We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ENTERPRISE AND TRANSPORT

Aviation Regulation Bill, 2000 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.

Contributions 249–498 of 1,252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.

Bill Aviation Regulation Bill 2000
Enacted

No. 24 of 2000 ›

No, not to my knowledge.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Bills Office groups amendments together. Are amendments missing?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 15 and 16 are in the Deputy's name.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Were there more than two amendments?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I tabled a long amendment to section 10.

Comment on this

That is amendment No. 16.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

It has been changed to amendment No. 16.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We did not do that; the Bills Office did it.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

That is fine.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 8, subsection (1), line 25, after "may" to insert "by order".

The amendment suggests that if policy directions were given by order, it would ensure that people are aware of what they contain. The users, who would be subject to charges on foot of the policy being operated by the regulator under the Minister's remit, would also be aware. It would ensure that matters are transparent and clear. People would know exactly why orders or decisions were made and the conditions would be apparent to everybody. Perhaps the Minister will accept the amendment.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

What does the Deputy mean by order in that context?

Comment on this

I mean ministerial order.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I am sure the Deputy did not mean a statutory instrument.

Comment on this

Yes, I did.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I understand. Initially, I did not know what he meant.

Comment on this

It is similar to the argument I made earlier.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not like the word "order".

Comment on this

Perhaps the amendment could be dropped if the word "shall" was substituted for "may".

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

To what amendment is the Deputy referring?

Comment on this

It relates to the section.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy suggesting that the word "shall" should be substituted for "may"?

Comment on this

If the Minister considered that, I could withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I will consider it.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 12, 54 and 61 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In page 8, subsection (1), lines 26 and 27, to delete "(including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located)".

Section 10(1) states that the "Minister may give such general policy directions (including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located) to the Commission as he or she considers appropriate to be followed by the Commission in the exercise of its functions". I do not understand why that is included. Does the Minister understand why it is included?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Senator Taylor-Quinn was keen to include that. I am not being nasty, I am just stating a fact.

Comment on this

It states "in respect of the contribution of airports". It could be possible to give unique adverse instructions to the commission.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy saying I would do so?

Comment on this

The Minister would not do that. However, the Minister's successor, who might have a bad mind, could say we want to close Shannon Airport. They could make a special contribution from that airport. Section 10(1) states: "(including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located)". What is intended by that?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I presume the Deputy is referring to the Bill.

Comment on this

Yes, section 10 of the Bill.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The section states that the "Minister may give such general policy directions (including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located) to the Commission as he or she considers appropriate to be followed by the Commission in the exercise of its functions". It is of benign nature in terms of the general regional development policy. We had a great debate on Shannon in the Seanad, led by Senator Taylor-Quinn and others. Why does the Deputy want to delete that?

Comment on this

I am afraid it could be used adversely.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

I remember we looked at this for a long time and we asked about its purpose.

Comment on this

There could be a situation where a regional airport, such as Shannon, could be disadvantaged by some actions of the regulator.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No. Deputy Stagg is saying it could be disadvantaged by reason of a Minister rather than a regulator.

Comment on this

Section 10(1) states that the "Minister may give such general policy directions (including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located) to the Commission as he or she considers appropriate to be followed by the Commission in the exercise of its functions". That is the Minister giving orders to the commission.

Comment on this

The argument is that if the regulator was taking some action which was disadvantageous to an airport such as Shannon, the Minister would be able to——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is the thrust of section 10 as it stands. We should come out into the open. When SIPTU came to see me, it said it wanted that changed.

Comment on this

SIPTU said that to me as well.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

There is no point in us pussy-footing around. The Deputy is correct that the Minister could be benign towards a regional airport. That was included as an acknowledgement of the role airports play in regional development. SIPTU said it would be fine while I was Minister because I feel that way towards Shannon.

Comment on this

We would be afraid not to say that to the Minister.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

However, when I am gone and my successor, who lives in Dublin or somewhere else and does not look kindly on Shannon——

Comment on this

People from the west would be all right.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

They would. It is a complete reversal of what has been said heretofore. SIPTU does not want the Minister to have that power. It is all right to have it now if it could be changed when I leave office. It wants the regulator, rather than the Minister, to have the power. All the amendments so far have related to leaving power with the Minister, not with the regulator. However, this amendment seeks to ensure the regulator has the power. Do you, Chairman, follow me?

