We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON HEALTH AND CHILDREN

Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.

Contributions 159–330 of 330. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Twenty-fifth Amendment of the Constitution (Protection of Human Life in Pregnancy) Bill 2001
Rejected

No. 48 of 2001 ›

Amend the 1861 Act.

Comment on this

I accepted that the Labour Party has a different point of view.

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with the Labour Party.

Comment on this

It has.

Comment on this

The Minister has opposed the approach taken by the chairman of the expert review group on the Constitution, Dr. Ken Whitaker, who laid out the correct approach very clearly. It is not Labour Party policy. Dr. Whitaker described exactly how he felt. Legislation could be drawn up in line with the X case that would not leave it open to abuse. That is a very serious proposal, but the Minister has ignored it.

Comment on this

I have not ignored it. I wonder why it has not yet emerged over the past ten years. Why did it not——

Comment on this

What is the Minister talking about?

Comment on this

The position of Deputy McManus is——

Comment on this

It is in the document that the Minister keeps quoting.

Comment on this

One alternative position that has been advanced is to legislate for the X case without the need for any constitutional amendment. It is worth reflecting on the fact that successive Governments, including a Government composed of different parties other than Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats, did not go down that route or attempt to produce a template in terms of legislating for the suicide risk or all the other issues in terms of the X case. This is key point.

Comment on this

That includes two Fianna Fáil Governments.

Comment on this

If people are arguing against a particular approach and saying to the Government that they think its approach is wrong, then those people have a responsibility to put forward an alternative proposition. That is all I am saying.

Comment on this

It is there.

Comment on this

It is not there.

Comment on this

It was outlined by Dr. Ken Whitaker.

Comment on this

The principle is outlined, but no political party has advanced any legislation.

Comment on this

The Minister has never explained why he refused that.

Comment on this

We did not do it, but we are not in Government.

Comment on this

The Deputies should deal with the substantive issue at hand.

Comment on this

We are not the ones bringing forward legislation.

Comment on this

Deputy Dukes mentioned the term——

Comment on this

That is the job of the Minister and he is making a hames of it.

Comment on this

Deputy Dukes said both sections have to be read harmoniously, alluding to the doctrine of harmony.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is new.

Comment on this

If the Deputy consulted some constitutional advisors, he would find it is not so new.

Comment on this

We will have to sing in tune.

Comment on this

Is Deputy McManus pressing the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes.

Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh na focail a thairgtear a scriosadh."

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 8
·
Níl 7
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Amendments Nos. 4 and 20 are related and are to be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

Tairgim leasú a 4:

I leathanach 6, líne 8, "tar éis ionphlandú" a chur isteach i ndiaidh "bhroinn".

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 7, line 7, after "womb" to insert "after implantation".

This is essentially a statement of fact. There is no protection for unborn life in the womb prior to implantation. Whether one is or is not concerned about that is not the issue I am putting forward although there are obviously very important questions relating to it. The overriding concern and criticism which has already emerged from our debate is the existence of ambiguities, confusion and possible contradictions and conflicts. One cannot say, as is stated in the Bill, that the life of the unborn in the womb shall be protected because for the purposes of this proposal, the life of the unborn has been qualified as meaning only after implantation. Article 40.3.3° of the Constitution does not have that qualification. Clearly what we are talking about here is the life of the unborn after implantation. Since that is the case, we should state it clearly in the Bill.

I know there are difficulties with regard to implantation about which Deputy Fitzgerald asked an interesting question. We are dealing to an extent with the unknowable. I note from the response of the Taoiseach that he agreed that at any given time the exact state of an ovum in the womb of a woman is largely unknowable. Be that as it may, the Government has chosen this point of departure. Some people were startled that the Attorney General appeared to be taking on St. Thomas Aquinas and all the other theologians who deliberated long and hard over when human life begins. Certainly, the papal view would be that this is not where human life begins. We need to be clear, therefore, in this legislation, which it is proposed to put into the Constitution, that it is human life in the womb only after implantation that we are talking about. That is the purpose of this amendment.

