We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Finance and General Affairs

SECTION 14.

Contributions 1–129 of 254. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Amendment No. 65 is being discussed with amendment No. 66. Amendment No. 94 and amendments Nos. 1 and 2 to amendment No. 94 are also related. Amendment No. 231 is consequential on amendment No. 94. They deal with the same subject and we may discuss them together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

We are getting to the heart of this Bill. The Minister has admitted that many of his amendments are technical. We have discussed a number of important principles. My amendment proposes to delete section 14. The Minister said on a number of occasions that this Bill arises from the 1992 programme for Government and the subsequent negotiations between Fianna Fáil and the Labour Party. However, the Minister must see those negotiations in the context of the time in which they were entered into and the experience of political parties during the past few years.

I was firmly of the belief that the electorate felt that there was a need to fund the political system. We would have been prepared to accept the funding of political parties but I am not convinced that the electorate still feels the same way. This Bill is substantially different from the one we negotiated with the Labour Party.

This section must be seen in conjunction with other sections dealing with issues such as disclosure and the control of election expenditure. I do not think the public wants political parties to fund their day to day expenses from the public purse. The section in the original Bill agreed between the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party was considerably different. Maybe I am arguing from the point of view that one might as well be hung for a sheep as for a lamb. The Minister said on several occasions that we agreed to it eventually but there is no doubt that Fianna Fáil had severe reservations about this and other aspects of the Bill. It is fair to say that, because the amounts of money talked about at the time the agreement was made were substantially more than those involved here, it was more acceptable to Fianna Fáil as a larger party. Other aspects of this Bill will affect both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael more than any of the other parties.

In the proposals before us the Minister is asking Fianna Fáil, as a large political party, to accept all the constraints of the Bill without any guarantee that it will be able to continue on the same scale as at present. I am not referring only to fundraising but to administration, etc. The Minister's proposal means that we will receive about £400,000 less. As soon as payments to political parties are agreed to by the House and we attempt to have a Church gate collection to raise funds — our national collection amounted to £329,000 last year — we will be told where to get off. In effect, the Minister is saying that the State will give the party £400,000 while taking away a source of party funding. It will probably not happen immediately but it will go over a number of years. Members of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael who are present should be honest enough to admit that. Because we will lose a source of finance, our net gain will be about £70,000.

The annual cost of the administration of Fianna Fáil is about £1.5 million and the Fine Gael figure would be similar. Those costs probably double in an election year.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin Minister for the Environment (Mr. Howlin) Labour Party

A quarter of a million pounds on posters.

Comment on this

Yes, but it is all right for the Labour Party which has one candidate in each constituency and a third of the number of representatives which Fianna Fáil or half the number Fine Gael have in the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

How many?

Comment on this

The Labour Party has 33 Deputies and I do not know how many Senators. Fianna Fáil has over 90 representatives.

Fianna Fáil has 2,700 branches, to which I will refer later in relation to the expenditure limits, and a considerable number of councillors. It is a large organisation. Its sources of funds will dry up. The national collection is one matter. I do not know what effect disclosure, which arises under a later section, will have on people. Fianna Fáil's fundraisers have reported that quite a number of people have said they will disclose if they must but they will still make donations. However, we do not know if that will be the case.

The Minister is asking Fianna Fáil to take a leap into the dark and accept these sections on the payments to political parties. Within two or three years a large party, such as Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael, could be crippled financially and have no real way to raise funds. Political parties should be about more than raising funds. The purpose of my amendment is to delete the section and I would also delete some of the other sections related to election expenditure.

If the Minister is to go down the road of making payments to political parties, let us do it properly. Let us make sure that political parties are properly financed. Let us not have half-baked ideas or cripple larger parties. I am not going to make personalised accusations against the Minister but I believe this and later sections of the Bill are ideologically driven, not for all the high moral motives which I hear from various people but to try to cripple the two largest parties in the State because, irrespective of whether the Minister believes it, that is exactly the effect these sections and provisions will have on the two largest political parties.

