We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality

Children and Family Relationships Bill 2015: Committee Stage

Contributions 164–329 of 329. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Children and Family Relationships Bill 2015
Enacted

No. 14 of 2015 ›

The strong legal advice I have is that when setting up a register like this, one needs to make this exemption based on the type of threshold that I outlined. In light of other provisions in the Bill, we should remember that the donor has consented to the giving up of parentage and the pathway to parentage for the child. The donor has put himself or herself in that situation. One must take this point into account.

I can consider the Deputy's question on the use of the term "well-being". I will take further advice on it and revert to him on Report Stage.

Comment on this

To pick up on a point raised by Deputy Shatter regarding subsection (3)(a), will the Minister provide the reasons she is refusing to give the information to the applicant? If she believes that she does not have to give the reasons, could they be sought from the Department under freedom of information legislation?

Comment on this

No, that is not the intention.

Comment on this

So it is not intended to give the reason for the refusal.

Comment on this

As Deputy Shatter said, if a person goes to court to appeal a decision he or she will do so absolutely blind. The Minister will defend the case with junior or senior counsel, while a 25-year-old will have to go in on their own with no information as to how to argue their case. It seems unfair and ludicrous.

Comment on this

Will the information be made available to the court in those cases?

Comment on this

Yes. They have to apply to the court for the information.

Comment on this

Will the court provide information to the person appealing it?

Comment on this

I will go back to what section 33(2)(b) states:

[T]he Minister shall, 12 weeks from the date on which the notice is sent, release to the donor-conceived child the information requested, unless the relevant donor makes representations to the Minister setting out why the safety or well-being of the relevant donor or the donor-conceived child, or both, requires that the information not be released.

The committee should remember the point I made to the effect that the donor will have already signed consents on parentage at the early stage of the process when they made the donation and agreed that they were absolutely clear about the fact that the rights were being transferred to the parents involved in the procedure.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, the person in question will be going into the Circuit Court to appeal the Minister's refusal of his or her request. The Minister said the information would be made available to the court, but when does the person making the appeal get the information? Do they have to wait until they are in court? That would mean they are at a disadvantage straight away. God forbid, but if the donor was a mass murderer it would not be in the best interest of a person to have this information. I just feel the person making the appeal is completely on the wrong foot. They may be a young person with limited resources to engage a legal team and they will not have the same expertise. As the decision is made in the Department, can the information be released under FOI?

Comment on this

No. The information cannot be released under FOI. The Minister would obviously be obliged to give the information to the courts.

Comment on this

A Minister cannot secretly communicate to a court the things he or she has relied on to make a decision. If an appeal is going to be filed in the Circuit Court there has to be some ground for it. One objects to the original decision for specified reasons. If one does not know the reasoning behind a decision one cannot state the grounds of an appeal. It does not make sense.

Comment on this

Perhaps it needs to be looked at again. We have teased out a lot of issues here to which we may need to return on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I will probably table amendments to this section on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I intend to bring an amendment to this section on Report Stage to require the Minister for Health to inform a donor who has requested identifying information in relation to a donor-conceived child from the register of his refusal to release that information.

Comment on this

This section relates to information in respect of other persons to be provided to the donor-conceived child.

Comment on this

I intend to bring an amendment to this section on Report Stage to replace the term "donor-conceived sibling" with an alternative term which does not connote a legal relationship between the two donor-conceived children. While they will be conceived from gametes donated by the same donor, they will not legally be siblings.

Comment on this

I intend to bring an amendment to this section on Report Stage to create a new section after this section which would deal with the jurisdiction of the District and Circuit Court for the purposes of sections 19, 20, 29, 30 and 33.

I wish to say a few things about Part 3. I mentioned that some statistics were collected by the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology. It collates statistics in relation to AHR procedures conducted in European Union countries. The majority of the Irish fertility clinics give information to the ESHRE on a voluntary basis regarding the AHR procedures they conduct, but not all of them do. Because of the lack of legislation and regulation in this area, we cannot be absolutely definitive about the information, and it does not encompass all AHR procedures that are conducted in Ireland. The most recent statistics available are from 2010. Those figures show that there were seven IVF clinics in Ireland, of which six provided data for 2010. In 2009, six out of seven clinics provided information to the ESHRE. The data for 2010 show that there were 1,856 cycles of in vitro fertilisation and 1,320 of intracytoplasmic sperm injection. In 2009 there were 1,987 cycles of IVF and 1,328 cycles of ICSI. It should be noted that each cycle does not necessarily result in a pregnancy or the birth of a child. The numbers relate only to IVF and ICSI and not to other AHR procedures, so we do not have exact figures for the number of children born on foot of AHR procedures in Ireland. These are the most comprehensive figures I could get.

Comment on this

Will the Minister circulate that information to the members of the committee through the clerk?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 34:

In page 35, line 14, to delete "(inserted by the Act of 1987)".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:

"In page 36, line 9, after “child;”,” to insert “and”."

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 36 to 43, inclusive, 52 and 54 are related and will be discussed together. Amendment No. 38 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 37 and amendment No. 42 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 41.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:

"In page 36, to delete lines 10 to 18."

Amendment No. 36 deals with the issue of the cohabitation rule put forward by the Minister, whereby a couple has to have been cohabiting for not less than 12 consecutive months, including a period after the birth of the child of not less than three consecutive months. One of the key criticisms of the Bill that is quite widespread is the fact that it does not give automatic guardianship to the father at the time of birth. If there are any reasons someone should not be given automatic guardianship, one assumes they can be dealt with through the courts process.

When an unmarried father registers his name on a birth certificate, he assumes he will be entitled to guardianship on the basis of having his name acknowledged on the birth certificate, but that is not the case. We want to remove the conditionality in this Bill and ensure that a father who has stepped up to the plate is entitled to automatic guardianship.

We talk about teenage pregnancies and young men accepting responsibility as a father and all that comes with it. Maybe the parents do not live together and are separated from the get-go but the father pays maintenance and helps with the upbringing of the child. That is not possible in these circumstances because of the proposed legislation. There is also the issue of fathers who have to work abroad, which is a big issue in Ireland today, and who cannot physically be there. If the couple are not married they cannot comply with the criteria. I ask the Minister to accept the amendment. I ask that we work between now and Report Stage on trying to ensure there is automatic guardianship for the father, and, failing this, that the father is informed from the get-go that having his name on the birth certificate does not entitle him to automatic guardianship, and that he should seek to make a statutory declaration. I will deal later with the issue of a central register for these declarations. My own hope and that of my party is that there would be automatic guardianship. Of course, if the father was not fit to be guardian, that could be dealt with through a court case. We need full equality in parenting. The purpose of this legislation is that it reflects the diverse nature of modern families in Ireland. It also reflects the reality that about one third of children are born to unmarried mothers. If all fathers were to step up to the plate, one third of them would not be given automatic guardianship.

So much more needs to be done in respect of the wider issue of fathers' rights in terms of family law and our courts system, which has families stuck in waiting rooms with other civil cases. There are long queues, which causes distress. It would be a good start if we were to make a clear statement that the mother and father, if they are not married, have equal guardianship rights from the get-go.

Comment on this

I believe Deputy Collins also wished to speak on an amendment in this grouping, amendment No. 52.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman. I have to introduce a Bill in the Dáil so I am keeping an eye on the monitor.

Our amendment is along similar lines and is about improving the rights of unmarried fathers. We are seeking to ensure that the father of a child is aware of his rights at the time of the registration of the child. The amendment places the onus on the registrar to ensure the father is aware that the registration process is taking place, giving him an opportunity to apply for guardianship under current legislation. The amendment would, for the first time, put the onus on the State to afford the mother and father the opportunity to jointly sign the statutory declaration consenting to the appointment of the father as a joint legal guardian. Oftentimes, unmarried fathers are unaware of the importance of the registration process. We believe there is currently a great imbalance between the rights of the mother and those of the father. In some instances this imbalance is justified, but in many instances it clearly is not. The amendment seeks to address the imbalance.

Comment on this

I have certain sympathies with Deputy Mac Lochlainn's amendment. In a lot of cases, it may not be possible for the mother and father to be living together. There are teenage pregnancies where both parents could be living at home with their own parents, or the father of the child could be married to somebody else. There are difficulties. The woman could already be in receipt of the one-parent family allowance and not allowed to cohabit with her partner. It is very restrictive and does not take into account the diverse society in which we now live.

Comment on this

More than likely I will be tabling an amendment to section 40 on Report Stage regarding the fact that, under the guardianship provisions, even married fathers do not have an equal right to custody of the child if the relationship breaks up. I have to have further discussions with some legal people on this. It has partly to do with how, even in marriage, guardianship does not entail equal rights for both partners.

