We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE AND THE PUBLIC SERVICE

Valuation Bill, 2000: Committee Stage.

Contributions 186–379 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Valuation Bill 2000
Enacted

No. 43 of 2000 ›

To make sure that if there is information that a situation has changed, it is passed on. It could involve a local authority.

Comment on this

Does this relate to property owned by public bodies or to any information that it acquires?

Comment on this

It relates to the duty of a public body to provide certain information to the commissioner.

Comment on this

I think the Minister of State understands the point I am getting at. If properties come into the possession of public bodies or changes are made to public property by the Office of Public Works, will it be obligatory on public bodies to notify the commissioner so that their rateable valuation can be reassessed?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Will the Minister of State clarify what is meant by a public body. Under the national development plan there will be public-private partnerships. A development might be made to public property by a private company, as part of a public-private partnership. Is that the type of situation that would be covered? To use a classic example, Portlaoise Prison is on public lands, but it was designed, built and financed by the private sector and has not yet been brought back into State ownership. That would be an example of a major development on public lands owned by the State, but the building was designed, built, financed and owned by the private sector until such time as the State may decide to buy it back. Should the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform notify the Valuation Office of a development by a private developer on its property?

Comment on this

No, as it is the occupier. If it is deemed to be occupied by the State, as the property is in the example given by the Deputy, the State does not pay rates. If prisons were to be privatised——

Comment on this

That would be a different story. I thank the Minister of State for clarifying that.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

We skipped over and agreed section 41. I want to give notice that I intend to table an amendment on Report State requiring the annual report be published.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:

In page 33, between lines 36 and 37, to insert the following subsection:

"(5) Subsection (1) is without prejudice to section 53(7) (which requires the deletion, in certain circumstances, of the value of certain property from an existing valuation list).”.

Section 43 provides for an existing valuation list to continue in force until it is replaced by a new valuation list. However, where a global valuation of a public utility is undertaken and entered on a central valuation list, as set out in section 55, valuations attributed to that property on an existing list must be deleted to avoid duplication of rateable valuations. The proposed amendment provides for the deletion of such valuations in the circumstances. This is a technical amendment.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

This section highlights the imbalance in the Bill. It appears to be a Bill by the Valuation Office for the Valuation Office. I mentioned the opt-out clauses from deadlines throughout the Bill. This section provides that the time limit must be adhered to by the other person concerned. Subsection (1) provides that, "An officer of the Commissioner may serve a notice on a person who is the owner or occupier of any property (whether relevant property or not) requiring him or her to supply, within a period specified in the notice (being a period of not less than 28 days beginning on the date of the service of the notice), and in a manner specified in the notice, to the officer such information as is specified in the notice, being information which is necessary for the purpose of the performance by that or any other officer of the Commissioner of his or her functions under this Act."

Subsection (2) states that a person who fails to comply with a notice under subsection (1) or supplies information which is false in a material respect in purported compliance with such a notice, knowing it to be so false or being reckless as to whether it is so false, shall be guilty of an offence.

The section does not include the words "or such later date as is practicable". The owner or occupier must supply the information required within 28 days and failure to do so will be an offence. The Bill is slanted in that there is not a balance between the rights of the commissioner and the rights of the rate payer. The Bill is imbalanced. The owner or occupier must supply the information within 28 days - the section does not provide for a period of ten years, six months or as soon as possible thereafter. Failure to provide the information within 28 days will be considered an offence and the matter can be referred to the DPP. This is a bad Bill. It does not have regard to modern concepts of individual rights or the right to freedom of information.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy and I are at cross purposes.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

We are. The Minister has done a very bad job with this Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy seems to ignore entirely the fundamental change which involves a three month consultative process, directly involving the ratepayer with the Valuation Office at every step of the way. It also involves all the information as to how the rateable valuation of property is arrived at, which is not the case at present, and the appeals processes which are built in. That is the fundamental change in this rateable valuation process which has been commended by almost every ratepayer I have met at public meetings around the country. It is the central, most important change in the process to be brought about by the Bill. If I had not included that provision in the legislation, the Deputy's points would have more validity. However, the way in which I have reversed the process of arriving at the valuation with the ratepayer fundamentally changes the approach and responsibility of the valuation officer.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The point is that we give 28 days notice to a person who might be away on holidays, sick or unable to meet the deadline for whatever reason. Yet, regardless of any explanation it will be an offence not to meet the deadline. Elsewhere in the Bill we give the commissioner ten years, or as soon as practical thereafter, or six months, or as soon as practical thereafter. The Bill is unbalanced and the Minister should reflect on these issues before Report Stage.

Comment on this

I said I would.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

All right. I am glad to hear it.

Comment on this

A three day deadline appears to be very short. When the commissioner or an officer of the commission wants to gain entry to a property, if consent is denied they have to give three days' notice. It seems that a longer period of notice would be reasonable in the circumstances.

