SECTION 14.
Contributions 130–254 of 254. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
This Bill is focused on funding political parties which are registered as such and obtain a threshold of votes and on the recoupment of money to candidates of all and no political persuasion who hold their deposit in the election. The question of funding for research, etc., is incorporated in legislation sponsored by my colleague, the Minister for Finance, and was enacted last December.
Comment on this
I support the Minister. Any incentive that might allow parties to splinter should be discouraged. The only logical way in which support for a party can be measured is by reference to the support it obtained in the last election.
Comment on this
On the basis that the Minster will consider removing paragraph (b) from the revised section 15——
Comment on this
It is fuller with the paragraph included. I do not know why the Deputy considers that the phrase "the candidature of a candidate at the last preceding general election" somehow demeans a political party.
Comment on this
That is why I suggest it be deleted. It demeans political parties if anybody can put forward candidates at a general election and be deemed to be a political party.
Comment on this
How does the Register of Political Parties define what is a genuine political party?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:
In page 11, subsection (1)(b), line 39 after "Dáil;" to insert "and".
This is a minor drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:
In page 11, subsection (1), lines 40 to 44, to delete paragraphs (c) and (d) and substitute the following:
"(c) the total first preference votes obtained by candidates whose candidatures were authenticated by the party at that election expressed as a percentage of total first preference votes obtained by all candidates at that election was not less than two per cent.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:
In page 12, lines 1 to 31, to delete subsection (2).
The changes provided in these amendments take account of the detailed legal advice obtained in light of the judgments in the McKenna case. They are designed to meet the emphasis in the judgments on fairness and equality in the electoral system and the democratic process.
Comment on this
It is unnecessary because of the new thrust that the McKenna judgment requires us to take in regard to it. In the new section, there is a definition of "qualified party" which is as I propose in section 15.
Comment on this
No, a group has to register as a political party. There is a body of amendments to deal with the criteria for registration later.
Comment on this
Has subsection (2) become redundant because membership of political parties is irrelevant?
Comment on this
A qualified party is a political party which complies with a, b, and c. The definition of a political party is one that is registered in accordance with the Registrar of Political Parties. What does the word "political" mean? Can the ICMSA, for example, register as a political party?
Comment on this
The criteria for qualification for registration of a political party are laid down and I will deal with them later. The Registrar of Political Parties must determine which are qualified in accordance with the law and judicial pronouncements on this matter.
Comment on this
I am worried that the definition is circular because political party means one registered in accordance with the law. There is no explanation for the word "political" in that context.
Comment on this
If the ICMSA wishes to become a political party, it has to make an application to the Registrar of Political Parties, qualify under the criteria laid down and be enshrined in it. If any party is so enshrined it qualifies.
Comment on this
With respect, the Minister is providing a circular definition. He says that a political party means a political party in the following——
Comment on this
It is a political party which complies with certain criteria. The Minister tabled an amendment to section 2 to insert the word "political" in the definition of a political party. What does he mean by the word "political"?
Comment on this
I am slightly worried about it because the Minister must have some reason. He included the word "political" on advice. What does he achieve by doing so?
Comment on this
It was for ease of comprehension. A party can be an individual and a political party has a normal meaning in English. A political party is a party registered with the Registrar of Political Parties under the procedures laid down. That is clear.
Comment on this
It is not a criminal offence to set up a political party outside the Act.
Comment on this
Due to typographical errors in printing of the first and second list of amendments on the above mentioned Bill, the corrections to the following amendments should be noted -Amendment No. 73: in line 3 of subsection (4) (a), the reference to "general hearing" should read "general meeting"; Amendment No. 121 is proposed by the Minister for the Environment whose title has been omitted from the list of amendments.
Amendment No. 222 is related to amendment No. 73 and both may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:
In page 12, before section 15, to insert the following new section:
"REGISTRATION OF POLITICAL PARTIES
15 — (1) The Electoral Act, 1992, is hereby amended by the substitution of the following section for section 25:
‘25.-(1) (a) The person who for the time being holds the office of Clerk the Dáil shall be the Registrar of Political Parties (in this section referred to as "the Registrar") who shall, subject to the subsequent provisions of this section, prepare and maintain a Register of Political Parties (in this section referred to as "the Register").
(b) If and so long as the office of Clerk of the Dáil is vacant or the holder of that office is unable through illness, absence or other cause to fulfill his duties, the Clerk-Assistant of the Dáil shall act as Registrar for the purposes of this section.
