We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON HEALTH AND CHILDREN

Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–158 of 330. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill 2001
Rejected

No. 48 of 2001 ›

The select committee has been convened to consider the Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill, 2001. I welcome the Minister for Health and Children and his officials. I suggest we consider the Bill until 4 p.m. with a break from 1 p.m. to 2.30 p.m. for lunch. If we have not concluded by then we will resume tomorrow, Friday, at 10 a.m.

Before Committee Stage commences I wish to deal with a procedural matter relating to Bills to amend the Constitution. The substance of the debate on Committee Stage relates to the wording of the proposed constitutional amendment and in this instance, a consequent legislative provision contained in the Schedules to the Bill. The sections of the Bill are merely technical. Therefore, in accordance with long standing practice, the sections are postponed until consideration of the Schedules has been completed. I ask the Minister for Health and Children to formally move, in accordance with Standing Order 114, that consideration of sections 1 and 2 of the Bill be postponed until the Schedules have been disposed of.

Comment on this
Micheál Martin Minister for Health and Children (Mr. Martin) Fianna Fáil

I move:

That consideration of sections 1 and 2 of the Bill be postponed until the Schedules have been disposed of.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I only received notice of this motion when I arrived at the meeting. We finished Second Stage of the legislation very hurriedly this week. When I concluded my contribution in the Dáil on Tuesday at 8.15 p.m. I had to leave to keep a public engagement in another county. I arrived home late that night and I only had until the following morning to draft amendments. I have had little time since then. No Deputy has researchers or back up staff available to him or her to draft amendments.

I came here ready to speak on amendmentNo. 1 which I tabled. I am dismayed to find that it will not now be taken. It is typical of the way the Bill has been processed generally. We are entitled to the courtesy of being properly informed by the Minister and properly assisted to do our jobs. We are present to debate section 1 and the first Deputy McManus and myself heard about the section not being taken was when we arrived at the meeting. That is not a satisfactory procedure.

Comment on this

It is incredible that we were presented with a fait accompli in terms of how Committee Stage will be dealt with. The Government intends to try to speed the legislation through and get rid of it at the earliest opportunity, even though it addresses life and death issues for women. Even when processing a normal, run of the mill Bill, it would be extraordinary to have a limit on the tabling of amendments, as has been the case with this legislation, but it is even more extraordinary for one to attend a select committee meeting and discover that a procedure has been proposed by the Minister which reverses the order in which amendments will be taken.

Any member of the public reading these documents would presume that we would begin with section 1 and continue to the end. It would be hard for an official of the committee, excellent as they are, to explain to a member of the public that the Schedules are mere technical matters and that is why they need to be taken first. My understanding is there is no good reason for the Minister putting forward this proposal and there is certainly no good reason for us to accept it. I was pleased when I read the amendment tabled by Deputy Mitchell because it is appropriate that we deal with the totality of what is outlined in section 1.

I urge the Minister, if he wishes to generate any goodwill, to withdraw his proposal for the order in which amendments will be taken. It may disrupt both his and the Chairman's briefing notes. I have been a Minister and very often briefing notes are simply an aid. A Minister must make decisions and deal with issues as they arise. Civil servants cannot do that for them. I am concerned at how procedures have been laid down both on Second and Committee Stages. It is interesting that even the Progressive Democrats Party is also concerned, according to newspaper reports. Can we please have some consistency in terms of dealing with this legislation? The proposal may set a precedent but it does not break the law. It means that we could have a logical debate.

Our position is one of great disadvantage. We do not have the legal back up which the Minister has and we do not have the pooled experience of the Department at our disposal. I resent the fact that I am starting from such a weak position to argue my case. I feel very strongly about this legislation on many counts and I certainly do not want to feel that the obstacles that are being put in place are being heightened. The bar is being raised.

The Minister for Health and Children can shake his head in a very patronising way because he does that quite often but the reality is that in good faith both Deputy Mitchell and myself presumed amendments would be taken in the order outlined in the list of amendments. There is a precedent for taking the Schedule first but I took it, because of the way the amendments were listed and because no one informed me otherwise, that this was the way this important Bill, flawed as it is, would be taken. I was aware of the precedent but I was not aware it would be used this morning and I object very strongly to it.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the personal comments that have been made, I am taken aback by the tone and tenor of the remarks. There is no desire on my part or anyone else's to put any obstacles in place. That has been overstated. The Chairman has outlined a precedent, which Deputy McManus acknowledged, and in time honoured fashion, I moved the motion.

Comment on this

But the Minister did not have to. There is no reason——

Comment on this

I do not list or group the amendments. That is done by officials of the committee.

Comment on this

It is done by the Bills Office.

Comment on this

I do not have any role in that. The Bills Office does that, as the Deputy will be aware. It is unfair to suggest that I somehow am deliberately coming before the committee to attempt to put members of the Opposition at a disadvantage. That is not the case and it is wrong to say so.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

We can agree to take the amendments in the order they are listed.

Comment on this

I do not like the allegations that have been made against me which are totally unfounded, unfair and without substance. I seek a suspension of the meeting for ten minutes to discuss the proceedings with you, Chairman, and the committee.

Comment on this

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

The Minister is to respond to the request.

Comment on this

I had consultations with the Chairman and am satisfied that this is a time honoured precedent and that I am not proposing anything which has not been proposed before. An enormous amount of work was done yesterday in the Bills Office in preparing the schedule for the Chairman and the committee in a specific sequence. In fact, the work was done overnight as frequently happens on Bills of this nature. To change the sequence would, to put it lightly, seriously inconvenience the Bills Office, and I am not prepared to do that.

The arguments made have been somewhat overstated. No element to this is being postponed. We are discussing the sequencing of the process. It is open to Deputies at a certain stage to oppose section 1 if they wish. I note that no amendments have been tabled to the section, but if people want to oppose it, that is fair enough. There is just one amendment to section 2. This is a very short Bill, and that is what is allegedly causing such angst.

I do not have an army of people behind me either.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

It was 86,000 at the last count.

Comment on this

There is a small group within the Department working on the Bill. The Bill was published on 2 October. There has been a considerable degree of legal scrutiny of it, not least by eminent lawyers from political parties in Opposition. I have examined 35 questions the Leader of the Opposition put to the Taoiseach. There is no question but that there was strong legal expertise behind both the framing of those questions and their tabling. Considerable legal expertise has been available to Deputies Mitchell and McManus. I am not so sure about Deputy Gormley because I am not sure how well represented the Greens are in the Bar Library.

I have been in Opposition and accept that, in the way the Oireachtas is organised, Opposition parties could be better resourced and, in recent times, we have resourced them better than before. This is a matter for the Oireachtas in the generality of events. I do not accept that the Bill has not been subject to considerable scrutiny since its publication and that considerable legal advice has not been available to all parties which have opinions on it.