Comment on this

That is based on experience. The system is working fine and nobody has raised the matter. I examined that point and inquired whether that was the practice, and it is. It seems to be working fine and there does not seem to be any problem with it.

Comment on this

Strictly speaking, it means that it is an offence if somebody is on holidays, to take Deputy Mitchell's example.

Comment on this

That is obviously taken into account.

Comment on this

I assume it is then up to the DPP to decide whether to prosecute in those circumstances. I take it that it is currently an offence to deny entry, if a three day notice is served.

Comment on this

It is, yes.

Comment on this

Is it the practice to prosecute?

Comment on this

There is no history of anyone having been prosecuted on that basis.

Comment on this

In principle, we should not create offences that we do not intend to prosecute.

Comment on this

No, but the point is that the three day notice period works.

Comment on this

The Minister is saying that it is a stick or a threat, rather than a reality.

Comment on this

No. I think people know the duties that are required of them and they act accordingly. Everybody understands it and does what is required. That is the reality.

Comment on this

Will the Minister indicate whether he expects the balance between different types of property to change when the new valuations are carried out? Principally, people want to know what are the implications of this new method of assessing value.

Comment on this

The Deputy is right, and I have made this point repeatedly, both on Second Stage and at meetings around the country. I did not try to hide the fact. I used the phrase: "I think there will be winners and losers", and there is no doubt about that. In Dublin there are great distortions between properties, some of which were fashionable a few years ago in areas where high demand would have yielded high rental income. Some areas of the city, however, have shifted, and properties that may have been subject to high demand a few years ago are now less in demand, and vice versa. We could easily say to those who will face a higher demand: “The reality is that you have probably been getting away with a low rateable valuation base for some time”, whereas those who are on a higher rate will obviously be coming back down to a lower rate.

The exact effects will not be apparent until the valuations are carried out, but it will be much more transparent. The bottom line is that the overall rates take will be similar to what it has been, allowing for inflation, the CPI and a reasonable capping. Therefore, the Valuation Bill itself, when enacted, cannot be used by the rating authority to make massive gains. Within it, however, there will be some inevitable changes in terms of the consequences for some properties. There is no doubt about that. Generally, offices have substantially out-performed retail and industrial properties recently. One would have thought that retail properties would have done so before. That is one of the obvious cases.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:

In page 37, line 16, to delete "subsection (2)” and substitute “subsection (3)”.

This amendment is to correct a reference error in the fourth line of section 50. The reference to subsection (2) of section 48 should read subsection (3) of section 48. It is a typographical error.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:

In page 38, lines 34 to 37, to delete subsection (3) and substitute the following:

"(3) An order under subsection (1) shall not-

(a) be made save after consultation by the Minister with the Minister for the Environment and Local Government and any other Minister of the Government who, in the opinion of the Minister, is concerned in the matter, or

(b) provide for the valuation of any relevant property occupied by a public utility undertaking for the purpose of generating electricity.”.

This amendment relates to the class of relevant property that will not be included in the global valuation of a public utility undertaking. Section 53(1) provides that the Minister for Finance may, by order, require the commissioner of valuation to carry out a global valuation of certain properties of a specified public utility undertaking. Subsection (3) provides that the Minister for Finance shall not make such an order, save after consulting the Minister for the Environment and Local Government and, in the opinion of the Minister, any other relevant Minister. The amendment provides that such an order shall not provide for the valuation of any relevant property occupied by a public utility undertaking for the purpose of generating electricity. In other words, property used for the purpose of generating electricity will not be included as part of the global valuation of a public utility undertaking. Such property - power stations - will of course be valued separately as part of a revaluation of the rating authority area in which it is situated or under the normal revision process if such a need arises.

The necessity for this amendment arises from the requirement to recognise the reality of the ongoing greater EU deregulation taking place in the electricity sector, with new and separate entities being able to establish and produce electricity in competition with the existing State electricity producer. It is necessary in equity that a power station or stations run by the State, or by any new producer, should be valued on the same basis as each other. To achieve this, power stations need to be able to be valued as separate and distinct properties, and not in the case of a public utility included as part of a global valuation of that public utility undertaking. That is just recognising the reality of changes occurring in the market.

Comment on this

What companies will be the subject of global valuations?

Comment on this

There is a number of them, including the ESB and Eirecom.

Comment on this

I do not quite understand why the same logic would not apply to those undertakings as applies to power plants since, in one form or other, they will all be involved in competition in the near future, if they are not already involved.

Comment on this

That is true, but in the case of the global valuation that exists, power plants are a major de facto existing situation. We have had no competition in that sector and there are no power plants in existence other than the State-owned ones. The new ones that are planned to come on stream will clearly need to be rated on an equitable basis with the others. It is a highly visible case in that context and the provision relates directly to it. I take the Deputy’s point. Who knows what may happen in public transport and the competition that may occur later?

Comment on this

What is the current practice, for example, with telecommunications companies? Is Esat Digifone done on a global basis in the same way as Eircom?

Comment on this

Only the ESB is done on a global basis.

