Children and Family Relationships Bill 2015: Committee Stage
Contributions 1–163 of 329. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 2015 ›
This meeting has been convened to consider the Children and Family Relationships Bill 2015. I welcome the Minister and her officials to the meeting. I must request that all mobile phones be switched off or else put on silent mode or some mode that does interfere with the sound system here.
I propose that we should commence now and continue until 11.30 a.m. when we will we take a break for 30 minutes. We will then go from 12.30 p.m. to 1.30 p.m. with another break for 30 minutes. We will then go from 2 p.m. until we decide to conclude. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I wish to give notice that I intend to move an amendment to this section on Report Stage. It will provide a collective citation of Part 4 with the Guardianship of Infants Act and provide for the commencement of Part 10 which amends the Passport Act 2008 by the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 1, 5, 18, 22 to 24, inclusive, 27 to 30, inclusive, 34, 47, 49, 57 to 59, inclusive, and 67 are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 10, lines 19 and 20, to delete “to which section 14 applies”.
This is a purely technical amendment to remove a redundant cross-reference in relation to embryo donations. The other amendments in this group are minor revisions for clarity and consistency in the language used in the Bill. They include the removal of redundant phrases or minor restructuring of certain provisions to make their meaning clearer.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 2, 8, 17, 26, 32, 45, 53, 55 and 56 are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 10, line 21, to delete “section 24(5)” and substitute “section 24(6)”.
This is a technical amendment to correct a mistaken cross-reference. The other amendments in this group are drafting amendments to ensure that cross-references within the Bill are clear and unambiguous, including corrections to some minor cross-referencing errors.
Comment on this
I plan to amend this section on Report Stage. The amendments will provide for a definition of a donation facility that includes foreign donation clinics. They will also refine the definition of "intending parent" to clarify that the intending parent, other than the mother, consents to parentage as opposed to requesting the donor-assisted human reproduction procedure.
Comment on this
There is one amendment in section 5 in the name of Deputy Mac Lochlainn, but as he is not here it cannot be moved.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 12, line 34, to delete “and”.
The amendments in this group are minor technical ones for stylistic consistency.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 13, to delete lines 15 to 19 and substitute the following:
“(a) that, in the event that he or she consents under section 6 to the use in a DAHR procedure of a gamete provided by him or her—
(i) he or she is entitled to seek the information referred to in section 32(2), and
(ii) where such a DAHR procedure is performed, he or she consents to the provision to the Minister of the information referred to in section 26(2)(a) in respect of him or her,”.
Comment on this
I intend to amend this section on Report Stage to clarify where consent can be revoked. Similar amendments will be required to sections 9 and 11 to provide absolute clarity as to where the intending parent may revoke their consent.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 16, line 6, to delete “procedure,” and substitute “procedure, and”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 7, 20, 25, 31, 33, 44, 46 and 61 to 66, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 16, line 9, to delete “a” where it thirdly occurs and substitute “the”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 17, line 5, to delete “section 32(2)” and substitute “section 32(1)”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 17, line 13, after “applies,” to insert “the”.
These amendments are minor drafting clarifications which address embryo donation to ensure that the section can operate effectively. The section, as drafted, refers to the donation of embryos by a couple who have ceased their donor-assisted reproduction treatment and where there are remaining embryos when they do so. At the moment it applies only where those embryos were themselves formed using donor gametes from another person.
I will be bringing forward amendments on Report Stage to ensure that a couple who have had embryos formed for their own use, and using their own gametes, may donate those embryos where at the end of treatment they have embryos that they do not intend to use. I will move an amendment on Report Stage to clarify the issue in relation to embryos.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 17, line 30, to delete “will be” and substitute “is”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 17, line 31, to delete “will not be” and substitute “is not”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 17, line 37, to delete “relevant intending parent” and substitute “person”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 18, line 21, to delete “the DAHR procedure” and substitute “the further DAHR procedure".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 18, line 23, to delete “his or her gamete” and substitute “an embryo”.
Comment on this
The question I want to raise is as relevant to section 14 as to other sections - that is, the interconnectivity between the section and the definition of "egg" in the legislation. The draft Bill examined by this committee had a definition of "human reproductive material" which included an ovum or part of an ovum. This had relevance in circumstances in which an ovum was provided but there was a background difficulty with regard to certain genetic diseases that could be inherited, such as mitochondrial deficiencies. If a husband and wife are using their own reproductive material to conceive a child but the wife has a family history of mitochondrial deficiencies, there can be an intervention under what is now the new frontier of genetic reproductive medicine, which allows for modification of the wife's ova with no impact on the looks or personality or the overall genetic makeup of the child that is ultimately born. A 0.1% change to the original material in the ovum using material from a donated ovum would prevent the type of difficulty that arises from what could non-technically be described as mitochondrial disease, where the body is not able to properly digest food to create energy that is necessary. This can have a dramatic impact on the health and welfare of children and adults in areas both mild and serious, including cardiac and respiratory issues. This issue was addressed recently when the Westminster Parliament dealt with a deficiency in its own legislation that created a barrier to dealing with this in the context of assisted reproduction.
This is also relevant in a context in which a husband and wife have no fertility issues, in the sense that they can conceive naturally, but there is an inherited mitochondrial disease in the family. What people may not understand is that the wife's ovum needs to be corrected in this particular way. I am conscious that this is at the frontier of reproductive medicine. It is something I was aware of when I prepared the draft Bill, and the reference to part of an ovum was designed to address this issue. I am conscious that when dealing with legislation there are ten different ways one can draft something to address a problem - there is no perfect drafting methodology - and one can problem-solve with a variety of different phraseologies. I am not sure whether there is a definitive definition. In the context of dealing with the embryo, there is a reference to "a human egg" and "a human sperm" and there does not seem to be a recognition, as the legislation is currently drafted - I am open to correction - that one could in fact be dealing with 99.9% of an ovum derived from the wife, with the final 0.1% coming from a donated ovum, which would correct an inherited deficiency that has an impact on well-being and welfare not just for the child that is born but for generations into the future. This is an issue that is relevant to this section and to earlier sections, and it is important that it be teased out a little.
Comment on this
I am interested in listening to the Minister's response on the extent to which this was considered when amendments were made to the legislation. It was always envisaged when the Bill went to a consultative process that it would be improved and that amendments would be made, as that was the whole purpose of the consultative process. However, I am concerned that because of the changes that have been effected, this particular issue - the creation of an embryo, and ultimately a child, with contributions from two separate ova - may not be envisaged in the legislation as we are dealing with it.
Comment on this
The approach in regard to this issue arises from the Department of Health's policy position. Its policy is single-egg only. The issue will be considered undoubtedly in the context of the development of assisted human reproduction, AHR, legislation, which will be worked on comprehensively. The Minister for Health came to Cabinet some weeks ago and got permission to draft the heads of a Bill and he has announced a consultation for later this year. The approach I have taken in the legislation arises from the Department of Health's present policy on this issue.
Comment on this
It appears, as Deputy Shatter says, that this whole area is changing by the week, with further developments coming forward all the time.
Comment on this
My problem with that is that this issue was addressed by virtue of the definitions contained in the heads of the Bill, to which this committee gave very detailed consideration, and gave rise to no difficulty or controversy. I do not believe there is anyone in this room, in any of the political parties or among the Independents, or anyone outside this House who would be of the view that a medical intervention that can ensure that a very serious genetically inherited physiological difficulty is corrected should not be carried out. In the context of the hearings that this committee held - I followed them with great interest, and a very interesting report was produced - I am not aware of anyone mentioning a problem with regard to the definitions that were used.
The difficulty with the Bill is that it is dealing with aspects of reproduction. What the Bill was originally intended to do was to identify parentage in the area of assisted reproduction. It is doing that in a variety of ways. A different formula is being adopted, and we will come to that shortly. I must say, frankly, that there are issues in this Bill that I envisaged would have been dealt with as part of a consultative process that the Minister of Health would undertake. Why that consultative process did not occur earlier is a mystery to me, because it was my understanding that it would have commenced fairly shortly after the heads of the Bill were published in January 2014. The Bill seems to be dealing with some aspects of reproduction, and in fact - I am coming back specifically to the issue - it is dealing with some areas that it probably should not be dealing with and omitting other areas that it should be dealing with. The point is that there are rules and specifics in the Bill with regard to whether anonymous donors are allowed or not allowed, and I am not sure whether we have touched on that. Yet the Bill seems to be progressing at a great rate this morning without the sections being examined beyond amendments.
Comment on this
I appreciate that.
There has not been adequate consultation on what is effectively the banning of anonymous donors in the context of assisted reproduction. Currently, the overwhelming majority of couples who engage in assisted reproduction using donor sperm or ova are entirely dependent on anonymous donation. There is a risk that this legislation, while providing for recognition of the parentage of children born through assisted reproduction, will mean that a majority of parents with fertility issues who need assistance through donation will need to go abroad. It will create another Irish solution to an Irish problem. The issue of anonymous donation should have been part of the consultative process in which the Department of Health is engaged. I do not know why it is now in this Bill without the extensive consultation that was required.
