Nurses and Midwives Bill 2010: Committee Stage
Contributions 135–271 of 271. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 16 of 2010 ›
I move amendment No. 42:
In page 43, subsection (1), lines 25 to 28, to delete paragraphs (a) to (c) and substitute the following:
"(a) a register to be known as the register of nurses and midwives, and
(b) a candidate register.”.
Comment on this
While we are gazing upon ourselves here it seems the Dáil has been suspended.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
In page 43, subsection (2)(a), line 37, to delete “appropriate,” and substitute
"appropriate, and".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 44:
In page 43, subsection (2), lines 42 to 47 and in page 44, lines 1 to 6, to delete paragraphs (c) and (d).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
In page 44, lines 22 to 33, to delete subsection (4).
Comment on this
Why was it not possible to move amendments Nos. 45 and 46?
Comment on this
The matter dealt with by amendment No. 44 having been agreed, amendments Nos. 45 and 46 could not be moved.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:
In page 44, subsection (5), lines 34 and 35, to delete all words from and including "midwives," in line 34 down to and including "may" in line 35 and substitute "midwives and the candidate register may".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:
In page 45, subsection (1), lines 36 and 37, to delete all words from and including "midwives," in line 36 down to and including "posts" in line 37 and substitute "midwives and the candidate".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:
In line 46, lines 8 to 18, to delete subsection (4).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51a:
In page 46, subsection (2), line 22, to delete "sections 49, 50, 51, 53, 54(4)
and 55” and substitute “sections 50, 53, 54(4) and 55”.
This is a technical amendment to remove references to sections 49 and 51 as it is proposed to delete those sections.
Comment on this
We are considering amendment No. 54. Amendments Nos. 60, 61 and 62 are related and amendment No. 59 is an alternative.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:
In page 48, subsection (1), line 24, after "disability" to insert the following:
"and shall declare any relevant medical disability acquired after making such an
application or after registration as the case may be".
I would like to hear the Minister's opinion on this amendment.
Comment on this
I will look at this on Report Stage. It is a difficult area and I would like to reflect on it. The same applies to amendments Nos. 60 to 62, inclusive.
Comment on this
I realise the amendment has been withdrawn but I wish to comment. The words "appropriate" and "inappropriate" are not defined in any register.
Comment on this
It was defined in amendment No. 60 but that amendment will fall. Amendment No. 59, in my name, mentions non-compliance with the code of professional conduct and there is a later amendment to delete "inappropriate behaviour".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
In page 48, subsection (1), lines 45 and 46, to delete all words from and
including "based" in line 45 down to and including "tribunal," in line 46 and
substitute the following:
"based on the person's qualifications, acts or omissions".
Comment on this
This is amendment No. 55. Deputy Lynch has moved the amendment. Is the Minister accepting it?
Comment on this
I beg your pardon. I moved amendment No. 59 in my name.
Comment on this
I understood they were being taken together.
Comment on this
Can I take it that I have discussed it already?
Comment on this
The purpose of this amendment is that the board could not take into account the findings of a disciplinary body either inside or outside the State. There has been much discussion, mostly with regard to doctors, of cases where someone was the subject of a disciplinary hearing in one jurisdiction and this was not communicated to another jurisdiction. This is of great concern to health Ministers throughout Europe and we have discussed it informally. The idea is here is that if the same applied to a nurse in another jurisdiction at least it should be communicated to the relevant regulatory body. If I understand the Deputy's amendment correctly, that would not happen. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I suppose it is to ensure that what has happened in the very recent past would not recur and that there would be an effort to communicate between different countries.
Comment on this
There may be a misunderstanding between us. As I understand it, this amendment would mean that An Bord Altranais could not take into account if someone had been disqualified in another jurisdiction. Perhaps that is not the intention.
Comment on this
We have been advised that is the case. Perhaps the Deputy could reflect on it before Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will come back to the Minister on this point because that is not the intention of the amendment and if that was the misunderstanding, then it was unintentional.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56:
In page 49, subsection (1), line 41, to delete "midwives, the candidate register and the AMP/ANP posts" and substitute "midwives and the candidate".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:
In page 50, subsection (2), lines 7 and 8, to delete all words from and including "reasons" in line 7 down to and including "concerned" in line 8 and substitute "reasons therefor".
