Nurses and Midwives Bill 2010: Committee Stage
Contributions 1–134 of 271. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 16 of 2010 ›
I welcome the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Harney, and her officials. The suggested timeframe for our deliberations is that we continue until 1.30 p.m. at the very latest. One hopes that with everyone's co-operation, notwithstanding the importance of the matters before the committee, members can conclude their deliberations within that timeframe. A briefing note and an amendment list have been circulated to members for their information.
I must step out of the meeting at approximately 11.30 a.m. Is it agreed that Deputy Conlon will then take the Chair? Agreed.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 1, 7, 8, 12, 14, 15, 38, 40, 42 to 53, inclusive, and 56 to 58, inclusive, have been grouped and will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 10, subsection (1), to delete lines 6 to 20.
I will outline briefly the rationale for the removal through these amendments of the provisions dealing with the regulation of advanced nurse-midwife practitioners and related posts. The Bill currently provides for the registration of advanced midwife practitioners and advanced nurse posts and the registration of advanced nurse-midwife practitioners, including a link between a post in employment and the individual, as well as protection of these titles. These provisions were included to formalise the arrangements that had been operated for a number of years by the national council. They were designed to ensure patient safety by setting the necessary independent national standard structures and criteria for both the posts and the individuals who occupied them. The purpose of registering the post was driven by the fact that it was always considered to be essential that the advanced practitioner would be facilitated with all the necessary supports and governance arrangements when engaging in advanced practice.
Following the Second Stage debate and on foot of representations from all sides of the House, I have had these provisions re-examined. An Bord Altranais, the regulatory body for nurses; the Health Service Executive; the Irish Association of Directors of Nursing and Midwifery; the unions representing the nursing professionals and so on considered the provisions to be unnecessary and that more appropriate arrangements could be put in place to ensure the necessary regulatory framework. It was argued by the relevant stakeholders that the envisaged provisions would be unique to Ireland. There was a particular concern regarding the provisions that required an advanced practitioner to be employed or to have an offer of employment in an advanced practitioner post before he or she could be registered as an advanced practitioner in the register of nurses and midwives. It was strongly believed that these provisions were unnecessary, lacked flexibility and could cause difficulties in terms of, for example, succession planning.
Having considered the representations, I propose to remove the provisions on advance practice, both to advanced nurse-midwife practice posts and the individuals concerned. As an alternative, it is intended that the board will regulate the individual advanced nurse-midwife practitioners in public and private health care settings by setting the requirements and standards with the education programmes, the practice standards and the necessary scope of practice relevant to those practitioners. It is intended that the HSE will have a central role in ensuring the necessary governance arrangements are in place for advanced posts for the public health sector. It is envisaged that, in the future, that will form part of the licensing and broadening of the Health Information and Quality Authority's remit to the private sector. The proposed amendments and deletions collectively provide for the removal from the Bill of all the relevant provisions and, therefore, deal with the Opposition Deputies' amendments in this instance.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister's opening statement. So many amendments were necessary at the outset because people had significant concerns about over-regulation and the fact that, had the Bill been passed as drafted, certain people would not have been registered and, as such, would not have had the cover of legislation. Clearly, the Department has been listening to the groups involved and there has been a significant level of discussion. I hope we can proceed in the same way.
Comment on this
We are discussing amendment No. 1 together with the 22 other grouped amendments. Deputy Reilly might care to address those matters.
Comment on this
What we are doing is decoupling the person from the need to have the post, which was a strong opinion put forward by the Deputies opposite, members of the Government parties, An Bord Altranais, the HSE and the unions representing the different branches of the nursing profession. Some time ago, I held a large meeting in my office to discuss this issue because the level of representation was so high. The large number of amendments reflects the outcome of those discussions.
Comment on this
If amendment No. 2 is agreed, amendment No. 3 cannot be moved. Amendments Nos. 2, 3, 11 and 16 are being grouped and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 10, subsection (1), to delete lines 33 to 42.
Comment on this
Our amendment No. 3 proposes, in page 10, subsection (1), to delete lines 32 and 43 and substitute the following:
" "clinical supervising authority" in relation to a midwife, means a person or body which the Board appoints under the rules to be the clinical supervising authority, after consulting the midwife concerned, not being the midwife's direct employer;
I hope the Minister will understand our argument, which is straightforward. Having one's direct employer deal with an issue like this is difficult. Since the Bill refers to the board and how it will deal with procedures, our amendment seems to be more practical than anything else. I hope the Minister will view it in that respect.
