Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation Bill 2026: Committee Stage
The Minister said the Bill would protect journalists, citizens and organisations from abusive litigation intended to deter public participation, while preserving access to courts for legitimate claims. He opposed listing specific procedural tactics, preferring courts to assess cases broadly; he also said EU judgments found to be SLAPPs could be refused enforcement on public-policy grounds. No amendments were tabled, though he may revisit the definition of “public interest” and whether IHREC should be named as the national focal point on Report Stage.
No. 76 of 2026 ›
As usual, I remind members to turn off their mobile phones or switch them to flight mode. This meeting has been convened to deal with Committee Stage of the Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation Bill 2026. I welcome the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, and his officials. Does the Minister want to make any introductory remarks before we move to the substance of the Bill?
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and colleagues on the select committee for facilitating the taking of Committee Stage of the Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation Bill. As members will be aware, this Bill introduces protections for those targeted by strategic lawsuits against public participation, commonly known as SLAPPs. These are abusive court proceedings which are not taken to assert a right or seek genuine redress but, rather, to prevent, restrict or penalise public participation by threatening and intimidating people or organisations engaged in public criticism or debate. SLAPPs have a very damaging impact on public interest reporting and debate and pose a significant danger to press freedom, public access to information and to democracy. This Bill strikes a balance by seeking to ensure that legal action cannot be used to silence those acting in the public interest without impacting the right of access to the courts for those with legitimate claims.
I have reviewed the comments made by Deputies on Second Stage. I thank them for the support shown for the objectives behind the Bill. There are no amendments tabled for discussion today. I hope that any outstanding points can be addressed and that we can progress this legislation and proceed to have the protections it will afford commenced as soon as possible. I may have an amendment to bring forward to section 15 on Report Stage in respect of the definition of "public interest". I may bring forward an amendment to align that definition in section 15 with that in section 4.
Comment on this
Do any members want to make opening remarks before we get into the detail of the Bill? No.
Comment on this
I want to ask about bad faith procedural tactics. A number of stakeholders have contacted committee members requesting that consideration be given to ensure that there would be an explicit list in section 2 in relation to the filing of excessive or protracted procedural motions. In other words, filing large amounts of non-relevant documentation during a case or in response to orders and so on. Is this something that the Minister would be open to considering? Does he believe legislation would benefit from those type of actions being clearly stated to be in breach of the law?
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for raising this matter. I would not be inclined to include that. It has been suggested that maybe the filing of excessive or protracted procedural motions would be included within the definition as being illustrative of SLAPPs. We are better off giving the courts a broader assessment of the terms upon which they can categorise proceedings as being SLAPPs.
It is probably the case that when we look at a SLAPP very many of the tactics that will be used will involve excessive or protracted procedural motions. That is something that will be inherent in the definition that is there already. I would prefer to leave it to the discretion of the court rather than trying to specify in a very detailed manner the type of procedural developments in a case that could give rise to a SLAPP.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister for clarification on section 6. Most people would agree that it is welcome that experts, or those with bona fide interests, would be able to make submissions to the court where relevant. Will the Minister clarify whether the provisions of the Bill regarding costs would apply to the costs incurred by any such person or body?
Comment on this
There is a mechanism that enables the court when it is giving a ruling in respect of costs to take into account that a person or body appointed under section 6 would have their costs taken into account. That is specifically provided for. Section 34CA provides that a third party with a legitimate interest in safeguarding or promoting the rights of persons may apply to make submissions. Third parties generally bear their own costs of proceedings but the court does retain an element of discretion on the matter of costs and, depending on the circumstances of a particular case, a third party may get their costs.
Comment on this
It is the discretion that exists within a court. A court can decide to grant the discretionary power to a third party to have its costs. They may be able to avail of costs where they have provided support to a defendant who has successfully obtained a declaration.
Comment on this
I am reading from a note prepared by officials in respect of section 6.
Comment on this
I am not sure if my question is relevant to this section. If it is not, we can come back to it. Is there is an organisation that is the focal point for people dealing with SLAPPs?
Comment on this
It is not in the legislation but I have a proposal in this regard. We are engaging with the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission, IHREC, at present on the question of designation as the national focal point. IHREC agrees that it is the organisation best suited to carry out the role of the focal point. IHREC is not included within the legislation but I will be designating it as the focal point.
