There is an anomaly in respect of maternity benefit on the basis that it is assessed on income two years prior to the birth of the child. The Minister does not need to read out the reply that he has in his notes - he told me last year that the implementation of this proposal could affect women detrimentally. The point I was raising is that they should have the choice to have their income based on the current year as against that of two years prior to the birth of the child.
Comment on this
We have made changes in terms of maternity benefit in the Bill for the self-employed. The position on the matter Deputy Brian Hayes is raising is the same as last year. It is basically to mirror what was done in respect of employees.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 33 is in the name of Deputy Broughan and Brian Hayes. Amendments No. 34, 35 and 36 are related so they may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
In page 10, to delete lines 22 to 25.
These amendments relate to the reservations which the Labour Party has about the management of the personal public service number. While we accept the basic rationale behind it and the extension, we feel there are areas of privacy and citizens rights which are important and need some protection. With regard to the some of the lines I have asked to be deleted, we are fearful that information would be collated that is not really necessary to maintain the public identity of a person, and that information would be swapped between agencies which have no business doing so. We should look at the general direction of progress in terms of ensuring reasonable privacy for citizens. I want to make it very clear that anything that contributes to social welfare fraud should be stamped out, as we discussed recently in questions. That would be an over-riding aim, as would easily identifying people working in a black economy.
This issue arises in all kinds of ways. The Chairman will know the discussions we have had about security and the rising crime rate and that there is so much crime and vandalism on the streets late at night etc. We all welcome CCTV cameras and, obviously, cameras controlling traffic, but one could have monitored virtually all one's movements from the time one leaves one's house until the time one arrives in one's workplace. There are areas we may need to look at. People who harass and vandalise in communities should be dealt with very seriously and directly through the court and punishment systems. I would be prepared to go that route rather than totally impinging on people's reasonable freedom to go about their business in a free society. There may be areas we need to look at and that is why the first amendment recommends the deletion of lines 22 to 25 in section 12(3)(a):
(xi) such other information as may be prescribed which, in the opinion of the Minister, is relevant to and necessary for the allocation of a personal public service number.
This seems to give future Ministers considerable power over what information they acquire. This is linked to one's own business at the moment in respect of one's social welfare or tax affairs or whatever. Everyone needs a certain element of privacy. Since the computer era arrived, there has been much more opportunity for people to avail of, and immediately call up, records of almost anybody without the knowledge of the person concerned.
Many citizens would have said they had tried to obtain information on themselves through the Freedom of Information Act and may not be clear on all the records the society holds. Perhaps it is time to reflect on the level of surveillance and interchange of information on citizens if there is to be a balance between reasonable information to prevent fraud and stamp it out and at the same time not intrude into people's private lives.
My amendment No. 34 seeks the deletion of subsection (5), lines 39 to 42, inclusive. That subsection reads: "Where a specified body collects from a person any of the information specified in subsection (3), that information shall also be collected for the purpose of maintaining the person's public service identity." That may be fair enough but on a first look at it I felt it could exceed the boundary.
Subsection (6) (a) reads: “Where a specified body has a transaction with a person, the Minister may share the person’s public service identity with the specified body to the extent necessary for authentication by the specified body of the person’s public service identity.” That subsection appears to give fairly significant powers to the Minister to swap information about a person’s identity with other agencies. It has been put in vague terms which could give future Governments power to maintain iron control over every aspect of citizens’ lives.
It is regrettable that three or four Bills have been combined in one, particularly the registration aspect, on which we have been awaiting a Bill for the past four and a half years. However, some of its key elements are contained in the Schedule. Perhaps, inappropriately, parts of it have had to be inserted into the Bill so that the Minister could say he had reformed the registration system as he leaves office. It would have been more preferable to have had the Bill. Like the Pensions Bill, we pass all kinds of Bills which may be important for some groups of citizens, but the areas of registration, privacy and people's basic civil rights are important areas of legislation on which other amendments have been tabled. In these amendments, I am proposing, on the legal advice of the Labour Party, that sufficient information would be available by means of the remainder of the section without the elements of amendments Nos. 33, 34 and 35.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Broughan on the issue of balance. It is important to have this in place because it would help reduce social welfare fraud and ensure an element of streamlining between the Minister's Department and other Departments. I welcome it in that respect. When I first read the legislation, I considered that everything in subsection (3) makes sense. However, the extension under subparagraph (xi) goes too far and I ask the Minister to examine it in advance of Report Stage. From my limited experience of legislative work in the House since 1997 it is bad practice to stitch in subsections which give Ministers additional power to change willy nilly the information they were seeking. The paragraph states, “such other information as may be prescribed”. What other information would the Minister seek? If he cannot tell us what other information he seeks he should not proceed with subparagraph (xi). That is my observation, otherwise I support it. It is bad legislative practice not to prescribe the information being sought. That has been done in respect of subparagraphs (i) to (x) but he lobbed in subparagraph (xi) which does not add to it.