I do not accept that the motion I moved in accordance with precedent in any way creates obstacles for people. That was not the motivation for doing so and people should acknowledge that. This is a time honoured precedent, as is the manner in which the Bills Office has organised this. It is in accordance with the precedent for considering Bills of this nature.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am anxious to get into the detail of the Bill and not to be caught up inwrangling. The Minister said that this is a short Bill. It is the longest Bill amending the Constitution I have seen in my 20 years in the Dáil. It is not an ordinary Bill but one amending the Constitution.

As the Minister will find out shortly if his party goes into Opposition, there are huge demands on the Opposition in terms of attending committees as well as the House and hearing submissions from the public which are part of the participative democracy developments which have taken place in recent years. When I left the House at 8.15 the other night, I travelled to Meath to fulfil a public engagement. I did not get home until very late, yet we were forced to have amendments tabled by 11 the following morning, a limit extended courtesy of the Chairman. It is not straightforward or easy.

Do I understand from the Minister's reply that he is prepared to agree that we can speak about our opposition to section 1 while dealing with the Schedule at the same time?

Comment on this

No, what we have done in the motion is postpone consideration of the sections until consideration of the Schedules has been completed.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Is there any reason we cannot——

Comment on this

There is nothing to stop people speaking when we reach that stage.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

We want to reach that stage in the beginning because that is how it is ordered. The first amendments were tabled to that. Deputy McManus and I have briefed ourselves to speak to it. Is there any reason we cannot speak to this motion and then take the vote when we conclude the Schedules?

Comment on this

I do not chair the committee.

Comment on this

No, that cannot be done.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I cannot accept this. It is unacceptable for us to receive this notice at the commencement of the meeting. I was given a list of amendments——

Comment on this

Deputy McManus acknowledged she was aware of the precedent.

Comment on this

Let me speak for myself.

Comment on this

I heard what Deputy McManus said and she clearly said she was aware of the precedent.

Comment on this

That is not what I said.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I was asked by a colleague on my way here had I heard anything about the changes. The first time I heard about them was when I was informed by the Clerk when I came here. I recognise this is very difficult for the staff of the committee and that the Bills Office staff did their best late last night to put these amendments together. In terms of the way we are prepared to participate in the debate, if the Minister and the Chairman are prepared to accept a compromise that we can speak to the section and voice our opposition to it at the same time as discussing the Schedules, I am prepared to go along with that. I cannot accept the Minister's proposal.

Comment on this

It is a pity this has happened but we would want to be clear what has happened. I was aware that there was a precedent in similar situations where the Schedule could be and tended to be taken first. When I received the list of amendments, my understanding was that these amendments would be taken in the order in which they were published. That is a reasonable assumption to make. I cannot read people's minds. I must take on trust what is given to me. It is clear not that someone wanted to befuddle us but that the Government has tried to fast track the Bill through Committee Stage——

Comment on this

——and that is why the Bills Office is not in a position to carry out its functions during the normal time it would take to inform the committee and ensure the Opposition has plenty of time to prepare itself for today. That is what has happened and nothing the Minister, for whom I have the highest regard, can say can alter that set of facts. The argument now being presented to turn this list of amendments topsy-turvy is being put on the basis that the Minister's briefing will be discommoded.

Comment on this

Let me finish my point. The Minister's briefing is going to be discommoded and he has used the term "the briefing of the committee." I want to make it clear that there is no briefing for the committee. The other members and I have not received any briefing from anybody. The Chairman receives a briefing and it is clear he would be discommoded by a change, but, frankly, that is what Chairmen have to do from time to time. They are paid to be Chairmen and have a certain responsibility towards those of us who do not have any special supports. The idea that we receive plentiful legal advice is laughable. It is extraordinary that the Minister would put it on the public record, as it is totally misleading. We do not receive plentiful legal advice and although what we get is excellent, it cannot compare with the resources the Minister has in the Department. It would be worth making the point again that Deputy Mitchell made: there are 83,000 employed in the health service for which the Minister is responsible. They will all get a copy of the executive summary of the health strategy. The Minister has a relationship with them. As that is the structure he heads up, it is not peanuts.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

What is wrong? Did the Minister not get Terry Prone to come in with him this morning?

Comment on this

Are the 83,000 going to advise me on abortion? Is that what the Deputy is saying?

Comment on this

It is important we understand there is nothing illegal in what we are suggesting. It is within the law about which there is no question. There are precedents, though, as we have seen in the Chamber, a precedent can be changed as it is a dynamic thing. It is not supposed to stultify and prevent the process from operating properly. The Minister is saying that his briefing cannot be interfered with but ours can. We have briefed ourselves on the sequence set out in this list of amendments. We have done so from a position of disadvantage as members of the Opposition with no dedicated resources whatsoever other than a constituency secretary who is run off her feet. If these are the conditions to be set out, let us be clear as to what those conditions are. The Minister is going to force this through, even though everyone knows that he, the Chairman and the civil servants can all work on the basis that we can be consistent and continue with the list of amendments, which have been published. Therefore, any member of the public can get a copy. Presumably many of them have, as the amendments are all over the newspapers today: they are already in the public arena. It is difficult to explain the reason, when the amendments are available, we have a situation where they will be turned on their head.

Comment on this

This is a terrible way to conduct business on such a sensitive and complex issue. It may be a short Bill, but it has to be teased out in quite a bit of detail. The Minister will have to accept that sufficient time has not been given to Deputies in terms of amendments. It has been rightly pointed out that I do not have legal backup. Normally we have sufficient time to look at these issues, but that has not been given. The Minister must accept this; I give him that information in good faith. To come in at 8.30 a.m. and be given until 11.30 a.m. is not the way to do business.

At the Whips' meeting there was no information about the committee and the way business was to be done. We were given no information. I assumed the amendments would be taken as they were submitted and that we would have time to go through them in detail in committee, even though we were not given sufficient time beforehand. I discussed the matter with Deputy McManus. However, it now seems that this is not the case. The Bill is being rushed through with unseemly haste and rushed legislation is bad legislation. We will suffer the consequences at a later stage. Let us be in no doubt - this issue is not going to go away and if we approach it in this manner, we will be back here again. I regret this very much as the way we are doing business means this is a dark day for Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

Again, it is absolutely untrue to say that the procedure articulated was motivated by the Government or that we interfered in any way with the Bills Office or the Chair in terms of the presentation, compilation or formulation of the brief for the Chair of the committee, which is what Deputy McManus was implying. That is absolutely and totally untrue.

Deputies are saying all this is motivated by the Government, but it is not. There is a time-honoured precedent——

Comment on this

As the Minister is proposing it, he should withdraw it.

Comment on this

I have listened to a polemic and a politicisation of the debate from Deputy McManus. I am coming to the conclusion——

Comment on this

I am a politician.

Comment on this

The Deputy may smile in her patronising way, but we published the Bill on 2 October. I do not accept the Opposition's protests that it was not in a position from 2 October until now to frame amendments. I do not accept that for one moment. From the correspondence exchanged since the Second Stage debate - which was longer than any similar debate——

Comment on this

Will the Chair take a point of order?