Comment on this
Given my amendment, amendment No. 3 is unnecessary, as it would achieve the same thing. I agree with the Deputy in that respect.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4.
In page 12, subsection (1), line 13, to delete "name is entered in the nurses division of the" and substitute "name is entered in the".
This is a technical amendment to amend the definition of "registered nurse" by removing the reference to "nurses division". This only applies to nurses with Part 8 registration and was a technical matter drawn to our attention.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 13, lines 21 to 27, to delete subsections (3) and (4).
These are drafting amendments proposed by the Parliamentary Counsel to improve the structure of the Bill. They provide for the removal of subsections (3) and (4) from section 4. Instead, a new section is being created that will contain the construction of all references, including the construction of two deleted references from section 4.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 15, lines 31 and 32, to delete all words from and including "the" where it thirdly occurs in line 31 down to and including "and" where it secondly occurs in line 32 and substitute the following:
"the promotion of excellence in nursing and midwifery and the protection of the public in connection therewith and".
The wording of the Bill is overly politically correct, if one can be overly politically correct in the Chamber. Apart from exceptional circumstances, which thankfully are rare, most midwives and nurses work to the benefit of the patient, but the Bill starts off by saying that the public must be protected. The amendment is about the language more than anything else.
Comment on this
The main purpose of the Bill is the protection of the public. It is a regulatory body for nurses. The Deputy's amendment would delete the provision on the protection of the public. However, I am prepared to examine the matter on Report Stage, as we could incorporate the provision on excellence without getting rid of the main purpose of the Bill. I was sympathetic when I saw the wording, but I do not want to delete the main purpose, which is the protection of the public. That is in order.
Comment on this
We do not want the Minister to do that.
Comment on this
I will revert to the matter on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. If I could recommit on Report Stage, I would be prepared to let the amendment go.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 16, subsection (2), to delete lines 1 to 5, and substitute the following:
"(a) establish and maintain the register of nurses and midwives and the candidate register,
(b) establish procedures and criteria for assessment and registration in the register of nurses and midwives and the candidate register, and the”.
The proposed amendment imposes a statutory obligation on the board to produce a code of professional conduct for nurses and midwives. This code will enhance the protection of the public by outlining clearly the professional conduct expected from nurses and midwives. Members may remember the references on Second Stage to disciplinary procedures for inappropriate behaviour. People had real issues with the provision, so we are deleting it. There will be a reference later on. The code of practice allows us to be able to delete the reference to inappropriate behaviour, so nurses will be obliged to abide by a code of professional practice, which everyone would regard as acceptable.
Comment on this
Due to the agreement of amendment No. 7, amendment No. 8 in the names of Deputies Kathleen Lynch and Jan O'Sullivan cannot be moved.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 16, subsection (2)(e)(i), line 16, to delete “States” and substitute the following:
"States or other relevant states within the meaning of the Regulations of 2008".
This is a technical amendment to ensure that the mutual recognition of professional qualifications of nurses and midwives reflects the states covered by EU Directive 2005/36/EC, which is transposed by SI 164 of 2008 on the recognition of the professional qualifications of nurses of midwives.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 16, subsection (2)(g), to delete lines 35 to 39 and substitute the following:
"registered midwives, including the establishment, publication, maintenance and review of—
(i) appropriate guidance on all matters related to professional conduct and ethics for registered nurses and registered midwives,
(ii) appropriate guidance on the maintenance of the professional competence of registered nurses and registered midwives, and
(iii) a code of professional conduct for registered nurses and registered midwives,".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 17, subsection (2)(l), lines 6 to 11, to delete all words from and including “of” in line 6 down to and including “and” in line 11 and substitute “of this Act, and”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 19, subsection (2)(b), to delete line 13 and substitute “midwives and the candidate”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 19, subsection (2)(b), line 14, to delete “be maintained” and substitute “be established and maintained”.
This amendment clarifies that the board's power to make rules on the formal manner of the register includes how the register will be established in addition to maintaining those registers.