Comment on this
All the issues being proposed in the Bill fully comply with the data protection legislation. Section 12 defines the elements of the identity which will include, inter alia, a person’s name, address, date of birth, sex, nationality and his or her PPS number. This is not a huge issue. On the issue of “such other information”, my amendment No. 36 will, I hope, allay the fears of Deputies. It provides that any such regulation to extend will require a positive resolution of both Houses of the Oireachtas before it becomes law. There would be other basic information, such as marital status, which we were going to include but decided that, perhaps, it was going too far. At some time in the future, marital status may have to be included. That is one issue I remember off the top of my head. That deals with amendment No. 33.
In regard to amendment No. 34, section 12 also provides that where information which forms part of a person's PSI is collected from customers in their dealings with a public service agency it will be used to maintain their identity in the event of a change of address. Section 12 provides that public service agencies may use the identity in carrying out its public functions relating to that person. I cannot agree with amendment No. 34 which has sought to remove this subsection. Once the public service identity is established it must be maintained or it will serve no purpose. If the identity is not kept up to date, its currency will be undermined and agencies will have no faith in it. In that event, the value of the PSI to the customer will be lost and they may be asked to produce documents or certificates to prove who they are.
In any event, the core principle of data protection is that information is kept up to date. Obviously, Deputy Broughan would agree with that. The principle of data protection legislation is that customers are informed as to the uses to which their data will be put and customers will be made aware that their identity is being made known by virtue of their dealings with any public service agency. With regard to the public service bodies using the PSI in carrying out their functions related to that person, I shall give the Deputy a concrete example of how it might operate. One of the proposals of the Bill is that my Department will be notified by the general registration office when a child is born. I hope in the near future to be in a position to automatically issue a claim form for child benefit to that child's mother as soon as notification of the birth is received. I can do that as I have the details of the mother's public service identity. I am sure Deputies will agree this is proactive public service, so often sought by members of the committee.
Section 12 provides that personal data collected at birth registration will be used for the purpose of allocating a PPS number for the newborn child. Amendment 35 seeks to remove this. Since 1998 a person transacting business with a public service agency must give their PPS number and the number of their spouse or children, where relevant. Therefore, the general registration office could already require the child's PPS number as part of the transaction. However, in practice, this would have meant that the child's parents would have to apply to my Department to have that number allocated to give it to the registrar for that transaction. While to date the General Registration Office has not adopted the PPS number as an identifier, that office is currently undergoing a modernisation programme which will see the introduction of electronic registration of events. As part of the programme, the PPS will be a key identifier. I am of the view that we have not gone as far as we might have originally intended when drafting the Bill.
We do not want to delay the rolling of the Reach project or the Grow project, which will probably come to fruition at the end of the year. If we were to wait until after the election it would delay implementation, particularly, of the Grow project.
Comment on this
The Minister said that if he wants additional information he will have to bring a positive resolution before the House.
Comment on this
In other words, we would have to propose a resolution and if it was not objected to within 21 days——
Comment on this
It does. When my party was in opposition I remember, as Whip, we opposed one. There was a debate. If memory serves me correctly, it was to do with health insurance.
Comment on this
If one tables an amendment, to the effect that the resolution should not be implemented, it triggers a debate.
Comment on this
What is the Minister saying in relation to the amendment? Will there be an amendment?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 10, to delete lines 43 to 45, and in page 11, to delete lines 1 to 10.".