With regard to the issues of parentage and consent to the use of embryos in further DAHR procedures, we are talking about, to take a simple example, a couple who have not used an embryo created from their own reproductive material and are now agreeing that it can be used to assist another couple. Perhaps this is a conversation that should have taken place on an earlier section. However, it is relevant to this section and to the definition of ovum that is applicable to determining what is an embryo in the context of the legislation. I have been part of this process and I have been on both sides of the divide in this committee, both as Minister and as an ordinary Member of the House. There is no reason for us to enact a definition that is now recognised by our neighbouring Parliament to be out of date. There is no reason for us to exclude the possibility in the area of assisted reproduction for couples who have fertility difficulties, and for those who do not but who want to correct an inherited deficiency that could have an impact on the life and welfare of the child to be born to them. There is no reason for not ensuring that we have an adequate definition that addresses this issue. This is not an issue of major complexity. I ask the Minister on Report Stage to look at the definition that is being used and to go back and examine the definition that was framed in the heads of the Bill as discussed by this committee.
I appreciate that the architecture of the Bill has been amended and, knowing how the system works, I do not doubt that some of that change was derived from the Attorney General's office. Without revealing too many secrets that I should not reveal, I can tell Members that during my three years as Minister there was many an occasion on which I had to engage in arm wrestling with the drafters in the Attorney General's office to ensure the legislation emerged out of that office in the form I wanted to see it. It seems to me there is a risk that this legislation is going to create a block, if the Minister introduces the provisions on anonymous donation any time soon, on assisted donor reproduction occurring at all in this country for the vast majority of individuals. We are at risk of creating a block on what I would describe as a crucial health intervention.
It is important to know where we are coming from. This area is currently unregulated. I agree that it is an issue for the Department of Health to introduce regulation for fertility clinics and, frankly, to introduce regulations or laws to deal with the issue of anonymous or non-anonymous donation, but why would we now change something and create a difficulty that does not currently exist? If someone is able to avail of this advance in reproductive medicine in this country today, why enact legislation that might, when it comes into force, create a block that does not currently exist? That is the point I want to make. We know from what the Minister for Health has said that there is no possibility that legislation dealing with the areas he is addressing will come before the Oireachtas and be enacted before the next election. It has taken decades for us in this State to deal with this matter. There is very little chance, whatever new Government comes into office in 2016, that the matter will be prioritised for revisiting by the Minister for Health. We should not create this difficulty. We should not leave parents in this State with a family history of mitochondrial disease in a position in which the only way they can have that corrected is by travelling to England.
Comment on this
As I have stated, much work has taken place in the Department of Health in recent weeks and months, as evidenced by the fact that the Minister for Health brought a recommendation to Cabinet for the heads of a Bill on assisted human reproduction to be developed. That is a very significant development. He has also announced wider AHR consultation, which is also important, as there is much on which to consult in this area. We have the recommendation made by the commission in 2005 for a regulatory authority, which is certainly needed. In this Bill we are dealing with certain aspects of AHR, but we are not dealing with the wider issues; we are dealing with parentage issues. I see the particular point raised as being very relevant to that wider debate and wider consultation. The Department of Health feels very strongly that there are many ethical issues involved. Its policy is single-egg only and it is not addressing the issue of mitochondrial disease. The UK, which has recently legislated on this matter, is the only country to have done so. Many of the issues that arise are more appropriately dealt with in the wider AHR legislation and consultation.
With regard to anonymous donation, I wish to make a number of points. The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child speaks about the importance of the child having access to its own genetic information, and that is the reason we have taken this approach. It clearly is in the interests of the child that it would have access to genetic information. This is best practice internationally and is what other countries have done. They have moved from anonymous donation. Obviously there are still some countries where there is anonymous donation, and there is a history in Ireland of using both anonymous and non-anonymous donation. This Bill makes it clear that we are moving to a situation of best practice in terms of donations and that they will be known. We have gone further and have talked about the type of detail that will have to be kept by the clinics. We are talking about the consent issues and the access of the child, when he or she reaches the age of 18, to that information. All of that is dealt with in the legislation on the basis of the right of the child to access its genetic identity.
With regard to the concerns of some of the clinics, I want to reassure them that there will be a transitional period. Much work remains to be done in terms of working out the detail of this regulation, the consent issues and the various other aspects that are addressed in the Bill. There will be ample opportunity for the clinics to engage, primarily with the Department of Health, on this issue. In fact, the Department of Health will hold a stakeholder meeting in the next few weeks in order to work with the clinics and discuss these issues. I am absolutely clear that the principle outlined in the Bill is the right one in the context of children and going forward with AHR in this country. There are transitional issues that have to be dealt with, and they will be dealt with, but the principle and the policy are right and they are in line with the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and the discussions in the committee, as well as the recommendations of the Ombudsman for Children. Sweden moved to this system 20 years ago. The international experience is that there can be a reduction in donations initially, but as the legislation becomes known and as people understand it this issue can be dealt with.
Comment on this
If I may return to that point, I will be brief. I very much support and have always supported the concept that in so far as is practical and possible children should be able to trace their origins. That is a fairly basic principle. We have failed abysmally to address that issue adequately in the area of adoption.
This is because of the constitutional issues and difficulties that arose in marrying the rights of children with the right to privacy of individuals who placed children for adoption at a time when no legislation on origin tracing existed. Donation, whether of sperm or eggs, is a complicated and more difficult issue. There is a diversity of different approaches worldwide. Some states have no particular rules at all. The donor may be anonymous or not anonymous. Some states have a mixture of rules with options for anonymous donation or identified donation. A smaller number of states require that the donor's identity be known.
The difficulty in Ireland is that it is an extremely small country. Our population is entirely different from that, for example, of the neighbouring jurisdiction. I presume that members of the committee have received the letter from the Institute of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. I wish to refer to one particular aspect of it. In its letter, the institute references the circumstances and the difficulties with regard to assisted reproduction in Ireland. I do not know if the Minister knows the number of children born through assisted reproduction by donation. If she does, perhaps the committee should be informed of it. We are also entitled to know what consultation the Minister engaged in with fertility clinics and those members of the medical profession who are engaged daily in assisted reproduction medicine in this country. We should not be enacting provisions and saying that we will have a consultative process later. It was my understanding, when the heads of the original Bill were published, that the Department of Health was first going to engage in a consultative process. This is why these particular provisions were not in the original draft Bill. The Institute of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists states in its letter:
It must be realised that virtually no sperm, egg or embryo donation occurs in Ireland at present using sperm or eggs donated in Ireland. It occurs in a handful of cases, usually involving family members or friends. Virtually all sperm donated and used here is imported sperm, mostly from Denmark, and donor eggs used come mostly from the Ukraine. Denmark allows anonymous or non-anonymous [donation] and the Ukraine is all anonymous. The majority of couples having egg donation in fact travel to Spain or the Czech Republic where donation is anonymous. This practice will undoubtedly continue for many years yet and it will take a slow cultural change for the majority of Irish heterosexual couples to move to open donation. Many people in Ireland do not live [it says] in a tolerant or liberal community. Recent appalling coverage in the media confirms this.
I will not comment on the last bit.
I am someone who emotionally believes, as opposed to intellectually believes, that children should be able to trace their origins. However, first, there is no certainty that individuals living in this State, in circumstances in which they have not done so to date, will, in the future, when donation is non-anonymous, provide the necessary donations to facilitate Irish couples in conceiving where there are fertility issues. Second, it is unenforceable legislation in any case. Until there is a united global approach, or at a minimum a united European approach, in this area, those who wish to conceive by anonymous donation will simply get on the plane and they will conceive. Third, even though all of us instinctively feel that children should be able to trace their origins, the truth and the reality is that the children concerned, and it might sound tough to say this, would not be born or exist in many instances without anonymous donation. It is a question of a balanced and rational approach that needs to be applied.
I am aware of what the UN and other organisations have said. However, we now live in a remarkably different world. One reason for recording information about donors or knowing information, for example, about the background of the biological parent or parents of an adopted child was so that its origins could be traced. The Minister referred to the second reason, which is that individuals would have some knowledge of heritable health difficulties they could suffer as a consequence of the genetic makeup of their biological parents.
Comment on this
It might be helpful to keep to the sections as they arise. This section is about consent to use embryos to further the assisted human reproduction, AHR, procedure only. The other issues with which Deputy Shatter is dealing are further on in the Bill.
Comment on this
Might I finish what I am saying with a final sentence?
Comment on this
Today a person can know much more about his or her health vulnerabilities through genetic testing than he or she would ever know from a brief medical history of his or her biological family up to the time he or she was conceived. Since the discovery of the genome and all of the enormous advances in genetic and hereditary medicine, the idea of having a history from the biological parent which is comprehensive and adequate is now largely irrelevant.
As I understand it, most of those who donate sperm are young men in the 18 to 30 age group. Unless they are required, be they in Ireland, Denmark or the United States, to provide details of their medical history annually, how their vulnerabilities develop and what their medical history is may not be known until they are in their 50s, 60s or 70s. By that time, the world will have substantially moved on for the child who has been born. The practical reality is that we cannot require someone who makes a donation to furnish annual returns as to the state of his or her health.
