Aviation Regulation Bill, 2000 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 499–751 of 1,252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.
No. 24 of 2000 ›
Amendment No. 19 is consequential on amendment No. 17 and these amendments may be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 8, subsection (4), line 47, after "commissioner" to insert "or deputy commissioner".
We have gone into great detail setting out how the commissioner will be appointed, the qualifications required and so on. However, we go on to suggest that the deputy commissioner will not have to go through any procedures and the Minister will be able to nominate an official as deputy commissioner who will have the same powers as the commissioner about whom we are going to a lot of bother.
Comment on this
They will be equal. Etain Doyle and Tom Reid are examples, but when I mention names it is just to help make a point. When the three people are appointed it will not be the case that one will be above the other two - there will be no primus inter pares.
Comment on this
There will be no deputy commissioner. The provision refers to a situation where someone would be away. There will not be a commissioner, a deputy commissioner and an assistant deputy commissioner. There will be three commissioners. It is wrong to refer to a head commissioner. The commissioner may have to go away and he or she will appoint a deputy commissioner for the period of his or her absence. It could be staff.
Comment on this
That is my concern. We will go to a lot of trouble to select a commissioner and are setting out in law the parameters regarding the position. There are a lot of rules and regulations. However, the Minister, or perhaps the commissioner, can then appoint someone, I presume at the drop of a hat.
Comment on this
The person appointed could be there for a long time. He or she could be there for a year.
Comment on this
Section 13 outlines the purpose and role of a deputy commissioner, that is, he or she acts in loco of the commissioner in certain circumstances. The deputy commissioner would be selected from the staff and not recruited by the Civil Service. It would be one of the three commissioners or a member of the staff.
Comment on this
He or she is likely to be one of the officials transferred from the Department as they will be the most knowledgeable people available.
Comment on this
All officials remain civil servants when they go to these regulatory offices. There is a little trouble about that.
Comment on this
That makes it worse because they will not be in any way involved in the industry. The person appointed cannot have anything to do with an airline for five years and so on. That is a later amendment. However, the deputy commissioner, who could be in charge for a year if the commissioner is ill, does not need to have qualifications. If there is to be a deputy commissioner, he or she should have the same qualifications and the same rules and regulations should apply to him or her.
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct because the three commissioners will be the same in that none of them will be the top dog. When we reach the stage where there are three commissioners they will be equal. The commission at present comprises only one person.
Comment on this
My amendment would have the effect of stipulating that a person should not be appointed as a commissioner or deputy commissioner unless the Civil Service Commissioners, after holding a competition on behalf of the commission, had selected him or her for appointment as a commissioner or deputy commissioner.
Comment on this
This issue does not matter at present because there will only be one person involved. However, when the commission is increased to three persons——
Comment on this
What if he is ill for six months? Someone else will have to be appointed, but he or she cannot be a civil servant.
Comment on this
The section states:
The Commission shall designate a member of its staff as a deputy member of the Commission . . . who shall assume and carry out with the authority of the Commission all of the functions of the Commission in the absence of the commissioners or when the membership of the Commission is vacant.
Comment on this
Section 11 contains a long list of stipulations regarding the commissioner. However, in the case of someone who will take over from the commissioner and who will have full authority——
Comment on this
I accept the Deputy's point but I thought he was talking about something different. We have outlined stipulations regarding the commission. I thought the Deputy was suggesting the deputy commissioner would be second in charge. He is not suggesting so. I accept the Deputy's point but the commissioner will not recruit the deputy commissioner to take charge while he or she is not available. The three commissioners will be equal.
Comment on this
Would it not be a good idea for the three commissioners to have a deputy? If there are to be deputies they should be as qualified as the people for whom they are deputising.
Comment on this
I know the point the Deputy is getting at but it is different from what I thought he was referring to. I thought he was referring to a hierarchical structure.
Comment on this
This is not an easy matter to address and my amendments would create complications for the Minister as she would not just be appointing a commissioner but a commissioner and a deputy commissioner.
Comment on this
I will withdraw amendments Nos. 17 and 19, but I may table them again to facilitate further discussion.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 8, subsection (4), lines 48 and 49, to delete "on behalf of the Commission".
This is a technical amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 9, subsection (7)(a), to delete line 10 and substitute the following:
"date specified therein or upon receipt of the letter by the Minister, whichever is the later, and".
This is a technical amendment regarding resignations.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 9, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following subsections:
"(8) Where the chairperson of the Commission ceases to be a commissioner he or she shall also thereupon cease to be chairperson of the Commission.
(9) The chairperson of the Commission may at any time resign his or her office as chairperson by letter addressed to the Minister and the resignation shall take effect from the date specified therein or upon receipt of the letter by the Minister, whichever is the later.".
