We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Legislation and Security

Estimates for Public Services, 1994.

Contributions 1–153 of 314. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I welcome the Minister and her officials to the committee once again. A suggested timetable has been circulated. This has been discussed and agreed with the convenors. It is proposed that the meeting commence with the normal opening statements, which will take one hour approximately. We will then consider each Vote in turn as indicated on the timetable before Members. We will take a sos at 1.15 p.m. for one hour and it is proposed to conclude our formal consideration at 4 p.m. if we have not concluded already. Is that agreed? Agreed.

The business before the committee today is the revised Estimates for Vote 19, the Office of the Minister for Justice; Vote 20, Garda Síochána; Vote 21 Prisons; Vote 22, Courts; Vote 23, Land Registry and Registry of Deeds; and Vote 24, Charitable Donations and Bequests. That is a total of six separate Votes the Select Committee is obliged to consider. I look forward to a constructive and informative debate.

Comment on this
Máire Geoghegan-Quinn Minister for Justice (Mrs. Geoghegan-Quinn) Fianna Fáil

This is the second occasion on which I have presented the Estimates for the Justice group of Votes, that is Votes 19 to 24, for consideration by this committee. The sum involved — nearly £558 million — is a reflection of the Government's continued commitment to the fight against crime and the reform of the criminal justice system.

Before I address the details of the Estimates, I wish to make some comments about crime. We are all of course concerned at the level and type of crime in Ireland today. The recent horrific and senseless murders in the Clare and Galway areas have heightened our awareness even further. In particular, they raise the spectre that the more violent criminal trends, which unfortunately are often a normal part of daily life in other societies in the world, might become a normal part of criminal activity in this country.

There are of course considerations which ought to be mentioned by way of setting things in context and avoiding undue anxiety. First, the crime situation in Ireland is no worse than many of our European counterparts and in fact is far better than most. Second, Ireland has the opportunity to learn, and is in fact learning, from trends which have already developed in other countries, how to combat certain types of crime and to ensure that our society is kept as safe as possible. Third, and importantly, the Irish community is, I believe, one of the most informed and conscious societies in the developed world and is extremely aware that they also have a role to play in crime prevention in addition to the response of the law enforcement agencies. This awareness is complemented by the increasing involvement in recent years by the Garda with the communities which they serve — a topic to which I will refer again later.

However, we need to say a little more in order to allay the concerns which emerged following the recent murders to which I have referred. The atmosphere which these appalling and tragic events have generated goes beyond the very natural feeling of grief for the victims and those left behind — there is generated also a sense that there is now a new norm in Irish life and that events like those I have mentioned may be visited on any of our neighbourhoods at any time.

I believe that, as public representatives, we have a responsibility to say that the circumstances which surround these particular and individual events do not signify the emergence of a new norm. All of us have been distressed and saddened by what has happened, but it runs way beyond the bounds of reason to cite these events as examples of a fundamental change in the standards of behaviour and treatment which the people of this country may expect from their fellow citizens.

It is no longer possible to give a strict definition of what constitutes "crime" as the issue has broadened significantly in line with those developments which are intrinsically related to modern society and which have affected the way we work, live and play. Fraud, for instance, is an example of a modern day crime and both the Government's and the Garda Síochána's response to this issue have adapted in line with these developments.

Since becoming Minister for Justice I have become aware of just how many aspects there are to the topic of crime. This awareness has, I believe, allowed me to consider in a more focused way that is a suitable response to dealing with the issue of crime and the fact that this response must reflect its current complexity. For this reason, the measures contained in the law and order package which I published last December, and which represent a significant initiative and investment by the Government, reflect the fact that crime in modern day society is a multi-faceted issue and that the response to the problem must be a considered and comprehensive one. I am confident this package reflects these aspects and will have long lasting and significant benefits for the public.

The drugs situation remains one of my highest priorities. We are all aware of the horrific effects of drug misuse and addiction. In so far as law enforcement is concerned, the Garda are having regular successes in detecting and prosecuting drug offences. We read about these cases frequently in the media. The Criminal Justice (No. 3) Bill, 1993, will be enacted, hopefully, very shortly. It will enable the proceeds of serious crime, including drug trafficking, to be confiscated. I am confident these new powers will prove most effective in tackling the main players in organised crime, including the "drug barons".

I turn now to the individual Votes. A sum of £19.114 milion is provided in the Vote for the Office of the Minister for Justice and for certain other services including the Data Protection Commissioner, the Garda Complaints Board and the Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal. The figure provided represents a 3 per cent increase on the 1993 provisional outturn. The additional funding is mainly to provide for increased costs due to additional duties and responsibilities which my Department has arising from the Maastricht Treaty and for increased salary costs. I have also provided a sum of £110,000 for the Irish Association for Victim Support — a voluntary organisation whose aims and objectives I support and whose sterling work with the victims of crime I greatly admire.

The provision in this year's Estimate for the Garda Vote is £393.936 million. This represents an increase of over £22 million, or almost 6 per cent on last year's initial allocation. A substantial part of this increased funding will be spent on a number of special initiatives in the Garda area, which I am taking in order to prevent and detect crime more effectively.

The Government is committed to giving the Garda, the courts and the prison service the necessary resources to tackle crime in all its forms. The package of law and order measures to be implemented in the years 1994 to 1997 has an overall cost of £66 million. The measures in the package are essential to confront the criminals in our society who prey on law abiding people.

On the Garda Síochána side, the main measures included in the package include the acceleration of the existing recruitment campaign by the recruitment of 407 additional Garda trainees this year. This involves bringing forward by one year the four year recruitment campaign originally begun in 1992 and due to end in 1995. This year the number of gardaí recruited will be double what it would otherwise have been. During the period 1995 to 1997, 1,050 gardaí will be recruited to maintain the force at its current optimum level. This will mean an annual intake of 350 a year in each of those years. This recruitment process has already begun. A commitment has been made to the ongoing process of civilianisation in the Garda Síochána. A further 200 civilians will be recruited at the rate of 50 a year for each of the years 1994 to 1997. This is a key strategy to get gardaí away from desks and out onto the streets of our cities and towns for operational duties, the duties for which they were recruited and trained. I am also in the process of beginning the recruitment of civilians to slot in at management level in the force to fill senior positions. A modern police force must be mobile and able to depend on its transport. My plan approaches the whole question of fleet management in a structured way and it ensures that the Garda will have the vehicles they need for all the varied aspects of their work.

Closed circuit television monitoring is becoming more prevalent in society today. We are all used to seeing the cameras in shops, petrol filling stations and banks. We also see the benefits of this technology as an aid to policing in programmes such as the "Crimeline" TV series. Closed circuit television is extremely successful in identifying criminals and it has a huge deterrent effect. My plan provides for the installation, on a pilot basis, of closed circuit television technology in two areas of Dublin — the city centre and the Temple Bar area. When we have evaluated its effectiveness, we will consider the extension of this initiative to other areas.

I also will be implementing certain proposals of the advisory committee on fraud in relation to staffing structures in the Garda fraud squad. The legal changes recommended by the committee are being worked on in my Department at present and I hope to publish a Bill updating our antiquated laws on dishonesty later this year.

I believe that preventing crime is better than solving it. For this reason funding has been provided in this year's Garda Estimates for the enhancement of crime prevention initiatives. My Department has been to the forefront in recent years in funding community based projects which have as their aim the diversion of young people at risk of sliding into a life of crime, vandalism and lawlessness away from anti-social behaviour and petty crime. This follows on from the conclusions in the 1992 report of the Inter-Departmental Committee on Urban Crime and Disorder.

My plan provides funding for the continuation of those initiatives which are channelled through the Garda to underscore the fact that the Garda are part of the communities in which they serve. These projects can be highly cost effective. I am happy with the success of the projects which were undertaken on a pilot basis in two areas of Dublin, in Ronanstown in north Clondalkin and Killinarden in Tallaght. This year I have included provision for the funding of further community based schemes in Knocknaheeny/Hollyhill in Cork and Moyross in Limerick. The extension of these youth diversion projects to other areas is also under consideration.

The present strength of the Garda Síochána is 10,892. In addition, the employment of almost 700 civilians to perform clerical duties has led to the release of gardaí to perform the outdoor operational duties for which they were specially selected and trained. The operational strength of the force is now at its highest level ever. The Government is committed to maintaining the strength of the Garda Síochána at this level and are taking the necessary steps to ensure this.

The Garda Estimate 1994 includes the provision of £2.4 million for the implementation of the Garda information technology plan. It will make a very substantial contribution to the effectiveness of the Garda Síochána. For example, the plan will enable information, once collected, to be used for several different purposes and for time-consuming manual procedures to be automated, thus enabling the gardaí to spend less time on paper-work and more on important outdoor police work. Crime detection rates will be increased through improved co-ordination of information and through the provision of computerised fingerprint identification facilities. Improved management information will enable more effective use to be made of Garda resources and a more effective response to be provided to the public.