(c) If and so long as the Office of Clerk of the Dáil and the office of Clerk-Assistant of the Dáil are vacant or the holders of those offices are unable through illness, absence or other cause to fulfill their duties, the Chairman of the Dáil may appoint a member of the Joint Staff of the Houses of the Oireachtas to act as Registrar for the purposes of this section.
(2) (a) A political party may apply to the Registrar to be registered in the Register as a party organised in the State to contest a Dáil election or a European election or a local election.
(b) An application for registration under this section shall be in such form as shall be prescribed by the Registrar.
(c) Where a party is registered as organised to contest a particular type or types of election, the registration shall have effect only in relation to elections of the type or types concerned.
(3) Neither an application for registration nor an application for an amendment of the Register under this section may be made in the case of—
(a) a European election, in the period commencing on the date of the appointment by the Minister by order of a day to be polling day in accordance with section 10 of the European Parliament Elections Act, 1997 and ending on the date of the issue by the Registrar of a copy or copies of the Register for the purposes of that election, or
(b) a local election, in the period commencing on the date of the appointment by the Minister by order of a day to be polling day in accordance with section 21 of the Local Government Act, 1994 and ending on the date of the issue by the Registrar of a copy or copies of the Register for the purposes of that election.
(4) Subject to the provisions of this section, the Registrar shall register every political party which applies in accordance with this section for registration provided that at the time the application is made —
(a) the organisation and direction of the party are governed by a constitution, articles of association, rules or other regulations which have been adopted by a general hearing or delegate conference of the party and which provide for—
(i) annual or other periodic meetings or conferences of the party; and
(ii) the conduct of the business of the party by an executive committee or similar body elected by the party; and
(b) (i) the membership of the party as certified to the Registrar in writing by a person qualified for appointment as auditor of a company in accordance with section 187 of the Companies Act, 1990 comprises not less than 300 persons (or, in the case of a party applying for registration as a party organised to contest a local election only, 100 persons) each of whom has reached the age of 18 years, or
(ii) at least one person who is a member of the Dáil or an Irish representative in the European Parliament (or, in the case of a party which applies for registration as a party organised to contest a local election only, each of three persons who are members of a local authority) certifies in writing to the Registrar that he or she is a member of the party.
(5) The following particulars shall be entered in the Register in respect of a political party registered therein—
(a) the name of the party,
(b) the address of the party's head-quarters,
(c) the name or names of the officer or officers of the party, one of whom shall be the duly elected leader or chairperson (or the equivalent officer) of the party, authorised to sign certificates authenticating the candidature of candidates of the party at elections,
(d) the type or types of election for which the party is registered as being organised to contest.
(6) Where a political party which is registered in the Register as a party organised to contest a European election informs the Registrar that a member of the party who is an Irish representative in the European Parliament is a member of a political group formed in accordance with the rules of procedure of that Parliament, and if that member of the party certifies to the Registrar in writing for the purposes of this section that he is a member of both such party and such group as aforesaid, the Registrar shall note on the Register, in relation to the party, the name of the group.
(7) A political party shall not be registered in the Register if its name—
(a) is identical with the name of any party already registered in the Register or, in the opinion of the Registrar, so nearly resembles such name as would be likely to mislead, confuse or deceive,
(b) is, in the opinion of the Registrar, unduly long.
(8) (a) The duly elected leader or chairperson (or the equivalent officer) of a political party registered in the Register shall notify the Registrar of any changes in the name or names of the officer or officers referred to in paragraph (c) of subsection (5) and the Registrar shall amend the Register accordingly and where such person fails to so inform the Registrar, whether at the request of the Registrar or otherwise, the Registrar shall cancel the registration of the party.
(b) Where any doubt, dispute or question arises in relation to a notification under paragraph (a), the name or names of the officer or officers entered in the Register pursuant to paragraph (c) of subsection (5) shall, untill the doubt, dispute or question is resolved, be deemed to be those entered in the Register prior to the said notification.
(9) Where the particulars entered in the Register in accordance with subsection (5) (other than those referred to in paragraph (c) thereof) change in any respect, an officer of the party referred to in the said paragraph (c) shall apply in writing to the Registrar as soon as possible for an amendment of the Register in respect of such change and the Registrar shall consider each such application and may, subject to the provisions of this section, amend the Register accordingly.