Comment on this
I have one further point. This discussion illustrates the very broad range of issues in relation to AHR and all of its complexities. We are the first Government to begin to address this issue and we are, I repeat, addressing some aspects of it regarding parentage in this legislation. However, there are many issues which will need much more detailed work and consultation because there are so many aspects to the area. It is primarily a Department of Health area. I think everyone would agree with this.
The issue of identity is far greater than medical history. This is the reason all best practice suggests that all of the information about the donor should be made available to the child at a later stage. The intention is that as much medical history and information as possible would be made available. If we move from anonymous donation to known donation, the donor is making the decision in a different way because he or she is making it with the knowledge that the information is going to be made available when the child is 18 years of age. This, as well as the question of ongoing provision of information, changes the perspective and the decision the person is making.
Many of these issues are related to the broader discussion on AHR. The current policy from the Department of Health is as I have advised. This is why this section of the Bill is drafted as it is.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Shatter comes in again, I remind colleagues that any issues raised here can be raised on Report Stage as well, once they are referenced here.
Comment on this
What consultation was engaged in with fertility clinics and members of the medical profession engaged daily in treating people in this country in the area of assisted reproduction?
Does the Minister know how many children are born annually through assisted reproduction by donation?
Comment on this
No matter how the Minister puts it, we are dealing with aspects of assisted reproduction that impact directly on real couples who have to come to terms with the fact that they need assistance in the area of assisted reproduction. For many couples, that is a stressful and emotional period in their lives and we should be careful not to create barriers with unintended consequences.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but we have discussed this for some time. I have to stick with the sections as they are. We should focus on the sections or we will go all over the place. This section concerns consent to the use of embryos in further DAHR procedures and that is the only thing we should be talking about. The information the Deputy wants could probably be ascertained by means of a parliamentary question.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 19, to delete line 6.
The proposal is to delete a reference in section 15(2)(b) to the donor of an embryo, whose gamete was used in forming the embryo, being informed that he or she will not be the parent of a child born as a result of the donation. This is because the person will already have been so informed under section 15(1)(a) and the reference is redundant. It is therefore a technical change.
Comment on this
I intend to bring an amendment to this section on Report Stage to make clear that the donor of an embryo whose gamete was used forming the embryo will be able to seek information under section 32(2) to find out whether a child was born as a result of the donation.
Comment on this
I intend to introduce an amendment to this section on Report Stage. I propose to delete the word "any" from line 37 on page 19. The adjective "any" is not used to qualify travel costs or medical expenses as provided for in section 17(3)(a) and 17(3)(b), respectively.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not tabling the amendment now but giving notice of his intention to table it on Report Stage.
I think I hear a mobile telephone. Can members please turn their off telephones off? It is not fair on the staff who have to operate the transmission.
Question proposed: "That section 18 stand part of the Bill."
Comment on this
The Minister may tell me that what I have to say is relevant to a later section. My understanding of the structure of the Bill is that any parent to whom a child has been born by use of assisted reproduction by donor up to the time when the Bill becomes operative, and who wants the child to be regarded as their own, must make a court application to do so. I am talking about the straightforward situation of a husband and wife where the wife has given birth. The original legislation had a structure where there was a presumption of parenthood and if there was a challenge to the parenthood of a child a court application could be made. The effect of that was that, for the vast majority of individuals who had a child through assisted reproduction by donor, the child would be regarded as effectively theirs.
I ask the Minister again if she is aware of the number of children who have been born by assisted reproduction by donor over the past 30 years. What work has been done to assess how many court applications could arise if the only way to establish parentage of a child born where there has been a donated sperm or ova is through the making of a court application? What consideration has been given to the capacity of the courts to cope with that? What consideration has been given to the difficulties that might arise if, as is likely, there are hundreds and possibly thousands of children whose parents will not make this application as the children may already be adults or no longer living in this country? Issues with parentage could arise on the death of a parent where there is a succession dispute. Will the fact that a person did not apply create a difficulty and will there be some measures in the Bill to address the consequences of this?
Perhaps I misunderstand the Bill but it does seem to me to envisage that where there has been a birth through assisted reproduction and a donated sperm or ova there will not be an assumption of parenthood by virtue of the fact that the couple residing together, whether they are married or a same sex couple, will require a court decision. If the Minister wants to provide for a degree of certainty in this matter, the Bill could have both the presumption and, should problems arise later, the facility to apply for a court declaration so that a person could marry the two processes. Removing the presumption leaves individuals vulnerable and will result in a lot of unnecessary court applications being made.
Comment on this
It is true that we are not creating a presumption in the legislation. One of the difficulties in this whole area, which emerges when one begins to examine it, is that there is not much in the way of statistics so it is difficult to give precise numbers. There is no legislation covering the area, and while there are EU regulations and Medical Council guidelines there are poor data because not all the clinics operating in the country provide the information to the relevant European group. We received a lot of representations on this point and it is envisaged that the couple would have an opportunity to deal with the issue retrospectively. We have built a procedure into the legislation whereby the couple can go to court to present the information and have the issue dealt with.
Comment on this
May I respond? It is relevant because there is a connection between the children to whom the sections apply and the process whereby declarations of parentage are sought in the District Court. We sometimes think we have to invent wheels that have long since been invented in other countries. I do not know the exact statistics but as far as I am aware, there have been many thousands conceived and born over the past 30 years as a result of assisted reproduction by donor. Many of them are now adults getting on with their lives and not all are living in Ireland. Members of the committee may not be aware of this but we used to have what were known as "presumptions of paternity". Mothers in our law were always individuals who gave birth but the issue was often who was the father.
There were presumptions of paternity. If a married woman gave birth to a child, the presumption was that her husband was the father. Now we are living in a more complex world of assisted reproduction where children are being conceived by donated ova and sperm. In other jurisdictions they move from presumptions of paternity to presumptions of parentage and the architecture used in the draft Bill provided for presumptions of parentage and was based on international precedence that had worked well in a variety of other countries. It was not a reinvention of a wheel that does not work; it was the transplanting of a wheel into our legislation that has proved to work well.
The Minister has said that presumptions of parentage are taken out of the Bill. In the context of couples who have fertility issues in the context of using donated sperm or ova, or even now, in the context of the issue I raised previously, where one may need a small intervention in a married woman's ova or in a gay woman's ova to correct an inherited difficulty, presumptions of parentage become a lot more important. I do not understand why presumptions of parentage are taken out of the Bill. I genuinely do not understand it. Happily, it has nothing to do with the Department of Health. It is to provide some degree of certainty as to the parentage of children in circumstances where issues might arise. It is a good idea that one not only has the presumption, but that the parents of a child, or the child himself or herself, has the facility to make application to the court to get a declaration of parentage but that was always in the draft Bill.
We currently have in our law provisions that derive from the Status of Children Act 1987 where one can make application to the courts for declarations as to parentage or paternity. I urge the Minister to reintroduce the presumptions on Report Stage. It is a serious issue. I do not think one can say one will only recognise that the people who have cared for a child born through assisted reproduction throughout the child's life are the true parents of the child if they make a court application and get a court declaration. If that invitation is taken up and if presumptions are not in the Bill, there could be thousands of applications taken to our courts which could be snowed under in trying to deal with them, albeit I appreciate they may not be contested applications. The volume of those applications could be enormous. There is also the blindingly obvious issue of should individuals incur legal costs in having to make those applications where there is no inter family dispute as to who the child is and who should be regarded as his or her parents and there is no conflict as to whether the parents consented to the use of assisted reproduction.
Comment on this
I promise I will not repeat all of this.
Comment on this
Section 46 of the Status of Children Act 1987 is still in place with all of the presumptions.
Comment on this
The legal advice was very clear that we needed a court procedure when assigning parentage retrospectively. That is the reason it is built in in this way. Of course, many of the children who are being spoken about will have been registered as the children of both in an opposite sex couple and benefit from the presumptions of parentage. It is primarily an issue where there is a dispute.
I wish to inform the committee that I plan to make technical amendments to this section on Report Stage. This will include amending the definition of "repealed enactments" within the meaning of the Civil Registration Act 2004.
SECTION 20
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 22, line 13, to delete "Subsections (4) to (8)" and substitute "Subsections (5) to (8)".
The purpose of this amendment is to rectify an incorrect cross reference in section 20 which enables a person to apply for a declaration of parentage to the Circuit Court in relation to a child born through a donor assisted human production procedure. The reference should correctly be to the requirements of subsection (5) to (8) of section 19. Reference to subsection (4) would suggest that the application must be based on an affidavit sworn by the applicants. However, this is unnecessary as subsection (4) of section 20 requires the application to be granted on evidence. Furthermore, if one of the parents has since died it may not be possible to have an affidavit made by each of them.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 22, line 17, to delete "section 18(1)(d)" and substitute "section 18(1)(c)".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 22, line 37, to delete "order" and substitute "declaration".