Total once-off expenditure on the IT plan will be in the region of £26 million. The £2.4 million included in this year's Estimate will be spent on the computer capital, staffing and consultancy areas and the sum is in addition to the normal provision of approximately £1.2 million for Garda computerisation, including maintenance.

Turning to the Prisons Vote, the Estimates provide for significant increases for prison staff and accommodation and also for probation and welfare service staff and community facilities. These are aimed in a strategic way at enabling both services to respond to the urgent demands being placed upon them. In all, a total of £108.6 million has been provided in the Estimates, of which £10.9 million is for the probation and welfare service. This compares with last year's provisional outturn of £96.3 million, of which £8.8 million was for the probation and welfare service.

The single biggest area of expenditure on the Prisons Vote is salaries, wages and allowances for prison staff. These account for £70.9 million in the Estimates for 1994, compared with last year's provisional outturn of £66.4 million. The increase is for 204 additional staff, as well as for the effect of increases under the Programme for Economic and Social Progress and increments.

The extra prison staff are being provided for the health care unit at Mountjoy Prison and to reduce the extent of overtime working which has been at an unsustainably high level of recent years. Last year's overtime expenditure came to £14.2 million, or 21 per cent of the pay bill. This situation, or course, reflects the expanding workload of the prison system arising by way of increasing numbers of prisoners, the operation of new accommodation and associated workload increases. Unlike other services, much of the work arising in prisons has to be done as it arises, and often the most effective and economical way to meet it is by overtime working. However, there is scope for identifying recurrent demands which could be met with additional staff. The recruitment programme which is provided for includes a step in that direction and will, in fact, re-establish the relative balance between pay and overtime which existed a few years ago.

There is a provision of £15.1 million for buildings and equipment under subhead B. This represents an increase of £4.5 million on the provision in 1993 and the increase is almost exclusively in respect of costs to be incurred this year in providing new prison accommodation. As Deputies will be aware, the provision of 210 additional prison places is an integral part of the comprehensive law and order package approved by the Government. Sixty of the additional places will be in a new purpose-designed prison facility for women offenders and the remaining 150 places, for male offenders, will be provided at Castlerea, County Roscommon.

A high priority is being accorded to the planning and construction of these two prison facilities. Planning work is well advanced in both cases and the construction of the prison perimeter wall and associated works for Castlerea prison has already commenced. It is my intention that the two new institutions will be completed and come into use as quickly as possible.

Side by side with the provision of extra places, it is my policy to develop further community-based sanctions for appropriate offenders. I am committed to finding the right balance between custodial and community sanctions. The law and order package involves the recruitment of an additional 50 probation and welfare officers and support staff over the next four years for that purpose and we have provided £0.5 million in 1994 for the first phase of this recruitment.

I have also obtained approval to fill 20 existing vacancies in the probation service this year. Thirteen of these staff will be assigned to the intensive supervision scheme. This is where young serious offenders are referred by the court as an alternative to custody or from prison at an early stage of sentence. Offenders are intensively supervised and are challenged to confront their offending behaviour — not just its causes but also its consequences on themselves, their families and their victims. I am satisfied that this programme is doing an effective job for us in reducing repeat offending among serious offenders. Over 100 offenders are currently participating in the scheme and this will be substantially increased to closer to 200 when the extra 13 staff are recruited. The response rate to the scheme measured by the numbers who remain out of crime and by the attendance and level of commitment to the programme, is approximately 75 per cent. The total of 70 extra staff for the probation and welfare service will represent an increase of over 40 per cent in the strength of the service by 1997.

Finally, in relation to this Vote I will shortly be publishing a comprehensive policy document/five-year plan for the management of offenders. The developments I have outlined above are a critical element of the strategy I will be adopting.

I move now to the Courts Vote. It goes without saying that the courts play a vital role in the administration of justice and I have broad responsibility for providing the services necessary to enable the courts to function efficiently and effectively. The Courts Vote provides the funding necessary to equip the courts to carry out their role.

The Vote covers the usual costs such as salaries, office equipment, accommodation and telecommunications. The estimated net cost of the courts system in 1994, taking into account the gross current expenditure and revenue accruing to the State through fines etc., is approximately £20.5 million.

The efficiency of all aspects of the courts is of great concern to me. I have already obtained Government approval for the appointment of three additional judges — one to the High Court, one to the Circuit Court and one to the District Court — to address delays in the hearing of criminal cases. With regard to the hearing of family law cases, I have read with interest the Law Reform Commission consultation paper on this matter and as soon as I receive their final report it will receive my immediate attention.

I am also actively addressing the problem of court accommodation. I am glad that this year I have secured an increase in the allocation for expenditure on court accommodation with £4.25 million being provided for capital works and a new allocation of £1 million being made available for maintenance projects in provincial courts. I will continue to take whatever measures are necessary within the resources available to me to maintain and improve the services provided by the court system.

A sum of £12.073 million being provided in the Vote for the Land Registry and Registry of Deeds represents an 8 per cent increase in the 1993 provisional outturn. The additional funds provided are mainly to cover salary and other costs associated with the operation of the registries.

The committee will be aware of the Government's decision to reconstitute the Land Registry and Registry of Deeds as a commercial semi-State body. The interim board to the registries, which was appointed in July 1992, is continuing its deliberations. Progress is being made in regard to the necessary administrative and legislative steps necessary to convert the registries to semi-State status.

The Government decided in November 1992 that part of the operations of the Land Registry is to be transferred to Waterford city. Arising from this decision, I established a study group in July 1993 to examine the problems arising from decentralisation and to make recommendations as to how the Government decision is to be implemented with minimum disruption to the operation of the Land Registry. Arising from the study group's recommendations, I have decided which areas of Land Registry work should be transferred to Waterford. The transfer of the work in question will involve in the region of 150 staff. A circular issued on 20 May 1994 throughout the Civil Service canvassing staff in other Departments who would be interested in transferring to Waterford. It is envisaged that the move to Waterford will take place in 1996.

Finally, a sum of £203,000 has been provided to cover the costs of running the Office of the Commissioners of Charitable Donations and Bequests.

In the time available I have tried to explain how the resources are being addressed so as to obtain the maximum value from the funds available to my Department. I look forward to hearing the contributions Deputies may wish to make and I will try to answer the questions which may arise.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I propose this committee should seek powers to send for persons, papers and records concerning the granting of Irish citizenship to two residents of the middle east and, further, agree to set up an inquiry into the circumstances surrounding the granting of citizenship to these persons and the related investment in a company owned by the Taoiseach's family. It is wholly unacceptable that a closed shop of Ministers should, first, consider persons for citizenship on the alleged intimate knowledge of one of its members; second, grant the applications behind closed doors; third, not inquire whether any colleague or his family benefitted financially by such a decision; and, fourth, bypass the IDA, which was not consulted in this case, although it was in others. If this were to happen in the Stock Exchange it would be called insider trading. Nobody likes involving the family of a Minister or Deputy in public controversy but it is simply not on for the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste to hide behind the shield of decency which is conventionally observed. Public office holders — not their families have some explaining to do. When the Taoisach left office as Minister——

Comment on this

The terms of reference of this committee are very clear and the Deputy is aware of them. It is not in order this morning——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

If you wish to press this, Sir, I will ask for an adjournment of this committee and we will go the House. We are debating the Estimates for the Department of Justice and various Votes. The office of the Minister for Justice, which granted these citizenships, is up for debate here this morning. It is wholly in order and if you wish to challenge my right to raise this matter here I will ask that this meeting be adjourned and we will go to the House to clarify the matter.

Comment on this

The terms of reference of the select committee are clear and precise on the matters falling within its remit. In essence, the committee may consider Estimates for the public service relevant to justice, law reform and defence; the impact on equality of policy relevant to the aforementioned areas; Committee Stages of those Bills relevant to the aforementioned areas as referred to us by the Dáil and reports relevant to the aforementioned areas referred by the committee to the Dáil.

It is not in my remit as chairman or, indeed, within the remit of this committee to act outside our terms of reference which clearly preclude the line of action suggested by the Deputy. The committee cannot unilaterally alter its terms of reference. If changes are to be made they cannot be made by the committee. The Deputy will have to go back to the Dáil and have that matter discussed. It is not within our remit, we already agreed that the purpose of this meeting is to discuss the Estimate for the Department of Justice, as agreed by the convenors and we should proceed with that.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is what I am seeking to do. I am not seeking to unilaterally change your terms of reference. I am asking for the committee's support to seek a change in our terms of reference to inquire into this matter. I hope that other members will support my proposal that we seek an amendment of our terms of reference to inquire into this matter. I intend to refer to this matter on the Vote for the Department of Justice. I hope that other members will support my proposal.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is quite in order since the passport issue falls within the remit of the Department of Justice. As seen on the Order of Business today, it is impossible to raise this matter and be in order. This House is a farce if a major scandal of public importance and interest cannot be raised. The Dáil is adjourning today and there will be no other opportunity in the main Houses of the Oireachtas to raise this matter of legitimate public interest. The Deputy is quite in order in bringing this matter up at this committee.