(10) The Registrar shall, with respect to each party registered in the Register, inquire in writing at least once in each year from an officer of the party referred to in paragraph (c) of subsection (5) whether the party desires to remain registered and, unless he receives an affirmative reply to such an inquiry within twenty-one days from the date of the making of such inquiry, he shall cancel the registration of the party forthwith.
(11) (a) As soon as he has considered an application for registration or an application for an amendment of the Register, the Registrar shall notify the applicant of his decision on the application (stating reasons in the case of disallowance) and shall cause notice thereof to be published in the Iris Oifigiúil.
(b) Where the Registrar has disallowed either an application for registration or an application for an amendment of the Register, and has stated his reasons for so doing in accordance with paragraph (a), such statement shall be regarded as a sufficient statement of the reasons for the disallowance.
(12) Where it appears to the Registrar that a political party registered in the Register has ceased to meet the criteria for registration set out in subsection (4) or has failed to comply with the requirements of this section, he shall, following such inquiry as he thinks fit, publish in the Iris Oifigiúil notice of his intention to cancel the registration of the party.
(13) A decision of the Registrar shall be questioned only by way of an appeal under this section.
(14) (a) For the purposes of hearing appeals under this section there shall be an appeal board which shall consist of a Judge of the High Court, (to be nominated by the President of the High Court), who shall be chairman, the Chairman of the Dáil (or where he is unable, through illness, absence or other cause to fulfill his duties or the office of Chairman is vacant, the Deputy Chairman of the Dáil) and the Chairman of the Seanad (or where he is unable, through illness, absence or other cause to fulfill his duties or the office of Chairman is vacant, the Deputy Chairman of the Dáil) and the Chairman of the Seanad (or where he is unable, through illness, absence or other cause to fulfill his duties or the office of Chairman is vacant, the Deputy Chairman of the Seanad).
(b) The appeal board shall, when considering an appeal under this section, consider—
(i) the grounds for the appeal stated pursuant to subsection (16) (a), and
(ii) such information (if any) as was made available to the Registrar in connection with the application for registration, the application for an amendment of the Register, or the cancellation of the registration, as the case may be,
and no other information.
(c) The Registrar shall give to the appeal board such information in relation to every appeal considered pursuant to this section as the appeal board may reasonably require of him.
(d) The decision of the appeal board shall be final and shall be complied with by the Registrar.
(15) (a) Any of the following persons may, before 12 noon on the seventh day next following the date of publication by the Registrar of a notice in the Iris Oifgiúilpursuant to this section, appeal to the appeal board against such of the decisions of the Registrar as are herein after specified:
(i) in the case of a disallowance under subsection (11) of either an application for registration or an application for an amendment of the Register, the party by which the application was made,
(ii) in the case of an allowance under subsection (11) of either an application for registration or an application for an amendment of the Register, any party registered in the Register at the date of the giving by the Registrar of such notice
(iii) in the case of a cancellation under subsection (12) of registration, the party whose registration it is proposed to cancel.
(b) Where no appeal is made under this subsection within the period specified in paragraph (a) the decision of the Registrar shall thereupon become final.
(c) Where a party is registered in the Register, the registration of the party shall not be affected by any appeal pending under paragraph (a) (iii).
(16) (a) An appeal under this section to the appeal board shall be made in writing and shall state the grounds on which the appeal is made and shall be delivered or sent by post so as to reach the Clerk of the Seanad on or before the time specified in paragraph (a) of subsection (15) together with the deposit referred to in paragraph (b), and any such appeal which is received by the Clerk of the Seanad after that time shall not be entertained or considered by the appeal board.
(b) An appeal under this section shall not be considered by the appeal board unless at the time the appeal is made a deposit of £500 is lodged with the Clerk of the Seanad by, or on behalf of, the appellant, which sum shall on the determination of the appeal be returned to the person by whom it was lodged unless the appeal board considers the appeal to be frivolous or vexatious and directs that the deposit be forfeited.
(c) A deposit forfeited under this section shall be disposed of by the Clerk of the Seanad in such manner as may be directed by the Minister for Finance.
(d) The Clerk of the Seanad, on receipt of an appeal under this section, shall notify the Registrar of such receipt as soon as possible and any such appeal shall be open to inspection at all convenient times by the Registrar.