Question proposed: "That section 22 stand part of the Bill."
Comment on this
I intend to make technical amendments to this section on Report Stage to ensure there is no doubt that references in the Bill to a donor will, where relevant, apply to the donor of an embryo, whether or not that donor's gamete was used in forming the embryo and apply to a person whose donated gamete was used in forming a subsequently donated embryo, whether or not that person is also the donor of the embryo.
SECTION 23
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 23, lines 28 to 30, to delete all words from and including "(1) A" in line 28 down to and including line 30.
The amendment refers to the provision: "A person shall not perform a DAHR procedure unless the person is - (a) a registered medical practitioner, or (b) a registered nurse." It appears to preclude what is termed DIY DAHR. As the Minister is aware, there are currently many families who have availed of reproduction outside of that parameter. The concern is whether that would impact on their guardianship and parental rights. I appreciate that the DAHR facilities would have a robust method of fully informing the persons involved in terms of consent and ensuring they are kept up to date. Is the Minister ruling out any other means of reproduction outside of DAHR facilities? Is that what this section is about? In terms of those who are currently availing of that facility, how are they impacted? To repeat a phrase used earlier, what are the unintended consequences?
Comment on this
One of the questions I had intended to raise was the one raised by Deputy Mac Lochlainn. There are numbers of people who would use what they describe as traditional methods to effect a pregnancy in circumstances which may not involve intercourse but which may involve a donation, particularly of sperm, which would facilitate somebody becoming pregnant. There is an issue around that and how that is to be regarded under the Bill. Relevant to the preceding section - I did not want to hog matters in any way - is the question I asked earlier and I want to ask it again.
What consultation has been engaged in to date with members of the medical profession engaged in reproductive medicine and the fertility clinics, with regard to the practice of assisted reproduction by donor continuing in this State, should these provisions be introduced? Has the Minister considered what I believe would be a more appropriate and balanced approach, which I again say should be dealt with by the Department of Health and should not be part of this legislation, which is to make provision for assisted reproduction by both anonymous donor and non-anonymous donor, which is, because of the type of difficulties I referenced earlier, a policy that has been adopted in some other states where either is a possibility?
I want to come back to this without repeating everything I said previously. I do not believe that these sections in this Bill should be enacted in the context of maybe we will engage in a consultative process later or the Department of Health will do it. Either there has been a consultative process and the problems that I have described have been addressed, and what is stated here by the Minister disagrees with what is stated by the Institute of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists in the passage I read out, or, if the Minister agrees with what I read out, how is it that we are in this space where this is going ahead with these provisions in it that were not part of the original consultative process and without, as it seems to me, an adequate consultative process having occurred? I think it is only now dawning on members of the medical profession that this is an area of major difficulty.
I do not believe that the majority of couples who currently anticipate requiring assistance from fertility clinics and assisted reproduction would be aware of what we are doing with this Bill on this issue and I do think this aspect of the Bill should be part of a broader consultative process because it was not part of the original consultative process on the Bill. That consultative process would appropriately be dealt with, without upsetting members of this committee, by the health committee because it uniquely requires looking at some medical issues and availabilities. I do not want us, out of the best of idealistic motives, and I am not attributing any ill motives to anyone, by facilitating children to trace their origins, to create the unintended consequences of creating a barrier which up to now does not exist to assisted reproduction by donation in Ireland.
Comment on this
This particular section is concerned with the performance of DAHR procedures. Will the Minister address the two issues that have been raised by the Deputies?
Comment on this
To address the points made by Deputy Mac Lochlainn, the aim of this amendment, which would remove the requirement that a donor assisted human reproduction procedure be carried out only be a registered medical practitioner or a registered nurse, appears to be that the parentage of a child born through a non-clinical procedure such as self-insemination would be recognised under the provisions of this Bill. These provisions have been carefully designed to allow the assignment of parentage in limited and specified circumstances. A requirement that the treatment takes place in a clinical context is an important element of the safeguards included. If wider provision were made for the assignment of parentage other than on the basis of genetic connection, this obviously would have significant consequences for the positions of natural fathers, for example.
There are several difficulties with Deputy Mac Lochlainn's proposal even if consents can be taken in broadly the same way as envisaged in sections 4, 9, and 11. In particular, it will not be possible to have independent verification that the child was born through a donor assisted human reproduction procedure and it will, therefore, not be possible to provide the necessary certificate under section 25(5). That certificate is essential to enable a couple to jointly register as the parents of a donor-conceived child. There would also be significant difficulty in ensuring that the safeguards allowing revocation of consent by a donor can be properly implemented. The case law on the position of a donor in cases of self-insemination is to be found in the Supreme Court judgment in the case of McD v. L. This found that the man concerned was, in law, the child's father and had the same statutory rights to seek guardianship, custody and access as another non-marital father.
The Bill does not attempt to regulate this issue or, for example, to ban it. It has the consequences though in relation to parentage as set out in section 5. However, where all of the adults involved are in agreement and it is in the best interest of the child concerned, there are options available which will allow a non-biological parent to secure a legal relationship with the child. That person could apply for guardianship of the child under section 6(c) of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964, as inserted by section 45 of the Bill, leaving the parental status of the natural father unaffected. Alternatively, of course, the mother and her partner could jointly adopt the child under the Adoption Act 2010 as it is proposed to be amended by this Bill.
In short, they will have a route to parentage which does not run the risk of undermining the position of natural fathers. I cannot accept the amendment. There is a very clear process and approach laid out in the Bill in relation to the question of the procedure and where it is carried out.
Comment on this
Why are people being excluded if they have engaged in the procurement in an ethical and informed manner, they have signed affidavits, the donor has consented to the treatment, and they understand their parenting roles? If they have the aid of clinicians and they have legal advice outside of the parameters suggested in this proposed legislation, is there any room for flexibility in terms of those who have gone down this course already? There is a sense that, as a result of this legislation, they will have lost the rights that they would have assumed they had or they see themselves as having less equality with parents who have gone down the route of the DAHR clinic process.
Comment on this
I want to get clarification on this. The amendment refers to deleting one particular subsection, which states, "A person shall not perform a DAHR procedure unless the person is a registered medical practitioner or a registered nurse". Does Deputy Mac Lochlainn want to take that out?
Comment on this
There are families who availed of other routes and their concern is that their right to parenthood is not automatically guaranteed by this legislation. They would also argue that they have had the proper clinical and legal advice and have done everything properly in terms of signing affidavits. That is their argument that is being put to us and we want to put it here today and have it thrashed out.
Comment on this
The effect of the Deputy's proposed amendment would be to enable the donor to contract out of parentage without the kind of safeguards and procedures that are in the Bill. The strong legal advice that I have is absolutely against doing that and the case law that I have quoted in relation to the Supreme Court is very clear about the assignation of parentage in that case. The way the Bill is constructed is to ensure that where there is that transition from the donor to parentage, there is a very clear route outlined for all involved so that the rights of everyone are protected, the donor and the parents. What we have done in the Bill is that we have outlined clear routes to parentage but we have the safeguards of where the procedures are taking place and the independent verification of them. That really is the essence of the approach. As far as I am aware, there is no precedent for what the Deputy describes of opting out of the parentage provisions by a donor by way of affidavit. I am not aware of any precedent for that.
This Bill is a beginning and in looking at this Bill, Deputy Shatter was dealing with the parentage aspects in order to have clear procedures in this area regarding what I call the routes to parentage where there was donor-assisted reproduction.
Comment on this
Will the Minister respond to my questions?
Comment on this
They were not specific to the amendment about which we are talking and with which we are dealing at the moment. We might come back to that when we come to the section, if the Deputy does not mind.
Comment on this
I want to try to keep this as tight as possible because this is so complex that we could get lost in details.
Comment on this
While I do not wish to delay the committee, perhaps the Minister will respond to the questions I asked earlier without my repeating them. If she needs me to repeat them, I am happy to so do.
Comment on this
In that regard, I will make the point that clearly, the submissions were considered by the committee during the public consultation. A number of recommendations arose from the committee's consideration regarding the question of identity. A clear recommendation came from the committee in that regard, of which I took note, as well as from the Ombudsman for Children and the relevant international provisions. That is what primarily has determined the approach regarding the child's right to genetic information. It is very much a case of considering it from the point of view of the best interests of the child. This is what has informed the approach in the Bill. There has been ongoing consultation between the Department of Health and the relevant clinics and their submissions have also been considered.
Comment on this
Unless I am missing something, it appears to me that the Minister is stating that neither she nor her Department has been engaged with the fertility clinics and that they have not considered the difficulty that could arise if we move from anonymous donation to identifying donors. No assessment has been undertaken as to whether a barrier will now be erected when this comes into force and will be placed in the way of couples who wish to conceive in Ireland through assisted reproduction by donor. I apologise but this is too important an issue. This legislation is designed to do something that has been ignored for too long in this country, that is, to provide rules with regard to parentage of children born through assisted reproduction. Unfortunately, the issue of surrogacy effectively has been abandoned to whoever is in government the next time around.