Comment on this
I move amend No. 14:
In page 19, subsection (2)(I), lines 33 and 34, to delete all words from and including “midwives,” in line 33 down to and including “posts” in line 34 and substitute “midwives and the candidate”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 19, subsection (2)(k), lines 42 and 43, to delete all words from and including “nurses” in line 42 down to and including “posts” in line 43 and substitute “nurses and midwives or the candidate”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 20, subsection (2), lines 4 to 12, to delete paragraph (n) and substitute the following:
"(n) the specification of standard governance frameworks for midwives, including the requirement for indemnity insurance for midwives,”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 17, 18 and 22 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17 :
In page 20, subsection (4)(c), to delete lines 39 and 40.
The IMO makes the argument, and it is well made, that the concept of linking membership of a register to holding a post is not an appropriate model. The Minister was sympathetic to this in her opening statement.
Comment on this
Are we discussing amendment No. 17?
Comment on this
Amendment No. 17 has to do with the requirement for the Minister for Finance to approve draft rules, which is common throughout the Government. If rules are to have an impact on the public finances I am afraid the Minister for Finance of the day - as has been common for many years - will have to at least see those proposals and, with the Minister for Health and Children, approve them. The purpose of the amendment is to delete the reference to the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot do that; I am not free to do so. It would be unfair of any line Minister to introduce a proposal that had implications for the public finances without the approval of the line Minister who would have to make money available, namely, the Minister for Finance. It is common throughout legislation. It is not only in this area that it happens.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 21, subsection (6), line 6, to delete "and the Minister for Finance".
Comment on this
The same applies to this amendment as to amendment No. 17 as they are related.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 23, line 15, to delete "indictable".
Comment on this
I cannot accept this amendment as it would require the CEO of the board to notify the Garda or the Director of Corporate Enforcement with regard to a minor offence. The purpose of the Bill is that the Garda be informed of an indictable offence or that the Director of Corporate Enforcement be informed in the case of a nurse running a nursing home. However, for something minor it would be unnecessary and unfair. It would lead to much time being wasted by the Garda and the Director of Corporate Enforcement. The idea is that where the board becomes aware of a serious matter which would be an indictable offence it has an obligation to inform the authorities, which would include the Garda and the Director of Corporate Enforcement. If it were a more minor matter then that obligation would not be on it.
Comment on this
The concern is about who determines what is a minor matter.
Comment on this
An indictable offence is specified; it would be a possible criminal matter. A minor offence could be not keeping books or the books not being in order - I am talking off the top of my head - and to require the CEO of An Bord Altranais every time something comes to his or her attention about a nurse or midwife to have to go to the Garda or the Director of Corporate Enforcement is unnecessary. Many of the issues that might be brought to his or her attention could be very minor. It would also be unfair on the professionals, to be honest.
We need to have a sense of perspective and perhaps the intent was misunderstood. The idea is that where something serious that is indictable which could carry a prison sentence comes to the board's attention it should be brought to the attention of the Garda or the Director of Corporate Enforcement at the earliest possible opportunity. However, where it is something relatively minor, and many complaints are minor and sometimes do not stand up when they are properly examined, it would be unfair to put that onus on the CEO of the board or have the nurse who is the subject of a minor complaint subject to inquiry by the Garda or the Director of Corporate Enforcement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 24, subsection (1)(a), line 23, before “prepare” to insert the following:
"following consultation with the nursing and midwifery professions in a form and manner decided by the Board,"
Comment on this
I am sympathetic to this amendment and I will consider it prior to Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 27, subsection (1), line 39, after "Minister" to insert the following:
"subject to the approval of a joint Oireachtas committee assigned the role of examining matters relating to health and children".
This country has had a long history of self-confessed explanations of how people have ended up on boards because they happen to be friends with someone as opposed to having any particular competence or skill. To ensure transparency, appointments of this nature should come through an Oireachtas committee and in this case the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Health and Children would be the appropriate forum. It would be to ratify and to ensure the appropriate people are appointed.
Comment on this
Two issues are raised. Many of the board members will be elected by various branches of the nursing profession. However, public interest people will be appointed by the Minister and I am happy to consider this prior to Report Stage. I do not disagree with Deputy Reilly. I would like to think the people we appoint would be acceptable to everybody.
Comment on this
I accept what the Minister has stated.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 22, 24, 79 and 81 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 27, subsection (1)(a), line 46, to delete “and Science” and substitute “and Skills”.
These amendments are to take account of the changed name of the Department of Education and Science to the Department of Education and Skills.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 28, subsection (1)(d), line 38, to delete “Act 2007” and substitute the following:
"Act 2007 and who is not and never has been a registered nurse or registered midwife in the State or in another jurisdiction".