Comment on this

The Deputy should be very careful about using the word "scandal". This matter was dealt with in the House very clearly by the Ceann Comhairle——

Comment on this

It is not finished yet.

Comment on this

——as laid down by the rules of the House. I want to caution members who are trying to use another method of raising this matter here. It is not in order——

Comment on this

The matter is raised, Chairman, with respect——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

You are eating into my time, Chairman. I want injury time.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt any Deputy. We came here for a specific purpose. Because people did not get their way in the Dáil with the rulings of the Ceann Comhairle——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Chairman, behave impartially, please, as a chairman should.

Comment on this

I will be impartial and I am asking for co-operation.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Do not make statements of that kind.

Comment on this

The rules clearly lay down the function of this committee, which I ask the members to remember.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

We are debating the Justice Estimate. You, chairman, are the only one being disorderly.

Comment on this

I am asking for the co-operation of the members to get on with the Estimate for the Department of Justice. I call Deputy Gilmore.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it not in order for any member of this committee to raise a matter which comes within the remit of the Minister for Justice when discussing the Justice Estimate? It has always happened. I recall raising during the Justice Estimate last year a very specific individual situation which arose within the Minister's remit. It was not ruled out of order then, it was perfectly in order. It has always been the case that a committee can ask the House to widen its terms of reference or remit. Quite frankly, Chairman, I am very disappointed that you are now seeking to muzzle members of this committee from raising a controversial issue. The fact that it is a controversial issue should not prevent us from raising and discussing it here. We have always been entitled to raise individual matters which come within the Minister's remit.

Comment on this

I am not refusing to allow people to raise the matter under the Estimate of the Department of Justice. However, it is not within my remit as Chairman of this committee to adjourn to have the terms of reference changed. That is the function of the Dáil.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Who used the word "adjourn"?

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

No, Sir. I read from the script in front of me. I noted it carefully and did not use the word "adjourn". I said that this committee agrees to seek powers to send for persons, papers and records concerning the granting of Irish citizenship. The record will show exactly what I said. I made no mention of the word adjourn. I am afraid, Sir, that you have been wrongly briefed by the people I sought advice from before this meeting.

Comment on this

What I am saying——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Look at the record. There was no mention of the word "adjourn" except from you.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wishes to have the terms of reference changed it must be done in another forum. That is what I am saying.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is entirely within the remit of this committee——

Comment on this

The terms of reference of the committee were agreed by the Dáil. I work under those and I will continue to work under them.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I was the chairman of a committee for six years and we sent a report to the Dáil seeking an amendment of our terms of reference, which was granted. I want this committee's support to seek the amendment of our terms of reference to inquire into this matter at arm's length and to make all these facts public. It is perfectly in order to seek to do that and it is also perfectly in order to mention this matter. If you do it outside the House, you are accused of one thing and if you do it when the Minister is absent you are accused of another. This is the proper place to do it when the Minister is present and has an opportunity to reply.

Comment on this

I would just like to remind the Deputy that if he is putting that down he needs to give notice to the committee.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am giving notice of the motion now.

Comment on this

The Progressive Democrats will support Deputy Mitchell in this application to see the files. It would appear that the Tánaiste has had access to files as a result of which he has given general absolution to the Taoiseach and other Ministers in this matter. The public has a right to know on what basis he reached that general absolution statement. The public has a right to know the detail of the matters raised. Legitimate questions were put to the Minister for Justice as far back as April on this matter. If those questions had been adequately answered the present controversy might not have arisen. The refusal and the distraction policies used by the Minister for Justice in this matter has resulted in the controversy. It is in the public interest and a legitimate point of inquiry. This committee should have the wherewithal and power to order that these files be examined.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I hope that these contributions are not coming out of my allocation.

Comment on this

I support Deputy Mitchell's proposal. This is the proper committee to investigate this matter. It should not be the subject of investigation behind closed doors by members of the Cabinet who have their own interest in ensuring that the whole matter is hushed up. This matter is now in the public domain and this is the appropriate committee of the House to investigate it. Again, I appeal to you to facilitate members of the committee who want to have this matter discussed and seek a widening of its terms of reference to enable the investigation to be conducted in public by the appropriate committee of the House so that the public can form its own judgment as to what took place.

Comment on this
Frances Fitzgerald Ms F. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I support Deputy Mitchell. How seriously are we treating these committees in terms of discussing real information and cutting edge issues about which the public is concerned? This committee should be used to look at the information which Deputy Mitchell is requesting.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Nobody likes involving the family of a Minister or Deputy in public controversy. However, as I said, it is simply not on for the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste to hide behind the shield of decency which is conventionally observed. When the Taoiseach left office as Minister for Finance he was presented with a spanking new Jaguar, purportedly by his family, the same family which gained a substantial financial investment as a result of granting Irish citizenship to two Arabs. Does anybody seriously believe that a substantial increase in the worth of a company built up by Deputy Reynolds will not at any time benefit him, directly or indirectly?

What would Deputy Spring have made of this if the person involved was Charles Haughey and not Albert Reynolds? The presentation of a dagger to the Haughey family by an Arab leader was the subject of a major public controversy. Who are the directors of C and D Pet Foods Limited? Who are its real and beneficial owners? Have we come to the stage in Irish politics where a spade in no longer to be called a spade?

Comment on this

We are not discussing that issue. Will the Deputy give formal notification to include this matter on the agenda and I will put it to the committee?

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will not be muzzled.

Comment on this

Today's agenda has already been agreed. If the Deputy wishes to raise a matter I want proper notice so that I can inform all members of the committee.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am informing the committee of a proposal for this committee to seek these powers and there is strong support for the committee having power to inquire into these matters. If the Government has nothing to hide why not put all the facts before the committee? The Tánaiste, Deputy Spring, has investigated; the Government is pretending to act as prosecutor, defence, judge and jury in a case in which it is also the accused. To nobody's great surprise it has found itself not guilty. This process is a parody of justice.

The committee should look into this. Justice must be done and seen to be done. If these files have nothing to hide and are available to the Tánaiste who has studied them at length apparently, let us have the files out in the open so we can examine them and, if necessary, exonerate those involved or point the finger if there has been impropriety. If this happened in the Judiciary there would be impeachments; members of the Judiciary simply would not behave in this way. However, a member of the Government can behave in this way without explanation and without being accountable to Parliament.

I want this committee to inquire into this matter and seek the powers to send for persons, papers and records. It is a simple proposal. I ask the committee to support the proposal——

Comment on this

I remind the Deputy again that there is no difficulty with that, but we need formal notice of the motion. The Deputy can raise this matter under the Justice Estimates but he has not done that.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I have; this is my opening comment.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wishes to change the terms of reference he can do so by a formal motion notifying the Chair. I am asking him to do so and he will not. He is taking advantage of the committee. He is entitled under the Justice Estimate to raise that matter but as regards the other aspects of what he is proposing, I want a formal motion to allow the Chairman to notify members that the matter is on the agenda.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am proposing that the committee should seek these powers. I did not ask that the committee should vote on it but if the Chairman wishes I will do so. I am entitled to make a proposal, to seek the support of members for such a proposal and am determined to make sure that I am not deterred from doing it. This committee is the appropriate one to inquire into——

Comment on this

Under the terms of reference of the committee I am entitled to ask for formal notification if the Deputy wants to change the terms of reference to do what he wishes. He is not doing that.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am giving notice now.

Comment on this

The Deputy has the opportunity under the Justice Estimates to raise the matters and he has not done so.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am giving notice now.

Comment on this

I want formal notice and that is not formal notice.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

This is my proposal and if the Chairman refuses to put it to the committee it is a matter the committee will have to look at.

Comment on this

It is not that I refuse to do so. I am observing the terms of reference of the committee. There are procedures for dealing with the business, of which the Deputy is well aware. If he wants adjustments to them there are procedures for doing so and formal notification should be given to the Chairman. That is what I am asking for.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am not only giving the Chairman notice but I am giving the committee notice that I want it to seek these powers.

Comment on this

The entire committee is not present. There is a procedure for dealing with this to which the Deputy is not adhering.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

All the committee members got notice of this meeting. If some are not here that is their problem. I am giving the committee notice that I am seeking these powers and there is obviously strong support here for seeking them. What have we got to hide?

Comment on this

There are procedures for dealing with that and the Deputy is not following them. An agenda was made out and agreed by the convenors. The Deputy is fully aware of it and I am not accepting the way in which this matter is being introduced.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am giving notice to the committee that I want it to seek an expansion of its powers. If the Chairman is refusing to put that motion to the committee I will raise it some other way. I was flabbergasted to find that we do not have the power to do this under this Estimate. It should be done here and now.

Comment on this

It will not be done here and now because that is not the procedure. I need formal notice of changes. We have an agreed agenda and the Deputy now wants to change it. There are terms of reference for dealing with the business of this committee; I am adhering to them and the Deputy is not. I need formal notice of the Deputy's proposal to deal with it. There is no problem dealing with the matter when I have proper notice of it.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Is the motion being ruled out of order?