The third reason I oppose this is the Minister will use this section to justify Part V of the Bill. He will say that because we are handing out State money to the political parties, the State should have control over what political parties spend on elections. That is why I propose the deletion of Part V — I hope that forms part of my list of amendments. The Minister will use this section to justify that. The sensible thing is to delete both of these sections because the Minister will not be doing politics or politicians a service because of public opposition to funding the political system. The large political parties will be hamstrung and unable to provide the necessary backup and facilities.

I ask the Minister to delete this section of the Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Dempsey is right. This is the meat of the Bill. To delete payments to political parties, as his amendment suggests, guts the Bill and that is his intention notwithstanding his acknowledgement that he and his party negotiated and accepted the principles of this Bill on the formation of the Government in the beginning of 1993.

Deputy Dempsey is also correct in saying that Parts III, IV, V and VI of the Bill are an integrated package. As such they limit State funding to political parties. In Deputy Dempsey's view this is too modest. However, I believe it is adequate. We do not need to continually increase the volume of expenditure on elections or on the business of politics. The payments system in the Bill is reasonable. It puts a disclosure threshold in place but does not, in its current form, forbid donations to political parties. It simply requires substantial donations to be declared and open. Deputy Dempsey feels that the impact of that will be to shut off political donations but I do not think that will happen. Most people, businesses and companies who donate modestly to political parties will continue to do so. Nobody will be ashamed of making that knowledge public.

We live in an era of transparency and the Bill seeks to provide that for the public. It also puts a ceiling on the amount that may be spent by a candidate or a political party at election time. That is a good move. We have already had a debate on the definitions and I do not want to go over that ground again but we should not be in a position where somebody with money can spend an unlimited amount on an election campaign. Many countries have recognised the need to impose some kind of a ceiling on such expenditure. There is a limit to the amount that may be expended on newspaper space and other campaign expenses. The three proposals — limited support to political parties, disclosure of substantial political donations to political parties and candidates and a cap on election expenditure — fit well together and are in tune with the mood of Ireland, notwithstanding Deputy Dempsey's views which have changed over the past number of years. The mood is clear; people want political donations and funding declared. The only way we will dispel the public's perception of party funding is to ensure that donations are made public and transparent. People can then have confidence in the system.

We have had an era of innuendo and suspicion. Politics and politicians have suffered as a result because there is a general feeling that people who make substantial donations can buy power and favouritism. This measure is designed to deal with that issue and to ensure the public retains confidence in the political system. The principle is right and was negotiated with Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Democratic Left all of whom supported it at one stage or another.

Deputy Dempsey is also correct in suggesting that there have been amendments to the Bill since it was initially published, most of which arise form the Supreme Court decision on the constitutionality of the funding of the divorce referendum campaign. The Bill is fairer as a result because it takes a broader look at political funding. It now seeks, in a very broad way, to fund the political system, not just political parties. Funding will not be confined to parties whose candidates are elected; it will be based on a percentage of the vote a party gets whether its members are elected or not. Independent and non-party candidates are treated in the same way as party candidates. That is a genuine improvement.

For all of these reasons, I am not convinced that the Bill will have the awful effect on the bigger parties which Deputy Dempsey suggests. The Deputy is letting his imagination run away with him if he thinks there is some kind of conspiracy by the Labour Party to do down the bigger parties. That notion is fanciful. We want a system which is fair to everybody and the proposed system has been negotiated on that basis.

This Bill will affect major donations. I do not think somebody will make a major donation as has happened in the past but perhaps that is not a bad thing. If people want to make huge donations to political parties, the public has a right to know in case there are consequential decisions which might be seen to be compromising. It is necessary to have transparency.