Comment on this

To all intents and purposes, therefore, we are doing away with global rating altogether, unless we have just decided to do it for CIE. Is that it, essentially?

Comment on this

If we do it for one, we must do it for all. There is a need to be equitable.

Comment on this

With regard to global valuations, Esat Digifone, Eircell and Meteor are private companies. Is it ultimately the intention that every transmission mast have a rateable valuation?

Comment on this

At the moment, yes.

Comment on this

What bout Bord Gáis, which is laying pipelines, through which it will transmit a service?

Comment on this

The pipelines are valued but not in a global sense. They are valued by each local authority.

Comment on this

Are rates payable to each local authority involved?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Who pays the rates? Sometimes the pipes are laid along public roads or across bridges.

Comment on this

The pipe is rated and the rate is payable by Bord Gáis.

Comment on this

How is the rateable valuation of a pipe calculated?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister of State could get that information. Many towns in my constituency are getting piped gas for the first time.

Comment on this

I will get the information and give it to the Deputies.

Comment on this

Is the provision in this section once-off or is it intended that the Minister will be given this power if and when he wishes to use it?

Comment on this

It is once-off.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Will the Minister explain section 56(3) which states: "The figure mentioned in subsection (2) is the quotient, rounded up to 3 decimal places, obtained by dividing the consumer price index number relevant to the appropriate year by the consumer price index number relevant to the preceding year.”

Comment on this

I understand it deals with increases in the CPI. It refers to year on year.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will take the Minister of State's word. The subsection hardly adheres to the wish of the Law Reform Commission that legislative provisions should be worded in plain language.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:

In page 44, before section 58, to insert the following new section:

58.-An order under section 53(8) may provide that, in respect of the period for which an existing valuation list remains in force by virtue of section 43 in relation to the area of a rating authority, the valuation referred to in that subsection which is apportioned to that authority by the order shall stand adjusted in a manner specified in the order to make it relative to the value of other properties appearing on the said list.

(2) If provision as aforesaid is made by an order under section 53(8), the Commissioner shall ensure that, in respect of the period referred to in subsection (1), the central valuation list specifies, in addition to the amounts respectively provided by paragraphs (b) and (c) of section 55(1) to be specified in that list, but in a separate part of that list from the part in which those amounts are specified, the said amounts as they stand adjusted pursuant to the said order.”.

It is planned that the global valuations of a number of public utility undertakings will commence and be completed before any revaluation of a rating authority is completed. In addition, the revaluation of rating authorities will take place on a phased basis, meaning that the valuation base of some rating authorities will continue to be expressed in a current fractional NAV, whereas other rating authorities where a revaluation is being completed will have their valuation base expressed on a full current NAV basis. Consequently, it will be necessary that the valuation derived from the global valuation of a public utility undertaking is able to be apportioned based both on the current fractional NAV basis and the full current NAV basis of the rating authority's valuation list as deemed appropriate until such time as all rating authorities have been revalued It will also be necessary for the fractional full NAV amounts to be able to be entered on the central valuation lists for public utility undertakings until such time as all rating authorities have been revalued. This amendment allows for this to happen.

Comment on this

Will the Minister of State specify those companies' undertakings which currently benefit from the exemption on mining and petroleum drilling?

Comment on this

Only the ESB has the global valuation.

Comment on this

We appear to be at cross purposes.

Comment on this

It is an exemption for the mines.

Comment on this

Who currently benefits from it?

Comment on this

Arcon. One other company benefits and I will get the details for the Deputy.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 40 to 45, inclusive, are related to amendment No. 39 and amendments Nos. 39 to 45, inclusive, may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:

In page 49, line 9, to delete "sections 27 and 28" and substitute "section 28".

The First Schedule lists those enactments that are being repealed as a result of the amendment and consolidation of the existing valuation code and the future operation of the valuation system provided for by the enactment of this legislation. Since publication of the Bill corrections to the Schedule and some further sections of Acts which are now considered to be necessary have come to light. This results in six changes to the Schedule.

Comment on this

I am happy with the Minister of State's explanation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:

In page 49, line 25, after "Section 69" to insert "and the Second Schedule".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 41:

In page 49, between lines 27 and 28, to insert the following:

“No. 35 of 1934 | Limerick City Management Act, 1934 | Section 28 and the Second Schedule”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 42:

In page 49, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following:

“No. 21 of 1939 | Air-Raid Precautions Act, 1939 | Section 59”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:

In page 49, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following:

“No. 25 of 1939 | Waterford City Management Act, 1939 | Section 27 and the Schedule”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:

In page 49, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following:

“No. 5 of 1941 | Cork City Management (Amendment) Act, 1941 | Section 19 and the First Schedule”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 45:

In page 49, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following:

“No. 24 of 1946 | Local Government Act, 1946 | Sections 13 and 21 and the Second Schedule”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:

In page 50, paragraph 1, between lines 11 and 12, to insert the following subparagraph:

"(3) A person who was a member of the Tribunal immediately before the commencement of this Act shall continue in office as such a member for the remainder of the term of office for which he or she was appointed, unless he or she sooner dies or resigns from office.".