Comment on this

I do. It is only in the context of general policy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is completely out of sync.

Comment on this

Everyone seems to be happy with it.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

They are happy now with me and they profess they will remain happy with me, but they do not know if they will be happy with a future Minister, whoever he or she may be.

Comment on this

That will not happen for some time yet.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. Such policy would be a matter for the Government of the day. I, like Deputy Stagg, was also puzzled. I teased it out with the deputation.

Comment on this

We will now discuss amendment No. 13. Amendment No. 15 is an alternative and both may be discussed together, by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:

In page 8, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following subsection:

"(2) Notwithstanding the generality of subsection (1), the Minister may give specific directions to the Commission on receipt of the report as provided by section 35(8) of this Act.”.

This amendment is self-explanatory. This new subsection would be inserted between lines 29 and 30. It states that "notwithstanding the generality of subsection (1), [which relates to general policy direction] the Minister may give specific directions to the Commission on receipt of the report as provided by section 35(8) of this Act”. When that report is received, specific directions could then be given to the commission.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Perhaps the Deputy could explain that to me.

Comment on this

It relates to section 35(8) which states that a "report under subsection (7) shall be sent by the Commission to the Minister and to the Authority”.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We spoke about this in general terms some time ago.

Comment on this

Yes. Section 35(7) states that "On making a determination the Commission shall make a report on the determination giving an account of its reasons for making that determination together with its reasons for accepting or rejecting representations made under subsection (5)”. Section 35(8) states that a “report under subsection (7) shall be sent by the Commission to the Minister and to the Authority”. On receipt of that report, “Notwithstanding the generality of subsection (1), the Minister may give specific directions to the Commission on receipt of the report as provided by section 35(8)”.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

If the commissioner lays a report here and gives me a report, the Deputy wants me to thank him or her for it and to give him or her an order about that report.

Comment on this

The Minister may give an order.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I would have received the report at that stage.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I may or may not like the report once I have read it. I may then tell the commissioner to do certain things and not to do other things.

Comment on this

If the Minister sees flaws in the system arising from that report, she could give corrective instructions.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Not on the detail of the report.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is because the report would have been furnished in such detail. The amendment essentially seeks to change a report because it is not liked. That would not be correct procedure. Perhaps it is not what the Deputy intends.

Comment on this

According to my brief, notwithstanding the fact that interested parties and the public may make representations under section 35(5)(c)——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Which they can do.

Comment on this

——there is no provision in the legislation for an appeal by an aggrieved party against the determination.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is another matter, dealing with the appeal.

Comment on this

Accordingly, in the interests of consistency it is requested that an appeals mechanism to the relevant Minister be incorporated in the legislation. Insertion of subsection (2) would facilitate an appeal by community-based bodies, such as SIGNAL, which would not have the financial resources to launch a court-based appeal.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

My amendment seeks the same change, except that it does not specify subsection (8). From the point of view of the appeals mechanism and the democratic deficit——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is further on.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

That is correct, but on the question of accountability, the Bill contains a provision dealing with access to the courts in respect of challenges.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is correct.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

However, a small group, such as a group of community workers, may not have the necessary resources to go to the courts.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The question of appeals will be dealt with under a later section where amendments are put down in respect of judicial reviews. There is also a general appeals issue.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Judicial review is a hugely expensive and complicated procedure.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That will be dealt with later.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Groups such as SIGNAL, to whom the Minister has made herself amenable - I hope future Ministers will also make themselves amenable - should have the right of access to the Minister on matters of concern raised in a report which might be to the detriment of the welfare of an airport, such as airport charges, or the community.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I accept what you say, but let us take it a stage further. Ministers from all parties will always make themselves amenable to people and will listen to what they have to say. I still meet groups all the time who tell me of their concerns etc. I accept that the position of community or smaller groups should be heard, but we should not link that with the appeals mechanism as that will be dealt with later.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

There is no appeals mechanism for groups such as SIGNAL.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We should not talk about them here.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I accept that.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

If a community wishes to see the Minister to the effect that what a report contains does not suit them and is to the detriment of the airport concerned, the next step, according to these amendments, is for me as Minister to tell the regulator that I do not like what is in the report and it does not satisfy a given community group. I could not do that.