Let me refer briefly to amendment No. 20. In section 1(3) of the Second Schedule, "reasonable opinion" is defined as a reasonable opinion formed in good faith which has regard to the need to preserve unborn human life where practicable and of which a written record has been made and signed by the practitioner. However, we are not talking about human life in this Bill; we are talking about unborn human life after implantation in the womb and that is another issue because of the questions raised about in vitro fertilisation and the possibilities of experimentation and so on. The Minister should accept these amendments in order to be clear that in talking about unborn life he is not referring to it in the way Article 40.3.3° of the Constitution does but in the specific way he has determined, presumably for practical purposes, to define it. Otherwise, he is not being accurate.

I do not think we have any hope, but let me give the Minister a chance to prove me wrong. He will have to be much clearer about what he is talking about in presenting a Bill of this kind. Another example of where the Minister has had to catch up with himself is in terms of what is a medical practitioner, a very serious flaw in the Bill which is only now being addressed. This is a flaw that has the potential to cause quite a lot of trouble. I suggest that the Minister consider accepting the amendments.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Section 1 contains definitions of the terms "approved place", "medical practitioner" and "reasonable opinion". It even contains a definition of the term "woman". However, nowhere in the section, despite the fact that it introduces the word "implantation", is there a definition of that term. Further, the word "conception" is not even mentioned in Article 40.3.3°, let alone 40.3.4°. This is relevant and I must press the Minister on it. I gave the Minister an opportunity when I asked him about the morning-after pill and challenged what he said at his press conference but he did not reply and the record will show that. He said that this was turning around the law on the morning-after pill. It does no such thing but the Minister did not take the opportunity to correct that or to put on the record what he said at his press conference.

I ask the Minister specifically what are the implications of this for embryo and stem cell research? The Minister has said that the Supreme Court will read the various sections of the Constitution harmoniously - Article 40.3.3° will be affected by Article 40.3.4°. However, since Article 40.3.3° does not carry a definition of the term "unborn" or define when life begins, is it not possible that it may be adversely affected, from the point of view of pro-life people, by Article 40.3.4°, because when the Supreme Court looks harmoniously, as the Minister puts it, at the Constitution to interpret the meaning of those words, it will find no definition of the word "unborn" in Article 40.3.3° but will find a definition of when life begins from a criminal offence point of view in Article 40.3.4°.

The Minister said that section 1(1) of the Bill, which deals with implantation, will create the criminal offence of abortion for the purposes of the Act. I asked the Minister on Second Stage at what point the clock of life starts to run as far as a criminal offence is concerned. Furthermore, what is implantation? Why has the Minister not defined the term "implantation" in the Bill when he has defined the term "woman"? Is this not the essence of this legislation? How do we actually get to the point of the criminal offence the Minister says he is creating? When does it start? When does the clock of life start and when does it start to enjoy the protection of the Constitution in terms of the proposed criminal offence? What are the implications of this amendment for that? This is important and the Minister must spell it out because nowhere in Article 40.3.3°, as it exists, is it stated when life begins. The article refers to the unborn but there is no mention of conception.

Article 40.3.4° refers to implantation of the unborn and the criminal offence arising then. The Minister should deal with those questions because it seems from what he said in his earlier contributions that the Supreme Court will certainly take into account Article 40.3.4° when interpreting Article 40.3.3° and other sections of the Constitution. Otherwise, this principle of harmonious interpretation of the Constitution to which the Minister refers does not apply. I would like some clarification from the Minister on this. This issue did not just arise today. I asked the Minister about it on Second Stage in the House.

Comment on this

I commend Deputy McManus's amendment to the Minister, without prejudice to the questions raised by Deputy Mitchell, which are important. Definitions are essential here. I reflect in passing that nowhere do we have a definition of the term "unborn". Is an unfertilised ovum unborn? In a very real sense it is, but does it enjoy the protection of the Constitution? The answer is that we do not know because we do not have definitions.