Comment on this

No. I am asking the Deputy to abide by the terms of reference and to give proper notice of this proposal to the Chair. When I get formal notice I will notify members of the committee that this issue is on the agenda and they will attend. It is not appropriate to do that this morning.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

If I put the motion to the Chair in writing could we adjourn and summon the members for a meeting this afternoon to consider it?

Comment on this

I will not adjourn the meeting. We agreed the timetable at the start of the meeting but, unfortunately, the Deputy was not present.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I have the timetable in front of me.

Comment on this

The members of the committee present agreed with the terms of reference and the timetable. Halfway through a meeting I am not prepared to change what was agreed by those present. I am not prepared to adjourn the meeting. I will accept a formal notification and I will put it to the committee.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I was given 15 minutes to make my opening statement and I started to make it, but I have been harangued and harassed by the Chair trying to stop me making my opening comments.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not because if he had addressed——

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

If the Chair wants notice I will give it. Will the Chair allow the committee to consider the matter this afternoon when members have been notified? I am prepared to accept that; I will put the proposal now and the Chairman can call a meeting to consider it later.

Comment on this

The Deputy is fully aware of the situation having been chairman of a committee. Certain guidelines are laid down. I have to give proper notice to members. To suggest that I adjourn the meeting to facilitate the Deputy is not acceptable because it is not fair to other members.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

May I have an undertaking that the Chair will, in the near future, call a meeting of the committee to consider this motion?

Comment on this

When I get the request I will deal with it.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am making the request now.

Comment on this

I will give it consideration if the Deputy follows the formal procedure.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Will it be accepted? If I put this proposal and it is ruled out now will a meeting of the committee be called to consider it in the near future while the matter is current?

Comment on this

I have been Chairman of this committee for over 12 months and the Deputy has repeatedly complimented me at meetings on the manner in which I have conducted the committee's business.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I hope to be able to continue to do so.

Comment on this

I am sure he has confidence in my ability to make a mature decision on this matter.

Comment on this

On a point of order, do we have the power to order our business on this committee? Is it possible for the Chair, at the request of committee members, to order another meeting in the near future?

Comment on this

This matter relates to terms of reference which we do not have.

Comment on this

Do the terms of reference of this committee allow us to order its business?

Comment on this

We are being asked to discuss a change in the terms of reference to carry out certain functions which the present terms of reference do not allow. It is not a straightforward meeting as the Deputy puts it. The request will be dealt with in the normal way and I will convey my views to the members.

Comment on this

As I understand it we are allowed to order our own business. We are convened this morning to discuss the Estimates for the Department of Justice. Among the matters we are entitled to consider as part of the Estimates for the Department of Justice is the Department's responsibility for dealing with citizenship. The members of the committee have many detailed questions to ask the Minister about the way in which that area of her responsibility has been functioning. I will certainly want to ask questions on the specific case which has come to light in recent days. The detail we will want to go into in those questions before we decide whether we wish to agree to the Estimates will involve a considerable amount of time. It would be prudent if the Chair allowed the opening statements to be made.

When we discuss the aspect of the Minister's responsibility dealing with citizenship, it will first be necessary for this committee to put a series of questions to the Minister who may have to bring the information we seek back to this committee. Perhaps it may be necessary to have a further meeting to consider that. The discussion of the Estimates will permit us to question the Minister on issuing passports and the affair that has recently become a matter of public controversy. Will the Chairman clarify if we are entitled, under the present terms of reference of this committee and the discussion of the Estimates, to put specific questions to the Minister on the Masri affair?

Comment on this

It would have helped if we had proceeded with the business and questions of relevance of the Department of Justice could then have been asked. I have no difficulty with Members asking questions on this matter. I am sure the Minister could adequately deal with them. However, Deputy Gay Mitchell has requested something different altogether. There is a procedure for dealing with the matter by giving formal notice to the Chairman. If that had been done, there would not have been problems. I am not prepared to discuss this during a meeting. A notification proposing a meeting will be dealt with in the normal way.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

Chairman, you have clarified one aspect. You ruled out Deputy Gay Mitchell's request, but when the Deputy asked if such a meeting would be convened if he gave formal notification, you hesitated in answering him. You have to deal with a formal application, Chairman.

Comment on this

I had no hesitation with that, Deputy. I got little co-operation this morning. If a formal request comes to me, it goes without saying that I have to deal it. Any issue relating to Justice could have been dealt with. Unfortunately, Deputy Mitchell wanted to go down another avenue not permitted by the terms of reference of this committee. The Deputy asked that a meeting be held to decide whether we travel that road. I will deal with this matter when the formal notification comes through.

Comment on this

Chairman, are you suggesting that, as a compromise, we can deal with this matter today by putting specific questions to the Minister for Justice under the relevant subhead dealing with passports and the administration of the Department of Justice as it relates to passports?

Comment on this

Members are entitled to deal with any issue on the agenda covered by the headings under discussion.

Comment on this

Is there not a time restriction on putting those questions and seeking clarification on certain matters?

Comment on this

That is a matter for the Members. We agreed on a timetable to assist Members. The meeting will end at 4 p.m., even if some other aspects of the Estimates are not discussed by then. This timetable was agreed by Members to ensure that all headings were discussed and Members could make a contribution. I can do nothing about it if Members spend all day on one aspect.

Comment on this

This morning, the Taoiseach denied the Tánaiste's statements last night about reviewing the system. There is a conflict between those statements.

Comment on this

Deputy, it is not within my remit to deal with the matter in this committee. The function of this committee is to deal specifically with the Estimates of the Department of Justice.

Comment on this

I will raise the matter under the relevant subhead.

Comment on this

Is the Chairman prepared to deal with a formal motion from Deputy Gay Mitchell when he receives it?

Comment on this

It is my duty to accept a motion from any Member. The matter will then be examined.

Comment on this

That is fair enough Chairman, will you also accept a motion from Deputy Gay Mitchell and others calling for this committee to be convened tomorrow or early next week to discuss this matter?

Comment on this

The matter will be dealt with when I get the motion.

Comment on this

What will be the procedure for Members to convene a meeting of the committee?

Comment on this

The convenors will decide when it will take place.

Comment on this

Will the convenor of the committee accept a motion from Deputy Mitchell calling for a meeting for some time next week?

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is a matter for the Chairman.

Comment on this

The motion will be submitted to me. The timing of the meeting will be decided between the convenors, in consultation with me.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Chairman, if you promise that the content of this motion will be considered fairly and impartially for consideration at an early meeting, I will not press the matter any further.

Comment on this

This committee is still in its infancy. There are limits to what this committee can discuss. The Government Whip indicated he is reviewing the efficacy of these committees and the need to extend them to accommodate other areas of Members' interests. At present, we are not empowered to do that. I support the Chairman's comments on agreeing to a set timetable to address the Votes of the Department of Justice this morning. It is only fair to adhere to that agreement.

Comment on this

Would it not have been unreal for the committee to meet without debating this subject? We would have been the laughing stock of the nation. It is up to the members of the committee to decide what they want to debate. If it is not on the agenda today and if the Chairman is prepared to consider Deputy Gay Mitchell's motion, will he then consider a further motion calling for the committee to meet either tomorrow or next Tuesday?

Comment on this

The formal procedure is that Deputy G. Mitchell will submit the question——

Comment on this

Surely the answer to my question is a simple yes or no.

Comment on this

Naturally, I have to acknowledge the request of a Member. Can we not proceed with the business proposed for today? Deputy G. Mitchell has agreed to submit his request for a meeting to discuss this matter and it will be considered.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Will it receive fair and impartial consideration?

Comment on this

Every decision I make is fair and impartial, and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

In that case, Chairman, I shall draft a formal request and submit it to you within the hour.

Comment on this

On the unprecedented high levels of violent crime in our cities and in rural areas, the Estimate provides the opportunity to condemn it and to propose specific strategies to alleviate it. People are tired of hearing about what is wrong and want to see results. In her opening statement, the Minister puts drug abuse and measures to counteract this high on her agenda. Will she confirm that the strength of the Drug Squad, numbering 27 members, has been diminished by a third due to administrative matters such as promotions or transfers? More crimes are becoming directly associated with drug abuse as many addicts need to feed their habit and thus resort to crime. More gardai need to be appointed to the Drug Squad to fill the gaps made by these administrative transfers and promotions, to enhance the force and give them more specialist and technical expertise, especially in their fight against drugs.

As regards the millions of pounds proposed to be spent on our prison system, it goes without saying that the system has been an abject failure. It is a waste of taxpayers' money to throw more funds at the problem without addressing the structural defects and lack of planning in the prison system. At present it costs £600 a week to keep one person in jail and the taxpayer is not getting good value for money.