However, one should not do something that has unintended consequences. I accept absolutely that the Minister does not intend these consequences. I accept absolutely that this is a well-intentioned approach to ensure that children can have information with regard to biological parents, that is, the donors. I accept absolutely the intentions behind this are well-intentioned and would not wish anyone to misinterpret what I am saying. I believe the necessary consultation on this matter has not occurred and that it will have unintended consequences. I believe it will greatly stress couples who have personal fertility issues and will create a difficulty for the continued work on existing fertility clinics. Moreover, I do not think it is good enough, for example, to state that while the measure will be enacted, it will not be brought into force instantly but that the Government will then engage in a consultative process. There must be some certainty in this environment for both couples and members of the medical profession as to the direction they are taking over the next period of time.
I wish to give one simple example in this regard. At present, there are couples throughout the country who are having difficulties in conceiving. They will be getting some medical assistance and, inevitably, will be attempting to conceive without assisted reproduction. The next stage may well be that they will attempt to conceive through assisted reproduction by use of their own reproductive material. The third step, if that does not work, may be by donor. In circumstances in which couples may have some reasonable prospect of conceiving by use of their own material without donor, will members, because these provisions are coming down the track, put them in a position where, if they wish to go through assisted reproduction in Ireland, they must forget about that and must conceive rapidly through anonymous donation for fear that in six, 12 or 18 months' time, there simply will not be donors in this country and their only alternative option will be to leave the State? Are we going to put couples in that position?
It is too serious to simply state there will be a consultative process later on and it is unfair. I acknowledge the Minister's amendments in this area are well-intentioned. I am totally familiar with the international legal provisions to which she is making reference and am aware of the recommendation of this committee. However, while I am open to correction by members, I do not think the committee explored whether, if we did what is now proposed, it could have the unintended consequence of bringing to an end for a time assisted reproduction by donor in Ireland. I do not believe any member of this committee envisaged that unintended consequence as a possibility. Moreover, I do not think one should simply ignore what the Institute of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists is saying about this issue. I urge the Minister to rethink the presence of the provisions contained in this section and related sections. I will not come back and repeat this but I urge the Minister to rethink the appropriateness of their inclusion in this Bill with a view to what she states should occur, that is, the engagement of the Department of Health in a consultative process and these elements of this Bill being removed from it on Report Stage. Let the Department of Health get on with its consultative process, which is the area in which it should be dealing and not on the issue of parentage in the context of surrogacy. This is the particular area with which it should be dealing. Let us not create a difficulty or unnecessary worries for people by the enactment of this measure in its current form without understanding the unintended consequences.
Comment on this
Obviously, the intention of Committee Stage is to raise issues like this and then to report back to the Dáil thereafter. No amendments have been tabled in respect of any of these matters on which we can make decisions here. Members can raise and discuss such issues and then report back to the Dáil, by way of amendment, if people wish to raise them there at that time.
Comment on this
Obviously, I understand completely the position of people in Ireland who wish to use donor-assisted reproduction procedures. Each member of the committee has a significant understanding in this regard and obviously wishes to support the very best practice in this area. At this stage of the discussion, it is appropriate for me to state that in respect of the broader regulation of assisted human reproduction, the regulation of clinics and all the details this area involves, which are many, complex and evolving, the appropriate place for such discussions clearly is in the development of the legislation being undertaken by the Department of Health.
As for concerns about the future of donor-assisted human reproduction in Ireland, if one examines the position internationally, when countries moved from anonymous donation to known donation, donor-assisted human reproduction did not stop in those countries. It simply meant that best practice was in place with regard to protecting the interests of the child. While I clearly desire to have a system that is effective and that works, there are a couple of key principles, one of them being a move from anonymous to known donation. I already have spoken about that. As I stated, there is not evidence available from elsewhere that in the longer term, this has been a problem in countries which have moved in this direction. In addition, I have made it clear that a stakeholder meeting is coming up between the Department of Health and the clinics.
I have already spoken with the Minister for Health, Deputy Varadkar, on a transition period. We can examine the length of the transition period so that these issues can be dealt with. The range of concerns the clinics have can be worked through during that transition period, but in terms of the routes to parentage and assigning parentage in this Bill, I have very much taken the approach that it should be known donations rather than anonymous ones.
Comment on this
On a point of information, the committee did address this issue and get submissions on it.
Comment on this
The other point I wish to make is that in September when I published the scheme, all of those issues were also included in it for consultation and information.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 25, line 26, to delete “concerned”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 25, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:
“(8) A transition period of 12 months, from the date of enactment, shall be allowed for cases where patients have already selected or paid for anonymous sperm donors or have the donation currently in storage in Irish clinics awaiting use in treatment, to complete their treatment cycles.
9) A transition period of 12 months, from the date of enactment, shall be allowed for cases where individuals have already initiated the process of anonymous egg donation, to complete their treatment cycles.
(10) A transition period shall be allowed for cases of treatment involving a DAHR procedure resulting in a sibling child from an anonymous donor for a period of 3 years from the birth of the first child or 3 years from the date of enactment, whichever of the two is longer.”.
There are three separate aspects to what we propose. The first deals with those who have selected or paid for anonymous sperm. We seek that they would be given a further period after the enactment of the legislation to avail of the process on which they have already embarked. It is a very sensitive and difficult process for the hopeful parents involved and the intention is to take account of that. I understand 600 to 700 patients across the country would be prevented from completing their treatment and they are the people addressed in the proposed new section 24(8).
Section 24(9) deals with those who have initiated the process of anonymous egg donation and allows them to complete their treatment cycles. The third subsection deals with having the same donor to produce siblings. We are advised that it would be reasonable to allow three years from the birth of the first child. If the legislation as put forward by the Minister is enacted it would apply to people who engage for the first time in the process, but the intention is to take a compassionate approach to those who have already engaged in the process in recent years in order that they would be allowed to complete the cycle. That is the advice we have been given. We are hopeful the Minister will accept it as it is a very reasonable amendment. It is a compassionate amendment.
Comment on this
The amendment would provide for a transition period to allow couples currently undertaking donor-assisted human reproduction procedures to continue with their treatment and to facilitate an orderly move to the regulatory framework envisaged in Parts 2 and 3 of the Bill. In principle, I broadly agree that such a transitional period has its merits and I stress in that regard certain transitional provisions are already included in section 20(5) and (6). The Deputy's provision in the proposed section 24(10) would to some extent cut across the provisions set out in 20(6) which sets out a three year period from the commencement date to allow the couple to have a sibling using gametes from the same anonymous donor. That is a very specific section to deal with the issue of siblings.
As an alternative to the amendment, I propose to give a clear commitment to the Deputy, together with the Minister for Health, Deputy Varadkar, that Parts 2 and 3 will not be commenced for a minimum period of one year from the date of enactment and that would provide at least the same transition period which would enable couples currently undergoing treatment to continue with that treatment and will give clinics time to prepare for the new regulatory framework. This is a practical and pragmatic administrative solution to which I will give a binding commitment so that we will have a seamless transition to the new regulatory framework. On the basis of my commitment in that regard I ask Deputy Mac Lochlainn not to press the amendment.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister's commitment. She referred to section 20(5) and (6).
Comment on this
It is section 24. I am sorry. I said section 20.
Comment on this
I will just check the reference.
Comment on this
While Deputy Mac Lochlainn is looking at the Bill perhaps I could let Deputy Shatter contribute and then I will come back to Deputy Mac Lochlainn?
Comment on this
I have found the reference. I just wish to clarify with the Minister that what we propose in section 24(10) is covered by section 24(5) and (6), and that what we seek to achieve has already been achieved in the Bill.
Comment on this
It is a slightly different time but I believe it essentially deals with the point made by Deputy Mac Lochlainn.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. The Minister has said the proposed measure in section 24(10) is already addressed in the legislation and in terms of the proposed section(8) and (9) provisions that it will be a year before the legislation is enacted to allow the necessary time to complete the process they have begun.
Comment on this
I am actually saying there will be a minimum period of one year. That is an issue that can be further addressed in the consultations with the shareholders which are being held by the Department of Health.
Comment on this
Could everyone speak through the Chair, please, otherwise we will be going all over the place.
Comment on this
My apologies, Chairman. There is no need to press the amendment because the commitment from the Minister is a binding one and it achieves what we seek to do. On that basis, I welcome the Minister's assurances and I will withdraw the amendment in good faith.
Question proposed: "That section 24, as amended, stand part of the Bill."
Comment on this
First, I will address the specific provision the Minister referenced. It is section 24(5). It provides for a period of three years from the date on which that subsection comes into operation, a gamete to which paragraph (a) of that subsection does not apply may be used, basically, in an assisted human reproduction procedure. Then it goes through a whole series of issues.
The three years is the problem. I am going to ask the Minister to amend that on Report Stage because in circumstances where there is frozen material available to be utilised in assisted reproduction, that could be used over many years. In the context of that, it does not make sense that it is confined to a three-year period. For example, where a couple has an arrangement or where material is available, will it be the case that if one wants to have children, one had better have three in three years?