Comment on this

If it is a point of order.

Comment on this

The Minister should not waste the time of the committee with reflections of this kind. He knows as well as the rest of us that it is one of the conventions, if not the fictions of parliamentary life, that we do not draft amendments until we have heard the Minister's conclusions at the end of Second Stage. It has happened, though not in the case of this Minister, that Ministers have shown a certain capacity to understand what the Opposition is saying on Second Stage and changed their minds about parts of Bills by the end of Second Stage, thereby rendering any amendments that might have been relevant at the beginning of Second Stage——

Comment on this

With all due respect——

Comment on this

I know that is out of keeping with the current Minister's mindset, but he should not detain us with his ramblings.

Comment on this

On a similar point of order——

Comment on this

That was not a point of order.

Comment on this

——there is an agreement in the House that there should be a gap of two weeks after the conclusion of Second Stage. If the Minister was serious about getting consensus, he would have given us that two weeks after the conclusion of Second Stage and before the beginning of Committee Stage. He knows he is rushing it. Why the rush? Why not go with the precedent of the House, which is two weeks——

Comment on this

With respect, that is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Those are responses to issues the Minister raised.

Comment on this

There is an opportunity to respond.

Comment on this

Any person standing back from this would have to accept that at this point in time, given the conclusion of Second Stage, there is a strong political context to this debate. I am not so sure it is all about procedure and sequence. I have to question——

Comment on this

Very shrewd.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt and would appreciate the opportunity to speak. I question the motivation behind what is happening this morning. People are talking about huge, topsy-turvy amendments, but there are no amendments to section 1.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

How could the Minister——

Comment on this

There is only one amendment to section 2. People are saying almost hysterically——

Comment on this

Let us take them.

Comment on this

——that this is a huge change which will dramatically affect the sequencing. There is one amendment to the Title of the Bill and there is to be a general debate on sections. My briefing is in no way discommoded, as Deputy McManus suggested. I am not bothered one way or the other regarding the briefings. However, it would seriously discommode the Bills Office. That is an important point. Staff were there last night until 2.30 a.m., as they are on all Bills.

This is not worth the candle. No one will be debarred from discussing any element of the Bill, whether the sections or the Schedules. We know the real meat is in the Schedules. There is an unwarranted degree of fuss and histrionics and the only conclusion to which I can come is that this is more of the procrastination and obstruction which have become features of the discussion of this Bill. The procedure involved is the same as that adopted in June 1995 by the Rainbow Government regarding the constitutional referendum on divorce. That process involved a similar procedure on Second Stage, although less time was spent on that Stage. The Committee Stage debate of that legislation involved exactly the same amount of time as is the case with this Bill.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

This Bill is not something to be fitted in between photo opportunities. We require the Minister to go through the legislation in detail.

Comment on this

Is the motion agreed to?

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

No.

Cuireadh an cheist.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 8
·
Níl 7
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Tairgim leasú a 2:

I leathanach 6, idir línte 22 agus 23, an méid seo a leanas a chur isteach:

"Cuirfear na fo-ailt seo a leanas le halt 3 den téacs Sacs-Bhéarla:

'4°. In particular, the life of the unborn in the womb shall be protected in accordance with the provisions of the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002.

'5°. The provisions of section 2 of Article 46 and sections 1, 3 and 4 of Article 47 of this Constitution shall apply to any Bill passed or deemed to have been passed by both Houses of the Oireachtas containing a proposal to amend the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002, as they apply to a Bill containing a proposal or proposals for the amendment of this Constitution and any such Bill shall be signed by the President forthwith upon his being satisfied that the Bill has been duly approved by the people in accordance with the provisions of section 1 of Article 47 of this Constitution and shall be duly promulgated by the President as a law.'.".

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 7, between lines 4 and 5, to insert the following:

"The following subsections shall be added to section 3 of the Irish text:

'4° Déanfar, go sonrach, beatha na mbeo gan breith sa bhroinn a chosaint de réir fhorálacha an Achta chun Beatha Dhaonna le linn Toirchis a Chosaint, 2002.

'5° Beidh feidhm ag forálacha alt 2 d'Airteagal 46 agus ailt 1, 3 agus 4 d'Airteagal 47 den Bhunreacht seo maidir le haon Bhille a ritear nó a mheastar a ritheadh ag dhá Theach an Oireachtais, ar Bille é a bhfuil togra ann chun an tAcht chun Beatha Dhaonna le linn Toirchis a Chosaint, 2002, a leasú, mar atá feidhm acu maidir le Bille a bhfuil togra nó tograí ann chun an Bunreacht seo a leasú agus ní foláir don Uachtarán a lámh a chur le haon Bhille den sórt sin láithreach ar mbeith sásta dó gur thoiligh an pobal go cuí leis an mBille de réir fhorálacha alt 1 d'Airteagal 47 den Bhunreacht seo, agus ní foláir don Uachtarán é a fhógairt go cuí ina dhlí.'.".

While this is not a major amendment, I am relying to an extent on the expertise of the Minister's advisers. There must be full translation between of the two languages in any constitutional amendment. That is how it was done in the Good Friday Agreement where there was an amendment to an amendment. It was included in the Constitution because it related to the amendment to Articles 2 and 3. The amendment occurred eight times because of the need to have a full translation between the two languages. I am concerned about the issue here.

Another matter may also need to be addressed. The First Schedule reads, "Cuid 1 - Part 1, Cuid 2 - Part 2" which are not direct translations. Both pages are not identical. One is not a translation of the other, one is Part 1 and the other is Part 2. My understanding is that when one is dealing with the Constitution it must be an exact translation. I am not an expert, nor am I trying to create a problem, but there seems to be a problem. We need to be very careful about this because it is most unusual. What is being presented by the Government is unique and unprecedented. However, in other ways it is not, because there is the Good Friday Agreement model which is similar but not exactly the same. It seems in that instance the provision relating to the translation was fully met. It may be that it is not being fully met in this instance, which is the issue I am raising here.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Deputy may be raising more than an academic point. It is important, particularly in terms of a constitutional amendment but also in regard to any legislation, because the Irish language takes precedence in the courts. The Minister as a former teacher will have good Irish, but I notice in a later section the wording in the Irish section reads, ". . . go bhfaighidh an bhean bás". I think this translates that there is a substantial risk that the women will die. The English version reads, ". . . a real and substantial risk of loss of the woman's life". Some people may say that is the same. If it is the same meaning, I do not know why we did not use those words in English. It seems to me that the courts, given the recent judgment about the use of the language in legislation, will rely on the Irish version of any legislation, particularly a constitutional amendment. We need to be careful in this regard and I would be interested to hear the Minister's response to the point raised by Deputy McManus.

Comment on this

My understanding is that the Irish version of the Constitution is superior to the English version. In deference to what the Deputies have said, I understand it is not necessary to proceed with this amendment. I will reflect on what has been said between now and Report Stage and seek further advice in order to be absolutely sure.