Comment on this
A vote has been called in the Dáil.
Comment on this
The next amendment is No. 59 which deals with removing inappropriate behaviour.
Comment on this
No, the next is amendment No. 58. It has already been discussed with amendment No. 1.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:
In page 50, subsection (1), lines 44 and 45, to delete all words from and including "midwives," in line 44 down to and including "posts" in line 45 and substitute "midwives and the candidate".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:
In page 51, subsection (1), line 16, to delete paragraph (c) and substitute the following:
"(c) non-compliance with a code of professional conduct,”.
This is the deletion of inappropriate behaviour, which everyone has asked for.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In page 51, subsection (1)(h), line 24, to delete “an irregularity” and substitute “an offence”.
I believe "irregularity" is not strong enough and that "offence" is a stronger word.
Comment on this
It would be good if we could conclude this section. Does the Minister wish to respond to the amendment?
Comment on this
The word "irregularity" is poorly defined. The Bill states "an irregularity in relation to the custody, prescription or supply of a controlled drug". "An offence" is a more appropriate term.
Comment on this
In light of the vote, I propose that we suspend the sitting and we will return to the amendment immediately afterwards.
Comment on this
The word "irregularity" is loose, like "inappropriate". We want to strengthen the phrasing by including the term "an offence".
Comment on this
That would limit the scope available in this matter. An offence would require a conviction in the courts. Many complaints are made about the mishandling of medication which accounts for 16% of adverse events in hospital. Before disciplinary proceedings could consider this as a ground for complaint, a conviction in the courts would be necessary and that is too narrow. No one has made this point to me and it would restrict the role of the board where nurses or midwives dispense medicine inappropriately, which could be dangerous for patients and should be a ground for the investigation of a complaint.
Comment on this
Will there be a definition of "irregularity" within the Bill?
Comment on this
The idea is to leave the ground as open as possible in order that if someone considers he or she could make a complaint because something irregular has happened, it could be investigated by the board. It would not be possible to define all the circumstances that could account for an irregularity. If it was to moved to an offence, a conviction in the courts would be needed; therefore, there could be a nurse or midwife who was not appropriately dispensing medication without being prosecuted and convicted. Even if that were to happen, there would be a long period in which the person concerned could still be in situ. With "irregularity" the board is free to consider a complaint from those who may work in an environment with a nurse or midwife who may consider the dispensing of medication is not being appropriately handled and make a complaint. In this way, that complaint can be investigated in the interests of patient safety.
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment suggesting the use of the word "offence", on which I accept the Minister's argument. Perhaps we could include the term "breach of protocol" as covered in the other section.
Comment on this
I will look at that matter before Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 73 and 74 are related to amendment No. 63 and they will all be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:
In page 52, subsection (6)(a), to delete lines 17 and 18 and substitute the following:
"the Board shall decide under section 71(1) to cancel the nurse’s or midwife’s registration under section 71(1)(f), and”.
These are drafting amendments to clarify that in a case where the board decides to cancel a nurse's or midwife's registration under section 57(6), where there is an offence and it is in the public interest to take action immediately, the decision to cancel is taken under section 71(1). Amendment No. 63 provides for the inclusion of a reference to section 71(1) in section 57(6). Amendments Nos. 73 and 74 provide for the inclusion in section 71 a new subsection (3) which clarifies there is no report following a decision made under this section to which 57(6) applies. These are technical amendments that will bring clarity to the legislation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:
In page 55, subsection (1), line 17, to delete "ex parte application” and substitute “application, which may be made ex parte,”.
This amendment relates to ex parte evidence. The court is not inclined to rely on such evidence to the extent it did in the past. The amendment would ensure where there was time for the person himself or herself to present, ex parte evidence would not be relied upon entirely. I have not taken silk recently, but I rely on the advice I receive and the point is well made. I am told case law leans strongly against ex parte applications of this kind, partly for constitutional reasons, to preserve the integrity of the legislation. We suggest that, instead of providing the application would always be made ex parte, there be power to have it made ex parte but not necessarily in every case. If there was ample time to give notice without an adverse impact on public safety, the primary concern of the Bill, a court might be unhappy about granting an order of ex parte knowing it was not an emergency or that there was no immediate risk to public safety. We do not want someone to be successful in a challenge to legislation that is new.