The amendment Deputy McManus proposes is essential for the purposes of the Bill. In particular, it is essential to give meaning to section 1(1) of the Bill within the Bill which specifically refers to unborn human life after implantation in the womb. If we are to be sure that the constitutional provision which it is proposed to make can be read concurrently or harmoniously with the rest, this amendment is not only useful but essential to state clearly what the context is. It does not matter if we eventually do not pass this because if we do not pass the Bill within the Bill, the amendment to the Constitution is not made. It is another day's work to talk about that. However, if the Constitution is to be faithfully reflected in the law and if there is to be no possibility of conflict between them, when both speak of a given thing they should do so in the same way. Deputy McManus's amendment, in the context of what the Minister is trying to do, is essential to prevent later doubts or possible need for reinterpretation.

As I said, if we do not pass the Bill within the Bill, the proposed amendment to the Constitution fails. Will the Minister reflect on what the situation will be if we hold a referendum and the proposed amendments to the Constitution are made and the Oireachtas, having been presented with the text of this Bill within the Bill, decides not to pass it? What will happen? We will have a situation where the amendment to the Constitution for which the people voted is not made. It will fall because the people have prescribed a Bill that the Oireachtas should pass, but the Oireachtas, under the terms of the Government's proposal and in the proper discharge of its functions under the Constitution, has decided not to pass it. That could be presented as the Oireachtas giving the back of its hand to public opinion. The Minister is creating the real danger that this could happen. It could be an even greater danger depending on the timing.

If a referendum is passed in the lifetime of this misbegotten Government and the 180 day period for the passage of the Bill within the Bill happens at the dawning of the new life of the next Government, where there is a different majority in the Dáil and the Bill is not passed, it will be interesting to hear what members of the Fianna Fáil Party will say when they are unfettered by the privilege of being in opposition. There might be some honest commentary from them. What would be the situation then? The Minister will have created a right constitutional pickle. That comment is without prejudice to what I have just said about the amendment. The amendment is entirely consistent with the Minister's newly stated fondness for harmony and concurrence.

Comment on this

The case made for adding these words in the three sections under amendments Nos. 4 and 20 is crucial. By adding Article 40.3.4°, the Minister is adding another description of the life of the unborn and how it will be protected. The legislation within the amendment is the first time that the concept of implantation is mentioned. Until now, when people spoke about abortion or life they generally referred to conception. The Catholic Church always maintained that human life started at the point of conception. It will be interesting to discover the reason the Church has given no verdict on this legislation and it is waiting for the Minister to complete this rushed job before commenting on it. It is extraordinary. The Minister will be in direct conflict with the Catholic Church's professed definition of human life as commencing at the point of conception, not implantation. That is something he will have to handle when the Church comments on this legislation.

Earlier the Minister, in reply to Deputy Fitzgerald, said implantation is not an exact science. In other words, if there is fast implantation or a fast sperm moving along——

Comment on this

They are all fast here.

Comment on this

——there are only three days. If it is not a fast implantation or a medium one, there might be five days. I am making the argument in a ridiculous way. A doctor will have to make these decisions and if there is somebody——

Comment on this

They will not have any decision to make on that.

Comment on this

It will be a criminal offence——

Comment on this

There is a practical issue. Somebody who comes to the doctor will do so because she is pregnant. She will not imagine she is in three days.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Is the Minister suggesting that somebody is not pregnant until there is implantation?

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is not as simple as the Minister says.

Comment on this

Deputy Owen has the floor.

Comment on this

The purpose of this legislation is to create a criminal offence if somebody carries out an abortion after implantation. However, implantation cannot be defined in such a way as to say that, no matter who the person is and regardless of whether it occurs slowly or quickly, implantation will definitely have taken place in the wall of the uterus in exactly five days. What if somebody decides to challenge a doctor who is dispensing an IUD or a morning after pill? This can be done within up to ten days if implantation is slow or within three days if it is not slow.