Current members of the Valuation Tribunal are appointed under the provisions of the Valuation Act, 1988, which is being repealed in the First Schedule to this Bill. This means that the current Valuation Tribunal would fall on the commencement of this legislation unless its continuance in office is specifically provided for in the Bill. This amendment, proposing the insertion of a new subsection to paragraph 1 of the Second Schedule, provides for the continuance in office of the existing members of the Valuation Tribunal for the remainder of their terms of office. The amendment provides that a person who was a member of the tribunal immediately before the commencement of this Act shall continue in office as such a member for the remainder of the term of office for which he or she was appointed, unless he or she sooner dies or resigns from office.

Comment on this

How many members are there on the tribunal? Are there vacancies and, if so, for how long?

Comment on this

There is no limit on the number of members. There are approximately 13 members at present and there are probably two or three vacancies.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 47:

In page 51, paragraph 3, line 32, after "chairperson" to insert "of".

The purpose of the amendment is to correct a typographical error in paragraph 3(4)(c) by inserting the word “of” after “chairperson”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:

In page 53, paragraph 11, between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following paragraphs:

"(2) A notice of appeal to the Tribunal shall be in such form as is prescribed by rules made under this paragraph.

(3) Rules made under paragraph 11 of the First Schedule to the Act of 1988 that were in force immediately before the commencement of this Act shall continue in force, subject to the modifications of their effect provided for in subparagraph (4) of this paragraph, as if they were made under this paragraph and may be amended or revoked accordingly.

(4) The modifications mentioned in subparagraph (3) of this paragraph are-

(a) the substitution in the rules concerned for references to a provision of the repealed enactments of references to the corresponding provision of this Act, and

(b) any other modifications necessary to ensure that the operation of the rules are consistent with this Act.”.

The new subparagraph (2) to paragraph 11 provides that a notice of appeal to the tribunal shall be in such a form as is prescribed by the rules made under this paragraph. These rules are made by the tribunal with the consent of the Minister for Finance. This amendment makes the tribunal responsible for determining the form of the notice to be used for appealing decisions of the commissioner to the tribunal. The new subparagraphs (3) and (4) provided for the continuance in force of the existing rules of the Valuation Tribunal. Again, the existing rules of the tribunal are made under the provisions of the Valuation Act, 1988, which is being repealed in the First Schedule to this Bill. This means that the existing rules of the tribunal would fall at the commencement unless their continuance in force is specifically provided for in the Bill. The rules of the tribunal are made by the tribunal with the consent of the Minister for Finance. They set out the procedures of the tribunal.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:

In page 57, paragraph 1, after line 46, to insert the following:

"(p) property which in the opinion of the local authority are aparthotels.”.

I tabled the amendment at the request of Dublin Corporation, which seeks to extend the rate base to include what are known as aparthotels. As I understand it, these are basically groups of apartments which do not fall under the technical definition of a hotel but nonetheless clearly provide accommodation on a short-term basis and are in competition with hotels, guesthouses etc. The corporation takes the view that in order to level the playing pitch, aparthotels should be included in the rating base.

Comment on this

I agree with the principle underpinning this amendment. The situation has changed hugely. Some politicians are fearful of subjecting bed and breakfast establishments to rates but I believe that should be done also. It is a case of agreeing the definition of the size of establishments.

The bigger bed and breakfast establishments, self-catering establishments, guesthouses and aparthotels are driving a coach and four through the system. In Dublin there are some aparthotels with 100 rooms. In some cases there are two establishments side by side, one of which calls itself a hotel and pays rates while the other calls itself an aparthotel and does not. There is no tangible difference. Initially the aparthotels did not have a bar or restaurant but they have got bigger and bolder since then. One would not know one from the other at this stage.

If we are updating the 1852 legislation, we should take account of what is happening in the marketplace. Whether the wording of the amendment is correct, this principle ought to be incorporated in the Bill because the law as it stands is stupid.

Comment on this

Aparthotels, which are similar to hotels but provide apartments rather than bedrooms, are not domestic in nature and therefore are rateable.

Comment on this

They think they are not rateable. They are getting away with it.

Comment on this

They are rateable where they conform to the definition of a hotel. One may get into the area of splitting hairs but what I mean by the definition is that they are rateable if there is a lobby area when one enters the establishment. For instance, I know of one near where I live in Waterford. It is clear that it is just a block of apartments but there is a lobby on the ground floor and it pays rates. Aparthotels are rateable because they are not domestic in nature.

If a private individual owns an apartment and decides to let it, that is a different situation because it is a domestic property.

Comment on this

If they are rateable, should that be stated in legislation? The Minister of State has proved the point of the amendment.