The report of the visiting committee for the last three years indicates that the situation in Mountjoy, in particular, is unsustainable. The committee referred to it as a potential volcano and the latest report says it is an appalling vista. The Progressive Democrats believe that our prisons should be places of discipline and detoxification, instead of places where 80 per cent of the inmates do nothing all day. That is verified in the report of the visiting committee, which states they are encouraged to do nothing. There is no incentive for inmates to engage in the rehabilitation and educational projects which are available. In 80 per cent of cases, as verified in the Mountjoy report, they opt for inactivity. The report states that it is impossible to quantify the extent to which the drugs and HIV problem in Mountjoy are cultivated by daily aimless activity. We have evidence that prisoners are only waiting for their next fix. This is a complete waste of the taxpayers' money. It is inhumane for prisoners and does not help to rehabilitate them. We need a plan for our prison population, to find out why they are there and if they will commit a further offence when they are released. It should be taboo for juveniles to go to Mountjoy. The juvenile justice Bill is urgently needed.

Bail reform is urgently needed, and this is almost a truism at this stage. Because of the constitutional imperative at present, a person can only be refused bail if there is evidence they will intimidate witnesses or not turn up for trial. The Progressive Democrats believe it should be possible to refuse bail and that bail sureties should be related to the good behaviour of the accused as well as to his possible failure to turn up for trial. In other words, the bailsman would be liable to forfeit bail if the accused committed an offence while on bail. This simple measure would radically reduce the number of crimes committed when people are on bail.

We need a separate remand institution. At present, prisoners on remand are left among the general prison population. This causes overcrowding which means that people who have gone through the criminal justice system, found guilty and sentenced are released to make way for people on remand. People on remand are presumed innocent until proven guilty and it is ridiculous and senseless that they should be left with the general prison population. This causes overcrowding which means that convicted prisoners must be released early.

The delays in the courts system should be discussed under this Estimate. There is no need for the present delays in the system. Summary offences are dealt with six to 12 months after the event because of court listing problems. Appeals for summary convictions frequently take another six months. This is the Minister's direct responsibility. Trials on indictment normally take place 12 to 18 months after the event. The overhaul of the courts system and courts administration and the speeding up of the listing system will have a marked effect on our justice system.

Morale in the Garda Síochána is something which cannot be paid for in this— or any other — Estimate. It is low at present and we should be concerned about this. The excellent men and women in the Garda Síochána are feeling low, unappreciated and unrepresented by the Garda Representative Association. It is unfair to expect them to accept the criticism of and responsibility for the proper administration of the criminal justice system when their needs are not appreciated or addressed.

I have written to the Minister for Justice to ask her to intervene in a festering industrial dispute in the Garda Síochána. The Dublin members of the Garda Representative Association have been given a mandate to form a breakaway group in July. Deadlines have come and gone, but no acceptable mediator has been agreed between the disputing partners. A legitimate case could be made because there is a perceived under-representation of the larger divisions in the Garda Representative Association. That was identified and recognised in an independent report by Mr. Crotty, which was commissioned by the Irish Management Institute.

We must address this problem, which is of fundamental importance to the working conditions of the Garda Síochána throughout the country. The gardaí have no voice and because they are not part of an ordinary trade union cannot withdraw their labour, go to the Labour Relations Commission or to an independent mediator. It is the Minister's duty in the public interest to intervene and to ensure that they come back to the table to discuss the perceived under-representation of larger divisions in Dublin. They have a legitimate right to question the fact that a smaller rural division, representing 160 members, can have the same voice at the Garda Representative Association as a larger division representing 600 members in Dublin South. It is fundamentally wrong and it must be tackled because morale cannot be bought with the taxpayers' money. The Minister must address this issue.

I tabled a written parliamentary question to the Minster for Justice in relation to the Garda Complaints Board and I expect an answer this afternoon. I have asked the Minister what percentage of alleged complaints brought against individual members of the Garda Síochána have come before the Garda Complaints Board and what percentage of those complaints are vexatious or malicious. I also want to know what action is taken, if such a finding is made, to vindicate the good name of the garda. A complaint against an individual garda can take up to a year to investigate and during that time the garda is under suspicion, morale is reduced and it affects them taking on extra duties. They are afraid to take risks because a complaint may be lodged against them. If most of the complaints against a garda are vexatious, he should have a right to reply and his good name should be vindicated.

The Progressive Democrats also believe that victims' support is inadequate. I appreciate that the Minister has improved the contribution to the Irish Association for Victim Support and that is as it should be. However, we believe that the victims of crime have been the poor relation in the justice system. Compensation should be statutory. At present, we fully compensate victims of uninsured driving, yet we offer nothing to victims of rape or to elderly victims of assault. There is a compensation culture in Ireland, but this is not reflected in compensation to victims of crime. This is the weakest section of our community, which has no voice.

At present, victims are compensated for their medical expenses. Those healthy or young enough to work get compensation for loss of earnings. However, even those meagre gestures at compensation are delayed by up to 30 months. It often takes two years for an award to be announced by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal. It takes a further two and a half years for the Department of Justice to pay the money to a victim. This is a delay of almost five years from the time of the crime to the time the payment is made. The Minister must put the Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal on a statutory basis and use increased fines to pay part of the cost of compensating victims.

As regards the cost of the new prison in Castlerea and the criteria used when deciding where to site it, would it have been cheaper to build the new prison on a green field site beside Wheatfield prison? What criteria was used when deciding to site it in the west? Was there a difference in cost? I understand the existing building in Castlerea will have to transformed at considerable expense to make it suitable as a prison. What cost analysis was done in relation to that decision or was it a political decision to site in the west? I understand not many jobs will be created because those in the prison service in Dublin will be transferred.

The Progressive Democrats carried out a survey in Dublin South-Central last weekend which found that over 25 per cent of those surveyed had witnessed a crime or that a member of their family had been a victim of criminal activity in the past 12 months. Incidents of crime are on the rise and perception is as important as reality. The Minister said crime levels here are not as high as in Britain and other European countries, but we must deal with the sensitivities of the people to this. There is a marked increase in fear among citizens and it is the Minister's responsibility to take urgent action, but not on a five year plan basis. Simple administrative changes could be made, which would not cost a lot of money. That should be the first item to be addressed by the Minister.

The Progressive Democrats put forward procedural and administrative changes which would not cost a lot. I urge the Minister to continue the work. She is a good Minister and responsive to suggestions from the Opposition. All parties are at one in putting crime at the top of the political agenda because that is where it is with the people.

Comment on this

The Minister's Estimate covers a range of areas and, given the time available, it would not be possible to address them all so I will concentrate on a couple. I will refer to the aliens section in the Department of Justice dealing with naturalisation and citizenship, which has been the subject of controversy over the past couple of days.

A couple of months ago, I was one of a number of Deputies who asked the Minister questions about a suspected two tier system for granting naturalisation and citizenship but the Minister assured me there was not. The reason I asked was that there was speculation at the time that there was a facility whereby investors in this country could get citizenship more quickly than those entering or those who had already entered this country in other circumstances.

I am concerned — other members will have experienced this over the years — about people who have come to this country with their families, who have lived here for many years and apply to the Department of Justice for citizenship. In some cases their application is virtually ignored or put on the long finger, while in others, applications are treated with hostility. There are also widely reported examples of people coming to this country from oppressive regimes being turned back at our ports and airports and in some cases being locked up in prison for several months. In a number of cases people were put in prison for several months for no other reason than they had come here to seek asylum from an oppressive regime.

This country has not taken the most enlightened approach to citizenship, asylum and the rights of refugees in relation to other EU member states. It is ironic that at the time the Masri application was being rushed through the system, representatives of the Government attended a European Union meeting addressing proposals to allow emigrant workers to be joined by their families. Of the 12 member states, this country objected to the humane proposal that the spouses and children of emigrant workers should be allowed to join them in the EU. It is ironic that unfortunate people, many of whom may end up working in menial occupations, are treated one way, while those in a position to put large sums of money on the table are treated in a preferential way.

I do not propose to go into the case which has been the subject of controversy over the past couple of days, whose company it is, etc., because at this stage most people who are aware of it have made up their minds. However, I would like to deal with the principle behind the business investment scheme. We are placing a low stock on the concept of citizenship and on the value of our passport if we proposed to flog it around international markets to whoever is prepared to put money up front.

I am in favour of having an open approach to those who want to come to live and invest in this country and to facilitate them in every possible way. However, the information which has been made public over the past couple of days about the way this has been done, in particular the information my colleague Deputy Rabbitte put on the record in the Dáil, shows a squalid approach in dealing with citizenship and access to passports.

I would like to address a number of questions to the Minister, to which I hope she will respond. The Tánaiste announced that the business investment scheme is being reviewed, although there is some doubt about this. I would like the Minister to say whether the business investment scheme and the way it is used to facilitate the granting of citizenship is being reviewed. I would like to know the nature of that review and who will conduct it. Will it include an examination of the racist dimension to the whole scheme, referred to by my colleague in the Dáil two evenings ago where he quoted the document which was being flogged around the international business community which spoke about applicants of Chinese or Indian origin not being eligible for it?

If the scheme is being reviewed and, in view of the fact that it has now been brought into such public disrepute, will the Minister agree to suspend it until the review is completed? Will the Minister make information available to this committee in relation to the operation of the scheme, in particular as to how many passports have been issued under it, how many people have been granted citizenship, a list of the people who have been granted citizenship, how much they invested in this country and where they invested it? It would be very helpful if that information was made available to the committee.