I ask Deputy Dempsey to accept Parts III, IV, V and VI of the Bill which we have discussed at length and which stand together. Their content is well laid out and has been debated over the years. I do not envisage anything other than public support for these measures. People cannot have it both ways. If one asks the public whether they want large business to fund the political system they say they do not. If politicians are not to be seen to be dependent on substantial, big business or corporate donations then the only alternative is some limited form of State funding. A range of western democracies — I can give the Deputy the list if he wishes — already have some form of State support for their political systems. If one looks at what happens in developing political systems and at the current chaos in some of the emerging east European countries that are trying to establish a democratic system that is not beholden to sinister elements, one will see what can happen. It is in the interests of democracy to have a clear, transparent and open system where donations are made public and where there is a cap on election expenditure.

Deputy Dempsey has made the point well on a number of occasions that those who give huge sums of money do not always receive the benefit of it. Every citizen should have a fair chance of being elected to the Houses of the Oireachtas. I have made this case ad nauseam and I ask Deputy Dempsey not to press his amendment.

Comment on this

Whatever happens, it is essential that the present system is changed because the manner in which politicians have to beg, bow and scrape for money is demeaning and degrading. If one were to look at the minutes of the meetings of any district or constituency branch executive, what would one find? Would they deal with serious issues such as the difference in policy or outlook between Fine Gael and its partners? They would not. Rather, they spend at least half of their time dealing with the issue of fundraising.

I believe that if someone gives a politician £100 for a ticket, that politician is under some obligation to that person. The obligation increases the larger the sum of money concerned. The manner in which political parties had to fund themselves over the years was wrong and was bound to explode at some time along the line.

If donations were an extra layer of funding on top of basic funding, that would be acceptable. Basic funding must be provided. The Minister is correct in saying that we should cap the expenditure on elections. However, we should not cap expenditure on the cost of running a party or on research, an area in which we are lacking. We should expend funds on research as happens in Germany.

There is an extraordinary amount of unnecessary expenditure and hype at an election. I must admit that, to a certain extent, I was responsible for an escalation in expenditure. In 1981, I produced a press budget for Fine Gael which was exactly eight times as much as the party had spent in the 1977 election.

Comment on this

You introduced RTÉ levels of expenditure.

Comment on this

I should add that we won the election. However, we should curtail expenditure. As the Minister said, an election is often a competition between the various parties and if expenditure is not capped the parties will increase it, irrespective of whether they have the money. They will spend first and try to collect afterwards. We should tackle this if at all possible. The real beneficiaries are the newspapers and other media. Having said that, posters are a service to democracy. They heighten awareness that there is an election.

Comment on this

They create an atmosphere.

Comment on this

Yes. They may not do a great job for a party or a candidate but they are a major contributory factor in bringing the public out on the day, although they are not environmentally friendly. The Minister is right, there must be a change in funding and we should have done it years ago. Deputy Dempsey said the public may react unfavourably to what we are doing but anything politicians do relating to money is suspect because of the cynicism which exists. If we argue that we cannot carry on as we have been, people will accept that. I believe this will be accepted as a major improvement in the way we run our democracy as distinct from our parties.

Comment on this

There are other elections such as Presidential elections, local elections, by-elections, referenda, etc. We have far too many elections and for that reason I favour Deputy Dempsey's idea of examining the electoral system and considering fixed term elections. We have had 25 elections in 75 years, one every three years, and there have been by-elections which have diverted us and cost a great deal. Bigger issues are involved.

Comment on this

The Minister has honed in on part of the Bill we are not discussing yet relating to disclosure.

Comment on this

The Deputy raised it.

Comment on this

I mentioned it in the context of our discussion but it was not my main argument. The Minister will know I have tabled few amendments to that part of the Bill and those I have suggested are designed to tighten the provisions so that politicians will not be at a disadvantage as regards other people. I have nothing against the principle of disclosure.