Comment on this

Let me begin by saying what the Bill does for unmarried fathers. As the committee is well aware, there is at present no provision in law for automatic guardianship for non-marital fathers. The legislation will introduce such a provision for some non-marital fathers. Under it, an unmarried father will automatically become the guardian of a child if he lives with the child's mother for at least 12 consecutive months, including three months after the child's birth. The policy decision was taken not to extend automatic guardianship to all unmarried fathers for a variety of reasons. Some unmarried fathers will not be involved with their children to any extent. However, the unmarried father will be able to make a statutory declaration jointly with the mother saying that he is the guardian of the child. That option remains for an unmarried father, as does the option for him to go to court to be given guardianship.

In the section dealing with the best interests of the child, the Bill specifies that the best interests of the child are the paramount consideration for the courts in such circumstances. I would point out to Deputies that one of a number of specified factors and circumstances that the court must take into account when determining the best interests of the child is the benefit to the child of having an ongoing meaningful relationship with each parent and sufficient contact with them to maintain such a relationship.

The legislation is the first recognition in Irish law of a mechanism for automatic guardianship of a child for a non-marital father.

That is the first point I want to make.

To reply to Deputy Mac Lochlainn, he should be aware that his amendment would delete the newly proposed provision which will make certain fathers automatically the guardians of their children.

Comment on this

That is not my-----

Comment on this

Sorry Deputy-----

Comment on this

I will explain that in a moment. I am disappointed with that. That was not our amendment, it was not what we submitted.

Comment on this

We will come back to it shortly. I am suspending the meeting because a vote has been called in the Dáil.

Comment on this

Chairman, are we breaking for lunch?

Comment on this

No. We will come back and break at 1.30 p.m.

Comment on this

Chairman, I have to introduce a Bill in the Dáil. I want to press my amendment but if I am not here, I will reintroduce it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Before the Deputy leaves I would make the comment that I accept the spirit of the amendment. I will introduce amendments on Report Stage on some of the key points he makes in the amendment.

Comment on this

I am advised the Deputy must nominate a colleague or somebody else to move the amendment here on his behalf in order to be able to re-table it later.

Comment on this

I am happy to do that.

Comment on this

The Minister was in possession.

Comment on this

Deputy Mac Lochlainn wanted to make a point about this but just to say that the effect of the deletion would be to maintain the status quo, that the only fathers who are guardians are the child's marital father or a father who makes a statutory declaration with the child's mother appointing him as guardian, or a father who obtains a court order appointing him as guardian under section 6A of the 1964 Act.

I am very conscious of the desire to improve the position of other natural fathers, and I am investigating ways of achieving that. However, this deletion will simply mean that a substantial number of non-marital fathers will not now benefit from the new provision which would enable them to become guardians automatically without taking any further action.

Are we also dealing with Deputy Collins' amendment?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

As I said at the outset, there was a good deal of discussion on this during the course of the Second Stage debate in the Dáil. Subject to some particular comments I want to make, I can accept the spirit of the amendment. These comments are, first, that the information on guardianship proposed in the draft subsection (5)(c) is specific in regard to a court application under the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964. It may put registrars in a difficult position if they are required to give information to new parents on possible adversarial processes.

I am keen that parents have information, but the information which should be provided is confined to the fact that the father is not a guardian unless he takes further steps. I also intend to provide for registrars to have the power to witness statutory declarations. They are not in a meaningful position to carry out any form of welfare or best interest test. Further work will be necessary before establishing a register or repository on the basis of guardianship declarations being made in a variety of places. On the basis of the commitment I am making to bring forward a Report Stage amendment, I ask the Deputy not to press the amendment.

Comment on this

The amendment we submitted was "after line 10, to delete section 40(b) in its entirety" so, unfortunately, what has been presented as our amendment is not the one we submitted. That is unfortunate. We do not propose to remove section 40(a) but rather section 40(b). That is out of our control but we will resubmit the amendment and ensure it is worded properly the next time. As we are speaking to amendment No. 39, I will be moving it on behalf of the relevant Deputy. I would like to see it implemented. The Minister has not outlined why she believes automatic guardianship should not be given. Once a father has his name on a birth certificate, why can that automatic guardianship not be given?

Comment on this

I welcome the legislation and the new provisions in it, and I have listened to the comments. As a Deputy, I meet many fathers who do not get any or adequate access to their children, particularly if a couple does not get on. The people may be separated, for example, and the issue is that the parents do not regularly see the children. I know courts can make decisions in this regard. Is there any implicit recognition in this legislation of a right to see the child? I know there are legal issues with the likes of barring orders and so on. One of the commonest complaints I hear from fathers is that they have nowhere to bring a child even if they have access. Poorer families in particular might have to walk in Drogheda or Dundalk on a Saturday or Sunday or go to the back of a pub or inappropriate places. These people want to bond with children but cannot do so in such places. I recently visited the Tusla centre in Drogheda and there is a special room for provision. Could the State do more to assist parents in such difficult positions? Often, if these men are not living at home, they are living in very poor accommodation or apartment complexes. They are often in very difficult financial circumstances. It is an issue for a number of my constituents.

Comment on this

We are on the next section but we can allow that as a general contribution.

Comment on this

What was striking about the Second Stage debate was that people spoke about automatic guardianship involving the father, and almost everybody who talked about it also spoke about exceptional circumstances in which a mother could find herself with respect to the father's role. For example, people mentioned cases of domestic violence and many called for exceptions to be made if the pregnancy was a result of rape. A variety of circumstances were cited by Deputies who spoke on the Bill. Many family law practitioners would have a particular concern about the issue. Nevertheless, it is a very real area for consideration. The approach we have taken in the Bill is to link the automatic right to cohabitation for a specific period. It is the first time this is being dealt with in legislation.

For non-married fathers who go to court seeking guardianship, the vast majority of such requests are granted but a percentage are not granted where the courts do not consider it in the best interests of the child to have the father as a guardian. That is because conferring guardianship has specific effects. If a father is not on the scene or involved, his failure to exercise guardianship responsibilities has real consequences for the child and mother. The mother would have to apply to court to dispense with the consent of the father to the issue of a passport, with related implications. It would be extremely difficult to place the child for adoption or for the mother to adopt the child jointly with a new partner if the father did not consent to the adoption. However, all of these issues would in such a context be very carefully considered with respect to the best interests of the child. Other considerations would also apply.

I will go through some other concerns in detail. If a mother decided to relocate with a child, her legal position and authority to do so would be unclear as a guardian has the right of custody within the meaning of the Hague Convention on international child abduction or the Brussels II bis regulation. These are very vital protections where both parents are involved with the child's life, but they could be problematic for a mother and child if a father with no involvement with the child had an effective veto. These are real and potentially serious implications of automatic guardianship, and that is not to speak of some of the other issues I discussed.

I am therefore proposing an amendment. There is a real problem in that many fathers, especially young fathers, are not aware that they can sign a statutory declaration in front of a peace commissioner or a commissioner for oaths that would give them guardianship rights. There is a real information deficit with this issue, and that is a clear opinion of all the non-governmental organisations working in the area and speaking about it. A number of Deputies have raised the point and argued that it should be easier and more straightforward for fathers in that position to know their rights and be able to exercise and vindicate those rights through a statutory declaration. That relates to cases where a mother does not object, because where there is conflict, there would be a court hearing.

Perhaps I can give a further indication of the Report Stage amendment I intend to introduce, as it may be helpful to the discussion. I have gone into some detail already. The purpose of this Report Stage amendment relating to guardianship is to enable registers to witness a statutory declaration by which the father can be appointed a guardian at a time when a couple is registering a child's birth or within a short period afterwards. Treoir and a number of other organisations made submissions in this regard. This statutory declaration mechanism is easy, straightforward and inexpensive. The principal difficulty for many non-marital parents is that most are not aware of the existence of this mechanism. This amendment would ensure that a couple would have necessary information and can make an informed choice on whether the father should be a guardian. Subject to legal advice, it is possible that the Report Stage amendment will amend the Civil Registration Act 2004.

I also plan, and will say so on Report Stage, that I will review this issue in two years time, at which time it will be possible to consider the impact of the proposals in this Bill to make it easier for non-marital fathers to complete a statutory declaration. We can see what the result of that has been and whether we are seeing the kind of increases we would expect to see. Many people who have looked at this area feel that the information and the access to the statutory declaration is one of the big barriers. I believe that with the combination of initiatives in this Bill, we are moving forward substantially in regard to the rights of non-marital fathers.

