We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ENTERPRISE AND TRANSPORT

Aviation Regulation Bill, 2000 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.

Contributions 752–1,003 of 1,252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.

Bill Aviation Regulation Bill 2000
Enacted

No. 24 of 2000 ›

Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

It is also important for the body being levied to know where the levy is being applied, as it will be entitled to pass the levy on to its customers.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, somebody has to pay it.

Comment on this

The levy could be 5% on the drink in the bar or it could be on car parking charges, but Aer Rianta should know on what it is to be applied. It should be incremental and an identified sum. The regulator will do that in reverse when he applies the charges in the interests of transparency to ensure that people know what is charged, but when the levy is coming the other way, to pay him, he will be entitled, as the Bill stands, to take, for example, £2,000 out of a figure of £50,000.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

To support his office.

Comment on this

Yes. The amount would probably vary as a result of inclusion of this amendment, as there will be a cost involved in doing this.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes, the Deputy said it should be incremental.

Comment on this

Yes, it should be incremental and an identified sum.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

As Deputy Stagg said, the emphasis is being put on transparency to ensure everyone will know where the money is coming from and, from the point of view of passing it on, the regulator will be able to verify its source, the reason for it and to justify it. It should be transparent and incremental.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We talked about that, but I did not clarify my full thoughts on it. The Deputy wants the amount the regulator will charge to be transparent.

Comment on this

The amount he will charge and the areas he will charge. There are various economic interests from which the levy will be derived.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I will be honest and say I am not clear on this.

Comment on this

Does the Minister need more time to consider it?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. I discussed it yesterday and again today, but my thoughts are not clear on it. The purpose of wanting to have it identified in terms of where it will go is fair enough.

Comment on this

One of the reasons for that is to ensure that it can be passed on fairly and that not more than what has been derived by way of levy is passed on.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. That is what we said this morning. I thought that might be the objective of the amendment. If it is agreeable to the committee, I will consider a similar amendment if tabled for Report Stage or I might table an amendment on it.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

The Minister has taken the opportunity to revise her thinking, which is welcome. In doing so, she should take cognisance of the anxiety there would be about future investment and other decisions that might be made on that, even if there was current investment, the type of levies that would be applied and whether they would be proportionately linked to passenger numbers and airport services or capital based. Levies might end up as penal for both Cork and Shannon and, at the same time, become less of a factor——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No, he will use the levy for his office.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The levy Deputy Carey refers to is only the levy for the running of his office.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

How will the levy be related to airports? Will he charge it to the company and will the expenditure be proportionately applied?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The levy is for Aer Rianta and the IAA; the two companies will pay the levy. However, this levy relates to his office. Is the Deputy referring to any other levies?

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I have undertaken to refer back to the Deputy.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

There should be proportionality in the allocation of charges. The commissioner will eventually read the transcript of this debate and I am seeking the equitable distribution of the levy charge across the company.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Aer Rianta will pay it.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

——and the IAA.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I understand what the Minister is saying but I am trying to make another point.

Comment on this

The Minister will reconsider the matter.

Comment on this

It is for the estimated operating cost of the commission.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is right.

Comment on this

If I understand Deputy Carey, he is referring to the charges, which are being dealt with separately. They will be done on the basis of passenger numbers through airports.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

There is a determination of how many passengers——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Aer Rianta is dealt with as a company. However, this is about the levy for the office of the commissioner, to furnish him with enough money to run the office. Both Deputy Higgins and Deputy Stagg want it to be shown that this is what the money is for.

Comment on this

How it will be collected is what concerns Deputy Carey.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I have not studied that enough. The idea seems fine but I think I am missing something in it.

Comment on this

It confers an ability to pass it on to where it is due.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

What Deputy Stagg said and the formula in his amendment are important.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 36:

In page 16, subsection (6), line 7, to delete "subsequent".

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I move amendmentNo. 37:

In page 16, between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following subsection:

"(7) The Commission shall ensure that its own costs of operations are kept to a minimum and are not excessive.".

