We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Legislation and Security

Estimates for Public Services, 1994.

Contributions 154–314 of 314. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

(Carlow-Kilkenny): Where was Deputy Fitzgerald?

Comment on this

The bodyguards.

Comment on this

It is on the record how often you go down there.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

It is on the record how often Deputy McDowell goes to the Law Library.

Comment on this

The Deputy was with me before lunch.

Comment on this

That allegation should be withdrawn.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

I am not making an allegation. I am asking a question.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

I have the democratic right to ask questions just as insinuations can be made by Deputy McDowell.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzgerald, please refrain from interrupting the Minister.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

It is typical of the arrogance from that quarter and that is why they are sinking fast.

Comment on this

A reshuffle must be imminent.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzgerald, please refrain from interrupting the Minister. I ask for the co-operation of Members.

Comment on this

They have been frothing at the mouth for the last two days.

Comment on this

Before Deputy McDowell came in, I said that if the Ethics in Public Office Bill, 1994, requires amendment to include those areas the Deputy mentioned, the Cabinet, the Government and the Minister responsible for the Bill will have no difficulty with inserting a relevant provision. Then if one Member of Government is dealing with matters which affect another Cabinet Member, there will be a mechanism in the Bill to cover those circumstances.

The residency requirement was raised by Deputy O'Donnell. Applicants are required to display an intention to reside in the State for a reasonable period of time and they must do this at the time of the application. There is no mechanism whereby we bind someone by contract to spend all of his or her time in this country. We ask for the best indication, in that applicants are required to purchase a residence — all Governments have this requirement. That was done in this case.

A question was asked about a loan to the Taoiseach's family and whether this was right or proper. It would be unfortunate if someone who became involved in Government gave up and management and direct control of a company and then that company was treated less favourably than other private companies with which it is in competition.

One can look at this in another context. If someone involved in a large solicitor's practice became a member of Government he would retire from direct involvement in the practice. That company could apply under the criminal and civil legal aid scheme to represent someone in court and receive payment through the scheme. It would be unfortunate if that firm of solicitors was discriminated against and not allowed to participate in the scheme because a Government member was formerly involved in the company. I do not think anyone is suggesting that should happen. If it were the case, people of that calibre would be slow to accept positions in Government.

In answer to Deputy Gilmore, I made clear the original application from the people concerned was submitted in the normal way. It was sent to the Department of Justice via the Minister for the Environment, Deputy Smith. I made clear that he did not make the application but there is still some confusion on that point. The regular procedure for these applications is that members of Government or of the Dáil hand the application to the Minister for Justice or the Department. Nothing unusual occurred in this case.

I said the name of the company was not known at the time of the original application. That is normal.

Comment on this

The application came in after the investment was made.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Then how could there be any doubt about it?

Comment on this

There is no question on the form asking specifically what company or where the investment is made.

Comment on this

What was left blank?

Comment on this

Nothing was left blank.

Comment on this

Then no question was asked?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

I ask the Minister to say that more slowly for Deputy McDowell. It does not seem to be sinking in.

Comment on this

It is important that everyone knows there is no specific question on the form on that issue. In all these cases the Department follows up the original application and finds out that relevant details. That would include how much money was being invested; the name of the company in which the money was being invested; the number of jobs being created; the background of the family and the various enquiries the Department of Justice would normally make about anyone applying for naturalisation; and any State involvement.

The consultants who made the application on behalf of the company involved told the Department the IDA had supported the project undertaken by C & D Foods Limited. There was no necessity to go to the IDA again because it had been confirmed on the file. The officials in the Department of Justice were satisfied there was State involvement.

I will not give the date because I do not have the file with me and I do not want Deputy McDowell to say I said one day and meant another. That would be totally inadvertent, as he knows. Prior to making an investment in C & D Foods or applying for naturalisation, this family and its associates had met with officials of An Bord Tráchtála to discuss proposals to purchase materials, specifically foodstuffs I understand, in this country. They were here before investing in C & D Foods and before applying to the Department. They were interested in doing business with this country and because it was a trade matter ABT met with them.

To clarify this again, there is no question of the Department of Justice or the Minister granting naturalisation to someone without knowing where and in which company the investment is being made.

Deputy Gilmore asked if the consultancy firm had been involved before. I have confirmed that they had submitted applications on behalf of various people under different Governments. He also asked if I would make available the list of applications made by the firm. That would be a total breach of confidentiality. As I said in the Dáil and elsewhere, the list of those who have been naturalised is published in Iris Oifigiúil as a matter of course. That is a matter of record from the beginning of the scheme’s operation.

Comment on this

They are not differentiated from normal naturalisations.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

One person on the list might be the wife of a surgeon and another case might be investment related but the public would have no hint as to which was which.

Comment on this

No differentiation is made.

Comment on this

Is that not undesirable?

Comment on this

The interdepartmental committee may recommend that when names are published in Iris Oifigiúil in future, there should be a differentiation. I have no difficulty with that; I would welcome it because it would bring the transparency which eveyone wants.

Comment on this

Is it possible to identify now those who were naturalised under this scheme? There was an average of 20 per year.

Comment on this

That is not appropriate to discussion of the Estimate.

Comment on this

It is not possible. What goes into Iris Oifigiúil is that which is prescribed under the Act, which is the name of the person, the address——

Comment on this

Most of the address.

Comment on this

——and whether the person is a minor or an adult. The interdepartmental committee may well recommend that we identify this type of naturalisation. The Department and I have no difficulty with this because it would provide the transparency people are seeking and for which I established the committee.

Comment on this

The racist consultants——

Comment on this

I understand the company said the number of jobs created was 40. I may not have given that information to the House when we discussed this matter. I think that answers all the questions.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): I asked a question twice and would like it answered before a latecomer asks another. Was the IDA consulted?

Comment on this

I answered that a minute ago.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): The Minister mentioned An Bord Tráchtála.

Comment on this

I am sorry if the Deputy did not hear me. I said that in the course of the normal investigation of the file, the question of State involvement is investigated by the Department. The consultancy firm confirmed that the IDA had grant aided the overall project.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): The consultancy application stated that fact, but the Minister said there was no need to check this with the IDA.

Comment on this

No, because it was stated in black and white.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): Are the true facts stated in every application which the Department receives? Does the Department check anything? If someone states in a form that the Government or some group has approved an application, does the Department check it?

Comment on this

This is a detailed procedure. All information must be in order for it to be accepted by the Department of Justice. Any of the Deputy's colleagues who may have been previous Ministers for Justice will tell him there is no better Department in the country for checking and double checking things to ensure they are factually correct and above board.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): Did the IDA sanction this?

Comment on this

The IDA grant aided the overall project for the company.

Comment on this

My question relates to a conflict of interests. Does the Minister agree it is inappropriate for a Member to discuss legislation and to promote amendments on the floor of the House, while acting in a legal capacity for an organisation with vested interest in the legislation?

Comment on this

I will relieve the tension by saying that ignorant question concerns me.

Comment on this

It is far from being ignorant. It is factual and accurate.