In relation to the particular case that has been the subject of controversy, the Tánaiste has gone on public record stating he examined the file in relation to it. It seems to me that there is so much now in the public domain about the application that it would be appropriate for the Minister to make that file available to this committee so that examination of it — which the Tánaiste stated he has undertaken — can be undertaken by this committee.

It is important that the Minister responds because we are convened to approve the Estimates for her Department and in normal circumstances neither I nor other Members of this committee would have any great difficulty in agreeing them. However, given the very serious questions raised over the past couple of days, it would be very difficult for this committee to agree the Estimates for the Department of Justice until it is satisfied in relation to the whole passports for sale issue. I hope the Minister will be able to provide us with the information I seek.

I wish to refer briefly to the wider issue of crime which is the main concern of the Department of Justice. We need a radical re-examination of how the problem of crime is being addressed. I know the Minister is committed to tackling crime and that she has put measures before this committee and the House at various times in relation to that. There is, however, a vacuum that needs to be filled. There is no body at present which draws together the opinions and views of the various people involved in tackling crime and in its prevention.

This committee is the appropriate body to put together a comprehensive policy for tackling and preventing crime. Prior to the establishment of this committee and in the last Dáil a committee on crime was beginning to make progress, which produced a very good report on the area of juvenile crime which I hope will form the basis of the legislation the Minister is preparing in this area. This committee needs to address the wider issue of crime and how it should be tackled. It needs to be in a position to talk to the gardaí, to people from the probation and welfare service, the prison service, and so on who have views on the issue. It would be helpful to the Minister for Justice if this committee was enabled to do that over a period of time.

There is an undue emphasis in tackling crime on trying to find solutions. We are spending a lot of money on the Minister's crime package on prisons. Very substantial sums of money are being spent in providing additional prison places, additional staff for the prisons, all of which unfortunately, are necessary in the present climate.

As we are addressing the financial side of justice, we have to ask whether public money might be better spent in trying to prevent crime. There is a need for an investment by the State in communities. The State should give money to assist local communities and voluntary associations, many of whom are starved of resources, in communities which are working extremely hard to try to keep people, particularly young people, out of trouble. There is a need to provide those resources to local communities in order to help their work.

The problem of terrorist attacks in this State, unfortunately, has come back on the agenda and we have already addressed in the House the recent pub bombing in Dublin. It is ironic that that bombing occured virtually on the 20th anniversay of the 1974 Dublin and Monaghan bombings which are still unresolved and the subject of considerable distress to the families of those who died or who were injured in those bombings.

I know the Minister has been examining this whole area following the Yorkshire Television documentary. I had hoped that she might have been in a position to make some positive statement as to what will be done about it to coincide with the 20th anniversary of the bombings. I do not know if she is yet in a position to make a statement on it and to tell us what progress is being made, but a number of very serious aspects of that case were raised in the Yorkshire Television documentary, in particular the virtually inexplicable cul de sac in which the gardaí wound up when they were attempting to investigate the bombings, when they clearly had suspects, when they brought their information to the RUC.

It would appear that north of the Border their attempts to investigate it were blocked and the then Minister for Justice made the unbelievable claim that he could not remember what had happened. It appears no attempt was made at the time to unlock the doors politically. I find it unbelievable that the gardai could, on a serious matter of this kind, the biggest carnage that occurred in this country during the whole troubles, while conducting a serious investigation, run into a stone wall north of the Border. I find it unbelievable that they would not have brought it to the attention of the Minister for Justice at the time and that the Minister for Justice at the time would not have made some attempt to try to unblock the whole situation.

Suspects were identified in relation to those bombings and we need to know what efforts, if any, have been made to bring them to justice? Given that various new extradition procedures have been put in place since 1974, can they be used to bring to trial in this jurisdiction people suspected of the 1974 bombings, identified by witnesses, suspected by the Garda and whom it wished to question at that time?

Comment on this

Regarding Vote 19, are there any questions?

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

Is the Minister prepared to answer questions on this Vote?

Comment on this

My function at this committee is to act responsibly and to answer questions regarding every aspect of the Votes for which I have responsibility. I have no difficulty answering questions.

Comment on this

On a point of clarification, under which subhead would it be appropriate to put questions regarding the passports issue?

Comment on this

I assume under subheads A.1 to A.8, dealing with administration.

Comment on this
John Browne Mr. Browne (Carlow-Kilkenny) Fine Gael

Members of the committee canvassing in the European elections have found that many people regard the elections as irrelevant to their lives. It also appears that the Dáil has been irrelevant for some time. Perhaps the huge Government majority is a cause.

On matters of public concern it is important that answers are provided. While the Minister was not responsible at the time, she now holds office and should provide answers to questions. In view of the recently published Ethics in Public Office Bill, 1994, which places our partners under pressure, as if they were going to do something drastic, it is amazing that the situation where somebody is linked up with a Minister and his family is not considered a breach of ethics.

Who were the directors and the beneficiaries of the company involved? If partners in mickey mouse deals are asked to reveal their sources of income and so on, is it too much to expect that the family of a Minister should be asked to identify themselves on an issue such as this?

The fact that the then IDA appears to have been bypassed raises a question. Everybody welcomes money coming into the country for industry, and more of this kind of money is desirable given the high unemployment. The then IDA continually endeavoured to establish industries in the country and rejected schemes for various reasons. Why, therefore, would an investment of £1 million not be checked out by the IDA and cleared? It appears, however, it was not involved in the matter.

There are many conflicting stories about who knew whom and what was going on. It was said that the Minister for the Environment, Deputy Smith, had intimate knowledge of the applicant, although this has since been questioned. Did the Minister have this knowledge, and in what way did he know the applicant? If this incident took place on the Stock Exchange it would be regarded as insider trading. How can this behaviour be justified, therefore, by asserting that there was no involvement by the Government and that it is not a source of embarrassment?

It appears that the Ethics in Public Office Bill, 1994, will require people to declare any sources of additional income over £5,000. Most people will have nothing to declare. Despite these stringent requirements, the Government does not appear to be concerned with this issue, which deals with a far higher figure. There is something peculiar about the fact that a decision on this issue was made during the formation of the Government and in this respect the image of politicians suffers once again because it appears they are looking after themselves. It is an image which is grossly unfair, but the public is only waiting for the opportunity to denigrate politicians.

I require some information on these questions as it may throw some light on the subject.

Comment on this

I have no difficulty answering the questions. The only matter I have difficulty with is that there appears to be a suggestion that in some way I told lies to the Dáil regarding this issue, a suggestion which I understand neither Deputy Browne nor Deputy Gilmore is making. I find this very damaging, both to me personally and to the Department and office which I represent. The information which I have given to the Dáil, and which the Dáil has, I hope, accepted as the truth, is available on file in the Department. I will go through the file and endeavour to answer a number of questions raised by both Deputies.

Deputy Browne asked a number of questions in the Dáil this week regarding, for example, the identity of the directors and the beneficiaries of the company involved. I take it that the Deputy is not suggesting that, I, as Minister for Justice, should be aware of this information, because this is a private company. All the information regarding questions of that kind may be obtained from the Companies Registration Office and the company itself. Commercial questions of that kind should be directed to them. I cannot be expected to have responsibility regarding who may be the directors of the company, and it is not a function of the Department of Justice.

Section 16 of the Irish Nationality and Citizenship Act, 1956, which was amended in 1986 provides that the Minister for Justice, in absolute discretion can grant a certificate of naturalisation where the applicant has Irish associations. It has been the policy and practice of successive Governments to give favourable consideration to applicants for naturalisations in the case of persons making or facilitating substantial investments in the State where such investments have the aim of job creation or the preservation of jobs that might otherwise be lost.

The consistent view of successive Governments has been that by being prepared to make a substantial investment in jobs in this country, and by purchasing a residence in the country, applicants for naturalisation, assuming that there is no serious impediment to naturalisation on other grounds, should be deemed to have the Irish associations necessary for the grant of citizenship.

I understand that certain other countries follow a similar policy and I believe that it would generally be considered to be in accordance with the intentions of the Legislature and with the spirit of the legislation that we should, as a matter of normal practice, grant applications in such cases rather than refuse them, in the sure knowledge that the investment will go elsewhere. Indeed, this kind of scheme is operated by many countries, including member states of the EU. In fact, it appears that systems operated by other member states of the EU are far less rigid than the scheme operated in this country through the Department of Justice.

Many favourable naturalisation decisions were made over the years. In answer to Deputy Gilmore's question as to how many, I repeat an answer I gave in the Dáil that they would run at approximately 20 per year. Regarding the Deputy's question as to who was involved, the list of those who have been naturalised is published as a matter of course in Iris Oifigiúil, through which the names are available publicly.