We are talking about levies, costs and recovery of costs. The amendment provides that the commission should ensure that its costs of operations are kept to a minimum and are not excessive. I am sure the Department of Finance has laid down this guideline for everybody.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is not the intention that the commission would make profits. The amendment is good housekeeping so I will accept it.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 38:

In page 17, subsection (2), line 6, to delete "other".

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Amendment agreed to.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Question proposed: "That section 27, as amended, stand part of the Bill."

Comment on this

We have dealt with this already. Will it be possible to table parliamentary questions on the operation of the commission and will they be answered?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Questions on the duties of the commission laid out in the Bill are not answered. It is Etain Doyle's job, for example, to deal with deflector issues. I was lucky, she was appointed two days before me and she took up the deflector issue. That was her job then and I did not answer for it.

Comment on this

The Dáil reform committee is deliberating on these issues at present. One of its recommendations is that Ministers would reply in the House to questions about State agencies, even though they do not have the responsibility they previously had for them. Deputies could get the information the Minister mentions.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Would a regulator be a State agency?

Comment on this

I am not sure.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy means Aer Lingus, VHI or the like.

Comment on this

They certainly will be included, regardless of whether the regulator is. The Deputy makes a good point. Maybe there could be some method of asking questions other than bringing the regulator before a committee once a year.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Deputies from all parties are complaining about this. When we were in Opposition we regularly did so. Deputies ask questions and sometimes I wince to see the answer I put forward which states that I have no operational responsibility for why something is or is not happening. It is correct that one does not have operational responsibility but in a way one has Dáil responsibility. I did not know this was being considered. Is there a Dáil reform committee?

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Does it involve the Whips?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is the committee that suggested a Member could call in the Dáil during the morning for the Minister for Public Enterprise, for example, to answer questions.

Comment on this

Not only that, we recommend that committees would be able, at two to six hours' notice, to request the Minister to come before them. That would happen during the committee week.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is a good idea.

Comment on this

It should be pointed out that the current Minister for Public Enterprise has a good record in getting around the rule whereby she is not allowed to answer questions by simply answering. I thank her for that and hope she keeps it up.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Aer Rianta will be within the regulator's remit. Will Aer Rianta be required to draw up its accounts in the manner the commission or the regulator requires?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

It is not possible at present to see a proper analysis of accounts. It is important in the context of, for example, Cork and Shannon where developments are taking place that we see exactly what our obligations are, what the write off is for new buildings and capital expenditure etc. This analysis must be available.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

This provision empowers the commission to require the separation of accounts in respect of any activity regulated by the commission. This ensures that the commissioner has access to all necessary and relevant information in order to reach the appropriate decision in the charges determination.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

With regard to my earlier proposal of a reduction in charges, the Minister gave a figure for Aer Rianta of 17%. However, that may not necessarily be the balance in the Irish context in so far as the traffic flows at Shannon and Cork would be different from the traffic flows at Dublin Airport and the percentages may vary as a result. Does the Minister expect the commissioner to carry out a full analysis of it?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. He is required by law to get the full facts to enable him to make an analysis and, in turn, a determination.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Companies such as Aer Lingus had a similar power and it bought hotels in America and set up other companies. Must the commissioner have this information?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. He will have all the information. I understand the Deputy's point, but he will require all the information.

Comment on this

I understand the regulated and unregulated business must be separated.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy referring to the single tail concept or the non-single tail concept?

Comment on this

It is the single tail concept. The business regulated in Shannon and Dublin and owned by the same company is not required to be separated in the accounts. However, Aer Rianta, for example, must separate Warsaw in its accounts.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

All that must be taken into account.

Comment on this

They must be separated.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

It is important that they are separated because the charges and what is covered should only relate to the regulated business. If there will be a supposition on the basis of income from Warsaw, there should be no charges at Dublin Airport. It is most important that they are separated.