Comment on this
Does it weaken it if it is not named in the legislation? I do not have a particular opinion on that; I am just wondering.
Comment on this
I have spoken to Liam Herrick about this. I think IHREC would prefer if it was named in respect of it but there is a significant overlap between the functions to be carried out by the national focal point and the functions already conferred on IHREC under the 2014 Act. Circumscribing the role of a national focal point in primary legislation is, therefore, unnecessary and may limit the flexibility which would be beneficial to IHREC as the national focal point in circumstances where the legal framework governing SLAPPs is at the early stages of its development. The anti-SLAPP recommendation provides for the role of a national focal point. That is under review.
Comment on this
I am conscious that this focal point will be a really important role and will require resourcing.
Comment on this
Perhaps if it is designated it also aids the potential necessity for the resourcing it will need in budget terms.
Comment on this
That was part of IHREC's concern, which I do not necessarily share. Part of its concern was that it wanted to be expressly named in the primary legislation so that if there was any issue about its funding it could say, "Listen, we are specifically named here." However, if it is designated by statutory instrument - secondary legislation - it will still be taken into account in terms of its functions and the budgeting that will be required. There are many statutory bodies and entities that have functions allocated to them through secondary legislation and it does not diminish their entitlement to claim budgetary increases.
Comment on this
It is the entitlement to claim rather the expectation-----
Comment on this
I will have a think about it for Report Stage. I have spoken to IHREC about it. I will not say that its concerns are baseless because I can understand why it wants it in the legislation, but I think it will be protected enough even if I do not include it. I will, however, have a think about it.
Comment on this
It is about the entitlement to claim as opposed to the expectation to receive.
Comment on this
Section 13 is another welcome provision. It ensures that Irish courts do not comply with SLAPPs originating outside of the State. There is an anomaly, however. Irish courts will be able to declare a case from anywhere in the world as a SLAPP, including Ireland and Britain, apart from other EU states, and that is potentially problematic. Has the Minister sought safeguards, or is he confident they exist, in respect of the potential for a SLAPP to emerge from another EU member state, perhaps an EU state that might be experiencing democratic backsliding? We have seen attempts to interfere with the judiciary in member states previously. What would happen if an Irish court were to receive an application from an EU member state which the judge and the court were of the view was in fact a SLAPP?
Comment on this
There is an obligation on every EU member state to transpose EU directive No. 1069/2024, which is what we are doing here. Every member state will have, at least, the protections in respect of SLAPPs as they operate and are presented in the directive. Any member state permitting SLAPPs would not be in compliance with the directive and would find itself, I would have thought, in a legal difficulty. It is certainly the case that one member state may regard something as not being a SLAPP and it could come here and we could regard it as a SLAPP, but that is very much a judgment call. On the fundamentals, however, where it is clear that it is a SLAPP I believe there is not an issue arising in respect of member states because of the legal obligation imposed upon all member states by EU directive No. 1069/2024.
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept that it would not be unique for a member state to be in breach of an EU directive? In fact, we cannot get on the high moral ground in that respect. It is apparent on a daily basis when we see member states in breach of EU directives. There is a mechanism for the Commission to hold states to account for not complying with the directive but what provision is there for the courts if they receive an application they believe to be a strategic lawsuit against public participation emanating from a court in a member state?
Comment on this
I do not have it in front of me, but in terms of the enforcement of judgments in one member state that is given in another member state, there are very clear rules in respect of that with the Lugano Convention, the Brussels Convention and enforcement of judgments. I do not have it in front of me but I think there are very significant protections there in respect of it. I do not see a situation where a SLAPP has been issued by courts in a country within the EU that is then sought to be enforced here. The only reason they would to try force it here is because the person against whom judgment has been secured is resident or domiciled here. There are all sorts of protections for an Irish court when it comes to the enforcement of EU judgments. I do not have it in front of me but I am fairly certain there are protections in place under the Brussels and Lugano conventions.
Comment on this
Is there anything within the EU directive that prevents it? What we have here is a provision in section 13 that allows an Irish court not to comply with anything it believes is a SLAPP originating from outside of the EU. What harm would it be to extend the scope of the section to include the EU?