Comment on this

The Bill states that if one is providing lodgings, one's establishment can still be defined as domestic and, therefore, is exempt from rates. That is my understanding and certainly that is the view of Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this

I am specifically answering the point about aparthotels. I am saying clearly that aparthotels which contain a lobby area are rateable. They are not domestic in nature. I have looked at this point as a result of what Deputy Ahern, Deputy McDowell and others said on Second Stage. Aparthotels are not domestic in nature and, therefore, they are rateable.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is not clear. What might be called aparthotels by one person might not be called aparthotels by others. In my constituency there is accommodation for senior citizens, for instance, where there are private apartments but there are agreed services. In one case, for instance, there are private apartments and there is a nursing home attached to it, but the services of the nursing home, including meals, are available to the old people living in the apartments. Under the Minister of State's definition, that would possibly be construed as rateable.

Comment on this

I have moved to meet the point which was raised. I may need to define it better. I will look at it before Report Stage and perhaps return with an amendment.

Comment on this

Certainly it is my understanding that Dublin Corporation does not rate aparthotels.

Comment on this

I am telling the Deputy that it can rate them. Perhaps I can make it more specific on Report Stage. I want to meet those concerns raised largely by Dublin Deputies on Second Stage. I believe that these properties should be rated. My definition may need to be a little more refined so that it is crystal clear what may be rated by the local authority.

Comment on this

Regarding what the Minister of State said, every apartment block has a lobby. Many rural Deputies own apartments here and many of them have a lobby inside the door. The crucial point is obviously the size of the lobby. One can stay in some of these places for two nights or two years. If one is staying for two years, it may be deemed domestic in nature. The position is different when one can rent it by the day or week.

Initially the aparthotels in Dublin did not have a bar or restaurant, or they had one next door, but now one would not know the difference between them and hotels. I do not believe the corporation is sitting back just for the fun of it. I do not know if there was a test case in the courts.

Comment on this

I do not want to expand the debate at this stage but I know there are a number of guesthouses which, it could be construed, are getting away without paying rates but which are actually paying rates where local authority officials have gone out to them and said: "This is a major commercial venture". The local authorities must change their approach.

I take the point about the definition. Perhaps I need to make it more specific but my understanding of an aparthotel is an apartment block in which a company is letting out bedrooms. It is not where an individual owns two or three apartments and is letting them. It is an entire block which belongs to a company which sets itself up as a hotel and has, as an off-shoot, aparthotels. As far as I am concerned, they pay rates, as they should. I will try to improve the definition for Report Stage to make it as clear as possible.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I would ask the Minister of State to clearly differentiate between aparthotels and apartment blocks.

Comment on this

I will have a look at the definition.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

There is another question related to lodgings. According to the definitions in the Bill, lodgings shall not be construed as including accommodation provided in premises registered under the Tourist Traffic Acts, 1939 to 1998. Does that cover aparthotels?

Comment on this

It relates to hotels, guesthouses and self-catering. I do not dispute the fact that this is a minefield.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

There is provision in the Finance Bill where people can bring people into their own home. Are they exempt? Does that affect this?

Comment on this

Absolutely not.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Paragraph (2)(b) of Schedule 3 states that the condition mentioned in paragraph 1 of this Schedule is that the property concerned “is unoccupied but capable of being the subject of rateable occupation by the owner of the property.” What is sought to be achieved by this? Is it that even if the property is unoccupied, if it is usable it is rateable but if it is not useable it is not rateable?

Comment on this

Basically, because it is empty does not mean that it cannot be rated.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am glad to hear that that is what it means but I wonder should the wording be stronger. There are many buildings left derelict and not being used. The owners of such property should not escape paying rates. They should pay a penalty rather than derive a benefit. Is there scope for strengthening that?

Comment on this

I will have a look at it. I would have thought that the provision meets the requirements. There is no need to do anything more with it. I take the Deputy's point and I agree with it.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

There are several such pockets of derelict buildings or sites in my constituency and I see similar properties in other constituencies when I am travelling around the city. They deface the city.

Comment on this

Vacancy relief is available under another Act relating to local authorities. It has emerged from the debate on the Bill that the rating law needs to be substantially updated, in parallel with this legislation. I understand that the Department of the Environment and Local Government is working on that at present. It is obvious that a major change is needed. I will consider the matter to which the Deputy refers. However, I believe the paragraph is sufficiently clear in its intent.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The first two words in the paragraph, "is unoccupied", are fine. My difficulty is with what is stated thereafter, namely, "but capable of being the subject of rateable occupation by the owner of the property." The latter leaves scope for argument as to whether it is capable of being occupied. Is there any property which is not capable of being occupied following refurbishment?

Comment on this

I will consider the matter further.

Comment on this

Looking at Schedules 3 and 4, it appears that land is not rateable. What is the position vis-à-vis land in west Dublin or Kildare which was zoned but remains unoccupied or land the Minister for the Environment and Local Government spent a fortune purchasing under the serviced land initiative? Is it not possible to rate land that a developer has done nothing with for a number of years following its zoning? In my opinion it should be possible to do so and the value should increase, particularly if the Minister for the Environment and Local Government has invested money in the land under the serviced land initiative.