Comment on this

I spoke twice in the House and I notified the Minister in advance.

Comment on this

That does not make it right.

Comment on this

On both occasions I was careful to say I had an interest in the matter.

Mr. Lawlor: The Deputy should not make a case on the floor of the House if he has an interest in the matter because he is collecting fees.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

Any member of Dublin Corporation with a conflict of interests absents himself from such matters.

Comment on this

What about Deputy McCreevy?

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Donnell knows this.

Comment on this

Is it in order for Deputy McDowell to collect fees from an organisation and to promote their amendments on the floor of the House? It does not matter if he declared this. It is incorrect for him to do so; it is a conflict of interests.

Comment on this

In fairness to Deputy McDowell, I should say that I spoke to him before he came into the meeting. He made grave allegations against myself — although I am not as concerned about those because I can fight my own corner — and against officials in the immigration and citizenship division of the Department.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

That is disgraceful.

Comment on this

The secretary of the Department of Justice and all the officials are gravely concerned that it should remain on the official Report of Dáil Éireann that the Department of Justice operates a racist policy against people of Indian and Pakistani extraction. I said that Deputy McDowell probably made those statements in the heat of the debate and that if he had been able to consider what he was saying he would not have said them. As far as the secretary of my Department and all the officials are concerned, it is important for Deputy McDowell to have an opportunity to state that this was said in the heat of the moment and that he was not making serious allegations against the officials.

Comment on this

For the benefit of the Minister and her Department officials, I refer them to the Minister for Enterprise and Employment, Deputy Quinn, in relation to this matter.

Comment on this

That is not good enough. Deputy McDowell made a specific——

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

The Minister will not get an apology from Deputy McDowell because he is a small man.

Comment on this

——allegation in relation to racist policies in the Department of Justice. I have the Official Report of Dáil Éireann with me. The Secretary and the officials in the immigration and citizenship division of the Department, some of whom are sitting behind me today, feel, as I do, that they are owed an apology from Deputy McDowell for saying what he did in the heat of the debate.

Comment on this

Deputy McDowell is aware of the Minister's views because they are on the record. I propose to suspend the sitting for one hour. We will resume at 2.25 p.m.

Comment on this

Before business is suspended, the Minister has requested Deputy McDowell to apologise and he is refusing to take this opportunity.

Comment on this

Deputy McDowell knows what was said this morning and it is up to him to respond. He has not responded, therefore I am not entering a debate about it. We will resume at 2.25 p.m.

Comment on this

We will proceed to subheads A.1 to A.8 of Vote 20, Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): Could I refer to the old chestnut of gardaí on the beat? The ushers walking around the Dáil exert a certain amount of control over those who come in. Teachers walking around a playground — both the Minister and I have done this — cause a certain amount of fear. Discipline and good behaviour are important. The absence of the gardaí from the streets is a drawback.

Although civilian secretarial staff is available, why does the system tie up garda time filling in forms? Why are gardaí not free to be on the streets? Gardaí are nearly becoming a tourist attraction at this stage, although one sees them in squad cars. It is not their fault that the system ties up their time in court, where they send a lot of time, particularly if cases are postponed. Could the Minister or the Commissioner come up with a system whereby gardaí could be seen on the streets? Gardaí should be on the streets not as a threat to people, but as a reminder to young people congregating in groups.

The ushers in the Dáil and teachers ensure a certain amount of decorum and it is important to see gardaí on the streets, particularly in small towns in rural areas where some Garda stations have been closed. One may travel through towns from here to a by-election in County Mayo and never see a garda on the street. That is a serious drawback and the system should be changed to allow gardaí to be seen.

Comment on this

I support points made by Deputy Browne. As he acknowledged, I have said time and time again that it is my policy to have more men and women from the Garda Síochána on the beat, walking around and being a visible presence on the street. Deputy Browne was correct when he said the presence of the Garda Síochána is preventative medicine for young people, who might be inclined to get involved in crime. It makes them think twice and prevents them from going down that road. It also brings back the level of respect Deputy Browne and I and people of our generation had, and still have, for gardaí.

Deputy Browne asked why are there not more gardaí available. There are a number of answers to that question and the Deputy answered one himself. A ludicrous situation exists where in any one day at a District Court sitting in this city upwards of 15 gardaí sit outside the courtroom waiting for their case to be called because they do not know whether the case before is going to collapse, be settled or otherwise. That is a major drawback and, indeed, the Garda Commissioner and senior management support me in this regard. I will introduce legislation in the autumn which will deal with the situation so that fewer gardaí will spend time in court and only certain ranks will go to court, in so far as it is possible.

Over the years more gardaí have become involved in administrative and paper work in Garda stations. That happened because we did not have a facility of civilianisation as in other agencies. It was only in recent years that people began to look seriously at the administration area and decided that something should be done about civilianisation. That process has started and we have several hundred civilians doing work which gardaí previously did. We all accept that there will be situations which only a member of the Garda Síochána can deal with. However, it is not necessary that gardaí should do a vast amount of administrative work. We have already gone down the road of civilianisation. Provision has been made for more civilians to do administrative work and release gardaí to go out on the beat where we would like to see them.

I would like gardaí to become involved in community initiatives. Last night I visited a project in north Clondalkin which has received EU funding and substantial funding from my Department. The gardaí, including the superintendent, the inspector and sergeant were also there. There is room for more involvement by members of the Garda Síochána in such initiatives. They are involved in juvenile liaison schemes and sporting organisations in the community, but more specifically they should get involved in initiatives which give young people a challenge other than getting involved in crime. It is important for young people to have something to do to fill in their free time and we have encouraged this.

Deputy Browne mentioned rural garda stations. In 1991 one of the main reasons the Commissioner recommended a change in policy in relation to rural policing was the results of a survey carried out at that time. The survey found that in many of the rural stations where a garda was based for 12 hours each day that person only dealt with one or two callers to the station and maybe one telephone call each day. The Commissioner felt that that garda's time would be better occupied if he or she was available to police the community they served rather than being inside a building all day. That was the basis for the change in rural policing.

It was re-evaluated in 1992 and 1993 and certain other changes were made each time. This will be re-evaluated again at the end of the year and I have no doubt that further changes will be made. When I go around the country to the different divisions, I find that in some it is working well, particularly in Deputy Browne's constituency of Carlow-Kilkenny, but in other areas there have been hiccups. These hiccups often relate to the hours Garda stations are opened to the public, which do not suit the community. The divisional officer and superintendent in each district is responsible for working out the most appropriate hours for the Garda station to be open so that they suit those who need to do business in the station.

Questions were raised in relation to rural policing because of recent events. As I said in the Dáil, all questions in relation to that incident — we will not go into it today — will be answered in the course of any inquiry or investigation with takes place. Some 700 civilians are already in place doing work which 700 gardaí were doing before. Each time we employ a civilian, we release a garda on to the street. I support that.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

On a point of order, has the Chairman received further communication from Deputy Gay Mitchell? Could the Chairman indicate the nature of that communication?

