We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ENTERPRISE AND TRANSPORT

Aviation Regulation Bill, 2000 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–248 of 1,252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.

Bill Aviation Regulation Bill 2000
Enacted

No. 24 of 2000 ›

I welcome the Minister and her officials. We are here to consider the Aviation Regulation Bill, 2000 [Seanad]. We have agreed to wait until 1 o’clock before reviewing progress.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Minister for Public Enterprise (Mrs. O’Rourke) Fianna Fáil

I thought we had arranged to have two sessions.

Comment on this

We have arranged two sessions, but we want to review progress. We will take a sos between 1 p.m. and 2 p.m. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

The minutes of the meeting of 7 September——

Comment on this

I know the point the Deputy is going to raise, but that must be done at a meeting of the joint committee.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 1 is in the name of the Minister and amendments Nos. 26 and 43 are consequential. Amendments Nos. 1, 26 and 43 may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Minister for Public Enterprise (Mrs. O’Rourke) Fianna Fáil

Has everybody received the groupings of amendments?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 5, subsection (1), between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following definition:

" 'airport authority' has the meaning assigned to it by the Act of 1998;".

These three amendments were given to us by the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel to the Government. Amendment No. 26 is as follows: "In page 12, subsection (7), lines 4 and 5, to delete "(within the meaning of the Act of 1998)". Amendment No. 43 states: "In page 18, lines 16 to 18, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following. . . "

Comment on this

Amendment No. 2 is in the name of Deputy Jim Higgins. Amendment No. 3 is an alternative and amendments Nos. 2 and 3 may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 5, subsection (1), between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following definition:

" 'airport user' means any person responsible for the carriage of passengers, mail or freight to or from an airport;".

The original draft of the Bill contained a definition of "airport user" and I want the Minister to explain why that has been deleted. The Bill includes definitions of airport, commission, commissioner, etc. It seems logical that there should be an agreed definition of what constitutes an airport user.

Comment on this

There is a need, because of the difference of opinion as to what an airport user might be, for it to be defined. The original Bill included a definition and the definitions suggested by myself and Deputy Higgins are fairly similar, and are also similar to what was contained in the original Bill, although they are somewhat more expansive. It would be worthwhile to include such a definition. It isnot a controversial issue but it would clarify matters.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Deputy Higgins is correct in saying a definition was included in the first draft of the Bill. We had a lively debate on the matter in the Seanad - I think it might have involved Senator Taylor-Quinn, although I am not saying the Deputy should be restricted because of that. He is his own person and is entitled to table an amendment. We changed the Bill as a result of that good debate in the Seanad.

The amendment tabled by Deputy Higgins states that "airport user means any person responsible for the carriage of passengers, mail or freight to or from an airport." If that were to be taken literally, it would include buses, taxis, cabs, etc. which carry people and which have nothing to do with the regulator. Deputy Stagg's amendment states that an "airport user" includes "a person who attends the airport." The definitions are entirely different as I read them. The first means any person who is a carrier to or from the airport, which includes buses, trains - if such a service is provided - cabs and taxis, while Deputy Stagg's amendment talks about a person in the airport for a purpose or a person dependent on the airport for any commercial or non-commercial purpose. I know the amendments have been grouped together, but they are entirely different. Perhaps the Deputies would like to tease them out a bit.

Comment on this

I would prefer if the Minister accepted the necessity to clarify the matter. "Airport user" as a term is used regularly and a definition is necessary so that people know exactly what it means. I am happy to leave the definition up to the Minister and her advisers in the Department. However, it is necessary to have a defini-tion because Deputy Higgins and I interpreted the term quite differently.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Was Deputy Higgins referring to taxis, cabs and buses?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Essentially, I took the definition contained in the original draft of the Bill, that defined "airport user" as any person responsible for the carriage of passengers, mail or freight to or from an airport. I acknowledge that airports users are viewed essentially in terms of airlines rather than taxis, buses etc.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We included the words "by air" in the original draft.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I would be happy to accept Deputy Stagg's definition but I agree that the words "airport user" should be defined in some way. I would be prepared to withdraw my amendment if the Minister would consider introducing an amendment to this end. It would be a major omission not to include such a definition in the Bill.

Comment on this

I presume the words "to or from an airport" in Deputy Higgins' amendment refer to carriage to or from an airport by air.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The original draft included the words "by air". Deputy Higgins' amendment could be interpreted to mean how people physically get to an airport. That could occur in a number of ways.