Comment on this

I draw the Minister's attention to the fact that her amendments Nos. 38 and 42 are part of this grouping if she wishes to discuss them.

Comment on this

She has an opportunity to comment now because once the amendment is put, we cannot go back on them again.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 38 is a minor drafting revision and I wish to move amendment No. 42.

Comment on this

The Minister can move it when we reach it but we are discussing them at this stage.

Comment on this

The Minister has suggested that she will not concede on the cohabitants rule in terms of guardianship. However, she will entitle somebody who has not complied with that criteria, and is not going to, the opportunity to make a statutory declaration at the time of the birth certificate. Does one provision not contradict the other? Have I missed something?

Comment on this

That is right. I am not removing the cohabitation requirement. I am moving the-----

Comment on this

That is not the question I asked. Perhaps I have not phrased my question properly. If the Minister is saying she will bring in amendments that will allow for a father, at the time of the name going on a birth certificate, also to make a statutory declaration which would obviously, I assume, give him guardianship rights, why would one also need a cohabitants rule along with that? Have I missed something? Why is that provision necessary?

Comment on this

One is automatic and the other is not. Is that right?

Comment on this

Does one provision not overrule the other?

Comment on this

It is in parallel. Once one has the statutory declaration, clearly one has the guardianship rights. There will be fathers who will not do so at that point. If they do not, then the other provisions continue to apply. The statutory declaration gives one the guardianship rights.

Comment on this

I can see what the Deputy is trying to say. There is a provision at the moment that the father can be granted guardianship rights by the mother. What the Minister is suggesting, I think, is that guardianship will be made known more clearly and explicitly at the time of the birth of the child. If that happens, then the cohabitation provision will not apply because the father will be a guardian by virtue of the declaration.

Comment on this

The Minister is saying what happens when a father steps up to the plate and is there, although the couple might not be living together, and is putting his name on the birth certificate. It is at that point that the registrar will inform both parents that they can choose to avail of a declaration of guardianship. If that happens, then the cohabitancy rule does not apply because one has made a declaration at that point. If, for whatever reason, a father has not done so, then the cohabitants rule applies.

I assume that the Minister intends to hold a public information campaign. I presume there will be a visible poster for everyone to see when they go into the registry office, as well as that a person in the registry will be obliged to say to people when registering that they should be aware that a father does not have automatic guardianship and if they wish to have it, he can make a declaration there and then. The Minister has suggested that is way and that if a person has not done so at that point, this provision would kick in then.

Comment on this

To clarify, that is precisely the situation. Quite a number of Deputies and organisations working in this area have spoken about the need for better information to be available to fathers, for example, in maternity hospitals and when the mother is registering the birth, and that there should be information leaflets available advertising such information and very obvious things. There is clearly an information deficit in this area. The provisions are obviously responding to those suggestions.

I have also had some contact with the Department of Social Protection which is supportive of this provision. The provision is not by any means saying there is automatic guardianship for non-marital fathers. It simply takes an initiative in this area that will ensure that more fathers would be aware of the statutory declaration. It also makes it easier for them at the point where they could do so, when the family or mother and father are registering the birth of the child.

Comment on this

There is a legal requirement now that the father's name goes on the birth certificate. If the parents have not been cohabiting, for whatever reason as we outlined earlier, can the mother of the child object to the father's application for statutory guardianship? Is there any way to stop him? If he wants to sign a statutory guardianship declaration to say he wants to be a guardian of his child, can the mother of the child object to him signing such a declaration?

Comment on this

One cannot make a statutory declaration in the situation of a non-marital father unless the mother agrees.

Comment on this

What happens if the mother does not agree for whatever reason? There are many reasons.

Comment on this

That is precisely what happens at present. The father must go to court where a decision is made. This Bill is based on the best interests of the child and a range of considerations apply, including the ongoing relationship that the child would have with both parents. My understanding is that the vast majority of guardianships in those circumstances are granted in the courts but not all are. Clearly, there are cases where the court considers that it is not in the best interest of the child to go in that direction.

Comment on this

I find it difficult to accept this. If a couple has cohabited for 12 months of which three months can be after the birth of the child, which means nine months beforehand, the father of the child gets automatic guardianship. I have serious doubts about that provision although I do not oppose it. I have serious doubts as to why 12 months' residency or cohabiting qualifies somebody to be the automatic guardian of the child. I am reminded of the old saying, if you want to know me then come and live with me. The mother of the child may have better and more reasons, after that period, for denying guardianship than when the child is born and the father applies. Does the Minister understand what I am saying?

Comment on this

This is the kernel of the issue. There are very different views on this point. Some jurisdictions have automatic guardianship for non-marital fathers while others do not. Other jurisdictions use a variety of criteria or mechanisms. The situation varies quite substantially. We had this debate in the Dáil where some people asked, as Deputy Ferris has done so, about those circumstances where the involvement of the father may not be in the best interest of the child and where that only emerges after a certain period. Obviously in the legislation we are taking important steps.

Given that one third of children are born outside of marriage in this country, this position affects many fathers. We are saying in the Bill that it should not automatic but that where a father is living with the mother three months after the birth and these circumstances have been met, the father then would have automatic guardianship. As we can see, people will also say the stipulated time is not long enough. At what point does one decide that the father could have automatic guardianship? Does one say one year, two years, three years or does one just say it is an inherent right that a father should have? That is the issue we are grappling with here and there are very different views on the matter.

Comment on this

I agree that it is difficult.

Comment on this

Even though this cohabitation rule is being proposed and despite the fact that the Minister states it will entitle the father to automatic guardianship, if he is the perpetrator of domestic abuse or a criminal, then it will not be automatic and the mother of the child will be in a position to go to court and have his right to guardianship quashed. That is why I do not believe this provision to be necessary. At its core, this is a matter of equality. Like many others, I am arguing that the mother and father should begin as equal guardians to the child. If there is a good reason the mother objects to the father being a guardian, then she should take her case to the courts. If she is found to be in the right, then I presume the court will not grant guardianship to the father. The difficulty now is that the father must ask permission from the mother to be granted his equal rights. That is not fair. The cohabitation rule is a distraction. The core issue is that the father must approach the mother to be granted equality. If she agrees, then all will be well. If she does not, however, he will be obliged to take her to court.

I feel very strongly about this matter. As public representatives, we have all been obliged to deal with fathers who have needed to have recourse to the courts. I accept that there are terrible fathers and men who have no right to claim the title "father". However, there are also very good fathers who have been exasperated as a result of their need to undergo the legal process just to exercise their right to be parents to their children. If we get this right, we will send a clear signal to the effect that we are of the view that mothers and fathers are equal from the outset. If an issue arises, then the mother, or indeed the father, will be able to take a case before the courts to state that the other person involved should not have guardianship rights. The courts, which are independent, should decide these issues. I ask the Minister to reconsider the position on the cohabitation rule and examine the possibility of granting automatic guardianship from the outset.

Comment on this

I am conscious of the time and we stated earlier that we would suspend proceedings at 1.30 p.m. Perhaps we will dispose of this amendment and the section before taking a break. The next section relates to the courts. We have teased out the matters to which the amendment relates to quite a degree at this stage. Do members want to discuss the issues involved further?

Comment on this

I just wish to make the point that I plan to bring forward an amendment on Report Stage to include in this section the definition of "enforcement orders" used in the new sections 18A to 18D, inclusive, which section 56 inserts into the 1964 Act.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Mac Lochlainn intend to press the amendment?

Comment on this

Yes. I apologise about the wording. I have already clarified that the wording, as presented, is not that which we submitted. I intend to press the amendment. I was inclined to call a vote on the matter but the wording precludes me from doing so because it does not reflect what I was seeking to achieve.

Comment on this

How stands the amendment?

Comment on this

On reflection, and through no fault of our office, the wording does not reflect what we were seeking to achieve. As a result, I will not press the amendment. I will resubmit it in a different form on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I wish to give the Chairman notice that I intend to raise a range of issues in respect of the section.

Comment on this

If that is the case, we will suspend proceedings for lunch.