Comment on this

Or a region.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The regional aspect is addressed later. The regulator must compile his report in accordance with other provisions contained in the legislation. I could not, therefore, ask him to change an aspect of the report on the basis that I did not like it.

Comment on this

Could the committee act in that way?

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Account must be taken of whether the commission is independent.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is correct. There is a need to strike a balance. Mention was made of the commissioner's remuneration. He would probably resign if I was to ask him to change a report because I did not like it. I will not do that.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

The Minister said that later provisions of the Bill deal with mechanisms of accountability.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is correct.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Section 27(3) provides that the commissioner shall account for the performance of his functions to a joint committee of the Oireachtas and shall have regard to the recommendations of such a joint committee relevant to his functions. How strong is the term "shall have regard to"?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

In a general sense the regulator in question would be foolish not to listen to what a committee had to say. He can interpret it at his discretion. Let us focus on the matter before us. The amendments propose that having considered a report by the regulator and met various interest groups, I can ask for the report to be changed on the basis that I did not like what it contained. I would not do that, nor do I expect any other Minister to act in this way. Again, a balance must be struck between independence and general policy directions. It is very difficult to define that, in a regulatory Bill or in any papers dealing with regulations.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

We do not envisage that the Minister would become unduly influenced or prescriptive. Subsection (1) provides for general directions. Our amendments seek to insert subsection (2) to the effect that the Minister may make prescriptions on the detail of any report submitted. We regard it as a right for the Minister to exercise, but only on the rarest of occasions.

If an appointed regulator is given carte blanche for the duration of his term of, say, five years, he does not have to consider any views. He is effectively a solo performer, operating under general guidelines, but in effect he has absolute power and discretion when making decisions on when and how levies should be charged and so on. These amendments seek to ensure that in certain circumstances and if the Minister feels strongly enough about a proposed infringement to the welfare of an airport or a community that is of vital importance, he or she may give a specific direction.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is not provided for.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

That is what we are seeking to achieve.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I am aware of that and I have gone over this many times with Etain Doyle and Tom Reeves. If a measure of independence is not granted to a regulator, which includes transparency and accountability - we all seek that - there is no point in proceeding. There is a requirement to have an officer of a regulator. It is not as if one person will dictate things. Three people will be involved in the telecommunications commission. An Post will also be included. In the same way electricity will take over gas and three people will be involved. There will be no primus inter pares. They will be three people of equal standing. In the same way aviation may be linked to transport or some such element. The Bill allows for three people to be involved in this aspect.

When dealing with the ODTR, the regulatory authority for telecommunications, I was worried about the involvement of only one person. The Cabinet contains 15 members and all can give their point of view. Everybody must be responsible to another and must listen to others. No one person will dictate everything. I certainly would not see a situation arise where on receiving a report, one would decide that one does not like this or that. If that were the case, one would not get a person to take the job.

Comment on this

On a point of clarification, Deputy Higgins raised a point about section 27. Subsection (3) states: "the performance of its functions to a Joint Committee of the Oireachtas and shall have regard to any recommendations of such Joint Committee". The report will come before the joint committee. Does that mean that the commission simply listens but disregards?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No. The phrase "shall have regard to" is one of those legal terms which is used in all legislation. In the end it comes down to the qualities of the person and the fact that he or she would listen to the committee. Clearly if the committee was of one mind, it would be a rash regulator who would not pay due regard to it.

Comment on this

The person would take it on board.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That has to do with future policy making. It would not be with regard to the report. I envisage this regulator appearing here before the committee - under its own remit, the committee may want to see him the day after he is appointed - to answer practical questions such as how much he is earning, how many staff there are etc. The committee could ask what is the programme of work for the year ahead and the regulator would lay it out. The committee could ask the regulator to report again in six months, at which time the regulator would furnish a report. I cannot then see that the committee could state that it did not like chapter two or three or line 10 or 11 of that report because that would lead to an unending process and an unbusiness-like commission.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I do not disagree with the Minister's analysis but the real problem is that users, be they community or workers, do not have an opportunity to appeal. If, in the definition of users, the Minister had included people who are working in the airport or people in the community associated with the airport, one may have had access to the commissioner. It is a matter of access to the commissioner.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

On that, I understand Ms Etain Doyle meets people and groups all the time, or her officials do so if she is not there. Access would never be a problem. Like in other circumstances, people would meet people unless they are very dogged. I would not envisage that access would be the difficulty.