Comment on this

I will deal with that matter shortly.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): I welcome what the Minister has said. Although a garda may receive only one call each day, he may be in a small station like Hackettstown, where a delegation met the Minister. There is a need for Garda stations in small towns and villages. Even if gardaí are not on the street, they control the area around them. Those coming from Dublin in stolen cars are given a free run if there are no gardaí to stop them on the way. Manning levels in large villages or small towns needs to be reassessed.

Comment on this

The Garda Commissioner, but particularly divisional officers—the chief superintendent in any division is responsible for deciding manpower levels in a Garda station — regularly review the number stationed in an area, even without a deputation to me, but particularly after a deputation because I am obliged to pass on comments to the Commissioner. The Commissioner no longer has the power to direct a garda to live in the area where he or she is stationed. I cannot give the exact date that power was given up but it was relinquished by the Commissioner as a result of strong representations from the various representative associations. I am approached on a regular basis by Deputies who say there should be a sergent and two gardaí responsible for their area but they are commuting from 20 or 30 miles away. Unfortunately, that will remain the position because the Commissioner no longer has the power to direct a sergeant, a superintendent, an inspector or anyone else to live in the area in which they are stationed.

In some cases the garda will live in the area and in others the garda will live outside it. We cannot change that now, but I accept that Garda management has to evaluate the number of gardaí based in areas. From time to time in different counties large volumes of people can arrive for festivals or other events and it is important that the divisional officer should have the power to transfer extra members on a temporary basis — three or four days or a week — to police an area where there might be a large volume of people. For example, this could apply to seaside towns during the summer. It is important that the divisional officer should have that power.

Comment on this

In my opening statement I put some questions to the Minster, particularly in relation to the strength of the drugs squad. Will the Minister tell us if it is true that the drugs squad has been reduced by nine people because of transfers or promotions and is in need of rebuttressing to bring the squad up to a desirable level? Will the Minister also respond to my question about the festering dispute in the GRA which reflects on the morale and the welfare of the individual members of the Garda Síochána? I have raised this matter with the Minister with a view to her intervening to agree a suitable mediator in this matter.

I also asked a question in relation the Garda Síochána Complaints Board, as to how many of the complaints against individual members of the Garda were found to be vexatious and without foundation, and what action was taken to vindicate the good name of the gardaí involved. I would also like to raise the issue of the role of the Garda in liaising with health boards in relation to the mandatory reporting of cases of alleged sexual abuse when they come to the attention of the Garda. Is it true that at present there is no obligation on the Garda to report any suspicion to the health board? Will the Minister agree that there is a need for a formalised procedure to be put in place by the Garda to liaise with the health board in such matters?

Comment on this

As the Members are aware I received notice of a motion from Deputy Gay Mitchell in relation to holding a special meeting. There are two clauses in the motion; first, to extend the powers of the committee to send for persons, papers and records etc.; second, to conduct a full inquiry.

In regard to the first, the terms of reference of the committee are those set by the Dáil on the establishment of the committee and it is only the Dáil, by way of formal resolution, that can change the terms of reference. It is, of course, open to the committee to request the Dáil to extend its terms of reference. It is a matter for the committee in the first instance as to whether this course of action should be pursued. In regard to the second clause, the establishment of an inquiry is clearly outside the terms of reference of the committee and is out of order. Accordingly, the motion as worded is out of order as submitted.

Comment on this

Would it be in order to raise this matter by way of substantive motion in the Dáil in Private Members' Time?

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Dáil, not for the committee.

Comment on this

We are only dealing with the matters for the committee. I am just ruling on the motion put here.

Comment on this

We will raise it in the Dáil.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): In fairness to Deputy Mitchell, he asked to raise the matter and the Chairman said that if got a formal application he would consider it. The Chairman has made a decision on the spot as to its being out of order. Apart from this matter, the committee has objected before when it wanted to call a Garda superintendent before it and found that it could not. We have already asked for this review to take place and we must make some effort to give ourselves power to call people before the committee. We should be making a case to the Dáil to give us those powers, irrespective of any current political innuendo. We must have some power. If we reject this we are saying we are happy to be dead ducks with no power.

Comment on this

Is it the terms of the motion that the Chair is rejecting or the motion in its entirety?

Comment on this

The motion as presented is out of order.

Comment on this

In other words, the Chair would accept another motion.

Comment on this

We are all aware of the intent of Deputy Mitchell's motion even if it is not so worded. Is the committee in favour of seeking to extend the committee's terms of reference so that it can consider the matter? I am putting that to the committee. I was accused this morning of not acting correctly but I did act correctly. I gave Deputy Mitchell an opportunity and the motion as presented is not in order. If the committee wishes it can have a special meeting regarding this matter. I put that to the committee.

Comment on this

Bearing in mind that there is a Government majority on this committee, the Chair is effectively using a veto to silence the voice of Opposition Deputies.

Comment on this

I am not using any veto. I have ruled clearly on the matter.

Comment on this

If the Chair rules that Deputy Mitchell's motion is out of order because of its content I accept that. I suggest that the Chairman and Deputy Mitchell get together and agree on the wording of a motion.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

I have a lot of respect and regard for Deputy Harte but he knows as well as I that Deputy Mitchell's motion has more to do with the European election campaign and the hype it might give him over the weekend——

Comment on this

That is his brother.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

——than any serious attempt to address the issues.

Comment on this

Deputy Gay Mitchell is not a European election candidate.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzgerald should address the matter before the committee.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

Mitchell is Mitchell. The issue has been addressed by the Chairman; he has consulted on it and has made a decision based on the best advice available to him. He has given the committee that advice which is that the matter is outside the terms of reference of the committee and the proper forum for it is the Dáil. The matter has been raised there and if there are people who are still concerned they should go back to the proper forum and raise it again.

Comment on this

If the matter is out of order as far as the Chairman is concerned then it is out of order. It is a matter for the Dáil to consider whether to change the mandate under which this committee operates.

Comment on this

The Chairman has not ruled the option out of order. He has ruled the terms of the motion out of order, which suggests that he would accept an alternative motion from Deputy Mitchell.

Comment on this

I concur with the sentiments expressed by Deputy Browne. He and I are the convenors to this committee. I am on record at a previous meeting as supporting Deputy Shatter in relation to proposals he put to the committee. I am a little disappointed that Deputy Harte raised the issue of the veto of Government. We all realise that there has been a need for Dáil reform and this is one of four legislative commitees which are the first step of Dáil reform. We have all appreciated the forthright and open discussions Members of the committees have had with each Minister who has addressed the committees.

We recognise that there are certain restrictions on us because of the terms of reference and the parameters laid down by the Order of the Dáil, but I urge Deputy Harte to recognise the excellent progress these committtees have made, the excellent work that has been done, the need for a review to take place of the first months of operation and the commitment of Government and, in particular, the Government Whip who is at present reviewing the need to extend the powers of this committee.

I wholeheartedly support the ruling that the proposal before the committee is out of order because of its terms of reference. We should get on with the business before us.

Comment on this

The majority of the committee Members are Government supporters. Therefore, they have a veto. The Opposition does not have a say.