As I said to various representatives I met - and I am glad it is included - it is also in the interests of the smaller airports within the State, such as Cork and Shannon, to be in the same bookkeeping system as Dublin. If they were separated they would be at risk. There is no requirement for them to be separated because they are regulated, but they might be separated.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

However, they do not have to be separated.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is correct.

Comment on this

It is possible; it is not excluded. I presume it is a cleverly designed section.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

They are different ends.

Comment on this

I would be fearful that my colleague might press for something that would have a negative effect.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I agree.

Comment on this

I make that point in the full knowledge that that would not be his intention.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

There is some interest in having the office established outside Dublin and I encourage the Minister to consider the possibility of adding a provision under which the regulator would bear in mind Government policy on decentralisation, the aim of which is to relocate 10,000 civil servants outside Dublin.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

There is a change on that front.

Comment on this

Slow change.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

In terms of change, the only information I have is what I read in the newspapers. Deputy Carey asked about the official line. The provision allows the commission to make its own arrangements as necessary in relation to its offices. Given the difficulties at present in relation to office space, particularly in the city centre, and the competing demands on the asset list of the Office of Public Works, it was considered practical to allow the commission to deal with those matters itself.

Comment on this

Section 22 states that offices may be made available to the commission on request. The Minister said the commissioner is already located in Mount Street.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I understand that is only an interim measure.

Comment on this

Is he considering buying Aras de Valera?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is in Mount Street too.

Comment on this

The commissioner is already in Mount Street but I presume he will not remain there.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We think that is of a temporary nature.

Comment on this

Did the Department lease that office to him under section 22?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is an office of the Office of Public Works. The Deputy wants me to tell him to get out of town.

Comment on this

I want him to keep in mind that the Government has a policy of decentralisation.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That part is correct. The Government has a policy of decentralisation.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister could add a provision to the section under which the commissioner should bear in mind Government policy on decentralisation.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That would mean that he must decentralise and I cannot tell him to do so. I take the Deputy's point because the Government has a policy on decentralisation. I will communicate with the commissioner and outline the Government's policy on decentralisation. However, I will not put that in the legislation.

Comment on this

Previous Bills used to state that head offices had to be located in Dublin.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I do not remember such provisions.

Comment on this

Old legislation used to contain such provisions. Perhaps the Minister could consider the other point of view and state that such premises "may" be located outside Dublin. It would be a hint.

Comment on this

As the Minister is aware, the Aviation Authority's head office is located in Shannon.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

There is a building available there and it could move in immediately.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We must also bear in mind the five civil servants. They may not want to relocate.

Comment on this

Some of the people will be from the Aviation Authority.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

No, the current position is that they are from the Department. I will refrain from putting such a provision in the legislation, but I will say it to the commissioner.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 39, 41 and 42 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 39:

In page 18, subsection (3), line 11, to delete "order" and substitute "regulation".

These textual amendments were suggested by the Parliamentary Counsel.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 40:

In page 18, subsection (3), line 12, to delete "subsequent".

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 41:

In page 18, subsection (3), line 13, to delete "order" where it firstly occurs and substitute "regulation".

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 42:

In page 18, subsection (3), line 13, to delete "order or".

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Will the Minister give the explanation for the section?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I did not read the explanations for the amendments, but they are most revealing. The section outlines the scope of the regulatory regime in so far as airports are concerned. It provides that airports with annual passenger numbers of 1 million will be regulated. This excludes Kerry, Sligo and Knock Airports. A total of 1 million passengers must be going through the airport.

Comment on this

How many did they have?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Knock had up to 200,000 in July 1997. It would be approximately the same. The half yearly figures show that Donegal had 12,000 passengers, Galway had 56,000 passengers, Kerry had 85,000 passengers, Sligo had 13,000 passengers and Waterford had 9,000 passengers.

Comment on this

Effectively, under this section, the Minister can bring in more airports by reducing the figure.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is one million, but I could bring it down.