Comment on this

I want to raise some matters. This seems to be the first section dealing with the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964 in the Bill and it seems to also be partially a definitions section. I want to just repeat something that I said in the Dáil on Second Stage. I believe it is good legislative practice that we try to keep what is a fairly complex area as legislatively clear as possible. I really do not understand why the Bill does not simply repeal all of the relevant provisions in the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964 and the Status of Children Act 1987 that relate to guardianship and custody of children and do what the original draft Bill did, which was incorporate all relevant provisions in the one piece of legislation. I think that, when we are dealing with section 40, we see how additional complexities arise as a consequence of that because of the multiple amendments having to be made to the 1964 Act. I still do not understand why that change has been effected. The only reason I heard mentioned was in case we left something important out that was in the 1964 Act - if there is something important in the 1964 Act that needs to be retained, it could have all been retained. If we adopted this approach to legislation, which is epitomised by section 40, we would never have enacted the Adoption Act 2010 and would have just done a series of amendments to all of the preceding adoption legislation. We would not have enacted the Freedom of Information Act 2014, which replaces all of the previous legislation in that area. I just do not understand why we have made this more complex than it needs be.

In relation to the specifics of the section, in so far as it is amending the 1964 Act, there are, and have been since 1964, definition deficiencies in the 1964 Act where concepts are not adequately defined. The Law Reform Commission, when it was looking at this area of the law, recommended certain changes. A part of the changes it recommended was a change of terminology so that we replicated here the terminology that they have adopted in England. That is not appropriate and certainly was not appropriate after the constitutional referendum relating to children. It is right that we retain the terminology we have, but the issues in particular that were dealt with in some of the draft legislation which are excluded - I do not understand why they are excluded - are important definitions of concepts people think they are familiar with but which are normally defined in similar legislation in nearly all the other common law jurisdictions with which I am familiar. I want to raise these particular definitions and suggest they be incorporated by the Minister on Report Stage.

The first is the concept of access. We were discussing access previously. There was a definition of "access" in the measure that this committee previously looked at, which said, "'access', in relation to a child, includes the right of the child to maintain personal relations and contact with a parent and relatives or other person with a bona fide interest in the child on a regular basis except where such access is not in the best interests of the child". What that did by way of a definition which could be incorporated into section 40 as an amendment of the 1964 Act was make it clear that access was the right of a child as opposed to simply the privilege of a parent or the entitlement or right of a parent. There have been court decisions which have described "access" as the right of a child. The definition recognised that the access or contact that a child had not only included the right of the child to maintain personal relations and contact with the parent, but also with relations. I think that is important because, when relationships collapse, all of us as public representatives learn of circumstances where, in the marital war or parental war that follows people's relationships collapsing, important people with whom a child has contact are often cut off, like grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins and others within the family. Later provisions of the legislation allow for relations to make applications for access, but there is a need to define what we mean by "access". That is a modern definition which reflects the approach taken in a series of other countries.

We also do not have a definition of "custody". Everyone thinks he or she knows what the concept of custody means. One of the great areas of difficulty when relationships break down is, if one parent is awarded custody, the other parent thinks he or she has no further involvement or engagement with his or her children. While the concepts of custody and guardianship have been used for some centuries, they are not adequately defined in Irish law. There is a need to define the concept of custody and be clear on what we mean by it. We reference it in the legislation; it is not defined. The definition that was previously before this committee stated as follows: "'custody', in relation to a child, includes the provision of day-to-day care of a child, to protect and supervise the child and the right to provide a residence for the child and may include providing such care for one or more specified days or parts of days". On some occasions, parents have joint custody. They share the custody of a child and a child can live with one parent for a period of the week and the other parent for another period of the week. We do not have a definition. Unless I am missing something, it seems that the definition has been dropped out of the legislation. Again, I do not understand why.

Turning to the final issue that I want to mention in this context, I cannot think of where else I can reference it other than in the conversation that we might have on section 41, so if the Chairman wants to pull me up when I-----

Comment on this

I do. We will reach section 41 shortly.

Comment on this

This is a definitional issue around what the concept of guardianship means.

Comment on this

We will get to that in a minute.

Comment on this

I am quite happy to discuss it under section 41.

Comment on this

If the Deputy speaks then, that will be fine. Does the Minister wish to respond to any of the issues raised about the definitions of "custody" and "access"?

Comment on this

Yes. We took a different approach to the development of the legislation. We decided that, instead of repealing the guardianship Act, we would amend it in this Bill in the way that has been outlined. That different approach had implications for other sections of the Bill and some of these definitions. My legal advice was that no new definition was required or advisable in our approach to the Bill.

This is a contentious area in the courts. A number of broader points were made by Deputies in the course of the Second Stage debate. In light of the new initiatives contained in the Bill, many Deputies made the point that how children and families were dealt with in the court system needed to be improved and court welfare services for parents needed to be developed.

I take the Deputy's point on the definitions of "access" and "custody". The decision to amend rather than repeal was taken. This is a large Bill and has involved a significant amount of work. I wish to take this opportunity to thank the Attorney General and all of her staff who have been working on it for months on end to address the range of issues it encompasses. While I take the Deputy's suggestion about including further definitions, it was decided to amend rather than repeal, and my advice was that the concepts of access and custody were well understood in the context of the 1964 Act.

Comment on this

With due respect, to say that makes no sense whatsoever. I am sorry to phrase it that way. If the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964 remained exactly as it was with no amendments, there would still be a need for us to finally have a definition of these concepts. They are defined worldwide in legislation dealing with the custody, care and upbringing of children. In my view, the entire Act should have been repealed. On occasion I have had to wrestle with the approach of the Attorney General's office to particular pieces of legislation. The drafting of the Bill would have been simpler if the Minister had not travelled the route she has taken, yet even travelling that route, there is no logic in the suggestion that these concepts should remain undefined.

The concept of access, as the courts have generally perceived it, has largely been applicable to the relationship between a child and parents. This legislation does something very important in recognising the role that relations can play in a child's life. There is a need for us to provide a modern definition of access, as opposed to allowing it to remain a concept that is referenced in court judgments in various formats and differing half-definitions. Some judges have tried to define access as something that is the right of a child. It makes no sense that in 2015 we are enacting a piece of legislation of this nature while the basic concepts of access and custody are not defined.

There also is a need to define them because there is enormous confusion on the part of parents as to what the concept of custody means. I am going to talk about guardianship later on. Once one parent concedes custody to the other in a court or mediation context, perhaps in circumstances in which it may not be practical for him or her to look after the child on a day-to-day basis, he or she is conceding a whole range of other things on which it is important to be consulted, such as the child's health, education, cultural engagement or religious upbringing. The parent who obtains custody believes that, because he or she has custody, he or she can exclude the other parent from engagement on such issues. In order to reduce the level of family embattlement that takes place when relationships break down, there is a great advantage in having a clear definition of custody, such that people understand it to mean that the child is physically being cared for by one parent, without meaning that that parent should not consult with the other parent, who has a good relationship with the child, on some of the fundamental decisions to be made about the child's life.

One of the difficulties have I found as a practising lawyer, particularly in the District Court, is that judges often do not themselves distinguish between guardianship and custody, and are confused about it. To get over the sense some parents have that they are to be disengaged from their child's life entirely when the other parent is granted custody, there are occasions when judges make orders of joint custody that do not involve the child living part of the time with one parent and part of the time with the other. They make an order of joint custody and detail that the child should primarily reside with one of the parents. That is just a custody order. Even the Judiciary can be confused as to what on earth custody means, particularly at the lower levels. I have seen it on multiple occasions in 30 years of practice as a family lawyer. It is extraordinary how this is a continuing and prevailing difficulty.

I ask the Minister to reconsider this on Report Stage, because it makes no sense. I do not know what advice could be legitimately given to suggest, even given the somewhat complex structure that has now been adopted, that it would do some damage to include the definitions I have suggested or some reasonable variant of them. That is an issue on which the Attorney General's office should be further engaged. I presume we are stuck with the structure that is here, but I would dearly love to know why we are preserving a piece of legislation that contains some provisions - I do not have the 1964 Act with me, but from memory I think they are in Part III - that have been redundant for decades. Why are we not providing a modern legal framework in its entirety? We should have one piece of legislation that people can go to - namely, the legislation dealing with guardianship, custody of and access to children - rather than having to stray through myriad different pieces of legislation, with sections of one Act amending another Act that amends another Act. It is bad legislative practice and it is also unfair to assume that when we legislate this way, everyone who practises in the area, including the Judiciary, will necessarily find their way through the legislative maze that is created.

Comment on this

When we are reporting back to the Dáil, all of these issues can be taken into account. Colleagues can also put forward amendments on Report Stage.

Comment on this

In terms of the legal advice that has been made available to me and the work that has been done on this over the last weeks and months, I am advised that the direction in which we are going in the Bill allows the widespread understanding of these terms to be retained. The new provisions allow for flexibility to expand the understanding of these concepts. The decision to approach it in this way must be taken in the context of some of the other provisions in the Bill that are helpful in terms of the types of decision the Deputy is saying have to be taken in court. I understand and recognise that they are very complex decisions, but if we look at the best interests provision in Part 5 of the Bill----

Comment on this

We will move on to that in a minute.