Comment on this

That is not the way it works.

Comment on this

These matters should be done by consensus. Chairman, you should consult with Deputy Mitchell and agree on a suitable wording. The matter can then be debated along those lines.

Comment on this

The committee does not have the power to hold inquiries. The Dáil establishes inquiries by formal motion. I can only deal with what is before me. What happens from here on is not an issue. I am not accepting this motion. It is out of order as presented. I now ask the committee to——

Comment on this

That is acceptable, Chairman, provided you do not use the steamroller technique to do it. If you make that decision, we will accept it.

Comment on this

There is no question of steamrolling. This committee was set up to make its Members' views known.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): For the sake of Members in future, could we revive the idea that our terms of reference should be reviewed? I do not know if shooting down that idea means that we are happy with the present situation, but if senior officials from the Army or the Garda cannot be called to come before the committee, we will be hampered in getting information.

Comment on this

There is an annual meeting of the committee where all these aspects are discussed. An agenda can be set out at the appropriate time to deal with these matters. We have made a decision and I ask the Members to accept it.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

If there is to be a major inquiry on this matter, there is another issue I would like to raise.

Comment on this

Sorry, Deputy, but we will not do that.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

If we are to deal with committees of inquiry, I would like to raise the issue of the Gold Card Club in Cork, which is commonly referred to as the Progressive Democrats' golden egg fiasco.

Comment on this

These matters can be dealt with in our annual report where we can discuss, debate and make recommendations as to our terms of reference.

Comment on this

With regard to the questions raised by Deputy O'Donnell, I stress that responsibility for dealing with drug offences is not a specialised function within the Garda. All members can detect and prosecute such offences. Over 200 members of the force have received intensive training in drugs matters and they are distributed around the country.

The existence of special units, such as drug squads and units is in response to the organised nature of certain aspects of trafficking in illegal drugs, such as the networks of importation, distribution and supply that are the trademark of the drugs business. Even in regard to this aspect, the Garda law enforcement response can be described as flexible, with additional resources requisitioned from other special units, such as the divisional crime task forces or the general uniformed forces as required.

There is no single drug squad, but a number of drug squads and units are based throughout the country. The drug squad in Dublin is based in Harcourt Street. There are specialist drug units operating from seven other Garda districts in Dublin where localised problems are known to exist. Outside Dublin, there are drug squads operating in Cork, Limerick, Galway and Waterford. In addition, a Garda national drugs administration office was established in 1990 with responsibility for co-ordination of national drug law enforcement and liaison at national and international level and is based in Garda headquarters.

There are a total of 111 members involved full time in drugs work in those drug squads and units, in addition to the 200 members with specialist drugs training. That represents a sizeable increase in resources in recent years devoted to drugs protection and prosecution of drugs offences. The Garda Commissioner considers that the specialist resources devoted to their problem are adequate at present, but he will keep the matter under close review. The divisional task force on drugs was reduced from 37 to 30 people because the Garda Commissioner felt it was better to concentrate on drug units in the various divisional areas rather than in this central unit. He was especially concerned with Fitzgibbon Street and Santry.

With regard to vexatious complaints about the Garda Síochána and its morale, 178 complaints were deemed inadmissible in 1992 on the grounds of being frivolous or vexatious. In its first triennial report covering the years 1987-89, the Garda Complaints Board considered that matter. It did not recommend an amendment to the Act to introduce penalties in those kinds of cases. It is already an offence knowingly to allege falsely an offence has been committed. The board felt that further criminalisation might deter more genuine complainants. Therefore, it could not recommend an amendment. It also felt that it would be time consuming and difficult to successfully prosecute a vexatious complaint or complainant. It stated in that report that it would address frivolous and vexatious complaints in its triennial report, which is due later this year. I am anxiously waiting to see that report. If the board recommends there should be an amendment to the Act at that stage, I would have the support of all parties in doing this.

The morale of the Garda Síochána is always a matter of concern to me. It should be at the highest possible level. The dispute mentioned by Deputy O'Donnell is an internal matter which has to be resolved by the association. The right of members of the Garda Síochána to form representative associations is contained under section 13 of the Garda Síochána Act, 1924, as substituted by the Garda Síochána Act, 1977. This Act prohibits the formation of more than one association to represent a rank in the Garda to influence pay, pensions and conditions of service of the force. The Garda Representative Association was established under this Act and I have no proposals to amend it. A Supreme Court judgment in 1989 confirmed there could only be one association representing a rank in the Garda in respect of these matters.

I again reiterate that the dispute is an internal matter and the GRA has recently made serious proposals for mediation. We should wait for a reaction of these proposals. It would be premature for me or anyone else to comment at this stage. Therefore, any changes that might be required or suggested by any group of individuals within the association would be a matter for clarification and discussion within it. The association has recently made serious proposals regarding mediation and I expect a response to them. We should await that response before becoming involved.

I have great concerns about the morale of the Garda Síochána, which has recently taken a beating. It seemed to begin with the unfortunate incidents at the association's conference earlier this year. The association should be allowed to enter into whatever negotiations necessary to resolve the matter so the confidence of the public in the Garda can be restored.

Comment on this

There is a need for greater co-operation between the Garda and the health boards on the matter of sexual abuse. A number of incidents have been recently reported, but most people agree that it is a serious problem whose frequency across the country has not been fully estimated or comprehended. The matter must be seriously examined. The two bodies can compliment each other but there still should be greater cooperation between them.

The Minister referred to the morale of the Garda. I am worried at the ambivalent attitude people seem to have towards the force. I was recently mistaken for a member of the Garda. I normally wear my hair short and drive a blue car that is not dissimilar to an unmarked Garda car and I happened to be wearing a blue shirt.

Comment on this

I happened to be in the company of a couple of men attending a wedding. They had taken a couple of jars and the abuse and insults I had to take from them gave me an insight into how some gardaí are treated. In order to stem this kind of behaviour it is important that there be greater liaison between the gardaí and the schools. It is at that level that the gardaí should be involved with young people. There must be respect for the gardaí and if that breaks down there will be serious trouble. Perhaps a pilot scheme could be established whereby a liaison officer would meet with students on a fairly regular basis. In order to boost morale in the Garda Síochána and restore public confidence in the force, it is important that action of this kind be taken.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): I note that when the Deputy speaks of boosting the morale of the gardaí, their entertainment budget was reduced from £26,000 to £6,000. What scrooge mentality decided that £6,000 would entertain anybody, even for one good night?

Comment on this

The idea of community gardaí and gardaí working more closely with people in the community is a point that has been raised many times. The public wish to see more gardaí on the beat, to recognise their own local gardai and to know somebody when they have to contact them or pay a visit to their local Garda station. An extension of this issue is that gardaí visit schools and get closer to young people so that as they grow older young people will respect gardaí and give them greater co-operation. In certain areas of my constituency gardaí work closely with young people, but I am not sure if this is widespread throughout the country, or if gardaí visit schools.