Under Schedules 3 and 4, many art galleries etc. are excluded, but there is no general heading for State owned property. Is that heading no longer used? Local authorities in Dublin are being heavily penalised because there is so much State owned property in the city.

Comment on this

We discussed that matter already.

Comment on this

We discussed it earlier, Deputy Ahern.

Comment on this

With regard to the Deputy's first point, all land, by its nature, is agricultural land regardless of how it is zoned. I am not disagreeing with the Deputy, but this matter is more relevant to the Department of the Environment and Local Government.

Comment on this

I have been making inquiries with that Department about this matter for a number of years and I have been informed that a major land revaluation has been in the offing since 1852. We cannot take a narrow view of this matter. I am a member of the Joint Committee on the Environment and Local Government and I am aware that major developers are having land rezoned and then doing nothing with it. A great deal of taxpayers' money is being invested in putting services in place in respect of such land. The Minister for Finance has reduced capital gains tax to try to provide these people with an incentive to proceed with developments. Zoned land, the value of which might rise from £20,000 per acre to £2 million per acre, should be rateable. If the Minister for the Environment and Local Government invests a great deal of money in putting in place underground services in respect of that land, the valuation should rise accordingly. In my opinion that is a common sense approach.

Comment on this

I am not disputing the points made by the Deputy. However, I am not sure that using the valuation-rating system is the proper way to deal with this matter.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

The fundamental principle of rating is that a property or piece of land is rated as it stands, not in terms of what it might potentially become. The entire basis of the rating system would have to change if we were to do what the Deputy requests. He raises a fundamental point and using the taxation system or finance legislation might be the way to deal with it. The Valuation Bill cannot be used for this purpose. I could not change the system to the effect that something might be rated on the basis of what it might become.

Comment on this

The land to which I refer has already become something else. If a person has an acre of land that is worth £15,000——

Comment on this

Domestic property is not rateable.

Comment on this

I accept that. However, Schedule 3 states that rights of fishery and tolls, for example, are rateable. What is a fishery right until one catches a fish?

Comment on this

Such rights are very valuable and a number of them are the subject of High Court cases at present.

Comment on this

With regard to land, if somebody is sitting on a fortune——

Comment on this

I can only, de facto, rate something as it stands at a particular time. I cannot rate it in terms of what it may become. Fishery rights etc. exist; they are what they are. However, the zoning of land is immaterial because, as it exists, the land in question is still agricultural land. What it may become is another issue. The Deputy will appreciate that I cannot base rating law on what something might become.

Comment on this

It is illogical.

Comment on this

I support the point made by Deputy Ahern. The first item listed in Schedule 4 is "Agricultural land", while in section 3 it is stated that agricultural land "means land which is used as tillage, meadow or pasture ground or which is suitable only for such use". Land that has been zoned and under which service pipes have been laid is suitable for purposes other than agricultural use. The definition clearly indicates that to be agricultural land, a piece of land must be suitable for agricultural purposes only. The land to which Deputy Ahern refers is suitable for other purposes such as building, particularly if it has been zoned and services have been put in place. I contend that this land does not fall within the definition set down in the Bill.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy. Even though the land might be zoned and worth an absolute fortune, there might be sheep grazing on it at the point when it is being rated.

Comment on this

It is suitable for other purposes.

Comment on this

That is the point. It may be suitable for other purposes, but it will only be rated when it is used for those purposes. If a parcel of land is zoned but is not going to be developed immediately, the owner just places a few cattle on it. The land is agricultural until it becomes something else.

Comment on this

Is the value of the asset not a basic principle of rateability?

Comment on this

I do not rate farmland in this county.

Comment on this

Perhaps we could call it something else. The only animals on the land to which I refer are wandering horses. The developers in question are not interested in renting the land in order for someone to graze their sheep on it because it would not be worth their while financially to do so. They can sit on this land, which is not farmland, and the only people who use it are the wandering horse brigade.

Comment on this

I fully understand the point the Deputies are making. I am simply saying that as I deal with such land and taking account of how the rating system works, I cannot but base a rate——

Comment on this

The Minister of State is changing the system for the first time since 1852.

Comment on this

Yes, but the implications of what the Deputy is suggesting would completely change the entire valuation system. I will provide a further example. A space may be used as a car park, but it would clearly be worth millions as a development site on which a skyscraper - if we allowed their construction - could be built. I cannot rate it on the basis that a skyscraper will be built there, I rate it on the basis that it is a vacant piece of land used as a car park.

Comment on this

At least the Minister of State gets something out of it.