The critical issue in all cases, including the issue which is the subject of public debate, is whether proper procedures have been followed and whether the standard regarding Irish associations, accepted by successive predecessors of mine and by successive previous Governments, has been met. The files of the Department on this case show that on 10 July, 1992, the managing director of a consultancy firm, the same firm which has submitted other and unrelated applications for naturalisation, forwarded an application for naturalisation to the Department of Justice on behalf of the two persons whose names are now in the public domain. The consultancy firm was DML, a matter which is now also in the public domain, and it submitted the applications through the Minister for the Environment. Where could anyone get the idea that he had intimate knowledge of the individuals involved? This was not mentioned by him, the Department of Justice or anyone else in authority during this debate. The position stated by me is that the original application was submitted through the Minister for the Environment. This is not abnormal. Ministers, apart from the Minister for Justice, Ministers of State and Deputies from all sides of the House submitted applications to the Department of Justice during the years this has operated.

The applicants in this case were a mother and her son. We clarified that the husband was not involved. The application, when it came to the Department of Justice, indicated that it was on foot of a substantial investment in a manufacturing company in the midlands and the name of the company was not stated. When the Department carried out the normal inquiries and investigations it makes into these companies, it transpired that the name of the company was C & D Foods. The company confirmed that the jobs were created and maintained and a letter dated 15 July 1992 from a large and reputable firm of solicitors in Dublin confirmed that a residence had been purchased in Dublin. Subsequently, on 25 November 1992 the two investors made the required declaration of fidelity to the nation and loyalty to the State in the District Court in accordance with law and both of them were granted their naturalisation certificates on 15 December 1992.

There was nothing out of the ordinary or underhand about the way this application was dealt with. It was not unusual for the company which submitted the application on behalf of the individuals to submit it through another Minister. Such applications have often been submitted through other members of the Government, Ministers of State and Deputies from both sides of the House. Substantial job creation and investment was involved, there was a family investment in a residence and the declarations required by law were made in court. Several applications were granted by my predecessors in similar circumstances. From the day this application was submitted to the day a decision was made, representations were not made by the Taoiseach, Deputy Albert Reynolds.

The scheme operated from the beginning on the basis of substantial investment which succeeds in maintaining or creating jobs. There are several examples which I will not discuss now because it may be difficult for the Irish companies involved if their names are made public. There have been specific instances-workers, trade unions and managements in these companies would be able to confirm this-where jobs have been saved and created by such investments.

On whether this matter came to Government this case was never discussed by the Government. This is normal. None of the individual cases, of which there have been less than 20 per year since the scheme came into operation, went to Government during this period. These decisions are a matter of discretion by the Minister for Justice. Over the years I imagine there has been general discussion on the scheme, its operation and whether it should be extended. Without breaking Cabinet confidentiality, I can say a member of the Government once proposed that this type of scheme should be expanded to include investment in golf clubs. The Fianna Fáil Minister for Justice refused to accept this on the basis that the scheme was introduced to help existing jobs and to create new jobs. This would not be the case with golf clubs and for that reason, was not acceptable.

Last April, before this controversy arose, I initiated an inforaml discussion on this scheme at a Cabinet meeting. I recommended to my Cabinet colleagues who agreed, that an interdepartmental committee should be set up to look at the scheme. A number of applications were submitted to me since I became Minister for Justice and I made this proposal to the Cabinet because I felt we did not have the necessary expertise in the Department of Justice to make business decisons on investments of this type. In making recommendations, on such investments I wanted to have the benefit of information available through the Departments involved, such as the Department of Enterprise and Employment and Forbairt. I asked the Government for permission to set up a committee and this was given. The Departments of Finance, Foreign Affairs, Justice, Enterprise and Employment and Forbairt are involved as members of that committee. The committee's first task is to prepare the criteria for such investment. This is a positive task for the committee. After this, all applications will go the committee to be discussed and evaluated by it and it will then submit them to the Minister of the day.

I wish to clear up something very important said in the Dáil this morning. There was a suggestion that the Tánaiste stated that amended legislation would be introduced to deal with this area. The Tánaiste repeated what I said just now, that we set up an interdepartmental committee whose first task is to produce criteria or terms of reference, which will be published shortly, for the examination of investment proposals. There is no difference between what the Tánaiste said and Dáil statements that no legislation is promised in this.

It was suggested that a section of the Ethics in Public Office Bill could be amended. I am in favour of this if it is felt that a section of the Bill- we will have a lengthy, full and comprehensive debate on it-can be amended to include this type of investment procedure which may affect a Member of the Oireachtas, a member of the Government, a public servant at a high level or anyone else covered by the Bill. The Government and I would have no difficulty with this. I took the unusual step of showing the file to the Tánaiste yesterday. His subsequent statement indicates that I presented a full and accurate picture to the Dáil. Neither of the two Deputies here are suggesting I did not do so. There was noting to hide. As far as the Government is concerned, the matter is now closed. Two matters were the subject of comment inside and outside the Dáil and have implications far beyond the boundaries of the case in hand. I accept that the statements to which I will refer were made in the heat of debate and I do not want to imply that they reflect the more considered views of the Members who made them.

It grates when I hear Deputy Gilmore refer to the emigration and citizenship division as the aliens division. As I said already in the Dáil when I started in the Department I hated the name aliens division because it implied something that I did not particularly like. We revamped the division and it is now called the emigration and citizenship division, which is far better.

Both I and my officials, including those working in the emigration and citizenship division, are gravely concerned about the suggestion that they operate a racist policy when dealing with naturalisation applications. That allegation was made in the Dáil yesterday. The officials concerned are not in a position to answer such allegations themselves and it is my duty to nail that lie.

The suggestion made by one Deputy that people of Indian origin are not granted naturalisation on racist grounds is without foundation. Several people of Indian origin have been granted naturalisation as indeed have people of Pakistani origin, another nation against which the Department allegedly discriminates. These people were not granted naturalisation on the basis of investment, at least not in my time in the Department, for the simple reason that there were no qualifying investment proposals from people of Indian or Pakistani origin. It is manifestly ludicrous to suggest that we would refuse naturalisation to an Indian investor while having no difficulty in granting naturalisation on other grounds.

One of my fears when this debate began was that a racist element would creep into it. I had included a reference to the possibility in my original speech to the Dáil but took it out lest its very mention would produce the result I feared. I now feel obliged to assure non-Irish nationals who may be worried about the matter that our naturalisation and citizenship laws are operated fairly and not by reference to racist considerations.

The second lie that needs to be nailed is the suggestion that the file I showed to the Tánaiste yesterday was incomplete or tampered with. I and the officials of the Department of Justice are more conscious than most that it is a criminal offence to tamper with or destroy official documents. The file given to the Tánaiste was the complete file which had been in the Department since these applications were considered.

The file includes all relevant manuscript notes of offcials and every single piece of paper that was attached to the file in the normal way since it was opened. I am sure it is not the first time the Tánaiste read an official departmental file. He is not so lacking in wit as to be unable to judge where a gap exists. Neither am I so stupid as to present to the Tánaiste or anybody else a file with gaps or which had been doctored. If anybody was in a position to produce evidence that this had happened it would spell the end of official and political careers.

In showing the file to the Tánaiste I took what I described as an unusual step. It is usual in my Department and others to operate an absolute rule regarding the privacy rights of individuals. It is simply not the practice to discuss individual applications or disclose details which applicants give in confidence.

In this case however, because of the extraordinary circumstances which had developed and because the family itself was being left open to criticism, I felt justified in showing that file to my colleague in Government, the Tánaiste. Nobody else in Government or outside the Department of Justice has seen the file. It is important that the family concerned know this.

Comment on this

The Minister accepts that extraordinary circumstances led her to release the file to the Tánaiste at his request. "Extraordinary" is a mild description; it is bordering on GUBU at this stage. In light of her acceptance of the extraordinary nature of the case, may I ask the Minister five questions?

Following her investigation of the files, does the Minister believe that the Masris were ever resident in Ireland on a bona fide basis? Does she believe they intend to become Irish residents? Does the Minister think it proper for an investment consultant to arrange a loan to the Taoiseach's family in the hope of establishing Irish citizenship for foreign lenders or that it is ethical or acceptable for her to grant citizenship to foreigners in exchange for a loan to the family business of the Taoiseach without a public declaration?

These questions were not satisfactorily answered today or in the Dáil yesterday. The Minister and the Government are engaging in collective self-delusion if they believe the matter is closed. This committee and the public require answers to several questions. Many of the matters which are the source of allegation may not be illegal at the moment but they certainly will be if the Ethics in Public Office Bill is passed.

The Tánaiste has engaged in optics and posturing. I do not know how he can say the matter is closed after his cursory investigation of the matter when so many questions are unanswered. I ask the Minister to answer specifically the questions I asked.

The final question is really a matter of common sense and one which an ordinary member of the public might ask. Even those who have no knowledge of the legalities or illegalities of this scheme would consider it strange that out of the 20 admitted applications per year under this scheme, one of them involves the private business of the Taoiseach's family. Is it not strange that out of 20 such applications, one is directly related to the firm in which the Taoiseach's family members have a beneficial interest? Those are questions which the ordinary punter in the street would ask and they have not been responded to by the Minister.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): I welcomed this scheme originally. I questioned two things and the Minister did not answer the question I really wanted her to answer. Was the IDA bypassed?