Comment on this

I just want to make the point that clearly, the criteria the courts now have to guide them - and it is not an exhaustive list - include the types of factors and circumstances one would take into account when making decisions about access and custody. For example, the benefit to the-----

Comment on this

Before we stray into section 41, I would like to dispose of section 40, and then we can talk about section 41 in its entirety.

Comment on this

I have one or two other points to make in response to the points that were raised.

What I have just said is a key point, because if we combine that and see the provisions that are there in terms of the range of factors that need to be taken into account when deciding on the best interests of the child, clearly they would be very helpful in terms of making decisions on access and custody. That is the point about the best interests provision. The Deputy would be very familiar with the fact that on occasion, repeals of entire Acts have resulted in inadvertent deletion of provisions it was intended to retain. Clearly, a factor in preparing for this legislation was that the 1964 Act, as everybody on this committee knows, is embedded in Irish law and is in daily use in the courts. While preparing this Bill, we decided this was the way to go at this point, given a whole range of considerations.

Comment on this

If I may give a one-line response to that, the references that were made to what comprises the best interests of the child were substantially taken from legislation in Australia and Canada, where it works particularly well and where the legislation is very up-to-date. In both of those jurisdictions, as in England, these concepts of access and custody are defined and are complementary to each other, as opposed to getting in the way of one another.

Comment on this

We have made that point very well. Perhaps we can put forward definitions to be considered on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Deputy Shatter has indicated that he would like to make some points on section 41, to which no amendments have been proposed. This section provides for the best interests of child to be paramount.

Comment on this

This is a good and important section. I want to return to the issue of guardianship as well. It is important that we have an extended description of the obligations - perhaps "responsibilities" is a better word - and rights of guardians. I will not detain the committee by reciting what was in head 36 of the draft Bill that this committee considered last year. That particular provision reflected global best practice in jurisdictions that have the most up-to-date legislation dealing with children.

It is particularly important in the context of relationships that have broken down to specify the rights and obligations of parents and to ensure the custodial parent involves the other parent in fundamental issues relating to children. I made a point in the Dáil about what happens in a small number of instances when relationships break down. This does not apply to the majority of parents who behave responsibly when relationships break down by trying to protect their children from difficulties. Most custodial parents try to maintain a good relationship with the non-custodial parent where it is in the best interests of the children to do so, but I am afraid that some parents do not behave in this manner. Some parents go to war with each other. Mothers create problems for fathers, or fathers create problems for mothers. Some parents simply try to destroy the relationship between the child and the estranged parent.

The provision in the draft Bill to which I have referred was an important one. It stated:

In exercising or continuing to exercise the duties, powers, rights and responsibilities of a guardian in relation to a child, a guardian of the child shall act jointly (in particular by consulting wherever practicable with the aim of securing agreement) with any other guardian of the child.

Such a provision has not been included in the Bill before the committee. The draft version of the Bill further provided:

Except where otherwise stated by way of court order, each guardian is entitled –

(a) to be informed of and consulted about and to make all significant decisions affecting the child in the exercise of the powers, rights and responsibilities of guardianship derived in subhead (5), and

(b) to have sufficient contact with the child to exercise those powers, rights and responsibilities.

Under the draft Bill, each guardian would have a responsibility to "nurture the child’s physical, psychological, emotional, intellectual, social and other personal development " and to "ensure the child is properly maintained and supported and is provided with necessary medical care, food, clothing, accommodation and access to appropriate education".

A range of matters were detailed in head 36 and the subheads that were published. I emphasise that these measures were not reinventing the wheel. They were based on best practice in other jurisdictions. It was considered not only that they improved the law and provided clarity, but also that they helped to create an ethos in which the courts would encourage co-operation between estranged parents in the interests of children. Those provisions represent a statutory roadmap, to some extent, in so far as they could very well be included in a very reasonable leaflet indicating to estranged parents that each of them has particular rights and responsibilities and that they need to co-operate in the best interests of their children by approaching matters as detailed. I presume I will be told that these provisions are not being included in this legislation because they were not in the 1964 Act. I am afraid that does not make any sense. If we were simply trying to keep the 1964 Act in place, some of the other changes that we are happily implementing would not be part of the legislation.

I am raising this not simply in my capacity as a politician but as someone who practised in the area of family law for over 30 years. I used to spend large parts of my time trying to persuade people who wanted to go to war with each other to deal with each other in a more civilised way in the best interests of their children. There were occasions when it was extraordinarily difficult for them to gain that insight. This legislation envisages that parents who are not co-operating might avail of parental counselling services or certain other support services. In that context, it would be extremely useful for the obligations of parents, as well as their rights, to be set out in a straightforward, easily understandable linguistic framework that would be part and parcel of this legislation.

Comment on this

It might be helpful to the discussion to point out that section 45 of this Bill, which inserts a new section 6C into the 1964 Act, is linked to the points that have just been made. It gives the court the power to appoint a person other than the parent as a guardian. It spells out in detail the rights and responsibilities of the guardian. The proposed new section 6C(11) of the 1964 Act provides that those rights and responsibilities are to:

(a) decide on the child’s place of residence;

(b) make decisions regarding the child’s religious, spiritual, cultural and linguistic upbringing;

(c) decide with whom the child is to live;

(d) consent to medical, dental and other health related treatment for the child, in respect of which a guardian's consent is required;

(e) consent under section 14 of the Passports Act 2008 to the issue of a passport to the child;

(f) place the child for adoption.

These key rights are clearly spelled out in the legislation. We have dealt with the point that guardians must act jointly. That does not always mean consulting on all decisions, especially those which are urgent. If we were to draft the legislation in a different way - a stronger way - it could cast into doubt the right of the guardian to make any decision unilaterally. That was the legal advice I received about the way this could be dealt with in legislation. Of course I realise, not least from my own practice as a social worker over many years, that these decisions are extremely difficult and complicated. I am aware that a range of relationships and competing rights come into play. I have always acknowledged Deputy Shatter's major contribution to this legislation. I think it will give us further enhanced powers, not least because the definition of "best interest" is dealt with in much more detail than ever before in legislation. That will be very helpful because it will ensure the courts have further legislation on which to rely in order to make the best decisions for children in these very difficult family relationship situations.

Comment on this

I would like to give a brief response. The very content of the section referenced by the Minister is causing me the greatest puzzlement because some of it reflects the provisions I mentioned. It is extraordinarily perverse that we are spelling out the rights and obligations of third parties who are named as guardians by the courts without defining or spelling out in detail what being a guardian actually means to a child's parents. It really does not make sense. I would like to see the best possible legislation here. I have no interest beyond ensuring we have the best possible legislation that protects the best interests of the child and provides absolute clarity for parents regarding their rights and responsibilities. Most parents in happy families do not need to be told that. It is of particular importance where parents are estranged. It is distinctly odd to set out the rights and responsibilities of third parties who have been made guardians by the courts without also delineating the rights and responsibilities of parents as guardians, especially given that this is done in legislation worldwide. I just cannot fathom why we are doing this.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy might table some amendments on Report Stage. I call the Minister for some final remarks. We have given this a good run at this stage.

Comment on this

These are rights for full guardians obviously. The important point is that the Act allows flexibility in terms of the other decisions that guardians have to make. It is important to note that point.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 37 is in the name of Deputy Pádraig Mac Lochlainn. I advise that if amendment No. 37 is agreed then amendment No. 38 cannot be moved. Amendment No. 37 has already been discussed with amendment No. 36.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:

In page 37, to delete line 38, and in page 38, to delete line 1.

I shall withdraw my amendment because the Bills Office worded it wrongly. I shall resubmit my properly worded amendment for the next round.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:

In page 38, line 1, to delete “woman who gave birth to” and substitute “mother of”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:

In page 38, between lines 2 and 3, to insert the following:

“(2) A man who is the biological father of a child shall have an automatically guaranteed guardianship, when deemed suitable in accordance with this Act and he has willingly made his interest known in being a guardian.”.

Amendment put and declared lost.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:

In page 38, to delete line 7.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 41:

In page 38, to delete lines 9 to 14.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 42:

In page 38, line 12, after “three” to insert “consecutive”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:

In page 38, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:

“Central Register for Statutory Declarations for Joint Guardianship

6C. The Minister shall cause to be established and maintained a register to be known as the Central Register for Statutory Declarations for Joint Guardianship, the purpose of which is to provide protection for the statutory declaration documents which grant guardianship rights to unmarried fathers in respect of their children.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:

In page 39, line 11, to delete “view” and substitute “views”.