I do not understand the three-year provision. It creates unnecessary difficulties. Could the Minister clarify if, for example, this were to apply to an embryo, if a number of embryos were created - I understand it will apply - let us assume there are five frozen embryos that a husband and wife can utilise to conceive a child and a donor has been involved with regard to the material required to create the embryos, are we going to say to them, first, any ones that can be utilised to conceive must be done within three years of the enactment of the Bill because the donor was anonymous? That makes no sense. There is no merit in it and I would suggest that should be revisited.
When replying in respect of Deputy Mac Lochlainn's amendment, the Minister indicated that Parts 2 and 3 of the Bill will not be brought into force for a minimum of one year and possibly longer. I am of the view that Part 3 should be removed from the legislation entirely. The difficulty with Part 2 is that it contains provisions relating to identifying the children born through assisted reproduction. I am quite happy that the provisions which should have been left to the Department of Health to deal with in the first instance will not be brought into force for a minimum of one year. I suspect that some of them will never be brought into force in their current state.
There is an urgent need to make specific rules in respect of the area of parentage. Under the enabling provision in the legislation, at section 1(3), the Minister "may appoint by order or orders either generally or with reference to a particular purpose or provision and different days may be so appointed for different purposes or different provisions". Basically, this means that he or she may bring different sections into operation. There is an urgent need to provide clarity with regard to the parentage of children born through assisted reproduction. It is bad enough that we are leaving out children born by means of surrogacy, particularly in the context of the number of court cases which have taken place to date on that issue and the number of parents and children affected. We should not be saying that we are not going to provide clarity for children who are born via assisted reproduction for a minimum of one year and possibly longer.
I do not want the Minister to be in a position in the future where when she wishes to bring certain sections into operation, she will be of the view that she has made a pledge not to do so. I hope that when the legislation is enacted, the provisions which offer clarity regarding parentage will be brought into force. Even though I disagree with the necessity for individuals to be obliged to go before the courts to obtain orders or declarations of parentage which indicate that their parents consensually agreed to use assisted reproduction by donor, we should postpone the possibility of their being able to do so for a minimum or possibly a good deal longer. I ask the Minister to reconsider the blanket promise to the effect that Part 2 will not be brought into force for at least a year. The parentage identity provision should be implemented immediately.
I welcome the fact that Part 3 will not be brought into force for at least one year. It would be preferable if the matter to which it relates were dealt with by the Department of Health. Whatever the position, the three-year provision in section 24(5) must be revisited.
Comment on this
It is important that I make absolutely clear the fact that embryos are permanently exempted. I will be introducing a further provision on Report Stage to clarify the position even further. For constitutional and other reasons - but mainly constitutional ones - embryos are permanently exempted from this provision. Even if the donation is anonymous, it will be permanently exempted. I wish to make that point perfectly clear to the Deputy. Parts 2 and 3 are inextricably linked because they set out in the Bill the whole approach we believe is necessary in the context of identity. They also construct the framework to be put in place in order to ensure clarity in respect of the various routes to parentage.
Comment on this
Essentially, the Minister is now informing us that as a result of the additional provisions introduced into the legislation - which effectively prevent the use of anonymous donation - those provisions that will facilitate identifying and confirming the parentage of the thousands of children born through assisted reproduction will not be brought into operation for a minimum of one year and possibly longer. That is regrettable. I do not believe there was a necessity to mix these issues up in this particular way. I urge the Minister to reconsider what is being done here. If she insists on going down the road of including in the Bill measures which would more properly be dealt with under legislation relating to the Department of Health and which are clearly recognised as creating a difficulty in the context of assisted reproduction by donation, then the issues to which I refer should be separated from the rules relating to parentage. They are of no relevance at all to the thousands of children already born by means of anonymous donation for whom a court procedure is being provided in order that they might definitively identify who are their parents so that their parentage will not be a matter of dispute in the future. It is regrettable that the issues in question have become interwoven in the way I have outlined. I make these points because it has taken us 30 years to get to the point of enacting legislation in this area. I urge the Minister to examine the architecture of the Bill in order that the parentage of children born to date can at least be readily determined, addressed and dealt with and to ensure that matters will not be left in limbo for a minimum of one year and possibly longer.
Comment on this
In developing the provisions contained in the Bill, many different aspects had to be taken into consideration. I received strong and complex legal advice to the effect that the identity and parentage provisions should be dealt with together.
Comment on this
I should point out that I intend to amend the section on Report Stage in order to provide key clarifications. I propose to amend the references in subsections (5) and (6) to consent to a form that is substantially the same as provided for in sections 6 and 14. This is because that is too high a threshold for these particular transitional provisions. Accordingly, I will amend the Bill in order to clarify that the consent in question is to the use of the gamete embryo in a donor-assisted human reproduction procedure. I will also make further provision to clarify that where a couple already have embryos - formed using gametes from one of them and from donor gametes - stored in a clinic, there will be no limitation on the time within which they may use those embryos. This is the point I sought to clarify earlier.
Comment on this
In the context of these matters being delayed for more than a year, I am conscious that so far much of my focus has been on heterosexual couples. Effectively, however, what is proposed means that gay couples who have had children through assisted reproduction will be left in a position whereby, for a continuing and indefinite period, the parentage of their children will not be capable of being definitively addressed. That is most regrettable.
Comment on this
Let us see what happens on Report Stage. It is open to all Deputies to bring forward amendments at that point provided they have highlighted them here in the context of Committee Stage proceedings.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 26, line 30, to delete “mother” and substitute “intending mother”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 27, to delete lines 1 and 2 and substitute the following:
“(b) a record of the revocation, under section 8, 10, 12 or 16, as the case may be, by a person referred to in paragraph (a) of his or her consent.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 27, line 5, to delete “a” and substitute “the”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 27, to delete lines 13 and 14 and substitute the following:
“(b) the information referred to in subsection (2) in respect of the donor and the intending parent;”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 27, line 23, to delete “date of birth” and substitute “date and place of birth”.
Comment on this
I intend to amend this section on Report Stage to clarify that the DHAR, donor assisted human reproduction, facility referred to in section 26(1) is that in which the gamete or embryo was donated.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 27, line 37, to delete “facility” and substitute “operator”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:
In page 28, line 20, to delete “place of work or”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In page 30, line 12, to delete “it” and substitute “him or her”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 30, line 14, to delete “subsection (5)” and substitute “subsection (3)”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
In page 30, line 29, to delete “its” and substitute “his or her”.
Comment on this
I will be putting forward an amendment on Report Stage to amend this section. It will propose to delete lines 27 to 33 on page 30 and insert a provision making an order to prohibit the DAHR facility from performing DAHR procedures for any period up to 12 months and that an operator of a DAHR facility will commit an offence if he or she fails in their obligations to comply with section 26 to the extent of causing the Circuit Court to make an order under section 26(5). It will also provide that a person who commits an offence under this section will be liable, on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding €3,000 and, on conviction of indictment, to a fine not exceeding €100,000.
Comment on this
This requires that the Minister for Health is to establish a register and details the information that is to go into it. How is it envisaged this is going to work in practice? This is relevant to a discussion needed on section 32. Is this a register that the Minister for Health will provide? Will some section in the Department operate it?
Comment on this
In 2005 the Commission on Assisted Human Reproduction recommended there should be an independent regulatory authority to deal with all of the issues with DAHR and AHR, assisted human reproduction. This is not in place yet. Regarding the original provisions in the Bill and the developments in the provisions dealing with identity, the appropriate Ministry is the Department of Health. I thank the Department for the work it has done in this because provisions have had to be brought in ahead of the comprehensive legislation needed in this area. There has been detailed contact and consultations with the Department to arrive at this particular architecture in the legislation.
In the first instance, this register would be the responsibility of the Department of Health which has agreed to take it on. As the legislation develops, the work that unit is doing within the Department of Health would be taken over by the authority which will be responsible for AHR. The Department will be responsible for the development of this register. It has much contact with the clinics and it will be working closely with them to establish the range of procedures necessary to ensure this will operate effectively.
Comment on this
It appears from what the Minister is saying that it is never envisaged that this provision will come into force in its current form. Whatever legislation the Department of Health is working on that might get published in 2016, 2017 or 2018 will provide for the creation of a regulatory authority in the area of assisted reproduction fertility clinics. It again illustrates why this aspect of this legislation should be dealt with by the Department of Health and should not be in this Bill. What is becoming clearer as we are having this discussion is that these provisions in this Bill will create a blockage on reforms relating to identifying the parentage of children born through assisted reproduction for heterosexual couples or gay couples across the country and that there is no certainty as to when any of the provisions in Parts 2 or 3 will come into force.
The reason it is important is because the architecture is making the presentation that this is a function that the Minister for Health is personally going to perform or his officials. When we come to sections 32 and 33, we will see that the Minister is then given an adjudicative function which is, because of its nature, completely inappropriate for a Minister to engage in. The adjudicative function will be around determining what information may or may not be given to a donor-conceived child who has achieved the age of 18 years or the parents of a donor-conceived child.