(17) The Registrar shall maintain a copy of the Register at his office and shall furnish, on request, to any person a copy of it.
(18) The Registrar may require any person to give any information in his possession which the Registrar may reasonably require for the purpose of his duties under this section.
(19) (a) The Registrar may require from any political party which applies to him for registration or for an amendment of the Register all such information as he reasonably requires for the determination by him of the allowance or disallowance of the application, and the Registrar may disallow the application of any party which fails or refuses to give any information so required of it under this section.
(b) Notwithstanding the authority of the Registrar to request information, it shall be the duty of every political party which applies to him for registration or for an amendment of the Register to provide such information as may be necessary to satisfy the Registrar that it is entitled to be registered in the Register in accordance with the provisions of this section.
(c) The Registrar may require that information furnished to him for the purposes of this section be accompanied by a statutory declaration made by the person by whom the information is furnished (or by such other person as he considers appropriate in the circumstances) that, to the best of the person's knowledge and belief, the information is correct in every material respect and that the person has taken all reasonable action in order to be satisfied as to the accuracy of the information.
(20) On the day of the issuing under section 39 of a writ or writs, the Registrar shall sent to the returning officer or each returning officer a copy of the Register then in force.
(1) The Register then in force at the commencement of this section shall be deemed to be the register prepared and maintained under this section and each political party registered therein shall, on the date of such commencement, be deemed to have conformed to the requirements of subsection (4).'.
(2) Rule 3 of the Second Schedule to the European Parliament Elections Act, 1997, is hereby amended by the deletion of 'On' and the substitution therefor of 'Not later than'.".
I may take time on this and I hope the Minister does not think I am filibustering. I thought the amendment might be tabled in various sections and we would deal with them as a series of amendments.
Comment on this
On a procedural point, this is basically a huge redrafting of the procedure for registration of political parties. There is some merit in looking at this but it does not belong in this Bill. We need to build a fair consensus in the political system before we redefine draconian terms of what constitutes a political party. There are very broad ranging impacts on this set of proposals. It will greatly narrow the possibility of registration of political parties. Eminent constitutional advisers are Members of this committee and are sitting on either side of Deputy Dempsey. I am not sure that parts of this would survive constitutional purview. I ask that this be looked at separately so that we can come to a political consensus to amend the registration process without further complicating this Bill. Even within the Deputy's party a broad discussion is needed on the impact of this measure.
Comment on this
If I thought the Minister was not going to put in place other aspects of the Bill as they affect political parties until we had that broad discussion I would have no difficulty acceding to his request. I agree this is an extensive amendment but it is not draconian.
Comment on this
It was designed to replace section 25 of the 1992 Act. Political parties will receive funding under the Bill but the criteria for registering parties in the 1992 Act are not sufficient. The Minister probably does not intend it to be interpreted as I have done. I make no apologies for being a member of a political party and for ensuring that an organisation must fulfil certain criteria to be a political party. Without labouring the point, political parties have served the State well. I do not mind people running as Independents or regional political parties but if a political party is to be worthy of the name it should have basic, minimum standards. Before I propose my amendment, is the Minister prepared to guarantee that we will discuss the registration of political parties before this Bill is brought into effect?
Comment on this
I cannot give that guarantee but as soon as this is done I will discuss the proposals with the committee and try to reach a consensus on defining the registration process separately from this. I am not my own master on the Government decision to bring this into force. I am under instructions to have it enacted as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not agree the Electoral Bill is the right place to define a political party? Where else should it be defined?
Comment on this
I do not say it is inappropriate to this Bill but it is inappropriate to do so by way of a huge block of amendments which fundamentally change the existing legislation. I would like time to discuss it further within my party and the Government parties. Given that the amendment was submitted the week before last, the Deputies opposite might not have had an opportunity to consider the implications of registration for the political system. I would happily look at this separately from the Bill, immediately after its enactment, to try to come to a consensus because it is an issue on which we should strive for consensus.
Comment on this
We could immediately introduce a Bill to amend the current legislation on registration of political parties.
Comment on this
If it facilitated the debate, we could arrange to place on the agenda a discussion on the registration of political parties immediately after Easter.
Comment on this
The only reason we had a system of party registration was to provide a description on the ballot paper. In the UK a candidate is allowed to describe himself as he pleases on the ballot paper, using up to 12 words. One could dispense with the system of registering political parties. Now, however, we are going further in that we are giving money to these entities. It is, therefore, reasonable from the public's point of view to ask what the entities are and how they are registered. It is an intrinsic part of this Bill.