Comment on this

The Minister could reduce it to 500,000 and bring in Knock Airport.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I could reduce it to 500,000 or 250,000. As it stands, it is one million, but it can be altered if necessary.

Comment on this

Enterprises will not want to be regulated.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

They will not want to be regulated, although they will want money.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 43:

In page 18, lines 16 to 18, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:

"(1) In this section and section 33, ’determination’ means a determination under subsection (2).”.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I move amendmentNo. 44:

In page 18, subsection (4), line 31, to delete "may" and substitute "shall".

Deputy Stagg and I have tabled the same amendment.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That is a surprise.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

We are talking about the welfare and long-term stability of Shannon and Cork Airports. Subsection (4) states:

Where it appears to the Commission that two or more airports are either-

(a) managed by the same airport authority, or

(b) that they are owned by the same person and operate as a group of airports whose activities are co-ordinated by that person, any determination in relation to any one of those airports may be made by reference to the aggregate of amounts levied by way of airport charges at that airport and amounts so levied at the other airports.

We want to change that to "shall be made by reference to the aggregate of amounts levied by way of airport charges at that airport and amounts so levied at the other airports". It is important from the point of view of the three State owned airports that they are regulated as a unit. This is required in terms of market stability and the regional development of policy. Cork and Shannon Airports have smaller volumes of traffic than Dublin Airport. Regulating the three airports as a single unit will ensure that the airport charges at Cork and Shannon Airports are competitive with respect to Dublin. The relative scale of an expansion programme can be quite large in comparison to existing facilities. The smaller airports, therefore, need to be part of a larger group for the purposes of regulation to even out the charge implications arising from this type of development. That is the reason we tabled this amendment which we ask the Minister to accept. It is important from the point of view of the welfare and long-term stability and viability of Shannon and Cork Airports.

Comment on this

Deputy Higgins has made a good argument for this amendment. It is crucial for the development of Cork and Shannon Airports and for regional development that there is not a discretion. If there is a discretion, it could lead to all types of possibilities. I have no idea why the discretion was built in in the first instance. I urge the Minister to accept this amendment and to replace the word "may" with "shall". It would not be detrimental to do so. I see a lot of danger in leaving it open and having a discretion. There is nothing positive in doing that.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

This provision is a discretionary power to the regulator to regulate the company as a group or as a separate entity. He is not obliged to regulate the three airports separately. The Deputies are saying he should be obliged to regulate the three of them together rather than looking at whether the glass is half full or half empty. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is important from the standpoint of good regulation that the commission will be given sufficient flexibility to address the charges issue as each examination of the situation dictates. One can look at this both ways. The Deputies are saying that the smaller numbers at the smaller airports mean that Dublin must be subsidising Shannon and Cork Airports. We all know that must be happening because of passenger numbers and the general running of airports. I ask the Deputies to table a joint amendment again on Report Stage

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I accept that.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is an important point. If Shannon Airport was told to be a stand alone operation, there would be difficulties. Perhaps the same is true for Cork Airport. However, there is a bigger operation in Shannon and the numbers are greater. I ask the Deputies to table the amendment again on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

We will withdraw the amendment and retable it on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

The Minister should remember that the national airline acceded to pressure from smaller airlines to compete on a route and then increased its charges when the competition was exhausted.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I presume the Deputy means the fares.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

Yes. Aer Lingus has continually done this. It has used Shannon Airport in that way. We are concerned about the difficulties of operating an airport without a major catchment area. The Minister is saying she accepts that the regulator would have this understanding.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I said the amendment will be resubmitted on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I move amendmentNo. 45:

In page 18, subsection (5)(a), line 36, after “for a” to insert “minimum”.