Amendment agreed to.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 45:

In page 39, line 17, to delete “subsection (4)” and substitute “subsection (7)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:

In page 40, line 5, to delete “interest” and substitute “interests”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 47:

In page 42, line 2, to delete “duties” and substitute “responsibilities”.

Comment on this

I intend to amend section 45 on Report Stage. Relating to the restrictions on guardians appointed by the court under section 6C or temporary guardians under 6E, certain functions are reserved from those guardians unless the court expressly confers them. Some additional restrictions are required in relation to consents a guardian may provide including: the taking of samples; repealing section 3(2)(e) of the Protection of Children (Hague Convention) Act 2000; and aligning the language in the inserted section 6E(5) with that in 6E(1) and (3) which refers to serious illness and injury. I intend to amend these on Report Stage.

SECTION 46

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:

In page 44, line 20, to delete “the surviving parent” and substitute “a parent of the child”.

Comment on this

I wish to signal that I plan to table a Report Stage amendment on this section. It will provide for a further amendment of section 8 of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964. The amendment will allow a person to apply to the court for a declaration that he or she is a guardian by operation of the law.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:

In page 47, lines 2 to 4, to delete all words from and including “by—” in line 2 down to and including “(b) the” in line 4 and substitute “by the”.

Comment on this

There are provisions in this section which are important and very welcome. They prescribe how to deal with difficulties that arise when a parent fails to comply with a custody or access order and, effectively, this legislation will deal with the issue of access.

There is provision for a parent who has financially lost out. For example, attending or arranging to meet a child for access but for some reason, or rather the other parent obstructs that. One parent can be required to compensate the other for whatever financial loss, the parent can be given alternative or substitute access, and he or she can be required to attend a parenting programme or family counselling. All of this is very worthwhile and works well in Australia. The provisions here substantially reflect the provisions in the Australian family law Act.

With the Australian family law Act, in Australia they discovered that all of this was right and well but there were groups of parents who were so entrenched that it simply did not work. One can urge people to go to parental counselling or to participate in some sort of family counselling or parenting programme, or one might even force one parent to pay the other parent the cost of the bus fare for an abandoned access that does not take place. It is important that we realise there is a small group of parents who set out to destroy the relationship children have with the other parent when a marriage or relationship has collapsed. It does not have to be marriage, people may have been cohabiting together, but one or both parents can go to war with each other.

Sometimes it is simply one and sometimes it is both, and the children are in the middle of it. When this happens, the judges are frequently out of their depth. They find family cases difficult to deal with. In practice, when parents conduct themselves in this way, judges will normally urge on multiple occasions a parent to abide by court orders. I have seen judges threaten to transfer custody of a child from one parent to the other where the custodial parent is clearly misbehaving, but very often that is not an appropriate order to make because the parent who is anxious to have access to a child either does not have the accommodation where a child could live or they are at work and it is not practical that they have the day-to-day care of the child. There can be a whole range of reasons that it does not work.

I have seen on occasion judges literally tearing their hair out to resolve problems. When people are on civil legal aid through one of the Government law centres and where one parent, for example, can afford a lawyer and the other cannot, and the parent with the lawyer decides to go to war with the other parent, there is the risk that the law centre would just throw its hands up and the parent who is experiencing difficulties in spending time with his or her children finds they cannot even get legal representation to make their case to a court. On occasion, judges just lose their temper with everyone, and where one parent is misbehaving and the other is behaving properly, the judge just does not want to know and will not listen to either of them, to the detriment of the children and the parent whose contact with the children is being obstructed.

That long introduction is about saying there is no point in having all of this in the Bill if there is no sanction the courts can impose where one has a recalcitrant parent. The only sanction the courts can impose at present is they can send parents to prison. No one wants to see parents sent to prison. Judges, understandably, are enormously reluctant to do that and in circumstances where it is the custodial parent who is misbehaving and the other parent does not have the capacity to care for a child for some of the reasons I gave, that is not even a practical option and it is not in the interests of the children that that occur.

Other jurisdictions have tried a variety of different ways of dealing with the situation. One is that parents can be fined, so as opposed to simply paying someone back the cost of the bus fare or the cost of the petrol to drive out for an access visit that never takes place, the courts can impose a fine. Often, where marriages or relationships have broken down there is limited finance so imposing a fine may not be a great option and indeed it may affect the children because there may be less money in the household, but it is one of the options that should be there because there are circumstances where people have gone to war where it is not a financial matter, they are just at war with each other, and the court should have sanctions as an option. The court should have an option, for example, to require the recalcitrant parent to do community service. It does not put them in prison or cost them money but takes up some of their spare time. They could be doing the community a service while the other parent is having access. There is a need for some form of sanction that falls short of imprisonment. Some suggestions were put in the draft Bill for the consultative process on which I expected people would have different views, but it seems there is now no sanction if one does not comply, other than the one I mentioned - that one might be required to pay someone back the cost of their missed visit.

If a court takes a view that two parents together, or one who is creating a difficulty, should go to parental counselling and the court makes that order under this arrangement and the parent simply does not co-operate, the question is what is to happen next. I am asking the Minister that question. If the court orders that parents should go to family counselling together and one parent turns up and the other does not, the question is what is to happen next. If they both turn up and one is just abusive of the other at the family counselling as opposed to trying to work through issues to the benefit of the children, what is to happen next? An answer is required in that regard for this to work, and to improve the predicament that some estranged parents find themselves in, which is enormously to the detriment of children.

The other thing I have learned from 30 years of family law experience is that I can recall circumstances where I represented estranged spouses in the late 1970s and early 1980s who went to war with each other and where one spouse set out to destroy the relationship of the children with the other spouse. I was long enough as a lawyer to subsequently represent the adult children of those people who themselves were in a dysfunctional relationship because they had been damaged as children by the way their own parents conducted themselves, and now they were damaged in their relationship and they were now behaving in exactly the same way because that is all they knew. This is not just about particular couples; it is about a cycle of family dysfunction that needs to be broken.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to respond to that interesting point?

Comment on this

Yes. The provisions in 18A and 18D of section 56 are very carefully balanced to address the issue, which is that we want to enable children to have meaningful relationships with both parents. The mechanisms we have here seek to change a parent’s behaviour, obviously not to penalise the child. It would be very traumatic for a child if a member of the Garda were to enter the house and remove the child by force to bring him or her to the other parent. We clearly want to see a situation where the court has increased powers to ensure that the parents are not in contempt of court and that they do carry out what the court intended in relation to the access issues we are talking about. The existing enforcement orders do provide for quite a number of approaches. I will not go through them all but they are listed under section 56(4)(a), (b) and (c)(i)(ii)(iii) and 123, which I believe gives the court extra opportunities which do not exist at present to ensure that the terms of access are met by both parents. That is the intention. Of course there will be circumstances where a parent may simply be in contempt of court. I was advised that community service is an alternative to prison and therefore a prison sentence would have to be specified in the first place before a person could be asked to do community service as an alternative.

The other influencer in terms of how we approached this section was the strong representations made to the committee by the Ombudsman for Children, who said that we should not adopt this approach to access. She advised very strongly against removing those sanctions, as did other organisations such as One Family, and Women’s Aid also made comments in relation to the sanctions.

This is a very difficult area in terms of trying to get parents to work well together in the best interests of the child. Sometimes, clearly parents do not act in the best interests of the child. The new mechanisms in the Bill will be helpful for courts. The broader context where this can be dealt with even more effectively is in reform of the courts, developing court welfare services to a greater degree and having more contact centres. All of those areas need development in this country as they are very under-developed at present. We have had two very good pilot projects on contact centres where very good work was done by Barnardos and other groups to help parents. In effect, they mediate with parents and make sure access visits go well. The feedback I got from Barnardos is that a very significant amount of detailed work needed to be done with parents before they could get them to the point of fully fulfilling the access, but they felt the contact centres were a very worthwhile way to approach it. We have a lot of work to do in this area to support parents to continue parenting even where there is high conflict, tension and emotion. A lot of work can be done with those parents but it does require the development of services in this area. There is much work to be done in this country in that regard. We removed the sanctions to which Deputy Shatter referred that were in the original draft on the basis I have just outlined.

Comment on this

I agree with everything the Minister has just said about the need to provide the back-up services and to provide a more sophisticated court welfare service, which is practically non-existent in the context of the family law area at the moment.