Comment on this
There are already detailed rules in place in the Brussels Convention dealing with the enforcement of EU judgments in other EU member states. My officials remind me, and I should have remembered this, that there is provision in the Brussels I Regulation to refuse recognition or enforcement of a judgment on public policy grounds. An Irish court seeing a SLAPP judgment coming from another member state would be able to decide it was not going to enforce it in Ireland on public policy grounds. There is a protection there for it.
Comment on this
Yes. Public policy grounds is broad enough to say that there are policy reasons why this judgment should not be enforced in Ireland.
Comment on this
I am not. Generally, when it comes to the enforcement of EU judgments in Ireland, there is not much controversy in respect of it. Generally, it is in terms of contractual debts, debts secured in other countries that want to be enforced against a person or corporate entity domiciled in Ireland.
Comment on this
Can we get clarification on this? This obviously provides additional protections beyond those that were provided in the anti-SLAPP section of the defamation Act.
Comment on this
That is welcome. Am I correct in saying that the Minister's approach is to repeal what was actually introduced only this year through section 3, only then to reintroduce it verbatim with the additional protections? Could the Minister confirm that this is the case and explain the logic behind it?
Comment on this
It is not the case. It is not being reproduced verbatim. There are some changes in respect of what is contained in the Defamation Act 2009. For instance, section 34CA is a new provision that is not in the Defamation Act. I think the same applies in respect of security for costs and security for damages in 34D. they have been added. The defamation legislation was amended to put SLAPPs into it. We thought it was important to do that in the context of the Defamation (Amendment) Bill that was going through the Houses. The Cathaoirleach will be aware that defamation is an area where SLAPPs can materialise and where they can be used quite frequently. It was thought important to get the SLAPP provisions into the defamation legislation in any event. The benefit of this is they are going to harmonised to a large extent, whether they are defamation SLAPPs, as contained in Part 3 of the Bill that we are looking at, or other civil or commercial SLAPPs which are set out in Part 2. The provisions we are looking at in section 15 strengthen it significantly and harmonise it with the other anti-SLAPP legislation in Part 2 of this Bill.
Comment on this
During the debate on the defamation Bill in the Chamber, the Minister gave his assessment or opinion that SLAPPs were not a feature of the Irish legal system. Is that still his assessment?
Comment on this
The Cathaoirleach asked me for an example of a SLAPP. I was thinking about this because one of my jobs is to always try to keep one step ahead of the Chairman. I generally fail in that. I was thinking yesterday that one of the questions the Chairman might put to me is to give an example of a SLAPP. I looked in Ireland and could not get one. I looked in England, however, where there was a judgment earlier this year in the case of Kamal v. Tax Policy Associates. That was a case taken by a tax adviser against a quite effective tax policy consultant who puts a lot of information out on social media. He was sued for defamation along with his company, Tax Policy Associates, by the person who said he was defamed. The judge gave a detailed judgment in respect of it. She struck out the claim for a number of reasons but then went on to look at it and say it was a SLAPP. There were lots of procedural motions in it. He did not have expensive lawyers or get it bogged down in huge costs, but in terms of the consistent detailed procedural applications that were brought, ultimately, the judge, Mrs. Justice Collins Rice reached a ruling that this was a SLAPP. I cannot give the Cathaoirleach an example of an Irish one. It does not mean to say that it will not happen in the future. As the Cathaoirleach will know, however, what one person regards as a SLAPP, another person may regard as a perfectly legitimate legal action.
Comment on this
We saw the flip side of SLAPPs where legitimate cases being taken have been described as SLAPPs, often for political purposes. One of the reasons I asked that is because we as a committee, and the House, are under pressure, particularly from the Minister's Department - I hope he does not mind me saying so - in terms of proactivity with regard to legislation.
Comment on this
Today we have to use a valuable committee meeting slot to deal with Committee Stage of the legislation to deal with an issue that, by the Minister's own admission, is not an issue, when we will be challenged to find adequate time and space to deal with pre-legislative scrutiny on the citizenship Bill, to give one example. Is it a case that we are being driven in areas like this by EU directives and the desire to fulfil obligations to the EU rather than allowing proper scrutiny and debate on domestic legislation that is arguably much more important and much more in need of full accountability and deliberations by these Houses?