I wish to make clear that the regulator would come here and state that this is the programme of work and he will return in six months with a report for the committee. In six months the regulator would return and report and my point is that the committee would then say that it wanted to change that report or the Minister might say so because I expect the regulator will come in to see me to outline the intended programme of work for the first six months.

Comment on this

Let us say that there was something in the report which was contrary to Government policy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That would be a separate matter. The general policy of this and the previous Government with regard to Shannon Airport, for instance, is that it should retain its status and be part of regional development etc. If the regulator came to me with a report stating that he would close Shannon Airport or dictate charges in such a way——

Comment on this

That it would close.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

——that ultimately it would close, certainly the Minister or a committee——

Comment on this

Let us say that the regulator had ten such items out of a hundred in his report.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That would be to attribute an enormous malfunction to the regulator.

Comment on this

Then the Minister would need to fire a shot across the regulator's bows in some form. If this subsection which we are proposing was in place, the Minister would have an automatic vehicle for doing so.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No. It would be incorrect to put in law that a report will be made and following that report the Minister will revisit the regulator's plan of work and what the regulator had done. One would not get anybody to undertake the job of commissioner. What would be the point?

Comment on this

A conflict with Government policy is distinctly different.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

With laid out Government policy, yes. I am just taking the Shannon Airport issue as an example.

Comment on this

The regulator would nearly know that at that stage.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, because it is self-evident.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Is Government policy covered by section 10(1), which states: "The Minister may give such general policy directions". Is that where Government policy comes into it?

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I asked originally if she would give us the benefit of the explanation to section 10 which the Civil Service has given her.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

My note states that section 10 provides for ministerial authority to issue policy of a general nature - that is in the Bill. This is a fairly common provision and permits a residual power to be exercised in the interests of issuing appropriate policy directives to a regulator. The requirements of any aviation sector can change, as we know.

Baring in mind that issue, on which the regulator will come to the committee and to me, basically the raising of money through the charges, the regulator will deal with the travel trade, licensing and some other matters, all of which are mechanical operations. The report to the committee and to me would state the cap on the money the regulator proposes to raise in order that the two bodies, Aer Rianta and the IAA, can run their businesses.

Comment on this

Here we would really be telling him how to do it and all he would have to do is go and do it.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

He would come to me and say that he had decided to massively reduce charges or raise the cap by a particular amount, or he might say that he had decided to do nothing. If I was to tell the regulator that I do not agree with raising charges or deleting charges, as the case may be, what is the purpose of the regulator?

Comment on this

The Minister would not have the power to say that she does not agree.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Not really, that is true.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

What are the appeals mechanisms or are there any appeals mechanisms for community groups, user groups etc.?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The user groups are the IAA and Aer Rianta - they are the two.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

If SIGNAL, for example, or some commercial organisation within the catchment area of Shannon Airport had a problem with a particular recommendation or determination——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy mean a problem with an airport charge?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Yes. Is there any——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The explanatory memorandum states that the regulator has five functions. It states that the primary function of the Bill is to provide for the independent regulation of airport charges, including charges for the IAA, that is, for Aer Rianta and the IAA. The legislation also provides that the commission will assume responsibility for a number of other aviation functions: the grant of operating licences to air carriers, which is a mechanical function; the designation, where necessary, of Irish airports as co-ordinated airports, which we are about to introduce because we could not wait; approval of ground handling services, to which we will return; and the licensing and bonding of tour operators and travel agents, which is purely a mechanical function also. Really we are talking about airport charges——

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

——IAA charges and Aer Rianta charges. With the greatest respect to SIGNAL, I do not know what the appeal against an airport charge would have to do with SIGNAL.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