Comment on this
We are not doing that, I am only asking for the best of intentions. We will do our best.
Comment on this
A person employed in an airport or by an airline could be very well suited to the job of commissioner.
Comment on this
What if the chief executive of Ryanair applied for the job? Surely they would carry over a residual interest in their former employer's business.
Comment on this
I am seeking to safeguard against such a situation arising. I thought the proposal contained in the amendment was relatively standard.
Comment on this
It is not contained in any other legislation. There was a provision in regard to people not being able to carry over leave. I am not particularly opposed to the Deputy's suggestion but I think it would be very difficult to enforce.
Comment on this
It is certainly a long time. People move from one job to another more quickly now than in the past and I feel such a provision would be challenged were it included in the Bill.
Comment on this
He came from the Competition Authority which is another body entirely and so he would not be affected.
Comment on this
If we leave it open to people from Aer Rianta or one of the airlines to apply for this position, they will essentially be poachers turned gamekeepers.
Comment on this
Section 17(1) on declarations of interests states:
On his or her offer of appointment, each commissioner shall make a declaration in writing of his or her interests to the Minister, in such form as the Minister . . . may specify.
That would apply in much the same way as Members of the Oireachtas declare their interests and update them on an annual basis.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that she received advice that there were legal difficulties with the amendment.
Comment on this
When the telecommunications regulation Bill was being introduced, an attempt was made to exclude civil servants from applying for the position of regulator. I argued successfully against that as I felt the exclusion of a particular category of person could have given rise to constitutional difficulties. The position here is different in that the people referred to would have a direct interest in this area.
Comment on this
Section 18(1) states:
Where a commissioner . . . has a pecuniary interest or other beneficial interest in, or material to, any matter which falls to be considered by the Commission, he or she shall
(a) disclose to the Commission . . .
(b) neither influence nor seek to influence a decision . . .
(c) take no part in any consideration of the matter . . .
Comment on this
I believe this would be challenged. I will seek a precise opinion from the Attorney General's office because we just made informal soundings.
Comment on this
It would have to be of a serious nature. It would not be because I did not like what he put in the report.
Comment on this
There are two ways one could be chastised because, under the section, the Minister has control over remuneration which must be agreed with the Minister for Finance. Effectively, the Minister could remove one by reducing the level of remuneration. This could make it undesirable for one to seek the position or to remain in it.
Comment on this
If, for instance, he did not behave in the way expected in relation to Government policy, would that be a reason for removing the person from office?
Comment on this
Section 11(7)(b) reads, “be removed from office by the Minister if, in his or her opinion, the member has become incapable through ill-health of effectively performing his or her duties or for stated misbehaviour. . . ”. That would need to be rather serious.
Comment on this
If the issue was detrimental to an area, such as the one about which we are concerned, could you remove a person for that reason if it was not in compliance with the Minister's policy?
Comment on this
We are now going a step further. First, there was the issue of whether I would question his report and now whether I might sack him.
Comment on this
Why was it thought necessary? If one is convicted of a criminal offence or something of that nature, one could remove him, but this relates to behaviour. What was the thinking behind this?
Comment on this
I do not know what the misbehaviour would be. Clearly it would have to be of a serious nature.
Comment on this
If, for instance, he were to make a decision in relation to charges which would mean people would not have employment or would have a negative effect on an airport, would that be considered misbehaviour?
Comment on this
Section 10 lays down that the Minister may give such general policy directions. I think that is included as a caveat. I do not know what serious misbehaviour would be.
Comment on this
I recall a chief executive of a State company being effectively sacked during the period I was in Government. I believe he should not have been sacked for what would now be considered a very minor misbehaviour, if even that.
Comment on this
I thought the authority was sacked by a Minister at one stage. Was there a reason for including this?
Comment on this
Is there any other legislation where there is an established understanding about stated misbehaviour?
Comment on this
I presume this was the intention. This particular individual is now appointed to the position.
Comment on this
No, but he would know that will have to be the case. That cannot be done until the Bill becomes an Act.
Comment on this
Suppose the man or woman in this position was a director of an air company and this came to light, would that be regarded as misbehaviour?
Comment on this
Not now because he is not taking the formal decisions. When this becomes an Act he will submit his statement of interests. That will then be scrutinised. Deputy Daly asked about stated misbehaviour. I do not know what this would be.
Comment on this
That is not satisfactory. I would like to pursue a matter which Deputy Daly raised. We need to know what the intention is.
Comment on this
We need to know what the Minister intends by including this in the section. Before we pass the legislation, we need to know the Minister's intention in this regard.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. What is the intention of the section? What type of misbehaviour is the Minister talking about? Is she talking about criminal or moral misbehaviour or breaches of Government policy?