Section 32(5)(a) states that a “determination shall be in force for a period of 5 years”. I want to include the word “minimum” so it states that a “determination shall be in force for a minimum period of 5 years”.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It could go up to 25 years after that. I would not be inclined to accept the amendment. Five years is a significant amount of time before there would be another determination. If we include the word "minimum", what would be the maximum? It could be 20 or 25 years.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

It is five years at present.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

The word "minimum" is probably superfluous.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Yes. It is five years now. There will be a review in two years and a fresh determination in five years.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 46:

In page 19, subsection (7)(b), lines 13 and 14, to delete “circulated” and substitute “circulating”.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 47:

In page 19, subsection (7)(c), line 17, to delete “order” and substitute “determination”.

This is a technical amendment. The term "determination" is the correct one and is used in all relevant provisions.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 48. Amendment No. 1 to amendment No. 48 is related. Amendment No. 1 to amendment No. 48 and amendment No. 48 may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 48:

In page 19, subsection (12), line 36, after "State" to insert "or by such other means as the Commission may determine".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1 to amendment No. 48:

To delete "or" and substitute "and".

If the word "or" is included, the commission may dispense with newspaper advertisements. That is highly undesirable.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy referring to new ways, such as the Internet?

Comment on this

Yes. Newspaper advertisements are the best format. I remember the same argument was made during the discussions on the Planning Act. It should be left in the newspapers as well.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I accept the Deputy's amendment to my amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:

In page 20, subsection (14)(a)(i), line 2 to delete “or” and substitute “and”.

This is a similar amendment but is in a completely different context. Section 32(14)(a) states:

The Commission may on or after the expiration of a period of 2 years after the making of a determination-

(i) if it considers that there are substantial grounds for so doing, or [I suggest "and" rather than "or"]

(ii) at the request of an airport authority or user concerned in respect of the determination,

If the Bill states "or" any user for which we have not got a definition - it could be a taxi driver——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Are we taking this amendment with amendment No. 48?

Comment on this

No, this is separate. This is amendment No. 49 in the name of Deputy Stagg.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It says here amendmentsNos. 48 and 49.

Comment on this

No. Amendment No. 48 and——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 49——

Comment on this

Amendment No. 1 to the amendment and amendment No. 48 were taken together. We dealt with amendment No. 1, which amended the Minister's amendment. That was agreed. This is amendment No. 49, in the name of Deputy Stagg, to section 32.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy wants to delete "or" and insert "and".

Comment on this

If we leave the word "or" there, it would allow anybody to demand a two year review. Such a request from anybody at all is now possible but it would only be accepted if the commission considers that there are substantial grounds for doing so. If one takes out the word "or" and substitutes "and", then one has the request and that together.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

If it considers that there are substantial grounds for so doing but the Deputy is saying "and" at the request of an airport authority or user concerned in respect of the determination.

Comment on this

If we leave the word "or" on its own, every two years there will be demand for review and people will be entitled to it. They will have to get it because they are two separate conditions.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Deputy Stagg is linking the two.

Comment on this

I am linking the two with the word "and". The commission would have to say there are substantial grounds for doing so and have a request.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We looked at that.

Comment on this

The Minister should be able to get over that - a request with substantial grounds or substantial grounds without a request. The Minister needs to rewrite that. With the word "or", the smallest user of the airport could insist.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That was not our intention.

Comment on this

I know but that is——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Looking at it now, it could be the outcome.

Comment on this

If the Minister could redraft that piece——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We will come forward with something ourselves.

Comment on this

Essentially what I am saying is that there should be substantial grounds——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I know exactly what the Deputy means.

Comment on this

——and a request or substantial grounds.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy means in both cases.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 50:

In page 20, subsection (15), line 12, before "charges" to insert "airport".

It should read "airport charges" instead of "charges".

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 51:

In page 20, subsection (15), lines 12 and 13, to delete "at an airport to which this section applies".

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

The question of an appeal——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We are coming to that.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

——has been subsumed. There is no mention of——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We are coming to the appeals section.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

When we talked about definitions and so on at the beginning, we were told we would move on to airport charges. There is no mention of appeal in regard to airport charges.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We are coming to an appeals section.

Comment on this

We are grinding slowly to it.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is in section 38.