Comment on this

If we withdraw these amendments, will the Minister consider the matter prior to Report Stage?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

What is the position in regard to ground staff and services?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

A number of later amendments define those issues.

Comment on this

Is amendment No. 2 being withdrawn?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, on the basis that I will examine the matter prior to Report Stage.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

On the section, when was the commissioner appointed and, in view of the fact that the legislation has not yet been enacted, what have he and his office been doing?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I have only met the commissioner once and cannot really tell the Deputy what he is doing. However, I understand he is very busy and that he has done a great deal of research, writing and consulting.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Is he officially on the payroll?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. He is working very assiduously.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I do not doubt that.

Comment on this

We are introducing legislation here to enable the Minister to appoint a regulatory commission or a regulator. The commissioner has already been appointed although the terms of reference for his appointment etc. are set out in legislation which has not yet been passed. This is a unique situation. We have been gazumped by the Government 's decision to appoint a person to a position which does not yet exist. It is somewhat strange that the commissioner's salary can be justified in this situation. I presume it was intended to introduce this legislation at an earlier date and I appreciate that the Second Stage Dáil debate was a very lengthy one. That said, the commissioner is in situ. If we amend the proposed manner of the commissioner’s appointment as we go through the Bill, will it be necessary to sack him?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not intend to start the new year by sacking anybody. The commissioner will be subject to examination by the Comptroller and Auditor General. That is enshrined in the Bill which also provides that the commissioner will be obliged to come before this committee.

Comment on this

That does not really answer my question. The commissioner has been appointed without legislative authority. How did that come about?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Civil Service Commission appointed the commissioner. I do not know whether the Deputy is insinuating that I had anything to do with his appointment but I did not even meet the man prior to his appointment.

Comment on this

I was not making any such insinuation.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I was provided with the result of the competition run by the Civil Service Commission and I brought that to Cabinet where it was approved.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Does the commissioner have a contract?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

He is an established civil servant.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Does he already have full superannuation rights even though we are enshrining such rights retrospectively through this legislation?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. I felt it was only right that the superannuation rights would be retrospective.

Comment on this

The commissioner has not been able to do his job to date.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I understand he has researched and consulted widely.

Comment on this

The situation is an unsatisfactory one.

Comment on this

I wanted to raise some points about the office, its location etc. but I felt those might be more appropriately dealt with under section 5 rather than under the definitions section. If we are to discuss the matter at this stage, I would like to know where the commissioner's office will be located, the number of people working in the office etc.

Comment on this

As the Deputy stated, those questions would be more appropriate to section 5.

Comment on this

I am anxious that the office would be established outside Dublin although I presume it is currently located in Dublin.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I think it is.

Comment on this

I would prefer to see it being located in Ennis or Athlone. Will the Minister tell us where the office is located and how many personnel are employed there?

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I wanted to ask a question on this section. As I understand it, this Bill is more or less a copy of a similar Bill in the UK. Several committees in Westminster are currently examining that legislation which is to be updated because it is out of date. What will happen when our neighbours, whose aviation regulation legislation is entwined with ours, introduce new legislation in this area? We are starting out at a disadvantage in that we are introducing legislation which has been deemed more or less extinct in the UK.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The UK introduced airport regulators in 1988. I spoke with the signal workers and Deputy Daly about this issue. The UK is reviewing airport regulations and has not come to any conclusions on amendments and so on. It has just announced that it will bring forward a White Paper. As far as I am aware, it has not as yet produced a White Paper. It is a long way from making changes and this is our legislation.

Comment on this

I accept Deputy Stagg's point. It is not unusual that these things take place before the statutory framework is put in place.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Other positions - not the regulator - relate to an unestablished civil servant. It was an interim arrangement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 6, line 40, after "Act" to insert ", provided that the Minister shall not make an order under this section until he or she has given comprehensive policy directions to the commission pursuant to section 10”.