Due to the Minister not defining implantation - he cannot do so because medical science will not let him - he is adding this uncertainty. However, if he is including implantation, the legislation has to define it. As Deputy Fitzgerald said when quoting from the Taoiseach's letter, as a matter of criminal law, there can be no presumption that it has or has not implanted in the womb. We are talking about whether an ovum is or is not fertilised at any given point or that it has or has not implanted in the womb. In response to how this applies to IUDs and the morning after pill the Taoiseach said that it is simply not possible to have a statutory criminal offence carrying a serious penalty for its infringement where its ordinary meaning for ordinary people in ordinary situations is left obscure and unknowable.

I am an ordinary person in an ordinary situation. I do not know at what point the dispensing of an IUD or a morning after pill, which is allowable before implantation, becomes a criminal offence. The Minister says he is using the word "implantation" to keep the two treatments legal and ensure somebody is not committing a crime if they take the morning after pill. However, if one does not know exactly when implantation takes place, the Taoiseach has said that, as a matter of criminal law, there can be no presumption that it has or has not implanted in the womb. The Minister is leaving a gap in the legislation should somebody want to get at a doctor who has prescribed the morning after pill or the IUD. The doctor could be open to somebody saying, "I know it was nine days or whatever." When the baby is born or should a baby be born, the person could trace back.

Comment on this

A baby is born.

Comment on this

Well, a baby should not be born. The Minister is leaving a gap as to what implantation means. Again, the word "unborn" is not defined. The Taoiseach referred in his letter to the right to life of the unborn and then included the phrase "however the unborn is to be defined." In other words, it is a case of have what one wants with regard to the definition of "unborn." It is not in Article 40.3.3° or this legislation. The Minister is sliding over these difficulties by saying that we are not redefining what "unborn" is. For God's sake, we have not defined it so, of course, the Minister is not redefining it. That is the whole problem - there is no definition.

Comment on this

No, we are defining unborn. That is the point.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

However, one cannot ignore things like what unborn means.

Comment on this

What about the harmony?

Comment on this

It states the legislation if enacted protects the "unborn human life after implantation in the womb of a woman".

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

But what about unborn human life before implantation? That sentence implies there is such a thing as unborn human life before implantation. That is what I believe the courts will examine. By saying it is unborn human life after implantation in the woman's womb, it presupposes there is also unborn human life before implantation. That is the way I would interpret it, although I am not a lawyer. By using such expressions, the Minister is leaving open the interpretation and could be accused of allowing abortions. That is why the people who think they want this amendment are against it as well; they see these difficulties with it.

Comment on this

I wish to inform the committee that we have gone over the time. I have two further speakers who wish to address the amendment. It is a matter for the committee whether it wishes to allow both of them to make their contributions and hear the Minster's response. Is it agreed that we continue for 30 minutes?

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Fifteen minutes.

Comment on this

Fifteen minutes, okay.

Comment on this

I have a concern that I wish to express after the Minister's reply.

Comment on this

I cannot speak with any authority on Deputy McManus's proposed amendment. I presume the Minister will be able to respond to it. I am a bit concerned that we are being warned, on the one hand, that we are in direct conflict with the Catholic Church's teaching on conception.

Comment on this

It was not a warning.

Comment on this

On the other hand, that is not what should dictate the legislation anyway. I am more deeply concerned by the fact - if I understand what Deputy Dukes said - that if the people decide to pass this referendum, and there is a change of Government, whatever Government comes into power after that would not obey what we describe as the supremacy of the people. The people are supreme, so I find that most disconcerting. People can disagree with this legislation and can vote against the referendum, but it is wrong for Members of the Oireachtas to say that if the people pass it, another Administration might ignore the specific——

Comment on this

It is the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

The people are supreme.

Comment on this

It is the Oireachtas. It is a law.

Comment on this

The Deputy stated that if the referendum is passed, the Oireachtas might decide not to pass it.