Comment on this
First, an ex parte application is made where something urgent occurs and it is in the interests of patient safety. For example, last Thursday night HIQA, the Health Information and Quality Authority, took an ex parte application to a court to de-register a nursing home in the midlands and the Health Service Executive had to go in and take over the running of that nursing home in the interest of patient safety. I understand most of those patients are going to other nursing homes. The same would apply here. It would have to be an urgent case to succeed. The Deputy does not appear to be concerned about that aspect of it but rather the legal technicality. I will ask the parliamentary draftsman again about the point she makes for Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will not press the amendment because I assume the Minister will come back to me.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 55, between lines 36 and 37, to insert the following subsection:
"(5) The Court shall ensure that the nurse or midwife concerned is given an opportunity to make submissions in relation to the making or continuation of the order, either before (if practicable) or as soon as practicable after the order is made.".
This is-----
Comment on this
The same argument applies in this amendment. If the Minister agrees to examine this I do not have a problem with that.
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment with leave to come back to it on Report Stage when the Minister replies.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In page 58, subsection (1), line 3, after "practicable" to insert "but not later than 30 days".
The rationale behind this amendment is clear. The phrase "as soon as is practical" is far too loose and in fairness to those who have complaints made against them as well as everybody else they should be informed within a specified period, and 30 days is reasonable.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:
In page 59, subsection (3)(b), line 29, after “affidavit,” to insert the following:
"subject to the right of any other party to cross-examine the deponent,".
The reason for this amendment is that we believe there is a contradiction between section 66(3)(b) where it refers to evidence by affidavit and section 65(3)(c), which states that there is a right to cross-examine witnesses. Our amendment seeks the right for the other party to cross-examine the respondent. It may be simply a drafting issue but the Minister might comment on it.
Comment on this
Obviously, it is a legal matter. Can I take advice before Report Stage?
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment and come back to it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 69 is in the name of Deputy Reilly. Amendments Nos. 70 and 71 are related and all three amendments will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:
In page 61, subsection (2)(a), line 35, to delete “and”.
The amendment seeks to remove the word "and" because I do not know what it adds to the section.
Comment on this
I might examine it before Report Stage. The fitness to practice is about the fitness of the nurse or the individual to carry out their practice but I will take advice and come back to the Deputy on Report Stage if that is in order.
Comment on this
If the Minister intends to do that, our amendment, which is related-----
Comment on this
Yes, I will examine them all - amendments Nos. 69, 70 and 71.
Comment on this
-----deals with the working environment.
Comment on this
We will come back to those amendments on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:
In page 61, between lines 38 and 39, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) Where a registered nurse or registered midwife, is the subject of a complaint before the fitness to practice committee, requests removal of her/his name from the nurse/midwife register the Board shall remove the name accordingly, subject to the written agreement of the complainant, and the enquiry into the complaint shall be considered to be completed.".
The purpose of the amendment is self-evident.
Comment on this
That would weaken the fitness to practice process because one would effectively remove oneself from the register and then undermine the inquiry. The inquiry could be important for many reasons. I accept it if one does not intend to practice any more but it may well be necessary to deal appropriately with a patient's safety or an inquiry of that kind. It would undermine the whole fitness to practice process.
Comment on this
That is the reason we specifically include with "the written agreement of the complainant" to ensure there would be no question of-----
Comment on this
What happens if they apply to re-register and the fitness to practice inquiry had not concluded? They would have to be automatically re-registered. I understand the point the Deputy is making. He is trying to avoid an unnecessary inquiry if somebody is gone.
Comment on this
Yes, but at the same time not allow anyone escape culpability.
Comment on this
We could cover that. If they ever sought to re-register the board would have to re-examine the position.
Comment on this
I will reflect on it for Report Stage. My instinct would be to say "no" but I ask the Deputy to allow me take advice on it.