Comment on this
We spoke earlier about whether there would be a more appropriate place for an amendment in relation to the deputy commissioner. If we are to have clear instructions about the commissioner's responsibilities, policy objectives and himself personally, the same criterion should apply to the deputy commissioner.
Comment on this
Perhaps section 13 would be a more appropriate place to make the amendment. I tabled the amendment to section 11.
Comment on this
There is no reference to "tender" in this section. Will it be included in the regulations? Does it need to be in the legislation?
Comment on this
It is over a certain amount. I think the figure is £100,000, but I will get the proper figure for the Deputy. If it is less than that the Department can decide to allocate it, but if it is over that amount, it has to go to tender.
Comment on this
No, but my Department exercises full approval over everything. This is done in conjunction with the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I have no problem with the provision but in certain cases the advice may be available from some of the people with whom he is working.
Comment on this
Yes. If the advice is already available from, say, Aer Rianta or another authority, it may be preferable to use it rather than bring in consultants.
Comment on this
I am nervous of the new reality in Departments, quangos and the new bodies we are setting up——
Comment on this
One might need one in the case of the hamburger. I want to put down a marker that the excellent staff working full time in these places give the information and, very often, an analysis of it to the consultants who write up the paper and get a big fee for it. I saw this when I was in a corner of the Minister's Department and I have seen it in other places since. The staff did most of the work and the consultants got paid. They came up with the exact same results as the staff.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that Civil Service advice is sound and it has the experience and wisdom. I am not saying that because civil servants are here, but it is what I have found. Sometimes a matter may be very specific and one would need technical facts etc. In general the information in the file from a civil servant is sound.
Comment on this
There is another reason, that is, to cover people's tails. Because a consultant said it, it can be a stick with which to beat the final decision-maker.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 10, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) The Ethics in Public Office Act, 1995, shall apply to the Commission and the commissioners and to such staff of the Commission as are of Principal grade or its equivalent and higher.".
I have no difficulty with the section as it is drafted, but I do not understand why we are providing in legislation that a code of conduct will be drawn up for public servants, which effectively they are in one form or other, when the Ethics Act is in place and it should apply to them. This gives them an automatic code of conduct.
Comment on this
Is my amendment No. 27 being taken in conjunction with this amendment? I have no problem withdrawing my amendment if this is the appropriate place to insert this provision.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 11, subsection (2), line 5, after "consultant" to insert "and adviser".
The chief parliamentary counsel has advised that the words "and adviser" be inserted after the word "consultant" in section 17(2).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 11, subsection (4) (b), line 23, to delete “context” and substitute “content”.
This is to correct a drafting error.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
In page 12, subsection (7), lines 4 and 5, to delete "(within the meaning of the Act of 1998)".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 28. Amendment No. 30 is cognisant. Is it agreed to take both amendments together? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 12, subsection (2) (a), line 45, to delete “her’s” and substitute “her”.
Comment on this
I think the subsection as drafted at present is correct. The word "his" is possessive and plural.
Comment on this
My English text guru did his best to get me to table an amendment to this provision but I refused and he gave me pages of an explanation as to why the Minister's amendment is wrong.
Comment on this
The section states:
For the purposes of this section, but without prejudice to the generality of subsection (1), a person shall not be regarded as having a beneficial interest in, or material to, any matter, by reason only of an interest of his or her’s or of any company . . .
The Minister is deleting "her's" and substituting "her", which is wrong.
Comment on this
I will get that for the Deputy. Does the Deputy want the explanation for the whole section?
Comment on this
The section outlines the measures to be followed where a commissioner or staff member or anyone engaged by the commission has an interest, pecuniary or beneficial, in any matter that is to be considered by the commission. In essence, the section provides that any such person shall disclose the nature of that interest and that he or she shall take no part in decisions or meetings relating to the concept.
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 29:
In page 13, subsection (2), between lines 6 and 7, to insert the following:
"(c) he or she or any member of his orher household is in the process of acquiringland or property to which such a matter relates.”.
Effectively we are talking here about disclosure of interests, anything that might present a conflict of interest. We are setting down that, for the purposes of this section but without prejudice to the generality of subsection (1), a person shall be regarded as having a beneficial interest if he or she or any member of his or her household, or any nominee of his or her's, is a member of a company other than a body which has a beneficial interest in, or material to, a matter referred to in that subsection, or if he or she or any member of his or her household is in partnership with or is in the employment of a person who has a beneficial interest in, or material to, such a matter. I am putting in another subsection, (c), that, in relation to possible land ownership, in other words, if he or she has acquired land or property in relation to this particular one——
Comment on this
The reason is clear. We are trying to exclude the possibility of conflict. As we know, there is at least one forum sitting in Dublin Castle, if not a second, which is concerned with interest in relation to lands and so on. I propose to insert "if he or she or any member of his or her household is in the process of acquiring land or property to which such a matter relates", in other words, that it would relate to property concerning the airport itself.