Section 22 provides for some members of the board to be nominated by a variety of stakeholders and bodies. In particular, section 22(1)(d) provides for one person to be nominated by the Medical Council whose name is entered on the register of the medical practitioners maintained under the Medical Practitioners Act. We want to ensure this is not somebody who was nurse and then became a doctor because the idea is to have a non-nurse lay majority. It is a technical issue.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 28, subsection (1)(e), line 40, to delete “Science from” and substitute “Skills from”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 29, subsection (1)(j)(ii), line 26, after “appropriate,” to insert the following:
"and after receiving the approval of a committee of the Houses of the Oireachtas designated by the Houses for that purpose,".
Comment on this
It concerns an indictable offence. I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I accept what the Minister has said.
Comment on this
Could we have some clarification on this?
Comment on this
We have already discussed it but I will allow the Deputy to contribute if he is brief.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated when speaking on amendment No. 21 that she would be sympathetic to this amendment.
Comment on this
We will come back to it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Yes, I will come back to it on Report Stage. There are two different amendments, with one relating to the public interest and the other relating to everybody else. We should accept those elected by the profession. With regard to those subject to nomination by the Minister, I am happy for them to come back to the Oireachtas committee. I will come back with a Report Stage amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
In page 29, lines 28 to 30, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following:
"(2) At its first meeting, the Board shall elect a person to the position of President of the Board for the first term mentioned in the Schedule.".
It is very important that there be no hint of political interference or influence with a statutory body like this. For the Minister to have the right to appoint the chair would not apply in the Medical Council or other councils I am aware of. This is not sending the right signal. I contend it would be better for the board to elect the president or chairperson.
Comment on this
I am happy to have a look at this and I am open to suggestion. I assure the Deputy that the intention was not to have any political interference; it came from the strong advice from people that the new board would see major transformation in terms of function. It is not an unreasonable amendment and I will either accept it or come back on Report Stage once we have a look at it.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 27 is the names of Deputies Jan O'Sullivan and Kathleen Lynch. Amendment No. 35 is related and both amendments may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 29, subsection (5)(b), lines 44 and 45, to delete
", or
(c) a member of a local authority.”.
Comment on this
It is self-explanatory and refers to the removal of any kind of political input into committees. I am not a person who believes these should be overly political but we should ultimately have the best people for the job. Somebody must speak up for the political process.
Comment on this
I have mixed views on this. We spoke earlier about the politicisation of the board and the issue arises as to whether a politician should be capable of being elected to the board or an employee of the board. It is common to medical practitioners and health Acts, as well as many other pieces of legislation. It is something councillors in particular feel strongly about and perhaps we could reflect on the amendment. We might distinguish between the board and employees of the board. It is preferable for the board to consist of independent people rather than be aligned to a political cause. That is my view, which is probably the view of the professions.
I agree with the Deputy that there is a large number of councillors in our community, some of whom are active in this space. Could we agree to reflect on the matter between now and Report Stage? There are mixed views on this.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 28 is in the names of Deputies Jan O'Sullivan and Kathleen Lynch. Amendments Nos. 29 and 30 are related, therefore, amendments Nos. 28 to 30, inclusive may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 30, subsection (2)(b), line 23, after “complaints,” to insert the following:
"which shall include a Registered Nurse in any case where the complaint relates to a nurse, and which shall include a Registered Midwife in any case where the complaint relates to a midwife,".
Comment on this
This grouping takes in amendments Nos. 28 to 30, inclusive. Deputy Reilly has put forward amendment No. 30. I am sympathetic to these amendments and I would like to return to them on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I spoke to a constituent yesterday who was worried because she has four children, with three born at home. She wants to know if this excludes midwives when women choose to have children at home.
Comment on this
I am sorry if this is the wrong time.
Comment on this
They must have appropriate insurance but we will deal with it later. We are bringing them in under this legislation so that when somebody has a birth at home, if something goes wrong the patient should be appropriately insured. We are not excluding midwives.
Comment on this
No, but there must be appropriate supervision and insurance. The Deputy does not need me to tell him that if there is a serious brain injury at birth, there are significant sums paid out in court. If somebody is at home in that kind of position with no insurance, the mother and family will be extremely vulnerable. We cannot leave it unregulated.
Comment on this
The choice still exists under certain regulations.