Comment on this
Liam Fitzgerald Mr. L. Fitzgerald Fianna Fáil

Having been involved with the inner city for approximately 12 years, I recall the first time a member of the Garda síochána visited my sixth class students. They were shocked. The garda arrived in uniform and had his baton and other tools of the trade with him. He had alerted me, as the teacher, and the school principal of his impending visit and we wanted to test the reaction of the class. I will not recall some of the comments from the back of the class. I will leave them to the imagination of Members of the committee.

In the course of time that community garda, or juvenile liaison officer, became well known to the pupils of the school where I taught and built up a great rapport with them. The garda went on to other duties. I would not describe them as more important because I cannot think of any that would be more important, but in fairness to him, and to others who succeeded him, a great respect for the Garda was inculcated. Doubtless people will cynically ask why, if this was so, there are so many crime problems in the inner city. But for that scheme we would have lost many more young students.

There is great work being undertaken by members of the Garda Síochána in the juvenile liaison officer scheme in Coolock in my own constituency. They have become involved in all kinds of community activities, in youth clubs and in the schools. It must be emphasised again and again that unless we can inculcate a respect of law and order at the earliest possible age, and in this respect I have consulted with the Minister on her forthcoming legislation on juvenile justice, and combine this with co-operation between parents, the Garda Síochána and young people, our cause is lost. In such an event, we can fire millions and billions of pounds into the system and we will continue to loose.

I urged the Minister to undertake all in her power to broaden and extend the powers of the juvenile liaison officer scheme and to make the availability of the scheme for schools at primary and second level, even greater than at present.

Comment on this

Regarding the community based crime prevention schemes. I am aware of one in north Clondalkin in my own constituency, which the Minister visited yesterday. This scheme has been in operation for almost 12 months on a pilot basis. The lessons which have been learned can be expanded throughout all the urban areas and through the country. It is money well spent.

Whereas initially there was some objection from the Garda Síochána, this is not the case at present. Those who have been specially selected for this work, and who have an aptitude for it, are enthusiastically involved in it in the area I have mentioned, and I am advised that this is the case everywhere. If a proper selection is undertaken, there is the personnel available within the Garda Síochána to effectively undertake the job of youth and community leadership.

The success of the development in the area I am familiar with in north Clondalkin is such that it should encourage the Minister and the Garda to approach this task in a far bigger way, and to consider it as a key crime prevention measure. Apart from the crime prevention aspect, which is a narrow focus, what is needed in many of these areas is community leadership.

Unfortunately this leadership is not being provided for many reasons, such as marital breakdown, social situations and so on. There are enough intelligent people and human resources within the Garda Síochána to undertake this job effectively and to have the necessary authority to see it through. In this respect, what has been achieved already in the way of pilot studies can be developed to an enormous extent. There is a great future in the area of crime prevention. It is constructive, positive and so much better than flinging Garda personnel at the problem willy nilly.

I am aware that serious detection work most be undertaken. However, hiring and paying more gardaí and putting them through orthodox channels can waste much money, whereas there is great scope in the development of the area involving selective application of good gardaí with the aptitude for this kind of community work, diverting them into it and giving them the necessary backing.

Regarding subhead A.7, I note that provision in respect of consultancy services for the Garda Síochána has jumped from £140,000 to £850,000. Will the Minister provide details on this? Modern administration tends to take the easy way out of problems by opting for consultants rather than undertake the job itself. The Civil Service and the Garda personnel are excellent in themselves. The hiring of consultants for the purpose of undertaking a cosmetic job is often a substitute for real work and investigation that can be undertaken within the resources and personnel available. In many cases expenditure on consultancy work is wasted. It is an effort to avoid real responsibility or merely a cosmetic exercise.

Comment on this

I wish to put on record once again my admiration and respect for the great work undertaken by the Garda Síochána in each and every community in which it serves, and for the courageous action undertaken by it on certain occasions. Regarding those involved in the community liaison officer and neighbourhood watch schemes, I endorse Deputy Lenihan's comments on those gardaí who have the attributes to work on such schemes. Deputy Power referred to an incident in the Kildare area. Like me, Deputy Lenihan represents a Dublin constituency. Communities have benefited enormously from the excellent work of community liaison officers and officers working with neighbourhood watch schemes. I ask the Minister to continue to support the development of these schemes.

I am pleased there is a 98 per cent increase in subhead E, which deals with communications and other equipment. This subhead provides £1.5 million for capital communications equipment. Will the Minister give details?

Subhead A.1 includes provision for traffic wardens. Does the Minister propose to increase the number of traffic wardens in the city area? If so, would it be self-financing? Have the cost effectiveness of traffic wardens and the need for additional wardens to cover extended areas of the city at peak travel hours been considered?

The Minister received a number of submissions from the Garda Representative Association regarding a limited number of retired officers, who are not satisfied with their pensions. There is the matter of rent allowance, which would normally be considered and a directive was introduced in relation to a limited number of pensioners. Has there been any progress on this matter and has it been costed?

Comment on this

I am sorry that, inadvertently, I did not respond to the point raised by Deputy O'Donnell on child sexual abuse. The woman and child unit has been set up in Harcourt Square for some time. I availed of the opportunity of International Women's Day to invite my women colleagues in the Dáil and Seanad to inspect the premises, see the work being done and talk to the officers who have responsibility for the unit. I should perhaps have also invited the male Members of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): I was waiting to be invited.

Comment on this

I can correct that omission. I agree there is a need to tighten up procedures. The Kilkenny report made certain recommendations on this issue. I wish to correct a statement in an editorial in a leading national newspaper on 19 May that I broke a promise I made on guidelines to the Garda on domestic violence intervention. Whoever wrote this editorial was misinformed because the guidelines were available at that stage. They had been issued to the Garda and give specific guidelines to all members on how they should respond to incidents of comestic violence. This is important. The Garda has put its own house in order. Deputy O'Donnell and others are looking for formal links between health boards and the Garda. I have been having discussions with the Minister for Health and my officials have been doing likewise with their opposite numbers in the Department of Health with a view to establishing more formal procedures. I have reason to believe this type of procedure will be put in place. Everyone, including the Minister for Health, believes this should be done.

Deputy Lenihan asked about consultancy services. These relate directly to the full implementation of the Garda information technology plan. The Garda do not have the expertise to enable it to put this in place and therefore, it must have the facility of consultants with direct expertise.

The schools project was mentioned by a number of Deputies. This was set up in January 1990 in two schools in Tallaght and extended to 12 schools in Coolock, two in Portmarnock and two in the Southhill area of Limerick. There is no doubt that this project has enormous potential to influence young people and encourage them to have respect for law and order and those who enforce it. The project was subsequently extended to all schools in Dublin, Limerick, east Cork, west Galway, Laois-Offaly, Carlow-Kildare, Wicklow, Wexford, Longford-Westmeath, Waterford-Kilkenny, Louth-Meath and Cavan-Monaghan Garda divisions and there are plans to extend it to the small number of other divisions which do not have it.