Comment on this
When we debated this matter in the Seanad, Senator Taylor-Quinn used the term "considering", "thinking of" or something like that. We had a long debate on that and we asked how anyone could know what they were thinking of, but this is more precise because they have entered into a relationship with a solicitor, land owner or whatever. I think it is correct because land adjacent to an airport would be extraordinarily valuable to that airport for development purposes. I will accept the amendment.
Comment on this
On the section, we are going to a lot of trouble and into much detail about the commissioner but we still have nothing inserted about a deputy commissioner or an assistant commissioner who will be able to do the same job.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean that the stipulation is put on the commissioner? That is what we had raised before lunch.
Comment on this
I am just making the point again that all this detail will apply to the commissioner. None of it will apply to the assistant commissioner.
Comment on this
That is a fair point, Chairman. If the commissioner suffered a minor stroke or something like that and was off duty for six months, with another person doing his or her job, all the painstaking criteria that we have built up for the employment of a commissioner would not be in place for the other person. I will certainly look at that. I will talk to the Deputy about it because I want to be clear on it. That is another "her's".
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 31:
In page 13, lines 36 to 38, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following:
"(2) The penalties for contravening this Act shall be as per section 7 of the Air Navigation and Transport (Amendment) Act, 1998.".
This amendment concerns the penalties formisuse of information. I am proposing to delete the existing penalties of £1,500, which are inadequate.
Comment on this
I believe a hefty penalty should be imposed on such people but advice on this amendment was formally sought from the Office of the Attorney General. The advice was that the Circuit Court penalty limit is suffice for the misdemeanour of the release of information. The penalty in regard to air navigation, which the Deputy is seeking, is for more serious crimes. The crime committed by somebody for which this would be the penalty would be a crime in connection with safety, which might imperil lives or whatever, and that would be an indictable offence, but this is the Circuit Court limit - is it £1,500?
Comment on this
That is deemed to be for the unauthorised release of information related to business, and we took the Attorney General's advice on it.
Comment on this
Section 7 of the Air Navigation and Transport (Amendment) Act, 1988, states that the penalty is £100,000, but we are not simply talking about information in relation to safety and safety considerations. We are talking about——
Comment on this
In the case of somebody in a position of responsibility, such as the individual in question, releasing confidential information which is of a highly sensitive and possibly valuable commercial interest, the fine of £1,500 seems to be derisory in the context of the potential damage to the interests of the airport and the potential gain to the individuals involved. It seems a trivial offence. A fine of £1,500 is what one would expect to be imposed on someone cautioned for making poitín.
Comment on this
Does that apply to the District Court or the Circuit Court? The advice is that there are degrees of crime, and that fine is appropriate to the offence of releasing unauthorised, confidential information.
Comment on this
The section states on summary conviction, which means it must relate to the District Court.
Comment on this
If we were dealing with particular categories of information, the fines could be calibrated accordingly, but we are talking about possibly very important commercially advantageous information on airlines. It is big business.
Comment on this
Yes. Is a similar provision included in the legislation covering the electricity regulator?
Comment on this
That is what I thought. There is a difference between doing something that imperils safety and lives, which is wrong. It is wrong to give confidential information, but it is not as serious as imperilling lives.
Comment on this
I will withdraw my amendment, but I ask the Minister to consider it for Report Stage.
Comment on this
He may be of the view that it is possible to have such a case tried in the Circuit Criminal Court.
Comment on this
We are dealing with vast commercial interests involving major potential gains which would arise from the release of sensitive information.
Comment on this
When one considers the enormous contracts, licences and vast amount of material involved in the electricity market, which, if not kept confidential, could result in enormous benefits or damage to firms that apply for licences, theoretically, it would be even more potentially beneficial if private information was given. Yet, we included a similar provision in the legislation covering the electricity regulator and in the ODTR Act, which covers an area involving major benefits arising from licences for transmission.
Comment on this
No, we studied all aspects and I specifically noted his advice. I can pass it on to the Deputy.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 33, 36, and 40 are cognate to amendment No. 32 and they may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 14, subsection (6), line 21, to delete "subsequent".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 35 is an alternative to amendment No. 34 and they may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:
In page 15, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) Such part of levy as is imposed on an airport authority shall be an incremental and identified sum which shall be charged in addition to such airport charges as may be payable.".
The operation of the levy to fund the regulator should be as transparent as the charges, and that is not the case unless he specifies to what purpose he will put the levy. If Aer Rianta has an income of £500 million per year and he decides its levy will be, for example, £2 million——