I take Deputy Nealon's point and I do not disagree with much of what he or the Minister said on this section about financing political parties. As I said, if we are going to do this we should do it properly and fairly and if the Minister is going to preserve this provision in the Bill we must address the issue of fairness. It is not fair to provide £390,000 for Fianna Fáil, £200,000 for Labour and £240,000 for Fine Gael because that will not provide the adequate funding for political parties which the Minister says he wants to achieve. He does not aim to provide total funding for the parties and the political system. However, if one takes into account the running costs of a party such as Fianna Fáil and the fact that, as Deputy Nealon said, the church gate collection will cease when State funding begins, our branches and constituency organisations will have to raise £1 million per annum. I do not know the running expenses of the Labour Party but I do not think Fianna Fáil's day to day running costs are extravagant. We accept the principle but the electorate will reject it. If the Minister persists with the provision, he might as well be hung for a sheep as a lamb. The system he puts in place should be fair but what he proposes in this part of the Bill is not fair to the larger parties.

As to disclosure, the reaction from people who give us money shows that this provision will not shut off donations. In common with other parties, we are seeking money in the run-up to the election. People are willing to contribute, most of them do not mind and will accept the £4,000 limit although they would prefer it to be £10,000. I have nothing to say against disclosure.

The Minister spoke about a perception. He and I have too much respect for the electorate to think it can be bought with high spending at elections, so I am not unduly worried about that. To some extent it is unfair to larger parties with many candidates but we can deal with that at the proper time. None of the parties is dependent on big business and no favours are granted exclusively on the basis that donations were made. Various allegations have been made but nothing has been proven. Our system is and has been largely free of corruption.

If the Minister expects me, as a representative not just of the public but also my party, to accept he is trying to deal fairly with everyone as regards funding for political parties, he will have to return on the specifics of this section. I proposed the deletion of this section so we could have a broader discussion and to see if the Minister could indicate that he would look again at the original deal made on this point.

Comment on this

That is unconstitutional.

Comment on this

How is it unconstitutional?

Comment on this

The Minister has been asked to see the Taoiseach at 10.15 a.m. Will the committee agree to adjourn at that time until 1.30 p.m., when we will sit until 3 p.m.? Is that agreed? Agreed.

Are Deputy Dempsey's figures accurate?

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance and I explained in December that, as a result of the McKenna judgment, we have separated different types of funding which must be seen in context. The first is support for the parliamentary activities of parties, as mentioned by Deputy Nealon.

Comment on this

That is in the Constitution.

Comment on this

That is right. Fianna Fáil gets £765,000, Fine Gael, £397,000; the Labour Party, £297,000; the Progressive Democrats, £185,000; Democratic Left £97,000; the Green Party, £25,000 and others get £30,000. Each Independent gets £10,000 for research and support.

Comment on this

That is influenced by whether the party is in Government.

Comment on this

Yes. There is an additional sum for those not in Government which is why the figures for Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats are considerably more.

Comment on this

What is the figure for Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

It is £765,000.

Comment on this

It is approximately £10,000 per Deputy.

Comment on this

There is a sliding scale.

Comment on this

Which is unfair to us. Individual Deputies should get £30,000.

Comment on this

That amounts to £1.8 million. There is a system for funding the political parties outside Parliament. Every party which gets a threshold of 2 per cent, whether they have members elected, will be entitled to that. We need to be seen to treat everyone fairly. Someone could be elected if they got 2 per cent of the national vote in one or two constituencies, but someone could get 2 per cent nationally and not be elected.

Comment on this

One person could be elected if they got 2 per cent of the national vote.

Comment on this

Or they could get 2 per cent and not be elected.

Comment on this

They would still get money.

Comment on this

Everybody who gets 2 per cent will get money because they have a political party to run. New parties have made the point that if they get a threshold of 2 per cent, they should have access to funds.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

It will enable them to grow.

Comment on this

It will help to support the democratic system. They have only a small entitlement to money. We fixed the pot at £1 million and everyone gets a percentage.

Comment on this

Even a raving loony or fascist party?

Comment on this

If they get 2 per cent of the national vote.