Comment on this

I intend to deal with the issue on Report Stage if the matter is not dealt with satisfactorily.

Tarraingíodh siar an leasú faoi chead.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 3 and 4 are related and amendment No. 4 is consequential on amendment No. 20. Amendments Nos. 3, 4 and 20 will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I have a difficulty because I do not think amendment No. 3 is related to amendment No. 4.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Deputy if she wishes to deal with the amendments separately.

Comment on this

I can see that amendmentsNos. 4 and 20 are related but I would prefer to deal with amendment No. 3 first.

Comment on this

I do not have a difficulty with that.

Comment on this

There is a connection but it is a bit tenuous in terms of dealing with it.

Tairgim leasú a 3:

I leathanach 6, line 7, ", go sonrach," a scriosadh.

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 7, line 7, to delete "In particular, the" and substitute "The".

This relates to a problem I have with the wording currently proposed. We must remember this is a subsection which is being added to Article 40.3. In that context, "In particular" gives rise to uncertainty and ambiguity about the relationship between the existing subsections 3 and 4. Article 40.3.3° of the Constitution refers to the right to life of the unborn and with due regard to the mother's right to life. The new subsection refers to the right to life of the unborn in the womb and makes no reference to the right to life of the mother. The new subsection implies that it is intended as a specific application of a general principle. The reality is that it is an exception from the general principle since its effect is to overrule the judgment of the X case, which was grounded on a Supreme Court judgment in subsection 3. A clear conflict between the two subsections exists and it cannot be reconciled by what appears to be a drafting sleight of hand.

It would be clearer if Article 40.3.3° was withdrawn and replaced with this proposal. I would not support it but at least there would be no ambiguity. That is not being proposed by the Government. It is proposing to keep Article 40.3.3°, which refers to where it is practicable to save the life of the unborn and also provides for the right to life of the mother. That has already been interpreted by the Supreme Court as including a threat to suicide or self-destruction. That stands and will continue to stand if there is this amendment to the Constitution. However, there will be an additional subsection 4 which, in effect, does not have as extensive protections not just for the mother but also for the unborn in the womb. It specifies that one is only talking about the unborn after implantation. Therefore, there is an ambiguity between the two.

I would like to refer to legal advice which I managed to get by begging for it. My briefing has been put out of synch by the way the Minister has insisted on rejigging the list of amendments, therefore, he will have to allow some leeway. The legal advice states that the proposed new Article 40.6.1° contained in the First Schedule to the Bill provides that Article 40.3 shall be amended to include a new Article 40.3.4° and 40.3.5°. Article 40.3.4° provides that, in particular the life of the unborn in the womb shall be protected in accordance with the provisions of what will be known as the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002. It is difficult to assess the compatibility of this provision with the existing Article 40.3.3°, in which the State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect and, as far as is practicable, by its laws defend and vindicate that right. It then proceeds to make certain guarantees.

The first difficulty relates to how far the new subsections actually overrule the judgment in the X case. The authoritative ruling gave priority to the mother's right to life, where that is in conflict with the right to life of the unborn. Where what will be the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002, clearly will not apply, Article 40.3.3°, the judgment in the X case remains law. Thus section 1(1) provides that abortion means the intentional destruction by any means of unborn human life after implantation in the womb of a woman. The judgment in the X case remains the law in relation to unborn life prior to implantation, presumably after conception. Article 40.3.4° offers no protection to the life of the unborn prior to implantation or outside the womb of the woman, for example, in the case of an ectopic pregnancy, where the foetus develops in the fallopian tubes or, more rarely, the abdomen or cervix.

The words at the start of Article 40.3.4° are difficult to interpret. Do they mean that the unborn can continue to have protection beyond that offered in the Bill, or do they limit the protection of the unborn to that offered in the Bill? These words imply that the Article may be incompatible with the existing 40.3.3°.

Article 40.3.4° may also be incompatible with Article 40.3.3° because it makes no reference to the equal right to life of the mother. There is also no reference in what will be the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002, to the right to life of the mother, yet Article 40.3.3° clearly provides that the State must have due regard to the mother's life. Limiting the right to life of the mother by ruling out suicide as grounds on which her right to life may take priority over that of the unborn appears fundamentally to be incompatible with the protection for her right to life under Article 40.3.3°. It is, therefore, very likely that, even if passed, Article 40.3.4° will give rise to significant litigation issues as it is difficult to see how the inconsistency between these two Articles can be overcome, given the wording of what will be the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002.

The Minister, by using the words "in particular," is stating that there is a difference between this proposal and the rights enshrined in Article 40.3.3°. That is of comfort to the many concerned that he is taking suicide out of the equation, or trying to, because I do not think he will succeed. He says that the words "in particular" will cover it, but the generality is already enshrined in the Constitution. What is he actually saying? Is he saying that, notwithstanding the fact that women have certain rights under Article 40.3.3°, he is going to limit them? This is not clear and not a matter of my opinion - I am proud to be a politician in dealing with issues such as this - but it is an issue about our work resulting in litigation with cases taken which will raise serious doubts about the process on which the Minister is embarking.

Comment on this

We now resume.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The words "in particular" stood out when I read the Bill and I wish to raise the issue with the Minister. I did not propose an amendment on it because of the other things I have to say about the Schedule. As it is, Article 40.3.3° says:

The State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect, and, as far as practicable, by its laws to defend and vindicate that right.

I will return to that in my own amendment shortly.

If this new Article was approved by the people it would become Article 40.3.4° so Article 40.3.3° would continue:

"In particular, the life of the unborn in the womb shall be protected in accordance with the provisions of the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, 2002."

It seems that the words "in particular" were inserted there for a purpose which the Minister did not explain to us on Second Stage. He should explain it to us now because, as I read it, Article 40.3.4° would be a more specific expression of Article 40.3.3° which I suggest remains the main provision. Article 40.3.4° would be a specific extension of that main provision and the words "in particular" are meant to create that specific from the general.

I do not know what the implications of that are for the morning after pill or embryo research. The impression given by the Minister at the launch of this Bill was that this now legalises the morning after pill but the morning after pill is not mentioned and whether we want to legalise it or not is not the point. The point is that the impression was given that this would now decriminalise or legalise the morning after pill. As I read it, under Article 40.3.3°, even if it is amended by Article 40.3.4°, it would still be open to the Oireachtas to bring in amending legislation prohibiting the morning after pill and would be open to any citizen to seek an injunction against the Irish Medicines Board or anybody else who approved the morning after pill. Article 40.3.4°, if added, would not give the protection the Minister implied at his press conference it would give to the morning after pill, IUDs or anything else. Will the Minister confirm that is the case? Will he confirm that it could still be legislated against under Article 40.3.3° if the Minister or any private Member wished to introduce a Bill or that it could still be challenged in the courts?

Will he confirm that the words "in particular" are meant to give a specific expression to Article 40.3.4° as a subsection or follow-on to the general provisions of Article 40.3.3°? What is the purpose of having the words "in particular" if not along the lines I have suggested?