Comment on this

We have to deal with section 33 in the meantime.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins Mayo Fine Gael

I move amendmentNo. 52:

In page 20, before section 33, to insert the following new section:

"33.-The cost of meeting international obligations shall be included when assessing and setting the level of airport charges.".

We should look at the full picture from the point of view of the obligations made nationally and internationally.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I think that is already in the Bill.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

It is further on.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Section 33(i) states: "such international obligations as are relevant to its functions."

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. Higgins (Mayo) Fine Gael

I have an amendment to that stating "national and international".

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We will accept that when we come to it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

In page 20, between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following:

"(b) environmental protection and noise pollution reduction and the desirability of structuring charges so as to reduce noise,”.

We have set down regulatory objectives in this section. I see it as vitally important that we would use the charges, or system, to ensure environmental protection, particularly noise level protection, at our airports. This is seemingly a standard use of charges internationally. There are lesser charges for aircraft with lesser noise.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Did Deputy Stagg take this from the UK Bill?

Comment on this

No, but there is a reference in the UK Bill to it. They have it and they have it in Europe. It is a general use measure where there is regulation - special consideration is given to low noise craft. They enjoy positive discrimination. It is something we need to look at because this will be the only opportunity we will have for a long time to do so. With the increased volumes of traffic at Dublin and the other airports, noise pollution is a real issue. My colleague, who is here——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

He came in when he heard the Deputy speak on this.

Comment on this

I have a number of things to do today.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Deputy Sargent is right; this is his issue.

Comment on this

I am glad Deputy Sargent is here.

Comment on this

I am listening carefully Deputy Stagg - keep going.

Comment on this

There is an opportunity now that we are putting a system in place for arriving at charges and for a regulator to regulate them to look at environmental protection and noise pollution and at how they can be positively dealt with in the context of charges.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Stagg for having the foresight to put down this amendment. On the Dublin Airport issue in particular, the Minister will have, if she has not had already, representations, particularly in relation to the planned runway and the effects on Portmarnock and, previously, the effects on the St. Margaret's area in the other direction. There is no doubt that if the airport is to be an acceptable neighbour, it will have to be very clearly stated that residents in the area are not the victims of that development. We had that problem in the past when the EPA Bill managed to get through the Houses of the Oireachtas and avoid, or omit, consideration of aircraft noise in its noise pollution section. The reason given at the time was the strategic interests and not getting in the way of those strategic interests and so forth. Nowadays, it would not be acceptable to override people's basic quality of life on that basis. We should look at this to keep us in line with other European countries which are far stricter in many of their airports——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Under environmental legislation.

Comment on this

——when it comes to night time flying, certain restrictions on noise levels and considerations of that nature.

I speak of Dublin Airport from personal experience. The flight paths could be more strictly adhered to. There seems to be a tendency to come in using visual tracking rather than coming in along——

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

That came up on Second Stage.

Comment on this

It did and I am not going to rehash Second Stage. I want to ensure Deputy Stagg's amendment has the best chance of being accepted. If it can be accepted at this stage, many people would be very appreciative.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I thank both Deputies. Deputy Stagg speaks of environmental protection, noise pollution reduction and the desirability of structuring charges so as to reduce noise. Is the Deputy saying that charges, as determined, should embrace whatever it would cost to reduce noise?

Comment on this

I am saying that people with low noise aircraft should be rewarded with lower charges and there should be positive discrimination in respect of operators who protect the environment and reduce noise pollution.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Where did the Deputy get the wording for the amendment?

Comment on this

We made it up ourselves.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It is essentially for the Environmental Protection Agency. Why does the Deputy not table amendments to that Bill?

Comment on this

I have tried. This is an opportunity.

Comment on this

I understand that when other airports in Europe talk about regulatory objectives, they include this.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I asked someone if this was in UK and in other legislation. They did not know and they are going to find out for me.

Comment on this

I would be happy to withdraw the amendment at this stage.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It makes sense if one can, even in a small way, encourage the use of less noisy aircraft. Is that not what the Deputy is saying?