In addition a video was produced, called "Be Safe Kids", to complement the programme. Its objective is to highlight the importance of responsible behaviour and to develop positive attitudes to road safety. The gardai involved in the programme undergo a two day training course and over 600 gardai have done this course already. Over 1,700 schools are involved in the project. The scheme is popular and worth while and gives a positive message to young people who might be inclined to become involved in crime. It encourages respect for gardaí. They visit classrooms and meet children. There is no need, therefore, for children to be afraid of them or have a lack of respect for them.

The provision for entertainment is primarily for entertainment at presentations of the Scott medal, passing out parades at Templemore and so on. I assure the Deputy there is no question of reducing the type of expenditure to which he seemed to refer.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): It was £26,000 last year and £6,000 this year, which is very little.

Comment on this

This is a notional figure.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): I hope so.

Comment on this

One can never say at the beginning of a year how much entertainment will be required or how much money will be needed for those specific days.

Deputy Callely made a point about the increase for communications and other equipment. The increase for capital communications equipment is required for the purchase of necessary replacement equipment and for upgrading the Cork radio system. The provision for non-capital communications equipment is the same as the 1993 allocation. This covers the cost of purchasing equipment, arms and ammunition for the force. The increased funding which was obtained under the law and order package provides for the installation of closed circuit television cameras in Dublin and the provision of fixed traffic cameras.

There are 57 full-time — and 123 part-time — traffic wardens. Some 50 of the part-time ones were recruited from a competition held in July 1992.

Comment on this

Would it be self-financing to increase the numbers of wardens to deal with areas of the city which have been identified as having peak traffic problems?

Comment on this

This is being looked at very carefully in the Department. I could not give an answer off the top of my head. Some might think it would be self-financing, others might think it would not. It would be helpful to us if it were.

Comment on this

I asked about a matter which is a bone of contention between the Department and the Garda Representative Association.

Comment on this

This was in relation to pensions. We have come through a series of conciliation meetings in relation to pensionability of allowances and unsocial hours earnings. Retired members are anxious about a number of matters. It is open to them to continue discussions on these and to be represented by the representative associations. When an issue is decided, it does not mean that all other issues in relation to it are dead and gone. The conciliation continues and if other items come up they can also be put into conciliation and discussed between the Department and associations. That will continue to be the case.

An interesting figure with regard to traffic wardens is that their pay was £1.7 million last year and the fines collected amounted to £3.9 million.

Comment on this

Will the Minister recruit more traffic wardens?

Comment on this

There should be a self-financing element. We can all understand and see the benefit of having more traffic wardens in the city, particularly at peak travel times. Much time is taken up with paid parking fines, in court and so on. I have asked before at this committee if it would be possible for the Minister to consider that if a person does not pay their fine within a 21 day period, a certain percentage is added to cover administration. With the aid of computers, it could be logged against the registration number of that vehicle and the person could only renew their vehicle tax if the fine was paid.

This would eliminate a number of costs in relation to court appearances and so on. It would also eliminate abuses where people do not register vehicles in their own name or address to avoid paying fines. Most vehicles are now registered on quarterly, half yearly or yearly basis. There would also be a greater number of fines collected.

Comment on this

The Deputy made written and oral representations to me in this regard and the matter is being examined in the Department on the basis that I felt that it was a good idea as did officials in the Department. Obviously, we could not go down that road without examining it in great detail. When the result of that examination is available we will publish it.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear that, I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): Will it be called the Callely plan?

Comment on this

The Minister said that 178 of the complaints made against individual gardai to the Garda Complaints Bureau in 1992 were vexatious. What percentage was that of the total number of complaints?

Comment on this

The number of complaints received up to the end of 1992 was 4,923.

Comment on this

Was that for one year or was it the total accumulated?

Comment on this

These figures were given in the triennial report. I will go through the figures to show the percentages. The number not admissible was 2,326; 1,150 were withdrawn; 186 were informally resolved; 829 were cases of no offence or breach of discipline. Ninety-six cases of minor breach were referred to the commissioner, 69 were referred to the tribunal and 267 carried forward to 1993.

Comment on this

Therefore, a very small number end up being of substance.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

There are grounds on the basis of those figures for a possible amendment of the Act to allow for some vindication of the gardai. It is perhaps becoming a matter of routine that these vexatious complaints are made, causing upset to the individual garda concerned and a collective lowering of morale.

Comment on this

As I said, the board said in its first triennial report that it would look at that in its next report due this year. If, as we expect, it recommends an amendment to the Act to take care of that I will put it in place.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): Would the 2,000 which were not admissible also be vexatious? Could the real figure not be much higher?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donnell's point is that a huge number are vexatious which is, in a way, agreeing with the Deputy that only a small number of complaints end up being of substance.

Comment on this

We will move on to Vote 21 on prisons. Are there any questions?

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): Is it a sign of positive advance that on subhead A.3, the escort and conveyance of prisoners, the figure drops from £711,000 this year to a projected £500,000 next year— a drop of £250,000 — or is it a change in the system?

Comment on this

I welcome the prison policy document which the Minister hopes to publish in the next few weeks. I hope it will be a very comprehensive document and will look at the operation of the prison system from top to bottom because that is very important. It is very welcome at present because of the concerns regarding people taking drugs in prison. Would it be possible for this committee, and perhaps outside people, to make comments and recommendations when that report comes out? There has been a number of letters to the newspapers by people who seem to have a considerable knowledge of the prison system.

I welcome the intensive supervision scheme which, I gather, is having a 75 per cent success rate which is very important. In a recent documentary on one of the English television channels, a prison officer who had been in the prison system for 40 years pointed out, in defence of the prison system, that one of the problems as he saw it was that, constantly, the same people from the same strata of society repeatedly come back to prison. The intensive supervision scheme which has a 75 per cent success rate is very significant, important and welcome.

Comment on this

I congratulate the Minister on drafting the prison policy document. She recognised, early in her portfolio, that prisons needed a total review, particularly when we are spending in excess of £108 million. I have asked a number of parliamentary questions in the Dáil in relation to the number of recurring prisoners coming in and out of the same cells for similar offences on an ongoing basis and the benefit of rehabilitation programmes within the prison system. There is a great scope with the spending of such sums of money to improve the efficacy of the system and to reduce the number of people coming back to prison rather than this pattern of being in and out of prison for six months at a time. There is great scope for rehabilitation.

Other Members and I, took the opportunity to visit one of the female prisons recently and we were perturbed by the Governor's remarks about the number of drugs available to prisoners within the prison walls. He had a certain knowledge of how the drugs were coming in. He also indicated his concern about trying to address the problem of stopping prisoners obtaining drugs as they currently do.

He explained that in a female prison the transfer of drugs normally takes place when the prisoner meets her relations in the visiting room. A relation may bring a child to visit its mother and drugs are then transferred during the natural embrace of mother and child. He said it would be difficult to impose a regime to prevent this kind of transfer. It is necessary to recognise the difficulties and attempt to put a mechanism in place which will address this problem.