David Byrne's speech was very important. He spoke about the difficulty of people empowered by the electorate giving the power to others without the electorate's say so. Effectively, when we appoint a regulator, we are handing the power of the Oireachtas to an unelected commission or quango - perhaps that is an abusive term for the regulatory system. There is a great deal of worry about how this can be made accountable. One of the key points in the former Attorney General's speech was that the Minister or the Dáil could not hand over authority to the regulator without specifying in detail the policies under which the regulator was to operate. It is very important that this be done. My amendment seeks to facilitate Mr. Byrne's point with which I believe the Minister agrees. The wording, "The Minister shall by order appoint a day to be the establishment day for the purposes of this Act" will be improved by inserting, "provided that the Minister shall not make an order under this section until he or she has given comprehensive policy directions to the commission pursuant to section 10”. The case stands on its merits. I know the Minister appreciates the point I am making and I ask her to accept my amendment.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I have considered the issue. David Byrne spoke with me about the telecommunications regulator, Etain Doyle, who, under the terms of the Act, did not consider she should attend here at a meeting. However, good sense prevailed, she attended the meeting and was most competent and confident. David Byrne spoke to me about the Act which did not have accountability in relation to the regulator. I suggested this was wrong and the Deputy admitted it was very wrong.

Comment on this

It was not my Act. It was the crowd around the Minister now who drafted it.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy brought it to the Dáil.

Comment on this

It was just handed to me; I was just the boy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is a great negation of the Deputy's responsibilities.

Comment on this

I was the junior Minister; the Minister knows who the senior Minister was.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We all agree that was wrong and the telecommunications Bill which is being introduced will rectify that. The energy commissioner, Tom Reeves, is accountable to the committee, as will be this commission. We are strengthening this power as we go through the Bill. The Deputy's amendment is seeking that if the Bill becomes an Act, I cannot make an establishment day until I tell the commissioner his orders or whatever. I believe this is unduly prescriptive.

Comment on this

Pursuant to section 10?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, and the Deputy asked for it to be strengthened. Therefore, I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Section 10 is very general.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has tabled amendment No. 5 to section 5.

Comment on this

That is more prescriptive. Under section 10, which is very vague, the Minister may give general policy directions, including directions in respect of the contributions of airports.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Perhaps the Deputy will clarify that issue when we get to it.

Comment on this

If we lose the opportunity to say that the Minister should do something about policy before the establishment order is made, if the order is made and the commissioner is free, with authority——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not mean to cut across the Deputy. The Minister of the day retains the power to give policy direction. That is included in the Bill.

Comment on this

Mr. Byrne argued effectively that the commissioner should not be given the authority until he knows what is the Minister's policy. The only way he will know the Minister's policy is if she makes policy orders.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, but policy will change. I am thinking of Etain Doyle and Tom Reeves. I have met Tom Reeves once since his appointment, but Etain Doyle comes here approximately every three months and more or less outlines her agenda for three or four months or whatever. I have informed the Cabinet about a couple of matters but I do not tell her what to do. The commission should be independent.

Comment on this

That is not the point I am making. I am making the point that the Minister currently has the authority which she will be giving to this man who will be appointed when the Act is passed. To validate that and to ensure that he is aware of the Minister's policies, it is necessary for her to indicate to him in some detail what her policies are. The best way to do this is probably by order. In the absence of this, he has no idea of the Minister's policies and he does not have to inform himself. It is not laid down that he must inform himself of Government policy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

This is mentioned throughout the Bill. If I were to go ahead with the section, it would mean the Bill could not come into force until I had laid down policy. The purpose of regulation is to strike a balance between independence, which they should have, and the retention of accountability, with which I fully agree, and transparency before they come before committees or wherever to tell their tale. They require a measure of independence and I am not minded to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I support the amendment. The Minister said she is not minded to accept the amendment. Would she be minded to accept it at a later stage?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Section 33——

Comment on this

Can I finish? This is a worthwhile amendment in terms of its spirit, whatever about the section to which it applies. We have some experience of how regulators operate and, for the sake of their work as well as the work being done in general, there is a need to avoid needlessly drawing the regulator into political controversy. That happens when the regulator, for whatever reason, gives the appearance of going off on a solo run or misunderstands the Government's policy. This is in nobody's interest and it would be worthwhile if the Minister, who is accountable to the electorate, were to clearly state over the next while the policy objectives in the public interest, and not in the commercial interest. This is the balance which has to be struck.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I take the Deputy's point. If he looks at section 33 - I know we should not be doing this, Chairman——

Comment on this

It is okay if it is in the context of explanation.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Section 33, paragraphs (a)to (i), more or less sets out the parameters ofpolicy.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

They are regulatory objectives. Is it not the case that no Government has developed aviation policy? Is that the reason for the Minister's reticence? I have never seen aviation policy set out in a White Paper. The Minister referred to the British Parliament but there certainly has not been any policy here. Policy is made up from time to time as events happen. The Minister may not accept what I am saying, but her reticence is born from the fact that we do not have aviation policy. Is that the problem?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is not my problem.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

The Minister is claiming that she has an aviation policy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I never said anything. The Deputy is claiming that this is the reason for the amendment. Deputy Stagg put forward the reason for the amendment, which, as I heard it, has nothing to do with a White Paper.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I did not say that either, but the Minister has no aviation policy. Is that not the problem? The Minister would accept the amendment if she had an aviation policy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I am minded not to accept the amendment. However, this is up to the members of the committee.