Comment on this

The text says that if a law is enacted by the Oireachtas——

Comment on this

My understanding is that any power that comes to the Oireachtas, comes from the people. The people are supreme but the Deputy is saying that even if this referendum is passed a future Administration——

Comment on this

Oireachtas.

Comment on this

——Oireachtas might decide not to pass it.

Comment on this

That is sensibly envisaged.

Comment on this

That is envisaged.

Comment on this

So, is that the Deputy's view?

Comment on this

That is specifically envisaged.

Comment on this

I think the Minister covered the other point. My understanding is that any of the agencies who administer the morning-after pill will warn people who are thinking of using it that it is only effective, and should only be used, within 72 hours. I presume the Minister will be able to confirm that. I am not aware that anyone would seek to have an IUD inserted in order to produce an abortion. The definition of abortion is quite clear and, therefore, somebody who carried out the procedure not knowing that would be the effect, would not be guilty of carrying out an abortion. That is the situation as I read it.

Comment on this

It is evident that the extent of the pig in a poke the Minister is selling us is not fully realised.

Comment on this

Deputy Dukes is straying into agricultural matters.

Comment on this

To take up the point made by Deputy McGennis, it is my clear understanding that Catholic teaching is very precise on this - that human life does begin at conception. I am sure many Deputies have received correspondence about it. That is the worry of those who perceive themselves as being the real pro-life people. We require definitions, yet there is no definition of "unborn human life". Deputy Dukes is quite right in asking whether an ovum is unborn human life. We could get into absurd "every sperm is sacred" Monty Python-type territory if we wanted.

Comment on this

Woody Allen.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Where is the harmony now?

Comment on this

Get the video out at the weekend.

Comment on this

To revert to a more serious note, Deputy McManus is trying to get a little bit of clarity and consistency, and that is commendable. I want to put a serious question to the Minister and I do not think we should be ducking this issue. If the Minister could pay attention just for a moment, is it his intention to commit the destruction of unborn human life prior to implantation? Is that what we are talking about? Let us be clear about this. What we are talking about here is the morning after pill which we know is in widespread use. We also know there would be even more abortions in England if it was not used. We need to face up to reality. Is this the Government's intention? Would it not be better simply to legalise the morning after pill? Will the legislation achieve that for the Minister? We need clarification on that point, Minister. There is too much hedging going on. We need to face up to the reality, as the pro-life people are saying, that human life begins at conception, and the morning after pill involves the taking of unborn life as far as they are concerned.

Comment on this

Since we have now entered this territory, I want to express my concern. I am not so much concerned about the protection of medical practitioners, although obviously that is an important part of the work we are doing. I am considering the position of a woman whose pregnancy test proves positive. Nowadays, pregnancy tests are more accurate, and at a much earlier stage, than they were when I was pregnant. Women can know extremely early on that they are pregnant and they can deal with it at a very early stage. Since it is now possible, and will increasingly be so, for women to cause their own abortions - doctors will largely be out of the equation - I want the Minister to deal with that context. A woman who finds herself pregnant may not have a clue as to whether or not implantation has taken place. How would she know and why would she care? That is not what she is worried about. She gets the pill that deals with the pregnancy from the Internet, takes it, carries out the abortion and could end up facing a judge and the possibility of serving 12 years in jail. That is what concerns me.

Comment on this

As regards the amendment, the scope of the protection that will be provided as a result of the enactment of the Bill is described in the text, hence the words "after implantation". It is not necessary to build this into the Constitution, as Deputy McManus's amendment attempts to do. Our approach has been to have the specific, necessary detail in the legislation and not in the Constitution. That is consistent with the arguments of all the Deputies who spoke in the earlier part of the debate this afternoon.

I do not see the necessity for amendment No. 20, but, with respect, I will undertake to reflect upon it between now and Report Stage.

Comment on this

What is the Minister going to look at again?

Comment on this

I will look again at amendmentNo. 20 which seeks to insert the words "(after implantation in the womb)".