Comment on this
If a party is set up to advocate a fundamentalist position, whether on the left or the right, it would be entitled to receive money under the Bill, even if it was organised in consultation with international organisations
Comment on this
Only if it gets the qualifying degree of electoral support. We cannot pick and choose political parties or deprive people of legitimate support because we do not like what they say. In France, the National Front gets votes and if it reaches the threshold it is entitled to the political supports available to parties in France. We do not need to like what they say. There are fundamentalists.
Comment on this
That is one of the fundamental objections to this Bill — fascists, racists and anti-semites can receive public money to help them propagate their policies
Comment on this
. If they put forward candidates and receive 2 per cent of the vote they receive a pay out from the Exchequer to help them receive 4 per cent the next time. That is the kind of thing which helped Hitler into office.
Comment on this
We can take this to absurd degrees. There are legal norms in the Incitement to Hatred Act and other legislation which provide that racists comments would not be tolerated. I do not think the political system can decide it likes and will give money to one political entity and not to another.
Comment on this
In the Deputy's absence we were making great progress towards building a consensus on the principle of funding.
Comment on this
In the last six weeks the Taoiseach has said that Sinn Féin is the same as the IRA and that the two are one movement. This Bill means that the party will receive public funding if it reaches the 2 per cent level of support.
Comment on this
Yes. I loathe the notion of Sinn Féin receiving money. Equally, I loathe the notion of Sinn Féin receiving 2 per cent of the vote. However, people may vote for the party and it is part of the political system. One thing we have striven for since the Downing Street Declaration is to bring groups like Sinn Féin into normal politics and debate, putting their arguments peaceably to the people of the Republic and Northern Ireland. The fundamental principle of supporting political parties with taxpayers' money is accepted in a range of democratic countries and once it is accepted we cannot pick and choose, we just set the threshold of electoral support. All groups will be required to comply with the law of the land and the norms on incitement to hatred, etc.
Comment on this
There is a difficulty because legitimate political parties could be excluded if the 2 per cent threshold was increased. However, if the threshold was 2 per cent of the vote, winning at least two seats and taking those seats——
Comment on this
The thrust of this Bill is not the support for parliamentary parties, that is, having people elected to Parliament. They are supported in the Bill introduced by my colleague, the Minister for Finance. This Bill supports political parties and is based on the support from the electorate regardless of whether the party has Dáil Members. A party can carry out normal political activity without electing people to the Dáil. For many years, the Green Party had no Dáil Members but was a legitimate party. If people feel strongly that the 2 per cent threshold — which is roughly 37,000 votes and not too many parties will qualify for more than that — should be higher, I will entertain that. None of these figures is set in stone. The idea is to be as reasonable as possible. However, we cannot pick and choose who qualifies and who does not.
Comment on this
The public wants to be satisfied that if money is being paid out to parties the registration system is properly run, which is why this amendment has been tabled. This issue is not separate from the Bill.
Comment on this
Looking at the figures from the last election, Sinn Féin would not have qualified. It got 1.6 per cent in the last election, with 27,800 votes for 41 candidates.
Comment on this
I want to phrase this carefully. There is a high level of anti traveller feeling, for example. There is nothing to stop anybody, particularly in constituencies where there is a perceived problem with travellers, setting up an anti-traveller party with the prevention of the provision of halting sites as its sole aim. That is not an incitement to hatred. An anti-traveller halting site candidate headed the poll in one town in an urban council election in Meath and two candidates were elected on the same platform in another town. There is nothing to stop such people getting together and saying they are a political party because of the looseness of the registration procedure, getting over 2 per cent of the national poll and getting State funds to propagate a policy which is at total variance with the stated policy of all other parties.
The Chairman asked us to focus on the amendment. Our net point is that if money is to be paid to political parties a proper registration system must be established under this Bill. I am prepared to be reasonable about this. I will consider withdrawing the amendment provided the Minister says we can talk about the amendment after Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I am not entitled or authorised to take this Bill off the agenda and deal with some other issue. I am not prepared to do that.
Comment on this
I am not talking about taking it off the agenda. I am talking about providing a proper registration procedure for the people to whom the Minister advocates giving taxpayers' money. If the Minister wishes to complete Committee Stage now, as he said he did, I am prepared to withdraw this amendment if we can agree a registration procedure after Committee Stage, which should not take too long. We could then finalise the Bill on Report Stage with a proper registration system.