Comment on this

The valuation is based on what something is, not on what it may become. That is a fundamental tenet of rating law. I can only base a rating on what is in existence on the day on which that rating is carried out. If circumstances change the following week, we can return to update the rating. However, I cannot make presumptions about what something may become because I would then be dealing in notional valuations. If I proceeded with such valuations, I would be brought to court and I would not have a hope of winning. I am not unsympathetic to the point the Deputy is making and I believe action should be taken in respect of it. However, I do not believe that rating is necessarily the answer. The end could still be achieved through different means.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:

In page 59, paragraph 4, line 6, after "sport" to insert "or recreation in so far as same is carried on or operated for reasons other than profit".

I am not sure I worded this amendment as well as I might have done. My intention was to deal with the point I made at the beginning of the debate when we discussed the definitions. I wanted to do two things, first, extend the exemption for sporting land to include sporting premises which are not used for commercial purposes and, second, by including the word "recreation", ensure that the broader definition of sport would be used in the Bill. I am not sure whether keeping pigeons is regarded as a sport, but there are a number of other examples which are more recreation than sports. The general principle in the Bill that we should exempt things with a community purpose is good and should be spelled out.

Comment on this

As I informed the Deputy earlier, I will consider this matter before Report Stage. Perhaps I can extend the definition relating to community halls to encompass the matters to which he refers. Everyone is at one on that and I am taking that on board.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I was puzzled that sections 8 and 14 should be separated because they are analogous in the sense that one deals with hospitals and medical treatment while the other deals with care for elderly, handicapped or disabled persons. This a provision whereby, if a building is operated on a not-for-private-profit basis, it is exempt from rates, but that is not the case if it is operated on a profit motive. Should we not encourage people other than the State to develop nursing homes and hospitals?

A number of hospitals in Dublin city have been closed and the buildings sold at an enormous profit and almost all were exempt from rates. For example, when Jervis Street Hospital was closed and replaced by Beaumont Hospital, which was built and paid for by the State, a huge profit accrued from the sale of the property which had not been rateable. Likewise, when Tallaght Hospital was opened, the Adelaide Hospital building was sold for a huge figure and is now being developed into major apartment blocks. The Meath Hospital and Harcourt Street Hospital were sold. They were not rateable, yet a huge profit has accrued to someone, not the State.

Two points need to be considered. Should hospitals, hostels or institutions for the care of the elderly, disabled or sick be treated equally regardless of whether there is a profit motive? If they are not rated, perhaps there should be a suspension of rates rather an exemption. If they were to be sold subsequently for commercial gain, the rates accruing would become due. It is a pertinent point given what has happened in Dublin recently. There is also a growing need for nursing homes. We do not have enough.

Comment on this

The point the Deputy makes is a valid one and I examined this at length in trying to devise something in the context of the Bill. The Government, through the taxation system, has substantially incentivised the development of private hospitals, for example. This has been done using capital tax allowances. The basis of the valuation system is that, where a property is operated on the basis of making a profit, it pays rates. I do not want to undermine that principle. That is not to be callous or cold-hearted in the context of many worthy areas with which we would like to deal. The State has other mechanisms and means of doing that rather than undermining the position of local government, which is what I do not want to do, or the position of the rating authority in terms of to what it can apply rates. I understand the Deputy's point and I have examined it. Many Ministers and Departments would have liked to use the Bill as an opportunity to solve many problems which were not suitable to be resolved by it.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is fine once I know the Minister of State has considered the point. If we adhere to the profit motive basis, on what basis are Deputy's clinics rateable? I do not have an office in my constituency, but other Deputies do. They do not operate for profit, yet they are rated. On what basis is that done?

Comment on this

They are rateable under the definition whereby they are deemed not to be just for charitable purposes.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Some of the Minister of State's advisers do not understand the nature of these clinics.

Comment on this

I have been asked about constituency offices. It appears that almost none of the constituency offices, where they are in Deputies' homes, pays rates.

Comment on this

Many of them pay rates. We all receive a visit in Laois.

Comment on this

That could be Deputies who have a business or business premises.

Comment on this

No, I renovated an old building for an office.

Comment on this

It is clearly separate from the Deputy's house.

Comment on this

It is not part of the house, and I was told that it was rated because it was not a domestic premises.

Comment on this

Yes, it would be rated.

Comment on this

That is the short shrift I received.

Comment on this

If we tried to remove Deputies' offices from the equation, our credibility in terms of the other——

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I do not agree with this.

Comment on this

Neither do I.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I have no interest in this area in that I do not have an office in my constituency. My office is in Leinster House. I do not have to pay rates on it and it suits me because it is a few hundred yards from my constituency, but what about Deputies a few hundred miles away who must have offices? Those are not run for profit. Why do we flagellate ourselves more than anyone else under many headings? If it is a just case——

Comment on this

The Deputy is well aware that allowances and expenses are given to Deputies with constituency offices which are not given to those who do not have them. It is taken into account in a different way.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Is the Minister of State saying that the allowances cover the full cost of those offices? I could not afford to open and man an office in my constituency with the allowances available.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The allowances given do not cover the costs. Why should we single out public representatives who open offices as a public service and not for profit and force them to pay rates? It is absurd and is typical of how we flagellate ourselves and make our lives impossible.