The public view is that if prisoners abuse a regulation relating to visiting rights, they should be made aware that this right will be withdrawn. An alternative would be that if there is an exchange of drugs during embraces which abuses the openness of the present system, a glass screen should be put in place to separate prisoners from their relations. What progress has been made by the Minister? Will this be dealt with in her prison policy document?

Comment on this

In light of the daily inactivity of the majority of the prison population, why are there are no incentives for inmates to participate in productive activities such as education or carpentry? What activities are offered to prisoners? I ask the Minister to respond to the reports of the visiting committees and I requested a copy of such reports on various institutions. Will anything come of these recommendations which, in some cases, would not cost any money?

I recall one particularly sensible recommendation, that prisoners should be registered with the Labour Exchange two weeks before they leave prison. When they leave prison they would immediately be in receipt of some benefit. Releasing a prisoner on Friday with £20 in his pocket will result in him being in trouble by Monday. A simple recommendation was that releases should be on a Monday with the proviso that prisoners will be in receipt of social welfare prior to their return to the community so they will not face a directionless future with no money.

I welcome the increase for the probation services. The union representing the probation service recently indicated that the service would collapse if it did not receive more funding. It costs £600 a week to keep each prisoner. Are we really getting value for money? Prisoners are wandering around with no activity, no incentive to work and no obligation to participate. This aimless inactivity is contributing to the increase in drugs activity in the prisons.

Prisons should be a place of discipline and detoxification since such a high percentage of our prison population are drug addicts. Some 75 per cent of the women in Mountjoy are intravenous drug users. The introduction of detoxification programmes and a disciplined regime is necessary. I agree with previous speakers that some element of discipline must be introduced in the areas of detoxification and visiting rights.

I asked the Minister if there had been an analytical and objective costing to compare the cost of building a new prison on a green field site at Wheatfield and the difficulties and high cost of renovating the building in Castlerea to make it suitable for use as a prison. What criteria were used and was there any objective costing?

I agree with previous speakers that there should be an audit of our prison population. I recommended this before and it has also been recommended by other people who examined the system. I agree that this committee should be involved in submissions on the reform of our prison system. We cannot wait any longer because it is and has been an abject failure. The £108 million spent on the prison system does not represent good value for money.

Comment on this

Deputy Browne asked about the escort and conveyance of prisoners. The 1994 allocation is £500,000, an increase on that given initially in 1993. The allocation at the beginning of any year can only be an estimate because we are not sure how many prisoners will have to be conveyed between prisons and from prisons to court. The figure may be higher at the end of the year and if it is, the money will be made available.

The prison review was mentioned by a number of Deputies. This is the first time that such a review has been undertaken. It will be over a five year period which I consider a normal timeframe for such a project. It will examine positive sentence management and alternatives to custody. It will draw on the Whitaker report and elements of that report which have yet to be put in place. It will also examine a variety of other issues, including the drugs problem, about which I and Members have expressed concern for some time.

With regard to Deputy O'Donnell's point, I would welcome an opportunity for this committee to debate the report after it is published. Members would have an opportunity to make suggestions about the recommendations in the report and how they may be strengthened or amended. It would be a useful discussion for this committee.

I will, as Deputy Ryan asked, give the report widespread circulation. I expect that people involved in the prison service, the social services and members of the general public will have points to make about the report. I would welcome as wide a discussion as possible because it will be the first time that the workings of the prison system, warts and all, will be made public by a Minister. We will need comment from members of the public.

Many Members mentioned the drug problem in prisons. I have made the point many times that we can have a drug free prison system if we implement a policy in prisons which I do not think would be acceptable to Irish people. This would involve strip searching prisoners in advance of visits, strip searching every visitor, including babies, and strip searching all prisoners again immediately after visits.

There is electronic surveillance during visiting times, particularly in Mountjoy. If prison staff see somebody transferring drugs, that person is immediately taken away and visiting rights reduced considerably. They can no longer have free association with their visitors and must meet them from behind a glass partition. There are severe reprimands in place. However, short of introducing the type of draconian measures that would keep our prisons totally drug free, there are some things that perhaps we should do and I will address this issue in the policy document.

In advance of the publication of the policy document, officials from the prisons division in my Department visited a number of custodial institutions abroad which operate a system called "drugs free wings". Prisoners who are or become involved in drug abuse are offered incentives to undergo a narcotics anonymous or similar programme and are supported by the prison and medical staff in doing so. The various incentives include certain remission of prison sentence. It is important for people to know that is available if they are prepared to get involved in a drugs free wing and to be located in that part of the prison. We do not have a closed mind in relation to what could be done and how the situation could be improved.

In relation to prisoners' inactivity, perhaps it would be useful to do what Deputy O'Donnell suggested by stating what is available in the prison education units. For example, there are basic matters such as reading and writing, english, history and geography. Technical drawing, technology, engineering studies, woodcraft, metalcraft, health education, environmental studies, physical education, yoga, aerobics, home economics, social education, catering studies, social sciences, particularly economics and sociology, art, pottery signwriting, video production, photography, music, drama, debating and creative writing are also available.

Comment on this

What is the incentive to study?

Comment on this

The difficulty is that we cannot make it mandatory for prisoners to participate in these courses. All we can do is encourage them to take part. There are also serious difficulties with space in Mountjoy. There is a huge number of prisoners there but they lack the up-to-date facilities which we wish to provide. The construction of a new prison will ease the pressures and make it easier to provide the type of facilities in Mountjoy that are available elsewhere.

The participation level in Arbour Hill prison is 92 per cent, 56 per cent in Cork, 57 per cent in Shelton Abbey and 80 per cent in Fort Mitchel. The level is 65 per cent in both Loughan House and Limerick, while it is 100 per cent in Shanganagh and 57 per cent in Wheatfield. However, in Mountjoy, the male prisoner participation rate is only 26 per cent, while the female participation rate is 75 per cent. The rate for Mountjoy male prison is less than half that in most other prisons. This is due to the very limited facilities that are available relative to the prison population. As the figure is so low, it sometimes puts all the other figures out of kilter.

The only way to deal with this problem is to make the two new prisons available as quickly as possible to relieve the congestion in Mountjoy and to examine, as will be done in the prison document, the type of incentives that could be offered to prisoners if they got involved in positive development courses. I agree with Deputy O'Donnell, as I am sure most people agree, that we should not have a situation where prisoners are idle and not encouraged to participate in the various subjects available to them.

There is provision in the package for the employment of 50 extra staff in the probation and welfare service. I also have the permission of the Department of Finance to fill the 20 vacancies in the probation and welfare service. This is an important element of support to the service, which, in common with many other services, is under pressure from time to time.

In relation to the cost of the prison, it was suggested that the perception is that a decision in relation to anywhere other than Dublin would in some way be construed as political. That is untrue and I do not think anybody is seriously suggesting it. The Department had to examine the cost of any new prison and give the taxpayer, who is paying for the facility, value for money. We also had to look at the socio-economic aspects of the costing and take into consideration the determined programme by this and the previous Government of the decentralisation of State services. All those matters were taken into account.