Comment on this
If there are appropriate regulations and insurance, the choice remains. I should have said that amendment No. 29 deals with being a member of a board. All boards, including the Medical Council, would need flexibility to bring people into sub-committees. The onus of work is such that it is not possible to get board members to sit at all the hearings. We are providing for the Medical Council to have people on sub-committees who are not members of the board. That would be the intent of the first amendment and Deputy Reilly's amendment, but amendment No. 29 would prohibit that. The strong advice is the amendment is too restrictive. The process of the Medical Council is working well.
Comment on this
I will come back on Report Stage to deal with the issues in amendments Nos. 28 and 30.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 31 is in the name of the Minister. Amendment No. 34 is related and both amendments may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In page 35, subsection (1), line 3, to delete "shall appoint a" and substitute the following:
"shall appoint a person recruited in accordance with the Public Service Management (Recruitment and Appointments) Act 2004 to be the".
These are technical amendments providing that both the CEO and the employees are to be appointed in accordance with the Public Service Management (Recruitment and Appointments) Act 2004.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 32 is in the names of Deputies Jan O'Sullivan, Kathleen Lynch and Reilly. Amendment No. 33 is an alternative and both amendments may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 36, lines 5 to 9, to delete subsection (6).
This subsection looks to gag the CEO, as it stipulates that he or she shall not question or express an opinion on the merits of any policy of the Government or a Minister, or the merits of the objectives of such a policy. This is a statutory body which is meant to protect patients and if there is something inherently wrong with the Government's policy that causes problems for the profession or is endangering patients, he or she would have a duty to speak. I do not see how we can gag the CEO and it does not seem appropriate. It does not give any impression of transparency.
Comment on this
Our amendment is virtually the same. I do not know of any CEO with an agenda to damage his or her organisation; CEOs are usually very protective of their organisations and this stipulation is being a bit overbearing. We must trust people placed in positions of responsibility.
Comment on this
This applies when the CEO comes before the Committee of Public Accounts. When the CEO of any public body comes before that committee he or she is in the role of Accounting Officer. Such people are not policy makers. There is nothing wrong with a CEO coming to this committee and giving an opinion but this simply refers to the role under the Committee of Public Accounts. Amendment No. 33 makes it clear that this relates to the accounting function, where the CEO accounts for money rather than any views on policy. The original Bill contained an error and had a more wide-ranging impact.
Comment on this
I am sorry to cut across the Minister.
Comment on this
It relates to the giving of evidence to the Committee on Public Accounts. It states:
The chief executive officer shall be the accountable person in relation to the accounts of the Board and shall, whenever required in writing to do so by the Committee of Dáil Éireann established under the Standing Orders of Dáil Éireann to examine and report to Dáil Éireann on the appropriation accounts and reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General, give evidence to that Committee...
That is not unreasonable. The CEO of the HSE comes here to give his views, as do the CEOs of other organisations. They are not limited in what they can say. This is a regulatory body, so the CEO will come before the Committee of Public Accounts when required to do so and speak on the accounting function.
Comment on this
That is a reasonable explanation. I know that neither the Minister nor the Department does the drafting of the Bill. I wonder whether that section could be made a little clearer, not in terms of the Committee of Public Accounts, but in stating that there is nothing to restrict the CEO from coming before another committee of the Oireachtas. I do not think we are disagreeing.
Comment on this
I am well disposed to what the Minister is talking about, but I ask her indulgence in telling us what the section will state when the amendment is incorporated.
Comment on this
The purpose of the board is to regulate the nursing profession.
Comment on this
We accept that, but what I am asking-----
Comment on this
If this committee invited the CEOs of the Medical Council, An Bord Altranais or the Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland to appear before it, one would find they would be forthcoming with their views on a wide range of issues to do with the regulation of the profession. However, the provisions in the Bill apply when the CEO comes before the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
The subsection only intimates that it relates to the Committee of Public Accounts. It does not mention the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
Not in that subsection. That is the difficulty.
Comment on this
Could we come back to this on Report Stage as we did with other amendments?
Comment on this
If they want to table an amendment on Report Stage they may do so.
Comment on this
I am seeking clarity. The difficulty is-----
Comment on this
Clarity as opposed to chaos. The Deputy will find that the CEOs of regulatory bodies are accountable to the body that appoints them, and they are very circumspect and careful. Their first responsibility is not to the line Minister. Other than passing this legislation, the Minister of the day has little function with regard to how regulatory bodies operate. People are often surprised that I hear about an inquiry into Dr. A or Dr. B by the Medical Council through the media. I do not know about these things, nor should I. That body operates totally independently of the Minister, and that is how it should be. It is the same with An Bord Altranais. I am not aware of what the board is doing on a day-to-day basis. Board members are aware of what goes on, as are the executives. In that sense, they operate totally professionally and independently, and that is how it should be.