The Minister has reached the crucial point. The chief executive officer of Ryanair was at Shannon Airport a few weeks ago and he sought as a policy the adoption of the abolition of all airport charges for airlines. He pointed out to the board at Shannon Airport that this policy has more or less succeeded at a number of airports, particularly one in Scotland which had almost gone to the wall. He had resuscitated it by partly taking it over. Such financial detail is keenly analysed by airport managers, such as those at Shannon Airport. We do not know if Shannon Airport is viable. I do not know, even if the Minister appoints a regulator, how she will conduct an analysis of the accounts as they stand.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We would conduct such an economic analysis.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

If that is the case, cross-subsidisation and other effects will become a problem. If Shannon Airport could not attract air traffic without introducing vastly reduced charges by comparison to Dublin or Cork Airports, there is no mechanism for appeal.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy saying that we would reduce charges so that the airport could attract traffic?

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

The regulator would, as a commercial consideration.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Aer Rianta is a commercial semi-State company, not a subsidised semi-State company. The notion that one would reduce charges to enable an operator to make more money——

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

When Shannon Airport was generating virtually all Aer Rianta's income, charges at Dublin Airport remained low because of the surplus generated at Shannon.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

When was that?

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Before Deputy Cowen deregulated the industry.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not follow the logic of Deputy Carey's point. Aer Rianta is a commercial semi-State company. It is not subsidised and, therefore, it must pay its way and live within its——

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

It may not need the income generated by landing charges. It may have other charges.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the regulator to examine. It is not up to me to decide from where it generates its income. That is the purpose of the legislation. Traffic at Shannon has increased hugely by 19% and 10% in recent years.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I will not argue with those figures.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not ask the Deputy to argue with them.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I can also pick figures from the sky.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

On a point of order, I did not pick those out of the sky. Those are audited figures available to everyone. I do not understand the notion that a commercial semi-State body would deliberately reduce charges. It is a subject——

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Many businesses reduce prices to increase business.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

They remain in business. They are economically run. That is what the regulator will do.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Aer Rianta can also be economical.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Exactly. I am sure it is run economically. Ireland has some of the lowest airport charges in Europe.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

That is another argument.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The figures are audited.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Yes, but as Deputy Higgins stated, there is no appeals mechanism.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I will deal with appeals later.

Comment on this

The amendment is withdrawn.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I retain the right to table the amendment again on Report Stage or on the basis of the discussion on appeals.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy can table whichever amendments he wishes but I will not accept the amendment because it negates the entire Bill.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Will the Minister consider an appeal?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

There is a section dealing with appeals.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 16 is an alternative to amendment No. 14 and both may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:

In page 8, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following subsection:

"(2) In giving such directions the Minister shall have regard to the following policy objectives:

(a) to foster a strong and competitive Irish airline industry by providing sufficient airport capacity where it is required;

(b) to minimise the impact of airports on the environment generally and to ensure that land use planning and conservation policies take fully into account both the development needs arising from airports and the environmental consequences;

(c) to make the best use of existing facilities and provide new capacity only where this is economically justified;

(d) to encourage the use and development of regional airports so that they meet the maximum demand they can attract;

(e) to ensure that all airports maintain the highest standards of safety;

(f) to ensure that air transport facilities should not in general be subsidised from public funds;

(g) to ensure that airports should normally operate as commercial under-takings.”.

This is an important amendment, which I hope the Minister will accept. It is based on a request by SIPTU which again seeks clarity on policy. The amendment is modelled on the UK Act. It provides a second subsection under general policy directions.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is very right wing. Did that come from SIPTU?

Comment on this

If the Minister looked at it from Deputy Joe Higgin's position, it might appear right wing. It should appear left wing from her position. The amendment states:

(c) to make the best use of existing facilities and provide new capacity only where this is economically justified; [I would be surprised if we did otherwise]

(d) to encourage the use and development of regional airports so that they meet the maximum demand they can attract;

(e) to ensure that all airports maintain the highest standards of safety;

(f) to ensure that air transport facilities should not in general be subsidised from public funds;

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is fair enough.