The whole point of this is to ensure that where people are in contempt of court, imprisonment is not the only remedy available to the court. I am an enthusiast for what we have here, in subsection (4) that the Minister mentioned, the parent counselling, family counselling, all of these provisions, which indeed were in the original provision that the committee dealt with. I have no theological or ideological commitment to the original Bill because my perception was that it could be improved and we wanted to go through a consultative process but I do know that unfortunately with the best will in the world there are a group of parents who will not cooperate with any of these arrangements and the courts are bereft of an alternative then to imprisonment. We need to ensure that parents who behave badly and who could impact, not only on the best interests of their children as children, but on the capacity of their children as adults to have a normal functioning relationship, that the activities of those parents are curtailed, that there is some sanction the courts can utilise. There is no particular reason, for example, a community service sanction in the context of family law needs to be tied in with anyone committing criminal offences. It is just that community service is an alternative in the criminal law area to a sentence of imprisonment. There is no particular reason there could not be a stand-alone provision where a judge dealing with a recalcitrant parent behaving contrary to the best interests of a child could not say, "Well, if you do not go to parental counselling or family counselling and if you do not genuinely co-operate, I have other remedies at my disposal and one of the things you may have to do is go off for a couple of hours or three or four hours every week and do designated community service". That is not the worst of sanctions but it incentivises co-operation and it is not a sanction that renders a parent incapable of continuing to act as a custodial parent, if it is the custodial parent who is misbehaving. I think we have to have an open mind on these things and all I am saying is, and I keep coming back to something I said this morning, we are not inventing the wheel. We are travelling a route that other jurisdictions have travelled in this area some 20 to 25 years ago and have discovered that just doing this is not the solution. This is really valuable and helpful but there must be some alternative sanction if it is not working.

Comment on this

As a non-member of the committee there are one or two things that I would like to raise, possibly with a view to---

Comment on this

The Deputy must confine herself to this section.

Comment on this

Yes, I will. There were many contributions on the last Stage in the House about fathers' rights and the alleged denial of access by women to fathers who have custody. There were many contributions by different Deputies about that. I think this section clarifies that a second parent can apply to the courts for enforcement and for custody. There seems to be a lot of confusion between guardianship and custody among Deputies and among members of the public. It seems to me that this is what is being used to justify the introduction of automatic guardianship, which I would have questions about, because guardianship gives somebody sweeping powers, for example in relation to passports and the residence of the child.

In cases where relations have broken down, and contact with the child may have broken down over years despite, let us say, the father in this case, living for a full year or more with the mother, I am a bit concerned about the safeguards in relation to violence against women, people who are escaping violent relationships, and giving automatic guardianship to men, in this particular case. One in five women experiences domestic violence. That is quite a lot of women. This country has the highest rate of single-parent families. I know there are situations where men have been deprived of seeing their children but it is very clear here, they can apply for custody and unless there is a very good reason, they will get access to their children. What I am more concerned about is guardianship being given automatically to people who may have had no connection over a long period of time and who have given no financial support, emotional support or anything else. There are quite a lot of lone parents, who are women, who I know are quite concerned about that. Could the Minister give her views on that?

Comment on this

We had this discussion this morning on guardianship and automatic guardianship. The Minister might address that briefly.

Comment on this

It might be helpful to address that particular issue. We had a discussion as regards that issue, as indeed we had on Second Stage. I have indicated some amendments that I am bringing in which would make it more likely that non-marital fathers would sign the statutory declaration and that they could do that at the same time as the birth registration. That is without moving towards the automatic guardianship which some Deputies had asked for and, indeed, which other Deputies on the committee had expressed some serious concern in relation to.

What is at the heart of the Bill, and what I have described as the golden thread running through the Bill, is the definition of "best interest". For the first time we have gone into detail, as I have already said to the committee, about what constitutes best interest. The point I want to make in response to the Deputy is that we have linked with quite a wide range of organisations that work directly with families where there is violence. We have included in the best interest description, when the court is making a decision about a child in relation to access, custody, or guardianship, "The court shall have regard to family violence that has occurred or is likely to occur in the family of the child including the impact or likely impact of such violence on the safety of the child and other members of his or her family, the child's personal well-being, including the child's psychological and emotional well-being, the victim of such violence, and the capacity of the perpetrator of the violence to properly care for the child and the risk, if any, that the perpetrator poses to the child." That is an interesting point that is often spoken about. We have gone into quite a lot of detail. It is one of the sections---

Comment on this

We are moving ahead now to section 58.

Comment on this

It is in response to the point that Deputy Coppinger has made in relation to those kind of decisions and what might guide them.

Comment on this

I draw the Minister's attention to the work that the committee did on community courts and community service orders and all that stuff that Deputy Shatter has highlighted and perhaps that report might be looked at by the Minister in the context of the points made.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Shatter suggesting that an offence should be created in this section?

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that. I certainly do not think that criminal law should be introduced into the family law area. I am concerned about the circumstance where, whether it is the mother or the father, one of them is misbehaving and creating an enormous difficulty with regard to access issues. On occasions fathers create enormous difficulties for custodial mothers by not complying with access arrangements or using them to try to turn the child against the mother. I have seen every combination of this. What I am saying is that what we have in the Bill allowing the courts to require people to attend parental counselling, allowing the courts to require people to attend family counselling, all of this is a great advance and very important but when those individuals whom the court directs to do this do not co-operate, the court needs some sanction and there is no reason why, for example, the court should not have the capacity to prescribe stand-alone community service. It is not about a criminal offence. It is a sanction instead of committal to prison for contempt of court. It is not even a substitute for that, it is not asking the courts to commit anyone to prison.

There should be sensible, stand-alone sanctions that do not damage the parent-child relationship and which are pragmatic and workable in circumstances where people do not have much in the way of available funds and where imposing a fine may not be a practical sanction. The courts need some form of sanction in order that, instead of judges urging people who are obstinate and intent on using their children as pawns in an ongoing relationship battle, they can tell those parents that if they do not conduct themselves properly they can do X. At the moment there is not an X which they can do. The only X available is parental or family counselling or making good the cost of attending where access was not granted, but if that does not work, what happens next?

Comment on this

That is a very interesting point but it is a question for Report Stage.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 50 in the name of Deputy Pádraig Mac Lochlainn is ruled out of order.

Comment on this

On Report Stage I intend to amend this section, which inserts new sections 31 and 32 into the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964. This will link the reference in section 31(2)(b) to the views of the child in the best interest provision to the provisions of section 32, which allow the court to seek a child's views directly or to appoint an expert to find out the child's views. It also amends the definition of "family violence" to "household violence" to ensure this encompasses more accurately the potential risks of violence that may have an impact on the child's welfare.

I plan to bring an amendment on Report Stage which will insert a new section after section 58. The amendment will extend the provisions of section 27 of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964, enabling the court to proceed in the absence of the child to applications under sections 6C and 6D as inserted by section 45 of the Bill.

SECTION 75

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:

In page 63, line 22, after "subsection (4)," to insert "and".

Comment on this

Sections 85 and 86 have an interconnectivity. Can the Minister explain how she sees the workings of those sections?

Comment on this

Section 85 amends section 41 of the Family Law Act 1995 to clarify that, where the court orders a maintenance payment under another Act to be paid by a cohabitant of the child's parent, that maintenance payment may be secured to the maintenance applicant under section 41. Section 86 amends section 42 of the 1995 act, which allows the court, either instead of or as well as securing a maintenance order under section 41, to order a lump sum payment. The Deputy raised this point on Second Stage.

The amendment in paragraph (a) is technical to reflect the additional categories of orders which may be so secured. The amendment in paragraph (b) provides for the insertion of a new subsection which gives the court the powers to order how a lump sum should be spent, including providing suitable accommodation for a child.

Comment on this

I want to raise some serious issues about this action. I will reference it as (2A) in section 86(b), though it is cross-referenced as section 42(b)(2A). Under this provision the Circuit Court or the High Court can make a lump sum order that is unlimited in amount. It can be an order made instead of, or in addition to, a periodical payment order. How will this work in practice and is it adequate? The amendment of sections 41 and 42 of the 1995 Act is not adequate and does not go far enough. I direct my attention to a child born outside marriage because in a marital family there is no difficulty about lump sum orders in other provisions in our family law legislation. My example involves an unmarried couple who reside together for a period, a child is born and the father makes off. Let us assume the father is reasonably wealthy and owns a number of properties or substantial assets and he may well be able to afford a house for his child if the court orders a lump sum payment including an element for the accommodation of the child. Does this section envisage a provision for a sufficiently large sum of money to buy a home for the child in these circumstances? In mirror circumstances, if a marriage broke down, would a spouse be required to buy a home for the other spouse and child?