Comment on this

I am not finished. We are dealing with the heart of the Bill and of the regulatory process in a number of areas. We are seeking to improve it from the first bad attempt we made in relation to the Telecom regulator.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Etain Doyle.

Comment on this

She was not bad.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I mean the regulator.

Comment on this

Each time we have had legislation since then we have improved it. I would like to see the Telecom regulatory legislation withdrawn or amended.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We have a new Bill which will be introduced in April.

Comment on this

That is welcome as there are flaws in the legislation which need to be corrected.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is true.

Comment on this

We are improving the position all the time. People are starting to think about this issue more deeply.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will be aware that I have published a document on it.

Comment on this

I know that, and I will quote from it later. David Byrne's speech in this regard was a key one. It was picked up by many people who said we need to look at what is being done to the Dáil and to the democratic institutions which have authority. He was very clear on this. I know there is a policy position available within the Department on all the issues for which the Minister is responsible and that these can be used very quickly if the Minister wishes to use them. I forget the name of the big fat book one is supposed to read when one becomes Minister——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I know it.

Comment on this

Within it there is a policy on everything and once the Minister signs they are her policies as well. She might influence them in some way down the line but what the Minister does is not as clear-cut as people outside might think. There is a policy there and I would be happy if the Minister said it would be conveyed to the commissioner as soon as possible.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy mean the objectives of the Department in the fat book to which he referred?

Comment on this

Yes. I am worried that we will have four or five commissioners or regulators without any instructions. Tom Reeves is lucky as he probably wrote his section of the fat book.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

A portion of it.

Comment on this

He knows it inside out. He also knows everyone else's section so he is well informed. However, others are coming to this from outside without any knowledge of how the system or anything else works. They are taking the authority of the members of the committee and the Minister out of this room into their offices down town somewhere and will operate it from now on. They should operate it on riding instructions. The problem is that if they do not get riding instructions they can do what they like. I will withdraw my amendment but some mechanism has to be found to ensure the regulator knows the Government's intentions.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Deputy Stagg and I have discussed this issue informally as well as formally in the Chamber. As the Deputy knows, after I went into the Department I got uneasy about this issue and I brought a memorandum to Cabinet. This will come out in time. This was before I started work on the regulatory paper, which has now been issued. Deputy Stagg, on behalf of the Labour Party, made a very valuable contribution to it. I began to get uneasy that people were walloping or hand-bagging politicians, but at election time they have the right to say "I like you" or "I do not like you or your party". There is a democratic control over elected people, but there is not democratic control in an elective sense over regulators. Yet regulators are established in both the communications and electricity areas. The power, responsibility and accountability are slipping from the elected representative who will have to come before the electorate at some stage to a person or commission of two or three people who will be accountable to a committee but will not be accountable in an elective sense. In case anyone thinks I am throwing stones at them, both regulators are entirely competent. Yet outwardly democracy would seem to be diminished because of this transfer. I am at one with the Deputy in this regard.

Comment on this

I am worried about that.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I would be too. This is a philosophical discussion, which is rooted in practicality now that we are dealing with the Bill. This transfer is admirable and needed and all modern countries have regulators - I think we are the last European country to introduce regulation in this form. It is new to us in that way but Deputy Stagg said he would be willing to withdraw the amendment if, when the Bill is passed, I would meet the commissioner and relay to him the clear wishes of the committee in this regard.

Comment on this

It will be necessary, from the point of view of the users of the airport who will pay the charges, that he will levy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Aer Rianta and IEA?

Comment on this

The people who pay the charges.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, that is true.

Comment on this

They will be paying them through the regulator to Aer Rianta or the airport owner. It is important that they would know the riding instructions that have been given to the regulator so that what he is doing will be transparent and that they will know the policy position. If we create a vacuum or if we tell him privately in some way, they are at a disadvantage because they do not know under what policy he is operating.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Bill is fairly clear on the various duties the commission will have. I certainly would want to meet him but I will not accept amendment No. 4.