Comment on this
What about the drafting of the Bill?
Comment on this
An Bord Altranais made many submissions on this legislation. These are available under the Freedom of Information Act and I would be happy to make them available to this committee. I am sure members of the board would be happy to come before the committee and talk about them if they were asked. There is no restriction whatever. We are not trying to gag anyone, there is no question of that. We are trying to ensure the functions are clear with regard to the responsibility of the CEO as an Accounting Officer before the Committee of Public Accounts.
Comment on this
I will not press my amendment but I ask the Minister, rather than pressing her amendment, to wait until Report Stage so we can consider the wording in a more calm environment. There might be a need for an extra line or something similar. I ask her to indulge us.
Comment on this
Do I take it, therefore, that amendment No. 32 is withdrawn, with the prospect of its being resubmitted on Report Stage?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
In page 36, subsection (6), line 6, to delete "under this section" and substitute "under subsection (5)".
This does not prohibit Members from tabling another amendment on Report Stage if they want to have this discussion again. Our aim is to bring greater clarity to the provisions, so we should do so at this point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:
In page 36, subsection (1), line 11, to delete "persons to be employees" and substitute the following:
"persons recruited in accordance with the Public Service Management (Recruitment and Appointments) Act 2004 to be employees".
Comment on this
It seems ironic that in a week when France has been brought almost to a standstill by protests over the raising of the retirement age to 62, we are here talking about the imposition of retirement at 65 and the withdrawal of employment rights from people who stay on after that. The entire section relates to this. In this day and age, the freedom to continue in one's profession is important, particularly in view of the expertise that is built up over the years. This Bill allows for additional expertise to be gained. We oppose this section.
Comment on this
These are standard provisions across the public service. For anyone who has joined since 2004, the age limit of 65 years does not apply, as it has been increased. For anyone who joined before 2004, the age limit of 65 applies. The Minister may make an order increasing that; I recently increased the retirement age for GPs in the GMS scheme, for example. However, this is optional; people are entitled to retire at this age but they also have the option to stay. The age limit of 65 for those who joined before 2004, and 67 for those who joined after this, applies across the public service.
Comment on this
As the Minister can make an order changing the age limit, it is not standard practice. There are things that happen within the system that distort it.
Comment on this
It is a complicated area to do with people's pension entitlements and employee rights. That is why it is more appropriate, when changing the retirement age, to do so by way of regulation rather than through primary legislation. For anyone who has joined since 2004, the age limit is now 67 across the public service. We have increased the age limit and, given the increase in life expectancy, no doubt it will be much higher in the future. I do not want to speculate on that because it might scare people to think they will have to work until an age that may seem unreasonable today. In the future I have no doubt the age limit will be substantially increased. I have been following, as have most Deputies, the debate in France, where they seem to be agitating over an increase in the age limit to 62, which I regard as very young.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 37, line 33, to delete paragraph (a).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
In page 39, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) Any expenses by the Minister in the administration of this Act shall, to such extent as may be approved by the Minster of Finance, be paid out of money provided by the Oireachtas.".
Comment on this
What the Deputies are seeking to achieve here is found on p.13 in section 5. "Any expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act shall, to such extent as may be approved by the Minister for Finance, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas". That is the purpose of both amendments. There may have been an misunderstanding.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
In page 39, subsection (1), lines 24 to 26, to delete paragraph (a) and
substitute the following:
"(a) the registration of a person in the register of nurses and midwives or a division of the register of nurses and midwives,”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 39, subsection (1), lines 32 to 34, to delete paragraph (e).
Deputy Conlon brought this issue to my attention. The aim is not to charge students or candidates and therefore I am removing the charge that was to be charged to nursing students.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 40, subsection (1), line 21, to delete "No" and substitute "Subject to
subsection (2), no".
This may have been dealt with already. The aim is to reconcile the subsections in line with the usual drafting practice. It is probably technical.
Comment on this
I asked the Parliamentary Counsel to look at this and counsel states that what is proposed here makes no change to the provisions of section 40. I shall look at it again on Report Stage, if the Deputies so wish, but that was the advice given.