The Minister cannot tell me the Department has not looked at this inside out and upside down because there have been court cases and it has been examining it since 1992. The Department has no intention of examining the registration of political parties if it can avoid it. Either we discuss this fully now or we get an undertaking from the Minister to discuss it before Report Stage.
Comment on this
I strongly support Deputy Dempsey. This is the right place to deal with this Bill, despite the Minister's protestations that it is for another day and other legislation. This Bill is the first legislation to give public funding to certain unincorporated associations. If one wants to formalise and regularise those associations, one does it at the time one provides funding for them.
Comment on this
I am not in a position to give an undertaking in the form required by the Deputy. I have said that as soon as this Bill has passed all Stages I will work through the details of registration with this committee. That is as much as I can say. I ask the Deputy to accept that as a reasonable approach.
Comment on this
I do not have the authority to stop the procedure at the end of Committee Stage and engage in a dialogue about registration.
Comment on this
If the Minister is not in that position, it would be best to deal with the amendment during Committee Stage. I gave fair warning that I had quite a lot to say on this amendment. I hesitate to move this amendment because I do not think the debate on it will be finished by the time Committee Stage is supposed to conclude.
Comment on this
I should warn Members there is a proposal to sit all day next Thursday. Perhaps the convenors will discuss that this afternoon.
Comment on this
In the printed version of the amendment the heading "SECTION 14" should read "SECTION 15".
Comment on this
This amendment is designed to replace section 25 of the 1992 Electoral Act. The amendment proposes there should be specific criteria for the registration of political parties to replace the current provisions which allow the registrar to do it based on his opinion. It also proposes to abolish the outdated concept of registration of a political party in part of the State.
It attempts to identify authorised officers within parties to ease some of the problems created for the registrar when a party splits, such as The Workers' Party and Democratic Left. Muintir na hÉireann has had at least three splits since it was formed. It allows for amendments to entries of the register of political parties. It also extends and refines the circumstances in which an appeal may be made and by whom. It prohibits application for a registration at election times. It defines matters to which the appeal board may have regard in hearing appeals. It suggests that appeals should be lodged to the Clerk of the Seanad rather than the registrar. It empowers the registrar to cancel registration in certain technical situations.
The amendment is very reasonable and long overdue. It is necessary to tighten up the current regulations which have been seen to be less than adequate over the years, particularly in light of a variety of court cases dating back to 1979. Deputy Lenihan mentioned that the only reason the registrar was put in place originally was to allow people to put the name of their political party on a ballot paper. However, given the proposal that people will qualify for taxpayers' money on the basis of registration, it is time to address this issue and provide for proper registration criteria.
I was surprised to learn that it was sufficient for the registrar to form the opinion that a party was a political party and that he could, therefore, register a party as such. It is ridiculous that a group can become a political party on the basis that the registrar forms an opinion that it is genuine and organised in the absence of criteria defining these terms.
The Bill provides for all kinds of regulations and for the disclosures of payments in respect of all political parties. There should be a level playing field when addressing these issues. Objective criteria must apply to all those wishing to register as political parties. Parties should have a semblance of an organisation, including a leadership structure, an executive, etc. The opinion of the registrar is not sufficient in this respect.
The minimum criteria we propose are reasonable and straightforward. We suggest that before any party is registered it should have a constitution, articles of association or rules, annual or periodic meetings, an executive, a minimum of 300 registered members and one Member of Dáil Éireann. If we continue with present arrangements any group of misfits could call itself a political party. Given the importance attached to the registration of political parties, especially after the passing of this legislation, standards must be established to which all adhere. The registrar is in an impossible position if the sole criterion is his opinion on what constitutes a genuine political party.
The main reason for moving the amendment is the provisions in the Bill allowing taxpayers' money to be paid to individuals. The amendment does not allow a political party to be registered once an election is called. It also proposes the abolition of registration in respect of part of the State because of the statutory provisions in place.
The section dealing with the identification of authorised officers caters for splits in a registered party. Such a party will be required at all times to keep the registrar informed of the names of its officers and those authorised to authenticate candidates for the party at elections. In effect, the persons whose names are registered hold the registration of that party and can control its identity and participation in elections.