Comment on this

I will withdraw the amendment but I ask the Minister to look at that area——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I will think about what the Deputy said.

Comment on this

——to see what can be done and what is feasible. I understand there is a certain degree of urgency about the matter as well and it was not the intention to delay matters indefinitely.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I know that.

Comment on this

I will withdraw the amendment and re-enter it on Report Stage when we can examine it again.

Comment on this

Is that just for clarification, Deputy, that Government policy on aviation generally would be communicated to the Minister?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

General policy is a different matter.

Comment on this

That is what I am talking about.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Comprehensive policy directions, which is a different matter to general policy.

Comment on this

We lifted the wording of the amendment from David Byrne's speech, and I am not trying to beat the Minister with David Byrne's speech.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I know that. We talked about it.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I concur with what Deputy Stagg is trying to achieve in this amendment, along with the observations of Deputies Sargent and Carey. The problem is that we do not have a mission statement or a clear policy specification and, therefore, we are giving somebody carte blanche. That is the difficulty. While we tried to strengthen democratic accountability in section 10, it is extremely difficult to bridge that policy deficit on the one hand and democratic deficit on the other. The whole concept of the Bill runs counter to the national trend, which is to have greater accountability. We now have a push for accountability across the entire commercial, political and social spectrum. For example, the Judiciary is now being held to account in relation to disciplinary procedures. The previously untouchable Director of Public Prosecutions, who is independent in the function of his office, is now explaining some of his decisions, for example, in relation to the Nora Wall case. Yet, apart from this individual making himself amenable to the committee, we, as a body, cannot give any policy instructions. There is a problem and I welcome the Minister’s commitment to examine it on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Deputy Stagg can certainly put it forward on Report Stage but so that there will not be any ambiguity about it, I will not accept the amendment as worded.

Comment on this

I am easy about the wording. It is the principle I am concerned about. If "comprehensive policy directions" is the wrong term and even if "by order" is too strong——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

"Order" is very strong.

Comment on this

It is as strong as one can get but I hoped to start at the top and come down to the point where we might meet in the middle somewhere. The Minister should look at this issue which is in all our interests. It is a major issue. Transferring authority from the Oireachtas to outside people is the kernel of the Bill and we need to do it so that we have continuing democratic accountability. It is impossible to have accountability if we do not have a known policy umbrella under which it can operate. It has to be known and demonstrated and David Byrne argued that point very effectively.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

The Minister recently met a deputation and indicated that she supports the idea of regional development, even though we are a small island. It has been policy in the Governments of which the Minister has been a member that Ireland would be treated as one region and in that, people like regulators have assumed——

Comment on this

That is section 10.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is another section.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I appreciate that, Chairman. The point I was trying to make is that if further down the road the Minister is agreeable to that, could she not see an amendment being necessary in this section to copper-fasten what Deputies Stagg and Higgins have argued? She may not accept the words used in the amendment but could she not bring forward her own wording on Report Stage to support that ideal?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The discussion is very worthwhile. I do not want to hark back to Deputy Stagg's Bill but 1996 was a different time and it awakened all our thoughts about regulatory matters but there has to be a measure of independence in a regulatory regime. There is no point in having it if there is not a measure of independence. Otherwise we might as well stay at our desks doing our own jobs. It is to get that balance. I will not accept this amendment so there is no point in anybody saying that I will but I will think about the suggestions made here and perhaps some kind of wording can be found that will convey to a commissioner or a regulator that he or she will be mindful, in a general sense, of Government policy.

Comment on this

He is not just mindful. That is not the point. He is absolutely bound by Government policy. That is the law.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I know but "comprehensive policy direction" is a very stark——

Comment on this

I was trying to ensure that he knew what he was bound by. If he does not know——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

He is bound by the law.

Comment on this

——what Government policy is, how can he be bound by it? We are saying in the Bill that he is bound by Government policy and I am saying we should tell him what Government policy is.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Let us go through the Bill and we will see where other matters emerge which will——

Comment on this

Have a bearing on this matter?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

I withdraw the amendments, Chairman, on the basis of the discussion we have had. In doing so I ask the Minister to examine the matter.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

At this stage I presume the Minister would have an idea of the overall expense involved in regard to salaries, etc.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not, because the regulator has taken some civil servants from my Department with him and they are being paid by my Department.

Comment on this

Until such time as?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Until such time as this Bill becomes law. I believe he has also taken on two people as advisers or managers.

Comment on this

He has about seven staff at present.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Five are on the Department's payroll or from some other Department.