Comment on this
I know these are all interrelated but we will come to them when dealing with the next sections.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that the Bill as drafted means that decisions on this, under section 33, will be made by the Minister for Health. However, we are now being told they will not be made by the Minister for Health but by a regulatory authority that has not yet been created and for which there is no legislation but is currently in the mind of the Minister. I am again making the point that I know what the Minister is doing is well-intentioned. It is another indicator, however, that crucial aspects of the legal architecture still need to be created. I do not understand why we are dealing with these provisions in this Bill.
Comment on this
These are similar to some of the issues I wanted to raise earlier but the Chairman put me off.
However, we have not come to those yet.
Comment on this
No, but we will come to deal with them. The issue is that many of these sections are interrelated. We have now come to the section dealing with the register and there are a number of sections involved and members can speak on these, but I am trying to help members to speak to matters covered within the sections.
Comment on this
We are appreciative but we want to avoid creating difficulties.
Comment on this
I am trying to help members to speak to matters within the sections, if possible, to ensure we have clarity as to where we are going but, I admit, there are overlaps. Does the Minister want to respond? Deputy Ferris can come in again after that.
Comment on this
I believe there is a misunderstanding here. I am not for a moment suggesting that the development of the national donor-conceived person register would wait until there is an independent regulatory authority dealing with donor-assisted human reproduction, DAHR. I am simply making the point that in the longer term, clearly that is envisaged. We need that and that is quite obvious from the commission's original report of 2005. What I am saying is that in discussions with the Department of Health, it has agreed that it will be responsible for the development of the national donor-conceived person register. We do not have an authority at present, so we have to identify where this work is going to be done. There are clearly resource issues as well, which the Cabinet has discussed and of which the Minister, Deputy Varadkar, is well aware, but the Department of Health has accepted that this would be part of its responsibility in terms of the implementation of this Bill. That decision has been made and the Department of Health has agreed to it. There is no question of putting off the implementation of this element of the Bill until there is an authority in place. I simply made the point that in the longer term, clearly these provisions would transition into an authority when it is established.
Comment on this
This section deals with access to certain information from the register. Does anybody wish to speak to that?
Comment on this
My point relates to sections 32 to 35, inclusive.
Comment on this
Yes, but there are no amendments to these sections and there is a thread running through them. Deputy Shatter has mentioned since early this morning that there are different threads running through sections and I agree with the points he has been making all along, but we are only now coming to deal with the points in these sections.
I have done quite a degree of extensive work on the adoption information and tracing legislation. I believe that instead of a contact register being set up in this area for children who are born as a result of the donor-assisted human reproduction procedure, as in the case of children born naturally, a no-contact veto provision should be provided. As much information as possible should be provided both on the donor side and on the side of the child who was born as a result of the donor-assisted human reproduction procedure. That information should be on a register in as much detail as I would be advocating in terms of the adoption information and tracing legislation, so that either the donor or the child could register. They would have to give this information but they could put in a no-contact veto provision stating that they do not wish to be contacted, rather than an application having to be sent to the Minister or whoever seeking the information and the Minister having to check what is on the file. The Minister mentioned that there would be a stakeholders' meeting after this and she mentioned time and again the role of the Minister for Health, Deputy Varadkar. The Minister for Children and Youth Affairs should certainly be brought into this discussion on this area as well. If the information on the tracing legislation goes through, and I hope it goes through in this Dáil term, and if the Minister takes up my suggestion about including a no-contact veto provision, there would then be a difference between children and adults who are born as a result of the donor-assisted human reproduction procedure and children who are born naturally. I am not sure what is the politically correct way to put that, but that should be re-examined.
Comment on this
I know Deputy Ferris's deep interest in this issue in regard to the child's right to know in regard to adoption. In developing this legislation, what is very much in our minds is the very difficult issues that have emerged in regard to the situation where children did not have access to identity and genetic information. That has been a central part of our approach to the setting up of provisions to ensure that as much information as possible would be given to the child.
Deputy Ferris, in the first instance, might elaborate on the no-contact veto provision in order that I understand precisely what is meant by that because obviously that would have to be translated into legal terms and I can then respond to the points she has made.
Comment on this
Yes, I do. That is why I suggested that the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs should also be brought into this conversation when the stakeholders meet. I was working on the adoption information and tracing Bill rather than on this Bill but it applies to this one as well. All possible information about the birth mother or birth parents and the child who was adopted should be on the register. In a case where a child, on reaching a certain age, or a birth mother would contact the register of adoptions seeking information to see if there is corresponding information there, and the information from both sides would be on the register for health and various other reasons, if the birth mother did not want to be contacted by her child at any stage, she could put a no-contact veto provision on the register. Her information, details about herself, her medical history and other information she might want to provide would be on the register, but instead of that person being contacted and advised by the Adoption Authority that their child wants to contact them, and a certain time being allowed for that person to respond, that person, either the adult child or the birth parent, could put on the register that they do not wish to be contacted. I know people have fears about harassment and all of that but we already have legislation in place that covers that. I made quite a long submission to the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs on this issue on behalf of the Labour Party, so it is on the record. I would ask the Minister and her officials to contact the office of the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs to get this information.
An aspect in this respect that might create a difficulty arises under section 33(3).
Comment on this
It is all part of it. I believe the provision under that subsection closes the door, as it were, because it states that if the Minister is satisfied-----
Comment on this
I ask the Deputy to defer making that point. When we finish dealing with section 32, we will then move on to section 33.
Comment on this
To return to the inclusion of a no-contact veto provision, rather than having both sides looking for information on contact details, I honestly believe we should change our mindset in the adoption information and tracing Bill and in this Bill to put in a no-contact veto provision.
Comment on this
For my own information, is the Deputy suggesting that the names, addresses and other such details would-----
Comment on this
No. They would be available on the register because that is the issue. I know we are straying into a different area here-----
Comment on this
-----but it is well documented that children who are adopted want to know their identity. They want to know information about themselves. If, say, the birth parent or, in this case, the donor gave the information about themselves but did not want to be contacted, they could still give information about their medical background. That is far more optimistic and healthy in terms of the future and it will help many people. That is the basis on which I am proposing this. If we were to put in the wording as it is, it would be completely different from what will be possible in the adoption information and tracing legislation.
Comment on this
The Deputy might consider tabling an amendment on this on Report Stage. Does the Minister want to respond?
Comment on this
The approach in this Bill is that the right to information is the right of the child. The child will not be contacted with the request if he or she has not made a notification that he or she is willing to be contacted, so the donor cannot veto.
That is a vital component of the approach we have taken to consent in the Bill, so that if one is a donor and is making a donation, one will be told that a child has the right to that information at age 18 and one will be asked to give as much information as possible. The range of that information will have to be worked out, but there are fairly accepted international standards. I have a great deal of information on what has happened in other countries when they have moved from anonymous to known donation. We are saying that the donor cannot veto and that is an important part of the approach we have taken to consent. Once the donor is involved, the donor will know there is a register and that the child has access to that information and can be given all the details the clinic has at that point.
Comment on this
I will let Deputy Shatter go ahead.
Comment on this
I want to raise a different issue under section 32. This section provides for two things: for information to be given either to a child over 18 or to the parents of a child under 18 concerning matters recorded in the register. However, it also provides in subsection (2) that the donor of a sperm or ovum, and it will more frequently be sperm than ova because of the way reproductive medicine tends to work and the difficulties people experience, "may request the Minister to provide him or her with information from the Register on the number of persons who have been born as a result of the use in a DAHR procedure of a gamete donated by the donor, and the sex and year of birth of each of them". How will that work in practice? Is the Minister obliged to respond and provide the information? Is there a timeframe within which information should be provided? Is there any basis for the Minister not to provide the information? I am just curious about how that will work in practice. I am open to correction, but it does not seem that there is anything else in the Bill of relevance to that subsection if the Minister refuses, for example, to provide the information, or decides to take five years to make the decision. I may be wrong.
Comment on this
As the Deputy has said, subsection (2) specifies that a donor may ask the Minister to tell him or her how many people were born as a result of donations he or she made and the sex and year of birth of each such person. That is the extent of the information the donor can request. I intend to amend this section on Report Stage to oblige the Minister for Health to comply with a request for information from the national donor-conceived person register, subject to the provisions of sections 33 to 35, inclusive, and to provide that the donor of an embryo who has provided gametes used in that embryo will be able to request information on whether a child has been born as a result of the donation. I hope that clarifies matters.
Comment on this
I believe Deputy Ferris wished to raise some points under this section. It relates to information in respect of the relevant donor to be provided to a donor-conceived child.
Comment on this
I want to query one point under this section. In subsection (3)(a) it is stated "if satisfied that sufficient reasons exist to withhold the information concerned from the donor-conceived child" and so on. Does that close the door completely on information being given? People get on in years, they change their minds and circumstances can change. Does that provision close the door completely on information being given, or can a request for the information be submitted at a later stage?