In recent times, parties have split and factions have assumed their electoral identity. In such circumstances the registrar, a non-political person, must judge and arbitrate between competing factions and effectively make a political decision. The registrar has no power to cancel registration in such circumstances. This amendment would allow him to do this. It would be a reasonable way out where competing claims arise over the ownership and authorised officers of a party.
The effect of part of the amendment is to pin registration to an authorised officer. This is reasonable because it allows the registrar to cancel registration without having to adjudicate on a political matter. In addition, the amendment would allow the registrar to amend entries. At present, registered parties are required to keep the registrar informed of the names of their authorised officers, but there is no provision whereby a party can change its registered name or address or alter other details, such as the class of election it is to contest.
The amendment also introduces the concept of an application for amendment to the register in respect of the registered details. It would facilitate the registrar in adopting a more flexible approach to registering political parties and it would also exclude those intent on becoming political parties through the back door, such as lobby groups.
One of the purposes of the Electoral Act, 1992, is to allow people to put the name of a political party on the ballot paper. Since its enactment, there have been eight appeals regarding the registration of political parties. In one instance there was a judicial review which went to the High Court and the Supreme Court. A number of difficulties have arisen because of the use of the words "genuine" and "organised" and the term "the opinion of the registrar".
As the Minister acknowledged, there have been calls for changes to the section. However, these calls have been ignored by the Department because it has the luxury of holding the legislative reins of administrative power and it will not be in the firing line when the regulations are implemented. The Department's actions are not open to judicial review because of the restrictive nature of the Electoral Act.
It is necessary to define in the Bill who can or cannot be registered as political parties. Before taxpayers' money is spent, we must attempt to define a political party and how it can be formed. The Minister has difficulty with parts of the amendment but the Bill provides an ideal opportunity to deal with this matter. The Minister should not oppose the amendment. If he wishes to alter certain parts of it, he can introduce amendments on Report Stage. Proper registration of political parties is required. The amendment may not be perfect but it goes some way towards defining political parties in terms of our system. I ask the Minister to consider it more favourably than he has to date.
Comment on this
The Clerk of the Dáil, who is the registrar of political parties, wrote to the committee on this subject.
Comment on this
The amendment contains many elements and it must be considered separately. The fact that it is a single proposition makes it more difficult to positively address elements of it. My Department held discussions with the registrar of political parties over some time and I acknowledge this area must be considered. My amendment No. 222 deals with one aspect of it. I ask the Deputy to withdraw the amendment so it can be dealt with separately. We must ensure that action taken in the entire area of registration is right.
We cannot construct a registration system which makes it impossible for smaller parties to register. In addition, we do not need a system which makes it impossible for regional parties to register. For example, in the context of local elections, it is possible smaller and regional parties will not organise outside a county and parts of the amendment would make it difficult, if not impossible, for them to be registered.
I have great respect for the registrar of political parties but the compelling case made by Deputy Dempsey in terms of the burden placed on him does not reflect reality. There have been two applications for registration in recent years. The registrar is not swamped by a mountain of applications for registration which take up much of his time. I agree difficulties in relation to a number of issues need to be properly addressed. However, it is more important to get it right than to address the burden placed on an individual who is charged with a job.
I am anxious the amendment is not pressed. I will deal with the substance of the proposals seriatim,a word much loved by a council colleague of mine in County Wexford who shall remain nameless. The first proposal relates to the omission of registration for part of the State. The registrar stated in his correspondence that substantial difficulties of interpretation have arisen in relation to this concept, not least those outlined in Loftus v.the Attorney General.
If difficulties exist, the judgment of the Supreme Court in that case provides guidance for the registrar in reaching a decision. Two groups are registered as parties to contest local elections on the current register. Given the small number of new applications for entry on the register, it is difficult to understand the need for the amendment. The main purpose of the register is the registration of parties and the fact that difficulties might arise for the registrar is not in itself a sufficient reason to change the rules. If the facility to register for part of the State is removed, it could be argued that small parties might be deprived of registration as they would not be organised to contest elections on a national basis. The concept of limited registration for political parties has existed since 1963. Removal of this provision would represent a significant policy change which must be debated.
Comment on this
Yes, two are currently registered, including the South Kerry Independent Alliance. Its registration address is High Street, Killarney, County Kerry. It is registered for the constituency of South Kerry and the Killarney area in the constituency for local elections.