Comment on this

I will follow along the general line of questioning and I commend Deputy McManus for raising this in her amendment. We are all aware of what happened with regard to the wording of the 1983 amendment. Some of us forecast that the interpretation of it would end up in the Supreme Court, and it did. That court interpreted it in a way that many people did not anticipate and about which they have protested ever since. Article 40.3.4° faces the same fate. It will be challenged because there would seem to be a conflict between 40.3.3° and Article 40.3.4° which is now the superior one.

With the 1983 amendment we had the argument, the debate and the interpretation examined and pronounced on by the High Court which came down on the side of the superior right of the unborn. It went to the Supreme Court which interpreted that in the case of self-destruction, in the light of the tragic circumstances of case X, the threat of self-destruction had to be taken into consideration and it allowed the mother to have superior rights when it came to weighing the value of the two in that particular circumstance.

Is the proposed Article 40.3.4° now attempting, by using the words "in particular" to actually give the superior claim to the right of the unborn and in that way counter the interpretation of Article 40.3.3° of the Supreme Court? We could find ourselves in a situation where the Supreme Court would find itself again having to try to decide which has the superior claim leading right back into the same difficulties it had before in deciding who had superior value and under what circumstances. It is fraught with legal challenge.

Comment on this

The effect of Deputy McManus's amendment would be to delete the words "in particular" from the proposed Article 40.3.4°. The words "in particular" are the key linkage between Articles 40.3.3° and 40.3.4°. That is deliberate. When used in the proposed Article 40.3.4° the words "in particular" make it clear that the statute envisaged by the amendment, if enacted, is not intended to be a restatement of the term "unborn" as used in Article 40.3.3°. Both would have to be read together. If the people pass the amendment, Articles 40.3.3° and 40.3.4° will not be read separately on their own and then put into competition, as it were. They will both be read together. That is my very strong constitutional advice.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

But it does not state "in particular."

Comment on this

Deputy McManus is correct in saying that, in essence, the effect of Article 40.3.4° is to remove the interpretation of Article 40.3.3°, which would permit the abortion of unborn life in the womb after implantation on the grounds of suicide risk. Therefore, Article 40.3.4° does deal with the suicide issue. That is the effect in inserting it into the Constitution.

Deputy McManus stated that what will be known as the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act could nonetheless permit abortion prior to implantation on the grounds of suicide risk. We have always been consistent in saying that the Bill does not purport to define when human life begins, rather for the purposes of criminal law, it defines the offence of abortion. In theory, people could argue the issue as between conception and implantation, but it would not be practical to frame legislation to deal with that period. If someone wanted to explore the route from conception to implantation, it is a possible theory, but it is not possible to envisage a credible example or define such a possibility or eventuality for the purposes of criminal law.

Rather than adding confusion the effect will be to give certainty from the legal perspective. The effect will be to make it entirely clear that, in what be will known as the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act, the protection of life will apply to the life of the unborn in the womb, as distinct from the life of the unborn as dealt with in Article 40.3.3°. However, they must both be read together for the purposes of legal interpretation.

In response to Deputy Barnes's point, anything we put into the Constitution is subject to interpretation at any point. Every citizen has the right to question particular actions from time to time. No amendment is immune from interpretation ultimately.

Comment on this

Particularly if it is in the Constitution.

Comment on this

I refer the Minister to a submission by Dr. Ken Whitaker to the all-party committee on the Constitution. I do not think he envisaged a proposal of this type where, in effect, there will be two subsections in the Constitution, which have within them an inherent conflict. I quote from Dr. Whitaker's report:

I would maintain that it is up to the Legislature to express very clearly and with very due regard the possibilities of misinterpretation of what it wants to be the law of the land. If the courts are in the ultimate position of deciding between disputing parties or disputing interpretations, the first requirement is that the law be set out in its original form with the utmost clarity so as to avoid in so far as possible recourse to the courts.

What the Minister is saying is that this proposal is specifying, in particular, a set of rights, but also restrictions. However, it is not possible to say they are overriding those rights and restrictions stipulated in Article 40.3.3° because they will both be in the Constitution. It is not up to the Minister or anybody else to decide which overrides the other.

Comment on this

That is not what we are doing.

Comment on this

That is what I understood from what the Minister was saying. The Minister is arguing for these words. I am not too concerned about them; it is the issue that I am raising. The Minister is clearly pointing out that there is a difference between what is in this subsection in terms of its restrictions and what is in Article 40.3.3°. Which has precedence? Deputy Mitchell's point is correct. If we leave aside women and the foetus, an anti-contraception group presumably could go to court and argue on the basis of this provision that we cannot allow contraception prior to implantation and the morning after pill. That is a real problem. This has implications for the Minister's strategy in terms of crisis pregnancies etc. He must have a really clear precise position on this in order that there will no be danger of misinterpretation, even though people have a right to go to court.

Comment on this

Article 40.3.3° acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect and, as far as practicable, by its laws defend and vindicate that right. Article 40.3.4° will insert into the Constitution the protection what will be known as the Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy Act gives. The great criticism of Article 40.3.3° was that we never subsequently brought forward legislation.

Comment on this

This does not clarify Article 40.3.3°.

Comment on this

It clarifies it quite significantly. It defines the offence of abortion after implantation.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

When we reach my next amendment the Minister will see that is not the case.

Comment on this

Once the people pass the amendment the two Articles will not be in conflict with each other. They must be read together.

Comment on this

They are in conflict.

Comment on this

No, by definition they cannot be; they have to be read together. That is my very strong legal advice. The advice is adamant. The practised procedure is for them to be read together because, once passed, they will form part of the same Constitution. Any case looks at the balances. This is true of all constitutional provisions.

Comment on this

Much of what the Minister says is rather specious; it does not have much meaning. Article 40.3.3° sets out to protect the life of the unborn - full stop. This has given rise to the problems about which we know. It is cynical and disingenuous of the Minister to tell us that, by inserting Article 40.3.4° as proposed, the words "in particular" add something.

This is a nonsensical Bill, in particular the Second Schedule. Does it mean that the Second Schedule is any more important than the whole Bill or that my dislike of the Bill has to be read in conjunction with my particular dislike of the Second Schedule? It does not. By using the words "in particular" it gives an explanation for a part of a whole. They must be consistent with each other. What the Minister really means to do in this text is to say there is a general protection in Article 40.3.3°, but that we are derogating from this general protection in Article 40.3.4° in some specific ways.

It would be more honest to say at the beginning of Article 40.3.4° that, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 40.3.3°, we go on to be more specific in Article 40.3.4°. This is the first place where there is a reference to what I call the Bill within the Bill, which sets out the exception to Article 40.3.4°. Article 40.3.4° means - I will say this as neutrally as possible - that the general protection afforded by Article 40.3.3° does not apply to a product of conception not yet implanted in the womb under the conditions that are proposed in the Bill within the Bill. That Bill provides that, in certain cases that fall outside the definition of abortion given in the Bill, the products of conception not yet implanted in the womb do not have the protection of Article 40.3.3°. The articles are not to be read together. One article has to be read as a particular exception to the other. The phrase needed here is not "in particular" but "notwithstanding" or "without prejudice to".