Comment on this

Paragraph (g) states: “to ensure that airports should normally operate as commercial undertakings”. That is by no means an exhaustive list but it captures a broad spectrum of what I hope will be the Minister’s policy and the policy umbrella under which the commissioner will operate. There should be clarity about what he should do.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Did the Deputy get the amendment from SIPTU?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

My amendment is basically the same but it is in an abbreviated form. The Minister should have regard to the following policy objectives: to foster a strong, competitive Irish airline industry by providing enough airport capacity where it is needed; to make the best use of existing facilities and provide new capacity where it is economically justified; and to ensure all airports continue to maintain the highest standards of safety in accordance with internationally accepted rules and standards. There is a commission to comply with directions given under subsections (1) and (2). We did not succeed in inserting subsection (2).

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is correct.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

It is self-explanatory.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The amendment is extremely prescriptive and when one does that in legislation of a general policy nature one finds that one has made omissions which need to be considered or one has gone beyond one's brief. The purpose of the Bill is to appoint a commissioner and get him or her to conduct his or her business.

Section 33 states that in making a determination the commission shall aim to facilitate the development and operation of cost-effective airports which meet the requirements of users and shall have due regard to paragraphs (a) to (i), which cover safety requirements, a reasonable rate of return, the efficient and effective use of all resources, the level of income operating, the level and quality of services and cost competitiveness. Different wording is used but instead of me ordering it to happen the legislation provides what the committee shall have regard to. We inserted sub-paragraphs (h) and (i) in an amendment in the Seanad imposing the minimum restrictions on the airport authority consistent with the functions and such international obligations are relevant to its functions. Senator Taylor-Quinn proposed these changes, with a number of others, but we accepted those two.

Comment on this

I accept the validity of the Minister's point. I will withdraw my amendment but I ask her to ascertain whether there are any points of merit in it.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is fair enough. That is what we did when Senator Taylor-Quinn tabled her amendment in the Seanad. We accepted two of its proposals.

Comment on this

We in the Labour Party used to call a number of similar motions which had been tabled together a composite motion. When they were finished one could not read them.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Essentially I am trying to be as positive as possible.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I know that.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

They are highly desirable objectives and I am trying to set the highest standards in terms of aspirations as to what we believe Government policy should enshrine.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I take that point. I undertake to examine the two amendments tabled by Deputies Stagg and Higgins and if anything in them is not encompassed by the legislation I will table an amendment to address that.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I move amendmentNo. 15:

In page 8, lines 30 and 31, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following:

"(2) Notwithstanding the generality of subsection (1), the Minister may give specific directions to the Commission on receipt of the report as provided by section 35 of this Act.”.

I will withdraw the amendment but I will table it again on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

We have teased out the section at length but in regard to the appeals mechanism can the Minister, under section 10(1), in certain circumstances if she regards something as damaging to the welfare of an airport or a region - Deputy Carey pointed out that charges can be crucial in terms of the welfare, viability and future of an airport - instruct the commission in that regard?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No, I cannot instruct him as to what charge he should impose. I do not have that right. He will be given that job when the legislation is enacted.

Comment on this

If Government policy is to maintain Shannon Airport, for example, and he introduced charges at the airport which would damage its viability, the Minister would have the power to intervene.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is bringing the issue another step forward. If Government policy was that Shannon Airport was the desired airport for regional development, that that should remain the case and that it should grow and prosper, and if the commissioner came to me with his report about the level of charges, he would have to justify them because that is provided for in the legislation. He will have regard to general Government policy. Deputy Higgins is asking me to tell him that the charges he has imposed on the airport are too excessive or too low and will not allow Shannon Airport to operate as per Government policy. I do not agree with that because how am I to judge that? He has a general remit under the legislation and how am I to tell him I do not like what he is doing because it will affect Shannon Airport? He can say it will not.

For example, if he makes his determination of charges in six months or a year and there is a review five years later with a review period of two years——

Comment on this

Others can request one also.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. It is a moot point but it is not defined when one should interfere.

Comment on this

Is there a specific definition to cover contributions of airports to regions under section 10?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I presume contribution means the beneficial effect of an airport. It does not refer to money.

Comment on this

It means the social and economic effect of the airport.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Exactly, the well-being of the region.

Comment on this

If someone damaged that, I am glad the Minister will have the right under the Bill to intervene.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

If it flew in the face of Government policy or a Government decision.