There is no suggestion and nothing to suggest that the facility in Castlerea, which involves the refurbishment of an existing building, and the construction of a new purpose built facility will be more expensive than anything that might be done in the capital city, including a green field site attached to Wheatfield. At this stage we should not approach it from the point of view of cost because it would in effect signal to potential construction companies that the Department is prepared to pay a certain amount of money and that, if they tendered at that level, they would be successful. We have to proceed by way of tender and consider the lowest possible. We will get very good value for money for the facility that will be provided in Castlerea. Ultimately, we will discover how much it cost. However, the initial indications, when the possibility of providing the facility was considered, showed no appreciable difference in the costs of building it either in the capital city or in another location.

Many specific questions were raised in relation to the prisons. I will welcome a wide-ranging and comprehensive debate on the document when it is published next month. Members of this committee will have a valid contribution to make and professional and non-professional members of the public, who are interested in the prison system, will also have an important contribution to make. We want to prepare our prison system for the next century and do all the things we would like to do.

Comment on this

There are three remaining Votes, courts, land registry and registry of deeds and charitable donations and bequests.

Comment on this

In relation to courthouses, I note an increase of 218 per cent, to £6.291 million. Will the Minister explain the increase? I welcome it if it is for the improvement of courthouse buildings, given the poor condition of many. I have not been in many courthouses but those I have seen are in a deplorable state and this money should be used to improve them.

There are huge backlogs in the District, Circuit and High Courts. I ask the Minister to examine this matter and to consider appointing extra judges. There is much financial pressure on the Minister but extra judges are needed in certain areas to try to reduce the backlog.

Comment on this

The efficiency of the courts is an important, central factor in people's perception of the administration of justice. The courts spend too much time dealing with cases. There is an excessive delay in cases coming to hearing and too many adjournments. The problem of the courts being clogged with litigation and preliminary work is bringing them into disrepute. The Law Reform Commission recommended the suggestion regarding settling pre-trial issues. Before a case is heard, many issues can be settled by solicitors sitting around informally and agreeing, for example, medical and engineering evidence in civil cases, privately in committee before a registrar or before a court clerk. In criminal cases, there may be technical aspects on which the prosecution and defence can agree. The trial then proceeds before a judge with just a limited number of issues to be decided. This is what is meant by settling pre-trial issues and would involve an official of the court dealing with these in an informal manner. It would enormously reduce the length of time it takes to hear cases.

In relation to increasing the number of judges, one practical step, which would eliminate a tier of the court system as it stands, would be to make all the Circuit Court judges High Court judges which would eliminate the artificial distinction between them at present. The steps would then be District Court to High Court to the Supreme Court. There is also a strong case for having seven rather than five Supreme Court judges as permitted by the Constitution. The Supreme Court of seven judges could be divided into two courts of three judges and those courts could decide all appeals, except in constitutional cases. The full Supreme Court would meet to decide constitutional cases but all other appeals could be dealt with by the two divisions of the Supreme Court.

I was critical earlier of consultants. However, an efficiency group — if it may be called that — should be appointed to examine the basic structure of our courts. The group should look at how hearings could be shortened, how cases for hearing could be expedited and how judges could perform their work more efficiently and effectively to create a proper public perception of the courts and how they work.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): My question relates to physical surroundings in the courts. Some time ago I raised a matter on the Adjournment regarding the provision of a lift in Carlow courthouse. I understand that such a lift has been sanctioned. Is it included under the £4 million expenditure?

Comment on this

Provision of a lift has been sanctioned. However, it will be part of phase 2 so it will not be installed this year. As the Deputy is aware, certain matters relating to the caretaker must be resolved. When they are, the lift will be part of phase 2 of the development.

Deputy Ryan mentioned the huge increase in funding for courthouses which we received this year. The funding is related primarily to capital works and the provision of seven major courthouse refurbishment projects. The projects in Galway and Cork are already under way and the others will be carried out in Carrick-on-Shannon, Donegal, Clonmel and Longford. Provision has also been made for a number of small projects, for planning of further major projects and works directly resulting from this under health and safety regulations.

There is provision under the maintenance programme for the maintenance costs of the Dublin courts-which are estimated by the Office of Public Works -miscellaneous premises expenses in Dublin and the cost of renting accommodation for the courts' use in a number of provincial centres. There is also provision, for the first time, of a sum for maintenance and repair work in provincial court venues. Deputy Ryan is right in assuming that the huge increase in funding is provided to address the problem of very poor courthouse accommodation throughout the country through major refurbishment works and, in some cases, the construction of new courthouses.

The Department has prepared two Bills to deal with all the issues raised today. They are the miscellaneous provisions Bill and the courts and court officers Bill. While I would have liked to publish them before the summer, they must take their place in the queue for the attention of the parliamentary draftsman. We have been pushing very strongly for both Bills because changes must be made in how the courts do their business. Deputies have been pressing for such changes and I share their concerns. I hope this committee, the Dáil and the Seanad will have a busy time discussing the Bills in the autumn.

A call was made for the appointment of extra judges. We propose to appoint three extra judges-one to the District Court, one to the Circuit Court and one to the High Court. However, I am not satisfied that the extra appointments are sufficient. I am considering proposals to the Department for the presidents of the various courts concerning their requirements, the huge backlog in a number of courts and the increasing pressure of work in the family law area. I will put proposals to deal with those competing demands to the Government. Nobody would expect me to make those proposals and recommendations public in advance of putting them to the Government.

The retirement age of judges is another issue which will be dealt with by the Bills. A large number of representations regarding this issue have been made. The usual age of retirement- 65 years - for all public servants does not apply to our judges who can be given extensions to the age of 70 years. I have made it known that I am unhappy with that situation but it can only be changed by an amendment to the legislation. The amendment will be included in one of the Bills in the autumn and it will make the retirement age for judges the same as in the rest of the public service. All of us will welcome that change.

Comment on this

I am happy with the Minister's response. I wished to raise the issue of speeding up the justice system because delays have an impact on people who are on remand. That has a knock-on effect on the prison system. I am glad the Minister is introducing those long awaited changes.

I understand the Minister received a joint submission from the Bar Council and the Law Society which made heartfelt pleas for help and I am glad she is responding to them. The Minister will have to appoint younger judges if they will be obliged to retire at 65.

Comment on this

That concludes the committee's consideration of the Estimates for the Department of Justice. I thank the Minister, the Opposition spokespersons and other Members of the committee who participated.

Comment on this

The chairman has been fair in chairing what could have been a quite disorderly meeting. I also thank the Minister for being, as usual, open in her responses.

Comment on this

(Carlow-Kilkenny): I also thank the Chairman and the Minister.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy O'Donnell and Deputy Browne who spoke on behalf of their parties. I also thank the other members of the committee for their constructive approach. Deputy O'Donnell is correct, it could have been a difficult meeting for all of us and you, Chairman, handled it in your usual fair and open manner. I thank the officials from the Department of Justice who helped me to respond to the Members' questions.

The Select Committee adjourned at 3.57 p.m. until 11 a.m. on Wednesday 15 June 1994.

Comment on this