This relates to the registration system. I have tabled an amendment recommended by the Adopted Peoples Association which is interested in reform of the registration system. Could there be a situation where, for example, if a researcher is researching somebody's origins or whatever, the public service number could be used to identify personal details?
Comment on this
That is already restricted. Personal information is restricted to the person concerned. No other person would be able to get it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
In page 11, between lines 27 and 28, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) Section 4(5) (as amended by section 14 of the Act of 1998) of the Principal Act is amended by substituting '223(1), 223(3), 223A(1)' for '223(1), 223A(1)'.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 12, before section 15 but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:
"15.-Section 82B(5) (as amended by section 26(1)(b) of the Act of 2001) of the Principal Act is amended by substituting ’34’ for ’38’.”.
This amendment seeks to ease conditions of entitlement to carer's benefit for certain job sharers and part-time workers. Under the current rules, an applicant for carer's benefit must work 38 hours in each period of a fortnight during the 13 weeks immediately prior to claiming carer's benefit. This condition disqualifies some job sharers and part-time workers from the scheme.
When introduced in the year 2000 this minimum threshold was chosen to ensure the applicant has a reasonable attachment to the workforce. It was recognised prior to introduction of the scheme that the caring contingency may affect all types of employees and in order to facilitate atypical workers, such as part-time and job sharing employees, the contribution conditions of the scheme were made as flexible as possible. However, in some cases job sharers are contracted to work for 34 to 36 hours per fortnight and, based on these working hours, are not eligible for carer's benefit. A number of such cases have come to light.
These difficulties were also highlighted by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. Research has also shown that many companies and organisations, particularly in the public sector, have varying working arrangements and conditioned hours and that these can even differ between different workers within the same organisation. In local authorities, health boards and Aer Lingus, for example, some employees work less than 19 hours per week or 38 per fortnight and thus do not qualify for carer's benefit. As it is considered that this is not consistent with the original intention of the scheme to facilitate such workers, I am bringing forward this amendment to reduce the number of hours required to 17 hours per week or 34 per fortnight.
Comment on this
I welcome the amendment and thank the Minister for listening to the strong representations made on the issue. Part of the problem with carer's benefit is that there are still situations where, either because of the number of hours one works or due to other issues that arose in the discussion on the Carer's Leave Bill, the benefit cannot be accessed. On Second Stage I pointed out, in the context of carer's benefit, that the numbers are still low. The amendment will have an effect in that regard. Some believed the Minister should take a longer time period, such as over two or three months, to average the hours of part-time workers such as shop workers, workers on call and so forth who could have extremely varying hours of work per week over a month or two months. Therefore, some of them still might not be covered by the amendment. However, the Minister has come a long way towards meeting the requests in this regard and I thank him for putting forward the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amemdment No. 38:
In page 12, before section 15 but in Part 2, to insert the following new section:
"15.-The Minister shall report to both Houses of the Oireachtas on the implications of enabling adopted persons to have a right of access to information relating to their identity.".
I am not sure if I have placed the amendment in the right position. It relates to what is, in effect, the mini registration Bill the Minister has inserted in Part 4. This is a long-standing request from the Adopted Peoples Association and various other representatives of adopted persons. We have been talking about civil rights, rights of privacy and so forth. The impression I received when I addressed the association and some of its groups was that they had a profound interest in an absolute right to their own identity. It is a matter that has become quite prominent again. I was representing some parents today who are on the waiting list, which is now about three years, for assessment for adoptions. As our health board does not have the necessary resources, people who have no children and desperately wish to have a family are waiting years for assessments to complete inter-country adoptions.
Most would accept that any child adopted should have an absolute right to his or her identity. The frustration of members of the Adopted Peoples Assocation is that the registration system in place so far colluded with certain authorities in creating a brick wall, as it were, between them and their fundamental identity and ancestry. The Bill provides for a mini version of the registration Bill. This issue probably goes beyond the Minister's remit into civil rights issues and so forth, but there is a fundamental demand in this regard. The members of the association also point out that in the Canadian provinces, for example, there is an absolute right to one's own identity. They also make the argument that sometimes it is critical to know one's identity, particularly if there are ancestral genetic disorders or other medical conditions. It is bad to be placed in a situation where one is not sure about one's genetic family. It could be serious, even life threatening, for the person concerned.