Comment on this

Or if six independent candidates in six constituencies decide to call themselves a party?

Comment on this

No, they must be a registered party.

Comment on this

Anyone could be a registered party. That is why an amendment was made to section 25.

Comment on this

The amendments make it difficult to register a political party. What is wrong with the system?

Comment on this

It is madness.

Comment on this

The 2 per cent threshold is low.

Comment on this

It is not. Deputies should look at the parties which reached it at the last election.

Comment on this

It is low.

Comment on this

It is to get Democratic Left in after the next election when it gets 1 per cent.

Comment on this

We cannot be exclusive. There are smaller niche parties which have a right to be represented. If we look at the threshold in other countries ——

Comment on this

It is 5 per cent in Germany.

Comment on this

——it varies from 1 per cent or 1.5 per cent to 4 per cent or 5 per cent.

Comment on this

Strong regional parties could only have 2 per cent nationally.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

We are discussing amendments Nos. 65, 66 and 94, amendments Nos. 1 and 2 to amendment No. 94 and amendment No. 231, which is consequential on amendment No. 94. We have had much discussion this morning and previously on these amendments.

Comment on this

I said something to the Minister earlier on the principle of this and the point of view I put forward on funding political parties. While we may agree or disagree on whether the electorate wants this, the Minister is intent on including this section. Will he adopt a more realistic attitude to the amounts of money he proposes to make available to political parties which is crucial from our party's point of view?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy change his attitude to the section?

Comment on this

The Minister said we made an agreement when in Government, but we did so on a completely different basis. If the Minister is intent on including this section, so be it. The people can make a judgment on it and on us. The Minister said many sections and amounts of money were not written in stone. Will he give me an idea as to whether he is prepared to talk about changing the £1 million included in the Bill?

Comment on this

That figure has been negotiated between the parties in Government and is a reasonable sum. I do not want to trespass too far on the willingness of the electorate and the taxpayer to support the political system. The sums involved are reasonable for the general running of a political party. I cannot give a definitive answer as to whether there will be some movement. If the Deputy said he supported the principles of the section and an amendment of the figures, I would be happy to discuss it further with Government, but I would have to know that in advance.

Comment on this

The proposal is totally unreasonable in that it is too low.

Comment on this

The Government is committed to enacting this legislation as quickly as possible and to having it in place for the next election. I said that at the beginning of this debate.

Comment on this

I have made no bones about it from our point of view. We have a difficulty with the amounts and so on.

Comment on this

If we revisit the figures, everybody would benefit proportionately from an increase. I do not know how the Minister for Finance or my Government colleagues would react to that. If I believed I would build greater political consensus on the principle, I would be willing to discuss it with them.

Comment on this

This section will be included regardless because we are in a minority. There would be greater political consensus if the figures were more realistic.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be prepared to go further on the disclosure thresholds?

Comment on this

The disclosure thresholds are very low at present.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy go lower?

Comment on this

No. I do not believe they are connected.

Comment on this

The Deputy made the connection when he said that the effect of the disclosure would be to freeze off——

Comment on this

It is one of our fears. I was honest with the Minister because I have met fundraisers in the party who are trying to raise funds for the election and so on.

Comment on this

Quite successfully.

Comment on this

I hope so. We can always get credit in advance. Although fundraisers have said there is not much disquiet and that people will comply, we do not know that until the Bill is implemented. I gave the figure of £1.5 million for ordinary running costs each year. I do not know if Deputy McCormack or the chairman know the Fine Gael figures. I take it there will be a fall out even in the church gate collection, our major fund raising event for party administration. We will both have to make an act of faith.

Comment on this

What type of figure would the Deputy consider?

Comment on this

I would like to go as close as possible to the original figure but I know that would not be feasible because it was not accepted by Government before. I suggest a figure between the two amounts.