Comment on this
The short answer is "No". I did not say that this is not an issue. I said I could not give an example of a reported decision from Ireland where the court found that it was a SLAPP. Ireland is no different from not only other member states but European countries. I gave the Cathaoirleach an example of a decision of the courts in England and Wales. It is important to have in place legislation to deal with and deter certain types of activity, even though there have not been reported examples of it from the courts before. It is also a directive, as the Cathaoirleach knows, that has to be transposed. It is an important measure to have in place. It will give confidence to people in the NGO sector, journalists and politicians that they are able to talk in public about issues and raise issues of public concern. If it is the case that somebody decides to use the law to try to tie someone up in excessive costs or procedural applications before the courts, it is important that a person has a mechanism to bring that application before the court and for the court to look at it and determine whether or not it is a SLAPP. It is worthwhile legislation. Other legislation will be coming from the Department. I am very aware of how busy this committee is, but I do not think it is a reason not to proceed and enact this legislation simply because there is not a reported decision to the courts in respect of SLAPPs.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that the legislation is not worthwhile; I am suggesting that we have other priorities. I am putting on the record that the Minister should not use the time constraints and the busy nature of this committee as an excuse to bypass this committee in respect of legislation that might be coming before us. I will say very clearly on the record that this committee takes its role in respect of scrutinising legislation very seriously. I would hope that this would be respected.
Comment on this
I will come back on that. I received a letter from the committee stating that it only had one date available - this is not criticism but facts - to deal with legislation between now and Christmas. We can discuss that in due course if that is the case. There is legislation that I have to get enacted before Christmas.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister will work with us. This committee is very happy and eager to meet on multiple occasions on any given week, if we can get the committee room and are facilitated by the Houses of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I will come back to the Chairman on that. I am happy to do that.
Comment on this
I think all members are on the record as saying that we want to be able to deal with our own elective business, which is fairly minimal in comparison with what the members have requested. We want to deal with pre-legislative scrutiny, Estimates, Committee Stage legislation and all of those things. I ask the Minister to be of any assistance in ensuring that this can be facilitated.
Comment on this
I will come back to the Chairman in correspondence.
Comment on this
On behalf of the committee, I thank the Minister and his officials for attending our meeting today. Does anybody want to make any closing remarks?
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for being here with us today. On the gap being filled by this legislation in terms of credible information, access to credible information is an important part of our democratic resilience. The Bill deals with one threat to that, namely, the chilling effect of expensive litigation. I will take a liberty - given the Minister's national security responsibility, is he satisfied we are doing enough to protect our information environment and democratic resilience in other aspects in particular in relation to our national security? We do not always get an opportunity to discuss that.
Comment on this
We have the National Cyber Security Centre which has come under the responsibility of the Department of justice since last year. It is a very effective and well-resourced agency responsible for protecting the country against cyberattacks. I will be bringing forward legislation shortly to transpose the NIS 2 directive through the national cyber security Bill. That will come to this committee in the not-too-distant future, I hope.
There is also the issue of disinformation. The Garda Commissioner keeps me updated frequently on any threats to national security arising from disinformation. To ensure that we counteract it and are able to confront it, we need all elements of society assessing what is coming out. We need a vibrant media and political system and courts that can hold people to account and make directions that will result in production of documents. Part of the problem we face in that respect is that it is to ensure all of those obligations are complied with by people who operate on social media. We are putting structures in place. We spoke about defamation earlier. That applies to what is being said online. Similarly, where we see disinformation, it is important Coimisiún na Meán or other entities are in place to ensure we try to correct disinformation put into the public domain but there is so much information out there that it is difficult to keep tabs on it consistently. In terms of information challenging national security, that is done effectively by An Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
Is the Minister open to coming to this committee and having a further discussion about national security, even if it needs to be in private session? I recognise there is great sensitivity when it comes to national security.
Comment on this
I have no difficulty with that. I do not know whether national security is a matter for this committee - we can discuss with the Departments. I thought there was a proposal previously for a national security committee.