Comment on this
It does not say. I do not know if the other party is a sister of Deputy McDowell's party but it is called the Donegal Progressive Party. It is registered at Raphoe, Lifford, County Donegal, to contest elections in the constituency of Donegal.
Comment on this
These parties have a legitimate right to exist. I do not want to foreclose the option of groups functioning, registering and operating exclusively in certain constituencies or a region because only two parties are registered at present. This aspect must be carefully considered.
The second proposal relates to the amendment of entry details. I have no difficulty with that but I wish to deal with it separately. The third proposal relates to prohibiting applications for registration at election times. Under the amendment, no application may be made in the period commencing on the date of the appointment by the Minister by order of a day to be polling day for the European election and ending on the day the copy of the register is issued to returning officers. Local elections are mentioned but there is no reference to Dáil elections in the amendment. The registration of political parties would be prohibited in the run up to European and local elections but not Dáil elections. However, that omission is not my difficulty. There is merit in the proposal but the text is defective.
Comment on this
Dáil elections are not included because the register of political parties is published immediately after the declaration of a Dáil election. In effect, there would not be time to do it.
Comment on this
The fourth proposal provides that the criteria for registration should be specific provided that, at the time the application is made, the organisation and direction of the party are governed by a constitution, articles of association and rules or regulations adopted by the party. It also provides for a range of other matters. I defer to my three legal colleagues; I am intimidated and do not know what Deputy Dempsey and I are doing here. Accepting this amendment will make work for our colleagues because including these conditions for registration would be open to challenge in the courts and could be interpreted as being oppressive restrictions on recognition. In the Loftus case the Supreme Court said the words "organised to contest a Dáil or local election" refer not to the degree of perfection of the organisation, which we would all probably welcome, but to the fact of being organised for that object and purpose. The words "genuine political party" do not depend on the extent to which a group or body in question has established itself in the public consciousness or in the range or effectiveness of its organisation. It must be adjudged a genuine political party if is bound together by the cohesion of common political beliefs or aims and by being organised for electoral purposes as an entity to such extent and with such distinctiveness as to justify its claims to be a truly political party in its own right.
Comment on this
The Minister cannot seriously think he can give public money to a body which has no rules.
Comment on this
That is a different issue. According to the Minister here we are to give money to a body who need not have a rulebook.
Comment on this
That was on the basis of existing case law. If we made the law and a case goes to a judge, he will interpret what we meant in law.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying public money should be given to a group of people without rules?
Comment on this
I am not saying that. We put down clear criteria for the draw-down of funding. Here we are talking of the criteria for registration. I am open to a considerable overhaul of the registration procedure. This long amendment must be teased out carefully and I wish to have the space to do so. I probably have no objection to the bulk of this but let us examine this within the political system. I have spoken on smaller or regional parties and we can come to a consensus about modifying the registration regime without going the exact road mapped out by this amendment.
I acknowledge Deputy Dempsey's points on the identification of authorised officers, limitation of appeal board matters, appeals to be the sent to the Clerk of the Seanad instead of the registrar and the registrar's ability to cancel registration in certain circumstances of technical breaches of conditions of registration. Would the Deputy agree to my proposal to disentangle this? It is all one amendment. Deputy Dempsey says it does not all stand up.
Comment on this
The Minister has only addressed the omission of parties registered in part of the State. I accept the general point that this might be divided into a series of amendments. Perhaps that could be done at the next committee meeting.
Comment on this
The Minister did not because he was going to give money to parties registered under the current regime which I do not believe are political parties.
Comment on this
I will be speaking about the Minister's extensive programme of reform for local government next Thursday in Kenmare and he would not deprive me of that opportunity to say some nice things about his plan. When we resume he might respond to this.
Comment on this
To address my points, the Minister might propose his own measures to us at the next meeting.
Comment on this
Would it not make more sense for the Minister to come forward with his proposal and then Deputy Dempsey can see if he is happy with that?
Comment on this
I do not doubt the Minister but we know what will happen on Report Stage: the Bill will be guillotined in an hour or maybe without any discussion.
Comment on this
The meeting will adjourn until Thursday, 10 April, or Tuesday, 15 April. We will meet on Tuesday, 8 April, and Wednesday, 9 April, with a view to concluding Committee Stage if possible. This gives the Minister and Opposition spokespersons time to discuss this in order to find a way to make progress.
The Select Committee adjourned at 3 p.m.