Deputy Dukes raised the issue of what would happen if the Oireachtas did not decide to legislate after the constitutional amendment was passed, but that is very clearly laid out. This will be put to the people. If such a law is not enacted within 180 days of this section being added to the Constitution, the section shall cease to have effect and shall be omitted from every official text of the Constitution published thereafter. That is what will happen.

Comment on this

What would be the effect of that?

Comment on this

The effect would be significant because the will of the people would be subverted by the Legislature.

Comment on this

That is because of the way the Minister has written it.

Comment on this

That is a matter for the Legislature of the day. It is a matter for every individual legislator but I would never attempt to subvert the will of the people as a legislator. If others want to do that——

Comment on this

The Minister is doing so. In 1992 the people passed a referendum and the Minister is trying to subvert it here.

Comment on this

This is going before——

Comment on this

The Minister is doing so.

Comment on this

This is going before the people, not over their heads. The people ultimately will decide on this, not me or anyone around here.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Will the Minister answer all the questions he was asked?

Comment on this

Yes. Will the Deputy give me a chance?

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister went straight to the political question but there are other ones.

Comment on this

No, I did not.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I gave the Minister the opportunity twice to answer them but he still has not done so. The record will show that.

Comment on this

I apologise. I think someone asked about embryo research.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I asked the Minister about the implications of this and the harmonious——

Comment on this

This Bill does not deal with embryo research. It does not encapsulate either the regulation of assisted human reproduction——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I asked the Minister what are the implications.

Comment on this

There are none because we are not——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I asked the Minister for the definition of "implantation".

Comment on this

There are many points there which I will take one by one. The Deputy also asked about the clock of life and I will come back to that shortly. I would like to make the point in terms of embryo research——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I asked about Article 40.3.4° as against Article 40.3.3°.

Comment on this

Approximately one year ago I established a commission headed by Professor Dervilla Donnelly——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

That was number 66.

Comment on this

If Deputy Mitchell can sort out assisted human reproduction, I will give him the floor.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am not putting forward the legislation.

Comment on this

I am not being facetious but if the Deputy can sort out that one overnight without some commission with expertise——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is the Minister's job to justify the legislation to us.

Comment on this

Over to Deputy Mitchell.

Comment on this

Gentlemen.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is the Minister's job.

Comment on this

It is a very complex area.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

If the Minister wants us to vote for this legislation, he should explain to us what it contains.

Comment on this

I am saying——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister should have explained it to the four Independent Deputies when they came knocking on his door.

Comment on this

This legislation, as we have clearly stated from the outset, has not been designed with a view to resolving the issues pertaining to assisted human reproduction. There is no question that those issues are very complex. Developments are ongoing internationally. We have appointed an expert committee with people from different fields of expertise to produce a report for us. I will share that report with the Oireachtas - I have no problem with that. That is the context, framework and the process within which we will deal with the issue of assisted human reproduction. I respectfully suggest this is the only process in which one could realistically do so.

Comment on this

It is not exclusive to unborn life, or potential unborn life.

Comment on this

Could I be allowed——

Comment on this

I am sorry, I could not contain myself.

Comment on this

This is a debating arena in which people have made points to which I am responding.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister is not responding. That is the point.

Comment on this

Please allow the Minister to respond.

Comment on this

Deputy Mitchell raised the issue of when the clock of life begins. I think Deputy Owen referred to this issue as well. We have been very clear from the outset that the Act to protect human life in pregnancy does not define human life. We have made that very clear. We are not about defining human life.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

When does a criminal offence commence?

Comment on this

We are about defining abortion and the criminal statute. We are updating and modernising the law in relation to abortion and we are prohibiting abortion. We have provided a definition of abortion in the Act.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister is not. He is creating a criminal offence of abortion but he is not telling us when the criminal offence commences and when the clock starts to run.

Comment on this

We are saying in this Act that abortion means the intentional destruction by any means of unborn human life after implantation in the womb.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

When does that happen? We know when conception happens but when does implantation happen? The Minister is not telling us.

Comment on this

Let the Minister speak.