Comment on this
Okay. We will withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 73 in the name of the Minister should have a footnote indicating that the reference to subsection (3) refers to the subsection (3) proposed to be inserted by amendment No. 74. I call the Minister to move amendment No. 73, therefore, which has already been discussed with amendment No. 63.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:
In page 62, subsection (1), line 16, to delete "sections 57(6)(a) and 72” and substitute “subsection (3) and section 72”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:
In page 62, between lines 41 and 42, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) Where the Board wishes to make a decision under subsection (1)(f) in a case to which section 57(6)(a) applies, the Board may do so notwithstanding that there is no report from the Fitness to Practise Committee under section 69(1).”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:
In page 65, subsection (1), line 47, to delete "21 days" and substitute "42 days".
This amendment seeks to substitute 42 days for 21 days. We are all aware that midwives, by their nature and by virtue of having a saleable commodity as a skill, tend to look for work in other areas. This seeks to give them some leeway to allow them do that. It is not even-----
Comment on this
It is 21 days after they are sent a reminder but I may come back with 28 days. We will compromise. That is just four weeks.
Comment on this
I think a compromise would be after 32 days.
Comment on this
This is after they are sent a reminder. This is a self-financing board-----
Comment on this
-----and I am conscious that it needs to get in their registration fees but I will examine it and we might extend it by another week.
Comment on this
I am not certain that 21 days will have any major-----
Comment on this
It is after the reminder. It is not just 21 days. It could be 21 days after a fairly long period. I will reflect on it and come back to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I will withdraw it and come back to it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
An amendment to section 86 in the name of Deputy Reilly has been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 78 is related and an alternative to amendment No. 77. Therefore, they may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:
In page 71, subsection (1), between lines 15 and 16, to insert the following:
"(c) The Board shall ensure that the requirements relating to the education and training of candidates for registration in the nurses and midwives register satisfy the minimum standards in any relevant directive or regulation of the European Union which relates to qualifications required by nurses and midwives to secure registration.”.
This amendment seeks to ensure the standards required to be met here match the minimum standards required to be met within the European Union. As this requirement is not specified in the Bill, this would be a useful provision.
Comment on this
My advice is that, given the professional qualifications regulations 2008 transposed into Irish law under EU Directive 2005/36, the amendments are unnecessary. However, I will reconsider the matter before Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment on that basis.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:
In page 71, subsection (2)(a), line 20, to delete “Science, and” and substitute “Skills, and”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 80:
In page 71, subsection (2)(c), line 31, to delete “prepare” and substitute “set”.
This is a technical change to the wording to ensure consistency.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 81:
In page 72, subsection (2)(j), line 12, to delete “Science on” and substitute “Skills on”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 82:
In page 74, lines 19 to 21, to delete subsection (2).
I am sure the debate on Report Stage will be wide-ranging. It seems the Medical Practitioners Act does not contain a similar requirement. Why is it included in this Bill and not in that Act?
Comment on this
It relates to the regulations. The Deputy's point is correct. Under the Medical Practitioners Act, the Minister for Finance must approve the regulations, whereas in this section we have added that a proposal must have been approved. We do not want people to draft regulations if proposals have not been accepted in the first instance. This will ensure they will not waste time in drafting regulations if we know from the outset that they will not be approved.
Comment on this
We have almost completed our consideration of the Bill. Would it be possible to receive a note on that matter?
Comment on this
The amendment in the name of Deputy Reilly has been ruled out of order, as it involves a potential charge on the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 84:
In page 81, before section 109, to insert the following new section:
(1) Every reference to a midwife contained in any enactment, any statutory instrument or any other document shall be construed as a reference to a registered midwife.
(2) Every reference to a nurse contained in any enactment, any statutory instrument or any other document shall, unless the context otherwise requires, be construed as a reference to a registered nurse.
(3) Every reference to An Bord Altranais or Bord Altranais agus Cnáimhseachais na hÉireann contained in any enactment, any statutory instrument or any other document shall be construed as a reference to the Board.
(4) Every reference to the register of nurses contained in any enactment, any statutory instrument or any other document shall be construed as a reference to the register of nurses and midwives.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 85:
In page 86, paragraph 21, line 6, to delete "act or matter at" and substitute "act or question at".
This is a drafting amendment to ensure consistency.