Comment on this

Yes, less noisy aircraft. There are other environmental protection issues at an airport which I have not identified.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

We will undertake to look at similar UK legislation and that of another country in Europe to see if they have a provision like that or similar to it. They have all been down the path of regulation.

Comment on this

This is important for the public.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It takes away from the purely mechanical aspect of regulation. We will check that and come back to Deputy Stagg informally between now and Report Stage and we will see what the next stage should be.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 54 was taken with amendment No. 12. Amendment No. 12 was withdrawn.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 54:

In page 20, between lines 28 and 29, to insert the following:

"(d) the contribution of the airport to the region in which it is located,”.

I withdrew amendment No. 12 because it was wrong. I did not withdraw amendment No. 54.

Comment on this

The Deputy discussed it.

Comment on this

I did not really discuss it. These amendments bear no relationship to one another. I do not know how they were lumped together. This is a very important amendment for the regional areas. The contribution of the airport to the region in which it is located should be in the regulatory objectives. I would appreciate a little latitude, Chairman. We should have, as a regulatory objective, the contribution of the airport to the region in which it is located.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Stagg looks at section 10, it states: "The Minister may give such general policy directions (including directions in respect of the contribution of airports to the regions in which they are located)".

Comment on this

Yes. That is good there, and we talked about it for a long time. When we come to the regulatory objectives, it is appropriate to state it again so it is not lost.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It has already been done but there is no harm repeating it.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 55 in the name of Deputy Stagg is related to amendment No. 56 and both may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:

In page 20, paragraph (d), line 30, after “other” to insert “airport”.

Section 33(d) should read: “the level of the income of the airport authority from airport charges at the airport and other airport revenue earned.”

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy want to insert after the word "other" the word "airport"?

Comment on this

Yes, otherwise one could take into account revenue from the Great Southern Hotels, for example. I think it was intended to state "airport" there. It should read "the level of income of the airport from airport charges at the airport and other airport revenue earned by the authority".

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is saying at airports rather than at any other activity in which it might be engaged.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

What about their overseas investment?

Comment on this

I do not know whether they can touch them anyway.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The way they are set up -

Comment on this

No, I do not think one can take them into account. In deciding the charge for an airplane flying out of Dublin Airport, the commissioner will not be able to say Aer Rianta has £2 million from duty free sales in Moscow which it will dock from what it will get for running the airport in Dublin, otherwise all of its profits would be cancelled before it could get any charge in Dublin. The Bill will not let the commissioner do that. Am I right?

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The amendment provides that after the word "other" the word "airport" should be inserted. The Deputy said we should consider only the revenue accruing from an airport and use it to determine charges. We believe the regulator would take account of at all the moneys accruing to the company and would then examine the distribution of charges, although I do not know if that would be a good idea. I am inclined towards the Deputy's amendment.

Comment on this

If Aer Lingus had £100 million profit from its overseas operations, it could not charge anything in terms of Dublin Airport.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy means Aer Rianta.

Comment on this

Yes. If it had a large profit from its duty free sales and management of other airports, its profit would be wiped out before it could charge Dublin anything.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

It would not be able to build up capital investment which it now needs. The Deputy is saying that the wording of the section should read——

Comment on this

It should read "and other airport revenue earned by the authority".

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

What we appear to be saying is that we should examine everything the company earns to determine its charges, but such an approach might diminish greatly the potential of the company.

Comment on this

It would be easier to put up charges in the airport than for it to run an enterprise elsewhere to make a profit.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I take it the Deputy is talking about any subsidiary activities the company may have.

Comment on this

That is correct. I will withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Mrs. O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

I am very much in sympathy with what the Deputy said, otherwise we will spancel Aer Rianta to an enormous extent in that the revenues it is only beginning to earn abroad, which I hope will provide it with the necessary finance for capital expansion, would be whipped off on the altar of lower and lower charges, and for what purpose other than to make other people rich.

Comment on this