Comment on this

There is no reference in Article 40.3.3° to implantation in the womb. Is that correct?

Comment on this

What is the definition of implantation and when does it take place? What understanding is the Minister working on in that regard?

Comment on this

I am looking at the explanation the Taoiseach gave to our party leader, Deputy Noonan, in reply to the 34 questions that were tabled. I imagine the Minister is working on this because a legal person told the Taoiseach the kind of answers to give. As the debate has evolved, it is clear that the words "in particular" are totally inappropriate in this section. In his explanation, the Taoiseach said it will be noted that the proposed wording in the Constitution is to provide a "particular" scheme of protection for the life of the unborn in the womb. If that is what it is doing, it is qualifying, adding to or doing something to Article 40.3.3°. That cannot be second guessed because that is the explanation we have been given and it is obviously what the Government is working on. It goes on to state that the term "in particular" when used in the proposed Article 40.3.4° makes it clear that the statute envisaged by the amendment, if enacted, is not intended to be a restatement or redefinition of the term "unborn" as used in the Article 40.3.3°.

The exact words used are not a redefinition of "unborn" but the reference to the protection of the unborn in Article 40.3.3° is now qualified by the Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill, 2001. The last sentences of the Government's answer states that "it is hoped" the Government's proposals will result in the enactment of a law which is clear as to its meaning and its effect. Enacting laws that are clear in their meaning has to be the primary responsibility of every Minister. If ever a law needed every comma, apostrophe and parenthesis to be clear, it is this law. We know from personal experience of 1983 and onwards that if the law is not exact, interpretations can be made.

The Minister may tell us that his legal advice is that we take one article with the other. However, taking it with Article 40.3.3° is precisely why the amendment is being made. The words "in particular" are adding, changing or in some way redefining the matter, but the Taoiseach said there is no intention of restatement or redefinition of "the unborn". The Minister holds that this is not the effect of this article. However, we are talking about the life of the unborn in the womb as set out in Article 40.3.3°, if the Minister wants both articles to be read together. The Minister should listen to the committee and give it, if he can, a more understandable explanation.

The Minister's words to the committee could end up in the Supreme Court when a case is made. The lawyers will check committee records to find our great words and they will use them in the courts, as they must do. The intent of legislation can also be interpreted by what is said during the implementation of legislation, as the Minister knows. The Minister should consider the submissions being made here.

Comment on this

I am listening to what Members are saying. These issues are not new to me and they were examined by the interdepartmental committee. To suggest that law is an exact science is disingenuous. We know that is not the case, in an absolute sense. The Legislature passes laws while the people pass amendments of the Constitution. Going back to 1983, we know that Article 40.3.3° was subsequently amended by the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

It was not amended. That is a distinct slip the Minister made.

Comment on this

Sorry, it was interpreted rather than amended. We want a genuine debate on the issues here and we should not get too picky or personal. The interpretation by the Supreme Court was not in line with what people thought they were doing when they voted for the amendment in Article 40.3.3°. That is what gave rise to subsequent behaviour in 1992 when the matter was revisited and that is also the case to an extent this year.

The Constitution is an organic document which changes over time. In Irish history, the Supreme Court has been a significant factor in the evolution of the Constitution and its impact on citizens. The Constitution passed in 1937 is not set in stone and has changed dramatically over the decades. One of the great catalysts for that change has been various interpretations by the Supreme Court. This will happen no matter what kind of amendment is made to the Constitution. In terms of this particular amendment and the words "in particular," the Supreme Court has laid down approaches to constitutional construction that are well known. The doctrine of harmonious interpretation requires that constitutional provisions should not be construed in isolation from all the other parts of the Constitution among which they are embedded, but should be so construed as to harmonise with other parts of the Constitution. It is not anticipated that the Government's proposals for the amendment will impinge on the rights of the unborn and the mother, already identified in the Constitution. The doctrine of harmonious interpretation has been laid down by the Supreme Court and that is how any subsequent interpretation would flow.

Regarding the definition of implantation, we know that it is a process by which the fertilised ovum becomes implanted or adheres to the lining of the uterus. This can take place anywhere from three to ten days after fertilisation. It is not a moment in time that can be defined but a process for which we have a reasonable timeframe from a medical perspective as to what happens.

Comment on this

When does the law take over?

Comment on this

That brings me back to the point about practicality. Article 40.3.3° clearly says that the law, in as far as is practicable, must defend and vindicate rights. Are people suggesting that we bring in a criminal law that would prohibit or make an offence of anything that happens between the three day and ten day point? That is not practicable, although there are issues relating to this question.

Comment on this

I agree there was a problem with the 1983 amendment and it was not clear. Many people were relieved when the Supreme Court enlightened us as to what it meant rather than being upset about it. That was a lesson in terms of what we are doing now. That is the reason I am disturbed that the Government is inserting legislation into the Constitution without provision for the Legislature to change it. If this proposal is passed, another referendum will be needed. With the possible exception of the Chairman, none of us believes we are infallible, yet we are being asked to act as if that were the case.

Let me make another point about the idea of being harmonious. There is no harmony between the two subsections I have been discussing. The Minister has signalled the lack of harmony. Being honest, the removal of the words "in particular" will not eliminate this problem, as the disharmony will remain, regardless of whether my amendment is accepted. It is not fair for the Minister to have to attend this meeting without constitutional or legal advice. I have the highest respect for civil servants in the Department of Health and Children, but we are discussing an unprecedented constitutional amendment which has been subject to grave criticism. The Minister should publish his legal advice, as the committee does not know what it is. It might be helpful.

Comment on this

I have given the legal advice in terms of harmonious——

Comment on this

The extent of the legal advice is insufficient to allay the committee's worries. The Minister should be able to draw on legal advice when difficult issues arise. I have no doubt that Deputy Owen was right when she said we can be sure this matter will end up in the courts. I am worried that, in effect, the Legislature is unable to deal with the matter of abortion, first, because of its nature and, second, because of our inability to meet the requirements set down by Dr. Whitaker. It is clear that we are nowhere near reaching that requirement in terms of clarity.

Comment on this

The Minister spoke about implantation, which is mentioned in one article but not in another. He replied to Deputy Noonan's question on the matter by saying:

At any given time, the exact state of an ovum in the womb of a woman is largely unknowable. As a matter of criminal law, there can be no presumption that a particular ovum is or is not fertilised at any given point in time or that it has or has not implanted in the womb. Medical research tends to suggest that around half of fertilised ova never implant in the womb at all. In addition to that, there is reason to believe that a significant proportion of fertilised ova which go on to implant in the womb almost immediately come to nothing. These facts underline the difficulty in providing protection by criminal law.