Comment on this
I said I would reflect on the excellence in nursing aspect of the wording before Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will, therefore, deal with the matter on Report Stage.
Comment on this
May I may one or two further comments before we concluce Committee Stage?
Comment on this
We all gave our word that we would raise the issue of the position of community midwives. While we all agree that there is a need for community midwives to be indemnified, whether by way of a State indemnity scheme, a personal indemnity scheme or an indemnity scheme through a co-operative, if the service is not facilitated in some way, it will result in a removal of choice. Should it happen that there is a rare and unfortunate event during the birth of a child - such events are rare - we all agree that it would be preferable to give birth in a hospital. Nevertheless, there will always be a cohort of women who will choose to have a home birth and there must be a way of providing for this. The Bill will go a long way towards providing for a good midwifery service which will not necessarily be hospital based. Antenatal and postnatal care need not necessarily be provided in a hospital setting, although perhaps the delivery could, but the service involves far more than this. For instance, a service is provided in the majority of maternity hospitals to assist women who find it difficult to become pregnant. Many women find it a more satisfying experience to give birth at home. It would be extraordinary, should there be an unfortunate event, if all the people involved found themselves exposed in terms of liability. I would like the Minister to reflect on this and know that it is not beyond her wit or that of her officials to come up with some scheme that would allow this service to continue.
Comment on this
I echo what my colleague, Deputy Lynch, said. There is a demand for home births. In not providing for this there is a danger that people will be driven into dangerous waters. It is far better that it be done in an organised fashion with insured midwives in conjunction with the full team available around obstetrics. Different types of models have been put in place around the country and we would all agree that we would want to keep choice.
The second point I want to make relates to the fund for and cost of this initiative. While amendment No. 83 was ruled out of order because of financial considerations in that it could be a burden on the Exchequer, it is difficult to understand why it would be. Given that all of these people have already been remunerated from other areas, all that we were seeking was to ensure that the board would not be further disadvantaged by loss of funding which is currently available to it. That is a valid point and perhaps the Minister might reflect on that as well when she is finalising the Bill.
Comment on this
I am a supporter of home birth in the case of low-risk pregnancies, but clearly it must be done in the context that somebody signs the memorandum of understanding which has been agreed between the HSE and the self-employed community of midwives. We must ensure that mothers and families are protected in the event of something going wrong. If the midwife was not covered, the family would be left exposed. There is no disagreement between us. The State Claims Agency will obviously provide the indemnity, provided those concerned have signed up to the memorandum of understanding. I understand the vast majority of the self-employed midwives have done so. There is an ongoing committee, which is representative of the chief nurse in my Department, the HSE, consumer interests, nurses, etc., trying to work through some of the issues that arise.
On Deputy Reilly's point about the national council where the amendment was ruled out, we are constantly being told to merge organisations to save money. If an organisation has been subsumed into another organisation, I would hope that there would be some small saving. Deputy Reilly is suggesting that all of the money would go and that we would achieve no savings. In fact, last year the organisation did not spend all of the money allocated to it.
Comment on this
With respect, I was not suggesting that for half a moment.
Comment on this
I misunderstood Deputy Reilly, I apologise.
Comment on this
What I was trying to ensure was that there was no loss to them as a consequence of them coming together.
Comment on this
There are issues. Originally, we were going to split them between the HSE and An Bord Altranais and the council made a strong case that they should go together as an entity, and I have agreed to that. They will go together as an entity into An Bord Altranais. I would envisage, as a result, that we would be able to achieve some efficiency and other savings which, I am sure, in the current climate-----
Comment on this
I think so. For example, in 2009, their budget was €4.285 million and they did not spend all of their money. They were carrying forward a little. Their staff costs were €897,914. The cost of the staffing this year will be approximately €800,000 and that is as a result, obviously, of there being somebody on a career break but also the reduction in public sector salaries. Clearly, we would hope that we might make some efficiency related savings as a result of the merger of the two.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister and her officials for attending today's session and for the considerable work they have put into bringing this important legislation to this point. The select committee will now adjourn until 10.30 a.m. on Thursday, 11 November when it will consider the Child Care (Amendment) Bill 2009. Bill reported with amendments.