Comment on this
I sit on that committee. It is defence and national security but our remit is so narrow; we can only speak about cyber defence, undersea cables and associated hybrid risks. We have several times requested that An Garda Síochána come to the committee but it cannot because it is not within our remit, which is understandable. There is a gap in scrutinising what is happening in our national security space. We are between two stools.
Comment on this
It is tricky because it is difficult for a Minister or a garda who has information about national security to discuss it openly, to be frank.
Comment on this
Even with a committee in private session, it can be tricky. It is challenging. If the Deputy wants to add it to the list of issues the committee will write to me about, feel free to do so.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister.
This legislation does not just pertain to protecting journalists, it is also for citizens and community groups. If groups choose to express their public participation in a physical way with a demonstration or protest, is the Minister satisfied there are adequate resources in terms of garda numbers to ensure public safety, in particular in rural areas? It is to protect the individuals expressing their right to participate publicly but also members of An Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
The legislation we are looking at is solely focused on strategic lawsuits. It is people, corporations or entities that institute lawsuits, proceedings in our courts, against individuals where the primary purpose is to block and reduce public participation. The issue about demonstrations and protests is not really covered by this legislation.
I am satisfied the Garda is well resourced. As of August we have 14,600 gardaí. There is another passing out on Friday. We will have approximately another 200 coming out. There is another passing out in December. I am hopeful we will be close to having recruited 1,000 this year and getting closer to 15,000 gardaí. We always want more but if we get up there, that will be the biggest number ever.
Comment on this
I accept that and I am grateful for it . I am aware of an incident in south Kilkenny this past weekend where there was a public order incident and one single garda was dispatched on his own and was faced with groups with hurleys.
Comment on this
My understanding of the legislation was that if the protection is not limited to written or spoken expression, it would cover a community group which perhaps organised a protest against planning proposal or something like that. That is why I asked. It is one thing giving protection in law but I needed to be sure about that, particularly in rural areas.
Comment on this
I think there is a separate issue in that regard. This is about strategic lawsuits. A large corporate entity could take a lawsuit against a group of protestors locally to put huge pressure on them to stop them participating in the public issue about a planning matter. That could potentially by a type of SLAPP. When it comes to the number of gardaí at a protest, that is a separate issue.
Comment on this
From a rural dweller point of view, it would be good.
Comment on this
I raised this issue on Second Stage with the Minister's colleague. It relates to assessments of need and the State failing to provide them in the statutory timeframe of six months set out in the Disability Act. The State has spent €7.2 million over the past four years defending these cases even though it knows it is not going to win them. Could that be considered as the State being involved in a SLAPP?
Comment on this
I do not know about that. I commend the ingenuity of the members who managed to get in every type of issue.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy talking about cases taken against the State?
Comment on this
It would never be a SLAPP to defend proceedings. A person cannot say, "This person is defending my claim, it is outrageous, they need to cave in". SLAPPs only operate where somebody takes proceedings and the purpose of taking the proceedings is to deter, undermine or damage public participation.
Comment on this
Are there provisions in the Bill we are talking about today that would help somebody in defending these cases? Would they pertain to the State as well? Will the State get some protections?
Comment on this
You would have to get the court to accept that is a SLAPP and for the type of cases the Deputy described, he certainly does not think they are SLAPPs. I doubt the court would either.
There are all sorts of measures in this Bill. A really interesting measure is someone can apply for security for costs against a person taking a case which is a SLAPP.
Generally, the rule in Ireland is that you cannot have security for costs against a person resident in Ireland. You can have security for costs against a company or somebody who is resident outside the jurisdiction, generally outside the EU. That is a new provision that is in place that protects defendants in cases.
Comment on this
While we are doing the jukebox round, as it pertains to the courts, I finish by encouraging the Minister to engage with the criminal legal aid solicitors and bring that issue to an end.
Comment on this
I will be here next week to discuss it with the committee but, yes, I will.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for dealing with the legislation before it in such a prompt and thorough manner. I will come back to the Cathaoirleach in respect of other matters. I appreciate the pressures this committee is under, but similarly I would like it to appreciate that I am also under pressure in terms to get legislation through. We will engage with each other and will see if we can progress it.