Given that the Minister said implantation is inexact, that one cannot be precise about it, and that the proposed constitutional amendment defines abortion as "the intentional destruction by any means of unborn human life after implantation," how will a medical practitioner know whether he or she is operating inside or outside the law?

Comment on this

While this is not a party political issue, I re-echo my party's concerns as this is a political matter for legislators. As has been pointed out, we have learned the hard way from the 1983 referendum. The Supreme Court's interpretation of Article 40.3.3° was the exact opposite of the interpretation desired by pressure groups and contrary to what many thought they had voted for in 1983. I commend the Minister for his reference to legislation being ongoing and open to amendment, depending on time and circumstances. Such circumstances may change as a result of huge developments in medical and reproductive procedures. We can only guess the form such changes will take in the next decade. It is almost impossible to legislate for all possibilities, much less insert them into the Constitution. It is downright dangerous to make constitutional changes, as the process does not evolve organically. A process of Supreme Court interpretation and referral to the Legislature once more seems inevitable.

This section raises many questions. I am worried that if we, as legislators, are not allowed to develop, amend and change the law as is needed in each Dáil session and as the Minister rightly says we should be allowed to do, we will be trapped by legislation that is set in stone. The process will not be organic and referenda will have to be held to make necessary amendments, no matter how small. Legislation should be flexible and open, as the Minister has said. It is fundamental that we are specific in legislation, although we cannot be as specific as we want to be. This amendment, the first we are discussing today, raises a huge issue. Similar difficulties will be faced when dealing with further amendments.

Comment on this

In response to the point made by Deputy McManus, I have had full access to constitutional advice on this issue. The advice has been published, as have the Taoiseach's replies to 35 questions asked by the leader of the Fine Gael Party. The questions were answered comprehensively, honestly and transparently. The replies did not pull any punches in terms of difficulties with definitions and other matters, including those raised by Deputies Fitzgerald and Barnes. It is not as if this issue is being raised for the first time today.

The Attorney General's key advice on this issue is that the Supreme Court has laid down particular approaches to constitutional construction which are well known, particularly in the legal world. The Attorney General has advised that the doctrine of harmonious interpretation applies in this case. If the people, in their wisdom, decide to pass a particular amendment, it forms part of the whole. The Constitution has to be read in its entirety. Other sections of the Constitution emphasise balancing rights and the Supreme Court is empowered to adjudicate on and to interpret such rights. The clear and strong advice on this matter is that the existing Article 40.3.3° and the proposed Article 40.3.4° will be read together, not separately. The Articles will not be in competition with each other.

It is clear that the insertion of Article 40.3.4° will mean that the situation will change, as constitutional protection for legislation will be provided and a new criminal law prohibiting abortion will be on the statute book. Article 40.3.4° will define specifically what is to be prohibited and permitted in terms of medical procedures to save the life of the mother when her life is in danger. The proposed Article will also provide for the removal of the risk of suicide as a ground for abortion. The proposed constitutional amendment is very clear in each of these areas. The morning after pill will not be prohibited, although it would be an issue if one was to return to the conception argument. Deputy Fitzgerald and other Deputies articulated that we are almost looking for a theoretical exactitude in terms of legislation.

Comment on this

We also seem to seek a theological exactitude.

Comment on this

I refer specifically to the search for theoretical exactitude, which is almost impossible to find. The wording of Article 40.3.3° of the Constitution clearly points the way towards the vindication of the rights of citizens, by guaranteeing that the State will defend "as far as practicable, by its laws to defend and vindicate the personal rights of the citizen."

Others may have different viewpoints. Deputy McManus has acknowledged that, from her perspective, this amendment will not have any impact on the problems she has outlined. I assume she speaks from the advice she has received. It could be argued that the words "in particular" should be removed, but I do not agree and have not received advice to that effect. We are discussing the amendment brought forward by Deputy McManus, but others have not brought forward other types of amendment in relation to this issue. The reason we are adopting a legislative approach within the constitutional context is that it is clear to us that the people want to have a say on the matter. Deputy Barnes has argued that the Legislature alone should deal with the issue, which is also the view expressed in Dr. Whitaker's report. The all-party committee outlined three options. We have taken the third. We sincerely believe that the people have a right to be consulted on the issue and that, given its history, it would be inadvisable to move forward on the legislative front alone.

Comment on this

On a point of information, the reason I quoted Dr. Ken Whitaker was that he was the chairman of the expert review group which, interestingly, also included David Byrne, the previous Attorney General and current Commissioner. The unanimous view of the group expressed in a recommendation was that we should not take the constitutional route again and should legislate in line with the judgment in the X case.

The difficulty is that, regardless of whether one removes the words "in particular," one still has the conflict. The amendment was not tabled to resolve the conflict, the Minister created it. Presumably one could have resolved the conflict by removing Article 40.3.3° and replacing it with this text, which the Minster did not want to do for political reasons. This means that, once this is all agreed, one will have two parts of the Constitution. The problem is that different rights will have been established. They can be read concurrently, but also as having an inherent contradiction which will, I presume, be tested in the courts.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will put down a marker for fear that the Minister's statement will go unchallenged. When we reach my amendment, the one after next, I will demonstrate that there is potential for a lacuna. There is a point which we will need to tease out and challenge.

Comment on this

I agree entirely with the comments of Deputies Gay Mitchell and McManus. The Minister raised several other issues. The nonsense of having to read these protections concurrently becomes clear immediately when one reflects that one cannot concurrently be a product of conception before implantation in the womb and a product of conception implanted. They are quite different things.

The Minister raised the route the Government is taking on this matter. He is good with honeyed words. The Government has decided to cave in to pressure exerted by persons who do not trust legislators to deal with these issues. I remind the Minister that they are the same people who did not trust the Legislature in the 1980s. They got it disastrously wrong and are determined to continue to get it disastrously wrong for as long as they are allowed to get away with it.

The Government has chosen a very odd mixture of constitutional and legislative action. As I will comment further on this matter when we discuss the Schedule, I will confine my remarks to a point the Minister made without the Chairman intervening to request that he not stray from the amendment. The form of legislation the Minister is proposing is the oddest one I have ever seen and not, incidentally, directly comparable with the approach taken with regard to the Good Friday Agreement. What is proposed here is that the Dáil and Seanad would be invited to pass a Bill, the text of which forms part of the enterprise with which we are dealing, which will be presented to the Houses of the Oireachtas on a take it or leave it basis with no provision to modify or critically examine it. That is utterly insulting to the Oireachtas. It is pandering of the worst kind to people who have shown a great capacity to get things wrong. If this passes, as it may well do, the Government will have created a precedent which it could very well rue in the future when dealing with other legislation, even if, as I hope, it finds itself in opposition very soon. There are other areas, which I do not need to go into, where people will make the same point, namely, they do not trust the legislators to do what they are elected to do.