The Minister said she was not obliged to establish the identity of the directors of a company. If citizenship is granted to somebody who gave £1 million to a company, is the Minister's duty to establish if there was any conflict of interest involving a member of Government. It blows the Ethics in Public Office Bill, 1994, out of the water. This is being treated in a casual fashion. It is as if it is no cause for embarrassment that a Minister's family would be involved in getting £1 million where citizenship was granted. Did the application meet the IDA's standards and, if not, why did it go through?

I never questioned anyone's integrity with regard to the file. However, there are official and unofficial documents; there are chats over cups of tea and chats after meetings and negotiations. A variety of things can happen. While the Tánaiste, Deputy Spring may be as sharp as the Skibbereen Eagle, nothing out of order would appear in any file in the Department.

That does not answer how the Taoiseach's family were involved. Nobody seemed to know and it did not seem to matter. We are now fussing over partners in the Oireachtas who have almost nothing to declare and yet are held up to scrutiny. Was it not bordering on insider trading? The public are asking how this could happen in Government? That question should be answered.

Comment on this

I have a number of questions arising from the Minister's response. She stated that the original application, which I understand was made on behalf of the two applicants by the Minister for the Environment, did not identify the company in which the investment was being made. When applications are made under the business investment scheme, is it normal that the company is not identified on the application? It is rather odd that somebody who makes an application on the basis of an investment in job creation——

Comment on this

It should raise questions.

Comment on this

——would not at least identify the company in which the investment is being made.

Since the application was made by the Minister for the Environment, did he know the identity of the company in which the investment was being made? If he did, why did he not identify it to the Department of Justice when the application was made?

The Minister said that following normal investigation, it was established that the company was C & D Foods. Could she explain what that normal investigation specifically involved? Was the IDA consulted on the company and asked for its views on the investment? If the IDA gave views on the investment, what were their views?

I understood from the Minister's statement that the company confirmed this was a substantial job creation investment. How many jobs were created? What was the verification process in that regard? The Minister also stated that the consultancy firm which initially forwarded this application had previously submitted other similar unrelated applications. Will she make available to the committee the list of the applications by that consultancy firm and say how many were granted?

These questions relate to the specific case which was the subject of controversy. On the interdepartmental committee, which has been established, are its terms of reference available to the Minister? She spoke generally about this in terms of examining the criteria but has the interdepartmental committee received formal terms of reference? If the committee has been established, can the Minister state its members and who is represented on it? If it has commenced work, how many meetings has it held? When is it likely to complete its work and when will a report be made? Specifically, will the Minister suspend the business investment scheme pending the report of the interdepartmental committee and whatever action she feels will be necessary arising from that report in view of the concerns recently expressed?

On what the Minister refers to as the racist allegation, I do not know if she was referring to the document that Deputy Rabbitte read into the record.

Comment on this

I was referring to a specific allegation by a prominent member of the Opposition yesterday against me and departmental officials.

Comment on this

To clarify this point, it was not Deputy Rabbitte's intention to reflect on the Minister or the officials. However, since the matter has been raised and the document to which Deputy Rabbitte referred clearly expressed racist views as to who might qualify for citizenship under this scheme, what action does the Minister propose to take in this regard or on the practice whereby some consultancy firms have been flogging the prospect of Irish citizenship to prospective investors around the world? Apparently, they have been doing so on the basis of the type of document to which Deputy Rabbitte referred.

Comment on this

On a point of order the consultant whose racist comments were included in a document read into the record of the House by Deputy Rabbitte should now be named by him so that the Department of Justice will never again entertain submissions from a consultant who would include such terms as part of the procedure to qualify for consideration under the scheme. Perhaps it was a fictitious document.

Comment on this

It is a matter for Deputy Rabbitte to make a statement in the House.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Gilmore will debate the issue. It is a serious matter that a consultant representing this country in a scheme for investment from abroad would tout that type of untrue condition. The Minister adequately clarified the matter. It is now up to Deputy Rabbitte to put the record straight.

Comment on this

I shall convey to Deputy Rabbitte that Deputy Lawlor shares his deep concern about this matter.

Comment on this

We have run over time. We agreed a timetable and the time for Vote 19 has been exceeded. I hope we can draw this to a conclusion. Deputy Callely has indicated his wish to speak and I will then ask the Minister to respond.

Comment on this

It is important to introduce a little balance to the debate. I understand we are discussing a matter which comes under the 1956 Naturalisation Act, which was amended in 1986. It covers a broad spectrum of people who may apply for naturalisation and discretion basically rests with the Minister. I am sure many public representatives have contacted the Department of Justice and the Minister about naturalisation applications.

One application has been politicised and unfortunately, a company associated with the Taoiseach. There are a couple of questions one would like to ask about the debate. A number of people spoke about job creation and asked how many jobs were created. That matter was discussed during the week when it was said that consideration is given to job creation or sustaining present employment numbers. We should have a balanced attitude in considering whether ten or 100 jobs were created or if it was simply a matter of sustaining existing employment in an area of the country that requires every effort to sustain and create jobs.

I am also concerned that people in public life or their spouses or family who might aspire to holding office — as most politicians do — will have to look over their shoulders continuously. In view of the way in which this matter was politicised, are we saying that a person who has an innovative, entrepreneurial approach in building up Irish business should not have it if they intend to enter politics?

I wish to bring balance to this argument. I spoke to a number of small business entrepreneurs in my constituency in the days since this controversy started. The feedback is quite negative towards people who are opportunistic in the face of a situation that is seen to be transparent.

We are discussing the Irish Nationality and Citizenship Act, 1956, which was amended in 1986. I am pleased that the Minister, Deputy Geoghegan-Quinn, had researched the naturalisation issue area and that she had, prior to this controversy, established an interdepartmental committee to look at applications that come before the Minister for Justice. I am also pleased that she will seek the interdepartmental committee's views on such applications. It is important to recognise the fact that she took that course of action prior to this controversy.

Comment on this

The final speaker is Deputy McDowell. I want to dispose of Vote 19 before we adjourn at 1.15 p.m.

Comment on this

If the Minister for Justice was about to issue a passport or certificate of naturalisation in respect of an investment in his or her company, he or she would have to comply with the provisions of the new Ethics in Public Office Bill and declare that interest. That is the proposed procedure in the Bill. The reason, I presume, is that these transactions must be both transparent and demonstrated to be above board and not done quietly and secretly. That is the purpose of the new Bill.

Section 14 of the proposed Bill — which we are not debating today — does not make it necessary for one member of the Government to declare the interest of another member of Government in a decision which is about to be made. That is a major drawback to the Bill. It means that one member of Cabinet can make a decision which he or she is bound to declare when they are dealing with their own affairs but they are not obliged to make any declaration of interest when they are dealing with the affairs of another member of Cabinet.

Regardless of the bitterness and recrimination of the last few days, the Minister will agree that it is most unsatisfactory that a Minister in one Department can make a decision which radically affects the welfare and, perhaps, personal wealth of another member of Cabinet without the public being assured that there is a mechanism in place to deal with that apparent conflict of interest. A child, let alone an inexperienced lawyer, could drive a coach and four through the proposed changes in the law as it stands. I make that point without acrimony or bitterness. It is not politicising the issue to say as much. It is time that this massive defect in the proposed Bill was confronted.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach was the first Taoiseach ever to disclose his interests. What happened Dessie and his partner?

Comment on this

I am not trying to be acrimonious, Chairman. There is no point in heckling.

Comment on this

That is a change.

Comment on this

I am not trying to be acrimonious. I am making a constructive point.

Comment on this

It is about time.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach's bodyguards are here.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): A while ago the Deputy asked us to leave it.

Comment on this

I ask Deputy Callely to refrain from interrupting.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Deputy Callely.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been frothing at the mouth for the last two days.

Comment on this

Minister O'Malley omitted in the Tara Mines issues to make the same declaration.

Comment on this

I am asking for the co-operation of Members. The Minister has dealt at length with this issue and we are discussing Vote 19.

Comment on this

I made one point and I wish to make another. The Taoiseach told Members of the Opposition to address their questions to the company. The financial controller of the company said in a radio interview of which I have the transcript, that he was first approached by somebody offering an investment of this kind in September 1991. Can the Minister indicate whether any further citizenship applications were made in respect of any further investment in that company or any related company? Is that the only application made in respect of that company? The Minister can answer "yes" or "no" and I will accept her answer.

Comment on this

The answer is no. I have checked with my officials. They have seen no further application in respect of investment in that company or a related company.

In relation to the point made by Deputy McDowell, I am sorry he was not here earlier. I told the committee that in relation to the ethics Bill——

Comment on this

He was in the other House.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

Deputy McDowell comes here, leaves after five minutes and three hours later comes back——

Comment on this

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

He was in the Law Library.

Comment on this

I was not.

Comment on this