Comment on this

The intention of the morning after pill and IUDs is to prevent implantation. They are not abortafacients and have never been described to me as such. On Deputy McManus's point on that question——

Comment on this

The IMB——

Comment on this

It has sought legal opinion on it and I understand it will legalise that particular product.

Comment on this

It is an amazing coincidence.

Comment on this

I had no influence one way or the other and I can put that on record. I would not even attempt to have influence.

Comment on this

I am impressed.

Comment on this

In terms of drugs that may come on the market, there are drugs that can be used by women to self-induce an abortion. RU-486 is one such drug which operates much later than the period of implantation. That would be illegal in the context of——

Comment on this

That does not answer my question.

Comment on this

It would be illegal under the Act. It would be an offence.

Comment on this

I did not ask about the drug. I asked if a woman takes a drug she gets from the Internet without knowing whether implantation has occurred, is she running the risk of appearing before a judge and of a 12 year prison sentence?

Comment on this

There is a whole area dealing with the committal of the offence and so on and there are many issues about assumptions being rebutted, reasonable opinion, people knowingly doing things and so on which are dealt with in the Bill.

Comment on this

She knows what she is doing but she does not know when implantation occurs.

Comment on this

With respect, the Deputy just said the woman did not know.

Comment on this

Clearly, women do not know when implantation takes place.

Comment on this

That was not what Deputy McManus said.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that if a woman goes into court and says she does not know when implantation takes place, she can always have an abortion?

Comment on this

There is a process and a framework there in which these issues will be arbitrated on in terms of any offences that will be prosecuted.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

In the courts, obviously.

Comment on this

How?

Comment on this

With respect——

Comment on this

So she does run the risk of appearing in court.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know what happens when somebody takes that drug? I do not want to be graphic but how does one prove implantation?

Comment on this

The issue here is abortion. We have accepted from day one that this is not an exact situation.

Comment on this

The Minister is criminalising women who might take that drug without knowing when implantation takes place.

Comment on this

I know what is being raised here, Chairman. This is a classic attempt to stereotype and to bandy about the phrase "criminalises". Every Deputy on this committee knows the existing legislation, the Offences Against the Person Act, over which every Deputy here whose party has been in Government has presided, which contained life imprisonment for any woman in an abortion scenario. Let us get rid of the "I am criminalising it and those opposite are not" type of hypocrisy that has been going on for some time in this debate and to which I take offence. It has been the feature of the Legislature that we have presided over that scenario and over an Act that is 140 years old. That Act has much stronger and stiffer penalties than anything proposed in this Bill.

Regarding Deputy McManus's question, there is a clear definition here in terms of what is prohibited in the Act. If anyone wants to prosecute on the basis that an offence has been committed, he or she must do so with reference to due process. People are presumed innocent until proven guilty and people can defend and rebut arguments. It would depend on the particular circumstances of a case.

Comment on this

Inherent in the Minister's approach is that when a woman says she is suicidal, the Minister does not believe her.

Comment on this

The Deputy is stereotyping again——

Comment on this

I am sorry but I have heard this over and over again——

Comment on this

——and she is endeavouring to categorise, classify and emotionally blackmail people. That is wrong.

Comment on this

——from Deputies from the Minister's party who say they will not believe women when they say they are suicidal.

Comment on this

No, I am not saying——

Comment on this

Is the Minister telling me that if a woman goes to court, her word will always be accepted?

Comment on this

I am not saying that. That is polemic yet again.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister is doing in this Bill.

Comment on this

It is a consistent attempt by the Deputy to politicise the debate and to introduce emotional blackmail into it, not to deal with it rationally and with some degree of a logical thought process.

Comment on this

This is not a school debate.

Comment on this

I will not stand for that.

Comment on this

This is a matter of women's lives. This is not a school debate.

Comment on this

We have gone past 4.15 p.m, so I will adjourn the meeting until 10 a.m. tomorrow.

Tugadh tuairisc ar a ndearnadh; an Coiste do shuí arís.

Comment on this