The Minister and the Government have made a very grave error in choosing this combination. It is conceivable, for example, that the Government's objectives could be achieved in other ways. The definition of abortion, the protection of current legal practice - irrespective of what it is or our view of it - and the implicit legalisation of the morning after pill and IUDs could be achieved through simple amendments to existing legislation. For example, a simple amendment of sections 58 and 59 of the 1861 Act would achieve this, which would leave one net issue to deal with from a constitutional point of view, that is, the Government's intention to roll back the judgment in the X case.

This is the only issue which requires a constitutional decision. What the Government is doing is unnecessarily confusing it with a whole series of other issues. It is a very bad way of proceeding. Even though I make very few predictions with certainty, I am certain that we will regret this in the years ahead.

Comment on this

We do not need to proceed with this debate having already hit the proverbial wall. The Minister is the master of his own destiny and the manufacturer of his own problems because, as Deputy Dukes said, of the way in which he is seeking to pass a constitutional amendment which, once passed, will give effect to the Bill, thus tying the hands of the Oireachtas. It is already clear from today's proceedings that a challenge, even to the innocuous words "in particular", could engage the Supreme Court for weeks in the process of working out whether Articles 40.3.3° and 40.3.4° are compatible or whether there is a hierarchy of protection. It could lead to an interpretation that the life of the mother is somehow less protected because the life of the unborn has been given the extra protection of the words "in particular". That is my concern.

I have not received legal advice on the issue. Article 15.2.1° of the Constitution states:

The sole and exclusive power of making laws for the State is hereby vested in the Oireachtas: no other legislative authority has power to make laws for the State.

It does not state that the people can make the law. The sole and exclusive power for doing so is vested in the Oireachtas. We are making a law here as is our right. The Minister, however, is asking us to give away our right set out in Article 15.2 of the Constitution. As soon as this Bill is passed, we will become powerless, emasculated. We will no longer have the power to amend the law or, probably, deal with any laws or problems which may arise from it without first returning to the people to seek an amendment.

The Minister may be a young man and probably has ambitions to be leader of his party. He will not be Minister for Health and Children for the next 15 years, during which time the unforeseen effects of this will become evident. This is aside from discussing the rights and wrongs of removing the right to abortion if one is suicidal or even what is in the law. We are talking about the mechanism the Minister is using. He is fettering the powers given to me as an elected representative under Article 15.2 and I strongly object to that.

The other article, to which Deputy Quinn referred in the Dáil, was Article 46.4. It states that any proposal should not be joined by any other. In respect of dancing on the head of a pin, the Taoiseach said there is no other proposal, but there is another. It is proposed to put to the people an amendment and then, on the back of that, to pass a law. We have no choice. If this amendment is passed by the people, there will no choice within 180 days. I am sure it will not be dealt with in time to have the 180 days elapse within the life of this Government. Members of the Oireachtas who are re-elected will have to return fettered, bound and dictated to by the Minister.

The Minister is breaking new ground and he is doing so at his peril. I believe he is getting bad advice on this matter; I have talked to lawyers, as have other members of the committee. Article 15.2 has not figured very much - maybe it did before I came in - but I stated what it says and I will protect it for myself and for posterity as I was trying to do today with regard to another issue. I am trying to protect this House for people who will come after me when I am dead and gone, or at least retired and capable of being a hurler on the ditch. We must protect our constitutional rights as legislators.

Comment on this

In any society with a written constitution, there is, by definition, a restriction on the Legislature. The Legislature is not supreme in Ireland because we have a written Constitution. That is a fact. Other jurisdictions do not have written constitutions and, consequently——

Comment on this

That is——

Comment on this

With respect to Deputy Dukes, we know this because other laws and areas have required the passage of legislation subject to the Constitution. We do not legislate unfettered in our jurisdiction, nor have we ever done so. We can legislate only in accordance with the Constitution and it is the right of the people, if they so desire, to change that Constitution from time to time. It is the right of legislators to advance a change to the Constitution at any given time——

Comment on this

So the Minister is amending Article 15.2.

Comment on this

No. Legislators can put propositions to the people, as we do on an ongoing basis. The people can either approve those amendments or reject them. If they approve them, an addition to or a deletion from the Constitution must be made, which, by definition, changes it.

Comment on this

But then we go on to pass the law——

Comment on this

The Minister is beside the point.

Comment on this

Some Governments have attempted to deal with this while others have not. There has been a strong attack on the Government's approach to this matter. Some independent legal commentators have articulated the view that the legal construction here is a work of ingenuity. I am not saying——

Comment on this

It is not a contest. We are not having a competition here between——

Comment on this

The Deputy questioned the advice. The constitutional advice I have received——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

It sounds like the advice is that one is looking in a mirror.

Comment on this

It is not a question of who is the very best Attorney General in the country.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

The Minister is saying——

Comment on this

No. The advice has been questioned. The advice has been undermined by the comments from speakers so far.

Comment on this

What is the Minister's point?

Comment on this

I refer to the advice that has been put forward

Comment on this

What is the Minister saying?

Comment on this

People are saying that the advice I received is not good, that it is bad. That is what Deputy Owen is saying.

Comment on this

Our job——

Comment on this

I am not giving out about that——

Comment on this

That is an incredible thing to say.

Comment on this

I am just saying it is a fact.

Comment on this

The Minister used the word "undermined". Our job is to question——

Comment on this

——and to assess it in terms of our best opinions. That is not to undermine anybody. We are not——

Comment on this

Some of the commentaries had the impact of endeavouring to undermine my advice and say it is of no quality. That is the gist of what some of the Deputies have articulated. Let us not be totally disingenuous.

Comment on this

The current Attorney General is a dab hand——

Comment on this

I accept totally the right of Deputies to question——

Comment on this

——Deputy who is in this House——

Comment on this

——but there is also a clear attempt to undermine and say the advice is not good. It was said to me: "Minister, you are getting very poor advice."

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

I would read that——

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister made those comments when he was on this side of the House.

Comment on this

That is a statement which, by definition, undermines the quality of the advice. I will not dwell on that. I want to address the core point.

Comment on this

That is an admission——

Comment on this

A key point is that the Deputies opposite were in Government and did not attempt to legislate. I accept that the Labour Party has a position on this matter, but I do not think the Fine Gael Party has one yet.

Comment on this

That is none of the Minister's business.

Comment on this

It is actually.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Perhaps we have been too decent to the Minister, but if he thinks we will let him throw his weight around like that, he has another thing coming. Does he want us to go out on the plinth and bring the whole thing down? We have behaved in a very democratic, constitutional and proper manner in respect of this Bill. I will not accept any more petty, political nonsense from the Minister.

Comment on this

This is not——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Let us keep to the Bill and have no more of the Minister's nonsense. He is raising temperatures here with his behaviour.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deal with the issues at hand?

Comment on this

Chairman, I am dealing with the issues. Points have been raised as to the advisability of the Government's approach. People have questioned it very sincerely. I am responding by saying that the Government has given considerable thought to this in the light of the views the Oireachtas committee expressed and following the Green Paper process. If Deputies can come up with something better in legislative terms, maybe they should table their amendments, which should be to the point.

Comment on this