Comment on this

Yes, it does envisage that. I am conscious of cases in this area.

Comment on this

That leads on to another issue which is a problem. I would have mentioned I was involved in court proceedings some years ago. This is a declaration of interest that I have referenced on several occasions. The McE case involved an unmarried mother left high and dry by an extremely wealthy father with whom she had been residing. The Circuit Court made an order for €400,000 for the purchase of a house for the benefit of the child and the mother. The High Court reversed that order on the basis that lump sum orders under this particular provision could be made to benefit the children of married couples but not a child born outside marriage. This made no sense in the context of how the law was framed. The case was taken to the European Court of Justice and was settled on the basis that the law would be adequately changed to ensure no judge would do this in the future.

This provision goes part of the way. The real difficulty is that it does not spell out in full what the Minister intends. I agree with her that this is the intention. There is a risk, however, in the manner in which the Judiciary approaches this. The antiquated approach taken in the above case by a learned member of the High Court which was clearly going to get this State into difficulty in the European courts could be replicated. There is a need to expressly make it clear that in making provision for accommodation, it can include, where it is financially appropriate, a sum be provided for the purchase of a home for the benefit of the child and the parent - most frequently it will be the mother - bringing up the child. That is not clear from this, however. This measure could be interpreted by a court as requiring someone to provide a couple of thousand euro by way of a lump sum as a down payment for a rental property. It may well be that this is what it can only be where people have very limited means. However, that was not the intention.

The second aspect is that if the courts are to make a lump sum order to allow for the purchase of accommodation to give a child security, the courts have to have powers to determine the ownership of that property. If a lump sum is to be provided for accommodation, is the property, for example, to be purchased in the mother’s name to be held in trust for the child? Is it to be purchased in the father’s name on the basis the child will only live in the property until a particular age and then will vacate it? Can the lump sum be used to put the property into the joint names of mother and child where perhaps the mother will be the primary custodial parent, the best part of 18 years? It would be a gross injustice that when her child finally reaches adulthood and ends education that she and the child could be rendered homeless. This is not adequately teased out yet.

The original provision that the committee considered had another section that allowed for the courts to order that property be purchased in the name of trustees. More work was needed to be done on that particular provision, however. That was fine by way of heads of a Bill but it needed to be teased out further. It now seems to me that instead it has not dealt with the ownership of a property that might be purchased to provide a roof over a child’s head, provide security in that property, to provide the parent caring for the child, who in 98% of such cases in these circumstances will be the mother, will not be rendered homeless after she has brought the child up. These issues need to be dealt with.

There are interesting provisions in English legislation that could be possibly adapted into Irish legislation. They would have to be adapted, however, because the manner in which English courts have interpreted their particular measure is not adequate to meet our obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights. This has been dealt with in other jurisdictions. The reason is simple. If a marriage breaks up and a divorce decree is sought, the courts can make lump sum orders and require that a home be purchased with funds where there are family assets for the benefit of the mother and child. When a couple breaks up or a child is born outside of marriage to a very wealthy father, then that child should have the same equal entitlement to a roof over his or her head as any other child has.

What was in the original draft Bill was not by any means perfect. It was adequate for a consultative process. There is a need to tease this out further. This is too brief and knowing the manner in which the Judiciary will come to approach this, we will all be back again some years from now. What is more important - people being back here or the State being in the European Court? This will be to the disadvantage of a number of children in coming years for whom better provision could be made if we deal with this correctly now. A more sophisticated provision addressing these issues should be introduced on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Another section relevant to this Part is that we have separately amended section 11(2) of the 1964 Act to ensure a parent is liable for maintenance, whether or not the parent is the guardian of the child. We did examine this in detail and considered setting up trusts but there could be potential conflicts of interest.

We felt the approach we took in the Bill left the courts with a wide and appropriate range of discretion. Family law Acts do not require accommodation to be purchased in the names of children. I take Deputy Shatter’s point and I will get further legal advice to see if this section can be strengthened in the way he has outlined.

SECTION 88

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

In page 69, line 4, to delete “sub-paragraphs (i) to (iii) of section 19(1)(b)” and substitute “paragraphs (i) to (iii) of section 19(1)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:

In page 70, line 10, to delete “section 20” and substitute “section 19”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:

In page 70, line 11, to delete “section 21” and substitute “section 20”.

Comment on this

I intend to make technical amendments to this section on Report Stage in order to remove the references in paragraph (b) to "inserted by section 45 of the Act of 2015" and correct some punctuation in paragraph (c).

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 57:

In page 86, line 23, to delete “(in this Act referred to as a maintenance order)”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:

In page 92, to delete lines 30 to 32 and substitute the following:

“(a) in subsection (1)—

(i) in the definition of “lump sum order”, by the substitution of “paragraph (c) or (ca) of section 117(1)” for “section 117(1)(c)”,

(ii) in the definition of “periodical payments order”, by the substitution of “paragraph (a) or (aa) of section 117(1)” for “section 117(1)(a)”,

(iii) in the definition of “secured periodical payments order”, by the substitution of “paragraph (b) or (ba) of section 117(1)” for “section 117(1)(b)”, and

(iv) by the insertion of the following definition:

“ ‘Act of 1964’ means the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964;”,”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 59:

In page 93, line 24, to delete “who is a child” and substitute “who is under the age of 18 years”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 60:

In page 93, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:

“Amendment of section 113 of Act of 2010

145. Section 113 of the Act of 2010 is amended—

(a) by designating the section as subsection (1), and

(b) by the insertion of the following subsection after subsection (1):

“(2) For the avoidance of doubt, it is hereby declared that the grant of a decree of dissolution shall not affect the rights of the parents of a child, under section 6 or 6B of the Act of 1964, to be guardians of the child jointly.”.”.

The amended version of section 145 is the same in substance as the previous version, with the important modification that it additionally specifies that, under section 6B of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964 - as inserted by section 45 of this Bill - guardianship of a civil partner who is a parent will be unaffected by the subsequent dissolution of the civil partnership. This has the same effect as provisions in the Family Law (Divorce) Act specifying that the divorce of parents does not affect their status as guardians of their children.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 61:

In page 95, line 23, to delete “is” and substitute “was”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 62:

In page 95, line 24, to delete “is” and substitute “was”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 63:

In page 95, to delete lines 26 and 27 and substitute the following:

“(d) in subsection (7), by the substitution of “paragraph (a) or (aa) of subsection (1)” for “subsection (1)(a)” wherever it occurs.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 64:

In page 97, line 28, to delete “a” and substitute “the”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 65:

In page 99, line 11, to delete “is” and substitute “was”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 66:

In page 99, line 15, to delete “is” and substitute “was”.

Comment on this

I intend to bring forward an amendment on Report Stage in order to make a technical correction to the amendment of section 123(9) of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010. The amendment in question will relate to the obligation of trustees of a pension scheme to notify a beneficiary.

Comment on this

I intend to bring forward an amendment on Report Stage in order to correct cross-references relating to the amendment of section 133 of the 2010 Act.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 67:

In page 102, line 15, to delete “makes an order for the grant of a decree of dissolution” and substitute “grants a decree of dissolution (within the meaning of Part 12)”.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 68 to 71, inclusive, are related and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 68:

In page 104, between lines 31 and 32, to insert the following:

“ “ ‘Act of 2010’ means the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010;”.

This set of amendments effects a drafting revision required in order to ensure that the definitions applying for the purposes of the Adoptive Leave Act 1995 apply in full to the entire Act. The effect of the amendments will be to move those definitions into section 2(1) of the Adoptive Leave Act and to apply them to the whole Act, instead of subsection (1A) only.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 69:

In page 104, line 32, to delete “ “ ‘Act of 2015’” and substitute “ ‘Act of 2015’ ”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 70:

In page 104, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:

“ ‘civil partner’ shall be construed in accordance with section 3 of the Act of 2010;

‘cohabitant’ shall be construed in accordance with section 172(1) of the Act of 2010;

‘cohabiting couple’ has the same meaning as it has in section 3(1) (amended by section 96 of the Act of 2015) of the Adoption Act 2010;”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 71:

In page 106, lines 12 to 22, to delete all words from and including “adopter.” in line 12 down to and including “2010.”.” in line 22 and substitute “adopter.”.”.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister and her officials for their attendance.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman, members of the committee and the committee staff for facilitating the Committee Stage debate of this Bill. It is intended to take Report Stage next Thursday in the Dáil.

Comment on this

The deadline for Report Stage amendments is 4 p.m. tomorrow.

Comment on this