Comment on this

Or if he was in breach of including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, but I would have no right to say the charge imposed is too low and that airport is not economically sustainable. He would have done it against the background of economic viability. That is how I see it.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

If the viability of the airport is in question, in future the regulator will have to recommend increased charges and it can never become a low cost airport, where one could have low cost carriers operating out of Shannon. Viability is an issue all the time. The Minister or a future Minister might decide to make Shannon Airport a low cost carrier airport. Where would the regulator be then?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not think any Government would challenge low cost air carriers. There should be a variety of airline companies, as is the case. If the Deputy means low cost airport charges, which is what I think he is saying——

Comment on this

He is talking about Ryanair.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. Thank you.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

It could be Virgin or any airline. It could be an American airline.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is a commercial semi-State company. As of now, airport charges account for 17% of the operating costs.

Comment on this

As well as referring to the section, which I am happy with and fully understand now, the Minister is telling the committee - I refer to section 10 - that in circumstances where she would determine that the commission was acting against the interests of the contributions of airports to regions, she could act.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Bill states that the Minister may give such general policy directions, including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located. Presumably this relates to the benefits of airports to the regions in which they are located. We inserted this in the Seanad as this went on for weeks in that House - at the end we were nearly a debating society. That was put in with all-party agreement.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I thank the Minister for inserting that. The crucial assertion is "including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located". We are talking here about the importance of the airport to balanced regional development.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

It strikes me that if the Government says it has policy interests in relation to Shannon Airport and there is a deviation from that on the part of the regulator, the Minister may make a prescription within this provision.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, but not on the precise nature of airport charges.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Surely the Minister sees the point that some advantage must be given to an airport like Shannon. It must do something to attract business.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It must be doing it well.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

It has the benefit at present of the bilateral agreement, but if that were to go and this Bill were not reviewed in five years, there could be difficulties down the line, with economic charges imposed by the regulator possibly being so high as to send an airline in the opposite direction. Because of the regulator's strict interpretation of commercial viability the charges could not be reduced as I requested originally.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I am not going into whether the regulator will reduce or raise charges. The area of charges is his main remit. In general policy section 10 is a good one.

Comment on this

A group could appeal to the Minister.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Minister may make such general policy——

Comment on this

A group might feel that the Minister should be informed of a certain matter.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, at any time. In addition, it is not five years; the review is in two years.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

It is effectively five years.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

By law it is two years, which is not out of the sky.

Comment on this

The commission is required to operate within the policy guidelines set out by Government - I sound like I am repeating myself - and we are giving the Minister specific power concerning regional airports.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy means State regional airports, yes.

Comment on this

I presume it means all regional airports.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No, they have to have one million passengers.

Comment on this

The ones that are affected are probably the State ones anyway.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

As of now.

Comment on this

One million in Knock.

Comment on this

The figure is 966,000.

Comment on this

If the commission does anything regarding charges or otherwise, this section gives the Minister the authority to be effective in ensuring Government policy is adhered to.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, Government policy would have to be adhered to.

Comment on this

Does the Minister see the point I am making?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do.

Comment on this

This would bring them back on line.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not have the authority to question what is given by law.

Comment on this

Unless it contravenes Government policy.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Exactly.

Comment on this

If he is wrong, the Minister has the authority to tell him the regulator he is wrong and he will have to correct himself.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

If it is against Government policy.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

If the charge is excessive and, therefore, contravenes Government policy, it would seem in those circumstances——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Government policy is not laid down——

Comment on this

We do not want to give the Minister back the job of setting an example. That is not what we are trying to do.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Exactly. I accept that but section 10 is a good one which arose out of a Seanad debate.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned 17%.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is for aeronautical revenue - airport charges account for 17% of revenues for Aer Rianta.

Comment on this

What is the main cost?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

There are shops, car parking and other ancillary matters.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Car parks are very profitable.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

A figure of 17% is amazing.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms. O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Does that relate to one airport?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is Aer Rianta. I remember when the IEA invited the former secretary of the Department of Aviation as a guest speaker in the summer - Senator Taylor-Quinn and I heard his speech - he told us that ours were the lowest charges in Europe and he could not understand that Aer Rianta was getting only 17% in charges. I am saying so before anyone starts to roar and shout at me.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is a meaningless figure because, for example, car parking charges may be extraordinarily high.

Comment on this