Comment on this
Obviously it would be extremely rare and it is difficult to imagine the circumstances but it would probably be where there was a threat, for some reason, to the life of the donor or of the child, or that the child's safety and well-being would be completely prejudiced by releasing the information. If that situation changed, clearly, the request could go in again. Obviously, there could be an appeal by the person as well to the Circuit Court and notice would be given to the Minister. It must be heard otherwise than in public in these particular circumstances because they would be very unusual circumstances. It is a provision included for exceptional circumstances where the child's safety would be prejudiced by releasing the information.
There is a process. If this changes another application can be made.
Comment on this
It is not easily read within the section that it can be reopened. Perhaps it can be reworded to make clear another application can be made at a future time.
Comment on this
I will examine it and see whether a point on the circumstances changing needs to be included. If my advice is it is already understood from the drafting, I will inform the Deputy. I will certainly examine it.
Comment on this
I have concerns as to how this will work in practice and what transparency, if any, there will be in the process. There is obviously an interaction between subsection (2) and subsection (3), in that under subsection (2) the Minister must within 12 weeks from the date on which notice was sent release to the child the information requested unless the relevant donor makes representations to the Minister setting out how it would affect the safety or well-being of the donor or the donor-conceived child or both. It seems to be an issue of safety or well-being. I do not know in legal terms what the phraseology "well-being" means. I have absolutely no idea what it means. The meaning of "safety" is reasonably clear but I do not know about "well-being". In the context of the donor, should the well-being solely relate to the donor or to anyone associated with the donor, such as children born to him by a partner, whose well-being needs to be considered in all of this? I simply do not know the answer to this.
Subsection (3) states the Minister shall consider these representations and if satisfied sufficient reasons exist to withhold the information, may do so. The words "well-being" and "sufficient reasons" are not adequate. As the child will be over 18, will the best interests principle be applicable or some other principle because the child at that point will be an adult? In the context of the adoption legislation and the difficulties around tracing origin and giving information, the paramount consideration when making a decision about revealing information was the welfare of the child. We now use, correctly, the formula "best interests".
These provisions are very unclear. It is not clear whether the Minister must state the reasons he or she makes a decision. There should be an obligation to expressly state what the reasons are. It is not clear procedurally. For example, if the donor objects, will the Minister have in front of him or her an application for information and a donor objection? Will any of the information contained in the objection be furnished to the now adult child? I do not know the answer to this. Will the child have an opportunity to respond? I am not clear on this. Will any fair procedures apply? I do not know.
In the context of an appeal there should be an obligation that the court knows the exact basis on which the Minister has withheld information. Presumably whatever document is furnished to the Minister by the donor will have to go to the court. We cannot have a court process where an adult child makes an application without the adult child knowing what it is he or she will confront. Some form of the objection will have to be given to the child, even if it is redacted to exclude the name and identity of the individual who has raised the objection. I am not sure why we are doing it in the Circuit Court, other than Circuit Court judges often behave better than some of our District Court judges do in giving time to deal with family cases and family issues. This is a serious practical problem but it is another day's issue. There are problems and this has not been fully thought out. There are difficulties with it.
The Minister must make a decision within 12 weeks and release the information. This cannot take place until a child is 18. If the notice goes out to an address of the donor that the donor gave at the time he donated sperm, who is to know whether the donor receives the information? Is there any provision to ensure this will be sent to an up-to-date address? There are issues which need to be teased out. I do not want to go on at any greater length, but I am not sure how well this has been thought out.
I am concerned about how legal costs will be dealt with. Let us say the Minister makes a decision to turn down an application. Subsection (3) states an appeal on notice to the Minister will be held otherwise than in public. Will notice to the Minister make the Minister a defendant in the proceedings? Let us presume I am a 20 year old who wants to obtain this information, and on the basis of something the donor has said, the Minister makes a decision I should not get information. Could I find myself in a Circuit Court application with the Minister represented by senior and junior counsel and either representing myself or being represented by a solicitor? What legal costs will arise in this process? This is an important issue.
The provision also states it will be heard otherwise than in public. This goes completely against the tenor and new ethos of the courts legislation enacted in 2013, under which family law cases or family applications can now be reported but anonymity of the people is preserved. There is a residual right on the court to exclude reportage in particular circumstances. The media have not taken it up in the manner I would have hoped they would, but some of what happens behind what used to be the closed doors of a family court is now getting some fresh air and there is some insight and limited transparency. There is no particular reason the same rule should not apply here. If there are issues around the circumstances in which information will be made available, and the anonymity of the parties needs to be preserved, information on the donor and information on birthdates should not come into the public domain, but the manner in which these applications are dealt with in the family courts and the family Circuit Court, which I presume will deal with it, should not be any more anonymous than any other type of family case. With transparency there is greater public insight into how the courts approach matters and greater insight by Members of the House as to whether laws are not working as anticipated and need to be changed. I query this.
Comment on this
The main point on this provision is it is seen as applying in very exceptional cases. The strong presumption which clearly exists throughout the Bill is in favour of release. I have been advised, in the context of establishing a register such as this, one should allow for exceptional cases and that this should be provided for legally. My legal advice is it can be done in the way I have outlined. It is not the best interest principle, in the sense we are building it in as a basic right for the child to information.
We have done this for the reasons I have already mentioned. In some ways, it is similar, if not absolutely comparable, to the position that applies in immigration, where there is ministerial discretion. While that issue arises frequently, this case would involve exceptional circumstances.
In terms of court, we have stated that the case must be heard otherwise than in public, but my understanding is that this would not preclude some aspects of the case from being made public if the court so decided. I am not sure, so I will check. This provision is to be seen as a strong presumption in favour of release while allowing for exceptional circumstances, for example, where the safety or well-being of the child or the donor could be at risk. The Minister would have to justify his or her decision if it was disputed. For the reasons I have outlined, it is important that we include this provision.
Comment on this
The only issue is that the legislation does not use the words "exceptional circumstances". It uses the term "well-being". I am very conscious of, and I want to come back to this, the desirability where possible of facilitating individuals born through assisted reproduction or through adoption to trace origins, but one has to have a robust and coherent procedure and there has to be a prescription as to how it is going to work. The Minister has not replied as to whether it is envisaged a Minister who turns down an application would effectively be the defendant or the respondent in these applications and would play a role in defending the decision or whether the Circuit Court would be at large to consider it all from the perspective of what has been submitted to the court and then make a decision. I do not know the answer to that. Perhaps that could be clarified.
I do think it is important that there is a reasoned basis for the decision. It is not simply that the Minister decides he or she is not going to release the information and there are no reasons given. There is a need for this section to delineate an obligation to detail the reasons for the decision made.
I am presuming on the other side of this, as we are dealing with this, that if a decision is made by the Minister to make the information available, the donor can appeal to the Circuit Court. Equally, where the Minister rejects the donor's objection, presumably the donor should know the reason why. If it is a one-sided appeal, that would be a very strange procedure. I am particularly concerned in circumstances where the appeal is not going to be dealt with, from what the Minister said, in the initial period when this legislation might be in force by a specialist body. It is going to be dealt with by the Minister or the Minister will make a decision based on whatever recommendation he or she may or may not get from officials in his or her office who are assigned to process these applications.
Comment on this
Let us revert to what the legislation states. Subsection (3) reads:
Where a relevant donor to whom subsection (2) applies makes representations to the Minister in accordance with that subsection, the Minister shall consider those representations and--
(a) if satisfied that sufficient reasons exist to withhold the information concerned from the donor-conceived child, shall refuse the request under subsection (1)...
This is the threshold test. There is ministerial discretion in that decision and a range of factors would be taken into account. The Minister would be the defendant, as in the other example I cited. The donor cannot appeal the decision.
Comment on this
I do not wish to prolong this unnecessarily, but if there is a range of factors to be considered, they should be detailed in the legislation. If the decision is based on "well-being", there is a need to clarify what "sufficient reasons" means or can the Minister simply say that, based on his or her perception of the well-being of the donor or the well-being of the child, he or she will or will not make this decision? I do not think it is appropriate that a mechanism is created which is designed to protect safety or designed to protect "well-being", whatever that means, where if a decision is made not to do something, the party affected by that can appeal, but where a decision is made to do something, the party affected by that cannot appeal.
Can I put it in a political context? Let us assume for a moment, as the Minister said, the bias would be to make information available, but when it comes to making a decision, a Minister cannot come to it with bias. He or she must make an objective decision based on the information furnished to him or her. Of course, one of the difficulties is how the information furnished is validated because this does not involve any form of a hearing process. It seems to be based on some form of written submission. That is a particular difficulty. If it is the type of procedure that is here envisaged - not to be obtuse about it - and a 20 or 25 year old wants information or the donor does not want information provided, the Minister is the person making the decision. It is not an independent body or authority. Does the donor or the 25 year old conceived with the assistance of donor-assisted reproduction mechanisms start knocking on the doors of the constituency clinics of individual Deputies asking them to urge the Minister to make a particular decision or not? If we are going to have this process, it should not be a ministerial process. It should be a separate authority. I do not believe that it should be brought into operation with a Minister dealing with it until the independent authority is dealing with it.