Comment on this

There is very little difference between a constituency office and a local citizen's information bureau. I do not expect they pay rates because they are the responsibility of the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs.

Comment on this

The allowances are not necessarily paid either. A number of Deputies who have an office and secretary in Leinster House do not qualify for an allowance. It does not affect me but I know my constituency colleague and Deputy Mitchell's constituency colleague have offices manned by people who are paid by the Deputies concerned. The allowances only cover the cost of some of those employed.

Comment on this

I know the position well. I tried to run a constituency office but the costs and allowances do not marry up. We are into the area of definition and difficulty, and so on.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

There is a related area.

Comment on this

As it stands, constituency offices are rateable. I do not propose to use the Bill as a vehicle to remove that given that I was very open and discussed at length issues such as hospitals, nursing homes and charity shops. It would have been very strange for me to remove Deputies from the system and not others. The problem I face is that, once I move into this area, while there are a large number of genuine cases, and I do not dispute that, I must get the base of the rateable valuation system to reflect the needs of local government and to be as broad as possible. I believe I have met that in the Bill.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

This is a glaring anomaly.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is as it appears to me, and I can speak freely on it because it does not affect me.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Life is becoming impossible for Deputies. I do not know who in their right mind would want to become a Deputy given the huge pressures and proper accountability. We make the job unattractive under many headings. The facilities are so poor compared to anywhere else that it would be very difficult to get people to enter politics.

Comment on this

I do not disagree with the voracity of the Deputy's comments. One can look at this whatever way one wishes. If we are near a conclusion I am prepared to discuss these issue on Report and Final Stages.

Comment on this

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

The Minister of State said he would consider the amendment.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I may table an amendment to deal with this issue.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:

In page 60, paragraph 15, line 23, after "hall" to insert "including any premises which is certified by the local authority as being used largely or exclusively for community purposes".

The definition of a community hall in the earlier part of the Bill specifically excludes club premises. However, some club premises are effectively community halls.

Comment on this

I will look at this overall area but I cannot give any guarantee to the committee.

Comment on this

There is a family recreation centre in my constituency which is constituted as a club. However, it was built by contributions from several thousand people and is effectively open to the entire community.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Does it have a bar?

Comment on this

It has a bar and there would be a need to define the difference between the two. However, it is still largely used by, for example——

Comment on this

I will look at this issue.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Is it the case that any premises which has a bar is not exempted from rates?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

We need to rate the bar and not the rest of the premises. That would cause difficulties but we should do so for reasons of equity.

Comment on this

We have moved on from what we were talking about earlier regarding dressing rooms, pitches and so on.

Comment on this

This is different. I am talking about the definition of a community hall which excludes club premises.

Comment on this

I will look at this issue.

Comment on this

Some club premises are effectively community halls and should not be excluded from the definition.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

In page 60, after line 42, to insert the following paragraph:

"19.-Any shop or retail outlet operated for the purposes of promoting or raising finance for a registered charity.".

This amendment deals with shops which are run for profit by charitable organisations so they are charity shops. The Minister of State and I received representations to the effect that as these shops are being run for the charities they are not profit making in the true definition of that phrase and should be exempted. This is a reasonable argument.

Comment on this

I examined this issue at some length. Members have been involved in much lobbying on this issue. It would have been my preferred option to get to a point where I might have been able to do more than I have done. However, I have exempted from rates any administrative headquarters of charitable organisations which are not involved in business. It would be wrong to exclude a charity shop, irrespective of the end use of its resources, if it is competing with a shop up the street. There are second-hand shops which are legitimate businesses and which pay rates but which would have to compete with a charity shop in the same business which is exempted from rates. Such charity shops would probably utilise their exemption from rates in their margins. That would be wrong.

No matter how I approached this issue, the defining line was that if shops are trading on a commercial basis and competing for commercial business with other shops, many of which are small family-run businesses which are struggling and paying rates, it would be wrong to exclude the charity shops from having to pay rates. Effectively that would be asking one to subsidise the other which would not be fair to individual ratepayers. I have gone as far as I can by excluding all other areas and premises of charitable organisations except premises used for running a business which makes a profit.

Comment on this

The Minister of State is suggesting that a premises should be rated on the basis of what it is and not on who owns it. This goes back to the point about State property.

Comment on this

Premises should be rated on the basis of what they are used for.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister of State makes a distinction in the case of State property.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to land?

Comment on this

No, a shop or State property. The Minister of State is suggesting that it should not matter who owns a shop. I could turn that argument around as regards an office block owned by the State.

Comment on this

The Deputy is correct. I do not disagree with this point and that is why all State property will first be valued. That is a big step forward. Another Department would argue that this is already taken into account and was given back in the rates support grant. We have moved on from that but I am not disputing the Deputy's argument.

Comment on this

We will revisit this argument on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Chairman, I advise the committee of a possible amendment I may make on Report Stage regarding the implications of the Bill for the courts jurisdiction.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State and his officials.

Comment on this