I have tabled the amendment in relation to the registration section to see if we can reach some kind of consensus on the matter. The strong view of adopted persons, as outlined at meetings on the issue during the years, is that they have a right to their identity, either with regard to the past or future adoptions. Somebody adopted from Vietnam or China, for example, should be able to return if he or she wishes and directly interface with his or her genetic family. It is an important issue for a significant minority of our constituents.
Comment on this
This is not an issue for me but for the Minister for Health and Children. I understand the Government has approved proposals for legislation on adoption information, post-adoption contact and associated issues. A Bill is being drafted by the parliamentary counsel and when approved by Government it will be published and all Members of the Oireachtas will have an opportunity to comment on it.
I entirely agree with the Deputy's comments. My personal view is that the information should be available on all occasions. We should do everything to assist this.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 13, after line 46, to insert the following:
"
2 | Section 34 (as amended by section 11 of the Charities Act, 1973)(a) | Insert the follow ing after subsection (4):
’(4A) Every disposition being a lease authorised under subsection (1) shall be effected in such manner as the Board may approve and shall contain such covenants, conditions or other provisions, if any, as the Board shall require.’.
(b) In subsection (6), substitute the following for paragraph (d):
’(d) accepting a surrender of a lease or other contract of tenancy of it, or (e) leasing it.’.
".
This amendment was requested by the Commissioners of Charitable Donations and Bequests to address an anomaly in the 1961 Charities Act. Under section 34 of that Act the commissioners have the power to authorise a disposition of land held on charitable trust where a power of sale was not provided for in the original gift. The amendment proposed would empower the commissioners in such cases to authorise a lease rather than a disposition, as currently defined, where it would be of benefit to the charity. I agreed to bring forward the amendment as it is a useful one for charities because it enables the commissioners to allow a charity with land to put the property to a use not provided for in the original gift. A charity, for example, could lease rather than dispose of a property and, in doing so, could stipulate in a covenant the conditions for the upkeep of the property. That could prevent the property from falling into disrepair or dereliction and it permits the charity to retain ownership.
Comment on this
A public consultation process is about to begin in that regard. We hope to introduce legislation, although it will be in the new Dáil. My Department will work closely with the commissioners and the various voluntary organisations to undertake a major reform of the charities legislation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:
In page 15, column 3, line 51, after "Act," to insert "before the coming into operation of item 5 of Part 4 of the Schedule to the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2002,”.
This is a technical amendment which was requested by the parliamentary counsel.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 42, 43 and 44 are related to amendment No. 41. Amendments Nos. 41 to 44, inclusive, may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 18, column 3, to delete line 30.
We discussed this issue earlier. I want to delete "personal public service number". As regards the registration of birth, I want to delete "mother's personal public service number" and "father's personal public service number".
Comment on this
I will bring forward a number of further amendments in relation to the registration of births and deaths on Report Stage. There are one or two other issues about which we will let the Deputy know in advance.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In page 4, lines 10 to 13, to delete "THE REGISTRATION OF BIRTHS AND DEATHS (IRELAND) ACT, 1863, THE BIRTHS AND DEATHS REGISTRATION ACT, (IRELAND) 1880, THE REGISTRATION OF BIRTHS ACT, 1996" and substitute "THE BIRTHS AND DEATHS REGISTRATION ACTS, 1863 TO 1996".
This is a technical amendment.
Comment on this
As regards the charities Bill, it would have been preferable if we had been able to discuss two Bills. Does the Minister see the need to go ahead with the original plans for the registration Bill?
Comment on this
Yes. It will be comprehensive civil registration legislation. It will ground the new system which is running quicker than the legislation.
Comment on this
When the changes are made to the legislation, how long will it be before it is up and running? One of the advantages of child benefit is that as soon as people have a baby, they automatically get the payment rather than having to wait for five or six months.
Comment on this
Yes. I am talking about births and deaths on computer rather than on paper. It will then roll out as time goes on.
Comment on this
The advantage is that once a child is born, the length of time it currently takes to process child benefit will be reduced.
Comment on this
Yes. One will be able to get it on the Internet and buy it in places one would not have been able to buy it previously.
Comment on this
It will not be a paper trace. Will one still have to provide the long birth certificate as part of the application for child benefit?