Comment on this

I will bring the Deputy's point of view to Government. However, I cannot give the Deputy a commitment in this regard. I am anxious that we have as much political consensus as possible. It is important because no matter which party is in Government after an election, it will be governed by these rules. I would like to be fair to everyone. There is no agenda other than trying to address a few basic principles which are important. All parties have agreed in broad strokes to the principle. We may be able to build a broader consensus by adjusting figures. Nothing is written in stone on that front but I cannot make arbitrary decisions on expenditure.

Comment on this

I accept that. I will withdraw the amendment to give the Minister a chance to discuss it with the Government.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 66:

In page 11, line 31, after "POLITICAL PARTIES" to insert "AND REIMBURSEMENT OF ELECTION EXPENSES OF CANDIDATES".

This is a technical amendment to extend the title.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 68, 69 and 70 are related to amendment No. 67. Amendments Nos. 67 to 70, inclusive, may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 67:

In page 11, subsection (1)(b), line 38, to delete "of a candidate" and substitute "of at least 10 candidates".

This relates to the definition of political parties. We have proposed a longer amendment which deals with the process of registration.

Comment on this

Have we dealt with the new section 18?

Comment on this

We are on section 14.

Comment on this

In some respects, this amendment is linked to later arguments I will make regarding the registration of political parties. The Minister spoke earlier about being fair to everybody and giving people the widest possible opportunity to be involved in the political system. I do not oppose that nor do I believe that people should necessarily get involved in existing political parties. However, it is a mockery of serious political parties, which are striving to develop policies, conduct research and contribute to the political system, to deem as a qualified party entitled to payment a party that puts forward one candidate at a general election. No group which puts forward one candidate should be deemed to be a political party or get payment from the Exchequer as a result. Nobody could treat such a party as a serious political party.

Comment on this

This amendment relates to the section dealing with party registration. Every registered party must be treated in the same way. There is at least one regional party functioning in Kerry which is likely to run a candidate. It qualifies for registration as a political party.

Comment on this

Because of our lax laws.

Comment on this

We will debate that later. It is important to deal with this issue correctly. The later amendment proposed by the Deputy seeks to rewrite the process of registration and I am loath to accept it. This legislation is about establishing the political system here and we must be as open as possible. There is also case law involved.

Comment on this

I understand the constitutional concerns of the Minister and his legal advisers. However, this could lead to severe splintering of the political process and that is not in the interest of political stability or of the country. I recall what happened in Germany when a similar situation pertained under the Weimar Republic. It was not possible to form a stable government and there were disastrous consequences.

Under Standing Orders of the Dáil a political party must have a minimum of seven members. If this Bill is enacted, one member of a party who is elected to the House will have to be recognised as a party and will have the same rights as parties with 60 and 70 members. There is already disproportionate treatment of small parties in the House. Proportionality should work both ways. The concept of a one member party appears to stretch constitutional demands too far.

Comment on this

The legislation is based on careful legal analysis of a Supreme Court judgment. We have tried to base support for political parties on electoral support in terms of votes. That is why we have established the 2 per cent threshold; it is not based on members elected or candidates fielded. It is reasonable that the 2 per cent threshold should activate the payment system. Unless a party is registered it will not qualify for payment. We can address the issue of tightening up the registration procedure but once a party is registered and receives the requisite percentage of the vote, it must be entitled to payment like any other political party.

Comment on this

In theory can a party which puts forward one candidate receive 2 per cent of the vote? Is the Minister referring to 2 per cent of the vote in the constituency?

Comment on this

No, nationally.

Comment on this

It would not be possible to get 2 per cent of the vote with one candidate.

Comment on this

It would not be possible.

Comment on this

Would the party not be disqualified for funding?

Comment on this

Yes. Two per cent of the vote was 37,000 votes in the last election.

Comment on this

At least five candidates would be required to secure 37,000 first preferences. Why not make it a realistic figure? We are including a theoretical figure to make the provision look right when, in practice, one candidate cannot get 2 per cent of the votes. That defeats the purpose. We need a system to get this right rather than just having it look right.