Comment on this

I am just trying to get a handle on the extent of this.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I had a conversation on that with the Deputy this morning, but I am not clear about the shape of that yet.

Comment on this

Section 9 provides for the transfer of many other functions.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, five altogether, the travel trade——

Comment on this

Will that necessitate additional expenses in terms of staff?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is a matter for the regulator as to the number of staff he requires. A later amendment is tabled with regard to keeping expenses to the minimum.

Comment on this

I am anxious to ensure we avoid building another financial monstrosity.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. As to the two previous ones, covered under the 1996 Bill and the one I was involved in with Tom Reeves, both of those do not operate to make a profit but only to run their offices efficiently.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins Mayo Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 7, between lines 13 and 14, to insert the following subsection:

"(4) In carrying out its functions, the Commission shall ensure that all determinations, conditions attaching thereto, amendments thereof and requests shall be objectively justified and shall be non-discriminatory, proportionate and transparent.".

I am sure my objective and that of Deputy Stagg in tabling this amendment is to establish a uniform and standard philosophy to guide all regulators. Essentially, this amendment reflects best practice at national level in the Telecommunications Regulation Act, 1996——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That did not have it.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

It did. It also reflects best practice in the European Community's telecommunication licences.

Comment on this

It was quoted once in Deputy Stagg's Bill - credit where credit is due.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

It is also consistent with the position put forward by the Minister in the White Paper on governance accountability in the regulation process published in March 2000. I ask the Minister to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I support what Deputy Higgins said.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Section 27(3) states that, "From time to time, and whenever so requested, the Commission shall account for the performance of its functions to a Joint Committee of the Oireachtas and shall have regard to any recommendations of such Joint Committee relevant to its functions." The amendment provides that the commission shall ensure that all determinations, conditions attaching thereto, amendments thereof and requests shall be objectively justified and shall be non-discriminatory. That is fair enough. I will accept the amendment, as it strengthens the section.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I thank the Minister for that.

Comment on this

It will improve the section.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We argued about that point yesterday and I came down in favour of accepting it.

Comment on this

I raised the question of the location of the office.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Does that come under this section?

Comment on this

We said we would deal with that point raised by Deputy Daly under section 5. Will Deputy Daly repeat his question?

Comment on this

This new office will be important and independent with functions relating to all the regions. It should be located outside Dublin. There is nothing written into the Bill on this. There was not much point in tabling an amendment to that effect, as I do not think the Minister would accept it.

Comment on this

It could be located in Knock.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It might be needed there.

Comment on this

It is a good location for an administrative office, so why not? Cahirciveen is another place. There are plenty of places in the west that are suitable locations for this office. I presume the office is located in Dublin Airport at present?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

As of now the regulator is in Mount Street, but that is only temporary.

Comment on this

It would be good if we had an idea where he will be located, as we would be able to find him if we need him.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

He is based in Mount Street as of now, but that is temporary.

Comment on this

I encourage the Minister to use her influence to locate that office outside of Dublin.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is not my job, but I do not need to tell the Deputy that.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I agree with Deputy Daly who is seeking to place more emphasis on the regions in this context and I am aware the Minister is of the same view. Aer Rianta promised it would decentralise some of its larger offices in Dublin Airport to the country, but it has not done so. It seems to be consolidating its business more around Dublin Airport. While we might express a wish for such decentralisation at a meeting such as this and when legislation is being dealt with, can the Minister not give stronger support to Deputy Daly's request, that when commissions such as this are set up in future that their headquarters will be located outside Dublin?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not intend to give orders as to where they should be sited. While we are being walloped over the head about decentralisation in terms of the ideas put forward by the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, in respect of which there seems to be a shift to one side or another, it is not appropriate for me to be the one to give orders on matters such as this.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 7, between lines 15 and 16, to insert the following subsection:

"(2) Notwithstanding subsection (1), the Commission shall appear before and be responsible to a committee of the Houses of the Oireachtas designated by such Houses for the purposes of this section.".

The objective of this amendment is to set to one side forever all the times the Minister has raised the issue with me of not including a similar provision in the telecommunications Bill. I wish to ensure such a provision is included in this Bill.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is provided for in section 27(3), which states: "From time to time, and whenever so requested, the Commission shall account for the performance of its functions to a Joint Committee of the Oireachtas and shall have regard to any recommendations of such Joint Committee relevant to its functions." That is more of less what is provided in the Deputy's amendment.