Comment on this

The focus is not on the number of candidates. That does not matter. We must provide that the party contests the election and payment will be on the basis of achieving the threshold of votes. A party might not have a candidate elected and still get 2 per cent of the vote.

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this

It does not matter if the party fields one or ten candidates. The two criteria are, first, that the party is registered and, second, that it secures the percentage of the vote.

Comment on this

Why is one candidate mentioned?

Comment on this

That indicates that the party must field a candidate. In essence, we are saying the party must contest the election.

Comment on this

It would be better to contest the election and get, say, 2 per cent of the vote, rather than specifying——

Comment on this

What does contesting the election mean? Does it mean field one candidate or contest the election in every constituency?

Comment on this

A candidate has to be elected.

Comment on this

That is what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

That has been amended. The original 1994 Bill says that he must be elected. Page nine of the blue book before members sets out the amended wording for section 15 and includes the following:

(a) the party registered in the Register of Political Parties. . .

(b) the party authenticated the candidature of a candidate at the last preceding general election of members to the Dáil; and

(c) the total first preference votes obtained by candidates whose candidatures were authenticated by the party at that election expressed as a percentage of total first preference votes obtained by all candidates at that election was not less than two per cent.

Comment on this

It safeguards us.

Comment on this

Yes. If the section is read as it would read in the amended section 15 set out in the blue book it will be seen that the situation is as I explained.

Comment on this

Presumably the figure of 2 per cent refers to 2 per cent of the total first preference national vote?

Comment on this

Yes, by all candidates at that election.

Comment on this

Is it not necessary to specify "national" vote?

Comment on this

I am advised that the wording is taken to mean that.

Comment on this

What about a candidate who obtains 2 per cent of the vote in a constituency claiming that he got 2 per cent of the total vote?

Comment on this

Is it necessary to include paragraph (b) in the section? The provision demeans political parties by referring to the putting forward of a single candidate and the total first preference votes obtained by candidates.

Comment on this

If the party does not have any candidates it cannot get 2 per cent of the vote.

Comment on this

It is not consistent with the other provisions.

Comment on this

It is consistent. Deputy Dempsey does not like the notion of a candidate or candidates.

Comment on this

It is covered under paragraph (c).

Comment on this

I will consider that.

Comment on this

Suppose there is a reform party which splits. Does paragraph (b) not exclude it? If a party splits why cannot it get funding?

Comment on this

I do not understand the question.

Comment on this

Suppose a reform party contests the election and wins 60 seats. A split ensues, with 30 seats going one way. Why cannot the two factions share its portion of the £1 million, based on the fact that it is a registered political party and it has Members in the Dáil, which would satisfy the criteria? It cannot prejudice the Exchequer because the money is merely being divided.

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with prejudicing the Exchequer or with sums of money. I have considered these issues from a practical viewpoint. I do not want a mechanism that would encourage parties to split.

Comment on this

It would not encourage them, but it would treat them fairly if they split, for whatever reason.

Comment on this

Until they rectified themselves and presented themselves in their new livery at the next election. I do not believe that a party can be established and make the assumption that it won X per cent of the vote at the election in its previous incarnation. It is predicated on the party standing and getting a political endorsement of at least 2 per cent of the vote nationally.

Comment on this
Mr. McDowell

Had this legislation been in existence, the Workers Party would have continued to get funding even though it was reduced to only one Deputy. What is the point of that?

Comment on this

It is important that there be validation of the party. At that time, the Workers Party fielded candidates which were elected. Until such time as the electorate is again asked to give an opinion——

Comment on this

The cheques from Moscow would have continued. Would it not be clearer to give Members of the Dáil the same status?

Comment on this

What happens if a person leaves a party and becomes an Independent? Can the Deputy draw the annual allowance for Independent Members?

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with this Bill.

Comment on this

However, the principle is the same.

Comment on this