Comment on this

It is good enough for me.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is happy such a provision is included in the Bill.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Is there any provision for the commission to make an annual report to the Oireachtas?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, we discussed that. That is provided in the Bill.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Where in the Bill is that provided?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It will make a price determination first.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Correct.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

There is a provision that it should report on that.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

On each price determination?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It has to publish a report and speak on that.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

That is only when the price determination is made, but there is not a provision that it should make an annual report to the House as such.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is responsible on an annual basis to the Comptroller and Auditor General. It would come before him. The committee can request that the regulator appear before it at any time and lay out his plans for the future. The Bill provides for that.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Yes and he must appear.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

The terms of reference of the committee allows for the examination of the report, the hearing of strategy statements and so on.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

I presume Standing Orders can be amended, if necessary, to further strengthen the committee's hand on what is provided in section 27.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. The committee can ask the regulator anything it likes. The important point is to ensure that he is obliged to appear before the committee. That is the purpose of this amendment, which is already provided for in the Bill, but I have no objection to including such a provision in this section. I accept it might be tautology but the more it is repeated, the more obvious it is that he will be responsible to an Oireachtas committee. I will accept amendment No. 6.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 7:

In page 7, subsection (3), lines 23 and 24, to delete "granting operating licences to" and substitute "licensing of".

There are a number of technical amendments to the Bill. The Chief Parliamentary Counsel is an estimable man but he has had too long to think about it, look at and twiddle with this Bill. Many of these technical amendments are twiddles although they are deemed to be proper.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 67 and 68 are related to amendment No. 8. Is it agreed that amendments Nos. 8, 67 and 68 be discussed together? Agreed.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 8:

In page 7, before section 9, to insert the following new section:

"9.-The Minister for Public Enterprise, in conjunction with the Commission for Aviation Regulation, shall ensure that all agencies permitted to work in the operational area of State aerodromes and licensed aerodromes in handling activities which impact on the safety of aircraft have the necessary competencies in their related field to ensure safety of operations.".

This amendment is self explanatory. There is a huge security element in aviation and at airports and an absolute requirement to have maximum security. It is self evident that the people who are permitted to operate within the airport zone should be vetted for competence. There should be no question mark over their ability to do the job and there should be no security element or risk. That is the reason for the insertion of a new section.

Amendment No. 67 provides that the Irish Aviation Authority Act, 1993, be amended by the insertion of the following:

(a) in section 14(1)(c), by the insertion of-

'to ensure that all agencies permitted to work in the operational area of State aerodromes and licensed aerodromes in handling activities which impact on the safety of aircraft have the necessary competencies in their related field to ensure safety of operations,' after 'services,' and

(b) in section 43 (1)(a), by the insertion of ’and section 33 of the Aviation Regulation Act, 2001’ after ’Subject to subsection (3)’.”.

The Minister mentioned tautology earlier but from the perspective of safety and security, I doubt that we can emphasise sufficiently or often enough the need to ensure the absolute integrity of the people who operate within the zone of the airport. That is the reason for the amendments.

Comment on this

I tabled amendment No. 68 and its wording is similar to Deputy Higgins'. It states: ". . . to ensure that all agencies permitted to work in the operational area of State aerodromes and licensed aerodromes in handling activities which impact on the safety of aircraft have the necessary competencies to ensure safety of operations". That power should be extended to the Irish Aviation Authority. It effectively means the gap between where the Irish Aviation Authority takes over and the door on to the tarmac is covered by the Irish Aviation Authority. That gap at present is effectively self regulated and nearly all the accidents at Dublin Airport happen in that gap.

The Health and Safety Authority can be called in but it is not a hands on authority. It does not have people there all the time like the Irish Aviation Authority has. It does not set specific regulations for airports, as the aviation authority would. It is sensible to extend the remit of the Irish Aviation Authority from the door of the plane to the door of the building or until people get off the tarmac. That is currently self regulated and nearly all the Ryanair incidents and safety incidents at Dublin Airport occur in that space. There is no effective regulation. The Health and Safety Authority has no special rules for that area.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That authority is to be called in rather than——

Comment on this

That is the problem. The Irish Aviation Authority has up to 800 staff operating hands-on for the airports. I strongly recommend that their remit be extended to that gap.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

These amendments, in effect, deal with ground handling. Ground handling has been the subject of an immense number of parliamentary questions and a number of meetings I have had with ICTU, airport staff and other bodies who are worried about the subject. The IAA and the HSA are currently discussing the drafting of a memorandum of understanding. It is a nebulous area over which, as of now, nobody has full control or the final line of authority. We discussed it within the Department last week and this week.

I do not know if this is the correct place to deal with it but I am concerned about the matters of which the Deputies speak. With the permission of the committee, I will ask my officials to speak again to the parties involved, that is, the IAA and ICTU; the HSA is only to be called upon as required. It is between six and nine months since I last met them. We will see then what their thoughts are on the matter. It is a matter of concern because it is nebulous and has not as yet been tied down and put at the door of a body or person.

Comment on this

In your discussions was the Irish Aviation Authority reluctant to take over that responsibility?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It seemed to me that it was. I do not know why.

Comment on this

I found the same.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister's acknowledgement that there is a problem because that is always the start of a solution. However, this is likely to get worse if the regulator has a clear brief to adopt a primarily commercial view of the operation of the airport. The amendments are important in that they deal specifically with competencies in the field of ground handling, something which, unless it is laid out clearly, is likely to be compromised. That is the worry of people in the ground handling area, that when commercial criteria are applied in a black and white way, competencies will suffer. This must be addressed because it is likely to get worse.

The obvious course for a body to take is to avoid responsibility which it does not have and if the responsibility is not clearly set down, the body will try to avoid it. The IAA or the Health and Safety Authority are obviously managing to claim that this is not their responsibility.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It has to be somebody's.

Comment on this

It does and that is where the Minister has a role to play. If this amendment is not the place for it, something should be done quickly because the situation will get worse.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I have been told for some time that the IAA is quite firm that it does not have a role. I do not know why everybody is shying away from it. However, it is supposed to be drawing up a memorandum of understanding which will set out the respective roles. I will ask the officials to contact the players in the field, meet them and see how far that has developed in light of this legislation.

Comment on this

The Irish Aviation Authority does not have a role at present.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It does not have a function in ground handling

Comment on this

It, therefore, needs this amendment to give it a function. If one attempted to give it a function without the amendment, it would not have any statutory or legal basis.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I understand the Deputy's point. The amendments and the time spent on them by the committee may excite some minds.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Given that there is a vacuum, it would be extraordinary if we did not grasp this nettle now and establish it.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I had a series of meetings with the authority.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Did the Minister receive any representations from Aer Rianta in this regard?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I am sure I did.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Recent representations?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I cannot remember them now because it is approximately nine months since I met all those players.

Comment on this

CRC?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. I also met SIPTU separately.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

The amendments seek to address the problem of who is responsible for the crucial vacuum that exists at present, which was identified by Deputy Stagg. I am sure a recent incident at Dublin Airport, which was highlighted in The Sunday Tribune, has been brought to the Minister’s attention. In that incident, a journalist succeeded in breaching security and getting in. He had full access to all backroom operations in the airport and was able to independently vet and photograph aeroplanes at the various terminals and in the various hangars.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is a security issue.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Yes, but it involves the confidence of the companies. During his period of access to the internal workings of the airport, nobody challenged him. It was only when he entered the public domain that an airport police vehicle followed him, asked him where he was going and tried to take his film from him.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

A judge in a courtroom in London had her face bashed in yesterday.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

There is a need to copperfasten the situation on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

As I said, there is a timeframe and, therefore, I will ask the officials to meet the parties we met previously and to discuss the current position with regard to the memorandum of understanding. I will revert to the committee on the matter.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 10 is cognisant to amendment No. 9 and both may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 7, subsection (1), line 28, after "transferred" to insert ", on the establishment day,".

Both amendments are technical and have been introduced on the advice of the Chief Parliamentary Counsel. I maintain responsibility until the establishment day is set down.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 10:

In page 7, subsection (2), line 29, after "transferred" to insert ", on the establishment day,".

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

The Minister probably has an explanation on why the section is as it stands.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Which section?

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Section 10.

Comment on this

Deputy Stagg's amendment must be dealt with first.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

It might be helpful to the Minister if she read out the explanation.

Comment on this

The usual procedure is that the explanation is given in response to a question.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I appreciate that.

Comment on this

There is no question as such. If the Deputy thinks about the matter, he may come up with one.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I tabled a series of amendments to section 10,

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Where are they?

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 11 to 14, inclusive, are in the name of Deputy Stagg while amendments Nos. 15 and 16 are in the name of Deputy Higgins.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Did the Chair receive notification about the ruling out of any amendments?

Comment on this